Community Redevelopment Agency (CRA) meeting transcript 11/10/26

10:00 I call this meeting of the community redevelopment agency, better known as CRA, to order. In the interest of time, efficiency, and ensuring everyone that
10:08 wishes to address the board is given the opportunity to do so, the following will apply to all comments made by the public in person and
10:16 virtually. Virtual participation NC meetings are available on your computer or smartphone via Microsoft Teams or by
10:24 telephone. Uh you can learn how to participate virtually by visiting our website at www.cleoutl.gov
10:34 and search for attend council meeting online. Each speaker will be permitted three minutes to address the council. In an effort to be respectful during the
10:42 meeting, please make sure your cell phones are set to silent. Thank you for participating in your city government.
10:49 All right. Before I go anyway, would you mind Mr. giving us prayer, Mr. Ben Wagner, please?
10:55 Sure. Let's pray. Father, thank you today for all our blessings. Thank you for the beauty and the splendor that we see all around us. Thank you for the
11:04 people in this community. All the things you've done for us. You've been so kind.
11:08 We pray for your continued blessing on our community. Watch over and protect us. I pray that you'd give each and every member here on this board this
11:17 wisdom from God to know what to say and what to do. And we invite your help in every decision now in Jesus name. Amen.
11:24 Amen. Amen. All right. Our first order of business is to approve the Main Street agreement.
11:31 Yes, sir. Do I have somebody presenting that?
11:42 Mr. Norris, M.
11:43 Do you want to come up here with and say anything?
11:52 Is there anything you want to say before we talk about that? Okay.
11:55 No. Uh, we'll turn it over to Mr. BK.
11:58 Yeah, I I think so because we've talked about it before. Somebody wants Thank you. I'm not adding anything new. Oh, not nothing from staff.
12:05 Okay. We're supported.
12:12 Okay. Hi everybody. Uh my name is Patrick Bianchi. I am the uh president of the board of Clermont Main Street. My address is 810 West Montrose.
12:21 Unfortunately, Natalie wanted to give this presentation, but she uh her daughter had emergency surgery, so she is with her. So, our thoughts and prayers are with her certainly.
12:31 Um, I guess the only thing with respect to this agreement, uh, I just want to kind of explain since it is going to be quarterly that we come in to talk to you
12:39 all about what we're doing, where we were, where we are, where we're going.
12:44 And the question I get often, especially pertaining to this continued services agreement, is what do you do with our money, and what does that look like out
12:52 into the community within the CRA? And so, uh, you'll hear me say often, we have four pillars of our organization.
13:00 um design, promotion, economic vitality, and organization. All of which uh have different functions within the CRA uh as
13:09 we know them. So, uh what I'll say off the top, because I'm a math and numbers guy, is that of the 70,000 that we
13:16 receive, um we will take that into account and we will raise 4 to one of
13:23 that amount. So, if you look at our financials, which we provide audits every single year of our financials, um
13:30 it's it's about a 4 to one. So, with that being said, I just wanted to kind of give you some data and numbers since
13:37 I'm before you tonight. Um of the 70,000 that main Main Street receives from the city, we raise 89% of
13:45 everything else. So, obviously, as you might know, we host 90 event days out of the calendar year. Um, so that's 50
13:54 farmers markets, 12 food truck Saturdays, um, 12 wine walks, anime night, so on and so forth. You get, you
14:02 catch my drift. Um, we have grown in revenue 43%
14:08 since 2000, fiscal year 23, um, which is exponential growth and our volunteer
14:15 hours has also increased. So, for example, in fiscal year 24, we had 716
14:21 hours and last fiscal year, we had 1,815 volunteer hours.
14:28 And by the way, this information I'm provided to you also is required by the state for accreditation. So, this is also available uh through them.
14:38 um with respect to attendance for our events because that's that's important as we go through all of our events and we kind of talk about why we do the
14:46 events and and how we do them. The biggest thing is of course we want to bring in small business and and of course somebody that may not otherwise
14:55 be can afford a brick and mortar. They they have a tent or a truck or something and we bring them to a place uh with a
15:03 bunch of people that attend and can buy their product and showcase their passion. That's great. But first and foremost, we want to make sure that it
15:11 benefits the ones who make the sacrifice and the investment in the brick-and-mortar locations. So, we do surveys. We do anonymous surveys. Every
15:19 single year, we send out like, "What did you think of our farmers market this year? What did you think of our food truck Saturday? Moving it from Friday, Saturday? I know that's a big conversation." And so on and so forth.
15:28 And what we've seen is overwhelming support of how we are doing our events.
15:34 You're going to have some outliers. some of the social media posts that you see, but for the majority, it's it's well attended, well respected, and we're
15:42 doing a good job and and our team and our board and our staff does a great job doing it. Um, so for food truck Saturdays, we're seeing right now, as of
15:51 the last one, if you were here in the last one, the attendance has grown. Um, this was a big jump from the time before. We arranged about 2500 people
16:00 for that specific event this last Saturday. Um adding the car show has certainly helped. Um, Sunday farmers
16:07 market we range because summers is hot right so you don't get as much attendance as you do now we are in busy season that ranges from 700 to 1500
16:16 attendees on any given Sunday which is a movie I think um during our events
16:23 obviously we talk about parking uh the cool thing about parking and the dynamic of hey we're we're filling up parking
16:32 spaces is the walkability proximity to other businesses that the person may otherwise not would have visited, but
16:39 yet parked next to it. So, curiosity, they walk in, they now know a business they've never been to. I can't tell you
16:46 how many times we hear, even as a landlord myself. Oh, I didn't know you were here or I didn't know you existed or this is the first time I've been
16:54 here. That's all part of the economic driver that Main Street helps. These events, yes, fill our parking, but they
17:01 also deliver opportunity. So, [snorts] something to think about.
17:06 Um, so in a year-to-year, I mean, we have over 50,000 people attending our events in any given any given cycle. Our wine
17:13 stroll has also grown. So, our top number we just recently had was 420 tickets sold. Um, which is interesting.
17:23 It's a different we don't shut down the streets. It's a different way of thinking uh doing our events. It's actually putting people inside a
17:31 brickandmortar store. Um, so from October 25 to July 26, we've seen about
17:38 3,700 attendants uh go through, guests, if you will. Um,
17:46 other initiatives that you don't see because we're not just an events company. So part of the 70,000 obviously goes into some matching grants that we
17:54 apply for. Um, we just received a $50,000 grant for design standards for historical preservation purposes. That's something that that we are very big on.
18:04 Um but also if you ever see face that runs the place, it's no secret that the restaurant industry is incredibly
18:10 difficult. It's saturated. Um you see a lot of restaurants closing down and new ones open. So, we created Face That Runs
18:18 the Place, and essentially that gives a really intimate moment for a a small mom and pop restaurant in downtown food and
18:26 beverage to show who they are, where they come from, why they're doing what they're doing. These are these are investments that we're making with the
18:34 money that we receive from the city um that we believe is important. So, one of our videos, I mean, had 18,000 views in a very short period of time.
18:44 I I'll name shuffing it up because I I did speak to him after we did it. He's like, "My sales went crazy." So, we see it working. Uh unfortunately,
18:53 there's only so many days in a year, right? So, we're trying to catch up with the amount of food and beverage, but we really see a need for that. We also see
19:00 a need for professional services, real estate. I mean, now we have a lot of cos cosmetic, you know, I don't do Botox or
19:08 lip filler, but that's a thing. And so, they want to be exposed and spotlighted, too. these professional services are going to be on our next step of kind of how we're going to curate these videos.
19:18 Um, we just did the the historic flag walk, you know, that's kind of like the winewalk themeesque but in a whole different light. I mean, those things
19:27 that we we curated. Um, the the paintings that you see now throughout downtown, the city center just hosted the urban guild, they're all there. It
19:35 was cool for these people to see what Main Street that was a $25,000 direct pay to artists funding them for their
19:43 work. Um, these are the initiatives that that Main Street provides. Um, I mean, I could go on and on and on. We do so
19:51 much. Um, I can provide you reporting uh if you guys want. I'm here to take questions. So I we we definitely I we
20:00 think we're showing value. Um that the 70,000 we haven't really asked for more than that from a contribution perspective with respect to cash. Um we
20:09 do receive some waiverss from the city with respect to events. Uh we could definitely talk about that if you want.
20:15 Uh I do believe that's on the next city council meeting. So maybe save it for there. I don't know. Um but I'm here to take any questions if you have and uh we
20:23 appreciate your support and hope that you say yes.
20:26 Quick question, Mr. Bianchi. I know you said you get four to one on the 70,000.
20:32 So if you got more then you would get is it is it an exponential? So let's say you got 100, you get 400. So you have half a million then. I mean it seems
20:40 like everything that you're doing is is I haven't heard any negatives yet like uh you know somebody had a bad food walk or something like that or wine walk
20:49 people stumbling. So everything seems like it's good. So, if you could increase that, would that would that be a uh something that the city would want to have?
