Clermont City Council Transcript 10/27/26

6:49 I I call this meeting to order.
6:52 Welcome to our council meeting for October 27, 2026.
6:56 Virtual participation in council meeting are available on your computer or smartphone via Microsoft team or by telephone.
7:04 You can learn how to participate virtually by visiting your website www.cleoutfl.gov
7:12 and search for attend council meetings online. In the interest of time, efficiency, and ensuring everyone who wishes to address to the council are
7:20 given an opportunity to do so, the following will apply to all comments made by the public in person and virtually. Each speaker will be
7:28 permitted three minutes to address the council and in efforts to be respectful during the meeting. Please make sure your cell phones are set to silence.
7:37 Thank you for participating in your city government. Tonight, we will observe a moment of silence. Uh please rise and remain standing for the pledge of allegiance.
8:00 Amen to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it
8:09 stands. One nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
8:16 All right, I hear you, sir. [laughter] Uh, this afternoon we have a
8:25 presentation from Admin Health, uh, Miss K. Barnett. Yes, ma'am. How you doing? Doing good. How are you?
8:32 Okay.
8:38 Well, good afternoon council. It's great to be with you this afternoon and a pleasure to just share some of the updates that we're seeing here at Advent
8:46 Health in service of the health of our residents here in Clermont. So, if you would go back with me in time,
8:55 I wanted to share just the history of Advent Health's presence here in Clermont and our endeavor of caring for the residents right here in Clermont.
9:04 While I've had the pleasure of getting to know a few of you over the past few years, Advent Health has actually been serving this community since 2005.
9:13 That presence here in Clermont really started with our first footprint of urgent care right down the road at Highway 50 and South Greater Hills Road.
9:21 It came to fruition in a much broader scale in 2021 when we opened our emergency department and health park.
9:28 And just last year, we were able to expand to our third site here in Clermont, right over on Highway 27.
9:34 Thank you, Mayor Murry, for joining us in that celebration as we expanded primary care and urgent care services in that corridor of growth.
9:43 Oh, where did my presentation go? There we go.
9:49 Thank you. So, just building upon the services that we have here. Just wanted to share a bit with you about the emergency level care that we are providing over there on Highway 50 in
9:58 Citrus Tower Boulevard. Everything at that emergency at that emergency site is at the full service level of care that
10:06 you could expect to receive at a hospital. That comes from our board-certified emergency physicians, emergency trained nurses, therapeutics,
10:15 and diagnostics as well. Next door to that is where we have our Advent Health Clermont Health Park. This is where we're seeing a lot of growth and some of
10:22 the exciting updates that I wanted to share with this group today. First and foremost being that we're recruiting more physicians to this area. We all
10:30 know that Clermont is a rapidly growing space and we're working diligently to bring more and more providers across
10:37 primary care and specialty care to this community. An example of that comes in our cardiology space. If you were a new
10:46 patient seeking care in cardiology about a year ago, you would have had a 45day wait to get into a specialist with Advent Health. Today, I'm proud to say
10:54 with the recruitment of additional providers, we've gotten that wait time down to two days so that new patients are able to get in and receive that care
11:02 quickly. Again, that site also provides a lot of outpatient services from lab and imaging as well.
11:09 Now, not only are we growing in Clermont, but I would be remiss not to share the progress that we're seeing right up the road as we've opened Advent
11:16 Health Miniola as well. What I'm proud about as it relates to our Clermont residents is now Clermont residents who seek emergency care have the ability to
11:24 stay right here in Lake County and reduces the need for those patients to leave our county when they need inpatient care. We've cared for over
11:32 12,000 patients since we opened in December of last year. And we are achieving the top 25% benchmark in every
11:40 clinical measure across the board. And so I'm really proud of the clinical team that's leading that work every day and very excited and passionate about making
11:48 sure that residents right here in Lake County can receive the best possible care. Now, while we're very excited to
11:55 provide excellent level clinical care, caring for our community and their health and well-being outside of the four walls of a hospital or a health
12:03 healthc care facility is just as important. And so, wanted to highlight some of the partners that we're working with. One example of this in driving
12:11 community well-being was our recent Hills of Hope Breast Cancer Awareness um tea. And so, thank you to our council women for being there and supporting
12:20 that initiative as we support the awareness of breast cancer and really s seeking to help our women in this
12:27 community um build upon their awareness in that space. So, here's a few photos and I just want to thank this council
12:34 for your ongoing support as we promote health and well-being in this community. Any questions?
12:43 I just wanted to thank you for doing the the breast cancer awareness tea. That was wonderful. And Miss Meyers, I got my
12:51 ultrasound done and I've got a clean bill of health. So, thank you for encouraging me to do that.
12:55 Yes. Thank you. And thank you for your support of that. We appreciate it.
12:59 I would like to say thank you for sponsoring that for us. It was a wonderful event and we look forward to having it again. Maybe you can come next year.
13:07 Yes. I that's my goal and my plan. So, thank you. It was wonderful. Thank you again. Yes, very much. It's our pleasure.
13:14 And I just say thank you for coming into the community and for all the things you all done since you arrived since 2005.
13:20 All the different events you have sponsored over the years and everything and since the uh hospital opened over there in Mola. I've heard nothing but great things about it. So, so welcome to
13:29 the community and let us know if we can be of any services. Thank you. We appreciate it greatly. Have a good afternoon. Thank you.
13:41 The next item is public comments. If you wish to address the council in person, please come to the microphone and state your name and address. Once in-person
13:48 comments have concluded, we will move on to the virtual comments. If you are participating online on Microsoft Teams and wish to pro provide comments, please
13:58 raise your hand and you will be called on to unmute your microphone when it is your turn to speak. If you are participating by phone, you will press
14:06 star five on your phone to raise your hand. When called upon, you will press star six to unmute your microphone.
14:14 For all virtual participant, if you wish to comment comment on other items on the agenda, please stay on the Microsoft Teams or on your phone and raise your
14:22 hand when the items come up on the agenda. This portion of the meeting is only for items that are not on the
14:30 agenda. In the interest of time, efficiency, and ensuring everyone who wishes to address the address the council is given the
14:37 opportunity to do so, each speaker will be be permitted three minutes to address the council to avoid disruption
14:46 of the meeting. Speakers should avoid inappropriate language, personal texts, and derogatory statements and direct comments to the city council. Everyone
14:54 is requested to be respectful of each other, even when we disagree.
14:59 Public comment is now open. Please come to the microphone and
15:12 good afternoon, mayor, members of the council. I have two issues and I'll be real quick with it. Um the first one, just some clarification. In our bill
15:19 this month, there was a notice that they are upgrading the water old water meters to new meters.
15:28 and that the upgrade reduces the cost of having someone drive each meter to read it um at a savings that is passed on to
15:37 you like me the individual. So my first question is how is that going to be passed on to me? Because someone used to
15:45 ride around and check them. How is that cost going to be passed on to me at a reduction? And then it also says that
15:53 because the new meters reading irrigation the first month is not capable, it's being calibrated that your
16:02 next bill may be a little higher. So my other question is if they're not able to read it when they put the the new one in, how are they going to determine a
16:11 cost to add it to my other bill? Like how are they going to capture the true numbers of what the bill will be if they can't capture that information when they
16:18 install the new meter? So if I can just get some questions to that. And the other issue is just like a public service announcement. Right. So, I'm a
16:27 member of the American Heart Association elect um executive committee and in our meeting the other day, they mentioned
16:35 that there's a program in all public libraries called Libraries with Heart.
16:42 I've never heard of it. Have you all heard of this library with heart? Okay, so Cooper Memorial does have this this program called Libraries of Heart and it
16:51 was announced by the Lake County Library System on September 18th, 2026.
16:56 And what and in partnership with the American Heart Association, the HCA Healthc Care Foundation, what this is is
17:04 that it allows a person to go to the library to check out a meter to check their numbers. I'm one for big on people
17:13 knowing their numbers. If you know your numbers, you know better. you do better.
17:16 But if it's not advertised, how are people going to know about libraries of heart to go check out the
17:24 meters so they know what their blood pressures are and we can eliminate strokes and heart attacks?
17:33 Thank you. Anyone else?
17:45 Good afternoon, Mr. Mayor. My name is John How. I live at 920 Lakefront Village Drive, Cleo, Florida. I'm here
17:53 and I'm also the vice president of the Lakefront Village Homeowners Association. We're requesting the city's approval to install residential only
18:00 street parking signage on the Lakefront Village Drive.
18:14 We're here to act proactively and stop a public safety issue before it can take it route with Lake Haven on Grand newly
18:21 prohibiting street parking nearby a wave of spillover traffic into our community is highly predictable because of our
18:30 narrow townhouse configuration. on the outside parking will immediately congest our streets, block delivery vehicles,
18:38 and prevent emergency services from safely accessing our homes. Establishing this enforcement framework now during
18:47 our developer turnover transition allows us to nip this hazard in the bud and protect our infrastructure. To ensure
18:54 seamless transition, our community is already organizing an internal residential vehicle tag system so
19:02 parking authorities can easily identify authorized vehicles and prevent mistaken towing. We ask your support and guidance
19:09 in establishing this protection and ensuring our residents continued safety. Thank you for your time.
19:16 Thank you, sir.
19:31 Good evening, council. Mike Kramer, uh, Clermont Yach Club. I want to say thank you very much uh to everybody who's
19:40 already voted. Uh, I voted and I'm really pleased and I see the numbers are big. So elections next week and I want
19:48 to remind everybody how important this election and every election is because there's a lot of change of foot and and we need to be a part of it. Don't sit on
19:56 the sideline and complain later. I want to thank council for passing comprehensive plan along. Especially I
20:04 want to thank councilman council person strange Myers and Peterson for moving that along. This is when small town government really works. You guys did a
20:14 great job because planning for growth is important and planning for the right kind of growth is essential. So we have our compass now and I hope that we can
20:22 use it to guide us forward. I thank everyone. I hope we have a succinct meeting. We did quite well for the most of last meeting right up until when we didn't. So thank you.
20:33 Thank you. Anyone else?
20:57 I am farmer Banks Hellfrick. I live in the Clay Road District. Farm tip of the day. Um there is a family called the
21:04 Brachius family. Uh that includes broccoli, cauliflower, cabbage, uh Brussels sprouts, and uh some types of
21:11 kales as well. Um mayor, council, distinguished guest, nostalgia is the place in time we visit where bitter and sweet connect.
21:23 Sweet as in it is a precious, beautiful moment we want to relive and bitter in that we can never experience it the same
21:31 way ever again, creating a happy and sad moment simultaneously.
21:38 When nostalgia arises, if we observe it through the eyes of gratitude, we spill into the sweet more than the
21:47 bitter. By being thankful for having the experience, by sitting with it, the bitter subsides.
21:57 For the past 23 months, I have attended and been a part of this community, shared insights, visions of a brighter future for all in this room.
22:08 Looking back, I feel nostalgic.
22:11 And yet, I choose gratitude over regret every time.
22:16 Thank you for allowing me to share my vision. Thank you for accepting me in this community. And of course, thank you for allowing me to offer a farm tip of
22:25 the day. I am Farmer Banks Hellfrick, your candidate for state house district 25. May you all be blessed and I thank you again.
22:35 Thank you. Yes, sir.
22:59 Good afternoon. My name is Kurt Shu. I live in the city of Clermont. I have restricted access due to my military service in combat. Um the last meeting I
23:07 was able to attend was in the end of September and u it was a long meeting short five hours or so from great discussions. I I actually bought an Elmo
23:15 and I forgot to bring it. So I want to thank you for all that. I have a little teddy bear and trying to get the slides. I uh next meeting I'll try to get that.
23:23 Um I had a lot of questions. Um, I enjoyed the debate about the parking garage and the paramedic firefighter EMS
23:32 service, but where my confusion was was about money pulled from restricted or reserve funds. And I was what I couldn't
23:40 find and I did some looking online is is there a policy when money's taken out and pulled from the reserve funds for the city and if it's put into an effort
23:49 or restricted fund. I don't understand that. And so my presentation about how money is allocated from the reserve fund that's been saved over I don't know
23:57 could be five years or 10 years. I don't know that answer. And so my question goes back to
24:04 um the amount of money that's pulled out. My understanding from the 22nd meeting was the money was pulled out of
24:12 the reserve funds. If I'm wrong, please tell me. And about $20 million for one of the two sites for the park garage.
24:19 Plus, if they don't go with the city hall site, which is my favorite because it saves money, then you've got to buy the land, which is four to$6 million. Is
24:26 that correct? No. So, I'm wrong. Second part is is did the city council ever consider putting that before the voters?
24:34 Is it if it's city money that's going to be spent on the parking garage or you ever think about putting for the voters?
24:39 Let the city of Clermont voters who would pay for the garage eventually, get them vote on it on the ballot. So, that's that. The same thing that applies
24:47 to the ambulance service. Did you ever think about the money? Because it's about $2 million extra per year from my
24:54 calculation. So, it's going to be about5 million and change a year for the city service. Save two to three minutes for the ambulance service and the EMS for
25:02 the fire department buying the equipment. My understanding you you set aside5 to $6 million. Is that correct?
25:07 Thank you, ma'am. And so, I'm concerned that why they wouldn't since this talk about it for a year or more. Why would we the voters actually have a voice in that and vote on it? That's my summary.
25:18 Thank you for your time. Have a wonderful Oh, last point. 23rd of October, the US Marine Corps barracks. I
25:25 was deployed in Beirut, Lebanon in 83 84. 241 service members died when a truck bomb.
25:33 They took the ammo away from the Marines. They went and put clips in their thing. I was over there. I was from the fall of 83 to the spring of 84.
25:40 And they would not let United States Marines who were very well trained on their weapons put a clip in and have their weapons loaded. The B the truck came up to Constantine, drove into the
25:50 barracks and 241. The guy, the last guy who was pulled out of that rubble, who survived five days, lives in Florida, lives in Orlando.
25:59 Five days he stayed in that rubble. God bless. Thank you. Anyone else?
26:09 This is public comment. Anyone in the chamber wish to address anything that's not on the agenda may come to the microphone and state your name and address and have three minutes.
26:18 Anyone else? Seeing no one else, I close down public chamber. Yes, sir. This time, sir.
26:26 No one online. Okay. Since there is no one online, I close public comment.
26:35 All right. Before we move on, uh Mr. Van Wagner, do we have any changes to the agenda?
26:41 Item number 15, uh is being withdrawn.
26:50 Okay, so it's withdrawn. We need no actions on that, right?
26:56 We need no action on that since it's already been withdrawn. Any other changes?
27:04 That's it. Thank you. Thank you. All right.
27:11 Before Before I go into uh the consent agenda is I would like to address the
27:18 item that's uh I think need need we as a council need to maybe uh give some consideration to. Um so if you allow me
27:26 couple of minutes. Um so moved.
27:30 Thank you. I want to address the letter we received from the Central Florida PBA's uh Climouth chapter. I do not believe we should allow that letter to
27:39 go unanswered. Uh police officer asking a straightforward question. Does the city stand behind its officers when
27:46 public statements are made about them and the facts are disputed. They deserve a clear and credible answer from this
27:54 council. Let me be clear about what I'm I am proposing. I am not asking the city to investigate a resident
28:00 judge in his one speech or determine the truth of allegations that may already be before court. I'm asking that we examine
28:09 our own action, our own procedures, and our own responsibilities.
28:14 Specifically, I believe an independent review should address three questions.
28:19 First, whether any official communicated or met with the comment commentator
28:26 involved in re regarding members of our police department, and if so, what information was shared. Second, whether
28:34 the city has fulfilled its public records obligation fairly, fully, and consistently with all requests there
28:41 concerning our police department. Third, whether documentation in the city's possession support our refutes
28:50 support or refutes the specific allegation involving one of our police captains that continue to be to circulate publicly. I do not believe
28:59 this review should be conducted by the city manager, the police chief or the city attorney or this council. Each has
29:07 a role in this matter under under consideration. and the public deserve a few uh review free from any appearance
29:13 of a conflict of interest. That includes me.
29:18 No one should be exempt from scrutiny simply because of their position.
29:22 Therefore, I move I ask this council to authorize an independent outside investig investigator, preferably an
29:31 attorney with no current business relationship with this city or any part party involved to conduct this review
29:39 and present the findings to the council in a public session subject to applicable law. I further propose that
29:46 we establish a reasonable timeline and budget. If our actions have been proper, an independent review will provide
29:54 documented evidence that our officers and residents can trust. If shortcomings are identified, we have an respon we have a responsibility to acknowledge
30:02 them and take corrective action. This is not about taking sides. It is about protecting the integrity of our police
30:10 department, respecting the rights of our residents, and maintaining public confidence in our city government. As mayor, I believe accountability begins with us.
30:21 I am not asking this council to accuse anyone tonight. I am asking whether we have the courage and the commitment to
30:29 examine ourselves, establish the facts, and let the findings speak for themselves. So, I move that we take this
30:37 step in the interest of transparency, accountability, and public trust. With that being said, I would entertain a motion.
30:44 Mr. Mayor, may I mention something real quick, sir?
30:47 Um, I've been on the phone all day and I'm waiting for some very important information that I think would be important to this conversation. And if
30:55 you'd give me the latitude, I'd like to share in my reports at the end. I think I have some very important information that you'd all like to hear before we do
31:03 anything. I'm not opposed to what you're wanting to do, but I think you want to know all this. And like I said, I'm just waiting on something right now. It could be any time now.
31:11 Mr. Mayor, I support um what you're asking. I think it's reasonable and appropriate and um I would like given
31:20 that I haven't had time to consider it um to maybe address this at the end of the meeting and hear from our attorney,
31:29 possibly the police chief. There's elements of this that I don't understand and so um if you're comfortable I'm happy to add it to the agenda at the end
31:38 and it sounds like you might have more information. Mr. City Manager, does that work for you to add this as an item at the end of the We can add it at the agenda and discuss
31:46 it. But I just like I say it's I think it's one of them things that we need to address and and everything. uh um
31:54 with the letters I I received and what I've seen float around or somebody brought to my attention float around on it. I think it's something we need to take care of. Okay.
32:03 So, I'm for that. Is there I'll move to add it to item number 24 tonight.
32:08 A second. A second. [clears throat] Okay. Well, we will add it to the agenda at report after we hear from Mr. Ben Wagner. We can discuss it. Okay. Right.
32:17 Thank you. Thank you. I appreciate it.
32:21 The next portion of the meeting is the consent agenda which contain items that have been determined to be routine and non-controversial. If anyone in the ordering wish to address a particular
32:30 item on the consent agenda, now is opportunity for you to do so.
32:34 Additionally, if staff or members of the city council wish to speak on a consent item, they
32:41 have the same same opportunity. The consent items tonight are items, if I'm not mistaken, item 1 through, excuse me, 11.
32:51 Yes. Okay. Anyone wish anything to be pulled from the consent agenda? Yes, ma'am.
32:59 I couldn't hear because I was out there.
33:01 Did you ask for if you're pulling on the consent agenda? Yes, ma'am. Um, number seven. Seven. Okay.
33:11 Any other number seven?
33:19 What was that? Question on number 11.
33:22 Okay. Well, I'm planning on Yeah, I'm planning on pulling that one so we can talk about that one a little bit. No, number 11 as well.
33:34 Any other? Seeing no other, I entertain a motion. I have a question. Yes.
33:39 Thank you. Um, I just have a question because I don't know know that it needs to be pulled. Can I ask the city attorney? Um, regarding number 10, um,
33:49 this proposal does not specifically allocate where the funds are coming from. That would be done through a budget amendment similar to I think we
33:58 had an item on the last agenda where I asked you if we wanted to specify where the funds come, we could do that at the the budget amendment resol or budget amendment agenda item.
34:08 That's easy to say. Is that correct? You can do that.
34:11 Okay. So, we don't So, approving this doesn't uh put in stone where the funding is coming from. Oh, no. It doesn't put it in stone.
34:19 Okay. All right. Thank you. So, you Okay. Mhm. All right.
34:25 There's no other. I entertain a motion for items 1 through six and item 8, 9, 10. So, order.
34:33 Second.
34:34 Okay. We have a motion and a second for approval of consent items 1 through six and items 8, 9, and 10. Any further
34:41 discussion? Hearing none. All in favor, let it be known by saying I. I. All oppose and the chair vote I as well. Motion passes 5.
34:50 Item number seven. Yes, ma'am.
35:11 Charlene Harrison, Fort Desoto Street, Clermont. As you see, Dodto, I'm a little confused. I would like to know first who did this and who asked for
35:20 this because nobody did down in the neighborhood. This was pulled years ago.
35:24 Do you know anything about it, city manager? Do you know anything about this? Well, I think it's put on agenda.
35:30 Can you speak up? I'm sorry. I I know it's on the agenda, but we can talk to public.
35:34 But well, but it didn't just happen by the fairy wand thing. Who put it on to ask for to go do a a study when they did
35:42 it years ago. They've done it three times. Cost well close to a million dollars moving power poles things. There
35:50 is only a short piece of Dodto and it's down there where I'm at.
35:54 Miss Miss, let me let me So I'd like to know who did this? Who who put this on there? Let me let me let me help you out with this. If I'm not
36:01 mistaken, this isn't [clears throat] is this isn't about sidewalks in your area if I'm not mistaken. What I read through in this package, it's what?
36:08 It's not about sidewalks down where where you live. Okay. And I was confused, too. So, my my I was my
36:16 impression. That's what I thought at first.
36:17 Well, it says the word sidewalks right here.
36:19 Yeah. But not not on your your area of town. They referring to East Desoto Street. Yeah. Okay. In the side street down where you are.
36:27 Yes. Down where I'm at. Okay. Uh, and the and if you're happy with that, that's fine. And I'll tell you why I brought this up. I I just I'm sorry I had to run from the house.
36:35 Yeah.
36:36 Yes. Well, I was I I understand. And when I saw it, that's what the first thing I saw I thought too. But then when I looked in really looked through the
36:43 package, they all on sidewalks on side streets on Easto by the cemetery.
36:48 And I hope y'all think too because I want the rest of you to know if this should ever come up. It's they've done it three times and there's people just
36:55 want to do it for spite. Pure spite. Do you hear me? Spite. Yeah. They would be five feet from our homes.
37:03 They could see the color of our eyes and everything we're doing in our window. How would you like that? Yes.
37:08 But you would have to take hundred-year-old trees, bushes, power poles, and it was going to be close to a million dollars. So, I wanted to make
37:16 sure when I saw that, I mean, it would have been nice for somebody to put East Dodto, right?
37:22 I mean, god dang, what do we pay people for? Sorry, but Yeah, I wanted clarification.
37:29 I get and if you're happy with it, mayor, down there, you might want to talk to some of your homeowners because it may be the worst thing because they can be out there at 2 o'clock in the morning
37:36 sitting on the sidewalk looking at your house.
37:40 Well, would you like that? I bet you wouldn't over there. Y'all, you enjoy not that over there too on Lakes Shore. We're okay. But this is okay. I'm good.
37:48 I had the same concern and I do know about the studies on Desoto years ago, West Desoto as well. So that's why I asked the question to myself earlier.
37:56 So, so we Okay. Entertain a motion. Are we closing public comment?
38:04 What's that?
38:04 It was pulled. So, okay. Well, we'll open. Uh, anyone in audio wish to address this item may come to the microphone and state your name and address and have three minutes.
38:16 Valerie Shuitt, 931 West Montro Street.
38:18 Um, I do think that investing in sidewalks in the neighborhoods that don't have it is a very good investment.
38:25 Um, it's just is what helps get and often people that live in those neighborhoods do actually want that.
38:29 They want to be able to walk safely um in their neighborhoods, kids going to school, all that kind of stuff. I do think that's important. I am a little
38:38 shocked at the $200,000 price tag for 7,000 linear feet for just engineering
38:44 of sidewalks. So, I would love to understand that a little bit better, but I would say that's a pretty big bummer
38:52 to pull that much money from our budget for um and it's just the engineering that doesn't that fills me with trepidation for some of the other
38:59 projects that we want to do for walkability and bikability. So, I know this stuff isn't cheap um but I don't feel like it's entirely unreasonable for me to think that is very expensive.
39:11 Yes, ma'am. Anyone else?
39:16 There's public comment. Anyone that want to address item number seven on the in the consent agenda may come to the microphone and state your name and address and have three minutes.
39:25 Seeing no one in chamber, we have anyone online, sir? No one online. I close public comment.
39:30 Bring it back to council. What? Say council. Um, Mr. Bank, [laughter] no comments. I support it.
39:39 Miss Mar, I support it too. No comment.
39:43 I support it with no comments or questions at this time.
39:46 Uh well, since it was pulled, um the information that I found was that public works is looking to connect all of the
39:54 neighborhood in the Lincoln Park area, pretty much east of east, west of 27, north of 50 [snorts] to each block, one
40:03 sidewalk on each street. Um this would provide connectivity to Aurelia Cole Academy, which has been one of the things that's been coming up as of late.
40:11 Um, I share the trepidation at a $200,000 expense for engineering. Um, what I was told was that the street the
40:19 sidewalks are proposed to be 5t wide, which is a good width. It's not, we're not talking three-foot sidewalks. That,
40:27 um, incorporating shade is something that would be part of this conversation.
40:33 and that originally this budgeted item was 250,000 by our staff and their first proposal was 225. So staff has brought
40:42 this down from what was originally proposed. Um I would be okay postponing this if we
40:50 wanted to. Um I did reach out to a a what I would consider a representative in the neighborhood and said you know is
40:58 this something you don't want? I mean that would be kind of the first question. I don't have a problem moving forward with sidewalks. Um I did
41:07 um I did feel like my questions were addressed and I am happy to move forward with it unless there was objection from
41:15 the public um so that we could move forward with getting these done. The funding of the design I'm told would be there was something else would be in uh
41:23 fiscal year 28. So it would come back to us with a proposal to actually build the sidewalks. I'm also told that staff is working on hiring an engineer in the
41:32 building services department and that that person might be kind of a gateway for things like this so that we have a better feel for
41:39 whether this price point is an appropriate price point which is why I'd be comfortable waiting if we wanted to wait. But all signs point to at least
41:49 this is a good deal compared to the way we've been doing things. So I'm okay if everyone else is okay. I wasn't going to pull it.
41:56 Okay. I'm I'm okay with it. This goes back to a few years back uh and especially in uh with Ria Cole Academy
42:04 and looking at Ria Cole Academy coming on uh we well even before I was the mayor actually I had put uh requested to the city council to put sidewalks on
42:12 every street out there and they had started this project and of course when Ry Cole Academy was coming along uh we came back and reiterated the fact that
42:20 we needed these sidewalks. So we have kids walking in the middle of streets out there. have some kids walking in streets where actually we've had people killed uh because of the speeding and
42:29 everything and and walking along because we don't have any sidewalk. So, it goes back um to address the the cost of
42:36 engineering. If you ever been on some of these streets, I think it's this package include about four different streets and if you look at the topography on there,
42:44 it's going to take some some engineering to get it all done because of the topography. Um, and one of the main streets that's not even in the package.
42:51 Uh, I think we went out and looked at it before and they was talking about engineering going, uh, just the engineering is going to be about $200,000 just for one one street. So,
43:00 I'm in support of it and ready to move it forward. So, thank you. Move to approve item number seven. A second.
43:09 Have a motion and a second to approve consent item number seven. Any further discussion?
43:15 Hearing none. All in favor, let it be known by saying I.
43:17 I. Okay. All oppose and the chair will vote I as well. Motion carries 50. Item number 11. Uh I know somebody out there
43:26 asked, but I pull this because I I guess I have some confusion on this uh because
43:33 what it's asking for is uh wave the fee for disabled veterans. And it was my understanding that our policy
43:41 already requires for this disabled veterans to park at the boat for free already. So, I was curious why we needed
43:49 to put this on here if our policy already allow for that. And maybe there is some I understand there may be some confusion because even if our policy
43:57 allowing for them, some veterans are actually been actually been paying. So, I'm trying to get some clarity myself. Okay.
44:04 Sure.
44:07 Yeah. Yes, sir. Uh, Mr. Mayor, it's it's my understanding that there's a state law that says that veterans don't have to pay for certain things like metered parking and things like that and
44:16 structure parking. So, what we did is is in that statute, it talks about a plated disabled veteran with a license plate that says disabled veteran.
44:25 What we did is we put it on here just to strengthen a little bit more and allow for someone with to say if the driver's license if they don't have a plate, they have a driver's license that has the DV
44:33 on it or the form from the military that says disabled veteran. if they were out with a friend's boat and they were out with them or something like that that we gave them that opportunity to do that.
44:41 So, we just did it to add a little bit more strength to the statute. But if if you're comfortable with the way the statute reads and that a plated disabled veteran, then it's already covered.
44:52 You're correct.
44:52 Right. Well, and I guess that's my question on it was the fact that if it's already covered by state law and everything and um I guess I didn't see
45:02 no need to have to go back and redo this. Okay. Um the one thing do concern me right there what you were just saying is about the fact that if they out with
45:11 their friend with a vote u they don't have a disabled Yeah. I'm sorry they they have to pay it in that case and and everything uh because state law and I I
45:20 think our policy should also state the fact that if they disable course most of them going to have a DV tag that say they disabled and they have a letter
45:27 that's saying this. So, um, and they need to put it on the on their vehicle, but, um, I'd be concerned with the fact
45:35 that just giving them stickers because anyone they can pass that loan to anyone without the DV tag. So, okay, be careful with that. But this is any and this is a
45:44 public form. Anyone in the public wish to address it may come to the microphone and state your name and address and have three minutes.
45:59 Paul Hoisington 564 east of Soda Street had the same concerns or questions that you just mentioned mayor. And then my other question was it says
46:08 city residents disabled veterans. I know there was discussion at the last council meeting about doing something for the city of Minnola.
46:15 So are we going to give Minnola disabled veterans the same privilege? And if we're not, just some clarity. That was just it.
46:25 Thank you. Thank you. Yes, sir.
46:32 Good afternoon, Mayor Kurt Shu. I live in the city of Clermont. I restrict the address. Um I'm a disabled vet. Uh I used to be the legislative chair for the
46:39 Veterans Foreign War Florida. I was on the committee both state and national for six years. Um, the law in Florida states for those disabled veterans that
46:48 are 100% permanent total, usually combat veterans like myself, have disabled vet plates, right?
46:53 Every time you see that plate that represents $4,000 in income to Florida from the federal government. We're number three for contributing money,
47:00 veterans, act duty, military, the budget that comes into Florida. We're number three as far as the state budget and contributing money to the state of Florida. But if you're not 100%
47:09 permanent total, you don't get a disabled vet plate. subd disabled veterans with plates who have parked when the disabled vet or handicap parking is blocked, they parked in other
47:17 spots and they've gotten fines or fees or tickets. So [snorts] there is room I think for the city to do something saying if you are a disabled veteran and
47:26 there's no handicap like at the boat ramp or somewhere which you brought up a previous meeting that you have they have cited them before when there is no
47:34 disabled or handicapped veter they park in a different spot and maybe there's clarification needing but other jurisdictions because I cover the whole state of Florida people have been cited
47:43 then they take their disabled vet letter like I have and and their plate number to the to the clerk or the police department they say you know what
47:51 happened. So hopefully that's informs the board members. Thank you very much for your service. Thank you.
47:57 Um the code is 320.80848 in the Florida statutes.
48:11 Good afternoon, 421 Brembo away, Florida. And I am a disabled veteran and I have parked down
48:20 at the waterfront and I paid $64 for that parking to find out a week later I didn't have to. As long as my
48:29 license plate shows that I have the wheelchair on there, the entire state of Florida allows us to park for free. The
48:38 only time you have you have to pay is if it's a private um parking lot. And I wasn't sure if the city rented out
48:45 sometimes cities lease collection of the money and everything which would turn it into a park private parking lot. But
48:54 since they didn't, I I did get it clarified though. And um not only is it the state of Florida, but the state of
49:00 Texas does the same thing. I parked in in Dallas and I never got a ticket. So um that Yeah, you can get it clarified
49:10 if you want, but your own police department can clarify it also. Right. Right. Thank you. Thank you, sir. Anyone else?
49:19 Anyone else? This is a public forum.
49:22 Anyone in the chamber wish to address this item number 11 on the consent agenda may come to microphone and state your name and address now. Three minutes
49:38 582 Eastnot Street. I just want to get some clarity on this uh uh parking thing. So we're saying that we're
49:45 looking at the idea of giving a break to the uh permanent and total disabled vets. What about the rest of them?
49:53 Disabled vest. That's not 100% 90% or 80%.
50:01 Excuse me. Disabled.
50:03 But you're not going to know that though. What's that?
50:07 I'm saying you see the tags for us with the 100% permanent in total. But the ones that's 90 or 80%, how are you going to know that?
