Clermont Planning and Zoning Transcript 11/3/26
14:32 I call the November 3rd City of Clermont Planning and Zoning Commission to order at 6:30 p.m. Will the clerk please call the role?
14:41 Commissioner Tidona present.
14:43 Commissioner May here.
14:45 Commissioner Neik present.
14:47 Commissioner Colby here.
14:48 Commissioner Kramer here.
14:50 Commissioner Hoisington here.
14:54 Please stand as you are able for the pledge of allegiance.
14:59 I pledge algiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands. One nation
15:08 under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. You may be seated.
15:19 I'd like to thank everyone for joining us tonight. Uh, I'd like to remind the commission um to make sure you turn on your microphone when you speak and also
15:28 uh members of the public, the microphone should already be on. And I'd like to remind everyone that this is being broadcast live on the city's YouTube channel at city of Clermont.
15:40 Uh, commissioners, uh, you have received two sets of minutes uh, from the two meetings that we had in October. Um, I
15:48 will entertain a motion to approve the October 6th minutes.
15:54 Commission. Uh, I will make a motion to approve the October 6 Planning and Zoning Commission meeting minutes. Do I have a second?
16:03 Second. All in favor? I. Any opposed? Chair votes I.
16:12 And at this time, I will entertain a motion for the October 12th minutes.
16:17 I will also make a motion to approve the October 12th, 2026 special planning and zoning commission meeting minutes.
16:24 Do you have a second? Second. All in favor? I.
16:31 Any opposed? Chair votes eye.
16:35 This is the portion of the meeting where we get reports from our commissioners.
16:38 Uh, so I will start to my far left with Commissioner Sidona.
16:44 Thank you, Mr. Chair. May I uh as I please do
16:53 so, just following up on uh a conversation of last month of uh when
16:59 DPZ was here and trying to bring in some uh commercial revenue into Clermont. I
17:07 went to the White House investment site because I wanted to know who who do we even talk about or talk to to try to get
17:16 them down here into Clermont. Um so as of 10:31 there are 343 companies
17:25 um which represent 343 cold calling opportunities to see if anybody any of these companies
17:33 need a two to threetory building for their HR legal fiscal training
17:39 departments or whatnot. These 343 uh cold call opportunities represent
17:47 somewhere in the neighborhood of 113 trillion dollar worth of investment into
17:53 the United States. Um we need 1% of that. We need 3.43
18:02 companies to come to Clermont to make money.
18:06 So I had an incredible conversation with Google AI. full disclosure and I asked them what would you say would be three
18:14 solutions where we could start getting commercial revenue into Clermont.
18:20 So the first was this job creation density bonuses.
18:25 Instead of telling developers no to a residential, the code can be written to say if you allocate 30% of the square
18:33 footage to light industrial, clean tech or corporate parks, you get a bonus on the remaining land. This incentivizes
18:42 developers to build what we need in Clermont.
18:45 The second suggestion was an industrial preservation district. Clermont, as you know, and Lake County share a joint
18:54 planning area. Clermont should advocate for a text amendment that creates an
19:00 exclusive employment enclave zone along specific corridors where residential is
19:07 explicitly prohibited. Prohibiting housing entirely in an industrial zone does not trigger the same state
19:15 preeemptions as trying to block it in a mixeduse zone. And last but not least, exploiting the tax argument. The best
19:24 language to use in a risk adverse city council is the cost of services argument. Residential HOAs cost cities
19:32 more in road maintenance, police, fire, school infrastructure than they bring in through property taxes. Commercial and
19:39 industrial parks are tax positive as they bring in massive revenue while requiring little service output. This is
19:47 not being anti-developer. It's just a form of, and I like these words, fiscal emergency protection
19:56 for the city's budget. The last thing that you have is an article from Breitbart from October 28th of this
20:04 year. Breitbart business digest. What if we are building too many houses? So what
20:12 John Carney does is he takes um the demand for housing and then he overlaps
20:20 and cross references it with population densities and the potential of population growth. He does not site a
20:28 particular city or state but according to his research along with the Harvard
20:35 joint center for housing studies projects that America will add 8.6 million households between 2025 and 2020
20:44 uh and 2035 followed by just 5.1 million in 2035 to 2045. This will be the slowest decade of
20:54 household growth in a century. And the fear is that we are building uh not that
21:01 we're building too much, we're building too too much, not too little, that there will be uh plenty of empty homes out
21:10 there uh within the next decade. So, thank you for your time, sir. Thank you, Commissioner May.