20:57 Well, I definitely don't want to sit here and tell you all the negatives. I mean, what we do is hard, right? Um it it is kind of a thankless job. We're
21:05 we're aside from the two staff members that we have. We're not paid, right?
21:10 This is all on a volunteer basis. Um we have 15 board members, one's an ex officio, so 14 of them are not paid. Um,
21:19 so I I don't know if I understand your question entirely other than of course if we receive more money, we could do more things. I mean, that just comes
21:27 down to it. Um, but the money that we do receive, we're very good stewards of it.
21:31 And I just want to make that abundantly clear. And when I say four to one, it's just based on what money we raise outside of that
21:41 70,000 to be able to do the things that we are doing and want to do because there's always goals and aspirations and different ideas that we're going to come up with um to be able to spend it.
21:54 Okay. Thank you, sir. Thank you. This this is a public forum. Anyone in the uh chamber wish to speak to this item may come to the microphone and state your name and address and have three minutes.
22:03 Anyone in the chamber wish to speak to this item may come to the microphone and state your name and the address and have three minutes.
22:12 Seeing no one in chamber, I close down chamber. Mr. Wayne, we have anyone online.
22:17 No one online. We bring Well, I bring it back to the board. I would like to ask a question.
22:22 Go ahead, Mr. Bianchi. Besides money, what else would you need from us?
22:30 Um, I I think that the way that we view Main Street in the city of Clermont is very much a collaborative partnership.
22:37 Um, we we appreciate everything that the city has done up to this point. I think we just continue in that collaboration
22:44 effort. If we have an event, post it on social media. Maybe all of you up here could could help aid in in the announcement of it to drive people
22:53 because at the end of the day, we we are trying to create a sustainable factor in downtown for these brick and mortars. Yeah.
22:59 No vacancies, no turnovers. Uh you know, the success of it. I mean, we have 220 new businesses um in downtown that that
23:07 that we've generated. Um I the the CRA tax increment if we wanted to talk about that and the the from a private
23:15 development perspective people are trusting to invest their dollars in downtown Main Street is a really big uh
23:23 I guess part of that trust um with what we're doing because if we just packed up and moved out a lot of these private
23:30 developers going to be like what's going on like you know there's some stability there so I wouldn't say that we need anything more than you're giving I would
23:38 just say continue um being supportive and and just more than money, but but on social media and so on and so forth. Okay. Thank you.
23:46 Yeah, no problem.
23:48 Can I ask um Mr. Peterson? Any questions? Yes, ma'am.
23:54 Um I'm not necessarily suggesting this should be Main Street, but do we know if anybody is um tracking like overall foot
24:01 traffic numbers and spending data? I know the softwares for that can be kind of expensive. I think parks and the parks and wreck was asking for a
24:09 specific software that had that capability. Has anybody been doing that?
24:13 I'm very curious. Anecdotally, I've seen the foot traffic increase. Living down here, seeing what a Monday looks like today is very different than a Monday
24:21 three years ago, but I'm curious if we have any kind of historical overall data.
24:26 Yeah. And I can provide you that information. We've been tracking that since 2022.
24:31 We we'll have the data and we have the data all the way up to today and projections to 2028. It's called Ezri Ezri data. Yes.
24:38 Um it is very expensive. I know that the city also talked about doing placer AI.
24:43 I don't know if that was only with respect to parks. Um but presumably that could extend to our events. I do know
24:51 that during the comp plan process, I don't remember which organization so forgive me. um they were kind of rating
24:58 uh the attendance of certain events and what brought in uh the the tax dollars and and the tourism dollars and things
25:07 like that. So you'll see that our harvest festival is is one of the ones on the top list there.
25:12 Um so yes, I can certainly share the EZ every day that we have. It'll it's projected all the way out to 2028.
25:19 We track it via credit card data and things like that.
25:21 Yeah, I would love to see that. I mean it's not conditional based on this but I think it would be so interesting for both the events but also just the ongoing um growth. So maybe by maybe for the next report um if you all have that.
25:33 Um overall though I think super happy to support this. Um you it's like a grand experiment what you all do uh the
25:42 marketing the events the responding to how how it goes with people um and so there's going to be es and flows and ups
25:50 and downs but obviously overall you all handle that I feel very well very responsibly and it's a net positive in so many ways for the city. So,
25:58 thank you, Mr. Crawford. No questions, Mr. Mayor.
26:06 All right, Miss Strange. Yes. Thank you, Mr. Bianchi.
26:12 [clears throat]
26:12 What is your Well, my first question is, is Waterfront Park in the CRA boundaries? Can somebody anybody tell me?
26:24 I thought the answer was yes. I think the answer is absolutely yes. Yes, it is. There is a carveout down there, but Waterfront Park itself is in there.
26:32 I'm just trying to find it to be sure. Yeah, I'm picturing the map over there.
26:38 That's what I need. Okay, thanks. Um, so my question to you is, do you feel that the summer sports triathlons are
26:47 beneficial to the downtown businesses that Main Street represents?
26:53 So, so Ma Let me try to track your question. So, Main Street is not affiliated with that event. Are you asking if we're supportive of them doing it?
27:02 Yeah.
27:03 Oh, absolutely. I think and I I want to make that distinction is kind of how you know all the meeting of the minds and even the chamber for that regard because
27:11 they have events down there is that 99.9% of all the events that we run close down
27:18 streets in proximity of the central business district Montrose 8th 7th Minnola. um notwithstanding some runs
27:26 that they have that close down the streets. So we Main Street doesn't get involved with any event that happens in Victory Point Park or Waterfront Park.
27:38 Like that is for the ones that do that on a yearly basis. We we we'll support them collaboratively. Like we have people that volunteer like Pig on the
27:47 Pond. You'll see, you know, Gigi and Amanda, they're all part of that. Um I just eat the food there. And so that you'll see that collaboration, right?
27:56 Um, but we we stay away from those territories.
28:01 I'm more I'm seeking advice on whether they're good events.
28:04 I think they're great because we're talking about your sponsorship and then later there's going to be questions about other events that
28:11 we're waving fees. Yeah. And so collaboratively, collectively, holistically, are these all good for the purposes of the CRA is what I'm asking.
28:20 as an expert. We believe they are.
28:22 Um, Clermont Main Street, you have events on the agenda later tonight. I'm assuming you think those are beneficial to downtown.
28:30 I I would be remiss if I didn't say yes.
28:32 [laughter]
28:33 Yes.
28:34 Um, and then I was looking through item nine later today. The Clermont is hosting special events. There's a series of events, most of them taking place at
28:42 Water Park, some of them also extending into downtown.
28:45 [snorts]
28:45 Um, do you feel in your opinion and your expertise that these are beneficial to the businesses located in downtown Clermont?
28:54 100%.
28:54 Okay. Um, Mr. Peterson asked a question that I understood differently than I think you did and so I'm going to ask a follow-up.
29:02 And what I heard him asking was if this council, if this board was to give additional dollars to Main Street, let's
29:11 say we gave 10 extra dollars, could Main Street turn that into potentially 15 or 20 or 30 or 50 or 100?
29:19 Oh, absolutely.
29:20 So stated differently, my question is if we provide a grant to you, are are your expertise such that you can take that
29:27 money and make it bigger than what we have given you? for sure. Okay.
29:33 And there's a there's a re I don't mean to cut you off. There's many ways that we do that.
29:38 So, one of them is is a money market account that we that we have because the reason why we have a money market account is not just to have
29:46 cash in there growing interest is that a lot of the grants that we're going that are bigger grants, they require a bank
29:53 balance for and and to support a matching effort. So, if we're going after $250,000, let's say, and we have
30:01 to support 50% of that, we need to have that in our account. Otherwise, they just won't give it to us. So, the more money we have, naturally, probably
30:10 bigger fish that we can go after. But I I I will tell you that I'm not standing here asking for more money. I would I
30:16 here's what I'm asking really is I think the next step in our partnership and maybe this goes to um Shandra Myers and
30:26 her her ask is that you guys have to become a certified local government.
30:31 You're not currently you have to have a historic preservation board. You don't have one currently. The reason why that's important in partnership with us
30:40 is that a lot of the grants that we go after, the city can also go after and and you know, our grant writer can also assist your grant writer. And whereas
30:49 you may have to match it, there's a lot of grants out there you don't have to match anything at all. So if you're going after a $50,000 grant and we're
30:57 co-sponsoring and we're going after the same 50,000, that's a h 100,000. You have to match at 2525. whereas now if you're certified local government and
31:05 historic preservation board is active, you don't have to match that. So now we get the full hundred. So I think that's how we grow that way. Um as opposed to
31:14 just giving us the money so we can go achieve more grants. I think there's an effort of collaboration that we can grow in that together. I I don't at this
31:22 point I don't know that we need anything else from what the 70,000's purpose is.