50:16 acceptable documentation of disabled veteran status, which may include a Department of Veterans Affair disability le, a US Department of Defense identification card indicating
50:24 disability status, or any other documentation deemed access acceptable by the city. Done. Well, yeah. No, I'll comment later.
50:33 [laughter]
50:35 Anyone else? Anyone else wish to address this item?
50:41 Seeing no one else at close uh chamber, anyone online, sir? Not this time.
50:45 No one online. So I close public comment and bring it back to Mr. Bane.
50:50 Thank you, mayor. Just for clarification for our new rules, it's three minutes of Q&A each and then it's three minutes of any
50:58 additional Q&A or comments each. Is that correct? Correct.
51:02 Okay. Thank you. Um, so I my question I guess would be is the intent for this to
51:09 allow for veterans who are also I guess for veterans of any disability
51:19 status versus a the 100% disabled veteran that's qualifies for the plate.
51:30 No. Well, my my question to staff, whoever's doing this, is is the city's intent
51:37 to do this so that for veterans who don't qualify for the plate but are considered a disabled
51:45 veteran, they too can get, if we approve this, a waved
51:53 parking fee access for the year at the boat ramp.
52:00 Yes, sir. That was the intent. So it was it was anything that qualified as one of those identification marks. So the plates are 100% disabled bed, but you
52:08 can get some of these other if you're not 100%.
52:10 Okay. So this would be for any veteran who has a disability who can verify that whether it's the plate, a card, a
52:17 letter, doc, some sort of documentation that they can bring into city hall when they go to purchase annually a boat ramp
52:25 parking permit. They would provide that and it would be w the fee would be waved.
52:30 That's correct. And that's why we didn't that's why we didn't resolve or that's why we didn't just count on the statute itself because the statute was plated.
52:39 Yep.
52:40 Okay. Um and with the passes now um we verify city residency since it's currently the passes are only the more than daily or that's correct.
52:51 Okay. And when they when they get verification, do we put the sticker on the vehicle or do we give them the sticker and tell them to place it on the vehicle?
53:00 I Brian, would you like to come up and how how it's
53:10 I was writing reading his hand signals and I got lost.
53:13 I I I got the first one, but the rest of them I was smart. So, um, residents only come into utility billing to get their
53:21 pass for the year and then when they get their pass, they put it back in their car, but the staff does not put it on their car for the Okay. So, we would do the same for this
53:29 process. Okay. Um, and then are there some sort of checks at the boat ramp when those passes are used to make sure
53:39 that they match with the vehicle of that person? Not at this time.
53:42 Okay. I just want to make sure. Thank you. Those are my own questions. Okay. Thank you, Miss Myers.
53:48 Um, I'm in support of it. No comment other than that.
53:52 Mr. Peterson, I'm totally in support of it. I have many friends of mine that are 20, 40, 80% disabled and uh they deserve this
54:00 break and I think it's it's a way for the city to recognize the service and sacrifice that disabled veterans have done. So, I'm totally in for in favor of this.
54:11 Thank you. And Miss Strange, I'm in support. The only thing that I would ask, and I don't even need it in the motion, is for Mr. City Manager, if
54:18 you can bring us a policy on how we process um any sort of passes or membership or access to the recreational
54:25 facilities over the course of the next month or two, that would be much appreciated.
54:31 Okay. Well, the problem here, it says disabled veteran. Okay. You could be 70% and have a disability, but you're not
54:38 disabled, rated disabled. So, that we I am in agreement with Mr. Mr. Bane here, if we want to apply this to all
54:46 veterans, then go go ahead and let's change the policy and let's remove disab disabled and say veterans uh is
54:55 authorized uh free parking at the program. Okay? Uh because way of lit is pertaining to disabled. Matter of fact,
55:02 I'm a veteran with only 70%. Okay? And I'm not considered totally disabled. All right? And I do not have to tag myself,
55:09 okay? Because I'm not totally 100%. So I have no agreement. Uh no problem with it. We just need to uh Mr. W I guess you need to get involved with this and
55:17 rewrite the policy for us. I guess uh to say uh all veterans I guess is what we're going resident residents of city.
55:27 Okay. Um and there was a question about Minnola.
55:34 No, this is not pertaining to Minnola, I don't think. I think our city manager and deputy city manager is still in in
55:41 um communication with the city of Minnola about what what we're going to do there. So, this is not uh including Minnola residents, just the Clmont
55:49 residents. That being said, I entertain a motion.
55:52 I move to approve item number 11, resolution number 2026-045R as presented by staff. Second.
55:59 I have a motion. Um, you want to do it as presented by staff or we want to uh say all veterans cuz
56:08 this say disabled cuz you have a you rated some disability don't say don't identify you as disabled. Okay.
56:16 I think that this resolution provides a vehicle for people who are 70% or 10% or 20% to provide a letter to show that they're disabled.
56:24 The request as it came to us was to provide disabled vets. We've moved forward with that request. uh if we want to workshop who all is entitled to free
56:33 access to the boat ramp, I'm happy to do that. But we had a citizen come to us with a request. We've satisfied that request. I think we've done it at the maximum available by law and I'm happy with it as presented by staff.
56:44 Well, I I could clarify it language with with a disability.
56:49 I mean, without changing what you have been presented just to say include exactly that just to make it clear.
56:55 Yeah. Yeah. If if adding partial disability is fine, that's that's fine. I don't have a problem with that. That'd be fine.
57:03 Okay. So, that would you uh so I move to approve item number 11, resolution 2020 2026-045R
57:11 as presented by staff with further clarification that partial disability would qualify.
57:15 Second. Okay. All right. All right, I have a motion and second with the um for approval of item number 11 with the
57:24 change in language as as stated. Um any further discussion?
57:30 Hearing none. All in favor? Let it be known by saying I. I. All oppose. Chair vote I as well. Okay. Thank you.
57:41 Public comment is closed. Sorry.
57:43 [laughter]
57:44 Farrell 421 Bramway, Minhole, Florida. It's closed.
57:48 I understand what you just said. That's fine. It's closed.
57:50 But I still fall under the state statute which says I can park even though I live in Minnola.
57:58 I [clears throat] can park anywhere in the state for free as long as um it's not a private parking lot. Okay.
58:07 Thank you. Okay.
58:08 Yes, sir. So, so you're not going to give me a ticket, right? [laughter] We we we going to have uh as I stated
58:15 before, I think our attorney need to get in here and rewrite it right our policy and everything with all that in there because uh as I stated when they brought
58:25 up, as I stated before, I know under uh we already allow for veterans this 100% disability. Okay. I trust you to do well.
58:33 Thank you. Right.
58:46 All right. Next item. Item number 12 is final consideration ordinance number 2026-00006.
58:56 Ordinance number 20260006, an ordinance of the city of Clermont, Lake County, Florida, adopting the small-cale comprehensive plan amendment
59:04 for the city of Clermont, Florida, pursuant to the local government comprehensive planning act, chapter 163, part two, Florida statutes, setting
59:12 forth the authority for adoption of the small-cale comprehensive plan amendment, setting forth the purpose and intent of the small-cale comprehensive plan
59:20 amendment, providing for the adoption of the small-cale comprehensive plan amendment. Establishing the legal status of the small-scale comprehensive plan
59:27 amendment providing for conflict severability administrative correction of scrier's error publication and effective date. Would you also like me to read the next one?
59:37 Yep. Ordinance 20260007, an ordinance under the code of ordinances of the city of Clermont, Lake County, Florida, amending the
59:45 official zoning map of the city of Clermont, referred to in chapter 122 of ordinance number 289C, code of ordinances, reszoning the real
59:53 properties described herein, as shown below, providing for conflict, severability, administrative correction of scrivener's error, recording, publication, and an effective date.
1:00:03 Okay, just a sec. Uh we went ahead and covered item number 12 and 13. We already had both of them. So we're going to do both of them, but we will act upon
1:00:10 and one of them be uh separately. Item 12 and 13 separate. We vote separately, but we hear hear both of them at one time. Thank you. Yes, sir.
1:00:18 Yes, sir. Good afternoon, Mayor, City Council, and guest Nick Gonzalez Development Services. This is Oakley Sber Recreation. The applicant, Jimmy
1:00:26 Crawford, is requesting a small-scale comprehensive plan amendment and reszoning for the 5 acre vacant parcel located northeast of Oakley Siver Drive and Huntrace Boulevard intersection.
1:00:38 The request includes changing the future land use designation from residential office to commercial and reszoning the property from R3 residential
1:00:46 professional to PUB with C2 general commercial uses.
1:00:51 The proposal includes one multi-tenant building totaling 30,000 square feet which would contain three restaurants and four indoor paddle ball courts. The
1:01:01 conceptual plan prepared by Germana Engineering shows the general layout of the building and associated parking.
1:01:07 Access to the site would come from Oakley Sever Drive along with continued crossaxis through Superior Residences property to the south used for emergency access only.
1:01:19 The city's traffic engineer reviewed the project and determined that a left turn lane is not currently warranted based on the existing traffic volumes and roadway
1:01:28 operations. However, because Oakley Sever Drive has curves and elevation changes that could affect visibility, the ordinance includes a condition
1:01:36 allowing the city to require a left turn lane if the site distance evaluation completed during the site plan review identifies any safety concerns.
1:01:46 The development will be required to comply with all applicable Clermont land development regulations and architectural design standards. The
1:01:54 applicant is requesting a waiver to emit canopy trees from the west landscape buffer along Oakley Sver Drive to
1:02:00 preserve views towards Jax Lake. Accent trees will be used instead with the total number of required trees still being provided.
1:02:13 Staff has reviewed the application and finds a proposed project is consistent with the Clermont code of ordinances and comprehensive plan. The proposed
1:02:21 commercial use aligns with the goals, objectives, and policies for future land use and the intent of the land development regulations. The planning
1:02:28 and zoning commission recommended approval of ordinance 2026-006 by a vote of 60 and recommended approval
1:02:35 of ordinance 2026-007 by a vote of 60 with the conditions that the access from superior residences be
1:02:43 limited to emergency access only and that the accent trees shall be used in the landscape buffer with the same number of required trees to be planted
1:02:52 provided that the required minimum amount of canopy trees shall be planted at a 1:1 ratio. ratio elsewhere on the property. At the introduction of
1:03:00 ordinance number 2026-00007 resoning, the recommended changes were amended and submitted with this packet.
1:03:08 Staff recommends approval of ordinance number 2026-06 amending the future land use and approval of ordinance number 2026007
1:03:18 resoning the parcel to PUD with C2 general commercial uses. That concludes SAS presentation.
1:03:24 Thank you. Is the applicant present?
1:03:32 Good afternoon, Mr. Mayor, council members, staff. Afternoon, sir.
1:03:36 My name is Jimmy Crawford. Uh, I'm an attorney representing the app. No, I am the applicant. I'm an attorney representing the owner as applicant. Uh,
1:03:44 I'm with Crawford Monica and Holt, 702 West Montro Street, Clermont, Florida.
1:03:49 Um, we're really happy and proud of this one. I hope everybody's gotten to look
1:03:56 at the um elevations that are in the pack. Um PNZ
1:04:04 had a great catch for us in that um we needed to do some further work on the access issue with Superior Residences to
1:04:13 our south. PNZ didn't want traffic traveling through their parking lot to get to our facility, which was never our
1:04:22 intent. Uh, so we went back, spoke with them, did some forensic research, and I do have one of these little packets for
1:04:30 everyone that I But I can just show them here. Whatever you guys would like. Let me do that. And if you want, anybody that wants one can first.
1:04:41 Yeah.
1:04:43 Okay. This is the original plan um that had the full access here um
1:04:51 showing gates. So we would have emergency access only through here.
1:04:57 The problem is that Superior Residences number one has an easement over this
1:05:05 part of the parcel because their main access to Hunt Trace is here. And this
1:05:13 is the access to get to much of their physical plant, uh, dumpsters, uh, all
1:05:20 AC, everything. So, they've got to have access to be able to go around there.
1:05:26 Uh, and the actual easement, which I've got and I think was included in your packet at the last minute, requires that
1:05:34 not to be blocked, and we certainly don't want to block it. So, we went back and have revised the plan to allow full access here from Superior.
1:05:45 These are not gates. Those are just the old easement boundaries. And gate here for emergency access only.
1:05:54 So, no one can get from Superior into our facility or from our facility into Superior unless they are emergency
1:06:03 services for Clermont or Lake County to do it. Um, the other question that PNZ had was on
1:06:11 the waiver of the canopy trees, they they weren't sure the view was worth preserving. And that's a subjective idea that everybody could have their own on.
1:06:23 But this is the view from the top and why we didn't want uh oaks and magnolia
1:06:30 20 years from now uh blocking that. We want to do sub subcanopy trees along here and replace an equal number of
1:06:38 canopy trees from there within our project. Um, I do have Chris Gmana who
1:06:45 is the project engineer here and he can answer any kind of technical questions and we'd be happy to hear from the public and answer any questions that you
1:06:54 guys have. And I've never tried paddle ball. It's it's uh uh often confused with pickle ball in Florida. Um, but
1:07:03 it's a big sport in Europe and South America. I was lucky enough last year to be in Italy and there were paddle ball
1:07:10 posters and tournaments all over the place. It's uh on TV. It's a it's a it's it's a big thing and I think it'll be
1:07:18 good for the fitness of our choice of champions location. With that be happy to try to answer questions or have Mr. Germanic answer them.
1:07:27 Thank you sir. If we have any question we will call you back up at a later time but this is a public forum. Anyone in the chamber wish to address this item
1:07:34 may come to the microphone and state your name and address and have three minutes.
1:07:48 Hi, good afternoon. My name is Lindsay Collins. Um I'm the executive director for Huntree Senior Living. Um we are formerly Superior Residences. So I think
1:07:56 that's a part of some of the problem here. We were never formally notified of this project. Um, we were never legally
1:08:04 notified of this project. We were never consulted with the developers or with Mr. Crawford's office. Um, so that's a
1:08:11 big part of our issue here. Um, I kind of heard this through the grapevine and I'm very disappointed in that. I've also reached out to the um, building and
1:08:20 zoning director here um, and never got a response back. Email, phone call, nothing. So, I'm a little disappointed
1:08:27 in that. Um, I'm very concerned about the residents safety. Um, our average resident's age is 85. These people are
1:08:36 your moms, your dads, your aunts, your uncles. Um, I'm sure they don't want this project in their backyard. It sounds like an amazing project.
1:08:45 [laughter] I'm all in favor for Clermont Grove. Um, however, I just want to make sure that it is used for
1:08:52 emergency access only. when we purchased um this this property. I've been with the company since 2010 12, sorry, 2012.
1:09:01 Um when that property was purchased, I believe in 200 I want to say one. Um it that that easement was put into place
1:09:08 because it was going to be used for um private access. We were going to add onto our property. U we were going to add an independent living. That project
1:09:17 was um scratched and we sold the property. Unfortunately, they sold it with that easement still in place. That was 20 something years ago. We've been a
1:09:26 pillar in the community for 24 years um serving seniors. Thank you for your service to everyone in here, by the way.
1:09:33 [laughter]
1:09:33 Um and so we would like to um I I love that Mr. Crawford said that it would be used for emergency access. That's my
1:09:40 biggest um complaint and objection with this is that I would want it to be only used for emergency access. Our residents use the parking lot. They don't go to the gym. They don't do paddle ball.
1:09:52 [laughter] they don't do those things.
1:09:53 Um, their exercise is literally physical therapy and it's our it's our parking lot. Um, and so I would like to be respectful of those residents in their
1:10:01 home and the noise level and all of those things that bring that growth along with it. Um, I would like to ask that you postpone a voting on this. Um,
1:10:09 we did not have an opportunity ample opportunity to review these records. Um, I would love to see that it's only used for emergency access only. um definitely
1:10:19 want to stress that and um I would I would definitely ask that that we give the the right opportunity to look at this paperwork and um to make the
1:10:27 appropriate actions. So that's all. Thank you. Thank you.
1:10:35 Anyone else? Anyone else? This is a public forum.
1:10:41 Anyone in the public wish to address this item may come to the microphone and state your name and address and have three minutes.
1:10:47 Seeing no one else in the chamber, I closed down the chamber. Uh, uh, Mr. Anybody online, Mr. Wayne?
1:10:53 No one online. So, I closed down public comment. Yes, sir. Mr. Crawford.
1:10:56 Uh, first of all, my apologies. I was under the impression from the owners that they had contacted the neighbors.
1:11:02 And I would imagine the letters, the posting I know happened, the letters I believe went out as well. So, I don't
1:11:10 know why uh those individuals did not receive the notice. Um, I would point to
1:11:17 the ordinance which requires that it be emergency access only. Um, I can put it
1:11:24 up here. If Nick's got it, he can probably do it faster than me.
1:11:30 Um, the last thing we want is to have any interference and good lord any injury or problem with somebody's
1:11:37 grandmother or grandfather. And at any of those, I would say that the easement is important. We understand because they
1:11:47 do need it to come around on our property to get into their physical plan operations. We don't have any plans on
1:11:54 blocking any of that, and we can't unless by mutual agreement we change the easement. Um, where are we? Here.
1:12:04 Yeah. Um, yes. uh primary ingress on Oakley Sver as shown on the plan uh
1:12:12 established cross access and it is established by an easement superior to be utilized for emergency access only.
1:12:21 And I will say it's the city's requirement might not be the right word.
1:12:27 There's a requirement for subdivisions over 25 lots and commercial over a certain intensity to have two ingress
1:12:35 and egress points. Um, that's fine. We we'd be happy not having
1:12:43 that ingress and egress point, just making a permanent gate. The fire department isn't going to come up hunt
1:12:49 trace all the way around the back of the facility and come in the ciruitous way.
1:12:56 I know it's for if if for one if for some reason one entrance is blocked, they need another one. So, I would leave
1:13:04 that totally up to the city. Our hope is that that lock rusts in place and never gets used. Uh but if if the city
1:13:12 believes it's important, we're okay with it. We just want to make sure that is ironclad in the ordinance recorded in the public records that nobody can use that except emergency services.
1:13:22 Okay. Thank you, sir. Mr. Bane.
1:13:27 Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I guess my question for staff would be what what do we have in record with regard to the notification
1:13:35 and do we have this adjacent property listed correctly as hunt trace
1:13:44 or are we sending things to superior that may or may not have actually received the documentation? We follow
1:13:52 standard procedure on our notification cards and we grab all the information from the property appraiser. So, whatever they're listed as in the property appraiser. I don't have the the
1:14:00 Excel sheet on me, but I can grab that Excel sheet and provide it. Uh but we follow that standard procedure to make sure that all those neighboring
1:14:08 properties have get a notification card and that notification card or I'm sorry that notification would go to the owner
1:14:17 of the parcel not necessarily who's operating and owning on a parcel. It goes to the owner mailing address.
1:14:24 So whoever owns the parcel, the land Yes. gets the notification.
1:14:28 Whoever's listed on the property appraiser may or may not be but true. Yeah, whoever's listed on the property appraiser gets that notification.
1:14:35 And then we also posted our our notifications or yellow signs on the property. Yeah. Um. Yep.
1:14:43 Okay.
1:14:44 Just quick update. John's over here pulling up who we sent the notifications to and the owner is listed in Alpharetta, Georgia. So that's who
1:14:52 that's where the that's where the notification was. Okay.
1:14:56 Is the is that owner that's listed in in in Georgia? I'm sorry, Mr. De. Is that owner still still the original owner or superior or the new owner?
1:15:07 I I can't answer that right there. Oh, you don't know? I don't know.
1:15:10 I I would add the property appraiser is
1:15:17 months behind on updating the property record cards and the GIS maps. So, it
1:15:24 would not surprise me if it went to the old owner. I don't know when all this happened. and um we've talked to them about it and they do the best they can.
1:15:33 Yeah.
1:15:34 Well, that would be s I unless commercial is very different than residential. The the Lake County Property Appraisers Office um gets those
1:15:43 done pretty quickly for residential transfers of of deeds within usually 30 to 45 days. So, um All right. Um,
1:15:54 with may I ask a question of the of the superior uh I'm sorry, Hunt Trace uh staff if we would you mind?
1:16:14 And thank you. Thank you.
1:16:16 I'm sorry I I didn't catch your name again. Lindsay Collins.
1:16:19 Collins. Okay. Miss Collins. You're the executive director, right? Yes, sir.
1:16:22 Okay. Um, is the do you know the the address of the property owner or who would be
1:16:30 listed on the on the on the deed as the owner of the land, our current owner?
1:16:35 Yeah, I am not. Um, I recently came back to the community in March um of this year.
1:16:41 So, I worked for them for 10 years when it was Superior Residences. At that point in time, it was owned by Don Bishop. um he's the one that sold the
1:16:48 property. Um it went through an ownership change and then it since went through another ownership change and now there's a new owners and I'm not
1:16:55 familiar. We're we're managed by SRRI management so I don't have direct um communication with the owners. I did
1:17:02 reach out to SRRI management um to see if they had any knowledge of this. They did not um they did reach out to the
1:17:10 owners. Again, I don't have that direct contact so I apologize. Um but um they were not aware that this was going on and I think they just want the ample
1:17:19 opportunity to like look at everything um to make any decisions. Um I personally like that I'm I'm now hearing I I haven't heard that before. Today's
1:17:27 the first day that I heard that it would be only used as emergency access. Um it obviously brings um I'm very concerned about the noise level um the lighting.
1:17:37 Um it butts up against our memory care.
1:17:40 Um I'm not sure if you're familiar with Alzheimer's or dementia. It's probably not the best environment to for them to be around. Yeah. Um so we are very
1:17:48 concerned about those things, but um again we are in support of growth. We also want to be a good neighbor. Um
1:17:54 [laughter]
1:17:55 so um anything that we can do to support that and just work together is what we're willing to do.
1:17:59 Sure. Absolutely. Um uh unfortunately I am familiar with uh working with patients with dementia as as um my
1:18:07 stepfather succumbed to a courageous battle of dementia two years ago. So um
1:18:13 do uh do you know when the the last transfer of ownership of the of the property occurred?
1:18:21 I believe that was in 2025.
1:18:23 And if that's true, council member, that is the most recent deed in the public records. It was 2025. Um, and it's in
1:18:30 the name of PCP Clermont Propco LLC, address in Alpharetta, Georgia. Okay. Okay.
1:18:41 Okay. Those are the only questions I have. Thank you. I appreciate that. And I I think I understand your your concerns that you've brought forward here. Thank you very much.
1:18:48 Um, Mr. Mr. Crawford as the applicant um
1:19:00 hearing the the information from the adjacent property. Um what are what are your thoughts if we uh delay this to the next meeting?
1:19:10 Uh I mean we would rather not postpone.
1:19:13 Um I've already given them my contact information. the issues that are remaining, lighting, noise, all those kind of
1:19:22 things are handled through the site plan process and I would commit to them to keep them personally notified of all of that so they can participate in that.
1:19:32 We're required to do the uh dark sky type lighting. I know there's not an
1:19:39 official ordinance and of course Clermont has a very strict noise ordinance for off-site noise. M U. So I
1:19:47 I believe we're going to be very good neighbors. If if council has questions that we can't answer or the neighbors
1:19:57 have issues that we can resolve the next two weeks, obviously I'm not going to storm out of here and say, "Oh, we're
1:20:04 withdrawing." But we think we provided the notices that were done. I'm sorry if they had an
1:20:12 internal miscommunication or discommunication.
1:20:15 Uh but now that I know who they are, we're going to work hand inand with them and we would asked to move forward, but of course um we will uh cooperate with
1:20:24 the council's discretion whichever way you go.
1:20:27 One final question. Would you be able to put back up on the map the the new proposed uh gate picture?
1:20:35 Yes, sir.
1:20:39 Thank you. Um, between the easement and the parking that's labeled 10 and four there at the bottom. Yes, sir.
1:20:48 What's the feasibility of putting the canopy trees that would be placed normally uh on Oakley Sver there to
1:20:57 provide additional buffer and have that be a larger buffer and enhancing that uh space in that area?
1:21:07 It's we already are required for a landscape buffer there to some canopy trees, but I think that's a good idea because I know you have to do the one
1:21:15 for one replacement. So, if we have some direction that I I would welcome something that says to the extent aroreal feasible, we would do
1:21:24 that. I I do this one doesn't bother me, but I live in a community where they planted live oaks in the 4 foot grass
1:21:34 between the sidewalk and the curb and it's a disaster. It is.
1:21:37 This these are 20 ft. So that's 20 ft or 22. So that's plenty of room. Okay.
1:21:43 So uh we would be happy to consider putting all feasible canopy trees in that location. That's a great suggestion.
1:21:49 That's the only questions I have and I'll save comments. Thank you. Thank you, Miss Mars.
1:21:56 Um, Mr. Bane answered the questions. I was going to ask about all of the stuff he said with notification. I was really concerned with that and I like his idea of having um the more uh trees there.
1:22:08 So, I don't have anything else at this time to add.
1:22:12 Mr. Peterson, I mean, I think you they address any questions about what what protections do they have about evening noise, you know, outdoor speakers, lighting.
1:22:23 Yeah. Are these been being addressed?
1:22:25 You know, and also is there going to be a restaurant odor problems because of their proximity like barbecue? I
1:22:33 I don't know. Maybe somebody doesn't like, you know, it is you're dealing with an elderly population.
1:22:38 I I understand, you know, and uh their sensitivities might be different than other people's sensitivities.
1:22:44 That's certainly true. There are no outdoor speakers, no amplified sound outdoors, and if we want to add that to
1:22:51 the ordinance, I'm fine with that. Um the lighting is per code and that does have
1:22:59 to come back for site plan approval which comes through you guys as well. Um so I'm
1:23:08 you know the hours are in there and there there will be some sound but it'll be inside almost exclusively.
1:23:15 Is there going to be a barbecue? Is that what you're saying? There's going to be a smokehouse in there or something.
1:23:19 Actually, it's a pizza place, a cafe, and a sitown restaurant. Those are the two that the three that are in there.
1:23:26 Almost like the top of the hill, the view. It's one building, but it'll have multiple vendor restaurants in inside.
1:23:33 Um there is some outdoor seating, but no outside amplified noise. Okay, thank you.
1:23:43 You're strange. I think my favorite comment on social media about this was I actually like this one. Um because
1:23:50 usually development doesn't get that response. So I think that that's really I think it's good. I I want to um
1:23:58 encourage the property owner. I think this is a great use for me. I cannot move forward if I don't know that the
1:24:06 neighbors are in support of a change of use. Um, the right on this property is for retail office and and that's what
1:24:16 the property owners expected when they bought the property. And we may have checked the boxes, but I don't think
1:24:24 that's the spirit of the the purpose of public notice. And I would like to see
1:24:30 us as a council be giving great weight to participation in
1:24:38 resoning and comprehensive plan changes that in where people are working together because I think that this is a
1:24:46 really great project that could be a benefit to both surrounding property owners, the medical offices to the north
1:24:54 and then we've got the, you know, the elderly in the south. But if it's not done in partnership with them, then I just think that we're we're missing out
1:25:02 as a community on providing the best service to the community. So, I'm in favor of this project, but I can't vote for it tonight when I have the neighbors
1:25:10 coming up and saying they nobody went next door and shook their hands and said, "Hey, we're we're changing this." And and we might have checked the boxes.
1:25:18 And I'm not saying we didn't, but I am saying I don't think I can't consider that good faith myself. So, I would
1:25:25 appreciate it if we could postpone it two weeks and give you at least two weeks and give you a chance to talk and and at this point, I'm curious what
1:25:34 communications went to the property owners to the north and if they're even aware of this happening because I think that's important. So, that's where I'm
1:25:42 at on this. And so, well, Council Member Strange and Mr.
1:25:46 Mayor, I don't want a divided council. I don't I think this is a project that ought to we ought to get United behind
1:25:54 and that includes the neighbors. So I would request Chris two weeks um a twoe postponement and we will get
1:26:02 with the neighbors right away and then be back for you. Sounds good. November 10th I'm sorry.
1:26:08 November 10th will be our next agenda meeting.
1:26:11 I mean council meeting Mr. Crawford. Miss Strange, you done?
1:26:14 Yes. I that's what I needed to say. I I think that's mighty nice of you, Mr.
1:26:18 Croy because I did have some concerns as well.
1:26:22 Um when this first came to me and the first thing I asked staff was um what superior
1:26:29 think about it and of course they told me it was okay. I concerned about the noise because the the memory care is right there on the back side. And so
1:26:37 that was um knowing the facility with memory care right there next to it. That was a real concern of mine. Um,
1:26:45 after last council when we brought this up, I didn't even get home before I had phone calls on it. Okay. Concerned because they knew nothing about it. So,
1:26:52 I think it's very nice of you to go would be willing to take uh two weeks postponing so you can get with them uh and and go over some of the details and
1:27:01 everything so we can be neighborly. Um, and I know I talked with uh I think I called Kirk the next day and told him my concerns and that uh didn't know why.
1:27:10 Didn't understand. Didn't know they had sold it myself. Okay. It was under new management. So, we appreciate that. And um November 10th is good with me. That's enough time.
1:27:21 Excuse me, mayor. Before a motion's made, I I did just want to put on record that uh we did verify that all adjoining property owners did receive a
1:27:29 notification card to that was sent out to the mailing address that was on property appraisers. Just want to put on record.
1:27:34 Yeah. Well, I guess that's one of I guess one of our problem trying to figure out who it goes to, did the facility get or where it need to go in. So, um yes,
1:27:44 and we used to be able to do that when we had the business tax receipts. we could know who was working actually in those buildings and we eliminated that.
1:27:52 So the city doesn't have a a check and balance system. We have to go off of what's in the property record. Correct.
1:27:58 We we c we can't expect our staff to uh walk doortodoor in every residential community and every commercial community
1:28:06 and say are you the property owner or are you a lease um and and figure out you know how to do that notification.
1:28:14 That's not feasible. And so, uh, I'm I'm empathetic to where we stand with the with Hunt Trace. Um, and I do think, um,
1:28:23 we I'm I'm happy the applicant's willing to to postpone until the November meeting. Um, but I also think we have to
1:28:31 be realistic with what we can expect our staff to do. We expanded the radius by which we do those notifications. Uh,
1:28:39 I I have a note for myself to actually uh a draft email to uh, Mr. Mr. Henchel and Mr. uh Wah to start working on the
1:28:47 sign because that was the next step of that um to to draft because I just saw a great example. I think it was in Eustace that they had a sign and it just yeah it
1:28:56 just said Eustace hearing so it could just be Clermont hearing uh and that would grab the attention and then so I think um we have to be cognizant of that
1:29:05 and I'm glad that we're willing to to do that to the next meeting.
1:29:08 Thank you sir. Uh before I ask for the motion or whatever u Mr. cross. One of the things I want you to give consideration to you talk we talked
1:29:16 about the trees back there along the easement. Yes.
1:29:20 With the uh closeness and you're talking about canopy trees. So the root structure let's let's be cognitive of that because don't want the roots to
1:29:28 start tearing up their driveway down through there because uh let's look at look at that as well.
1:29:33 100%. And we'll work with staff with utilities and everything to make sure that we're clear with that. And to Councilman's Bane's
1:29:41 uh idea on the signs, the latest greatest, and I don't know of any in Central Florida, but are QR codes on the
1:29:48 signs that that people can just click on and it goes straight to the backup. And well, that that'd be a great idea.
1:29:55 With that being said, I entertain a motion.
1:29:58 I'll move to table item number 12, ordinance number 2026-006 to November 10th.
1:30:04 I second. Have a motion and a second to table item number 12 ordinance number 2026-00006
1:30:11 until uh 10 November. Any further discussion?
1:30:16 Hear none. All in favor let it be known by saying I. I. All oppose and chair vote I as well.
1:30:21 Motion carries 50 and I think we can just go straight to move to table item number 13 ordinance
1:30:28 number 2026-07 to November 10th. Second. Second.
1:30:32 Okay. We have a motion and second to table item number 13, ordinance number 2026- 007 until November 10.
1:30:43 Any further discussion?
1:30:45 None. All in favor? Let it be known by saying I. I. All oppose.
1:30:49 Chair vote. I as well. So hopefully we can get it all done in November 10th.
1:30:56 Item number 14 is for final consideration of ordinance number 2026-029.
1:31:03 An ordinance of the city council of the city of Clermont, Lake County, Florida, amending chapter 101, article 2,
1:31:10 division 3, section 101104, granting of variances to establish procedures for the review and approval
1:31:18 of administrative adjustments to allow minor adjustments or modifications from certain dimensional dimensional or
1:31:25 development standards of the land development code. providing for conflict, severability, codification, administrative correction of scrivener's error, publication and effective date.
1:31:36 Yes, sir.