21:18 Just short and sweet. Um happy voting day. Still time to get your votes in.
21:23 6:36 7:00 is the closing. Good luck to all the candidates. Let the best man or woman win.
21:31 Thank you, Commissioner Neck.
21:34 Just want to say I hope all United States citizens const their constitutional right to vote. A lot of
21:42 good men and women sacrificed their lives for us to have this. It's very important. There's a lot of lot of
21:50 things on the ballot that are very important especially to the citizens and residents of Clermont.
21:56 So I hope everybody constit use their constitutional rights for it. No other comment.
22:02 Thank you Commissioner Kramer. Thank you chair. Um, I wanted to mention that Clermont was
22:11 recently featured in the Business View magazine as one of the best and well-run cities. So, I wanted to give
22:19 congratulations to city manager Rick Van Wagner and Deputy City Manager Dan Matthysse and the entire team and all the staff. uh you guys were recognized
22:28 and I hope that that um you guys are being rewarded as well for that recognition because that's a lot of hard
22:35 work by this entire team. So um thanks for the recognition. So regardless of tonight's outcome though, I wish every
22:42 elected uh official wisdom and strength and success in serving the people who have placed their trust in them. So may
22:50 we always remember that what unites us as Americans is far greater than what divides us. So, God bless Clermont, God bless those who serve, and God bless America.
23:00 Thank you, Commissioner Hoisington.
23:02 Thank you, Mr. Chair. Um, I too want to express the importance of exercising
23:09 your right to vote. Hope everyone has taken that opportunity to vote. Um, congratulations on our city for being
23:17 recognized. That's why I guess we'll call the city of champions.
23:20 Um, and also I just want to mention I want to thank the members of the council for approving the initiative for a
23:28 community center in Clermont, South Lake County. It took us 7 years
23:36 12 months and 9 days or 9 months and 12 days to get it before the council and to get an official vote. We're excited.
23:44 We're looking forward to working with city staff um establishing public partners, public private partnerships to
23:52 bringing services for all of the citizens of South Lake County.
24:00 Um thank you. Go ahead if if you like. Council, it's nice to see you join us.
24:08 Uh a quick question. Are we allowed to use laptops when we're looking at a map on a they thus
24:17 are you allowed to use the laptop to look at the map? Yes.
24:22 Like the give me what kind of is it if I had a laptop in front of me right now and I look at a map. Am I allowed to use that?
24:30 Maybe. Um, so is it a map that is being introduced by staff or one of the parties or is it just a map you're looking at that isn't otherwise a part of the hearing?
24:40 It's part of the packages. Oh, then sure. You are. Yeah.
24:45 I was under adisement. I wasn't allowed to use that from previous council. I'm just I'm just asking.
24:53 Nobody's perfect.
24:55 All right. Thank you. Um, and I just want to thank the city for doing a great National Night Out event. Um, this was the first time that I can remember that
25:03 it did not conflict with our planning and zoning meeting. So, I'm not sure who schedules that event, but it it was a really really great event. It was nice nice to have it when it was not on the
25:11 same night that we have a meeting. Um, so we're going to open up the uh the public hearing part of the meeting. Um, just for everybody's information, we
25:20 will start with the staff report on each item. We will then hear from the applicant. We will then ask for public comment and then we will bring it back
25:27 to the commission for discussion and questions. So we will start with item number one.
25:43 Good evening planning and zoning commissioners and guests. Justine day with development services.
25:52 I'm just trying to zoom in just a smidge. Sorry. Okay. Daryl Bearer on behalf of Fine Inc.
26:00 Studios is requesting a conditional use permit to allow for a permanent body art and piercing establishment to operate within suite one of the existing building located at 450 East Highway 50.
26:12 The property is an improved site and designated with the C2 general commercial zoning district.
26:18 on your screen. The property is outlined in yellow.
26:24 And here it is again, just a little bit zoomed in.