31:28 I know we had talked about parks and all that. that's an entirely different animal and you know different bucket of money and purpose. Um certainly that we
31:37 would love to collaborate on. I think we're very vocal in that. But as far as what the 70,000 is for, I don't know that that really is the next step to
31:44 increase that amount. I think we become certified local government historic preservation board. Let's collaborate on some grants and and move upward in in the dollar amount that way.
31:57 So, the reason why I'm asking this is because u I've spoken to the city council and I want to say it to this board as well. I think I've alluded to
32:05 it that um my perspective is that any activities that happen within the CRA boundaries um are best managed by the
32:14 CRA. I believe that decisions should be made at the lowest competent level. And I think that main, the small business
32:22 owner, Main Street, the CRA, that would be the order in which I think decisions should be made in this district. Um, and
32:29 I asked that because there are items on the agenda later today that we're asking the public at large to incur the cost of
32:37 and if those items benefit the businesses downtown.
32:42 And I'm not trying to I'm not trying to put anybody in any boxes today, but I am thinking, you know, if there's a way that that your agency could take
32:51 those items are going to be an investment by the general fund, but if we could increase what we're providing to Main Street and allow Main Street to
33:00 turn those dollars into more dollars to help cover the cost of some of these other events.
33:07 Okay. Right now, the request is to wave them, but I've been asking for a couple years if this can come through tourism.
33:15 I think the CRA and potentially your resources or our resources with the guidance of Main Street might be ways
33:22 for the taxpayers to not just bear the burden but rather to convert to create revenue in other areas so that all of
33:30 these number of events aren't just a taxpayer expense but rather might be something that could even if it's partially covered through the efforts of the small businesses in the region.
33:41 That's where I'm coming from and asking some of these questions.
33:43 I understand. Are you specifically talk so I understand are you specifically talking about the fees paid through
33:51 police and fire and public works with respect to our events and and what you're saying is move that to CRA and just pay
33:58 the the only thing I would say to that is um so like for police as an example there's a third party system that we have to use now I think it's called
34:06 defender um where we have to book a certain number of allocated personnel for a specific event and that number is
34:15 generated and derived out of like the police chief makes that call, right? Um or Lieutenant uh Bloom.
34:21 And so, for example, we had 10 officers at a food truck Friday night, whereas in the Saturday event, maybe four. Um so,
34:29 it would be hard to track that without like a policy of how they arrived to that number. And maybe it's based on attendance. I haven't been involved in those conversations. I know Natalie has.
34:38 Um, so I would say that from that point, like if the CR I don't even know who honestly
34:46 pays for it. If the CRA pays for it now and just reimburse the I mean I don't know. No, they're just fee wavers.
34:51 Um, so there's but okay, but we get I think we get reimbursed. So like if we pay for 10 officers, we put in an
35:00 invoice to the city and we get reimbured for that amount. I don't know where that reimbursement comes from, like what bucket. Um, but if if it needs to come
35:09 from the CRA, I mean, I think we'd be fully supportive of that.
35:12 So, I won't muddy the waters on your issue tonight. I just would like it to be something that we consider as we move forward with the operation. I heard you
35:19 say that we need to become words that I didn't understand and so they're not sticking with me about an official government. We need a historic preservation board. That's what I took
35:27 from what you said. And so I would very much like to see this board with the help of the experts that we have in our
35:34 partners figure out a way to be maximizing grant opportunities and revenue generation opportunities. I think what you all are doing is
35:42 fantastic. Um I'm supportive of the request before us today, but as we move forward um you know, Mr. city manager.
35:49 And if the if the board agrees, I would like to see a little more intentionality in in how this this particular fund is
35:55 operated so that we're not continuing to fund CRA activities through the general fund, but rather create a thriving
36:03 general fund or CRA fund, excuse me. And my last question to you, have you done your update for tonight or will we be seeing you again? Uh, you'll be seeing me again.
36:11 Okay, that's all I have. Thank you.
36:12 Okay, Mr. Bane.
36:17 Thank you, Mayor. Um, Mr. Bianchi and to the Clermont Main Street um organization and volunteers, thank you.
36:25 Uh, I think anybody who's been in Clermont more than five years
36:34 sees a major difference in what is happening, not only in attitude, but activity
36:42 and presence. and I appreciate that as a individual council member and as a resident of the community. Um, and 43%
36:50 growth I think you said since 2023 is a is a great number. Um, so congratulations on that as well.
36:56 Um, I have a couple of questions. Uh, one one more question for you and then a question for staff. Um, in in the
37:04 agreement, it indicates that that you'll provide your fiscal year 26 report sometime like nine months after the end of the year. Is your guys' fiscal year the same as the cities?
37:14 We we align it with align them. Okay. So, sometime June, July. Okay. Every June we we submit it.
37:19 Okay. Uh Mr. City Manager, did we get the fiscal year 25?
37:23 And did the CRA get copies of that because I don't believe uh anybody here on I I don't have a copy of it.
37:32 We did receive it. So, I'll have to get that to you. I don't know that we've given that to you.
37:37 Okay. because that would be helpful for us to understand and be able to more effectively uh ensure that not only we're
37:44 responsible with those dollars but also if there are you know additional or more unique or or new opportunities to to
37:51 make uh improvements or to enhance the investments that we're making having that data would be able to to help us do that. So that's why I asked that.
37:59 I do want to make a comment to that just for uh clarification. In the agreement, it talks about a third party financial audit with respect to our bank
38:07 statements, essentially financial statements. This past fiscal year, we actually have a fullblown state level audit. And the reason why we did that
38:15 and paid the $8,000 it cost to do it was because of the level of grants that we're we're seeking with the Clermont
38:22 Botanical Garden opportunities and and different things like that. So, when you get that, know that it's going to be at a much higher threshold than what you see.
38:28 Oh, sure. Yeah. Thank you. Yeah. If we could get that, Mr. city manager as a CRA, that would be helpful. Um, and then also just procedurally when uh when we
38:37 vote on this, do this does this agreement also go to council for approval or is the CRA the only approving authority for the agreement?
38:46 Okay.
38:48 It's always been the CRA from our perspect that's what I understood. I just want to make sure but I want to be clear. Yeah.
38:54 Because sometimes actions we do take then have to go to council and other times it doesn't.
39:01 This one's just the CRA.
39:03 Okay. All right. Those are my only questions. Thank you. Thank you. I entertain a motion.
39:11 I'll move to approve item number one. I second.
39:15 Have a motion and a second for approval of item number one, Main Street Agreement. Any further discussion?
39:21 See? None. All in favor, let it be known by saying I. I.
39:24 All oppose. Chair vote I as well. Motion carries 70. Item number two, update from groups.
39:33 What's that? What's group?
39:38 Yes. We'd like to hear from the Main Street folks first.
39:45 Oh, and that was my update. I mean, unless you are you okay?
39:50 I'm happy with that update. I mean, I could I could I do have more information about if you want it
39:58 if it's in writing. Do you want to email it to us? I can do that, too. Yeah, I can provide your report. Thank you.
40:06 Uh, great update. Thanks.
40:09 [laughter]
40:11 We're very blessed to have a great Main Street organization as well as a council that supports the downtown. I I can tell you just the feedback that I received
40:20 this weekend from those who attended the urban guild summit. They were blown away by our town and it shows. So, thanks everybody.
40:31 David Colby, president CEO of the South Lake Chamber of Commerce and Mr. Norris asked me to come and give an update on the Clermont City Center facility that
40:39 we do manage for the city. Um, I did a one-page update uh like to pass out to everybody. um as that makes its way
40:47 down. Just a historical perspective, the the the chamber has been involved uh a long time being um a facility manager
40:54 for the city. Um originally with the old Jenkins Auditorium um the it was the fourth public store in in the state or
41:03 anywhere. And um and when that became the Jenkins Auditorium was gifted to the city in 1965 and the city council voted
41:10 in 1966 for the chamber of commerce to be the manager. So that lasted a number of decades. And then in in 2013 when the
41:19 Clermont City Center was was constructed and they took down the the Jenkins Auditorium, the the chamber was asked to be the the manager of that
41:26 facility. Um that lasted until 2016, my first week here in May of 2016, um I was
41:34 asked to come in by the the city manager and they said that they were rethinking it and and maybe have the the chamber
41:41 not be the manager. So, we um contracted our our space to about half of of the office space at the city center and that
41:49 the the city um ran and managed that and we paid rent. And then in early 2025, um I was approached by by city management
41:58 and and um some some city council members had expressed that uh perhaps um it was a good time to look at the chamber of commerce maybe going back
42:05 into that that management role. So since uh with with the approval of of of the city council since July of 2025, the the
42:13 the chamber has been the manager of of of the facility. And uh with that, our agreement is that we do have a full-time
42:20 person at the front desk um 8 to 5, 5 days a week. And we also do pay folks to be our attendance at events. So that's
42:29 nights and weekends, anything um beyond regular business hours. So um I did provide some financial information. And
42:36 this is through 10 months this year, so through the end of October. And um we had collected close to to $90,000.