1:31:38 Good afternoon, mayor, city council members and guests. John Cruz, Development Services. Uh this item was uh brought before you for introduction
1:31:46 on August 25th. Um there was some changes that were uh directed to staff to make changes in the ordinance in the
1:31:53 chart and it was tabled from the October 13th meeting to today.
1:32:00 At the direction of the city manager's office, staff is proposing an amendment to the land development code in order to establish procedures for administrative
1:32:07 adjustments within the city limits. By establishing administrative adjustments, citizens will have a more efficient path
1:32:14 for resolving small sightsp specific issues without requiring a full public hearing before the city council. In
1:32:22 addition, this improves customer service through a time and money savings while ensuring all modifications remain consistent with the intent of the land
1:32:29 development code. This type of procedure is used in other municipalities such as Semino County, city of Maitland, Miami
1:32:36 Day County, and occurring in many more jurisdictions.
1:32:40 [clears throat]
1:32:41 The ordinance establishes criteria, submittal requirements, and parameters for allowable administrative adjustments, ensuring that the
1:32:49 flexibility provided remains predictable, fair, and consistent.
1:32:53 Adjustments would be limited in scale and may only be approved where they do not create adverse impacts. do not substantially alter the character of the
1:33:01 development and are in harmony with the intent of s regulations. Six review standards are incorporated into the
1:33:09 process in which all six must be satisfied with the substantial evidence.
1:33:13 Failure to meet any of one of these standards will result in a decision of denial. The applicant could then proceed
1:33:21 with the standard variance process before city council.
1:33:26 Um these are some examples to illustrate how the proposed administrative adjustment framework would operate. The
1:33:33 table shows examples of t uh typical dimensional standards and how a 25% administrative modification could be
1:33:40 applied. For example, the rear yard setback is 25 ft with a 25% administrative adjustment. That setback would be reduced to 18.75.
1:33:51 Another one that was uh for example is the height uh for commercial properties let's say it's 55 feet the maximum
1:33:59 adjustment would be um 25% which would increase the height to 68.75 ft.
1:34:08 These are uh the changes since the introduction uh and the draft and put in the ordinance includes the removal of the retaining wall height. I know that
1:34:16 that was uh in there originally and we were asked to remove that removal of the side yard uh footage adjustment and we
1:34:24 replaced it with the ability to install pavers on one side of the house only with written approval adjoining property owner. Also along with this adjustment a
1:34:33 hold harmless identification agreement would be required and then there will also be uh approval from the HOA if they were in a subdivision that had an HOA.
1:34:43 In addition, language was added to allow canopy trees replaced with accent trees supported by an arborist report or certified landscape professionals report
1:34:52 and would allow single variety to be planted similar to what was done in Kings Ridge parking lot. Also other
1:34:59 changes were quarter reports to council would be presented showing the number of applications and types received and approved by the development services
1:35:06 director and the administrative adjustment program would would have a one-year trial period unless extended by council.
1:35:14 Also, uh again, if they're in a a area that has an HOA, they would need a letter of approval from the HOA in order
1:35:22 to be considered meeting the administrative adjustment.
1:35:26 The planning and zoning commission recommended approval 50 as presented to them. Staff recommends approval of ordinance 2026
1:35:35 29 with the changes identified. That concludes staff's presentation. Thank you.
1:35:46 This is a public hearing. Anyone in the public wish to address this item may come to the microphone and state your name and address and have three minutes.
1:35:56 This is a public proceeding. Anyone in the chamber wish to address this item may come to the microphone and state your name and address and have three minutes.
1:36:04 Seeing no one in chamber, I'll close the public comment in the chamber. We have anyone online, ma'am.
1:36:13 I don't think so.
1:36:14 Okay. No one online. We'll close public comment and bring it back to uh council. We'll say you, Mr. Bank.
1:36:22 No questions, Miss Myers. No question, Mr. Peterson.
1:36:28 No questions at this time, Miss Strange. I'm ready to move forward.
1:36:33 I just have one question. U I see you you move. Of course, it's always going to decide setback. You removed the
1:36:40 percentage and everything. Can we I'm not sure and I went through it and I was trying to find and you saying we can put pavers on one side. Can we put in there
1:36:49 that that has to be approved with be engineered first if they do the pavers for drainage?
1:36:58 I'm just sitting here thinking that's for drainage purposes.
1:37:01 I I mean you have the legal ability to require that if that's your choice.
1:37:05 That that is something that the ones that were done down in Hardwood Landing that they did provide us documentation that they installed uh French drains to
1:37:13 deal with some of the runoff. Um that could be considered. Again, that's not my expertise, so I I don't rather not to answer that.
1:37:21 No, I I would just like to see it in our policy to make sure they they do the engineering and everything to make sure they don't just go out and put pavers in
1:37:28 and then we have a flooding issue. Uh which I think we have a couple of we dealing with right now. If you were inclined to consider that as a council,
1:37:35 I would suggest that that go into the red um underline under the table where it says pavers may go up to the property
1:37:43 line on one side of the house only for access purposes with both the written approval of the adjoining property owner
1:37:49 and uh satisfactory engineering or engineering plan satisfactory to the city's review for drainage purposes.
1:37:56 Yes, for drainage. I would like to see that in there, please. That's all I have.
1:38:02 Well, well, I have a comment during the second rebuttal period, Mr. B.
1:38:09 Um, I can support that uh addition, whether it's the language or just adding the second asterisk to that column as
1:38:18 well. That would also then meet it under I think the the second asterric piece. But I can support that for the one year. Miss Myers.
1:38:25 So, can I Mr. Peterson?
1:38:28 I mean, I understand. So we can so basically they'll you'll approve anything up to 25% higher but anything over that then it would have to come to
1:38:37 council. Is that my understanding? So if that is correct.
1:38:41 So are we making it into new rules at 25% higher then or is there have to be justification for that additional 25%.
1:38:49 Are we changing now if we have 55 ft is it really not 55 anymore? It's it's 68.5 now is that's the new maximum height.
1:38:58 they they would have to apply and it would be reviewed by the development services director and staff and they would have to meet the the criteria in
1:39:07 order to get that and again they would we would part of the process we would act actually reach out to adjoining uh
1:39:14 property owners especially when it's height related right and I know in the document we do talk about getting HOA approval um that is
1:39:23 something that we would also look at doing is getting the adjacent property approval as Well, but no, it's not a blanket statement that you can go to
1:39:30 68.75 ft. No, that that would not be correct.
1:39:35 And nothing in here is addressing sign size like over the 200 square feet that it is right now. It's not going to be
1:39:42 contingent upon the frontage of percentage of the frontage of that. Uh like you know, we think of Dick Sporting Good when they asked for that variance
1:39:50 to increase their size. that would still have to come before council or can you is that going to be something that you guys can approve?
1:39:57 That is something we did not put in here was signage. We felt that it was important for council to look at the signage because it's it's not one of our
1:40:05 most common variance requests. Usually it's rear yard setback, sideyard setback. Um, in terms of the variance
1:40:12 requests coming through, uh, in term again, the signage would be more on a case by case and they would give us, you
1:40:19 know, evidence to show why it's needed, right?
1:40:22 And we just felt it would be better conveyed to council to make that decision instead of staff. Okay. Thank you.
1:40:30 Thank you.
1:40:31 So, I just have one question, John, related to the side pavers. If somebody took a 2 by two pavers and spaced them
1:40:38 out with like grass in between, is that something that would trigger an engineering or is that something that's allowed?
1:40:45 That's allowed. That's permitted. The 2 by two stepping stones space sporadically to get around the house. We don't consider that.
1:40:53 Uh the the pavers is more when they put the subbase down, they're interlocking, you know, it's it's pretty solid from
1:41:00 the the house to the property line. So to answer that question, yes, that that's where the the the difference would be then I'm I'm fine with the addition of the engineering.
1:41:10 Okay.
1:41:12 I'm just I'm sorry. I just I've seen too many pavers be put on the side of the house and then we have flooding issues with with the neighbors
1:41:21 and everything. So we need to try to make sure the neighbors are protected on that. Okay. Well, it does have it does have to that point the the neighbors
1:41:28 supporting it and also the indemnification agreement are also already in there for people have neighbor support and not understanding that they haven't been
1:41:36 engineered and we still end up with flood and I think we facing a couple of old issues right now. So, but I entertain a motion.
1:41:43 I'll move to approve ordinance number 2026-029 final with the addition of the
1:41:50 engineering for draining regarding the sideyard. I'm sorry. This Yes, the side setback pavers. Second.
1:41:57 We have a motion in a second for approval of item ordinance number where we have 14. Order number is 2026-029
1:42:06 with the addition of the u um engineering for the side setback.
1:42:13 This is a roll call. Council member Strange I.
1:42:16 Council member Bane I.
1:42:18 Council member Myers I.
1:42:20 Council member Peterson I. and chair eyes as well. Motion carries 50. Thank you. Item number 15, ordinance.
1:42:30 Oh, I'm sorry. We We got rid of that one. Okay. Item number 16 is a various request Green Mountain.
1:42:40 Good afternoon again, John Cruz, Development Services. This is agenda item 16, Green Mountain subdivision variance. This item was uh presented
1:42:48 before you at the September 8th city council meeting. was tabled to today.
1:42:54 The applicant has revised the application as presented.
1:42:59 The applicant, Robert Herrell, is requesting three variances to the land development code in order to develop a residential subdivision. The property is
1:43:07 bisected by Old Highway 50 located south of the Florida Turnpike and north of the South Lake Trail.
1:43:14 Please note that the applicant has revised their original application and no longer requesting any waiverss regarding retaining wall heights,
1:43:23 elimination of secondary access to the subdivision for emergency uh access and the tree replacement mitigation request.
1:43:32 Upon reviewing the conceptual plans, it was noted that the property has some environmental concerns such as significant changes in topography and
1:43:40 wetlands. to address the existing site constraints and develop the property.
1:43:44 The applicant is requesting the following three variances.
1:43:49 The first one is to allow for up to 16 ft of cut and fill over more than 10% of the site. Majority of the the regrading
1:43:58 would occur in the northwest area of the property to work with the existing topography rather than flattening the hillside. To maintain the landscape
1:44:06 buffer along the turnpike and ensure safe transitions between lot elevations and street grades, the applicant is proposing to regrade the areas depicted in green on display.
1:44:19 The second waiver is to uh request is to wave the side and walk requirement on
1:44:26 areas designated as open space. There are only two areas that this would affect which are shown in blue on the display.
1:44:36 These areas are along portions of the subdivision that will not serve residential lots and are adjacent to wetlands and landscape buffers. safe
1:44:44 alternative pedestrian routes are still being provided for access between the north and south side of the projects as
1:44:50 well as to a close to home park. Lastly, the applicant is requesting to provide private uh I don't they're just going to
1:44:59 end up being private streets for the residential subdivision. Um the applicant states that this would increase safety in the community and
1:45:07 eliminate the city's expense for street m maintenance under section uh land development code
1:45:15 10124. Land uh variance may only be granted with a positive finding on all review criteria.
1:45:22 Staff recommends approval of all three variance requests.
1:45:27 Thank you Mr. Crawford and the applicant again.
1:45:31 [laughter]
1:45:33 Good afternoon, mayor. Uh, council members. Yeah, busy afternoon. Jimmy Crawford, 702 West Monstro Montro Street, Clermont, Florida. I represent
1:45:41 Pine Castle Investment. There's already been a full presentation on these. Um, we pulled the tree variants and we are
1:45:50 working with the city attorney and the city staff to come up with an alternative for that. That is not before you today. It'll have to come back in a
1:45:58 different day in a different matter. But we are requesting approval of the three variances. And I would just say it's a
1:46:04 happy day for me because I get staff recommendation positives on about one out of 10 of my variances. And to get
1:46:12 three I'm just I'm tickled and we and I do have Rick McCoy and uh Bob Harrell here to answer any questions from the engineer the owner side.
1:46:24 Thank you sir. If we have any question we will call you back at a later time but right now this is a public forum.
1:46:29 Anyone in the chamber wish to address this item may come to the microphone and state your name and address and have three minutes.
1:46:41 Valerie Shu at 931 West Montro Street.
1:46:43 Um I know I spoke on this last time and I'm genuinely not trying to pick on this developer. Um, but I do feel like this
1:46:51 is an example where we can possibly provoke better development or at least um ask some good questions of the development style. And these are sincere
1:47:00 questions. I don't understand everything that I'm looking at perfectly to be fair. Um, but this looks like a pattern of development that has is sprawl that
1:47:09 makes traffic worse. Um, that is has flattened our hills and that is unsustainable in more than one sense of
1:47:16 the word. And so I am wondering at what point we kind of turn the page and we stop accepting this kind of development in Clermont. There's a lot of
1:47:24 conversation around that, but at what point in the staff rule book does that change? Like when when do we start to see the shift, I guess, is what I'm
1:47:32 asking because this just feels like business as usual and a little contrary to where it seems like we're going with the kind of development that we want.
1:47:39 Um, so I I think I still am curious. Um, what access is provided to the neighboring commercial plaza? Uh, can
1:47:48 the applicant show the shortest walking route from the neighborhood to the Plaza Kina businesses that are there so they don't have to become traffic, the residents that live there if they want
1:47:56 to go there? Do they is it easy, safe, comfortable for them to get there? That would be important. um were alternative
1:48:03 site plans um explored before concluding that this degree of earth work was the minimum necessary to be done? I think
1:48:10 that's the saddest thing to me is um just to see us cutting into our hills even more. Um I mean do I think
1:48:19 development approaches ex exist that don't require so much um cut and fill but it's a different pattern. It's a different approach, but that would be a
1:48:27 question I would have. Um, is council being asked to relieve a hardship created by the land itself or
1:48:34 that one created by that design? Um, and I know that, you know, this is this can be tough. I know we have the development
1:48:43 design center. So maybe if this is something that we wouldn't accept or we want to see something better, we could resource this developer or we could if
1:48:51 it's going to require new variances or different kind of permitting, maybe we could wave some of those fees to incentivize something better. That would be my question. I think that would be
1:48:59 something um you all could do and I would love I would love to see um because it's not it's not them. I'm not trying to pick on them, but I think these are important questions and conversations. Thanks.
1:49:10 Thank you. Anyone else?
1:49:15 This is a public form. Anyone in chamber wish to address this item may come to the microphone and state your name and address and have three minutes.
1:49:22 Anyone else? Seeing no one in chamber, close the public comment for chamber. Anyone in online, Mr. Wayne? Yes, sir. Not at this time.
1:49:30 Well, we'll close public comment and bring it back to council. What say you, Mr. Yes, sir.
1:49:35 Thank you. I would like to address Miss Shuitt's comments. Okay. She is my neighbor and my compatriate on CRA boards and other things and I respect her opinion always.
1:49:48 Timing wise this is kind of a transition development. Uh it was started the
1:49:54 design of this was started 18 months ago and um that said the development design
1:50:01 center we are going to work with the economic development director and that process through the site plan and the architectural processes.
1:50:10 This is an infill site that's already has developments on both sides of it.
1:50:16 Some of her questions are site plan and design questions not variance questions.
1:50:22 The one variance question that is a very valid one is the grading uh variances
1:50:29 and I have Rick McCoy this the engineer here who can try to answer but he's worked with staff and staff is convinced that that's the minimum that we need.
1:50:40 You know, usually when we get the same variance requests over and over, I like to go to staff and say, gosh, can we
1:50:47 change that rule because you shouldn't be given 10 variances a year over the same code. The grading variance is one
1:50:55 that I don't feel that way. We are unique to [clears throat] topographical situation. Uh not just Clermont, but
1:51:03 South Lake. I had the opportunity not long ago to drive over the new Hancock Hill that goes over Sugarloaf Mountain and my goodness, those views. Now,
1:51:12 they'll all be blocked with rooftops soon enough, but for right now, it's incredible and we do need to preserve
1:51:18 that. And so, while I believe we do have to change the grading or we're going to have to hire a whole
1:51:25 bunch of North Carolina builders to come down here and figure out how to do it, Florida builders do not know how to do it. So we do the minimum that we can,
1:51:34 but each one should come before you and you should be able to ask staff and the engineers, are you sure this is the best
1:51:41 you can do? Why does that have to be there? Why why can you do that? And and we're happy to try to answer those
1:51:48 questions because I don't want to grade any more than than we need to. Uh but the engineers and the staff have
1:51:55 determined that that's the minimum that we need for this and therefore we would ask for your approval.
1:52:01 [clears throat]
1:52:01 Thank you. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Bane.
1:52:07 Thank you, Mayor. Um, Mr. Crawford, I do just out of curiosity, what uh I think we've talked about this
1:52:16 at least through one PNZ commission and maybe one or two council meetings. uh in I think like you said the last 18 months
1:52:23 we we talked uh at one point in time about connectivity to recreation nearby
1:52:31 and how residents in this area might be connected to that um to that recreation.
1:52:37 How in this plan are they are they connected to that or where in the process will that happen and what what is that going to look like?
1:52:45 Yeah. Uh well, Council Member Baines, I think I'd like to get Rick up to do it because I am a late comer to this particular project. Sure.
1:52:53 And I would also say, uh that we're not asking for a variance for any of those.
1:52:58 So, it's not the So, it's really a site plan issue, but we let's talk about it because I've already learned today when you don't talk about things enough, you uh wind up with a problem later.
1:53:09 Sure.
1:53:10 Sure. Thank you. [laughter] Rick McCoy, McCoy Associates, uh 106 South Palm Avenue in Howen Hills.
1:53:22 The three variances we're asking for, well, number one, the private streets, that's in your ordinance. We have to ask for that. The sidewalks is, you know, if you say no, we can put sidewalks in.
1:53:33 We're coming here because it doesn't make sense to put it next to the wetlands and, you know, nobody walks on it. the cut and fill.
1:53:42 I can if you deny it, I can meet your code. I cut the turnpike cut down and flatten it and we'll be within 10 ft.
1:53:52 We're trying to do something nice to maintain the elevations, but the builders, they still have to have a flat pad to build on. So we're
1:54:00 terracing and doing two terraces up there to do and and if you look on that northern side and we're keeping the park which is the high elevation and then it
1:54:09 drops 20 25 foot down to the turnpike because if you know that section of the turnpike that's where the the big slope
1:54:15 is and the and we'll keep the trees on top. It'll make a better project. I I'm sorry that you know that not everybody
1:54:23 understands that. I've been very intimate with it. Um, this is a beautiful piece of property that I've driven by for 40 years and said, "Boy, I
1:54:32 hope I get to do work on that one." And I think we're going to have a gorgeous project when we're done.
1:54:37 Yeah. And I appreciate connectivity. Connectivity to the to the recreation connectivity. We're tying to the to the um bike trail. So, we're we're actually
1:54:46 what I worked out with the county in lie of doing five foot sidewalks and taking all the trees out on Highway 50, we're
1:54:53 going to go back on the old railroad trail and do an 8-oot paved pedestrian walkway that'll tie into the rail trail. So, it will tie into the trail.
1:55:01 Oh, yes. Oh, yes.
1:55:03 Okay. Thank you. Um, and I'll mention too, yeah, our original plan started in the county with, I don't know, 500 units or
1:55:11 something with with condos and town homes and and Clermont said, "No, we want 75 foot lots.
1:55:19 No, no 75 foot lot. If you don't get 75 foot lot, I get no water and sewer." So, yeah, we're we're trying to to do what you want.
1:55:28 Yeah, I'm familiar. I I think I was on P the P&Z commission when it first came through and and that was discussed. The other question I had was just
1:55:34 connectivity to uh commercial and retail and I is there access on the um on the
1:55:41 south end there to connectivity to the retail and commercial. The retail Costco is right behind us. We're right against the property line.
1:55:50 Yeah, Costco built a 25 foot retaining wall. I don't know if it's really that high or not.
1:55:56 You'd have to scale it, but you can go back around the trail and go back Lake Avenue. I mean to to get to that and all right that's that's the best we can do.
1:56:04 Thank you. I appreciate it. Those are an elevator. Yep.
1:56:07 No, I appreciate it. Thank you. Those are my only questions I'll I'll save for comments.
1:56:10 I actually have ridden my bicycle to Costco down the trail and there is a way to go on the neighboring property up a grass hill and I wish to goodness they
1:56:19 would make an actual connection there but it's not our property.
1:56:23 We'll have to talk to the owner of that property.
1:56:26 Yeah, I've bought enough of their states. [laughter] Thank you.
1:56:30 Miss Mars, I just want to say thank you, Jimmy, and is it Mr. McCoy?
1:56:35 Um, for working with the city and trying to make things more to our liking. Um, I appreciate that and I recognize the hard work. And Mr. Jimmy, I appreciate you.
1:56:45 When you come in, you're always a delight and um, thank you.
1:56:49 Well, thank you very much, Mr. Peterson. At this time, I don't have any questions. And I want to also
1:56:56 reiterate what you said. I mean, you're you're working with the city as opposed to pushing things down or through. Thank you, Miss Strange.
1:57:06 Mr. Crawford, I think my questions are going to be for you. On the map, I just want to make sure I'm reading it correctly. The two lines that look like
1:57:14 they say second access entrance. Are those access points for bike access for the residents to the trail? Is that what I'm looking at?
1:57:22 I'm going to ask Mr. McCoy to come help me with that. I there's a couple places that it shows up. The the red lines that connect they
1:57:31 appear to connect to the trail on your map. Well, it's gray. Those are bike access to the trail. Is that correct?
1:57:37 That's going to be the bike trail. Yeah, the 8 foot um pedestrian trail in lie of sidewalks.
1:57:42 Okay. And then would your client be open to creation?
1:57:48 I don't know if you've been following our comprehensive plan and kind of the vision for the future. Would would your client be open to allowing some of these existing lots?
1:57:59 I'm looking at 48 to 51 and 3 to 7 existing to to potentially be used as something
1:58:06 that might be described as a trailfacing charming village center to create some sort of commercial
1:58:14 opportunity on the trail as like a welcome to Clermont.
1:58:17 I I Yeah. Um, and and we do have an owners rep here. That probably is a better
1:58:24 question. I think consider is always on the table. They haven't sold those lots yet.
1:58:31 Although I think or that space. I mean, there's something on the trail. I I understand.
1:58:36 I have to jump in. I have to jump in on this one. Um, when we consider variances, we're really limited to the
1:58:43 five elements that are in the code. And so to the extent that this question, you know, if it's relevant to your
1:58:51 consideration of the variance, it's granting the variance will not cause or allow interference with the reasonable enjoyment of adjacent owners.
1:58:59 Variance will allow reasonable use of the property which use is not out of character with the other properties. In the context presented, strict compliance
1:59:06 with the LDRs will not further any legitimate city objective.
1:59:11 Granting of the variance is consistent with the comp plan. And lastly, the variance request is the minimum variance. This is more getting into the
1:59:19 entitle other type of entitlement discussion. So I just want to make sure that when and if you do take a
1:59:27 motion up that that wouldn't be the bas the answer to this question is not the basis for your Okay.
1:59:32 Thank you. And I will never disagree with your city attorney. Almost almost never almost never. I don't today.
1:59:40 All right. [laughter] But I welcome the open discussion back and forth because this isn't the last time this project will be in front of you. And so I I
1:59:48 appreciate the input even though you know the the five criteria are are what they are. Thank you for the the input and we will cooperate every way we can.
2:00:03 That's all I have.
2:00:05 Okay. Thank you. Um, I would just like to say, uh, Mr.
2:00:13 Crawford and M Rick, I thank you all for for going back and listening to us and like you say, you've come before several times with this project and we required
2:00:21 the 75 ft lots and you're doing a fantastic job. Um, I still had some concern about the 16 ft uh, cut and
2:00:29 field, but um, I work with you enough, Mr. direct know the fact that you you know what you've done and other projects you've
2:00:38 worked on and everything you you did what was best and and come out to be some beautiful things. So I I can support this. Okay.
2:00:45 Yeah. So and Mr. Mayor going from the old comp plan toward the new one. The 75 foot lot
2:00:54 they certainly are going to continue to have a place but my uh lawn service guy said please keep the 75 foot lots in.
2:01:03 Yes, because [laughter] they keep the mowers and edggers in business all day long.
2:01:08 Well, well, that one of the things I know I know we kind of started insisting upon here at one point and everything, but Mr. W, uh, going back to what Miss
2:01:17 Strange was asking, even though we we looking at the variance and we can go ahead and approve this variance and they can still come back and uh, maybe renegotiate some of those things, right?
2:01:26 Uh, which things are you talking about? With M uh, Mr. Strange? Oh, absolutely. I mean, we are Mr.
2:01:31 Crawford already alluded to it, but we are uh in discussions and in fact I've been doing a little more research here on finding a way to do some other things with the property.
2:01:40 Okay. So let's maybe include uh include those items that M. Strange was just referring to. Okay. Yeah.
2:01:47 Cuz I was also concerned with and I think it was answered. I was also concerned with is there a way to connect have a connectivity to Costco and uh all
2:01:56 I know you said you had the grassy area uh that you go up. Is that over there where they building the new apartments behind uh Yes.
2:02:04 between the apartments and the commercial development that is the Costco and the big the dicks. I'm sorry.
2:02:11 Yeah. Okay. Between Costco and and the flooring decor.
2:02:15 Yes. You you can I have an electric bike so I cheat but you can ride up it.
2:02:19 [laughter]
2:02:20 So So we may we need to talk to owner about the owner of that, right? Trying to get that done for us over there because that would be great to have that
2:02:27 connectivity. Okay. But that's all I have entertained. Well, back around.
2:02:33 Thank you, mayor. Um, just the I I did forget to ask earlier with regard to the granting of the variance will not
2:02:41 interfere with the reasonable enjoyment um with the sidewalks. I think we talked about at one point if we grant the
2:02:49 variance for the sidewalks, but yet there would still be some sort of u trail or or uh I don't know if it's
2:02:56 going to be mulch or something like that, but we're not we're not just stopping and doing nothing. It's just not going to be paved sidewalk.
2:03:03 It will be walkable uh along there and not landscaped with hedges and things that that will give it.
2:03:09 I appreciate the flexibility and the cooperation with the city on on these changes. Thank you.
2:03:15 Miss Myers, I'm ready to move it. I have nothing else to say.
2:03:19 Mr. Peterson, I have nothing more to add. Miss Strange, I just want to make sure in our packet it still refers to the tree removal and replacement standards, but that is not
2:03:27 something we're voting on tonight. It's just the three listed in the agenda summary by staff. That's correct. Okay.
2:03:33 The tree removal and that's what you all negotiate right now, right? That's one of the things. Yes, sir.
2:03:38 Yeah. Okay. Separate. It'll come back later. Okay. I entertain a motion.
2:03:46 motion. No, go ahead.
2:03:47 I'd like to make a motion for the variance request for Green Mountain Subdivision. Second.
2:03:54 Okay, I have a motion and a second for approval of item number 16, variance request for Green Green Mountain subdivision. Any further
2:04:03 discussion hearing? None. All in favor, let it be known by saying I. I. All oppose. Chair vote I as well. Good luck.
2:04:11 Thank you. Thank you.
2:04:14 Item number 17 is consideration of lean reduction request.
2:04:24 Good evening, mayor, city council members. Kurt Henchel, development services director. Uh this is a lean reduction at the at a single family
2:04:33 residence located at 3262 Hanging Tide Street in the Lake View Preserve neighborhood. It is owned by Uklites
2:04:41 Uklites Gutierrez and is zoned planned unit development.
2:04:47 The case started in October 15th of 2024 for a building permit required. This is for added pavers and a gaz gazebo built
2:04:56 on the property without first obtaining a building permit. The case went to a codeboard hearing on July 21st of 2025
2:05:05 and was found in violation with fines acrewing at $150 per day after September 20th of 2025.
2:05:13 On May 18th of 2026, a case was presented again before the code board before code enforcement board due to
2:05:22 non-compliance and a fine of $36,000 was imposed upon the property owner for fail failure to comply for 240 days.
2:05:32 On July 7th of 2026, the property came into compliance. In accordance with the board's order, a total of 288 days of
2:05:41 fines were acred with a grand total fine amount of $43,200.
2:05:48 As of today, the property is still in compliance and the applicant is requesting a full waiver of the amount owed.
2:05:57 To recover staff's time involved in the case, staff does recommend the homeowner pay a minimum of 10% of the total of that total 43,200,
2:06:06 which would be $4,320 in that staff report. Thank you. Is the applicant present?
2:06:15 Yes, there.
2:06:20 Hey, good afternoon. I'm here representing my father. I translate for him. He doesn't speak English very well. So, I just want to explain his case.
2:06:27 Can I get your name and address, please, sir? And speak into the mic. Sorry. Good evening. Um, yeah, I'm here.
2:06:33 Um, thank you for letting us speak today. I'm here translating for my father. He doesn't speak English very well, so I'm just um doing this for him. What's your name?
2:06:41 Again, we live in 3262 Hanging Tide Street. Thank you.
2:06:48 Um, yeah. Um, I'm basically to explain that he hired a builder. Um he paid about close to 10,000 to um build his
2:06:56 patio. Um the building ensured that everything was okay and he told us that everything was fine to get this project
2:07:02 done. Um after 3 months he called my father and let him know that after um all this and after the work had been
2:07:10 completed. Um we were not in complaints of the city code after 3 months he works in transportation so he's normally
2:07:17 always traveling. Um, after letting us know, he worked in getting a general contractor to work um and get everything
2:07:25 in compliance, we did um but it took some time to get this done. So, we just basically want to get this um to a lower
2:07:33 cost and more understandable amount so we can pay and basically get get done with this situation. We have we're already in compliance. So, yeah, we just
2:07:41 want to pay the fine and be done with this. Thank you.
2:07:46 Okay. Thank you, sir. This is if we have any other questions, we will call you back at a later time. But this is a public form. Anyone in the chamber wish
2:07:53 to address this item may come to the microphone and state your name and address and have three minutes. Thank you.
2:08:00 Let me ask you.
2:08:05 Hi, my name is Patrick Bianke 810 West Mantros. I always have a heart for this because this is my industry. Um, as you probably have seen on the West Coast,
2:08:13 there was plenty of people that got in trouble for unlicensed work. I know most times my philosophy is ignorance is not a defense. But in this particular case,
2:08:21 you see this time and time again when a professional that it be in real estate, that it be in construction, will tell the homeowners that everything is okay,
2:08:30 that everything is to code, that everything is hunky dory and it works and they got governmental permission and they didn't. This happens every day. So
2:08:38 I feel really bad for situations like this and you're seeing a lot of these governmental entities coming hard down on these contractors for doing
2:08:47 unlicensed, unpermitted, licensed, unpermitted and so on. Many different categories. So that's all I have to say. Thank you.
2:08:53 Thank you, sir. Anyone else?
2:08:58 This is a public forum. Anyone in the chamber with the address of the item may come to the microphone and state your name and address and have three minutes.
2:09:05 Anyone else?
2:09:07 Seeing no one else, I close down public forum in the chamber. Anyone online, sir? Not this time, Mr.
2:09:12 No one online. I bring it back to council. What say you, Mr. Bank?
2:09:16 Thank you. I guess my question for staff first would be um so this case started on October 15th, 2024, which which means
2:09:25 that was two years ago and a little over two years ago and that's when the first notification from city hall went to this individual, this property owner.
2:09:36 Well, the case started then, so it was likely a verbal discussion. It wasn't a written document. Sorry. But then
2:09:44 uh in July of 2025, so still uh what uh 15 months ago, it actually then went
2:09:53 to the code board and at that point there would have been written communication absolutely to the no to the uh to the homeowner
2:10:02 and the fines started in September. So there was a grace period of come in compliance or the fines start. Is that correct?
2:10:11 That's right.
2:10:12 And then in May of this year, so almost a year later, it still wasn't in compliance
2:10:20 and didn't come into compliance until June of this year or I'm sorry, July of this year, a year after the first code board uh uh uh code
2:10:29 board meeting. Is that correct? That's correct.
2:10:32 Thank you. Um I guess then my question for the uh I think you were the son, right? Is that right? Uh for your dad.
2:10:39 So, did you guys uh receive the notifications and did you attend the code enforcement board meetings?
2:10:44 Um, yes, we did. And actually, we even spoke with um staff from the county and they said that what we did was okay.
2:10:51 That's why even a year after it showed that we were not in compliance cuz they first they said it was okay, but after they said it was not and we had to keep
2:11:00 making repairs and then finally we were done with that. So, basically someone from the county said that it was okay but it was not. So, let me ask I hear
2:11:08 you say the county twice. Did you go to the county or the city? Because this would be a city matter. I'm sorry. I'm sorry.
2:11:14 So, who who did you talk to that said it was okay?
2:11:16 Um I it was not me, it was the general contractor and my father. Um my father, he's like 5 minutes away, but the general contractor was the one who was basically in communications.