26:29 The proposed establishment would provide services such as tattooing, body piercing to clients by appointment or
26:36 walk-in. The establishment would also provide formal mentorship and professional uh sorry formal mentorship to
26:45 professional artists operating be required to maintain licenses and records in accordance with the Florida statutes and Florida administrative
26:52 code. These regulations also require that the establishment and staff uh are required to maintain a waste management
27:00 plan addressing the proper handling, sanitation, and disposal of equipment and waste involved in the procedures being performed. Inspection for
27:08 compliance with the applicable regulations will occur regularly by the Florida Department of Health. And on your screen is just some um examples of
27:18 what the interior could look like at the site.
27:26 Okay.
27:28 The property contains a 12,000t building with parking approved for office and personal service establishment use.
27:36 Based on the nature and the intensity of the proposed use, staff finds the use comparable to a personal service establishment. Additionally, other
27:44 jurisdictions typically interprets the proposed use as a personal service use.
27:49 Since parking was originally calculated on the site for office and/or personal service establishments, additional parking may not be required.
27:58 Because the land development codes does not specifically identify tattoo or body piercing establishments as a permitted use, approval of a conditional use
28:06 permit is required. Staff finds the proposed use compatible with the C2 district, which permits personal service establishments and accessory permanent
28:15 uh makeup services. Staff reviewed the application in accordance with the land development code section 1012 and finds
28:24 the proposed use can meet the general criteria for approval and will not be detrimental to the health, safety, and welfare of the surrounding community.
28:31 Therefore, staff recommends approval of resolution number 2026-042.
28:37 And just to point out on your screen, that is the um existing building on the site. Um it's not showing but outlined
28:46 on the right hand side is the location of where they would be in that um building. Um proposed location has about 60 spaces based on the site plan.
28:59 And then just to give you an idea of what the building uh currently looks like and what the inside floor plan
29:06 would be. This concludes staff presentation.
29:10 All right. Thank you very much. Would the applicant like to come up?
29:22 You're welcome. Thank you.
29:24 Um just wondering if you have any questions for us at all.
29:29 Do you want to just tell us a little bit um about what you're intending to do here?
29:32 Well um we have 25 locations. We're the first franchise in the United States and the first franchise in Florida obviously of for tattoo studios and body piercing.
29:41 [snorts] We have 25 locations, 21 in the Orlando area and four in Tampa. Scott and I, my partner, we have seven
29:49 locations between the two of us that we own and operate in Okoi, um, Orlando and Waterford Lakes.
29:57 Okay.
29:59 So, I'll speak a little bit. My my back background is in franchise development.
30:03 So we've basically taken, you know, like H handed Stone took the massage business that was kind of a back alley business, turned it into a reputable, you know,
30:10 business. It's in every shopping center now with Massage Envy and Handed Stone.
30:14 So basically doing the same thing with the tattoo industry now. It was used to be bikers and convicts. Now it's, you know, mothers, daughters, and granddaughters that come in. And as you
30:23 kind of saw by the images that are up there, you know, it's a it's a clean, professional salon look uh that we've done there. So we've been looking to to
30:30 find a good location in Clermont. we've been looking for for a couple of years now and finally, you know, found a location that we're we're excited about, feel, you know, it fits fits the the
30:39 image that we want and uh represents, you know, Clermont well and there's there's a need here certainly with the with the growth um in the area with the
30:47 younger, you know, younger clientele, our primary clientele is that, you know, 18 to 35 year old target market that we have. So, that's the big part of the
30:54 growth that's going on in Clermont. So, we feel like we we fill a existing need that's there.
31:00 Okay. All right. Well, thank you. so much and uh please stand by for questions.
31:03 David, can you have them say their names and Yes. Yes. For the record, skip that part. There we go. I didn't I didn't see it on the agenda.
31:11 [laughter]
31:11 I'm I'm Scott Anderson. Uh Daryl Bear. Address. Uh personal address. Yeah.
31:18 Oh, yeah. Uh 436 Hitchcock Street, Lady Lake, Florida. Lady Lady. Yeah.
31:24 Clermont. Oh, there we go. 3009 Santa Maria Avenue, Clermont. Thank you. All right. Yes, I voted.
31:33 Okay, here we go.
31:34 All right, bonus points.
31:35 Thank you so much. And anyone else who comes up and speaks, uh, we we do ask that you give, uh, your your name and address. So, thank you. Thank you so much. And, um,
31:43 we we appreciate that. Would anybody from the public like to uh to come up and and make a comment?