42:44 And um so per our agreement, half of that 44,88853 cents was was paid to the city. And then
42:52 we retained that amount to help pay for our expenses that that that we have um
42:59 for that paying paying th those folks um that that work for us. Um we um in that
43:07 amount of money there were 351 paid rentals. Um I I listed here some of the different types of of rentals. There are
43:14 all all the types of things that people look to have outside of their homes. Um weddings, birthday parties, anniversary parties, baby showers, school dances,
43:22 graduations, really anything when when people are looking for for for rental space. And in addition to that, um there
43:30 have been 118 unpaid. Um so per our agreement, the city is also able to use it for um for anything that the city
43:39 wishes to do and the chamber has a number of our events there. So um the the city center does ask us act as a
43:47 public polling place. Um there's different department meetings that are there. Um there have been workshops um
43:54 different employee wellness events. So, um I did put the the dates along with the uh the different events um that the city has also um granted permission to
44:03 the to the county to use it for for certain events as well. Um in um this
44:10 past week um we we had been working with the urban guild. We were trying to to be creative and and um you know something
44:17 that I think provided great value to our community. Brought an awful lot of people in in here. the urban guild was really looking to see how they can pull
44:25 an event together and um and and and without great expense. So, um we were able to work with our county tourism department. We were approved for a
44:33 $5,000 grant. So, um we are currently doing the the postevent paperwork for that right now, but we do anticipate
44:41 getting a uh $5,000 payment from tourism department. So, 3,000 of that will go back to the urban guild and then the the 2,000 uh will go towards the rental. So that will be a be a split with the city.
44:52 So we're just looking at at other ways that we can do things, bring things here to downtown Clermont and and and cover our expenses. Um you know, my my
45:01 challenge as the uh as the the manager and and and my accountability for for my board is to to get it to be a break even
45:08 for us. Um currently our our expenses do exceed the income that we that we have coming in. So uh we are we are working
45:16 hard to promote it as much as we can. uh through 10 months this year, it was about $14,000 more in expense than we
45:23 had income. But we're trying to uh trying to remedy that with um with with more rentals and and possibly doing a a modest um fee increase. I do not believe
45:32 in the almost 11 years that I've been in Clermont that there's ever been any sort of an increase. Um it is a very very good value um to rent the the large
45:42 room there. It's $80 an hour. people frequently get a discount if they are a Clermont resident or they're a nonprofit. It's $60 an hour. So, uh that is by far one of the biggest bargains.
45:54 Um so the hourly rate for the whole room, it does divide up into smaller pieces, but it's $80 for an hour for a
46:02 rental, but if you are a resident of the city of Clermont, it's $60 an hour. or if you're a nonprofit who's able to show
46:10 us your nonprofit paperwork, it is $60 an hour. So, um you know, we we've enjoyed the the relationship um with the
46:19 city. Um you know, the the building has not been without problems. I have to say that the city staff has been very very responsive. There's been some leaks
46:27 [clears throat] in the roof. There there's been some window issues and and and things like that. And we we have um you know, worked through that. Um, oftentimes there's things with the air conditioner and other mechanical things.
46:39 So, um, I I think it has been a good relationship. Um, I think that the partnership, you know, has us in in a position that we are absolutely trying
46:48 to maximize revenue because because um, you know, I'm on the hook with my board to to pay for as as much of of of the expenses that we have. Um, it does allow
46:56 us to be here downtown. It does allow us to have our events here. on and I think we really belong in downtown Clermont
47:04 and we like to have events when we we bring people to downtown. So, it's been a a good relationship. We've we've we've learned a lot through the process and um
47:12 you know, so I just wanted to give you give you that update and um you know, entertain any questions you folks might have.
47:19 Okay.
47:23 If we have any question, we'll call you back later. Thank you very much. I would like to ask him a question.
47:28 Okay. I would like to ask you a question. What exactly would you would like for us to do to help you?
47:37 I'm not really looking for anything specifically from from the the the CRA.
47:43 I I think you know um you know people can always help that you know [laughter] if there if there's there's rentals out there and and and people are looking
47:51 looking for for space but um you know we're we're not looking for anything specifically um you know from the CRA that the CRA has been quite helpful in
47:59 some of uh the events that we've done like with sips and salsa. We we've tried to do um large community events in in cooperation with the city. Um sips and
48:08 salsa is a big draw and and we're able to do that and draws draws a lot of lot of people. That's a true partnership with the city. The city was was very
48:15 helpful with our taste of South Lake um event which was was extremely successful and as Mr. Bianchi was talking about how
48:23 it impacts the the local businesses that they come out, they show off what they have, their sales go up. But um I'm not I'm not really looking for anything um
48:30 specifically from from the CRA. We are we are working at this and um you know we we appreciate the the relationship, but I just wanted to to let you know um you know kind of kind of where we stand.
48:40 Okay. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. North. Who we have next?
48:46 Oh, I'm sorry. I thought we were opening up to the public and then asking our questions. I had questions.
48:51 Well, as I said, if we had questions, I was going to bring it back later. I wanted to go through all the groups first. Okay.
48:57 Oh, if I can.
49:01 Um, for the historic village, um, I'm going to give the update. I want to I presume I don't see anybody from the
49:08 historic village here. So, they provided a report. I just want to share with you um sort of the highlights. Um they gave
49:16 us an update for this year through the end of October. Um essentially they've brought in about $13,000 and they've spent about $14,000.
49:26 They've had uh about 2500 people have signed their guest register. Uh 25% of
49:32 whom were from outside the areas um as far as way as uh Usbekiststan.
49:39 The Quansa Hut Museum has been completely reorganized this year. All artifacts were identified and numbered.
49:47 All fragile uh paper artifacts were scanned, copied, and the originals replaced in the archival storage. The
49:54 Cooper Library has been about 80% completely reorganized. The displays were arranged logically and new
50:02 artifacts added. The portion related to Clermont schools is to be completed.
50:07 Old photographs and documents in their collection, thousands of them, have been cataloged and organized, are in the process of being scanned and will eventually be made available online.
50:20 They're in the process also of updating their website and have increased their presence on social media. Their recent posts have been getting uh views in in the in the high 40,000s.
50:32 As regards volunteers, the historical society has approximately 25 full-time members and they have about 8 to 10
50:40 people who are actively uh uh volunteering and contributing their time. About 1,60 hours were put in by
50:48 volunteers from the society as well as about 150 hours by Kowanas Key Club um kids. They've only held one event this
50:58 season. It was a fall photo op with cookies and hot cider which was well attended. They're averaging about 130 visitors during the monthly wine stroll.
51:09 So in conclusion is uh always they continue to struggle with their finances. They continue to struggle with with volunteers.
51:17 Um a lot of their expenses are actually covered personally by their members. Um and they're coming out of the slow
51:24 season, the summer, um in hope that the cooler weather will bring back attendance levels. Um they have noticed
51:30 a marked a market drop off of visitors from Canada. And that's the the summary.
51:38 Any questions?
51:40 We do. We'll bring you back and we'll try to get through these groups.
51:44 Hopefully everybody if you have any question from anyone. Mayor, that is the uh last update.
51:49 That's the last update. do not have the update from the women's club at this time. I can go into the details, but we'll we'll provide an update as soon as we receive one.
51:57 Okay. In that case, then we going to open it up to the public. Anyone in the ch the chamber wish to address any of these groups that just spoken uh may
52:07 come to the microphone, state your name and address and have three minutes.
52:12 Anyone in the chamber which address either one of these items may come to the microphone, state your name and address and have three minutes.
52:19 Seeing no one, Mr. Wayne, we have anyone online? Not this time, sir. None online.
52:25 Miss, [laughter] you I don't have any. I already asked mine. I'm good.
52:31 Mr. Peterson, my question would be addressed to the uh to the chamber and the city center. Yeah. Uh one of the
52:40 things that you know I think we had asked what would you like us to do for you? You know, we have a a great communications department. And are you
52:47 utilizing that for your, you know, to increase your uh exposure either via Facebook, YouTube, things like that?
52:55 We we have not specifically talked to them about that. We we've been trying to do some some creative things. We're doing something with with Universal
53:02 that's giving tickets to um people that rent and different things like that. But no, we we haven't had specific conversation, but that's a good suggestion.