2:11:26 And as soon as we um they told us that we were okay, then they said we weren't.
2:11:32 So, as soon as we found out, we went ahead and fixed that.
2:11:36 Okay. But it it has been a big headed for us really. I mean um it's been a long time.
2:11:42 Sure. Absolutely. Absolutely. And I I I understand um I assume you probably thought that that you were hiring
2:11:50 somebody who would steer you in the right way.
2:11:53 Yeah. And I mean then they told us that this um this part of the city is a bit more complicated but I mean we thought
2:12:01 whether we were doing it with a professional and I mean this has been a a whole ordeal. This has been over two years. Like it's crazy.
2:12:08 Okay, I don't have any other uh questions. I'll have some comments at the end. Thank you. Yeah, Miss Mars.
2:12:15 So, just to reiterate, so in July of July 21, 2025 is when your father got
2:12:24 the notice and he had a another person who was the contractor who he thought
2:12:30 was going in between. So he did not call anybody from the city. Um the letter that he received in July,
2:12:38 um apparently he got in touch with the city and he got all the plans, gave um our plans for what we built and got um
2:12:46 the dimensions out how everything should be and basically did operations to get everything accordingly. But apparently
2:12:53 they were not right. Um like I said, someone from the city first said that it was right, but then it wasn't. Um, I'm sorry. Do not have that name right now.
2:13:01 So, you don't have the name because that doesn't sound like somebody from the city would say that.
2:13:05 I mean, I I know I even saw the contractor, but I forgot the name and I mean, I was not dealing with this since I saw it was a general contractor and my father was on it. Um, he should be here pretty soon.
2:13:14 So, your dad is coming.
2:13:15 Yes. I'm sorry about that. He Okay, no worries. Um, because I have a question from July to September, nothing. and then 240 days nothing was
2:13:24 done to come into compliance because the issue is following what the city has said that you can and cannot do but you
2:13:31 need your father to speak on that cuz that's not your purview I imagine is this him your dad okay
2:13:38 could you ask him what happened between July 21 and September and his correspondence with the city on this matter
2:13:46 absolutely
2:14:08 Okay. Okay. So, he just told me that during those three months, the general contractor, he was actually just trying to get the approval to not change anything. So, just to have everything as is and that's why nothing was um fixed.
2:14:20 But we got the know. And when we got the know, that's when we went ahead and started fixing um everything on the property. And can you put your father's name on the record, please?
2:14:29 Yeah, absolutely. His name is Danielle Corona. Thank you.
2:14:33 Okay. So then my other question would be then it was brought back to code enforcement
2:14:40 on May 18th and that's when and um and it still was not in compliance then and then you had
2:14:48 a fine of $36,000 was imposed on the property owner for failure to comply for 240 days. Does your father understand that?
2:15:21 Okay. During those 200 um days, basically that was the time with the general contractor told them that everything was okay. Um but basically
2:15:29 that he then said that we needed to submit another form. then we didn't need to submit anything and then we needed to basically um knock everything down that wouldn't get the permit.
2:15:40 So your father didn't understand that this contractor was not doing right by him back in July between July and
2:15:47 September because this because it sounds like he was uh heavily relying on this contractor and this contractor was not
2:15:55 being um in good faith toward him. He didn't realize that then because it looks like you've spent another 240 days
2:16:03 and still not in compliance relying on this contractor.
2:16:26 Um yeah, he really thought everything was okay until at least four months ago cuz like we said we said first like he was trying to get us to not not knock
2:16:34 anything and just get us get what we had built already approved. Um, but until four months ago, my dad says that that's
2:16:41 when he really understood that it was not working out because he wasn't getting anything approved and it was just a lot of back and forth on his work.
2:16:48 Did he do the work himself or did he hire someone else to bring it into compliance? My father or the general contractor?
2:16:54 Yes. Who did you all use to bring it into compliance?
2:16:57 We contracted somebody. We didn't You got someone totally different than you worked with?
2:17:00 Yeah, we did not build that um ourselves.
2:17:03 Okay. Thank you, Mr. Peterson. Okay. So, my understanding is your original contractor did not
2:17:12 fulfill his obligations to get permits from the city for the gazebo and some and a pavers there. Is that my understanding? Yes. Yeah.
2:17:20 And then so you then you it took you almost a year 288 days to realize that you you didn't have it in place. How how
2:17:28 did you get notification? Weren't you getting notifications that you know fees were were were coming due and they were acrewing? I understand you're in a bad
2:17:37 position with that because I, you know, as a previous person just said, this is not the first time these type of things
2:17:45 happen where you're relying on the contractor to do do the permits. The only bad thing is that the homeowner is
2:17:52 ultimately responsible. You know, I mean, we we love to point fingers at other people, but eventually comes back to us. And I understand your position
2:18:00 and I understand that, you know, they they're doing only 10%. And I mean I would say almost can we go after the builders in this or
2:18:08 the contractors in this respect that would be like an ordinance thing or something for legal to come up with.
2:18:15 Uh you know it is possible for the city to go after the people who are responsible per se. But similarly um to
2:18:22 the extent that it wasn't the owner's fault and they relied on the contractor.
2:18:26 Let's say that you end up approving a 10% whatever you decide.
2:18:31 Um, you know, they would have the ability to sue the contractor for that as well. They have a remedy that way. Okay. They do. Okay.
2:18:38 Okay. I mean, yeah. Um, unfortunately, this is our first time dealing with a situation like this. I mean, we're we're migrants. Um, we have been here for
2:18:45 around 11 years. Um, thankfully, we we live here happily in Clermont. Uh but basically he told us that everything was
2:18:54 going to be okay and he paid and we had the good faith that um the premise was were going to go through cuz he told us, "Oh, let's file this so you guys don't
2:19:02 have to demolish anything cuz the he had my dad had already paid um close to $10,000." So, I mean, having everything destroyed, I mean, you know, it's it's
2:19:10 kind of a setback. That's why it took such a long time to get this also situated and get it um in accordance.
2:19:17 But yeah, like like he said around 4 months ago, he noticed that it wasn't going anywhere and that's when he started knocking everything down.
2:19:24 Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Miss Strange.
2:19:31 Did this property or does this property have a winter garden address?
2:19:35 Um, yeah. It's for mail delivery on 247 [clears throat] delivery.
2:19:42 I just want to make sure I'm looking at the right. The service is in Clermont.
2:19:45 Sure. So, what I apologize in my packet, it doesn't show me what was built and how you came into compliance.
2:19:53 I heard you say gazebo and patio. What was built and then what did you have to do to bring it into compliance?
2:20:01 Um, we basically built like um a floor um in the back of the house, a white floor. Um, we also built um some
2:20:08 concrete sidewalks to the side of the house which were too close to the other property. Um, we had to knock that down.
2:20:15 um the backs um the back of the patio that we built, we had to knock that down like three feet as well and the gazebo
2:20:23 got the permits at least and we didn't have to knock that down but basically everything was um had to be rearranged.
2:20:30 So was the issue impervious surface? Is that what the problem was? And setbacks. Yes.
2:20:36 Would this property meet the requirements of the new waiver that we just passed tonight? Well, there was Excuse me.
2:20:44 [clears throat] Sorry. Yeah. No worries.
2:20:45 There's We don't know for sure because it requires neighbor Yeah.
2:20:50 the neighbor confirmation. So, possibly um but because we don't have the details of the neighbor and it may be a drainage
2:20:58 plan for it, but that was never provided. So, it is but they took it out. Yes. It came into compliance by That's right. Yes.
2:21:06 Okay. So, you still have your gazebo.
2:21:13 you don't have side access and you have some sort of patio in the back.
2:21:17 Um, basically, um, the patio stuff that we had to knock down, it was because, um, like the limit of the property is
2:21:23 about like 10 ft and we were at like 8.5. [clears throat] We were at 8.5. So, we basically had to
2:21:31 get rid of that and had it rebuilt um, so it could fit. And the side stuff we had to knock the concrete, everything down basically.
2:21:41 All of that is gone. And did you get engineering for this eventually to staff satisfaction?
2:21:45 Um yeah, it was um no and engineering and demolition.
2:22:02 Um he spent about 35,000 in engineering and um and the demolitions on getting everything set basically.
2:22:10 Wow. [clears throat] Um, so staff has recommended that we reduce the um the penalty from 43,000 to 4,300. Okay. My
2:22:20 question to you is what number do you think is appropriate?
2:22:27 [laughter]
2:22:29 Yeah. Um, my father, he wanted to propose a 5% um to see if that would that could get approved today.
2:22:37 How much did you originally pay? You said 10,000 um for the building to get everything built.
2:22:42 Your what got you in trouble? How much did you pay for that? Um 9,800. So yeah, almost 10,000. And since then you've spent 35,000.
2:22:50 Yeah. No, no, no.
2:23:06 general contractor,000 general contractor.
2:23:11 So, and general contractor was almost like any 9,800 bucks. So, yeah. So, 35 on getting everything demolished, then nine um 9,800 getting everything built and 9,800 on general contractor as well.
2:23:23 Okay. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. M strange.
2:23:32 Yes, that's all I have to say.
2:23:33 Thank you. Okay. Uh Kirk, I I'm I'm just I keep sitting here and looking at this and you say you started the case on the
2:23:40 in October 24th, but it didn't come to the code enforcement board until July.
2:23:44 Nine months. Why it took nine months there to come to the uh board?
2:23:50 From October to Yeah. Yeah. I started the case on October 15th.
2:23:56 I I do recall. Well, it started just before the holidays, so there was uh the code board didn't hit on one of those
2:24:03 holiday months. So, I mean, there was a probably a multitude of things that put it back. First of all, we gave him plenty of time, I'm sure,
2:24:10 to do it verbally, and then when that doesn't happen, then we give them another two months to do it with a actual documented code case number. Uh it it totals up.
2:24:23 Yeah. Well, I mean, all the numbers and the find and everything adds up. What I'm doing here, I was just curious why we took uh when we uh identified the
2:24:31 problem, it took us nine months to bring them to the code enforcement board to to start the findings and everything. We gave them plenty of time. Yeah.
2:24:38 Probably more than more than Yeah. Okay. Okay. Um and I and I can't agree. I hate to say
2:24:47 this, but you know, ignorance of of of the policies and requirements is isn't an excuse, but uh and I somebody
2:24:55 mentioned it earlier, and that's one of the things I've been trying to do even when I sit on the code enforcement board is some kind of way we can hold
2:25:02 uh contractors responsible for these things when when the homeowner they telling the homeowners that these things and all. U
2:25:11 say I I know I've been told over and over all we can do is probably go back and have the homeowner suited. uh uh the contractor,
2:25:18 you know, chapter 162 Florida statutes, which provides the model for our code provisions and most other cities and
2:25:25 counties provisions uh provides us the power to go after owners, tenants, and
2:25:32 violators and and people who facilitate that. Now, in practice, it's rare to go
2:25:39 after anyone besides the owners. And the reason for that is uh really honestly convenience.
2:25:46 We know where we can get the owners. Um going after the contractors and other folks, I'm not saying it can't be done.
2:25:54 It's just in practice it's not as often because then you're dealing with a whole different set of evidence. How do you subpoena them, get them there? What are
2:26:02 we going to lean? The the property's there, but a violator's property, who knows? uh if it's an LLC or a lawnmowing
2:26:10 company or something like that, who knows? You know, they might not have any. But to answer your question, mayor, I mean, it's it is feasible. It is possible.
2:26:17 That's right. Okay. Um I'm okay with the I'm okay with the 10%, but one of the questions I asked, can
2:26:25 can we also uh say it can pay be paid over six months period instead of trying to require that right now add that stipulation in there?
2:26:34 Um, and the reason being when I sit on the code enforcement board, we used to wipe out these things completely all the time, but we have work involved, uh, staff time and everything else involved.
2:26:43 And when and I was sitting on the code enforcement board when we we put these ordinance in place and rules in place to
2:26:51 try to collect something back. U, I used to always try to go with a 25%, but uh, previous attorney told me we couldn't do
2:26:59 that. So 10% I'm I'm okay with you know and if even if they want to go to 5% that's fine with me but uh can we do it over instead of requiring them to pay it
2:27:08 within 30 days do a uh six months uh payment plan or 3 months whatever. Okay help them out.
2:27:18 Yes sir.
2:27:19 Thank you mayor. Um I have to remind myself on cases like this because they infuriate me. Yes.
2:27:25 They really infuriate me. And I don't know if it's just that I'm in my 50s and I'm getting I'm reaching my like crotchety old man era or what, but like
2:27:34 it just it really burns me that this happens on multiple levels. It burns me that you got you trusted somebody, you
2:27:43 hired somebody to do work for you and they told you that that it was going to be done legally and right. Um, and yeah,
2:27:53 we have an obligation to to check that, but we don't always do that. I'll be the first person to say I don't always
2:28:00 verify every single time every every single time someone tells me something.
2:28:06 I don't always verify that. That's on me and I get that. And I think from what I'm gathering from this conversation here that you seem like standup folks
2:28:15 that you're trying to do the right thing. It just you trusted some people who led you astray. Um, and so there's a piece of me that's like
2:28:24 I I I want to give, you know, sympathy to that. I also say, gosh darn it, if we don't hold people
2:28:32 accountable, then we're just going to keep doing this over and over again and we're going to be continuing to have this conversation and we never get anywhere. Um, and so I think at the end
2:28:42 of the day based off when I was on code enforcement, I always had to remind myself the goal is compliance, not
2:28:49 finding, not throwing the hammer in the book at someone, but compliance. And we're in compliance. And that's really
2:28:57 ultimately at the end of the day what matters the most. Now, that being said, we do, I think, have an obligation to
2:29:04 the rest of the taxpayers in the city to recoup our staff time that was involved.
2:29:10 And I think we just passed some additional um ordinances that allows us to fully recoup that staff time. Um,
2:29:19 if 10% is that number, I support that. I think it it makes us whole. It makes the taxpayers of the city whole, and you don't have to pay the full full amount.
2:29:29 It gives some acknowledgement to the fact that there was some effort made to follow some rules and trust some people
2:29:37 that you thought would lead you correctly. Um, and my I guess just my final plea to to residents of the city is gosh, make sure that you're hiring
2:29:46 somebody that is licensed and bonded and that you can find them through an LLC or
2:29:55 through a business and look at them through the business better business bureau. And don't just go by someone who put a sign out on the corner of 50 in
2:30:04 Hancock. Um, and they're the cheapest, please, because this is what we sent seem to to get as a result of that. So,
2:30:12 I I appreciate that you've come in compliance and I can support whether it's five or 10, whatever makes us whole. Thank you. And I also can support the six months.
2:30:21 Thank you. Yeah, Miss Mars.
2:30:23 Um, I echo some of what he said. Um, I really hope residents understand that you need to call the city to verify. You
2:30:33 can trust, but in the military always has a saying, trust, but verify. So, trust and verify because people, you know, not everybody's honest,
2:30:40 unfortunately. Um, I'm more inclined for 10% because this was a lot of time and they had a lot of time to come into
2:30:48 compliance. Um, and you're right, Brian, with the coming into compliance versus the money because I was first like, "No,
2:30:55 pay it. pay it because I don't want to set a president where people think that they come here and they're just going to
2:31:03 get it waved and so therefore we don't have to be in compliance. That's that's my concern, you know. Um but hearing
2:31:10 from um the applicants maybe see things a little different. I still um think it's very important for us to
2:31:19 make sure that people come into compliance and to call to the city first. that will save you a lot of headache is to find out do I need a
2:31:27 permit for this and to ask the people who are doing the work for you. So I am more inclined for the 10% not 5%.
2:31:35 Okay, Mr. Peterson, I totally feel for what your situation is and I think we have to go to staff.
2:31:43 Is the 10% cover the cost of uh according to what they wrote here, it does cover the cost of that's the
2:31:51 administrative cost. So it's just 10% is what you calculate out. So if it would have been a higher number that would have been a different number then. So I
2:31:59 mean I feel for that. I think we unless we have some kind of new ordinance where we can hold the contractor to get it
2:32:09 done ahead of time, but I don't know if that's possible with the ordinances that we have in place right now. That being said, I I would follow whether it be
2:32:17 five or 10% whatever everybody comes up to an agreement on.
2:32:22 [clears throat]
2:32:23 Yes, ma'am.
2:32:23 Mr. Attorney, there is some sort of contractor recovery fund in DVPR. Is that something that we could use as a city to recover some of these damages when we find them?
2:32:33 No, but it's something they could. They could. We can't, but they can. Yes.
2:32:39 Oh, interesting. Okay. Um, so yeah, I've had to learn sitting up here that compliance is the goal. And they've been
2:32:47 in compliance. I mean, I I'm hearing and it seems authentic. I'm not getting
2:32:53 a feel of manipulation here. I mean, I'm hearing we had a contractor, we trusted the contractor, we got a new contractor,
2:33:01 and if you've worked with any contractors lately, it does take time. Um, you know, I asked what you'd offer.
2:33:08 I'm I'm hearing zero, right? But they offered 5%. I'm inclined to say the 5%.
2:33:14 You know, I'll go I I'm not going to die on any hills here. I'd like to wrap this up for these folks, but I think you're talking about a $10,000 project that
2:33:22 they've spent $55,000 on and, you know, another 4,300 just feels punitive to me.
2:33:30 I think 2160 kind of makes it hurt a little bit more, but I think they've gone through the ringer. And I I'd be happy at 5% if we feel like we can get
2:33:39 there. And I don't mind if they need time to pay it. They didn't ask for it, but motion.
2:33:45 Okay. As I stated before, um I can do five, I can do 10. Of course, uh staff say they have 10% tied up in it. So, I'm
2:33:54 and I would like to recover what we have tied up in it. As I stated when I first sat on code enforcement board, um people
2:34:01 used to deliberately ignore our fines and everything and they would come in and we would just totally wipe them out totally. And I think we we decided not
2:34:10 to start accepting some have to do something. And I feel I feel their pain and everything um with the contractor
2:34:19 telling um thinking relying on the contractor and believing the contractors and everything. However, I do feel like
2:34:26 if we just start reducing these and giving them away and all what's going to stop the next person coming in and saying the same thing. So how would we feel? I trust I trust what
2:34:35 they telling us about not knowing and all but I go either way again 5% 10% but I would like to see 10% to recover what
2:34:43 staff recommended and say that's what they got tied up in it and I'm willing as again I'm willing to you know put it on some kind of payment plan as well.
2:34:51 How do we feel about 5% if it's paid within 15 days and after that 10% over six months? It encourages them to pay right away.
2:34:58 That's right.
2:34:59 Put it to bed and then if they need more time they have more time. 5% paid in 10 days and then and the rest other 5% in another how many
2:35:06 if they if they don't pay then it would be the full 10% that they have six months to pay.
2:35:11 Encourage a quick payment to put it to bed. Yeah. Less staff time moving forward. Do we like that?
2:35:21 Motion.
2:35:22 All right. I move um to reduce the fine to $2,160 if paid within 10 days. if not
2:35:29 $4,320 paid sometime in the next 6 months. Thank you. Second. Thank you.
2:35:37 I have [laughter] a motion to reduce it uh down to um 21
2:35:45 what it 2160 have 436 20 2160 to be paid within 10 days.
2:35:50 If not paid within 10 days, it reverts back to the 43 uh 20 to be paid within six months. Yes. Okay. Excuse me. Any further discussion?
2:35:58 No.
2:35:59 Hearing none. All in favor, let it be known by saying I. I.
2:36:02 All oppose. And the chair vote I as well. Thank you. Have a lovely day. Thank you. Motion carries 5.
2:36:12 All right. Item number 18, board appointment.
2:36:23 Uh, Kirk, are you handling this board appointment?
2:36:29 [laughter]
2:36:37 Mayor, we received two applications for the code enforcement board vacancy and uh the names are Ben Martin and Patricia
2:36:45 Woodhouse. I know that Patricia Woodhouse is present. Mr. Martin could not be present to attend the meeting tonight. Okay.
2:36:54 Um, [snorts] yes. I'm going to go ahead and uh this is a public forum, but I'm going go before we open up to the public. Um,
2:37:02 Miss, since Miss Woodhouse is here, I'm going to go ahead and give her a couple of minutes to make a statement if she wish, please, and then we'll open up to the public.
2:37:19 Good evening. Good evening.
2:37:20 My name is Patricia Woodhouse. I live at 2010 Sunset Lane in Clermont and you all are very familiar with me. Yes.
2:37:28 Um I have been before this board uh council. I've been before the board. Um I have become very familiar with code
2:37:35 enforcement. I also would like to take this opportunity to thank several of you. Christian, Mr. Bane, mayor, mayor,
2:37:44 you are on the board. Maybe I'll have your job someday. Um, [laughter] I feel like what my family has gone
2:37:52 through and my neighborhood has gone through with code enforcement over the last five years qualifies me to look at
2:38:00 these ordinances and look at the board and look at uh some of this as the way the city of Clermont is growing and uh
2:38:07 become a productive member of this board. I'm a 30-year ReMax realtor in Central Florida. I visit many many
2:38:16 neighborhoods all over and um Mr. Bane, you know that. Um and I have a very good reputation and I know what makes
2:38:24 neighborhoods thrive. I know what hurts neighborhoods. Um I see what you've just allocated here and I to your point, Miss
2:38:33 Strange, I would feel sorry for these people for what they've been through.
2:38:37 But what I really have a problem with is the people that don't comply with anything and have gotten away with it.
2:38:42 And you all know what has been gotten away with where I live. It's better.
2:38:46 It's not perfect. So, um that's where I am. I the uh opening came up and I think that I'm very well qualified for this
2:38:54 and um I hope you will consider my application. Any questions? I'm happy to answer. Okay.
2:39:03 Thank you for your willingness to Thank you, ma'am. If we have any other question for you, we will call you back at a later time. But right now, this is a public forum. Anyone in the public
2:39:11 wish to address this item may come to the microphone and state your name and address and have three minutes.
2:39:16 This is a public forum. Anyone in the chamber wish to address this item may come to the microphone and state your name and address and have three minutes.
2:39:23 Seeing no one, I close chamber. Anyone online, sir? Not at this time, Mr.
2:39:28 No one online. I bring it back. What say you, Mr. Bane?
2:39:31 Thank you, mayor. For whomever on staff, we have one vacancy. Is that correct?
2:39:39 Yes. Okay. Yes. Um, do we have the ability to appoint a member and a um alternate?
2:39:49 No. No.
2:39:50 Is that because our code doesn't allow for it? That's right.
2:39:53 So, if we changed our code, we could do that.
2:39:55 Uh, well,
2:40:01 [laughter]
2:40:02 I don't mean to put you on the spot because obviously we can't do it tonight.
2:40:04 There are ways of doing it. The only Well, let me think about that. [laughter] Let me think about that.
2:40:11 And here's why. Well, let me ask you this, Mr. W. Could we approve a member with a alternate with an asterisk that
2:40:21 says if we're allowed to make them an alternate, we give them the alternate status.
2:40:27 Otherwise, we don't. And um we then it's up to us to make a a change to our code
2:40:34 if we can or do we is your advice just to do a one appointment?
2:40:39 It would be one today and and the reason is various sunshine issues.
2:40:45 No problem. I just want to and where I'm coming from that is we we often struggle particularly with code enforcement board.
2:40:53 Yes. to get members. And if we have two applicants and one seat, I'd love to just be able to put them in that alternate status. It's if you've ever
2:41:02 served on jury, you're there. And you know, you don't have to necessarily be involved, but you're getting that experience. And and we would be able to
2:41:10 bypass having to have a vacancy for months where we don't have a full board and we could just put them in if a seat came open.
2:41:19 One thing I would mention is that you brought up the other day, council member, that I think the historic preservation, it's a separate thing. It should exist. It should have members. We
2:41:27 don't. So, it may be something worth reaching out anyone who's not getting this to be involved.
2:41:32 Okay. Thank you. Then I would support uh Miss Woodhouse. Thank you.
2:41:37 Yes, ma'am. Miss Marish, um I support Patricia Woodhouse being on um code enforcement. I think she'd be a great asset.
2:41:47 Thank you, Mr. Peterson.
2:41:49 Yeah, I definitely would be uh supporting Miss Woodhouse. Also, I was on the code enforcement board and I understand it it it requires a lot of
2:41:58 real estate abilities like our city attorney has and I think it would she would be an asset to the board. So, I would do support her also.
2:42:06 I'm ready to move forward, Miss Woodhouse. Thank you. Right.
2:42:11 And I also support Miss Woodhouse. Miss Woodhouse, let me say this. I was very pleased when I saw your name on it on this list of this because uh and I
2:42:19 understand the the plight you've been going through over there and and I had to kind of like laugh because that I was going through the same thing in my
2:42:27 neighborhood why I ended up on the code enforcement board and they asked me when I started doing the same thing. So, uh be careful
2:42:35 [laughter]
2:42:35 be careful on the board. That's how it all started for me back there trying to help in the community. Next thing you know, they had me on the code enforcement. It just elevating kept
2:42:43 elevating from there. But I would totally recommend uh this and uh with what she's going through and it to give a better better insight. I know she has
2:42:51 some insight on what what the code is all the way at the back with the fight you've been having already over there.
2:42:56 So So thank you. Thank you for submitting your name.
2:43:00 Move to approve Patricia Woodhouse to the code enforcement board. Second.
2:43:04 Have a motion and a second to approve uh Miss Woodhouse for board appointment to the code enforcement board. Any further
2:43:12 discussion? Hearing none. All in favor, let it be known by saying I. I.
2:43:16 All oppose. And chair go as well. Thank you, ma'am.
2:43:20 Mayor, may I request a 10-minute recess before we get to the last part of this agenda?
2:43:25 I was just going to ask you if you needed a recess. [laughter] It's not always me. I try to ask for everyone.
2:43:31 Uh, I got I got uh 5:35. So 53 45. Is that good? All right. Recess for 5 to 5:35. 40 bucks.
2:43:54 [music]
2:44:00 [music]
2:44:17 [music]
2:44:24 [music]
2:44:32 [music]
2:44:41 [music]
2:44:46 [music]
2:44:55 [music]
2:44:56 Heat.
2:45:01 [music]
2:45:07 [music] Heat.
2:45:38 [music]
2:45:55 [music]
2:46:04 [music]
2:46:10 [music]
2:46:15 [music]
2:46:21 [music]
2:46:27 [music]
2:46:34 [music]
2:46:45 [music]
2:46:51 [music]
2:47:16 [music]
2:47:18 Heat. Heat.
2:47:48 Heat. Heat.
2:47:54 [music]
2:47:59 [music]
2:48:04 [music]
2:48:13 [music]
2:48:22 [music]
2:48:30 [music]
2:48:48 [music]
2:48:56 [music]
2:49:20 out there.
2:49:38 [music]
2:49:44 [music]
2:49:53 [music]
2:50:01 [music]
2:50:14 [music]
2:50:22 [music]
2:50:45 [music]
2:50:49 Hey. Hey. Hey.
2:51:02 [music]
2:51:25 [music]
2:51:32 [music]
2:51:45 [music]
2:51:50 [music]
2:52:00 [music]
2:52:05 [music]
2:52:16 [music]
2:52:23 [music]
2:52:35 [music]
2:53:14 and give me one head back to your seat.
2:53:18 All right, it's 5:45, so we'll resume item number 19, citizen request.
2:53:27 Where she turn?
2:54:15 Thank you, sir.
2:54:18 Good evening, mayor, members of the council. from Paula Hoisington, 564 East Dninnesota Street. Good evening.
2:54:24 And I'm also a member of the Lincoln Park South Lake Alliance Board. Thank you for giving us this opportunity to
2:54:31 present to you a proposal to construct a community center at McKenna Park and
2:54:39 discuss how we together, the alliance, the citizens of South Lake County, particularly those living in Lincoln
2:54:47 Park to be a part of this important initiative.
2:54:51 This evening, I'd like to focus on four areas.
2:54:54 Our vision for the center, the needs Excuse me. Would you mind speaking the mic? It's kind of hard to hear you. Okay. I'm sorry. Thank you.
2:55:02 Tonight, I'd like to focus on four. Is that better?
2:55:05 That's better. On four areas. The vision for the center, the need it would address, the importance of land use planning, and the specific commitments
2:55:14 we're asking the county, the commit council to make. We're simply not asking for a building. We're [clears throat] asking for the city to invest in the
2:55:23 people to strengthen the historic community and to create opportunities for generations to come. 7 years, 9
2:55:31 months, 8 days ago, a group of concerned citizens began a casual conversation to
2:55:38 talk about what was then Clermont Middle School, formerly known as Lincoln Park High, a place where African-Americans were educated. The
2:55:47 conversation represented more than a concern about the property. It reflected a desire to preserve the history, to
2:55:55 protect the history of the community, and to create something that Lincoln Park could be proud of. Since that time,
2:56:02 we have continued to work towards this vision, con connecting with property history, the needs of aspiration of today's residents and those of the
2:56:11 future. We're here this evening because we believe Lincoln Park deserves more than just a vision on paper. It deserves
2:56:18 a plan, a commitment, an investment in its people, an investment in the people, not just in Lincoln Park, but of South
2:56:26 Lake County. A community center is much more than a building. It's a place where people can connect with resources,
2:56:33 discover opportunities, and develop skills, and build relationships.
2:56:39 Our vision is to create a welcome, flexible, multi-generational facility that serves the residents of Lincoln Park in the greater South Lake County.
2:56:51 Our vision represent a need of cross generations. Adults need educational opportunities, computer resources, work
2:56:59 source, workforce development, and career preparation. Families need a place to connect with the community
2:57:06 services and to participate in activities to strengthen family relationships.
2:57:12 Our older population need the opportunity to be able to stay connected, to have opportunities to get
2:57:18 engaged, wellness activities, educational programs, and connections to all available services. We also envision
2:57:27 partnerships that bring health, education, financial literacy, cultural programming, entrepreneurship, and other
2:57:34 valuable resources directly into the community. We we realize that some of these services are already exist and we
2:57:42 recognize and appreciate those who are providing those services. It is our belief that with bringing these services
2:57:49 together, we'll have one location where all citizens can come to get this information. We envision a wraparound
2:57:56 service. Not just a place where people just come and gather, but wraparound services to provide to the community.
2:58:03 Our goal is not to dilute the services, is to bring the organization, the resources together in a central location. The center would become a
2:58:12 place where educational institutions, nonprofit businesses, faith communities, public agencies work together to respond to the actual needs of the community.
2:58:22 The question is not simply whether Lincoln Park needs another building. The question is whether we are willing to create a place where opportunities and resources and people can come together.
2:58:35 Why Mckenni Park, you ask? We believe McKenna Park offers an opportunity connect recreation, education, community
2:58:42 life at one location. The property has a historic significance in the Lincoln Park area and reflects a community of longstanding commitment.
2:58:53 The property is near the Lincoln Park Education Center. The newly opened Lake Technical College of South Lake County
2:59:00 campus and a preK. These nearby educational resources create opportunities to explore partnerships
2:59:08 that could benefit the children, the families, the adults, and our seniors.
2:59:13 McKenna Park already provides the recreational amenities including a playground, basketball courts, a ball
2:59:21 field, and other outdoor facilities. Our vision is to complement those existing amenities to explore how the community
2:59:29 center can expand those opportunities also and inv include learning, social
2:59:36 engagement, and community program. We're not proposing to eliminate the park's recreational value. We want to build upon it. We recognize that any
2:59:45 development must be carefully evaluated to ensure that the center can accommodate responsibly the appropriate consideration of the open space,
2:59:54 recreation, parking, accessibility, stone water, and overall needs of the community. We believe McKenna Park
3:00:02 merits serious consideration as a preferred location for the community center. Working with subject matter
3:00:09 experts, the architects can help determine the functionality, the economic design for the property. Our goal is developed a practical plan that
3:00:18 meets the community needs while respecting the city's financial responsibility.
3:00:25 We're asking for the opportunity to move this concept to a professional evaluation plan, establishing a career path forward.
3:00:36 There's another important issue we asked the council to consider the appropriate land use designation for the proposed
3:00:42 community center. We have discussed with DPZ whether the appropriate future land use terminology should be civil institutional rather than public
3:00:51 institutional building. The city's existing comprehensive plan includes public facilities institutional land use
3:00:59 category that addresses arts, culture and civic facilities. That language is relevant to the type of community
3:01:06 facility we are proposing. We're asking the city the city to compare to clarify the appropriate designation and identify
3:01:15 the applicable comprehensive plan policies and other requirements that would govern the proposed use.
3:01:22 We also asked McKenney Park to be identified as a preferred site for the community center subject to the
3:01:30 city as I said planning evaluation environmental engineering and other applicable reviews. We feel this is
3:01:38 important because we want to propose the center to have a clear consistent planning.