31:50 We go too far. I have questions.
31:54 All right. Seeing no one, I will bring it back to the uh to the commission. So, um, we'll start to my far right. We'll start with Commissioner Hoisington.
32:03 Thank you, Mr. Chair. Um, I guess have this question is for staff. Um, help me understand the difference in accessory
32:11 use versus permanent body makeup like what is accessory use when you're talking about a tattoo parlor? So the code
32:20 specifies that only permanent makeup services is permitted but as an accessory use to like a salon in this
32:29 case. However, nowhere else in the code does it specify anything about regular tattoo establishments.
32:37 Okay.
32:40 and they've identified ways in which they will ensure that all of their waste is properly taken care of that
32:50 it's not going to impact the general public. We're good with that.
32:54 So that would actually be identified by the Florida statutes and the Florida administrative code. Um department of health would typically inspect them to
33:03 ensure that they are disposing of biomedical waste properly. Um, and they inspect it, I want to say, at least once a year, if not more, depending on what
33:12 they go by. Okay. Is this our first tattoo parlor in Clermont? I believe so. Yes.
33:21 Okay, that's all I have at this time.
33:23 Okay, Commissioner Kramer. Thank you, Chair. So, um, Justine, how's the parking?
33:33 So, good question because I just fixed the photo. Um so for the building itself, if it was to be reviewed um as a
33:40 personal establishment, which based on other jurisdictions as well as my professional opinion, I believe it would
33:48 fit in the same intensity. Um parking would be then calculated based off of p personal service establishments, which
33:57 is 1 to 200 square ft. The building is about 12,000 square feet and the parking
34:03 at the site would be 60 spaces. So, they meet that requirement. Um, there's about I want to say seven suites within there.
34:12 So, if there's not one suite being occupied, whatever spaces that previous owner will now be just transferred over to the new owner.
34:20 Okay. So, I'm hearing from staff with confidence that the the parking is adequate. Correct.
34:26 Okay. Um, since this is unique for us, are there any health or safety or licensing compliances that we need to be aware of that are unusual for this case?
34:37 I don't think it would be unusual. Um, it is our first time doing a personal well, a tattooing and a piercing
34:46 establishment. So, just keep in mind that it is all going to be handled by the Department of Health. Um, inspections are going to be handled by
34:53 them, complaints as well. That doesn't mean someone can't call in to make a complaint, but you'll be getting the state involved with the city if needed.
35:03 Thanks, Justine. Um, any concerns around um any of the businesses around that? I
35:11 So, you guys are taking over the entire building or just portion of it?
35:17 Why don't you come up to the microphone because I'm sure we're going to have a few more questions for you guys anyway.
35:21 So, speak the health code department also ask more detail on that.
35:29 Sure. Um for the health department and we um our the company we have contracted is um let me just get the official name for it's called Medical Disposal
35:37 Systems. They come in um every two weeks to make sure they take all our biohazard material out and everything's bagged up
35:44 in red bags. We're in compliance 614E compliance code for that biohazard license. So all that stuff's taken care
35:51 of and like she said um the health department comes in for the initial inspection then they come back um with unannounced visits every six months. So
36:00 we get we get twice a year we have them come in and all of our artists are licensed and all of they go through our training program and all of everybody's
36:07 licensed by the state. Um, as it comes to the other, uh, businesses in there, um, we spoke and there's two barber
36:14 shops there for some reason, which is kind of strange, but there's two barber shops in that location, and we spoke to them, and they're excited that we're going to be there. And there's also a roofing company that we spoke with. And,
36:23 uh, so you're taking over the front side, the the part that sits right on 50 shaped right there, 2500 ft of the,000.
36:35 I see. I see it now.
36:38 There's also a I see it or it's previously been approved for a somewhere in the building was approved for permanent makeup which is the same
36:47 same you know micro blading that we're under. That's the same licensing for tattooing.
36:52 Okay. And then um we don't have any concerns um going back to Justine, we don't have any concerns with adjacency
36:59 or any um of the businesses in that area.
37:06 Concerns regarding the use parking I mean any concerns about putting from any of the neighbors? I know we probably sent some notice out or anything.
37:17 Yes. So we did follow the requirements to send out notices. The property as well had, I believe, two signs put on there, if not just one.