53:10 Okay. I mean it might be something that you could you know investigate because it it could be possibly something that would uh help facilitate an increase in
53:19 uh exposure that you'll get therefore an increase in revenues. I mean, I would think that would be the same thing even for the historical village and things
53:27 like that to to get uh to get our communications department involved with it with, you know, they do video programs. They and then it's amazing
53:36 what what Facebook can do and Instagram can do to to increase uh the revenues that we can generate.
53:43 Thank you very much everything you've done so far. Phenomenal job. Thank you. Sure.
53:50 What um events are eligible for those TDC dollars that you're going to try to go after more?
53:57 We went after room nights. So um so um there there's different different pots of of money. So um so in talking with
54:05 the tourism staff um because there were eligible room nights um they have a formula that that allows you to to get
54:13 paid back. So, um, they're they're kind of in the process of of redoing some things, bringing it online, and, um, you
54:21 know, they they welcomed us into into the process. So, this is the first time I've applied for for TDC dollars, but
54:29 um, but they're they seem to be opening it up in recent years that um, tourism dollars have have really expanded um,
54:37 since they've Airbnb is now a full participant um, in in that process. So, um, so they're they're trying to, you
54:45 know, work work with the community, make sure that those dollars get back invested.
54:50 I love that. I love that. That's something you can utilize. Um, I think what Bill said, an interesting, this is more, I guess, for like city staff.
54:58 You don't want to overwhelm and everybody post about different things, but it would be interesting to see like what are all the venues that are available for rent in the city. I think it's been a long time like curating
55:06 something that kind of shows we've got different pavilions, we've got the Ark rooms, blah blah blah. So making that information available probably doesn't
55:14 make sense in a bunch of social media posts, but making that information more easily.
55:17 And we we do we do um keep those because not you know the city center isn't for everybody, but we do have a preferred vendor list. So we we try to send people to to other locations in our preferred
55:26 vendor list. We also um suggest local businesses, you know, caterers and balloon people, every anything you can imagine connected with an event. So it's
55:35 an opportunity for us to to send business out to the the locals.
55:39 Yeah. Well, it's an opportunity for the city as the as the larger platform to be able to just curate that information and make it really easy and give everybody a
55:46 lift hopefully then too. So, that's it.
55:52 Mr. Crawford, no questions, Mr. Mayor. Wonderful. Oh, actually, I have one. How old is the building? The city center
56:00 20 2013 2013. So, it's going on 14 years old now. And is is the roof sound? It just
56:10 patching roofs over and over is a um dangerous
56:16 a band-aid on a motorcycle crash. Um do we have any long-term maintenance schedules for the building or
56:24 I I don't have any of that information, but we there there's been a number of number of of of times and we've had to take precautions. It's rained on our
56:33 coffee machine before and and and different things. So, um I mean they they have done some patching and and and trying to uh to uh to make it good, but
56:41 it it's still kind of a persistent issue.
56:45 Okay. I And I don't know what the city does as far as physical plant planning, but it sounds to me like that one's only going to get worse.
56:55 If if I may, um a couple years back, we had a problem with that building that stored the roof
57:03 leak. uh we had a problem where it was separating or something like this. We had to settle in and all that. So that created a lot of problems. So yes, we probably need to probably take a look at
57:11 it. I first I hear I'm hearing that this uh roof is leaking again. Okay. So probably we city need to probably take a look at trying to get the whole roof
57:19 redone, but I think we had to go in there and try to readjust the bill and everything because it was settling in some ways and causing all kind of problems over there a couple years back.
57:28 So Okay. All in all, I love the partnership. I'm certain it would cost the city or the CRA or whoever manages
57:35 it more than the 50% match on what you guys do to run it and it wouldn't support the community quite the way it does. So, thank you.
57:45 Thank you.
57:47 I second that. Thank you, M.
57:49 Um I actually would like to see Mr. city manager and this might be an issue at the general fund level. Um but I would
57:57 like to see our public works give us uh capital anticipated expenditures. Um Mr.
58:03 Colby, are you comfortable working with our staff? Absolutely.
58:06 Um I don't want another situation where we have an emergency $300,000 spend and I think that an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure. So I would like
58:15 to see that if possible at the next update which would be January I imagine.
58:20 How do the and I don't know who should answer this. There might be three or four people in here who can. Um com for the first 10 months the city will have netted $44,888.
58:30 How does that compare to what our net was in the previous period? Does anybody know? I feel like that number is consistent is why I'm asking.
58:43 Nobody. Do you remember?
58:45 I don't have the I did not bring historical data with me, but I can certainly bring bring that to the next.
58:51 I feel like I remember it was net negative still before, but don't Okay, so I have I imagine if I was
58:59 sitting in the audience and I was you and I'm hearing this board discuss a $70,000 grant to Main Street and I might have an opinion about it, I might not.
59:08 So my question to you is, do you have a feeling of Are we being just with the dollars that we're spending on the
59:17 different partners that are managing real estate and events in the CRA? Do you feel like there's something we should be considering?
59:27 No, I I I you know, I I think, you know, we're we're we learn and these relationships grow and and I think you
59:35 have some good community partners and we're all trying to do the right thing for the the the the community. So, I I don't have any opinion to do any anything different. Um
59:43 but um you know I think I think it's a great question but but I don't you know I I think you know there there could
59:50 always be you know more support but um but you know we and my organization is much different
59:57 than than Main Street. You know we we we don't we don't look for for for public dollars for for our organization. It's all all private based but um we we
1:00:06 operate differently. They're they're doing grants. So, it's it's it's a much different animal than um but no, I I I think, you know, just having the city
1:00:15 willing to, you know, find out how this works and and and have it be a mutually beneficial. I I to me that's refreshing
1:00:22 just to be able to discuss it and these are the things and um you know, and and I conveyed my my challenge, you know, my
1:00:30 my challenge with my board. You know, we went into this saying, you know, this is going to be a business unit for us and and and we need to at least get it to be
1:00:36 break even. we don't want this to to be costing us money, but I I don't have anything like, you know, if the city does does does this or that. Um
1:00:45 I just I want you to know that door is always open. If you ever have a different feeling, feel free to discuss it with me. Um I would be open to
1:00:52 considering fee increases if you want to bring us that in January or however that needs to work. Um feel free to do so. I
1:01:01 think that looking at surrounding properties, both private and public, is worth doing. There aren't many that are like this in the region to my knowledge.
1:01:09 So, um, let us know what you think is a fair rate. I have no idea what a fair rate might be.
1:01:14 Um, and then I counted 37 city of Clermont events. Um, that
1:01:21 includes supervisor election related and county events. And my question to you, it looked like a lot of those were
1:01:29 during the week. Not I just did a quick search for the dates.
1:01:34 What would you say is your hard cost to host to just to open the doors and have people come? What what is a hard cost
1:01:43 that essentially the Chamber of Commerce is subsidizing for the city when we're hosting an event at no fee?
1:01:50 I mean, we we we really look at it as as the people that we are paying, you know, I mean, we're the rest of us we're we're working and do I spend extra hour, but
1:01:58 we're not we're not really, you know, calculating that. And it it it's really um us having to pay people to be there.
1:02:04 So we're and we're we're trying to get fully utilization of of the facility when we we are obligated to have a full-time staffer there. And it costs us
1:02:11 more that we're paying them plus plus the extra person. So I mean I'm think it's just, you know, it's an hourly rate of of $20 an hour that that that we're
1:02:20 paying. I mean it's it's an hourly rate with with no benefits, but um but you know it's it's really $20 an hour is is
1:02:27 is what we are expending. um kind of hard cost um you know the there is an
1:02:34 opportunity cost anytime there there are other events that that could generate revenue. So you know like there there's some that are minimally invasive then
1:02:42 when we host the wellness way meetings well that's on a Monday morning that's very unlikely that that we're going to have another rental when we start having
1:02:49 things that are that are free use on Thursday nights or possibly you know that that's that's different. So, it's kind of it's a little bit of a of a of a
1:02:57 sliding scale, but you know, we we we do try to, you know, work very much with with the city and and um and um you know, try to make it as profitable as possible.
1:03:06 Well, I'm appreciate all you do and as you're looking at completion of your first year and I'll say for myself that
1:03:13 I'm open to consideration of, you know, should there be some fee or offset perhaps from our share if there is, you
1:03:21 know, city usage. Um, so if there are any sorts of rules or tweaks or fees or things, I'm open to having that conversation and so I encourage you to
1:03:29 bring that to us and and not be afraid to do so. All right, that's great. Thank you.
1:03:32 Yep. That's all I have, Mr. B.
1:03:36 Thank you, mayor. Um, I think that uh I agree with council member or sorry, board member uh Strange uh Strange's
1:03:45 comment about the uh capital plan for the city center. Um and also too just to throw out not for today but to throw out
1:03:53 the opportunity or or or idea to t to start talking about is the city center
1:04:00 the opportunity for us to consider would we be willing to entertain any kind of naming rights uh opportunities
1:04:09 and and what kinds of revenue might come into the CRA in this case uh or the city
1:04:17 um for uh some sort a partnership in a in a in a naming rights um opportunity.