3:01:44 We do not want the community center to remain a general idea while other potential use of the property advance
3:01:51 without comparable consideration for this community vision. We understand that land use decisions must follow
3:01:58 established procedures and that be supported by the appropriate analysis.
3:02:03 We're not asking the county the council to bypass this process. We're asking the council to direct the process forward, a
3:02:12 clear answer and a defined next step. We need clarity about the designation, consistency between the comprehensive
3:02:20 plan and the proposed use and process that allows the community center concept to be evaluated on its merit. We're
3:02:28 asking you to make an investment in the people for future generations. The benefits of this center would extend far beyond the walls of this building.
3:02:37 We want a place where organizations can share resources, introduce new programs, respond to the needs of the residents of
3:02:46 South Lake County. We also want to work with city staff and community partners to establish measurable goals. Goals so
3:02:54 that the residents as well as the city can participate in and decide the effectiveness, the partnerships, and the
3:03:02 benefits that will be delivered to the community.
3:03:05 This would allow us to assess not only whether the facility is being used but also whether it is making a meaningful
3:03:13 difference to the people and their lives. A community center at McKenna Park represents the opportunity to invest not only in a facility but in the
3:03:22 education relationships opportunity for community well-being. We believe this vision can
3:03:30 complement the city's investment in moving the city forward.
3:03:36 Our five requests of the city mayor and members of the council, we recognize that the project of this
3:03:43 nature requires thoughtful planning, financial analysis, collaboration, and responsible decisionmaking.
3:03:52 We're not asking you to approve a final construction design tonight. We're asking that you take the actions necessary to move the vision towards
3:04:01 reality. Specifically, we request formally support the community center at McKenna Park, clarify the support and
3:04:10 the appropriate land use designation, establish a timeline and accountability.
3:04:21 The report should identify the actions required, department's responsibility, anticipated milestones,
3:04:28 preliminary costs, potential funding source, and any issues requiring further council direction. These five requests
3:04:38 are intended to establish a practical framework for moving the project forward, allowing the city to exercise oversight at every stage.
3:04:48 At this point, I would like to bring up Alex from Gator Sketch. And what Alex will present to you is just a vision of
3:04:55 what we anticipate a center on that property could look like. Nothing permanent, as I said, just so that you can get a vision. You know, say if you see it, you can believe it.
3:05:05 So, that's what we'd like to do with Alex right now. And then I'll come back with a claim. What are the five requests? I'm sorry.
3:05:11 I had formally support community center, land use designation, timeline, and accountability. Establish a timeline. You got that one? Yeah. What was four and five?
3:05:20 Formally support. Yeah.
3:05:22 Clarify and support the appropriate land use designation. Yeah.
3:05:28 Identify and earmark funding for the project. Got it.
3:05:34 Authorize a feasibility planning and process. Got it. And then timeline and accountability.
3:05:42 Oh, and establish a timeline for accountability.
3:05:45 Got it. Thank you. At this time, I'd like to bring Alex up
3:05:52 [clears throat]
3:05:52 again. Good afternoon, Mayor Council. I have a guest. My name is Alex Boo. I'm with Gator Sketch
3:05:59 Architects. Um been working with the Alliance for about seven years now, I think. Uh they brought a vision to us.
3:06:08 Yeah, you get you had the right number, but um so I had a vision for a community center. um they were very concerned about what was going to happen with the
3:06:17 elementary school um when the students moved away from it and that empty parcel was going to be left. They were worried about the functions that might not be
3:06:25 compatible with the neighborhood. And so they formed the alliance and they asked me uh to help them to envision what a community center could be like on the
3:06:33 elementary school campus. So I'm going to go back a little bit um in history.
3:06:37 So this was back in uh after a couple of years 2021. We looked at the elementary school campus and we looked at basically
3:06:44 it's a programming uh map that shows all the things that the the alliance felt was important and from their um surveys
3:06:52 of the community, what was needed in the area. And this plan left the north part of the site um because there was a
3:07:00 pretty new building up there with uh kindergarten and elementary school classrooms that was left over for the school district to use as prek
3:07:09 classrooms which we thought uh could possibly support a community center. The southern port of the site portion of the site was for vocational training and it
3:07:18 had been identified especially construction trades that there was no training in South Lake and that was really needed. a big need [clears throat and cough] center of the
3:07:26 site retain the gymnasium uh the cafeteria uh with the thought that we could have a meeting spaces keep the
3:07:34 recreational components on site uh place for boys and girls and teens and seniors a literacy uh lab a computer lab and GED
3:07:44 education and so this was presented to uh several partners including the school district school district got Lake Tech
3:07:51 College involved um And what what ended up happening was that the school district decided this would be a great
3:07:58 location uh for the alternative high school that they were thinking about.
3:08:02 And so the alternative high school uh has uh different hours for classes so that they they can accommodate students that are working and they can still get their get their education and graduate.
3:08:13 And then Lake Tech College when they found out there was an opportunity to have a bigger presence on the campus they said well we don't want just those
3:08:22 four buildings you've allocated to us we could use the entire campus and provide vocational training on that campus and
3:08:29 so uh those things have been happening now what happened though was kind of the community meeting rooms and the
3:08:36 gymnasium components some of the educa the recreational components got pushed out of the plan as we had uh envisioned it those years ago.
3:08:50 Uh got the existing condition and what the elementary school used to look like.
3:08:55 That hasn't really changed that much back in 2021 with the concept. Uh we proposed a new uh uh entrance for the
3:09:03 campus in the what would be the community center portion of the project.
3:09:06 And now currently what you see in the bottom is where the design has evolved to in working with Lake Tech. Uh the
3:09:14 original high school has already been completed and is and is occupied and that architect we didn't have that project. We have been working with Lake
3:09:22 County. Um we've been fortunate to have that. And also I should take a moment to thank the city council. You guys included us in your next uh round of
3:09:31 continuing service architects. And so we are looking forward to working with the city again. It's been several years since we've been on that uh on that
3:09:38 program with you. Uh we were matching with the bottom Lake Tech. Um the high school developed a a cubist a rectal linear pattern of grays and and paints.
3:09:48 And so we're trying to follow that pattern to bring to campus as a cohesive entity even though it's working with two
3:09:56 different identities, the Lake uh district, Lake County School District and [clears throat] Lake Tech.
3:10:02 But the hope is that those same high school students are just going to move right next door on the campus and go from high school directly into
3:10:10 vocational training. Um, and so we want that campus to be and have an overall feel.
3:10:18 This uh just recently opened. As I said, the the the pattern has come came from the high school um elevations and so we
3:10:26 were trying to kind of use that pattern and continue with it in this uh uh building. This used to be the gymnasium.
3:10:32 It now houses mechanical, an HVAC and air conditioning classroom and lab, an electrical uh classroom and lab. And I
3:10:41 believe it's a robotics classroom and lab and construction management classroom as well as support spaces, bathrooms, break room, and that type of
3:10:49 thing that opened up or the grand opening was uh earlier this um this year
3:10:56 uh this fall. Uh this is uh renderings of what that entrance to the campus will be now. Um so we wanted to bring a nice
3:11:05 open uh glass enclosure for the lobby and become more inviting and basically update and revitalize uh the buildings and and bring them up to the current.
3:11:16 This is what's coming on that property.
3:11:18 Yes, actually on the on the uh C. Yes, that is coming. that that particular piece right there um has the
3:11:27 administration offices, a new computer lab, an accredited testing lab. Um I think primarily that's I think there's a
3:11:34 classroom there, but I'm not sure exactly what that will be. So that's the next phase. This is under bidding right now, so it should be under construction in January. And actually, uh the third
3:11:44 phase for Lake Tech is coming um next year. We've been awarded that contract and that will have additional vocational
3:11:53 programs. Um I've heard EMS culinary as in baking,
3:12:00 dental hygiene, and some of the other ones escape me, but that it's an ongoing process and there'll probably be a couple of more phases, but that will be
3:12:08 built out. All those buildings existing plus I think some new buildings will be on that campus uh to create a really powerful vocational training campus.
3:12:21 So, uh, the city, I'm sorry, the the alliance asked me, um, back when they realized that some of the functions were
3:12:29 not going to be able to be accommodated any longer on the elementary school site, they said, "Well, directly across the street from the building that just
3:12:36 opened the gymnasium is McKini Park. Is there a way for us to use McKini Park,
3:12:43 make it a part of this overall campus and concept that we have for community center and community support area? Um,
3:12:49 what is the maximum size community center we might be able to build on this property? Um, again, this
3:12:57 is just an architect reading the ordinances and and and looking at the setbacks and that type of thing. I've not worked with the city staff and we would obviously have to do that. Uh this
3:13:06 may not be what we end up having, but I was just trying to give some vision to what we could possibly do here on this
3:13:13 site. So um to keep the traffic patterns the same,
3:13:20 we kept the two entrances to you've got existing 20 uh space parking lot which are on south on Januita Street. And so we kept the traffic patterns the same by
3:13:28 keeping those uh openings there and not creating new traffic patterns with using the established traffic patterns which then put the parking lot to the southern
3:13:36 portion of the site. Um in order to have the least amount of site work cost and
3:13:45 the largest footprint for the community center, we ended up putting the community center uh on the north uh east side, which is a higher side of the
3:13:53 site. the sight slopes from east to west. So, we put it where we wouldn't have to do a bunch of retaining walls and uh a lot of drainage, storm water
3:14:01 drainage. So, from an economical standpoint, unfortunately, that spot did take out the um baseball field on the
3:14:08 site. Uh we proposed uh master gardening uh a master garden uh for classes doing
3:14:15 that. A butterfly garden um that would be next to the existing pavilion, the existing playground and the two uh basketball courts, exterior basketball courts would remain in their location.
3:14:27 Um and then we had the parking to accommodate uh the new community center. As I said that approximately 25,000 was the
3:14:35 maximum size we thought we could get on the site and meet the requirements for storm water and parking. The biggest concern that we heard about that
3:14:44 particular um solution was uh the fact that we lost the baseball field. So the alliance asked me to come back and see
3:14:53 if we could find a way to save the baseball field. So we've come back with a program here uh where the baseball
3:15:00 field is retained. Uh we're still using the same concept to keep the uh traffic patterns unchanged, building off the
3:15:09 existing parking lots. However, um the parking lot uh because of the amount of space that the baseball field uh takes,
3:15:18 we would have to take the non-conforming basketball court. You have one more or less regulation court outside. You have
3:15:25 one small basketball court that is not conforming to any size that would be uh have to be used for parking. Uh but that
3:15:33 basketball court would be be replaced with an indoor court inside the community center. Um because of the
3:15:40 location of the community center a little bit downstream. We are going to have to have a very uh uh creative storm
3:15:47 water uh solution. So the retention that we had before which should accommodate there might have to be some uh some
3:15:55 thoughts and some um something might might be need need to be done. I think the site work here is going to be more expensive by keeping that ball field but
3:16:02 the ball field you know is worth it I'm sure. Um there'll be a retaining wall for instance between the two parking lots. That's why they're split up.
3:16:09 There's a six foot drop between those two. And in order to get enough parking spaces, we'd have to build some retaining walls and maybe a tree well in
3:16:17 order to save that nice oak tree in the middle of the site.
3:16:21 Uh we managed to keep a small portion of the butterfly garden next to the building. And what we would propose is a high fence to separate the baseball
3:16:29 field from the parking lot, but we would stop it in the center field. Um and then allow that um that right field area to
3:16:38 be continue to be used for soccer that's sized for uh soccer play up to nine years old. Uh your baseball field is
3:16:46 sized uh for play up to 12 years old and that would remain in its place.
3:16:53 Again the playground and the pavilion existing pavilion on the west part of the site would remain as as well as the
3:16:59 exterior basketball court. Uh in this scheme uh we felt about the maximum size that we were going to get would be about
3:17:07 16,000 square feet for a community community center given the parking requirements um at 1 to300 for a recreational
3:17:15 facility. Again um that's kind of the uh the type of designation we'd have to figure out and what Paula is asking for
3:17:23 if this does go forward is would it be 1 to 300 feet? Would it be 1 to 200 feet?
3:17:28 that would kind that will dictate what the size of the facility can be and what the parking requirements would be. Uh inside we as I said we have the uh a
3:17:36 9,000 square foot uh basketball court and then we have um a community uh meeting space and classrooms on the
3:17:45 second floor above. There'd be a a plaza in front of the um lobby area where
3:17:52 people could congregate. Um also, um we were proposing just a pedestrian access.
3:17:57 We were talking about I heard talk about sidewalks earlier. Uh we were proposing a pedestrian access to the north side.
3:18:03 Um the one thing we want to make sure that we we do in the plan is to keep it so that the people that are on the site moving from one amen amenity to the
3:18:11 other do not have to cross over driveways and cross over um uh parking lots to get from one one site to the other.
3:18:19 Um so again this is uh this is just what we we thought we could do. It's um looking at
3:18:28 the floor plan you'll be entering um from the south u from the parking lot.
3:18:35 We have the dash lines that on the plan there depict on the south side depict the large overhang and we're showing some benches out there for people to
3:18:43 wait for drop off and pick up and comfortable comfortable areas sheltered.
3:18:47 Uh as you enter the building uh the yellow area is a lobby. Uh immediately upon your entrance uh in the center part
3:18:55 of the uh lobby you have an office that is located with windows so that it can monitor who is coming into the building,
3:19:03 who is going into the basketball courts, who's using the elevator which is adjacent to the office um and um
3:19:11 basically maintain control of the facility.
3:19:17 Uh also in the lobby there's a small seating area to complement the exterior seating area for waiting. Directly to
3:19:23 the east you have the community uh meeting room that is a space that could accommodate up to 100 occupants. Uh
3:19:33 serving that um or supporting that is a chair and table storage. So you could rearrange that not to be just seating but to have seats and tables uh for
3:19:41 different arrangements, different configurations and different functions.
3:19:45 Adjacent to that in the blue, we have a servery catering kitchen that could serve the community center. We'll have
3:19:52 two rollup doors, one facing the community center and then one towards the lobby there in the corridor that could serve as a concession stand for other type of activities.
3:20:03 Um, an elevator can take you up to the second floor for ADA compliance. And then to safely get you up and down, you've got two stairways, one on the
3:20:10 north and south side. And you have your group restrooms on that uh on that floor as well. Um going into the basketball court, that's a regulation size court.
3:20:19 Uh you would have uh additional two goals to the north, two goals to the south, so you could play smaller, you know, shorter game uh going the opposite
3:20:27 direction or set up for two volleyball courts simultaneously at the same uh at the same uh time.
3:20:37 Going upstairs, coming off the elevator or the front stair, you have a small lobby area. There's a little sink set up
3:20:44 there for a coffee, maybe a little coffee uh preparation, and then a break area possibly for that second floor with
3:20:51 some seating tables and chairs um there uh for a little small gathering place.
3:20:58 Then we have three uh full-size classrooms which would accommodate up to 25 students, one smaller classroom which
3:21:05 would be enough for 12 students and then the restrooms for upstairs. Um and that uh would complete the program. It's this
3:21:14 was the smallest uh as far as programming that the alliance really felt that they could live with. We're actually short half a classroom, but I
3:21:22 tried to squeeze as much as I could onto that site. Um, in terms of the construction, we would be looking at,
3:21:29 uh, what we're proposing would be something that would be a 50-year project. Um, concrete block, concrete
3:21:36 tilt wall. Um, uh, roof uh, two ply roof for some redundancy, lightweight insulating
3:21:44 concrete for, uh, resilience, storm resilience, as well as impact resistant windows, doors, and storefronts. and um
3:21:53 you know the consideration that this might be a good uh also hurricane shelter for the city if it's in the right location for the city to operate.
3:22:00 Uh but we would see a a 50-year life cycle for this building. Um appearances we didn't want to presume um
3:22:09 before we spoke to you about what this thing should look like. Um so we don't have any plans for you upon getting your input. we'd be glad to provide you with
3:22:18 plans, but we didn't want to go off in a direction that wasn't appropriate for your thoughts. So, um, that really, uh,
3:22:26 concludes my presentation. Um, thank you for your consideration and your time. I'll turn it back over to Paul.
3:22:36 Thank you, Alex. Members of the council, Lincoln Park has a rich history, a history that deserves to be continued, a
3:22:45 history that deserves recognition.
3:22:50 It's a community that deserves investment.
3:22:53 Imagine a place where children can explore new possibilities. Families can connect with helpful resources. Adults
3:23:00 can prepare for new careers. Older adults can remain active and engaged.
3:23:05 organizations can work together to strengthen South Lake County.
3:23:11 The vision that I bring before you tonight, Lincoln Park Alliance stands ready and prepared to work with the
3:23:19 residents, educational institutions, nonprofits, businesses, faith communities, and other partners to help
3:23:26 develop the programs and the partnerships that will make this center meaningful to South Lake County. We
3:23:33 understand that realizing that this vision will take collaboration, careful planning, responsible use of public
3:23:40 resources. We're prepared to be a part of that work. Tonight, we ask that the council take the next step, provide
3:23:49 clear direction, establish divi a defined planning process, make a financial commitment that gives this
3:23:57 vision the power to move forward. Let's honor the legacy of those who have come before us by creating opportunities for
3:24:05 those who will follow. Let's move from conversation to commitment, from vision to planning, and from planning to
3:24:13 action. Members of the council, let's work together to build a legacy and a future for all generations to come.
3:24:21 Let's build this future together. Thank you. And we're open for questions. Thank you.
3:24:28 This is a public forum. Anyone in the chamber wish to address this item may come to the microphone and state your name and address and have three minutes.
3:24:37 Anyone in the chamber,
3:24:48 Mike Kramer, Clare, my Yach Club, I came here with a pretty open mind about this pro project tonight and I'm
3:24:56 honestly pretty impressed that we've gotten this far. I am just blown away that we don't have a community center
3:25:03 serving some of our most deserving population. You know, if I want to go play basketball, I can hop in my car and run down to the performing arts center
3:25:11 and there's a lot there, but I've got a car and the resources and this is putting a a community center where it
3:25:18 most deserves it. You try to put a community center in where where people need it, where people can walk there and serve and serve that area.
3:25:28 I'm privileged to be able to go to a community center. I'm lucky to live in a community center area that has a community center that we have currently
3:25:36 um at the performing arts center. I would love to see something like that.
3:25:39 You know, the ability to have basketball and sports and just giving young people and people in that
3:25:47 community, but especially young people, a sense of purpose, community, and direction and and home. We've seen
3:25:54 Clermont grow by, you know, 30,000 people over the last dec decade. Yet, this one community has stayed there intact. And it's probably one of the
3:26:03 most intimate communities I in all of the Clermont area. The neighbors know each other.
3:26:11 They go to church together. They used to go to school together there. But most important, they need a place where we
3:26:18 can put children and our seniors and other folks that just have a little bit of difficulty with mobility. You know, I'm blessed. I I can get it anywhere I
3:26:26 need in this town. I can walk. I can ride my bike. I can drive my car. But this area needs
3:26:34 needs and I I I am I am so proud of uh Miss Hoisington and the alliance. I'm
3:26:42 ashamed of my lack of awareness of it. I wish id known more sooner because I would have helped out sooner. But she's
3:26:48 proposed a good project and again this is a really good time for you guys to do something to move forward. We can sit and talk about this but she's been talking about this for almost a decade.
3:26:59 So it's a great opportunity for action. Action. So thank you. Thank you.
3:27:12 Hello. My name is Patrick Bianke. Um 810 West Montro Street. Everything that was presented tonight, I I all I want to say
3:27:19 is this. When she said conversation to commitment, my recollection is that prior
3:27:26 administrations of this city didn't even allow the conversation to happen. And there's been many in occasions where the
3:27:34 Lincoln Park Alliance Group has tried to beat down the door to have conversations. So, thank you for allowing those conversations to happen.
3:27:41 Thank you to city staff for those conversations to start happening. I've personally met with the Lincoln Park Alliance Group about this project,
3:27:50 various different things that we discussed. They're the real deal. This is a community partner such like Main
3:27:57 Street, such like Livewell that you want to be a partner with. So, thank you for the conversation.
3:28:05 Thank you. Anyone else? Anyone else? This is on public forum.
3:28:11 Anyone in the chamber wish to speak to this item may come to the microphone and state your name and address and have three minutes.
3:28:17 Seeing no one else, I close down the chamber. Anyone online, sir?
3:28:21 Yes, sir. We've got interest on
3:28:23 [clears throat]
3:28:24 online caller. Go ahead.
3:28:28 Shannon, you're Hi, this is Shannon Herrera and my address is 265 Boulevard and I'm on the
3:28:36 Lincoln Park South Lake alliance. Uh, and I just I also work with have worked and volunteered with a lot of the
3:28:43 nonprofits in the area and I think this is a great project not only because of the location uh being at highway 50 and
3:28:53 highway 27 it's a wonderful location easy to get to and the prop is uh a very
3:29:00 important piece of property for the community and I think it has to remain serving directly to the community. It
3:29:07 started out being donated by families in the Lincoln Park area for the education of their children and it needs to stay
3:29:16 servicing the children and families of not just Lincoln Park but the greater area but it needs to stay serving
3:29:25 directly to the families. So something like a community center um before it ever becomes something else. So, um I'm
3:29:33 just really uh thankful to Paula Hoisington for presentation and um I really hope that uh the city council
3:29:40 decides to move in this direction. Thank you very much. Thank you. Anyone else? Yes, sir.
3:29:48 Next caller. Go ahead. Jenny, you're up.
3:30:04 My apologies. Jenny May, 4062 Greystone Drive. I wanted to to thank Paula for a
3:30:11 great presentation. I'm not part of the alliance, but my goodness, I should be.
3:30:16 Um, just wanted to just kind of touch upon, you know, my growth in community centers. was uh one of the biggest
3:30:24 advantages and I and I and I thank my aunt uh for many years for for bringing me to a community center um when I was a
3:30:33 child. It was just one of the most positive um experiences that I had as a child um and I think made me who I am
3:30:40 today. Um community centers is why it's considered a positive value addition to a city. I mean the key key benefits,
3:30:48 social connections, health and wellness, youth development, lifelong learning and economic and property values. Um I do
3:30:57 agree that this should be something that should come from paper to reality. I
3:31:04 think the time is is is is we need to stop talking about it and get some action done. So um you know I applaud
3:31:13 the alliance for putting a well presentation. Um I support this. I believe um that this should uh be
3:31:21 something of a you know of a priority or a list that the the city should uh put you know funding towards or or help in
3:31:30 that. But uh I wanna I want to thank Paulie again for uh putting such a great presentation and thank you for for the opportunity to speak.
3:31:38 Thank you. Anyone else, sir? Yes, sir. Next caller. Go ahead.
3:31:51 Jay, you're up.
3:32:00 Hey, this is Jay Brian Miles. I was actually calling in to speak on the next item, but I do want to comment on this very quickly. Um, I was a part of some
3:32:10 of the initial conversations that the Lincoln Park South Lake Alliance had with the city in regards to this community center. And I can tell you
3:32:17 just to speak towards uh Mr. Biankey's comment. There was a a large actually, let me change that. There was a very
3:32:25 small population with a very large voice that did not want this conversation to move forward. And I applaud the League of Park South Lake Alliance, not just
3:32:32 Paula Hoisington, but Sharon Keys as well for continuing to beat that drum until somebody hears it. And my hope is that council does hear it and does give
3:32:42 the opportunity for this group to take the next steps to figure out what they can do with the property available to them in that area. I think I won't, you
3:32:50 know, go over what they've already gone over, but there's plenty of space.
3:32:53 There's plenty of opportunities and Gator Sketch has put together what I think is a really great design that would make sense for that community. And my hope is that you guys will at least
3:33:01 give them the opportunity to take those next steps, put some things in motion, and actually maybe see this vision come to light. That's all I want to say. And I will speak on that item as well, too.
3:33:12 Thank you. Thank you. Anyone else, sir? Yes, sir. Uh Gail, you are up.
3:33:28 Gail, turn on your microphone and you may speak.
3:33:36 Okay. Good afternoon. My name is Gail Brown. My address is 4084 Foxtown Drive in Clermont. And I'd like
3:33:44 to thank Paula and Sharon and their group for putting together such a great presentation. And I'm really asking the
3:33:52 city to move forward so that they can move forward with this community center.
3:33:57 It's really necessary for our kids and our seniors to have a resource like this. And so, thank you very much, Paula. Thank you, city council.
3:34:08 Thank you. Anyone else, sir? That's it, sir.
3:34:11 That's it. So, we'll close public comment and bring it back to council.
3:34:14 What say council? Um, that's chamber. We close public comment unless it's up.
3:34:22 Well, well, that's up to you all. I mean, I closed the chamber, but if y'all say okay, it's fine. Step up to the [laughter] microphone.
3:34:29 She never comes. Come on.
3:34:31 And I think I think I had enough. Miss uh Miss Jackson, did you want to say something? Yes, sir. Okay.
3:34:40 Yes, ma'am.
3:34:42 Yes. Hi, my name is Cassier kind of Murry and I commend address please for wanting a community center. But
3:34:51 however, however, the McKini Park, I see that part utilized all the time by schools teams come and practice there.
3:35:00 Even the Head Start, they have their programs over there. And you know, I'm all about kids. I see families taking their kids there. They sit down for
3:35:08 picnics. All sorts of things go on in that park, you know, and I I really like the idea of having a community center,
3:35:16 but I don't think that would be the right place to have it. I really don't. Thank you.
3:35:22 Thank you. Yes, ma'am. Miss Jackson.
3:35:28 I I saw you stand up back there and I think you got when they know you by your name.
3:35:34 [laughter]
3:35:36 Yeah. My name is Glenda Jackson and I've been living in Clermont in part of Lincoln Park for over 50 years.
3:35:43 Um, I've noticed that I'm a retiree, go back to work retiree. And I talked to a lot of the seniors that don't have any
3:35:50 place to go and figure out what they need to do with the um computers. And I think having this community center in
3:35:58 Lincoln Park, wherever you decide to put it, is a great idea because you got young children. I watch the young children. I'm in that area all the time
3:36:05 because I go to church over there and I go to church at the Woodson Temple on Scott Street and um you see the little children playing in the road playing in
3:36:14 the area but this community center will pull I see she has a a boys and club boys and girl club building there that
3:36:22 will pull the boys and girl off the street into the building learning how to do computer other than playing those crazy games. They will learn how to play
3:36:30 on the computer. they would know how to get an education and have a stable lifestyle, go to college or whatever
3:36:38 they they plan to do what would be possible on their behalf. And I think like I said, I don't know where you plan to put it. That is a place that's the
3:36:47 idea for the council and whoever decides. And I thank the alliance for doing such an awesome job today. That
3:36:54 was an awesome presentation. And I just say we clear my I don't live in Lincoln Park but I live in Lincoln Park.
3:37:02 [laughter] So I think you should consider that idea and take care of it and move forward with it. Thank you.
3:37:08 Thank you ma'am. Anyone else?
3:37:17 Hello Sharon Keys 644 Westola Street. Uh like Miss Linda said, uh I don't live in Lincoln Park, but I'm in Lincoln Park.
3:37:27 Uh that's my home. That's where I was raised and will always be in my heart in my community. Uh we would like the
3:37:35 center on McKenna Park because we felt like the accessibility uh with the tech center, the prek and
3:37:43 all of that, that one campus area. And as a mother, um, to know that my child is right there amongst everything that's
3:37:52 going on and, you know, upfront, we just feel like that this would be the best best place for it. And
3:38:00 we need it. We need it. We've been coming for seven years. How many months? Nine months, 24 days, I think it was.
3:38:09 So, we've been having and like Jay Brian was saying, we've had some conflicts and things like that, but we're back now.
3:38:15 And we believe that this is going to be great a great legacy for the community and everything. So, thank you and please
3:38:23 consider it. Write it down. Make it happen. Thank you. Anyone else?
3:38:30 Seeing no one else, I'm going close public comment and bring it back to Mr. Bryan. Thank
3:38:38 you, mayor. Um,
3:38:42 [snorts]
3:38:43 I just want to state for the record that I think Mckin Park is the most appropriate spot. So, I'm looking at the
3:38:52 five asks support for Mckin Mckin Park location. Check.
3:38:58 Um, land use designation for staff. What is our current land use designation?
3:39:04 And are are we able to change a land use to something that's in
3:39:12 the comp plan and not approved yet or do we have to change it to something we currently have in order to accommodate if we were to move forward?
3:39:24 That's for you.
3:39:26 Yes. Anybody on staff who who can answer? I I actually don't know the answer to that today.
3:39:32 Institutional. Let me Okay. Because I I'm I'm just going to go I'm just trying to go through the five asks here from my vantage point that I I
3:39:41 think whatever purview we have and whatever ability we have to make the land use designation what it needs to be to
3:39:50 accommodate the the facility the convent convention the uh community center. Um,
3:39:57 I I think we can do. I just don't know if we can make it something that's in a proposed version of a comp plan or if it
3:40:05 it has to be something that we currently have. And, um, then we we make that additional change once a comp plan gets
3:40:13 approved. Um, and so, um, but I I would be curious of what the the current
3:40:20 future land use is for it. um in terms of timeline and um feasibility planning process. This
3:40:29 might I guess be for more for the city attorney.
3:40:32 So what sticks in my mind is our recent process with the with the uh parking
3:40:40 structure where we we we created a committee and I'm not suggesting we create another committee but we created
3:40:49 this committee um and they came up with two locations and some features and information and then we said okay we
3:40:57 accept this location and now we're going out for design to get something to come back to to understand cost and timeline
3:41:05 and all those things. Is that essentially the same process we'd have to go through here to do the same thing
3:41:12 without having to go to a committee, but just basically say we want to design, we will go out to bid for a design and and bring us a concept plan and and we
3:41:21 understand what it cost and we vote yes or no and we move forward.
3:41:25 That is a common way to do it. You can mic. Oh, sorry.
3:41:29 Thank you. Yeah. Um, that's the common way to do it. It's the basic way to do it where we kind of do this design build
3:41:36 process. We find out from some one what the design criteria package would be and then we go out for who might best be
3:41:45 around to build it. That that's what we did for the garage. You do have other options um which are similar to um I
3:41:52 think maybe for example we have continuing contracts with different vendors. you could just work with um management to pick the appropriate one
3:42:01 assuming the cost I don't know what the cost would be. That's my next question.
3:42:05 Okay. But if it was under 7 million I think the number is u it's it's a large number then we as long as they're on a
3:42:13 continuing contract we wouldn't necessarily have to go through another bidding process. So it just depends.
3:42:19 Okay. Okay. Um, let me follow up with saying, could we as a council say we're moving forward
3:42:28 conceptually with what we see in front of us and not give anybody any other opportunity to do anything or provide us any other versions?
3:42:38 Yes. Okay. Um to if my fellow council members will um
3:42:47 to the gentleman who presented, do you have a rough idea conceptually of what the cost of what you're propo or not proposing but what you
3:42:56 shared with us would be as a a very very rough order of magnitude about $300 a square foot for a
3:43:03 a building of this type right now would probably be a decent budget number and we were at 16,000 a little bit over
3:43:11 square feet. So 4.8 million for construction cost was what we as a rough estimate was what we came up with.
3:43:19 So around five, call it 5 mil. 5 million. Okay.
3:43:22 Uh there was also the question that you asked about the land use and we just we we like I said we didn't we didn't work with staff. We did try to pull what we could off of the uh ordinances on site.
3:43:34 So what I have uh forgive me can't see it. Um, I had the zoning as residential,
3:43:43 uh, medium density, uh, public facility allowed as a conditional use, future land use as parks,
3:43:51 45% maximum pvious coverage, and we were at 39%.
3:43:56 And that's off based off our current code in future land use.
3:44:00 Yes. Again, I I have not worked with staff and that would and this would work in our future land use staff. Okay. Yeah. And so how does that
3:44:09 work moving forward with a with a because we have this comp plan out there. If we have things in progress and we end up approving a new comp plan and
3:44:18 then a new zoning and things are in the works, do do we just make adjustments to the zoning then at that point?
3:44:27 Where the government Okay. We can do whatever we want.
3:44:29 Yeah. I'm just making sure that that we have that flexibility because I I I don't want to get down the road and then be caught up on a technicality because
3:44:38 of a of a code or something that's being put in place. Okay. Um and then with regard to um
3:44:48 earmarking funding, uh I guess this is a question would be for Miss Hoisington then um or any representative from the
3:44:55 South uh South Lake um South Park uh and a Geez Louise, I can't speak. Sorry. The alliance, the Lincoln Park South Lake
3:45:03 Alliance. Um, have you had any conversations with private entities about creating a public private partnership relative to this project?
3:45:15 Yes, we have. We've had some preliminary conversations and some commitments to work with us if the city will work with us.