37:25 Um, but they should have been notified already. Property owner of the building itself should have been notified. I
37:33 don't see why anyone would be missed at that point.
37:38 Um, but that would be also handled by the tenants and the owner of the building if they wanted to speak to the
37:45 other tenants regarding the use going in the suite.
37:49 Thank you, Justine. I have no further questions, chair.
37:51 The just to speak to that also the uh the building owner also was notified. He had to sign off on the fact that he was okay with us going into the building. So that's been submitted.
37:59 Thank you, Chair. All right. Thank you, Mr. Anemic.
38:04 Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Uh to the applicant, I have a few questions. I don't know if you can hear me. There you go. All right. How would this benefit besides taxes to the city of Claymont?
38:15 How would your business benefit us? I'm asking the applicant. That's you. Okay. How does it benefit?
38:23 She did a lot of research apparently besides tax. Well, um, we have a lot of individuals that go to our Koi location.
38:29 So, it's going to cut down on people that have to travel so far to come see us because, uh, Scott's really good at looking at demographics and where people come from. And between our location in
38:37 Koe and the one and four corners, all the people that live in Clermont or the Eustace area or Minnola are coming to those locations. So there is a need for
38:46 a tattoo studio in this area because we're pulling from the closest tattoo studio I think from ours is 18 miles away when you're heading west. So
38:54 there's really nothing out here at all when it comes to tattoo studios except for the two that are in Minnola.
39:00 And the way I as a resident here, you know, the growth in the city is it used to be a retirement community. I think we
39:07 all know that. Now it's gone to a younger community. Certainly as you go up towards Minnola, it's younger families, which is really what the the
39:14 clientele is. So there's there's a demand, there's an interest. How do you create that young energy like the the downtown revitalization that's going on, you know, they're not targeting my
39:23 people, you know, they're targeting, you know, a younger group, which is kind of the same clientele. So I feel like we fill that need that's continuing to grow.
39:31 Thank you to the man, uh, gentleman in black. That was a very good answer.
39:35 Uh, to staff real one quick question. Uh I believe two and a half years ago there
39:42 was one right next to Dunkin Donuts on 27. Is this the same company that's seeking a tattoo? Paula, that was us.
39:50 That was us. That was you. Okay.
39:52 We were going to apply and then we Right. Then you backed out of it. Exactly.
39:55 What are the odds of you backing out of this property now? I'm sorry. Say again.
40:00 What are the odds of you backing out of this property?
40:04 So, no, we're still finalizing the lease with the landlord, but it's just up to the landlord right now because we're ready to go. We have all of our artists ready to go. We've got
40:12 everything just kind of ready to go. As soon as we get the approval to go, then we're in it.
40:16 Leading to my other question, what time limit you looking at? Six months, three months, one month.
40:23 Two months. Estimate. Oh, yeah. Within two months. Two months. Okay. To do the inside at all. I'm sorry. I didn't hear you.
40:31 I'm sorry. I I was just going to say there's not a lot of work for us to do to come in here just buying the equipment and getting everything put in because the building is beautiful on the inside. There's just a little bit of paint that we have to do and that's about it.
40:40 Conceptional plans doesn't look like a regular Louisiana tattoo para so I'm impressed. Uh my other commissioners hit the nail on the head with the parking.
40:51 Uh that is a concern to me. But once again, what do I most of our I'm sorry to interrupt, but um like Scott was saying earlier, to me
40:59 it's like most of our businesses, you know, we're open till later in the evening. So those businesses will be closed because we're open to 8:00 during the week and 10 o'clock on the weekend.
41:07 So you must be a mind readader because that was my next question. Your hours of operation, uh we open every day at 11 o'clock. We close at 6:00 on Sunday. Um Monday,
41:15 Tuesday, Wednesday 8:00 and Thursday, Friday, Saturday 10 o'clock.
41:19 All right. that somebody somebody's doing a large tattoo. How many times do you go into overtime?
41:25 Um, not a lot cuz we don't like doing that to our artists, you know, because they're 1099 employees. So, we really don't like try to push them to stay
41:32 longer. We try to I tell all my artists that if a tattoo takes you longer than a half hour, that's allowed. That's all we really want to do is just longer than a
41:39 half hour. So, in our booking department, when we book tattoos, we kind of make sure that all our clients know that we want to be done and out by half hour at least after time we close.