1:04:23 So um rather than giving away the facility or or giving away the land entering into a naming rights agreement
1:04:31 um I I think before we do that we need to come up with some policies and procedures uh for that. But I think this
1:04:38 might be that facility and um that if there were one, maybe this would be an opportunity for us to look at whether or
1:04:45 not it makes sense. Um, so, uh, maybe that's something we can start talking about in the in the, uh, next year. But thank you for all all groups here, what they do.
1:04:54 Yeah, it is a a fiveyear five-year agreement that that that we entered into. So, we'll in July, we'll be we'll be two years into it. Um, you know, the
1:05:02 in per the agreement, it it does give the city unlimited opportunity to use it as they wish and that that comes through the the city manager's office. It also
1:05:11 um gives us the flexibility on on fees to to to set the fees. So um but you know I think
1:05:20 it can all be all be discussed in the future.
1:05:24 All righty. Thank you sir. I don't think we need a motion on this. Thank you. So uh we'll move on to item number three.
1:05:31 Update of the downtown master plan.
1:05:39 Uh we've uh printed out the latest draft for y'all. Hot off the press. Kurt is sharing it with everyone.
1:05:48 Um we also have uh DPZ on Teams on the video conference to be able to answer your questions in a moment. I'm just
1:05:56 going to highlight uh what's changed since the last time uh Ben Northrup gave the detailed overview of the downtown
1:06:05 action plan and tell you where we are in the process and where we expect to go.
1:06:10 Um the first thing to say is Oh, wait. Okay. All right. Um there's really just uh two big updates.
1:06:22 Uh the first is that there aren't many.
1:06:24 Okay. the uh the uh the most substantive one you'll find on uh on page 21.
1:06:33 It's uh the vibrancy or it's the elements of a vibrant downtown. It's a new graphic. You can see it all pulled
1:06:42 apart uh uh on your screen. I think it's normally vertically oriented, but this is a very important um addition uh to
1:06:51 you can better read it on the actual document just by going to page 21. I'm looking at it on the screen and it's
1:06:58 bothering me. Um uh this is terribly important. This is a lot of thought is put into this, but a
1:07:06 lot of people have a hard time differentiating between development in a downtown area that actually increases
1:07:13 uh the vibrancy of the downtown as opposed to decreases it. And what you're seeing here is on the top you're going to see what the private sector's responsibilities toward that are. Okay?
1:07:25 And then on the bottom, you'll see it says public realm. That's usually what the public is responsible for. And if
1:07:32 both parties do their part, you end up with a platform by which it it creates a a super vibrant uh downtown. The key
1:07:41 element more than anything else is making it a a pleasant place to be and an interesting place to be in large
1:07:49 measure because you have things like transparency. You can see into the buildings. People in the buildings can see out of the buildings. You have
1:07:56 shelter from the the uh the sun and the rain.
1:08:01 uh you don't have gaps in the uh in the street so you maintain a strong sense of enclosure for the
1:08:09 outdoor room that we call an urban area a downtown. Um so each one of these things having sufficient numbers of doors and windows has to do with
1:08:18 transparency. Um uh nobody uh everybody would rather look at uh people than park cars. So that's why you want to put the
1:08:25 parked cars behind the buildings. Um you want to have that outdoor room. So, you wanted uh the buildings to be of a certain uh height and you want to make
1:08:34 sure there aren't gaps. Um you uh and like I said before, you want the galleries and the awnings. Um on the uh
1:08:42 on the uh on the street on the public side, we've largely made the investment.
1:08:48 Okay, remember we put a huge amount of money in the streetscape and it's it's attracting uh uh people who want to
1:08:55 invest in here, but we've already done the hard part. Usually cities are trying to play catch-up, but that's that investment's been made. I would argue
1:09:03 that because that investment has been substantial and because it's uh been done well, we should have higher expectations about those who are going
1:09:11 to benefit from that investment, meaning um the uh the development community. So, we shouldn't just say, "Oh, well, they they should be able to do whatever they
1:09:18 want." Um they should be able to be at the same standard that the city is when they did their part on the bottom of this graph. So, I'm really pleased that
1:09:26 this has been added to the first initiative. Um, the second thing that I was going to say that has changed is we've tried to update some of the
1:09:34 graphics. You'll see that on pages 16 and 17 of your um of your draft. On
1:09:42 pages 16 and 17, it's just a graphic that shows a summary of the five core
1:09:49 initiatives. that's the focal point um for uh the uh the downtown action plan.
1:09:56 Um these five things really haven't changed the this is just a better way to sort of see it in one in one uh view and
1:10:05 that's once again to increase the vibrancy of the downtown connect the string of pearls meaning our our lakes.
1:10:12 Um it's providing shade uh uh and shelter from the sun and the rain. It's adding the storm water capacity with a
1:10:20 focus on center lake and how that can be done. And then finally, the one aspect of the downtown action plan that actually hasn't received any public
1:10:29 input uh so we're not done with it at all, which is coordinate the lakefront experience. And that essentially that
1:10:36 that initiative is a reminder is uh we can do a better job of managing our land along the water if we know how people
1:10:44 are using the water and what's the be you know the best way for people to use it. Whether you're uh interested in
1:10:50 fishing or uh just rowing uh uh whether you're a wakeboarder uh whatever it may
1:10:58 be uh that's what that initiative is about. So you may detect some differences from the original uh presentation, but they're really just
1:11:06 sort of graphical in nature at this point. The the final thing that I'll point out is that on the first few pages in the introduction, you'll see red.
1:11:15 Okay? And those reds just show uh the things like on pages um it looks like six and seven. Those
1:11:25 are DPZ's notes on what have to be uh filled out and and formulated. We decided not to do that until after we do
1:11:34 the public outreach on this draft. We felt like there was enough meat in this draft. There's a lot of details in here.
1:11:41 There's a lot of proposed designs of things in here that you heard about before that we would wait until the public outreach. Right now, the public
1:11:48 outreach, we're trying to coordinate with our other organizations in the downtown, like the main street, uh like uh the chamber and others to have the
1:11:57 outreach uh meetings. And uh right now we're looking at uh dates that fall between December 1st and December 11th.
1:12:05 Um we, you know, we're about to run into Thanksgiving, so we don't have enough uh uh uh uh notice right now, but uh we
1:12:14 think that during that time we'll be able to reach out to all the different in uh interested uh stakeholders uh in the downtown and get the feedback we
1:12:23 need so that we can come back with an updated one um uh in January for your consideration.
1:12:29 And that's the update.
1:12:33 If if you have any questions, I'm I'm happy to try to answer them or defer to Marina Corey who's on um on the video
1:12:41 conference right now along with Ben North.
1:12:43 I will uh have any questions. We'll bring you back after we open up to the public. See if the public have anything.
1:12:49 Anyone in the public wish to address this item may come to the microphone, state your name and address and have three minutes.
1:12:56 Anyone in the public wish to address this item may come to the microphone and state your name and address and have three minutes.
1:13:02 Seeing no one, I close the uh chamber. Any one on nine, Mr. Wayne? Not at this time, Mr. Mayor.
1:13:08 Not online. All right. What say you, Mrs. Lyers? I don't have anything just yet.
1:13:14 Just yet. Okay, Mr. Peterson.
1:13:19 I mean, we just got this little packet, so I don't think we can really digest it in the last five minutes, but I mean, it looks like a great packet. I mean, I I
1:13:27 love the the pictures in there. I love the development that we're doing into the town. I think it's important that we continue to do this and because every
1:13:35 time we see a vacancy this could be an area an opportunity then to uh redevelop this area into something like the
1:13:43 picture shown here with the you know on page was it page 727 or something.
1:13:49 I mean I think it was a great it's a great presentation but as I said I don't really can't ask her any real questions right now until we have a chance to
1:13:57 digest a little bit further. Other than that I think it's a great Thank you. Yes, ma'am.
1:14:03 Is there any specific element of this that you want to walk us through in more detail that would be helpful to have our feedback on right now?
1:14:10 Uh, no, not at this time. The the one thing that I really wanted to highlight are the two pages that I hit.
1:14:16 Um, like I said, most of the other stuff is just better graphics, but not um substantively different from what we heard before. There is one thing that I
1:14:24 want to make sure though is that um we'd like to be able to put it up on our website as soon as possible and we just want we're not asking a vote on this but
1:14:33 we're just uh if you have any reservations about that we'd like to know now so that we can change anything before we put it on the website.