3:45:22 Okay. So, you do have some commitments from public or private partnerships to partner with the city on that. Yes.
3:45:29 Okay. All right. Um, and then my only other thought uh question was with regard to eliminating some park space
3:45:38 here uh open green space or park space with buildings and and whatnot. Um,
3:45:46 would we be able to tie into this project
3:45:53 the ability to utilize the space on um, say the other space on Highland Avenue, which I think is like the other area
3:46:00 that's been talked about to create some park space, green space that might be
3:46:08 um, uh, somewhat altered from this plan to also then make sure it's still within
3:46:16 the vicinity of the project. And I guess that would be for staff if if that's something that we could do to to tie in with this project and and do it all together.
3:46:25 Schoolboard property.
3:46:26 No, no, I'm talking about the project the property that the city owns on Highland Avenue that's like behind the auto store, I think, or something.
3:46:35 Yeah. Water tower. What's that? The water tower. Yeah. Old water tower probably.
3:46:40 Yeah, the old the old water tower. Is that something that we could put together as a full package to do a community center and also look at
3:46:48 creating a park space in the in uh in that location to tie the projects together so that we're doing uh you know
3:46:56 we recognize some elimination of some green space and open space. But we understand the importance of what we're doing and by doing so we also want to
3:47:05 bring this other element in uh to compensate and and work with that.
3:47:11 Is that I don't see why not. Okay. Um just on first blush.
3:47:15 Okay. I think those are my initial questions that I have right now. I think I covered your five areas with those with those things. So, thank you.
3:47:23 Thank you, Miss Myers.
3:47:27 Good evening. I like the drawing of this. Um my question is how much would it cost to operate this facility?
3:47:37 We have not gone into um the cost the staffing. Um our initial
3:47:45 thought is can we get the approval to use that space and then once that is we
3:47:52 will dive into the staffing the public partnerships that would be bringing programs into the facility.
3:48:02 also looking at opportunities where we would be able to have a funding source
3:48:09 based on the vendors that we bring into the facility. But once we get through that stage, we'll be happy to bring back a presentation to you on what that cost.
3:48:18 Okay. So, you would my other thought is so you want the city to fund it or you would be the main funding of it for the [clears throat] operating cost of it.
3:48:27 Would it be you wanted on the city to be the one that mainly pays for the operating or do you plan on having your
3:48:34 um vendors, your organizations to be the main one or you wanted a mix? What what is your thought on that?
3:48:40 Well, we're looking for the city to maintain their runnerup. When we looked at community centers in the city of Orlando
3:48:48 and Orange County, they are all maintained by the city and Orange County. They're staffed. their city or county staff.
3:48:57 So when we look at their model and how they have community centers in almost every one of their neighborhoods,
3:49:04 they also have public private partnerships that work with them.
3:49:09 But the centers themselves are either [clears throat] county staff, those are in Orange County, and the city staff, those that are in the city of Orlando.
3:49:17 And we were hoping that we had the vision to see the need to do the same thing for the city of Clermont. Okay.
3:49:28 Okay, Mr. Peterson, come on. Okay. Uh, first of all, I want to thank you for your presentation. It was very accurate. It was it's it
3:49:37 spelled out everything we need to do, and I'm all for community centers, but we've been talking about this for years, seven, and I think we we need to get
3:49:45 get on with it by getting it to the next phase. So, I'm in all in favor of moving it on from McKenna Park. at least get this thing going up and running.
3:49:54 Obviously, we got to go into all the nuts and bolts about where we're gonna build it, whether it's gonna have a baseball field or not. I think with the baseball field, I think that's not
3:50:02 really big enough because I think you need at least three to 400 feet to the outfield. So, you don't want to have balls going into cars. That would be a
3:50:10 bad thing. And how high a fence can you really build? But at any rate, that's really the nuts and bolts of it. I think it's important that we we do take our
3:50:18 first step, get it in motion so that we can be a council that doesn't talk about it anymore, that we can put it into
3:50:25 action. So, that's how I feel about it right now. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. It's strange.
3:50:31 I'm going to be that girl. It's a softball field so everybody knows. Um and yes, the boys
3:50:40 can also play on it. um up to 12, but girls can play on it until up to 89.
3:50:46 Like that's that's we can play on it our whole lives. So, not important. Um I'm from McKenna Park. It makes total sense being next to the school. I think it's a
3:50:54 great location. It's been clearly been the one that's been requested from the community that there's no doubt it's a community park. In my mind, it's a no-brainer.
3:51:03 [snorts]
3:51:12 and I think that's a detail that will be obvious as we go through the planning process. As far as timeline and accountability, I'm going to propose to
3:51:22 this council that we designate McKenna Park that we empower the Lincoln Park Alliance to put together a business plan
3:51:29 and a concept plan and to bring that to us by July 1st of 2027 so that when we go into budget cycle 28,
3:51:37 we have a business plan and ideas of what this might look like, what it might cost. Um, I'm willing to earmark or
3:51:45 designate strange. Do I get a chance to have anything to say before you start all designating all that?
3:51:51 Yeah, my time's not up. I'm not making a motion. Okay.
3:51:53 I'm willing to earmark um a million dollars from our parks and recreation fund. We have 11 million right now um
3:52:02 towards earmarking it so that the alliance can seek matching funds and partnerships and show us what that might look like come July. I have a feeling
3:52:11 you can take that million and turn it into a lot in the way of commitments. Of that million, [snorts] I would be willing to um support
3:52:19 spending 50,000 for professional services and design work. I also would recommend that we allocate 10,000 from
3:52:26 the development and design center so that you can come up with a really cool vision for this and how it might connect. I think parking and some of the things that you're worried about aren't
3:52:34 going to matter so much when it's a community center. A lot of people I imagine are going to golf cart. They're going to walk. Like that's the point.
3:52:42 You know, people can get there some parking, but I think those details will be sorted out over the next nine months.
3:52:48 And then um I would be looking for Lincoln Park Alliance to drive this and work with staff and have these resources
3:52:56 allocated. So, as I'm sitting here today, I'm willing to say to move forward with Mckin Park, allocating a million,
3:53:05 50,000 can be spent for design services, 10,000 from the development design center so that you have the resources you need to put a plan together and then
3:53:12 to bring us that plan by July, I'm going to say 1st of 2027 because that's when we start our budget cycle. I think that's a good idea.
3:53:20 That's where I'm at. Does that feel like what you're looking for?
3:53:23 Feels good. And we're ready to step up and that will work with you if that works for you with what she just suggested if we all approve of that.
3:53:32 Yes. Okay. Um those are my comments. Thank you, Alex.
3:53:40 Alex, I noticed uh you didn't bring any any concept or where we uh what it can look like if we put a to put the community
3:53:48 center on Highland Avenue. What is there a reason why?
3:53:51 I wasn't asked to. I could bring you wasn't asked to.
3:53:53 No, sir. even though and and for full disclosure, I was one of the founding members of the South Lake uh Lincoln Park South Lake Alliance as well. So, I
3:54:01 used to be on the board and everything with them, but um I [clears throat] met with them with the city manager and everything a few months ago, uh
3:54:09 February, March and April or so, and we offered the piece of land over there behind Highland. Okay. U so I'm just curious why why we didn't
3:54:17 I I did look at that site. It's considerably smaller than this one, but they didn't ask me to do a they just had took asked me to take a quick look at it and ask me if what I had designed previously we could put on that site.
3:54:28 Um Okay. But I did they didn't ask me to put a layout on it.
3:54:33 Okay. But what I'm looking at here in this proposal that's on this here Yes, sir.
3:54:37 It's actually that area that you proposing to use pretty much is smaller than what Highland is now that you leave in the B softball
3:54:45 field. Um it by by acreage this is 4.2 and from what I saw I thought that other site was smaller than this.
3:54:54 It's 4.2 with the whole hill whole field. But if you just take out the portion where you got all the buildings and everything you come down that that
3:55:02 is about as large as that section is about as large as Highland which is just under three acres. Okay. Um could be. Yes.
3:55:09 Here's the other thing. I'm just curious. I I would like to see some concepts of what what you can put over there. over there as well. Um, if I may,
3:55:19 uh, Brian, yeah.
3:55:34 How much use did this this upper area of McKenna Park get?
3:55:38 We had just under 300 reservations of that field uh, fiscal year that just ended. 36 different groups rented it.
3:55:48 Okay. So, and here's the other problem.
3:55:51 If we were to do this, where going back to what Mr. Bane said earlier, where is this open space going to be? Where can
3:55:58 we put those kids that's coming up there practicing soccer, uh, football, uh, this open space running?
3:56:07 Where where where can we put them based on the design there? It would be on the smaller field. I would
3:56:14 smallest snail fell where I'm not I don't know I don't know the distance of those of that fence that I'm looking at it.
3:56:21 I think it was the other design that you had. It's 200 feet.
3:56:24 Well, either design doesn't basically you're taking away all the open and green space from the kids that's very much utilized right now.
3:56:33 Mayor, I would and it's going back to what Mr. Bane said. Okay. I'm I'm If do you want to do this with McKenna Park?
3:56:41 Can we make open space on Highland? Even though I would prefer seeing Highland as a community center because it's easier access uh than this congested area here.
3:56:54 And may I The first thing is [laughter] I'm this is the first I'm seeing this plan. So, well, it's my first seeing it.
3:57:01 I'm not I'm not part of that. But um I can say that
3:57:06 if uh gator sketch Alex if they're the if they're going to design it if I
3:57:13 worked with them on a plan for the property I could probably if there's some open minds and
3:57:22 it might cost a little more. If there's some open minds, I could probably get that field a bit bigger. But, um, I could work with I could work with them
3:57:30 on that to see what we could do differently with the layout of the property if that's the space that council wants to go forward with.
3:57:39 Well, you know, I I I've been fighting for a community center in here for for almost 15 years.
3:57:46 Okay. So, it's not the fact that I don't want a community center. I just don't think McKenna Park is the right place.
3:57:51 Um, I think we we'll be uh we'll be defeating going back to Miss Strange and her her vision of having a
3:58:00 park within five minutes of everybody house. When you do this, we just eliminated a park. Okay. So now, where
3:58:08 those folks in that area going to have a park at? Unless we tie back into Highland Avenue. Okay.
3:58:15 McKenna Park has been there and it's been a historical park for years. Okay.
3:58:20 And I hate to see it because it is so well utilized by our kids. And here's the other problem we have. Uh Alex, did
3:58:28 you take into consideration that little narrow street and access the people uh in uh what we will be doing improaching upon the quality of life of those people
3:58:35 up there? Because right now it's so congested up there. You can only probably get one car up and down that road at a time. I mean, it's very, very congested. Did we look at any of that?
3:58:46 We haven't done a traffic study or I mean I wasn't I mean I'm here pro bono doing my best to fulfill the vision for
3:58:53 the alliance and I we purposely kept the traffic uh as as it was so we wouldn't affect people that aren't used to having
3:59:01 traffic uh on the site. So uh beyond that the amount of congestion in that area I can't really answer to it.
3:59:09 Well I I can I can talk to it because I'm up there on a regular basis. I pass that park. A matter of fact, I sit in my yard. I look down at that park on a regular basis. Okay. Uh it's congested.
3:59:20 I was up there a couple of weeks ago and fire department had to answer 911 call and they couldn't even turn the truck around. They had to had to actually have a sparter to back it all the way out.
3:59:31 Okay. Um here's the other thing and I'm in agreement with Mr. Bane here. Fine.
3:59:36 If we want to do this, can any kind of way we can go back and tie in Highlands that we can have some green space for these kids to run around? Basically, we
3:59:44 eliminating all the green space right now, open field area, uh, with this here. And I also noticed in the package,
3:59:52 we got a lot of letter support that they just handed us and everything, but I don't see anything from any support from any of the residents in the community
4:00:00 because when I talk to the community, most of them tell me that isn't what they want.
4:00:05 I even asked the South Lake Lounge to go and have a community meeting and ask the residents what they want. That haven't happened. Okay. That has not happened.
4:00:16 Okay.
4:00:17 Mr. Mayor, if if I may, I think that a lot of what we're talking about and and the concerns that you're raising, valid concerns, are what would come up over,
4:00:25 you know, what I've proposed as a nine-month process of engaging the community to I that would be part of the process is going through the design
4:00:33 phase and coming up with that business plan. Um, I would suggest that we're not going to have those answers here tonight. And I don't think tonight we're approving a $5 million project. tonight.
4:00:43 The question is, we've been approached by a community group to take the lead on coming up with a business plan for us,
4:00:50 and that's what I'm hearing. And so, I think your questions are valid, but I don't think they're going to be answered tonight.
4:00:56 That's true. And and I I will u politely ask this counter before this council before we make consideration and and a
4:01:04 decision to put it in Mckini Park, we go back and we look at Highland Avenue and see what we can put on there. Because what I'm looking at here basically the
4:01:12 space they using here on this diagram is is avenue as much and the other thing I have I'm sorry and I said this to you
4:01:19 before and uh you have to have vision and look at thing if I put that in there and the city keep growing we need to
4:01:26 expand where you going to expand. I got opportunity if I put it on Highland Avenue with Wind Dix sitting there we can probably go out and we got uh in the
4:01:33 future we got room to expand. You got easy access. You got the bus line coming down Highway 50 that can kids can take
4:01:40 the bus to uh the community center be dropped off on Highway 50 right there.
4:01:46 And if you want to worry about being close to the school, you're only a block block and a half away from the school anyway.
4:01:51 Yeah. And I don't want to belver the point or cause the point of order here.
4:01:54 Um, but I do I am I am fairly confident that if we ask our uh parks and recck director, we'll find that most of those
4:02:02 36 organizations that are renting McKenna Park aren't in fact from Lincoln Park. And so I think that speaks to one of the concerns that we've been talking
4:02:10 about, which is having a city-wide plan for parks and recreation, which which our parks and recreation director is working on. And I think what that might
4:02:18 mean is that we may need more soccer fields, more diamonds in other parts of the city so that children don't have to
4:02:25 take the bus to get to the Lincoln Park Community Center, but in fact they can walk from their own home or bike from their own home. And so I think that is
4:02:33 part of this process. And I'm not saying Highland isn't an option. I think that we should be looking at every piece of property the city owns, but I don't
4:02:40 think that is part of what the ask is here tonight. And so I would like us to stay on track for for the ask that's
4:02:49 before us understanding that what you're talking about is a vision and we need to have that. So you know I would I would ask that we move on.
4:02:57 Well as as I say I would just like to I brought it.
4:03:00 I would like I would like to say that uh we asked them to go back Mr. Alice go back and see what what kind of uh we can do with with Highland Avenue as well.
4:03:11 Gladly.
4:03:12 Okay. Before we before we make that decision, we need, as you say, explore every avenue. And going back, as you always say about parks and everything, we f to kill a park right now. Okay.
4:03:24 See, I don't see it that way. I I do because where's the green space? Where's the area to run around?
4:03:30 I I think that you'll find there's a lot more green space once they go through this process because I don't think you're going to need all that parking.
4:03:36 Oh, yeah. You're going to need to Well, well, well, we're the city. We don't have to meet requirements. So, you're right. and everything.
4:03:43 Well, I think it's going to be for the community. So, most of the people are going to be coming there by foot or by bike.
4:03:49 That That's what I imagine. I don't know until we go through it. I don't know, but we're not going to find it out tonight.
4:03:54 No, we got to get our first step.
4:03:56 Yeah. Can we You go ahead and make the motion unless there's other comments. Mr. Bane might We normally have a rebuttal.
4:04:10 the parking that's for Lake Tech and for um the Lincoln Park Education Center.
4:04:17 Who owns that land right now? Is that uh is that school board? No. Or is that city? City owned.
4:04:24 Okay. So, and that's approximately how far from this location? Which?
4:04:30 Across the street. Yeah. Right. The the parking it's just upsom, right? Isn't it just one block up? So, I think to to the
4:04:39 point of the parking concern, I think there might be some ability to capitalize on some of that parking
4:04:47 there, particularly when classes aren't in session at Lincoln Park Education Center or at Lake Tech for any kind of
4:04:56 overflow parking or additional parking for the community center. So that as we go through this business plan design
4:05:04 plan timeline that we we whoever is designing if whether it's uh the the
4:05:11 gentleman from Gator Sketch or or other that we could you know factor that in and look at that and see what times those lots are used and what time we
4:05:19 think the lots might be fully utilized by the community center and how can we capitalize in that. Um the the only
4:05:28 other thing I'll say I I I think what uh what we have before us to to propose to
4:05:35 say we've looked at this location as our preferred location doesn't prohibit us from
4:05:43 getting an alternative site as well as a part of that. um but that if this is the preferred location
4:05:51 um here are the things that we need before July 1 and here are the things that we're providing in order for that
4:06:00 to make that happen which is um some allocations of of funding and um design
4:06:08 center um and and basically start I don't want to call it seed money but start the process to be able to to go
4:06:16 out into the to the public private sector to be able to find those partnerships and be able to show that the city's investing in a community
4:06:23 center in the Lincoln Park area. They've identified this McKini Park spot as the preferred spot, but we're moving forward
4:06:32 with a community center in the Lincoln Park center in the Lincoln Park area.
4:06:35 Um, my only ask to uh to complement that motion would be to also include the
4:06:43 Highland Avenue location um to be uh designed and designated to
4:06:50 be a park green space open space area um and you know um provide whatever additional funding in this motion that
4:06:59 we need to start that process to make that happen in conjunction with this because I do recognize that we are
4:07:06 whether we take out some parking or not eliminating some green space and we have that other existing space. I think we can tie these two things together and it
4:07:15 doesn't have to be uh just this or just this miss Mars.
4:07:24 Um I like us to move forward with the plans for McKenna Park and that's where I'm at on it.
4:07:33 Mr. Peterson, I think we're we're belaboring this point uh talking about minutia constantly and I think either we we need to move forward with this.
4:07:45 She put so much effort into this. I don't want to just put that aside. So I think it's important that we we get this going. We're talking about next July. So
4:07:55 we're not talking about we're going to be doing this tomorrow. So I just want to get the motion. You know, we could say, "Yeah, let's build it." Let this
4:08:02 person came up with really good solutions. Had people do proono work to design it. This isn't a final design.
4:08:09 This is just a conceptual design. We can make different changes constantly in this, but we need to get move. We've been talking about community centers
4:08:17 forever, years and years and every council. Oh yeah, we got to talk about it later. Let's move it over to this place. We can always talk about other
4:08:25 places. That's what procrastinates the whole motion because we constantly don't agree. Let's agree that we need a
4:08:32 community center, which is number one, and now we have a place that we could start our design, and by July, we'll know exactly what it's going to cost,
4:08:40 how it's going to get funded, and everything else that any other questions we might have at that time. So, I'd like to make a motion to get the ball
4:08:48 rolling, get this started, and get whatever necessary things have to be done. Okay, Miss Strange.
4:09:00 I think I can put a motion together that addresses everyone's concerns.
4:09:04 Okay, go for it. Any other comments, Mr. Mayor?
4:09:12 Okay. Um, I move that we direct staff to work with the Lincoln Park Alliance to come up with a plan for community center
4:09:20 at McKenna Park. that we allocate a million dollars from our parks and recck impact fee fund as a commitment
4:09:28 earmarked for the community center so that the Lincoln Park Alliance can seek matching funds that we allow the Lincoln
4:09:36 Park Alliance or staff to use 50,000 of the million for professional services that we allocate an additional 10,000
4:09:44 from the development design center to go towards design services and that the Lincoln Park Alliance bring us a proposed
4:09:52 concept and business plan on July 1st of 2027 for the community center at McKenna Park while also conducting a survey of
4:09:59 the residents of Lincoln Park to see what other needs might be necessary or accommodated at the Highlands Avenue site.
4:10:08 I can second that.
4:10:09 What What is the U [laughter] Highland? Anything on the Highland? I don't think I don't think we have enough information to know what should be at
4:10:17 Highlands, but the motion proposes that there be a survey asking the residents what might be appropriate at that site so they can bring it back to us and we
4:10:25 can make a decision, an informed decision.
4:10:31 Well, I think we uh like I say with losing the green space there, I think we need to
4:10:40 also go back and add in into that motion that they they do a they go back and they can do a rendition of what kind of community center they can put over there
4:10:47 as well. Uh turn it into green space uh because we're losing green space uh here with this park. And Miss Miss Strange, I
4:10:56 find it very strange that uh uh that with your old commitment to parks
4:11:04 and everything, we going to eliminate a park or green spout park and when we do this, no one where where's the closest
4:11:11 park to the people in this community. We don't have it. You'll remember your survey, sir. And that is the best way to
4:11:19 find out what programming is necessary for the residents of the park. We have been approached by people who have been asking for seven years for a thing. She
4:11:27 has not been heard for seven years. As a person who has sat in that audience and talked to government agencies for years as a professional,
4:11:36 I I don't I am not going to insult her by suggesting I know more than she does about what she needs in her community. I
4:11:44 have asked her to conduct a survey so that we can have that information. Staff can be part of that process. there's nothing precluding us from doing a
4:11:53 different design. She might get into this and say, "You know what? I was wrong. We need to spend that 50,000 on the Highlands property." She might say
4:12:01 that and I believe that she has the integrity to come back and say, "I was wrong. We need to put it at Highlands.
4:12:07 That's what the residents want and I trust that she'll do that." Well, Miss M. Strange, like I say, in March, April when I met with him, I
4:12:14 asked them to do that. Same thing is do have a community forum. I've spoken with a lot of the people in the community and I know what they've told me. They don't
4:12:22 want to see McKenna Park. Uh they think the better place for it is Highland. Um they work too hard. Most of the people in the community work too hard to get
4:12:30 McKenna car. We had to we had to go through a lot of changes to get that park. Okay. And now you want to tear it up and so many kids are utilizing that.
4:12:38 Okay. Uh and a couple of people told me that she did talk to them and they expressed the fact that they didn't want they didn't want McKenna the park torn up. Okay.
4:12:47 With all due respect, mayor, yeah, I have not talked to one person in Lincoln Park that have told me that they do not.
4:12:55 Just like you said, you have talked to people to say that they don't want it there.
4:12:59 I have talked to several who said that they do want it there.
4:13:03 There was a group on the park the other day.
4:13:06 We quizzed them, do you want a community center? And the teenagers all said, if we had a community center, we would have
4:13:14 something to do, right? there will be opportunities. So just like you said, you have talked to people and they have said that they don't. I have asked you who are those people.
4:13:23 I can tell you the people that I have talked to that live in Lincoln Park that have said they want the community center on
4:13:30 Lincoln Park. I'm not saying take away the opportunity for green space, but I think providing an opportunity for
4:13:38 children, for adults, and for seniors to grow educationally,
4:13:45 financially is will serve them in the long run than it would being able to kick a ball
4:13:54 on the soccer field. That's just my opinion. If I can provide an an opportunity for someone to have a hand up instead of a hand out to where we can
4:14:03 provide programs to them that we can do wraparound services for them. I would rather move in that direction than to
4:14:10 worry about whether a child has a bill to kick a soccer ball or play baseball.
4:14:15 You're looking at the future opportunity.
4:14:17 Well, see, and I guess that's my problem. I do have a vision for the kid to be able to kick a soccer. Can we have a vote on this?
4:14:24 Okay. Yeah. Can we call the question? We have a motion. Was there a second? Yes.
4:14:29 Yes. [laughter] Have a motion in second.
4:14:32 Um my only ask on the motion um is I'd like to make a a amendment to the motion
4:14:40 to earmark the property on Highland Avenue as a park.
4:14:49 We're going to have the survey. We're going to find out what they want and need for that. that I still think we need to designate and earmark that
4:14:56 location as a park so that nothing can happen in in between. Okay.
4:15:01 So that we're earmarking it as a park location. Um and we're saying we're going to get this information back by July 1.
4:15:10 Nothing else can happen in that area until we know what's going on with that survey. I can Yeah, I can support that.
4:15:15 So I I'd just like to make that uh amendment to the motion. You okay with that, Miss Strange?
4:15:20 Are you okay with that, Alison? I don't understand what you mean by that.
4:15:24 Okay. So, we're we're they're doing a survey on what what the community might want for that space, right?
4:15:30 My concern is that if we don't designate that as park space, we don't have to say that it's active, passive, any
4:15:38 combination. It's going to be park space that we're earmarking it as park space.
4:15:43 Nothing else can happen to that location then during this survey.
4:15:48 What else would be there's nothing happening. It's not being We have a We have an agenda item here tonight of an unsolicited bid. We could get another unsolicited bid for this
4:15:56 property. We can surplus. We We can still get a bid.
4:16:00 It doesn't need to be surplused in order to take Yeah. So, we I I think we I think we just need to say we're we're earmarking
4:16:06 this right now as a as a park space and and we're not doing anything with it that's not park related until we get
4:16:15 this information back and then we can determine what we do moving forward from there. Okay.
4:16:27 Okay. Strange, you okay?
4:16:31 I don't know. It feels it doesn't it's collapsing issues and I don't know if it's something I need to fight at 710 at
4:16:38 night after being here this long. Um I don't I don't think it's a park space and I think that we should be
4:16:46 considering if we're worried about that property which hasn't come on the radar.
4:16:50 I think that it should be considered on its own merits and not tied to the ask that's before us tonight. it it has a feeling of bad governance and like
4:16:59 there's something else going on that I don't understand because this property has only come up in in the context of
4:17:06 competing with what the citizens have asked us for. And so that's where I'm coming from. And and if we're saying we won't take further action on the
4:17:14 Highland property until this is resolved, I can get there. But to designate it a park space, I it I don't I don't like the feel. I
4:17:23 don't I'm not inclined to change my motion. I don't like the feel and that's okay because I'm making an amendment to the motion which I actually
4:17:31 need just needs a second and a vote to go into the motion. Um and so if there's if there is another council member who
4:17:39 supports the idea of earmarking it as a park for the time being, then they can
4:17:46 second that motion and we vote on that and if it passes, it becomes a part of the motion. If it doesn't, it doesn't.
4:17:53 Okay. Is there a second on Mr. Bane amendment?
4:18:04 And no second. We have a motion uh to proceed with McKenna Park as I
4:18:12 don't know which call for the vote.
4:18:18 I'm assuming we we going to look at the one that's before us. We're going to proceed with this one. This proposal that's before as proposed as this second proposal um and not the first. Okay.
4:18:29 As moved. All right.
4:18:33 Any further questions? Any further discussion? All in favor be known by saying I. I. I. All oppose. In front chair vote nay.
4:18:42 Motion carried 4 to one. Thank you. Thank you.
4:18:53 Item number 20, sale of city property at 650 West Montro Street
4:19:06 Council. Uh, we have a Tracy, do you need to read anything or are we good?
4:19:11 Cool. Uh October 2023, council purchased 650 West Montros for approximately $785,000
4:19:19 to be used for fire administration offices. Additional renovations took place, putting the total investment at
4:19:24 $1.2 million uh is uh fire personnel made a pivot and is now occupying the space at 12th Street Fire Training Complex.
4:19:34 Uh July 26, 2026, the city of Clermont received an unsolicited proposal from Clermont Main Street to purchase the
4:19:41 property. Uh in accordance with Florida statutes, the city advertised the offer uh gave competitive bid windows so that
4:19:49 we had to advertise twice and then we also had to post in the Florida register. Uh we've received no additional offers.
4:19:58 Uh, Clermont Main Street is proposing a financing structure to include a bank loan for $650,000 and a promisory note for the remainder of the purchase price.
4:20:07 Uh, Clermont Main Street is requesting the city note carry no payments of principal or interest until the two frontage pads are sold. Proceeds of the
4:20:16 sale of the two frontage pads will pay off the city note.
4:20:20 Uh, Clermont Main Street is offering the following enforceable protections. a restrictive covenant recorded at closing requiring that the existing building be
4:20:28 used for downtown revitalization, civic welcome center or compatible office uh purchases for not
4:20:36 uses uses. Thank you so much. Uh for not less than 10 years and a repurchase option in favor of the city exercisable if
4:20:44 Clermont Main Street ceases the covenant in use or transfer the property other than as permitted before the city note is retired. And now I'm going to
4:20:53 kick it over to our economic development director to show some of the designs for the frontage parcels.
4:21:02 Yes. Uh Nathan Norris, director of economic development. I would just wanted to show a couple images when they talked about the front two parcels. Uh
4:21:11 the image on the left obviously is how it looks today. You can see the huge investment the city's made there to revitalize Montrose. One of our
4:21:19 challenges on this block across the street from the city hall is that we have two suburban buildings in an urban place. That undermines the vibrancy of
4:21:28 the downtown. It undermines the ability of this block to be invested in by others until we cure the problem. The problem is that in a downtown area, you
4:21:38 want the street to feel like an outdoor room. It's got to have a sense of enclosure. So that's why we see the the
4:21:44 um the image on the right right there shows uh what those two buildings could be. Um as set out in their proposal, um
4:21:53 these two pads essentially support buildings that could be up to three stories that are uh effectively 24 feet
4:22:01 by 24 feet square boxes. That's approximate size of an accessory dwelling unit or a garage apartment. And
4:22:08 that's what's envisioned here to uh not only provide a sense of enclosure on this street that will allow people to feel much more comfortable walking along
4:22:16 here and have a dignified uh uh uh uh look across from the city hall. But it also has these small spaces where
4:22:25 essentially what could be envisioned is some sort of commercial use on the first floor. Once again, this is smallcale entrepreneurship. These are local
4:22:32 entrepreneurs that'd be going in here because of the space limitations. And then you'd uh want to have some residential use because one of the
4:22:39 downsides right now although it will be changing is having more residential in the downtown right on the streets. The
4:22:47 importance of that is simply having eyes on the street so that when you're walking outside when it's dark out you won't feel like oh uh oh I'm in no man's
4:22:54 land. Nobody's here to see me if something bad goes wrong. So here you could have a effectively a twostory uh
4:23:02 unit um on the upper two floors where the second floor where you see the balconies are where you have a uh a big
4:23:09 living room essentially and kitchen and and public area and then up on the third floor is where you can have you know your bedroom and other things. So these buildings end up being really important.
4:23:19 So the thing that we're looking at I guess we can go to the next page you can see it could be any number of different looks. These are some of the different
4:23:26 ways that it was conceived of. Uh ultimately ended up on the bottom right hand corner if you remember because we were calling them Montro twins and then
4:23:35 we called them Clare and Monty which are the the the fraternal twins on the bottom right. So there's all sorts of different ways that you can skin the
4:23:43 cap, but the the the larger idea and you can see the existing building behind them is that this changes the feel of the street almost immediately. So this
4:23:51 is very important not just on this parcel but more importantly on its impact upon the surrounding properties.
4:23:58 We've got a property directly to our east over here that's essentially underdeveloped for what that can be.
4:24:05 We've got um other property on the the west side that's similarly situated. So the impact upon this shouldn't be just
4:24:12 what's happening on this parcel. should be the impact that occurs um on adjacent parcels and more importantly not the
4:24:18 impact of the sale immediately but the impact of the sale over 20 or 30 years.
4:24:24 That's how you know if we buy a home in Clermont, we don't look at it. What's it worth just today? We usually say, is this going to be a good deal for us down
4:24:31 the road? And I I would hope that the city looks at it from that perspective.
4:24:35 In this case, instead of just looking at the purchase price or the terms, look at what what are we likely to get in return over the next 20 or 30 years and then decide whether it's a good deal or not.
4:24:46 That's all I had to say. You have something else. Thank you.
4:24:53 This is a public forum. Anyone in the public wish to address this item may come to the microphone and state your name and address and have uh three minutes.
4:25:03 Anyone in the chamber wish to address this item may come to the microphone and state your name and address and have three minutes.
4:25:12 Valerie Shu at 931 West Montro Street.
4:25:14 Um I think obviously I love Clermont Main Street. I'm very familiar with the good work that they do down here in
4:25:22 downtown. So, um I think when it comes to best uses for a building like this and great nonprofit partners, you know, it's kind of right there in front of
4:25:30 you. Um but on another note, what I love about the way that they've structured the proposal is we kind of are
4:25:37 guaranteed this this good development right here. It's a way to get some really good development and have some guarantees around that it is going to be
4:25:44 good development. So, thank you. Anyone else? Anyone else?
4:25:53 Seeing no one else in the chamber, I'll close down the public comment in the chamber. Anyone online, sir? Yes, sir. We got a couple online.
4:26:00 First call online. Go ahead. Jenny, you're up.