41:47 Okay. Uh, what about any fumes, aroma?
41:51 Nothing at all since you own several other ones.
41:55 Yeah, there will be nothing at all like that. I mean, will you be having any alcohol on site?
42:00 Um, there is um there's 70% um alcohol just to do some cleaning and that's about it for the And that's the only alcohol you're going
42:08 to have. Somebody's not going to walk in with a bottle of Jack Daniels. Oh, no. That kind of alcohol. No.
42:15 So, like Scott was saying earlier, it's like we kind of look at ourselves as the Disney spring of tattoo studios. No, seriously.
42:22 Look at Yeah. Looking at exceptional plants coming in. I I'm piercing little cuz I'm a piercer. I'm also I pierce at one of the locations is,
42:29 you know, I have kids that are two, three years old getting their ears pierced for the first time and then that's cute. 14, 15 years old getting pierced, you know. So, we're
42:37 no vulgar music, no vulgar radio stations being played. Everything is like, you know, we're Oh, that's in your Yeah.
42:43 Yeah. that's in your C. Uh, last final question that I see that I have is I'm a little concerned about the garbage like my fellow commissioner brought up, but I
42:52 wanted to know uh pretty much the schedule. You said one they come once every two weeks. Is that correct?
42:59 So, let's say you have an abundant amount of needles and ink and tissues and all. Where do you store?
43:05 So, we have um there's waste receptacles inside the studio that are red bagged and we have sharps containers. So we for
43:12 all of our sharps that hang on the walls or each artist has a sharps container and it takes a long time before it gets filled up.
43:21 Long time one. Yeah. Okay. Two weeks. I understand.
43:24 I I know it. I come out. Sometimes they come out and we don't have anything for them to pick up. But they come out on a regular basis.
43:31 It's a check. We don't call them to come pick it up because we're overfilling. They just come on a regular basis.
43:35 Is there like let's say you have an abundant amount you can have the option to call and they will call they will come within the next day.
43:44 All right. I like it so far. Uh no further questions, Mr. Chairman. Thank you, Commissioner May.
43:51 Since we were on the topic of uh the schedule, can you repeat that because it's a little different than what we have in the conditions.
43:58 11 to 6 on Sunday, 11 to 8 on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, 11 to 10 on Thursday, Friday, Saturday.
44:09 So, just to let the staff know, we have in our on page 25, sorry,
44:17 we have Monday to Thursday. So, that should be changed to Monday to Wednesday 11:00 a.m. to 8:00 p.m.
44:24 Thursday, Friday to Saturday, 11 to 10 p.m. Is that correct, sir? Yes, ma'am. Okay. And then Sunday, uh, 11 to 6 p.m. Yes, ma'am.
44:31 Okay. Just wanted to clarify since you had said something different that was in the paper.
44:38 So, how many customers do you have usually? Like that's the average. Yeah. So, we're a day, a week.
44:45 Um, it all depends. We're in the KO location. We're doing eight tattoos tomorrow. I know that's what I have on the books for tomorrow is eight tattoos and probably about a half a dozen
44:52 piercings so far. Um, we have six artists, tattoo artists that will be on site and um, two one piercer. So at any
45:01 given time you could have six people getting tattooed and one or two people waiting in the lobby and then one or two people getting pierced. So
45:10 it it depends. You know the weekends are busier than during the week. Okay.
45:16 It's a strange business where a busy day will be like 15 or 20 people. Yeah.
45:20 Yeah. Because the average is $150 $200, you know, per client.
45:24 Yeah. I just want to make sure on this all goes back to parking. Right. Because I know I I I counted 13 parking spaces
45:33 um from looking at the map, but um I'm going back to the staff Justine on the on what we have here which says existing
45:42 buildings and you have like little dots with numbers 168. Is that is that corresponds to the parking spots or
45:49 Yes. So basically when someone gives a site plan, they'll give a a little chart on the side with the total actual
45:56 spaces. But for our codes, when we're uh just double-checking how many spaces are in a line, sometimes they are required a
46:04 um like a little parking island in between those spaces. So, they'll also write out how many spaces are in that area before it's broken up by the next island.
46:13 Okay. So, those circles then are parking spaces. Correct.
46:16 Okay. And you're saying that we have 60 spaces total, correct?