1:14:43 I like the Yeah. No, this is great. I feel like last time and maybe I'm remembering wrong. We looked at a lot of concepts on sites. So looking at these
1:14:51 initiatives kind of helps with like it feels like a more complete um master plan action plan. Um so I appreciate the
1:14:59 big buckets. I look forward to diving in in more detail for sure. Mr. Crawford.
1:15:08 Um thank you. Just uh briefly I love seeing this get out on the website and
1:15:15 get as much public information out there as we can. So between December 1st and the 10th,
1:15:21 everybody knows and can come to this and uh I'll be going through it as well. Thank you. Great. Thank you.
1:15:30 That's strange.
1:15:32 Um Mr. Wall, I'm going to have a question if you want to meander towards the front. Um but for Mr. Norris, while you're here, uh I'll ask my questions
1:15:40 and then if you can reply. I noticed that parking was not listed as a downtown initiative. Um my question
1:15:48 would be what do you need from us between now and January?
1:15:52 And then a comment that I have and I thought it was really well done for the comprehensive plan but I would like to
1:15:58 see see the same level of activity on this one is with respect to the public
1:16:05 engagement. Um, you know, we have three partners that have reported here tonight and I would just love to be sure that
1:16:14 anybody who has any connection to downtown, whether it's active, especially because we still have the lakefront experience, active users or
1:16:22 even passive users, you know, people taking pictures of sunsets, people, you know, bringing their boats. I mean, I I just really want to be sure that we've
1:16:30 checked all the boxes on that. So that's kind of a comment, but if you can speak to the issue of why parking is not listed as a downtown initiative and what
1:16:38 you need from us between now and January, I would appreciate it.
1:16:41 Great. Um, yes, as relates to parking that is covered under item uh number uh the first one which is increase the
1:16:49 vibrancy of the downtown. It's the seventh action item. Um okay and and it's essentially talking about the need
1:16:56 to manage parking and treat as a shared resource in the same way that the downtown benefits from um storm water
1:17:03 being a a shared um um uh resource as well. So it's Thank you.
1:17:09 There's also an appendix that includes the analysis that was done uh almost a year ago by DPZ on the different sites
1:17:16 for the uh parking garages. So it's addressed there as well. That starts on page 124.
1:17:21 Thank you. Yes, like the others, I've not seen this. So, thank you for joining.
1:17:25 And and I think you are correct. I I should have been more clear about the coordinating of the lakefront experience. That is not going to be at a
1:17:32 general meeting. That is going to be a series of uh where we're trying to actively get the different users represented into a room together. And I
1:17:40 should have mentioned that before. I just forgot.
1:17:42 Thank you. And Mr. My question for you is um ultimately when this downtown action
1:17:50 plan comes back to us, whoever us is, is this solely a CRA decision or is this
1:17:58 also a a city council general fund issue?
1:18:01 It it's really I don't know the answer to that. And the reason is it's up to you all. Okay. In essence, um, these
1:18:08 kinds of plans, um, you could choose to make this the domain of the CRA, you could choose to make this the domain of the city
1:18:16 council, you could choose to make this the domain of both depending on what you require of each. So I now in from based
1:18:26 on what I've heard personally, I think this is really in in both. I mean, I think this is mostly a city thing, but I
1:18:34 think it's also a CRA thing. So, that's the way I'm looking at it now. I'll know more as it gets developed.
1:18:40 Can you do you know offhand when the last downtown action plan was approved? Who approved it?
1:18:46 Well, there is another one from 2015, I want to say.
1:18:51 Um, but I don't know much about that.
1:18:54 Can you get us an update on that in the next week or two? What do you want to know specifically? What how it was approved originally?
1:19:00 Oh, how it was approved. And um knowing I have the question and knowing that you're not clear on the answer.
1:19:07 Um if you upon contemplation have a strong opinion, I would like to have your opinion on this issue. U and the reason why I bring it up is because and I again I've spoken on this before.
1:19:18 Mostly the general fund has paid for the capital improvements that have occurred in the CRA. And um I continue to be of
1:19:26 the opinion that that is not appropriate in most circumstances. And that's how I feel. I'm just one of seven here and one of five on Jet City Council. But um I
1:19:35 would like to be very intentional about that as a board, as a governing body moving forward that we're mindful of who is paying for what and for the benefit of whom. So that's my concern.
1:19:46 Part of my hesitation just off the bat why is that the city is beginning to adopt citywide policies for things like
1:19:53 parks, for other things. And so when you look at connecting the string of pearls for example, the expenditures that are
1:20:01 going to be required for that kind of thing as well as for your storm water capacity [snorts] will likely exceed what you've envisioned with your CRA
1:20:09 budgets. So I'm just thinking as a practical matter. So if if you do as a CRA board and as a council, some of you
1:20:19 um want to reimagine what the focus of the CRA is, it's going to require some budgetary decisions.
1:20:26 And and related to that, my my comments to the board, I was really happy to see um Mr. Norris's presentation to allude
1:20:34 to or speak directly to the issue of the investment by the citizens into the public infrastructure and then the corresponding responsibility from the
1:20:42 private sector who benefits from that in the CRA to also perform their duty of the the buildout of the buildings that
1:20:50 the streetscape that victory point all of these things were invested it's almost $40 million that has come from the general fund and we have several
1:20:58 projects that are in the tune of 10 million or that we're being asked to consider. And at some point, I would like to see the
1:21:06 private sector stepping up and doing the development, I believe there are people waiting to do it. Um, but as properties
1:21:14 downtown are improved and developed, that will result in higher tax revenue, and most of that revenue would go to the CRA, which would allow the CRA to fund
1:21:23 additional projects moving forward. So, so my desire is not to restrict or inhibit in any way. It's just to structure it in in such a way that
1:21:31 allows for the flourishing of the businesses in this region without being unjust to the individuals and the the
1:21:39 property owners who live in other regions of the city. So that's where I'm coming from and something I think we need to be considering as we move forward.
1:21:47 Mr. B, thank you. Um, did we learn any lessons from the comprehensive plan process about making connections with businesses
1:21:56 and property owners before we put their parcels in this project with ideas to develop them or redevelop them?
1:22:05 Uh, ye generally yes. I won't say exclusively because we know for example we haven't had communication with the
1:22:13 Doyos family about their property and we looked at that.
1:22:17 Where I'm specifically thinking about is that um you know we got we had a a neighborhood association HOA come
1:22:24 forward and and felt pretty flatfooted based off of what they saw and and were very concerned that they weren't engaged
1:22:31 in a process that talked about their community. And and I I did see some language in here. I think I saw a picture of a building with the word
1:22:39 regrettable next to it and I I think that that type of terminology concerns me. Uh and I haven't had a chance to
1:22:47 read this and I I would be hesitant to say let's put something on our city's website that calls one of our downtown businesses parcels regrettable. Um I I
1:22:56 I'm a little concerned about that language. So, I I I I think we need to take make sure that we're using uh encouraging language and making sure
1:23:04 that we're including uh partnerships with our folks downtown uh rather than them seeing parcels that they may own or
1:23:13 have a business on that looks very different from what it is today. Um and also encourages them to partner rather
1:23:21 than calling them out as as something in more of a derogatory or negative way.
1:23:25 Um, and I I think I heard Mr. Norris, you say something about the timeline for input and specifically downtown. Are we
1:23:34 also are are we doing citywide uh uh meetings like we did with the comprehensive plan or is the goal really only to to work with downtown folks?
1:23:44 Because the down the the health of downtown expands much farther than the CBD and I think the CRA, I think we'd all agree with that. And so what kind of
1:23:52 what kind of uh communitywide engagement and meetings are we doing? I I think that's an excellent question.
1:23:58 What we were thinking, first of all, it was going to be open to the entire city and publicized to the entire city, but we're going to have the meetings in the downtown.
1:24:05 I Yeah, I don't have a problem with that necessarily. I just want to make sure that it wasn't being advertised to in a way that that you know, yes, they're
1:24:14 open, but we're really focusing on only getting a certain clientele here. Um because I think the health and vibrancy
1:24:21 of our of our downtown needs the entire city's engagement. Um because what folks shop here, spend money here, attend
1:24:30 events here, work here, have businesses here, and we need all of that, I think, in involved. So I want to make sure of that, right? No, I completely agree that the
1:24:38 downtown, unlike the other area, well, it's it's like having a a major park in your community, it's owned by everybody, and I feel that way about our downtown.
1:24:47 It's our identity as well. Okay. Thank you. Okay. I have no questions.
1:24:53 [clears throat]
1:24:55 I guess we need a motion or whatever you all want to do with the moving this forward. Um is there an action to take?
1:25:05 There's not an action to take. I just I'd like to make sure there's no objection for us to releasing this out to the public um on the website.
1:25:12 I support releasing it to the public on the website.
1:25:15 Yeah. And I don't know that I'm I'm will I'm willing or able to say you one way or the other because I I just got this.