4:26:08 Hey, this is J. Brian Miles again uh speaking on behalf of Clmont Main Street. I'm a board member and want to
4:26:15 encourage um the council to consider the opportunity for Clermont Main Street to purchase the property across from city
4:26:23 hall. I think that over the years there's been a lot of discussion as to what um could be done as far as you know welcome center uh some business
4:26:31 incubation some different things like that and I think in regards to Clermont Main Street a lot of people outside of the city events most people's first
4:26:40 contact with the city of Clermont actually comes to Clermont Main Street and uh you know not to toot our own horn
4:26:47 but cover your ears um we do a pretty good job and we've been pretty consistent at it too and I I think that the future development of Clermont Main
4:26:55 Street, our ability to expand to actually have a a home in the heart of downtown um would be a great thing. Um
4:27:03 you have one of the best developers in the area who's our president, you know, kind of championing this issue. I just
4:27:12 think there's so many positive things that could come out of us being able to work with the city and developing that property to what it really could be. And
4:27:20 the benefit really is for the residents and the visitors. So my hope is that um that you guys will consider this um that
4:27:27 you will go along with kind of um what staff has presented to you guys as this being a positive thing and give us a chance to explore the option of
4:27:36 purchasing this and working with you guys to make better. That's all. And I apologize for the background noise. I'm at a different meeting now. So but thank you for uh allowing me to speak.
4:27:48 Thank you, Jenny. You're up.
4:27:52 Thank you, Jenny May. 4062 Greystone Drive. Um, placemaking, check. Visionary, check.
4:28:03 Um, welcome center, very needed. I think it's a great idea. Check. Highest and best use. Absolutely.
4:28:11 The highest and best use. Getting tired of seeing that parking lot so empty. um benefits for the community. Absolutely.
4:28:19 Um one of the best ideas I've seen in a while. So um congratulations. Great idea. Main Street, thank you so much for bringing this to downtown.
4:28:32 And that's it, Mr. Mayor.
4:28:34 That's it. Thank you. We'll close public comment. Bring it back to the council. What say you, Mr. Bank?
4:28:41 Um thank you, Mr. Mayor. Uh, were you presenting? I I was going to uh if if that's okay.
4:28:49 Um, Patrick Bianke, one10 West Montrose.
4:28:52 I am the Clermont Main Street President. Um, I think it's important to talk about the genesis of how this came
4:28:58 to be. Um, it is no secret that Main Street has been looking for a permanent home. Um, we started uh our discussions
4:29:07 at the historic village. Um there was many months of conversations, meetings, various things, staff with them, so on.
4:29:14 We were going to enter into a tripartite agreement. That did not happen. Um for various reasons, okay, we we support
4:29:20 them. They support us. Um then as this building was being discussed for the
4:29:27 various uses, uh and Mr. Bane, you weren't on council at the time, but there was a discussion as to, you know, is this building going to be surplus?
4:29:35 What is it going to be used for? And so on. the city council decided to surplus it. I went to my board. We had many different discussions because at the
4:29:43 time this was a pretty big undertaking uh for us. We've evolved greatly since then. And do we want to take a stab at this building? A stab which meant a a
4:29:52 proposal request to to purchase this building to be uh more of a partner uh with our community and with the city.
4:30:00 And it's kind of that civic corner if you think about it. it's nearest what is now I call it the KBY center David Kobe
4:30:08 in the chamber and what they do there and then of course city hall across the street. Um so that was a decision. We're
4:30:15 a board of 15. We have 14 uh voting members comprised of many different talents uh backgrounds and so on which
4:30:22 includes you know thank you Jay. Yes I'm a developer and a real estate broker but we also have a great architect which is Jeff Powell and we have many different
4:30:30 real estate professionals on our board including our exeicio. I mean, so there's there's so many different unique characters that are a part of this that have the capability and skills to carry on just beyond a purchase of a building.
4:30:43 Um, the discussion is is Clermont Main Street a developer? You know, we had this discussion in our board meeting. Do we want to be in the business to develop? Uh, when we had our original
4:30:52 resolution, we had discussed just asset purchase in a [clears throat] way to be able to pay back the city because this currently is in your general fund. So, I
4:31:00 believe it's like, you know, 1.2 and change. um that is sitting in your general fund, taxpayer dollars that are spent on this structure that has
4:31:07 remained empty for a couple years. So, I know that we can discuss the mechanics of that, but ideally, no, we don't have $1.2 million to spend um just to give
4:31:16 you, but this is a creative way one that we we can actually purchase this. United Southern Bank, which sits on our board,
4:31:23 um has offered and provided us a term sheet to purchase at the 650 and then the the city would have a secondary
4:31:31 note. Um, and we did put a three-year deferral on it. I say deferral, not free of interest. Um, and it's more of that
4:31:38 again that community partnership. And they agreed to relinquish the secondary junior position if we were to sell the
4:31:46 the first two parcels, which is part of our proposal. The idea is that we would separate each individual parcel and then
4:31:54 we would provide you the money and you would be paid back as a whole. Um, we can get into the mechanics of that, but that in general is the genesis of what
4:32:02 happened to where we are today. Um, and we did have a follow-up meeting, you know, pretty much them designating my ability to come and speak on behalf of
4:32:09 Clermont Main Street and negotiate the terms in which may be discussed here tonight. So, that's all I have to say.
4:32:18 Thank you, Mr. Bank. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Thank you.
4:32:22 Thank you. Um, so I'm I'm reading the the staff at the requested action. It's it says staff is
4:32:29 seeking direction on on um this proposal.
4:32:34 And so I I'm reading that literally in the sense that we're providing direction for staff of what to do. And I think
4:32:43 that um we are not in a position to make any decisions tonight on actually uh
4:32:52 agreeing to uh a proposal because staff has had this this information for 3
4:33:00 months and our packet has nothing from staff in it. There's no responses to any of the items in in here where you where
4:33:08 Clermont Main Street has asked our city attorney to opine. We have n we have none of that information from where this if our attorney agrees or doesn't agree
4:33:17 to those terms. Um we have no information as to whether or not um this
4:33:24 structure is legally sound or what what you know and an understanding of what position it puts the city in for that.
4:33:32 Um, and so I I'm just concerned that we don't have all the information that we
4:33:38 need to make that decision because and the other part of it I wanted to say and we got it tonight in our supplemental packet, but we were I
4:33:46 thought pretty explicit in our direction to city staff at a meeting I think a couple uh meetings ago where we
4:33:55 said we we require an appraisal prior to making a decision. and we just got that tonight at 3:00. So, I I I haven't had a
4:34:04 chance to even look at this appraisal yet. Um, and I know that we indicated that we didn't want it to be dependent
4:34:12 upon, but we said we need to have the appraisal in hand in order for us to make these decisions. So, I I think we are premature in making a decision. I
4:34:21 think the direction needs to be given of what we need from staff in response to this information from Clermont Main
4:34:28 Street. the four tabs. Um, and I don't if we want to do that tonight and make the sausage, we can make the sausage here in the meeting, but I think it
4:34:36 probably would be better served for us to provide those questions to the city manager and the city attorney, get them answered and put this back on a future
4:34:44 agenda when we have it. Um, because one of the alternatives here, Mr. city attorney, if I'm not mistaken, is
4:34:52 couldn't we, because we own the parcel now, divide this into three parcels and and only sell off the one portion of
4:35:00 that, which is the the um building in the back, and then allow us to sell the the two other parcels and capture that money.
4:35:09 Yes.
4:35:09 Okay. So, I just think that there's a lot of things here that we just need to make sure we fully understand what we're doing with this parcel. I think the one
4:35:17 of the other questions that I've asked today is Clermont Main Streets indicated in here that it would be taxexempt, but I've heard from our city
4:35:25 attorney today that it may or may not be taxexempt. So, I think we need some clarity on whether or not it is actually taxexempt. Um
4:35:34 because quite frankly, Mr. Biaki, you stood right there and told us at this in this very chambers that using that building
4:35:42 for tax exempt purposes was the worst decision we could do when we considered putting city services over there.
4:35:48 Yeah. And so I I just want to make sure like I'm not saying we can't do it, but that's a shift in
4:35:57 what this council decided when they said we're going to surplus it and try to do it for
4:36:04 its highest and best. Um, and highest and best I think is probably more than just recouping what we put in because
4:36:12 those two parcels I have a strong suspicion based off of what's happening in downtown and based off my
4:36:21 professional experience are going to go for a lot more than $650,000 uh or generate uh potential uh sales revenue of additional than $650,000.
4:36:33 So, um I just I feel like we should be providing the direction of what we need from our staff in order to make this decision, not actually make a decision.
4:36:43 Thank you, Miss Meyers. I don't have any comment at this time.
4:36:49 Mr. Peterson, this property was surplus back in 2024
4:36:56 and we've been losing taxes on this property ever since. I don't even know what even if we can calculate that
4:37:03 dollar amount. And uh I know like initially it wasn't even you know we it was a couple maybe eight months ago that
4:37:13 we brought it up and oh we forgot that we did surplus and oh yeah it was it was like got you know it disappeared in
4:37:20 there. So now we have a viable offer, an offer that's that's going to give us tax revenue that's going to pay us back the
4:37:28 money in essence that we that you know the we we we put in uh it was originally we bought for 650. We put money into it,
4:37:37 but that didn't necessarily increase the value of the property. It increase the value if we were going to use it as a a fire substation, but that was it wasn't
4:37:46 like anything else. And I remember last time we let's rent it to, you know, sell it to a real estate a broker, a lawyer, something like that. But we it's been
4:37:54 surplus now for two years. We haven't had any offers for it. You know, you would think in two years we would had some offers. We haven't had any offers.
4:38:02 So now we we have an offer and uh and now we're saying, well, let's let's go into legal and see if this is legal. I
4:38:11 would imagine we've we've contacted our city attorney. Is that correct? Yeah. Yes, sir.
4:38:18 Okay. And sir, our city attorney has looked at this and if there was nothing that was uh inappropriate in this contract, or am I wrong?
4:38:28 I don't have a legal objection to it. No.
4:38:30 Okay, that's what I'm saying. So, there's no legal objection to it. And uh I don't see any reason why we shouldn't.
4:38:36 There isn't like a line of people out there that are ready to buy this piece of property and nobody else has come up with any kind of a venue to do it. So
4:38:45 with that, I think it's something we should entertain. Thank you, Miss Strange.
4:38:52 I won't keep us here all night. Um I have spent many hours looking into this, contemplating it.
4:39:00 There's been a lot for me that I have gone back and forth on this for all the reasons that both gentlemen have spoken
4:39:07 tonight. Uh where I'm at on this is a general feeling that I have that the government should not be in the
4:39:15 development business. I don't believe it's good practice for the government to speculate. I like good boring
4:39:22 government. And what I look at is the citizens of Clermont through the general fund have spent over 1.2 million
4:39:30 on this property. We have an offer that purports to be for 1.3 million. Pin that. I'm going to come back to it for a
4:39:37 second. So, for me looking at that and saying, "Okay, we can we have decided not to use it for the purpose for which
4:39:45 it was bought and we're able to get all of our money out of it and that to me is a win for the general fund and the citizens of Clermont. Now, we can
4:39:53 speculate on what it might be or what might happen if the downtown action plan is approved, if the code is approved,
4:40:00 but that would be speculation, and I don't think that's wise, especially in light of what I did see tonight in the appraisal that I don't think is
4:40:08 particularly good for the citizens of Clermont. If your offer still stands, I'm grateful for that. What I have come to terms with that I'm comfortable with
4:40:18 is moving forward with instructing staff to put together a contract.
4:40:25 But what I would like to see is that contract to go to the CRA because what I see is let me that
4:40:34 doesn't sound as bad as it came out of my mouth. What I would like to see is the longterm relationship relative to
4:40:41 this property. the payback over time, the management of the payments, the management of the interest. I would like to see that relationship on that note
4:40:50 between the CRA and its partner Main Street, not between the general fund and the CRA's partner Main Street. So, what
4:40:58 I would suggest, and I think Mr. Bane, you brought up a really good idea, is
4:41:03 [snorts]
4:41:03 instructing staff to put together a contract that addresses everybody's concerns. I don't want to make the sausage tonight.
4:41:12 know that's my opinion on that and see if the CRA would support buying the note
4:41:19 from the general fund. In other words, if we move forward with the sale, the city sells it to Main Street and takes
4:41:27 the note, but the note immediately at closing gets bought by the CRA. So, moving forward, any relationship and conversation is between the CRA and Main
4:41:36 Street and not the general fund and Main Street. Um, if we feel like we also want staff to explore splitting the property
4:41:45 and getting appraisals for what that might look like, I'm open to entertaining that as well. But I want to be very cautious that we're not
4:41:52 speculating. There's that expression, a bird in the hand is worth two in the bush, and I feel like we have a bird in the hand. So that's where I'm at.
4:42:04 Thank you.
4:42:06 Um, my main main concern is that is the financing. Okay. And I think I think you
4:42:14 kind of like just gave a [clears throat] solution to that because you you're saying you're offering us one point 1 1.3 million, but you want to uh do one
4:42:22 bank loan for 650,000, then want the city to carry a promisary note with no interest for 36 month. I have a problem
4:42:29 with that. And and I guess I need to ask the city attorney with the way I'm reading this, we sit in second seat, right?
4:42:37 Correct.
4:42:37 So if any if they were not to be able to uh if they were able to be foreclosed on their loan because they couldn't meet their loan, that mean the bank take
4:42:46 control of the property and we'll be hanging out there, right?
4:42:49 Potentially as as I see it now. But here's a relevant legal point that may factor into some of y'all's
4:42:57 calculations. Um on an unsolicited proposal, this is a very complicated statute. Okay.
4:43:06 Um even if you all move forward with the structure as proposed by Clermont Main Street, the next step would be the city,
4:43:15 perhaps the CRA and Clermont Main Street negotiating what's called a comprehensive agreement. Okay.
4:43:22 Okay. [snorts] So, uh that would have a lot of quote the sausage. Um, but it would detail all the mechanics. It could
4:43:30 conceivably incorporate all the material terms that Clermont Main Street has proposed, but it also could include some negotiation on what you're talking
4:43:39 about, mayor. In other words, and I don't know if Clermont Main Street's open to this. I don't know if uh USB is open to it, but it could be that there's
4:43:46 certain conditions on which they would agree to not have us take a bath in second position. In second.
4:43:53 Yeah. Um and so anyways talking out loud but yeah well well and I guess that's my question
4:44:00 and that's what I would u recommend uh propose myself instead of us taking second seat we be in first seat okay and
4:44:08 that way if they don't meet if they have to be foreclosed on it uh we we still in in our position okay right now with the
4:44:16 way I'm reading this if they were happen to not meet the obligation and be foreclosed on it we the city going to lose out on period
4:44:25 if there's not enough if if the equity doesn't if the value of the property is not enough right see so uh because we sitting in
4:44:32 second seat so if they were where if you were to flip them and the city is sitting in first seat uh I can probably support it a little bit more okay uh but
4:44:41 right now the way it is the financing of it the way it's right up financing I think it put the city in a very bad place then you're asking us to carry your promisary note for 36 months Okay.
4:44:53 With no interest or anything.
4:44:55 [clears throat] So, and I'm like, uh, and that kind of defeat our purpose. And the reason I'm concerned with that is because you asking for 600 to finance
4:45:04 $650,000, but every year for the last four or five years, we've been giving Main Street $70,000.
4:45:10 Okay. So, we already we kind of like I look at it like the city is almost uh buying it anyway. Just giving it all to you.
4:45:18 Yeah. I think so our money when we giving you this money and then you want to ask us not to charge you any interest
4:45:25 for six month for 36 months that's a that's a tall ask. Okay. But if we can redo something with the financing
4:45:33 and everything else I I I can support right and [clears throat] and mainly I guess if we flipped it and we uh city go in first seat [snorts] instead of second seat so we don't have to take a loss in case it's a foreclosure.
4:45:45 May I May I respond? May I? Um, what I would say about the the property as far as the deference and the three years, I
4:45:53 mean there there's plenty of examples within the city where the city doesn't charge anything for somebody to occupy and historic village being one. I mean,
4:46:02 you know, they've occupied that space for more than a decade at no cost essentially. Um, and so I I I think the
4:46:10 three-year deference is reasonable. And the only reason why we're we're even talking about three of deference really is that we want a a runway, if you will, to be able to do the thing in the front.
4:46:22 Um whether it's the thing that you saw tonight, whether it's something else that we [clears throat] can come up with, but it kind of gives that runway.
4:46:29 And I I think from a regulatory perspective, from a bank, they're they're going to need first position.
4:46:35 Now there's some technical things that can be negotiated like I stated about you know if if there was a conveyance of property like in the front to a private
4:46:44 developer then that proceeded they would agree that that proceeded go to the city right so they can they have that leeway
4:46:52 and I think those technical things can be worked out. Um, the other comment I want to address is when I made the statement about that building a couple
4:47:01 years ago, it wasn't so much as a nonprofit
4:47:08 or or a charitable entity or a non-ax, you know, put the tax roles. It was also the use of the structure. And the use of
4:47:16 the structure, I think, is is just as important as the ability to put it on the tax roles. You know, we can talk about the fire prevention and the use
4:47:25 and all that. I'm not going to get into that, but but what I'd say from that perspective, I think it's chapter 196
4:47:32 where it talks about mission use or use with respect to the mission of a charitable organization or or 501c3 like
4:47:39 we are. Yes, it is true that we could, and this would be from the property appraisers, designate portions like the
4:47:47 welcome center portion or maybe if we give free board classes or something, those portions of the building could be
4:47:54 taxexempt. But what isn't taxexempt is if we lease it to a law firm, right?
4:48:00 There there are uses and business uses that I think are important to Clermont Main Street and Partnering that is absolutely taxable. So, uh, the property
4:48:09 appraisers office would look at that and then they would tax it based on that.
4:48:12 Certainly, the front, as you see in front of you, is taxable, right? Um, and so there is nuance there. It's a
4:48:19 complicated nuance, but there's plenty of examples where 501c3's own buildings that yes, portions of it could be taxexempt, but there are in large part.
4:48:28 And then there's a 50% threshold that you get into like the lease test. So all of that in consideration um there will
4:48:36 be certain portions of this building that will be on the tax roles and I think that is important to notate. You know from a main street perspective economic vitality is one of our pillars.
4:48:46 Um it's very important that we do have those small business incentives and business business incubations and everything that we've talked about
4:48:54 through the many years that we've been uh operational. So uh I think we've been a great partner to the city. I think this is an asset that came up. Um it's
4:49:02 certainly something that that we're we're seeking. We want a permanent home.
4:49:07 Um there is a national main street uh accreditation process and part of that uh there's something called GAMSA. It's an award that welcome center is
4:49:16 absolutely integral in this. So we are seeking a welcome center. Um that is a specific use for Clermont Main Street.
4:49:23 We're not just trying to occupy the space for our event storage like there is a specific use for this. Um, I will
4:49:30 also say that this building was built for a very specific use. So, even if you were to go to Free Market, say no to
4:49:38 Main Street, as a developer and as a professional real estate broker of 18 years, even though I'm 35, do the math.
4:49:44 I I you're going to have to demo the inside because there's a shower, there's this and that. So you have to at the
4:49:52 city council and and possibly the CRA has to look at that building and say okay you know is it the highest and best
4:49:58 use of an insurance office to occupy probably not right but probably you know there there's just so many things that
4:50:06 you can sit there and and pick out and the minutiae but um when we submitted our our unsolicited bid to the city attorney and city manager yes it's a
4:50:14 very complex pro process certainly a rigorous one um but I think we're well seated We get audited every single year.
4:50:21 We actually did a full audit. We only really had to do a financial statement review, right? This year we did a full audit to be able to support and show you
4:50:31 that we we can absolutely do this. Um, so that's what we're here and that's kind of what I'll say.
4:50:37 Last last question I have on that then is the fact that if those two plots do not sell in 36 months, where are how you
4:50:44 propose to pay it off? We proposed an unsolicited bid that would be a balloon and we'd have to pay you entirely. Okay.
4:50:49 That's how it would be. It's treated as a balloon.
4:50:52 You treat it and do main and that's my my fear. Do Main Street have that kind of Yeah. And to council to to Councilman
4:51:00 Bane's point, I mean, look at what's happening. I mean, look at what me I'm the largest taxpayer right now in in the
4:51:08 CRA. the lumber yard will be that other um and so uh yes there's incredible momentum in what's happening in our
4:51:16 downtown that's not a secret used to be a secret not a secret anymore so I don't see us having an issue with either doing
4:51:25 it ourselves getting that getting that provider and by the way I mean United Southern Bank even even talked about in our board meeting the ability to to
4:51:34 actually fund and build the front and if that was the case you guys would be paid off way sooner So, I don't think that's a I mean, if the 1.3 million you got the
4:51:42 appraisal, it said 940,000. I looked at that appraisal being a professional in the industry and I'm like, if I was the
4:51:50 seller, I would probably submit an appeal and I'd probably provide them three other comps that they can reconsider. That's a that's a process
4:51:58 that you you have latitude. We agreed to pay half in our unsolicited bid. I think procedurally we it was required. It's
4:52:04 something that we offered into that as well. Um, so I think it it's in between.
4:52:11 We don't want the taxpayers to lose out here. We're not asking to buy the building for 940,000. If if anything, I would say that let's buy it for what you
4:52:19 paid for it. Get the taxpayers whole. Do the CRA thing. Sure, that's fine by us.
4:52:23 The mechanism there and and let us occupy the structure. Um, that's where we stand today. Yeah. Let me think. So, we can move on.
4:52:32 Um, would you be willing to listen what Miss Stra say, hey, and we do this, but then we admittedly turn it over to the
4:52:40 CRA, let them take That's okay. I mean, as the largest taxpayer in the CRA, we're happy to do that, too. I mean, it's Yeah, I I don't
4:52:48 I that's that's a mechanism that I think I I believe would be appropriate in this instance. I think if you as a council are are looking at the CRA and saying
4:52:57 and by the way I mean in 20 years the CRA is going to be non-existent so it's going to be absorbed by the general fund anyway but but let's say for today I
4:53:04 think the CRA should be self-sustaining it should it should feed itself in some respects and I think this is a great
4:53:12 option for it. So yeah when we sell the front two buildings then that would actually go back into the CRA dollars as opposed to the general fund. the general fund, which is the general taxpayers,
4:53:21 would be paid in whole day one. Yeah, I'm absolutely for that.
4:53:25 Well, like I say, that was the only thing I was looking at is the financing and everything and especially because the city is still tied up there. Yeah.
4:53:32 If we're going to sell it, I want the city completely out.
4:53:34 Yeah. And it's a revitalization effort, so it makes sense. I mean, it's a revitalization effort. I think it's appropriate.
4:53:40 So, I'm okay. If if we're willing to do that and and Mr.
4:53:45 And my understanding of tonight and and I think this goes to to Councilman Bane's point. I I don't think tonight is
4:53:53 say yes to the dress. No, say yes to the sale. Right. [laughter] I think it is to make a finding and and
4:54:01 when you make such finding, you will then presumably empower city staff to draft set agreement that would come at a
4:54:09 future date to be approved. That's my understanding of what is going on tonight.
4:54:13 That's what would happen. So, I mean, all that city council can do tonight is uh make a finding that this would be in the public interest, tell staff to draft
4:54:22 the comprehensive agreement pursuant to what's in the Florida statute, and it lists a bunch of things we have to put in there.
4:54:27 Um the things that are in the public interest that we've uh confirmed the financing mechanisms, uh things like that, and then it would
4:54:37 come before you and I guess conceivably the CRA. Um, so I guess this would kind of also be an
4:54:45 interlocal agreement. Sorry, this is an interesting wrinkle. And you know what?
4:54:48 Because it's [laughter] complicated, it's interesting, but um it's doable. So u but it would have to be on the agendas
4:54:56 for both the CRA and the next city council meeting.
4:55:00 What what time what kind of timeline realistically to get all of our feedback
4:55:08 of what we want in this comprehensive agreement? I think this is the term we use, right? Uh the comprehensive agreement and also to ask our two
4:55:16 members of the CRA who aren't up here right now to also weigh in uh to draft that then and then get that noticed and
4:55:24 and put on the agenda. What kind of timeline are we looking at? The good news is uh council member that really most of it has already been written
4:55:33 because it's in the proposal that's in front of you. What we'd be doing is ripping it and then adding on
4:55:41 the usual stuff, you know. Yeah. Legal ease, if you will. So, I'm sorry. Go ahead.
4:55:46 Well, I mean, today's Monday next week, so for the next council meeting on November time, I mean, they'd have to review red line.
4:55:56 So the question maybe is just as well to you.
4:55:59 Um we're I don't sleep. We're good. Well, wouldn't we need Mr. Van, Mr.
4:56:03 Wall, wouldn't we have to go back to the CRA and see if they open to that? And when is the next CRA meeting scheduled? Don't we have one in November? November 10th. November.
4:56:12 Can we do both back to back or is there have to be time in between? Nope. Okay.
4:56:16 I may just ask for earlier meeting now that we're adding another thing to it. Not the way y'all are talking about it.
4:56:22 It can be done back to back. I mean look of the other concerns there's questions as to when the circumstances under which a city can pledge its credit because
4:56:31 actually this is a form of seller financing as well and uh you'll note that the Clermont Main Street proposal talks a lot about
4:56:40 paramount public purpose. You only get into what's called a paramount public purpose if um we're uh pledging our
4:56:48 taxes as collateral. We're not doing that. So all we really do need to do is find that it is a public purpose, which is a much lower threshold. It's whatever you determine.
4:56:58 So I'm okay there. You know, on all the usual legal objections there might be, I I don't have them.
4:57:04 Then I'm comfortable giving staff that direction. Okay.
4:57:10 So making a motion for findings for the that it's in the public. Well, what I would ask if you choose to move this
4:57:16 forward would be to um find that the unsolicited proposal is in the public
4:57:23 interest, that it would be a public benefit to Clermont and direct staff to
4:57:30 proceed with the drafting, negotiation, and completion of a comprehensive agreement. And that's a specific term of
4:57:38 art, comprehensive agreement in the statute. Council members that so so moved comprehensive comprehensive agreement
4:57:46 that alleviate the city from any financial responsibility once they sell it and make [laughter] yeah if I can one thing I want to say so
4:57:54 that I'm not saying it behind closed doors since it doesn't sound like we're going to workshop this is there's a scenario where I know the fear is well
4:58:02 what happens let's let's imagine the CRA takes this on and let's imagine the the parcel sell and and we're short 150,000
4:58:11 200,000, 500,000, whatever is the number. And I say we, I'm talking about the CRA.
4:58:17 I'm going to suggest to this council that a balloon might be an option, but that we accept the possibility that if
4:58:25 it's short, then Main Street might have the burden of maintaining an incubator.
4:58:31 And so if we think about what happened with the downtown exchange, how we lost all those small businesses, if if the CRA was to find I'm not having CRA
4:58:40 conversation, but if if there was a debt to the CRA, then it would be I think
4:58:47 there's an argument to be made that if they if I almost would like Main Street to still owe the money because then they have to run an incubator which would
4:58:56 help promote small businesses so long as the CRA is in existence. So there is a scenario where for me I'm I'm happy for
4:59:03 the general fund to get the 1.3. That's that's important to me. But from the CRA perspective and I put that hat on, I'm not as worried about it at the CRA level
4:59:11 because there's the potential that we're feeding small businesses and growing small businesses within the CRA. So, I wanted to put that out if I'm way off
4:59:19 base because this is something I would say to our city manager that maybe the CRA would have the option of the balloon, but that the default might be if they can't ever pay it back, then
4:59:28 they must maintain an incubator for small business development.
4:59:31 So, so basically what you're saying, yeah, we go put it on CRA, but then also make balloon payment if necessary, go back to this to the main street.
4:59:40 Yeah. And that way if if when the parcels sell or when 36 months come, CRA might say, "Yeah, we're calling the
4:59:47 note. We want to get paid." But they also might say, "No, we like the incubator. Don't worry about it. Make monthly payments." Well, they could amend the agreement. I mean, the parties could amend it at that point.
4:59:56 Okay. So, I'll let you sort out the sausage. I just wanted to put that one out there as to me that has a great public benefit, I think.
5:00:03 So, my my two cents. Um, okay. So, I'm going to move that we make a finding that the unsolicited proposal is in the public's interest and that staff draft
5:00:12 draft negotiate a comprehensive agreement with Main Street to bring to the CRA on November 10th for the CRA to
5:00:21 consider an interlocal agreement that would then come to the city council on November 10th.
5:00:29 I mean, second, I can live with that. Does that work? I can live with that.
5:00:33 I got all the words wrong, I'm We have a motion and a second to uh the direct staff to go ahead and do the negotiation and rewriting the proposal uh to be
5:00:41 brought back to us on November 10th at the CRA for CRA agreement with the proposal uh before it come back to council on the 10th as well.
5:00:50 Um any further discussions none all in favor let me be known by saying I.
5:00:55 All oppose and chair vote I as well motion carries 5. Thank you. All right, introduction.
5:01:04 Come out west. Before I get in this, we got one, two, three intros. And I Fox, anybody anticipate any? Nope. So, we don't want to do any. Okay.
5:01:13 I don't have any comments.
5:01:14 All right. Intro. Item number 21 or uh ordinance number 2026-033.
5:01:21 An ordinance under the code of ordinances of the city of Clermont, Lake County, Florida providing for the annexation of a certain parcel of land contiguous to the present city
5:01:29 boundaries. providing for conflict, severability, administrative correction of scrivener's error, recording, publication, and an effective date.
5:01:38 And entertain a motion.
5:01:41 Make a motion to accept the intro ordinance number 2026-3.
5:01:48 So, I have a motion and a second for the approval of ordinance number 2026-33.
5:01:54 Intro. Any further discussion? Hear none. All in favor, let it be known by saying I. I. All oppose and chair vote I as well.
5:02:02 Item number 22, ordinance number 2026-034 intro.
5:02:07 An ordinance of the city of Clermont, Lake County, Florida, adopting the small-scale comprehensive plan amendment for the city of Clermont, Florida,
5:02:14 pursuant to the local government comprehensive planning act, chapter 163, part two, Florida statutes, setting forth the authority for adoption
5:02:23 of the small-scale comprehensive plan amendment. Setting forth the purpose and intent of the small-scale comprehensive plan amendment. Providing for the
5:02:31 adoption of the small-cale comprehensive plan amendment establishing the legal status of the small-cale comprehensive plan amendment providing for conflict
5:02:39 severability administrative correction of scrier's error publication and effective date. I'd like to make a motion for the intro for ordinance number 2026-34.
5:02:51 I second. I have a motion and a second for ordinance number 2026-034 intro. Any further discussion? Hearing
5:03:00 none. All in favor? Let it be known by saying I. I.
5:03:02 All oppose. Chair vote I as well. Motion carry 50. Ordinance number 2026-035.
5:03:08 Intro. An ordinance under the code of ordinances of the city of Clermont, Lake County, Florida, amending the official zoning map of the city of
5:03:16 Clermont, referred to in chapter 122 of ordinance number 289C, code of ordinances, reszoning the real properties described herein, as shown
5:03:25 below, providing for conflict, severability, administrative correction of scrivener's error, recording publication, and an effective date. I'd
5:03:34 like to make a motion for the intro for ordinance number 2026-35. I second.
5:03:41 Have a motion and a second for ordinance number 2026-035 intro. Any further discussion?
5:03:49 Hearing none. All in favor? Let it be known by saying I. I. I.
5:03:53 All opposed and the chair will I as well. Motion carry 50 reports.
5:04:03 An additional agenda item that was added.
5:04:06 Oh, that's right. [laughter] All right,
5:04:13 [sighs]
5:04:15 Mr. Mayor, if I may, before you get started, because I thought your statement at the beginning was okay.
5:04:20 Informative. Yeah. Um, I would appreciate getting council's guidance on
5:04:27 this. Um, I'm I find myself somewhat caught off guard only because I don't I've never dealt with this before and
5:04:35 because I know this involves a document that was published by the union. Um, I want to make sure that we're getting guidance from our attorney on what we
5:04:45 should do or could do if that's okay with you before we make well too many statements.
5:04:51 You you're right. And and actually [laughter] I know I called Mr. W after I got it because I noticed that the the written letter I got wasn't even sent to
5:05:00 him and that was my curiosity. So I called him and talked to him. Um, of course I had been waiting. I hadn't got he hadn't gotten back with me. Okay.
5:05:10 And then I start seeing all this stuff in the internet and I'm like I say, I don't want to Mr. Water really get involved in this. And that's why I'm kind of like saying, why don't we go for
5:05:18 independent uh uh investigator here? Uh because I'm also
5:05:27 and I'm trying I'm trying not to say some things that I'm also hearing such as the fact that I've heard there's been some communication going on that Mr.
5:05:34 Wall was involved so so uh in some meetings and things like this. So, I'm not sure what's going on.
5:05:40 So, I think where my questions are coming from is like because we have a CBA and because this involves the union, like are there processes or things that we should be mindful of?
5:05:52 You know, is there a pro? I don't know.