46:19 For the 12,000 ft. Okay. And how many tenants do we have in that building?
46:23 about seven based on um the information that I can find online.
46:30 Seven tenants and you're saying average you can probably get between 13 and 20 you were saying sir in regards to the parking on a on a day. So that's on a on your 10-hour day.
46:40 On a 10-hour day. Yeah.
46:41 Okay. I just want to So we may six or eight in there at one time. Six, you know, six or eight artists. Yeah. Probably max we'd have maybe 12.
46:49 12. Okay. And that would be typically that would be like the roofer is the closest. He's our next door neighbor if you will, right around the corner from us. And they're obviously working.
46:57 They're they're daytime. They're not weekend. So nights and weekends would be the time when we number busiest would be the weekends. Okay.
47:06 Um you answered that question.
47:18 So I see that um you're an established brand, 25 locations, 21 in Orlando area, four in
47:25 Tampa. You guys own seven AOE, Orlando, Clermont. Uh no alcohol will be sold and all work will be done indoors, no
47:35 parties, no nothing outside, no events, everything is all inside. [snorts] Um it was recently a spa, so it kind of plays
47:42 pretty well with uh with what you guys are doing. Trying to see if there's anything else that I have here. I think everybody else asked the right questions.
47:51 Nope, I think uh I think I'm good. So, thank you very much. You're welcome. Commissioner Teddona.
47:56 Good evening, gentlemen. Um, six tattoo artists, one piercer. Are they all working those hours or will they
48:05 fluctuate? Half a day here, different start times, things like that? No, they all start at the same time.
48:11 So, they'll all be doing the same hours all week.
48:14 Okay. You mentioned something about uh $125 to like $200 for a tattoo. Are you specializing in like small pieces?
48:23 That's the the average tattoo. So 70% of our clientele are female between um the ages of what 18 to 33 and they always get small fine line tattoos, but then we
48:32 do some bigger pieces every once in a while, but that's our average tattoo based on all of our studios.
48:36 Okay. So if somebody had to come back for several sittings, it's possible. Correct. Absolutely.
48:41 Okay. Thank you. I don't have no further questions, sir.
48:45 Thank you. Um I I personally really I I think it's it's upscale. I think it's good for the community. I really like the um the renderings that you have of
48:53 indoors and it's very tasteful. What about outdoors? What what's the signage going to look like on the building?
48:59 I The building is kind of our color code. It's a black and white building.
49:02 It's like we're not really touching anything outside at all. It's just the inside what we're going to do. Maybe some um a couple window graphics, some
49:10 honeycomb window graphics, and that's about it. And hopefully if we get approved to put a sign, we'd like to put a backlit sign of on in the um at apex right there above the doors.
49:20 Okay. Thank you. Um I do want to ask if uh any commissioners um have any other questions? Commissioner Hoisington, do
49:27 you have anything? Um I think you were pretty thorough and the commissioners asked some really good questions. Um any any questions? Anybody?
49:38 All right. I'll entertain a motion at this time. I'd like to make a motion to approve resolution number 2026-042R finding studios conditional use permit.
49:51 I'll second it. All right, we have a motion in a second. All in favor? I discussions. Do we have a discussion?
49:59 Yes, we we Yes, we can have discussion.
50:00 Okay, so um before we make that I mean we have to add the additional uh changes. Was that already done in
50:07 regards to the hours? So, oh, council, we need to add that.
50:13 Yeah, you're you're talking about the correction to the operating hours. Yeah, that should be made by the So, do you want to restate your motion?
50:21 So, I'd like to make a motion to approve resolution number 2026-042R finding studios conditional use permit
50:29 with the amended notations correcting the operating hours.
50:35 Okay, motion. [snorts] Do we have a second? I'll second it. All in favor? I.
50:42 And the chair votes eye. That is unanimous. Thank you very much, Jenny. Thank you very much. Good job, guys.
50:50 Okay, it looks like item two has been withdrawn. So, we will go to item number three.
51:00 So, we'll be presenting item number three, four, and five together. I assume that is correct.