1:25:20 I mean it's it's you'd like us to Yeah, it's literally 200 200 pages. I I just want an opportunity to look through it. Others may have up here. I haven't.
1:25:28 So it's 200 pages and I just need more than 10 minutes to look at it. How much time do you think you need?
1:25:34 Because I I think what we should do is a motion to instruct staff to release this to the public and start scheduling community meetings. And so, you know,
1:25:42 with the goal of getting it on the January agenda. So, I agree with you. It's 200 pages. So, 10 days, two weeks.
1:25:50 Do you want to do that release before they go through it? Uh, I think I heard Mr. Peterson say he he hadn't had a chance to go through it as well.
1:25:58 No, I haven't either. And that's why I'm asking, do we want to, you know, spend 10 days, two weeks looking it over, something like that? And if there's an issue, we might need to have an
1:26:06 emergency meeting, but if we all look it over and it's minor tweaks or things that don't I think I think it's a great idea if you release
1:26:13 it to the public because this way the public can all go through this and they can find an errors or emissions that were found and they could bring it back
1:26:21 to us then as opposed to us reading through it and not being able to find it. You know, it's much better if you have a pool of 10,000 looking than a pool of one.
1:26:29 It's true. We'll certainly find the errors faster. So perhaps we're we're comfortable releasing it to the public with the caveat that nobody on council or CRA has had a chance to review this
1:26:38 yet. And that's the disclaimer. Please feel free to make your comments. Yes. [laughter] Yes.
1:26:43 We look we look forward to your feedback. Feedback. Yes.
1:26:46 I mean, how do we are are we comfortable with that? We saw a version of this I I think a while back, but I I agree. It's a lot of pages. cuz I haven't reviewed it either, but
1:26:55 we we got present, but I don't to my best of my knowledge, we've never received an actual physical copy of this. That's correct.
1:27:02 Yeah. So, so we've seen concepts and uh I'm just I I'll state for the record I'm not okay with giving permission to put
1:27:11 it on the website yet, but if that's the direction, that's the direction just because I don't know and I and having seen the word regrettable. I I that I
1:27:20 I'm concerned about that word lang I I think language has got to matter in here and um uh I that concerns me a little bit.
1:27:28 Yeah. I don't know the technical side, but is there a way to put a little draft watermark on this thing when we put it out? Yes, sir.
1:27:36 Oh, yeah. It's a good idea.
1:27:38 Yeah, that's a good idea. Yeah. So then you know it's a drafting anything. Exactly. It's just a draft. Public record. You record if you'd like. Yeah.
1:27:46 Yes. Good idea. It's already public record now, right? Yes. Yeah. Well, for them to see on the website.
1:27:55 They haven't been released yet, right?
1:27:58 it every draft is a public record. Even the little notes we make on our things today, but but if people don't know about it, they don't request it in
1:28:05 there. So, the website is a great way to do it. Okay. So, how do how do we feel?
1:28:10 Do you want to have a week in case you see anything that jumps out at you, Mr.
1:28:14 Bang, before they send it out or 10 days or two weeks or Yeah, I I'll take a a week or two to to to review and provide feedback.
1:28:23 Can we maybe I'm comfortable if we define that with a set time a week or 10 days maybe.
1:28:28 So why don't um I don't know if we need a motion on this, but I would say let's start coordinating the community meetings. Yeah.
1:28:34 And you know, give us give us a chance to give it a quick look so we're not setting ourselves up for unnecessary criticism. I mean seven eyes are better than two.
1:28:45 Our next meeting is not for four weeks. Exactly.
1:28:47 So right if you do two weeks that how are we going to notify via email? via text for your Yeah. Yeah.
1:28:55 So, you know, maybe don't publish it just yet. I think Mr. Bane's the one most concerned about it. So, I'd like him to be comfortable before it goes a
1:29:02 reasonable amount of time. But otherwise, let's get started on noticing the community as you said and we're just saying why don't you go ahead and start setting up
1:29:10 community meetings and everything and they they can start going through it. Um maybe at our next what is our next council is December 8th.
1:29:18 December 8th. Um hopefully we'll all be had a chance to go through it there and we can give you some comments there and make a decision whether to go full full steam ahead.
1:29:28 But their hope is to schedule it first.
1:29:30 Well, I mean I don't have no problem with it. I don't have a problem.
1:29:33 That draws out the process a lot in my opinion.
1:29:35 Yeah. I think so if this is a thing where it can just be like a hey let's give it a week before we publish it on the website. You can organize the meetings just get consensus before you publish it
1:29:44 maybe from this group and then it can go live. But I don't think it needs to meet again. and we don't need to be making substantial changes to this plan before it's had public input. It's just to
1:29:52 catch maybe some of those things that uh Mr. Bane said he might be concerned about. So, if we start really diving in and thinking this is our chance for big edits, I think that would be
1:30:00 inappropriate before it goes out to the public.
1:30:02 Just [clears throat] communicate only with staff individually. Don't hit reply all and send to everybody.
1:30:08 Yes. Yes. Agreed. Okay. So, give it a week to put it on the website, but go ahead and get started.
1:30:13 November 17th, but we can go ahead and start scheduling public outreach during December. Yeah. Yes.
1:30:18 Okay, that's that's good for us. We'll do it and then we'll make sure it gets stamped draft no matter what.
1:30:23 There you go. Okay. All right. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Anything else need to go? Just one more thing, Mr. Mayor.
1:30:32 We're asking if we could have another meeting December 8th at 2 p.m. We were not able to get done the agreement for
1:30:40 the building across the street. We needed some more time to work through that. So, if you guys would consider that, I think if we met at two, we'd have plenty of time to do that.
1:30:51 I'm okay with that. Okay. Yeah. What time? I'm thinking 2 o'clock. 2 p.m. Um, I might be able to be here by two.
1:31:00 Oh, I'm traveling in from a a commitment that I I brought it up at our last meeting that I wasn't going to be able to be here early for that. So, um I might be able to be here at 2.
1:31:12 This is Does 2:15 help? I don't know that we need a whole hour.
1:31:16 Yeah. Yeah. I don't I mean Well, we say that. Uh I'm just being realistic. So I I think 2 o'clock is probably where it
1:31:25 needs to be. And if that's where it needs to be scheduled, I'll I'll do my best to be here by two. Okay. 2 o'clock.
1:31:32 Mr. Mayor, may I ask one question? Yes, sir.
1:31:35 Thank you. I'll try to keep it very quick. I know we're running out of time. Amendment three passed.
1:31:41 Amendment three penalizes general funds more than it's going to penalize the CRA. The CRA is
1:31:50 residentially uh low percentage and but it is going to
1:31:57 affect us. We don't have the dedicated staff like the city does to say, "Oops, here's our budget for next year. We got a lot of red lines across it." Do we
1:32:06 know at all how it's going to affect our budget? And this is probably a Nathan question, a staff question, or can we get a report on that sometime in the next two, three months?
1:32:17 Well, I I think that that would be up to uh the CRA to tell us how it's going to affect their budget, right?
1:32:24 Yeah. So, a suggestion on that um and disclosure. I discussed with the city manager about a proposed timeline to start addressing amendment three, uh Mr.
1:32:34 Mr. Bane based on some of the comments that you had made about maybe starting in January and you know I would suggest the nature of the conversation was that
1:32:42 he was getting with the property appraiser to get an idea and I'm sure everybody is getting with the property appraiser to try to get this idea. So I
1:32:50 don't think that's going to be terribly fast but if we my suggestion would be that we shoot for January. I think that was a reasonable idea Mr. Bane had
1:32:58 several months ago and it sounds like we'll be having a meeting in January as a CRA to hopefully address the downtown action plan. So maybe we can add the
1:33:07 budget simply loosely listed as the budget to that meeting for January so that we can get that information between
1:33:14 now and then and then see what the impact might be because don't forget the lumber yard should be coming online
1:33:21 sometime soon as well. So, I do think the budget for 28 as we're looking ahead is going to feel very different, but it
1:33:28 might actually be more than we have now because we have that coming online. Are we all comfortable with January as No, that's okay.
1:33:35 January is great. So, maybe we also look at shifting some Maybe we also look at shifting some responsibilities and and
1:33:42 actions if the CRA is might be able to help a little more because it's going to be everybody doesn't have a belt tight enough for this yet. So, right.
1:33:51 Nope.
1:33:54 And of course uh hopefully by then uh January I guess we will have a direction from the state on exactly what how we
1:34:02 are to implement everything because [clears throat] I understand there's supposed to be a a spec session uh call
1:34:09 here sometime within the next before December before January anyway to give direction and guidance on how how uh
1:34:16 what we can and cannot do. Okay. So we still waiting on some some guidance from Tallahassee as well. Okay.
1:34:25 Yes, I understand that. So anything else? Hear nothing else. meeting adjourned.