5:05:53 Well, first of all, and mayor, I didn't realize you were waiting for a call back. I apologize. I did. Thank you.
5:05:58 Um, no. I I don't think in thinking about the CBA that we have that I mean well
5:06:07 now that I'm thinking about it um I'm not aware of an issue. I it depends on what you want to talk about and
5:06:15 well look I mean in terms of an independent investigation the city doesn't have any interest in
5:06:22 hiding anything. you know, just like when people bring up a forensic audit or, you know, anything like that, the
5:06:29 city uh always has an interest in the truth and transparency and things like that. So, there's no, in my view, legal
5:06:38 issue with any of that. Now, depending on what y'all determine, it may be that that needs to go out on procurement. It might be an RFP. It depends on what
5:06:45 y'all want to do, but that's a separate issue. Well, I don't know what it hasn't been brought up yet, so I don't know what Well, well, as I stated in my opening
5:06:53 statement, if I uh you do an independent investigator investigation from someone, a legal firm or whatever, a lawyer
5:07:01 that's that has no ties to this and no business with the city or anything right now. I don't know. I was going to ask
5:07:07 you uh for financial cost, what what can we expect to have to p spend for some and how long something like this could
5:07:15 take because I have no idea. It depends on the scope of what you're envisioning.
5:07:18 Mayor, I think recently um Tarpon Springs put out an RFP for what they called a special counsel to
5:07:26 investigate um the dealings of its planning staff with the developer to see if they did anything unourred. Uh multiple law firms
5:07:35 bid on that. U the winning firm didn't um I mean I don't know that there was a
5:07:42 flat fee involved. So that's the other issue. Um, I think it took them nine months to do the investigation. It costundred $120,000 and they didn't find
5:07:51 anything. So, you never know. I I guess my question, do you anticipate uh think an investigation of this to uh sort will take that long and cost that?
5:08:03 Well, what do you have in mind? Well, basically, uh, going back to reading, of course, I forwarded the letter and everything what I'm reading and all the accusations that's made. And I can say I I just want transparency from everybody.
5:08:14 And of course, the, uh, um, I really don't know what role the city council has in this other than the fact the city manager worked for us and everything.
5:08:23 So, um, have we taken anything, uh, steps to make sure we're protecting our officers after these allegations have been founded, uh, largely against them
5:08:32 and, uh, found to be untrue or whatever, are we standing up for our officers and everything? Well, when I read the
5:08:39 letter, the the main accusation that I saw was that um the city management
5:08:46 wasn't um protecting or doing enough to support at least in the union's estimation, the officers or members of the Clermont Police Department.
5:08:57 So, I'm not aware of what, if any, remedial actions have been taken since the publication of the letter.
5:09:02 Right. And I guess that's what I just do with the union putting that out and that accusation. I want to see with an
5:09:10 independent investigation we go back and clear that and find out what we need to do or make recommendation to us what we should steps we should take at them
5:09:18 point if any are needed. if any need. Right.
5:09:21 Okay. So, that's that's what I'm trying to do to make sure my main goal here is to make sure our officers understand that, hey, we going we going to support
5:09:28 them. Uh and everything when these accusations are made, if they clear to the acc accusations, we need we need to support them. Um,
5:09:38 I I mean, I'll say that I'm not a, as you said, I think I'm I'm not a stranger to um the communications and accusations
5:09:47 and and matters that have been alleged about certain members of the Clermont Police Department. And I I'm also not
5:09:53 aware of anything that the city's done wrong by the officers. I you know, so which is why if you don't like that
5:10:00 finding, it may be worth going out. I mean, if if that satisfies and like I said, this there's never any um p
5:10:08 there's no interest in the city in hiding anything or not getting a second opinion. That's always okay.
5:10:13 Um is there a process in the CBA? So, what I'm hearing is the concern is that our officers [clears throat] may have a complaint.
5:10:23 Is there a process in the CBA for them to bring a complaint? Because my understanding is this is at this point
5:10:30 like a Facebook post. No, no. It was You received a letter from the uh PBA himself. From the PBA? Yeah.
5:10:37 Oh, okay. I haven't seen We all received the original letter came to all the council members. Uh Mr. Van Wagman, I think, and then the chief the
5:10:46 chief uh I was shocked because not not a a copy wasn't even sent to the city attorney. So, when I sit down and I read
5:10:53 through this and this is all a long thing and I'm sitting there saying, "Wow." So, I my first thing was to call Mr. W.
5:11:00 I think Mr. Mr. Van Wagner was on vacation at the time. So I called Mr. W and asked him if he had seen it and I was shocked that it didn't come to him.
5:11:08 And so I actually at that point forward it to him. Okay. And we kind of we kind of talked about it and everything. Of course
5:11:16 then when I'm starting to get somebody sending me stuff that the PBA had posted on Facebook, right, out there on in social media with some
5:11:24 of the same thing, I say, "Oh, I think we we need to we need to do this suppling this." Because as I told Mr.
5:11:30 wall. When I first read the letter, I'm trying to figure out why did it come to the council members because the police off police department worked
5:11:39 for Mr. Van Wagner, not us. And what what is our I don't understand our role as the council member other than the fact that uh Mr. uh Van Wagner do work
5:11:49 for the council. Okay. So now it is interesting. I I I didn't I mean I didn't think about looking at the CBA
5:11:56 until now, but there are restrictions on the union posting material that are that is adverse to the city or any of its officers or employees.
5:12:06 Um that's interesting. Yeah.
5:12:07 Um so I would like I mean I guess we probably should look at that.
5:12:11 Well well hey do investigation and hey into the whole matter but I think it doesn't need to be Mr. Van Wagner. It doesn't need to be our police chief you
5:12:19 or anybody else that has some connection with the city. we need someone outside uh uh of the city to do this thing so we
5:12:27 can have a fair fair look at it and everything. So, and if we find that the uh the union did something wrong by posting, hey, we we need to deal with
5:12:35 that. If we've did something wrong by not standing up for them, we we'll deal with that at that. It's up to the council.
5:12:41 So, that's basically what I'm asking, hey, do if you all feel like we need do an investigation. I'm sorry, Miss Strange. I I didn't I don't know if you
5:12:49 didn't read the letter and everything but I think it was sent on 21st of October.
5:12:54 Okay. The email it's a pretty long [laughter] Okay. And now it's flo and somewhat a different version is floating around that what they sending me is floating around on on on social media.
5:13:04 Okay.
5:13:05 My my initial take would just be that if that is what you wanted to do, if that's the council's pleasure, it would be an RFP um to go seek counsel of your choice.
5:13:15 Okay. Well, I I'm I threw it out there at the council. It's up to council what what they decide. I mean, I'm only one person up here, so Yes, sir.
5:13:24 Yeah. What is um if we did the RFP, if that's the recommendation, what kind of timeline do we have to put on that?
5:13:31 I mean, I I don't want to speak for Freddy, you know, but I mean, normally we do 30 days, something like that, to get proposals back and then they're
5:13:40 raided by an evaluation committee. They come to you. Well, if we're the ones calling for it though, wouldn't we
5:13:48 couldn't we just receive that information and make the selection?
5:13:52 Oh, absolutely. I mean, like you do a a city manager or city attorney, you can certainly do that. Okay.
5:13:59 And for the timeline, do do is is it is there a required length of time or could
5:14:06 we say we want this we want the we want it posted and we want the materials back uh in in time for us to decide well we
5:14:15 don't have two meetings in November so uh that we want this on the either yeah either a special meeting or on the
5:14:23 December 8th meeting. I I almost think he's going to be 90 days I I I wouldn't support 90 days. I think we have this has to be an expedited
5:14:31 process because we're we have accusations against staff and we have accusations against citizens and I
5:14:39 want to make sure that we are are not going about the governmental
5:14:48 perceived or actual dragging of the foot to get it to get it initiated and moving. And so I would support either uh
5:14:57 going out to RFP and having this come before us at a special meeting um
5:15:04 or at at at the latest December 8th, our only meeting in December.
5:15:14 I think that between now and then we also need information from our attorney.
5:15:18 I mean, here's what we know is that our attorney hasn't wasn't copied on this.
5:15:23 No, our city manager wasn't copied on this.
5:15:25 No, city manager city manager was responded.
5:15:28 Oh, I saw you resp I thought it was forward.
5:15:30 I just found it strange. I got it. Yeah, I thought he [clears throat] Okay. Um, I mean I'm interested in learning more as
5:15:37 well about what is the process with I mean the collective bargaining units agreements exist for a reason and part
5:15:44 of that is to establish process and so I'm all for investigations. I think
5:15:52 investigations are good. I think third parties reviewing is good. I think that's fine. But also, I would like to see while we're going through that
5:16:00 process of sending out the RFP, our attorney to look into and advise us on what was the process that should have
5:16:08 been followed so that we know what by what standard we're even measuring a firm to do an investigation. Like, if we're calling for someone to do an
5:16:15 investigation, we should know what they're looking into. And right now, I don't I don't have that. I don't think it'll take long to get that, but I mean,
5:16:23 I would I would be forensic. There must be forensic attorneys that do this type of investigation. Am I right or wrong? I don't think it's very forensic.
5:16:32 It's not very I don't think it's forensic.
5:16:34 They're looking for something. I mean, and secondly, I don't know why we're we shouldn't be involved in ongoing litigations, you know, from the I don't
5:16:43 think from the bench we should make any kind of, you know, we're tying other attorneys hands then, you know, we're we're trying to sway public opinion from
5:16:51 here. And I don't think that's our position to do that.
5:16:54 Yeah. I I I don't mind initiating a process of hiring special counsel. Um I mean I think the allegations are
5:17:01 serious, but also I would like to have our attorney I want information from our [clears throat] attorney on, you know,
5:17:09 what the allegations are, what the process is. Was the process followed and make sure that we're following that process because the process exists so that we're not
5:17:17 being frivolous with public money. So, I think we should do both simultaneously so that we're we're fully advised.
5:17:24 Okay.
5:17:26 If if it would be okay. I I just want to give you all some information.
5:17:29 Yes. I was going to ask if you had any information. Yeah.
5:17:33 Mr. Mayor, you made a comment that that was your first communication that you received. To the best of my rec recollection as the city manager, that
5:17:41 was my first communication from the union side. Now, I have talked with Chief Grac on a number of occasions
5:17:49 because we've looked at some emails that have been sent but not by the union.
5:17:52 So, my frustration as the city manager is use the process.
5:17:58 When you have somebody who you can talk to cuz I feel like I have a very good relationship with most of the police and
5:18:06 it it broadsided me. I didn't know that was coming until it came and I answered it back Monday when I got back from vacation. And then I found it on social
5:18:16 media that night after I had responded that I'm going to review this. I had received it. So in less than 24 hours,
5:18:22 it was put out on social media, which I found concerning that we didn't have the courtesy of a conversation and it's
5:18:30 already gone to that point. So I tried to figure out who wrote this because it
5:18:37 didn't say who wrote it. It just says it's from the PBA, but it gives no name of any individuals. And I've asked and nobody knows the answer.
5:18:47 So, I did the next best thing I need I knew to do. I talked to Chief Gracie at link today and I found him. He's a
5:18:55 really quality leader. He can separate things and try to look at it from both sides. Just so you know, not everybody has that gift, but I felt like he did in
5:19:05 my conversation today. That's just free information. I talked to him. I called uh Representative Taylor Yosovski. Part
5:19:13 of the reason I did that for him is he many people don't know he worked with me to actually get the accreditation for the PBA because we [clears throat] were
5:19:21 stalled in the city and we weren't able to go forward with negotiations and even go negotiate their contract. So I jumped
5:19:29 in and worked with Taylor and we actually got that approved working together. And I think everybody forgot that. But that's that's here or there also.
5:19:40 And so I started to communicate with him quite a bit. And then I got to talk with another gentleman I've never talked to before named Mick Mccale.
5:19:50 He is the executive director of the PBA and the vice president of the entire state of Florida. He read the post and
5:19:59 he had many things to share and they were all derogatory and being specific and detailed. I asked
5:20:09 him to put it in a communication that you'll receive tonight from me in an email format so you can have it. He said, "Good afternoon. This is to
5:20:17 confirm our phone conversation referenced the alleged Clermont chapter PBA of Central Florida PBA chapter.
5:20:25 There is no recognized group of our organization.
5:20:33 I speak as the executive director, the senior vice president of the state of the PBA to any and all postings or
5:20:42 correspondence of individuals representing themselves as such is not authorized or recognized by our organization.
5:20:53 We are in the process of having our general counsel address these matters immediately.
5:20:59 So they told me it's an inappropriate post. It never went through Tallahassee.
5:21:05 There was no approval process. And I even heard the word this was a rogue act, okay,
5:21:11 and not appreciated because some people feel like right or wrong, they believe that this was a political
5:21:19 stunt for the election next week and they want nothing to do with anything like that. Okay?
5:21:25 They their their reputation and what they're trying to accomplish, they don't want to get in the middle of any of that kind of stuff. So there's no
5:21:33 concrete evidence saying that it's that, but there's there is concern that this very well could be a political stunt and
5:21:41 they they did not want to be a part of that. So there was many many many things there was some concerns before this even
5:21:50 took place in dealing with our PBA also.
5:21:55 Okay. So they were ready to have some correction and set some things in order and they do not want to end the
5:22:04 relationship with the PBA, but they're greatly concerned how the PBA and the relationship is going right now. So
5:22:12 there is consideration how they should handle that. So it they were they're very ticked off. I don't know how to say it any differently. They're very upset
5:22:20 and feel like they got sideswiped. Had nothing to do with it. They said, "We don't know about it. We haven't heard about it. We haven't seen about it.
5:22:27 Nobody's called us." So, I wanted you all to know if that's my findings. I still haven't found who wrote it.
5:22:35 But I went to the PBA cuz they should know. I thought and they didn't.
5:22:40 Okay. Well, with that that being said and since they saying it think it's road, I guess this goes back to same thing which we never finally got the
5:22:49 answer to on the same thing with the city manager thing that we had a few months ago. Um, so at this point then Mr. W
5:22:57 should we be doing uh investigating who who probably is going around doing these things? And of course, like I say, we still haven't gotten to the bottom of
5:23:06 the city manager. we got to the bottom of the barrel which was VPN. You know, we Nigeria IP addresses supposedly created it.
5:23:16 Um, mayor, that's a determination that you all have to make. I mean, if if you are uh disturbed by what the city
5:23:24 manager said and think there should be accountability and for people who claim to be the PBA, that's another potential
5:23:32 subject, but that's for you all to determine.
5:23:35 And it could be our local guys. I just don't know. Right. It could be someone else.
5:23:40 It could be someone else. I just don't I don't want to say it is or isn't. I just want you to know. So So you operating with the same information I have.
5:23:47 Well, I appreciate you sharing that with us. And of course that, like I said, that put a different light on everything. But at the same time, uh, as
5:23:54 was saying, um, city staff being accused, uh, uh, residents being accused, the council being accused of not doing these things.
5:24:03 And I don't take that lightly, okay? Cuz I want to make sure we always transparent and we take care of whatever
5:24:11 we need we need to take care of. And so, how do we feel about um our staff giving us a report, including what the
5:24:18 normal process or what options might be, as well as starting the process of sending out an RFP for a special uh
5:24:26 special attorney for for this purpose to investigate these issues. And we can always pull that back. I mean, it has to come to us for vote.
5:24:33 That's fine. If that Well, if that's on the next agenda, then that gives us time to hear from see what happens with the PBA. See what happens when our attorney reviews it.
5:24:43 There's ways to trace back emails. You know, if you you know, you have people, they don't, you know, these like you said that went back to Nigeria with the
5:24:51 VPN, but maybe this person isn't as sophisticated, right?
5:24:55 And we can trace it to an IP address that could be local. It's possible, you know, I mean that's I mean I'm not a
5:25:03 a super IT guy, but I would imagine if you are, you can, you know, these things could all be traced. Everything can be traced, you know, exactly to the address it was sent from.
5:25:14 So, I mean, these are things I think we need to get. I I guess that would be you to I mean, somebody's trying to steer
5:25:22 the council to do things that's incorrect. And it even brought it up as an agenda item. So now we're spending
5:25:30 this time. So now that even though it's not true, it's getting voice, right?
5:25:35 And voice is power. Like you said, it's political. We don't know who who's who's motivated by, you know, you look, you
5:25:44 know, it's like follow the money, who gets who benefits from this type of of argument. [snorts] And that's where you look for, you know, you look for the uh
5:25:52 and you're you're right, but at the same time, we can't I know somebody else is out there may have doing it and everything, but we as a council and as a
5:25:59 city staff and everything can't have these type of accusations just floating around out there, but that's given it credence by you even saying that. You see what I'm saying? So
5:26:08 that's so this fake email is causing you to say that.
5:26:13 Can I ask for clarification on that? cuz I think well that's what I think I think we've just jumped to the conclusion that it's a fake email.
5:26:22 I'm not comfortable.
5:26:23 They're just saying it wasn't run through Tallahassee. They know nothing about it. Okay.
5:26:27 It wasn't. But didn't you ask RPA if they did it and they said well everybody I've talked to so far doesn't claim that they did it. But I haven't I haven't interviewed everybody.
5:26:36 I mean this isn't my this is not my forte. I I'd rather ask the chief to help me talk to people. I mean what they what they think they I mean did you say
5:26:43 that one thing the main PBA said is there is no specific like Clermont correct chapter.
5:26:51 They said the logo was not authorized to be used. The account was not authorized to be started on Facebook and they know nothing about it.
5:26:58 So they're claiming the organization doesn't necessarily exist on its own. Correct.
5:27:03 But the material may be authentic as a representation from Right. Well, and I think it I think the
5:27:10 title came from Central Florida PBA Climmont. I think Clermont. Yeah.
5:27:16 I I read that name back to him and he goes, "We do not have that." Right. So, but I just I mean
5:27:23 [sighs]
5:27:24 I still think we deserve to sit out and try to figure out even if it's uh not real, it's authentic, who was doing these things. then we need to go ahead
5:27:32 and try to figure out some kind of way to get to the bottom bottom of it and everything and figure out who's who's doing this and try to figure out why I
5:27:39 guess. Okay. Well, I'd be willing to, I guess, then put forward the motion to go out for the RFP to have honor before
5:27:48 the December 8th city council meeting uh for uh a special counsel and
5:27:57 concurrently have staff do whatever investigation and fact gathering, including the collective bargaining
5:28:05 agreement with the Clermont Police officers. and what those things outline for how to handle these types of
5:28:12 procedures. So, we have all of that information for us on or before December 8th as well. And we decide at that meeting what we're going to do.
5:28:20 Okay. A second. Okay.
5:28:25 Have a motion and second to give TF guidance as did you write all that down, Mr. B?
5:28:30 I I do just want to ask for guidance and clarity on the RFP. So this would be special counsel for the purpose of
5:28:38 investigating the claims made in the letter. Yes.
5:28:43 And see if we can try to determine where the letter came from. Okay. Okay. So, twofold, the claims, the source, the um
5:28:52 authenticity, authenticity and and I think the mayor talked earlier about uh he said something about protecting integrity and
5:28:59 making sure you know if there weren't steps to protect staff or citizens that we identify those. If there weren't meet if there were meetings that shouldn't
5:29:08 have occurred or meetings that should have occurred and didn't, we understand that all of that type of information to protect the integrity. Very good.
5:29:15 Okay. So any further discussion hearing? None.
5:29:20 All in favor, let it be known by saying I. I. All oppose. And chair will I as well. So thank you all. Appreciate it. Uh reports.
5:29:29 Mr. Van Wagner.
5:29:31 Real quick, Tuesday, November 3rd is our election here. [clears throat] Tuesday, November 10th, we have a CRA meeting. I'm going to ask that you'd
5:29:40 consider coming at 1. I'm sorry to have to do that, but now that we have more items and things, I'm not sure we can get that done. So, you let me know if
5:29:48 that's a possibility or not. And that's all I have for tonight.
5:29:53 Um, can we try 130, [laughter] please, sir, for the CRA?
5:30:01 I can do 130. Okay. All right. That's good for you. Others? Yeah, I can do one.
5:30:08 Uh, 10 November. That's 10 November, right? Yes.
5:30:13 All right, Mr. Wah, no report. Council member Strange.
5:30:20 Um, there was a question of whether we can put major financial decisions on the ballot. I don't have the answer to that. Can you speak to that?
5:30:26 The answer is yes, but I it it normally has to do with bond issues and things like that. So, they were required in certain circumstances to put them on the
5:30:35 ballot. Um, and it's theoretically possible that you could have put um the parking garage on the ballot as part of
5:30:44 that. Um, it's also theoretically possible that depending on if you wanted to add something to your charter, you could put that as a referendum, but it's
5:30:51 not it's not something that's required, but that would apply to the general fund, right? So, like if the parking garage is handled through the CRA, then would that go on a ballot?
5:31:01 uh if it was handled by the CRA, it depends on the if it if there's a certain bond issuance. Oh, I see. Yeah. Okay.
5:31:09 Um and then just for clarity for our for the council, a comment came up earlier tonight about and I think Mr. Van, you
5:31:18 raised the concern about the burden of noticing neighbors when there's a development. And I I was thinking about it and I I do want to be clear. I see
5:31:26 that burden as on the developer, not on our staff. I think our staff jumping through the hoops of checking the public
5:31:33 records is enough. But I think and I encourage all of us to hold the developers who are asking for changes to
5:31:40 their property rights to demonstrate that they've been good neighbors by evidencing that when they come to us.
5:31:47 And I don't know if that needs to be part of any sort of formal process, but that's where I was coming from is not for our staff, but for the actual person asking for the change of condition.
5:31:59 Yeah. Oh. Um, the Urban Guild Summit, Mr.
5:32:06 Matthysse, you asked me [laughter] to bring that up. I'm excited. I don't know if you have all seen it, but I would like to go. And I don't know if I need
5:32:14 to get council approval to do it um through the training budget. I didn't use any of my training budget last year, if that matters to anybody, but um I
5:32:23 would like to go. I think it'll be a great event right here in town. and and we we briefly excuse me we briefly [clears throat] talked about it in some of the one-on- ones. I'm going to be
5:32:31 sending out an email tonight to all of council and PNZ just to give them a little update of what it is, what the program's like, and if if anybody wants
5:32:39 to go, then we have the funds to send to everybody.
5:32:43 Is that is that the one you uh sixth, seventh, and eth? Yes, sir. Okay.
5:32:48 Of course, I know I told you I couldn't do the seventh, but [laughter] I got so many things on there, you know. So,
5:32:55 that's all I have. Okay. Thank you. Uh Mr. Bane.
5:32:58 Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Um to Council Member Strange's point, um I as I referenced earlier, I had already have a
5:33:06 draft related to um the signs for those notifications cuz I I saw one today for Eustace and it stood out. I was like,
5:33:13 "Oh, that's one I want to add to the example." I do think when we revise that section of the code again to to address
5:33:23 the signage, I think if the council's will is such, we could also say that notifications
5:33:31 are sent to the property owners and to the addresses because those notifications are paid for by the
5:33:40 developer. And so we can bill directly back to the developer or the per the applicant um for those notifications to
5:33:49 pay for the staff time it takes to send out notifications to property owners and
5:33:57 app and the addresses so that if it's a lease person a lease situation someone would get it in their mail you know
5:34:04 resident of 123 ABC Street they would get it and the property owner would get it and as you're drafting that what I I
5:34:12 don't necessarily want to duplicate the burden or the expense because it could be a lot because we expanded that. But I definitely think the immediately
5:34:20 adjacent property owner Yeah.
5:34:24 And if that property is vacant, the next closest occupied property.
5:34:29 Yeah, I think that's Yeah, that we may just have to kind of just say, look, you got to do it or maybe there's an HOA like it goes to HOA or whatever. Yeah.
5:34:36 So So Mr. Let me ask in that in that proposal. Are we looking to change right now
5:34:45 we notify somebody that's within so many feet? I know we just extended I'm not saying expanded even further.
5:34:51 I'm just saying uh within that radius right now we just do property owner.
5:34:57 Well, we kind of just found out that maybe property owner isn't the best person to notify. Maybe we need to also
5:35:03 notify the resident of that address that that's within that frame. And if we can do that in a way, and I'm just throwing
5:35:12 it out there. If we can do that in a way that is not too problematic for staff that we can also then bill back to the applicant like we do now with the
5:35:20 current process, maybe we should consider that. All right.
5:35:24 And then um my only other thing was uh for the city manager, I believe the comp plan was transmitted. Is that correct?
5:35:31 Um, I think it was mentioned in that process that council would get the comp plan and transmitt information and we
5:35:38 haven't gotten that yet. So, can we please receive that uh of what was transmitted in the actual plan? Thank you. Can it go on the website, too?
5:35:46 I think it should go on the website.
5:35:47 Yeah. But yeah, thank you. That's all I have.
5:35:50 Thank you, sir. Council member Myers, no report.
5:35:55 Council member Peterson. Uh couple of things uh m Miss Hoisington said about the uh the water bill like they're putting these new little meters. One of
5:36:04 the things when they changed their their plan I know they they did inservices in the different communities. Maybe they couldn't do that again. I know a lot of
5:36:11 people like that especially like the 55 and over communities they cut you know explain what's going on and yeah they got put it in but how is what is the
5:36:20 reduction is the reduction equal to the cost of putting these things in. So it'll in essence be an increase then.
5:36:26 You know what I'm trying to say? I mean it's easy to say a reduction but it's it's if if it doesn't have any value then it has nothing. Same thing with she
5:36:33 had mentioned the American heart in the libraries. You know it does blood pressure screenings. I mean that's I think really on the libraries function
5:36:41 to publicize that. There's a lot of organizations that do blood pressure screening blood glucose readings things like that. And yeah, I think Councilman
5:36:51 Bain since about the permits. I think it was mentioned that this is a problem with contractors, you know, coming in and
5:37:00 giving you a great price and not even getting a permit. And now, you know, three years later, they changed their name from ABC to CDF and you could never
5:37:09 find them. So, you know, but you can always find the property. So, that's the, you know, that's the deep pocket that the city looks at. But I think we
5:37:16 did the right thing by reducing it. But maybe we, you know, we got to be careful of that because then does that bring out everybody else that has a fine and say,
5:37:24 "Hey, listen, it wasn't me. It was my, you know, my contractor." So that's something we need to do. And uh and lastly, you know, we have election next
5:37:33 week and everybody's running around and I just want to thank everybody that came to all the different meetings we had. It was great. It was nice to see the
5:37:40 public. It was great to hear their questions and hopefully give them the correct answers. With that, thank you very [laughter] much. Hopefully.
5:37:47 Hopefully, hopefully we could. Mr. Matis. Yes, sir. Just a couple quick things.
5:37:54 One of them you asked uh council member Bane, you asked about the comp plan. We did get confirmation from the state that they received it and they're starting their review, but we will get it up on the website tomorrow.
5:38:03 So, we'll have that. The other thing is in in a lot of your one-on-one briefings that we had, we talked about the mayor Minola is inquiring again about the boat
5:38:12 ramp and um we talked about some of the options that that she recommended. Maybe they'd pay double fees, things like
5:38:19 that. So, I I know she's going to call me this week because she knows we have a council meeting. She's going to want to know what kind of direction I've been
5:38:26 given. So, I just wanted to throw it out and see if council has any directions for for me to provide to her.
5:38:34 Yeah, I believe we should uh direct staff to do some research on the number of parking spaces available at the boat ramp and the number of annual passes
5:38:43 that we sold to residents for the last fiscal year, including the daily passes sold last year to determine
5:38:50 what our capacity is for annual passes for non-residents.
5:38:54 Yeah, they can bring this information back to us in our next council meeting. then we can make a more informed decision as to which way to go on the capacity
5:39:03 availability for non-residents and still we asked them to come back with an offer of a mutually beneficial agreement. I'm not hearing one.
5:39:10 You're you won't hear one. The offer was the the response was no we don't we don't need
5:39:18 to provide anything. We'll be happy to pay double the price or double whatever but we don't have anything to offer was
5:39:24 basically the response. Well, well, u Okay.
5:39:31 Well, as I as I know I talked to you the other day about this. As I said the other day, I I have no problem with if we want to charge them $100. I know we
5:39:39 clim residential is $20 a year. If we want to charge them 100, give it to them 100. I know they can't. They don't have anything they negotiate with. Uh going
5:39:47 back to what Mr. Peterson just said about trying to figure out how many passes we serve.
5:39:53 I don't think we going to restrict how many uh annual passes we serve because then we restricting income and plus the fact that um we trying to li that way we
5:40:02 limit how many people are actually using the boat ramp. Okay. We can sell the 100 passes today but that don't mean all 100 of them are going to be there today.
5:40:11 Okay. He may not have been gone from there just to see like what the data is, you know, to see is it even worth it just to have the data.
5:40:17 We we we have a lot of residenc I say I say yeah let's staff bring it back and let him do his report.
5:40:25 Yeah, that's fine. You that's all I had.
5:40:30 So you okay with getting to that answer when you when you see her?
5:40:34 So So the so if I could recap the answer was I don't have the answer. Yeah. Our position hasn't changed.
5:40:41 I know we talked we talked about it uh we talked about it yesterday. I know and everything. So that's where we are.
5:40:47 Right. And council member Bane had some good comments in our oneonone about what about the other residents that are not in Minnola that are that have a
5:40:55 Clermont [snorts] resident or address but aren't really residents that use the boat as well? Are we shutting them out and only allow So there that's why I wanted to open up to get some kind of
5:41:03 consensus today because there's a lot of great comments during that's why yes if is what helps you make us an offer.
5:41:08 Yeah. You know, otherwise if it's just reducing a price, we're one bidding against ourselves that we're doing it without all the information and we're
5:41:16 just asking everybody else to ask for a lower rate, too. I'm sure our prices are set for a reason. I might be wrong in that assumption, but you know, it's a yes if. So, what what what do we get?
5:41:27 And I don't mean it like tit for tat.
5:41:29 I'm just saying like what how does this work and what do they have? Like make me an offer. You know, like the the only offer that was made is
5:41:36 we'll be happy to pay double what the residents pay.
5:41:40 Double triple if I mean, [laughter] but they but but they but the mayor basically said the same thing is tell us what you want.
5:41:49 Yeah.
5:41:50 Yep. Yep. So So um okay, going back to the comp plan.
5:41:55 I know you answer Mr. Bane said it was going to be on there. Are we going to get a hard copy of what was actually sent? That was that was on my list here.
5:42:02 Yeah, we we can get a hard copy for sure.
5:42:03 Okay. So, we can get a hard copy. I think I'm not sure if that was asking for. Okay. Um
5:42:11 Miss Strange, you you handled the one on uh garage funding, but it was also a question about how do we allocate uh reserve funds.
5:42:20 Okay. Uh if we can, Mr. Matthews, Mr.
5:42:23 Van Wagner, if we can get some something on that. Um and there was a question something about street parking, lakefront street parking. And I didn't I
5:42:32 didn't get all that. I didn't get all that. Did anybody else?
5:42:35 Yeah. Sounds like the the gentleman that spoke Let me find my notes. He got his number.
5:42:42 Okay. Okay. So, Miss Mr. How from Lakefront Villages wanted to no on street parking signs.
5:42:48 Yeah. Yeah. I didn't know where it's at, but I just Okay. All right. I got the mayor's lunchon next on Tuesday at 12:00. I'll be at uh where am I at? Uh
5:42:57 Chick-fil-A on Highway 50. Okay. uh go back to the water meters. I think these are the what they call we call our smart
5:43:04 meters. Um to be honest, which I have to verify with Mr. Brunson, but I don't think it's going to you going to see too
5:43:11 much savings in your bill. U most of the saving you will see in the fact that we no longer have to have a person we hired that actually go out and read your
5:43:18 meters. They can just all do it from from inside. And so it's I guess you can call it reduction of staff. Okay.
5:43:25 [laughter] You know, is where is the savings at? Uh, and newly, Miss Orington, when they put these meters in, they they first put them in, uh, they
5:43:33 have to go a cycle or two before they can get all the true accurate data. You know, they can know what they put it in.
5:43:38 And then, um, I think in the past they told me they they kind of like estimate where where everything is at. Uh, looking at what what the present meter
5:43:46 is saying and then they try to go from there. Uh, but if you don't mind, Mr.
5:43:50 Van Wagner, get with Mr. Bronson and get a few uh get that for sure and all. But like I say, these are very so-called
5:43:59 smart meters and they are pretty good and uh they can actually sit in in the in the office over there and tell you
5:44:06 got a leak in your house. So So that's that's a great thing. They do a lot of good things. They no longer have to come out and read meters. So that's where most of the reduction is is at what my
5:44:15 understanding. Um that's all I have. Anybody have anything else?
5:44:22 You have not needing a journal.