51:06 Well, good evening planning and zoning commissioners and guests. Nick Gonzalez Development Services. This is the agenda item 3, four, and five. John's Lake
51:14 Auto. Jimmy Crawford on behalf of Kromar Groves, Inc. and Cand Sadler is requesting a small-cale comprehensive
51:22 plan amendment reszoning and cup for the vacant property that is located south of State Road 50 east of Ray Good Game
51:29 Boulevard and is approximately 21.53 acres. The subject property is located within the ISBA area and the joint
51:37 planning area. And the property entered a utility service agreement with the city in November 2007 to receive water and wastewater services.
51:52 The proposed map amendment will change the future land use designation from Lake County's urban low to city's
51:59 commercial. Uh under policy 1.12.3 of the city's comp plan encourages the voluntary annexations uh when compatible
52:08 with uh with services that can be properly provided and when proposed uses are compatible with the city's comp plan. The property is located along
52:18 State Road 50 corridor, an area characterized by established and planned commercial uses. The commercial future land use of this site is a logical
52:26 extension of the city boundary and is consistent and compatible with the existing development pattern along this corridor.
52:34 The proposed resoning would change from Lake County PUD and Agriculture to City C2 general commercial.
52:46 The property was originally developed under Lake County's PUD with the most recent amendment being ordinance 2021-32
52:54 which allows the Cromar property tract M. That's
53:01 this section right here is the track M portion of the property.
53:09 uh that allowed 161,000 square foot square feet of C2 commercial uses excluding adult entertainment, gas
53:17 stations, automobile dealerships, automobile parts stores, car washes, and automotive repair. The county PUB also
53:25 allows an unlimited grading variance to accommodate the interface with State Road 50. The property also consists of lakes, wetlands, and storm water ponds
53:34 that would count towards the required open space.
53:38 As development along the surrounding corridor has progressed over the years, the area has transitioned to a mix of residential and commercial uses.
53:46 Commercial development has concentrated along the Highway 50 corridor, including large furniture retailers, restaurants, shopping plazas, and automotive
53:55 dealerships. The C2 general commercial designation is consistent with existing nearby uses, aligns with the city's commercial standards along State Road
54:03 50, and will ensure consistent development regulations, signage standards, and administrative procedures for this established commercial area. In
54:12 the C2 zoning district, any use for an automobile dealership, car wash, and automotive repair facility would require
54:19 a conditional use permit. The applicant proposes one.
54:26 Let me just zoom this out just a little bit.
54:34 The applicant proposes one building of approximately 43,000 square ft that will operate as a car dealership. Operations may include
54:42 car washing services and automotive repair. The property may also be developed with any permitted uses allowed in the C2 general zoning
54:50 commission. zoning district and the city's land development regulations. The hours of operation shall be limited to
54:57 Monday through Sunday, 7:30 a.m. to 8:00 p.m. No outside speaker systems will be permitted at the site, and the car wash
55:05 shall use a water recycling system for washing vehicles.
55:14 The applicant has requested two waiverss. The project may include a maximum fill of up to 39 ft and a
55:21 maximum cut up to 34 feet across approximately 34% of the project area.
55:27 Under Lake County's PUD, a limited grading on the site was granted due to the topography changes. The final cut fill calculations will be submitted to
55:36 the city engineer at the time of final engineering. The maximum height of any retaining wall shall not exceed 10 ft
55:43 with a minimum horizontal spacing of 10 ft between wall tiers. To soften the visual effect of heartscape features, an
55:50 additional landscaping shall be installed along retaining walls visible from State Road 50. And here is an example of the west facing wall that will have the additional landscaping.
56:03 Zoom in.
56:09 As part of the development program, a lake cleanup and restoration effort on the lake located on the western portion of the property shall occur no later
56:17 than 5 years from the date of this resolution. The applicant will also construct a recreational park amenity along the lake boundary on the western
56:25 portion of the site, including a walking trail, benches, and parking as shown as on the conceptual plan. This amenity
56:32 will be donated to the city upon completion.
56:36 Staff has reviewed the application and find the proposed use compatible with the district. The State Road 50 corridor has transitioned into a heavily
56:43 commercialized area characterized by automotive, retail, and service based uses. An automobile dealership, car
56:50 wash, and automotive repair facility are consistent with the existing development pattern along the corridor and are similar in scale and intensity to neighboring commercial establishments.
57:01 The proposed use benefits from direct access to major arterial generated generating traffic primarily from
57:08 regional and pass trips rather than local neighborhood streets. As a result, the use is not anticipated to be more
57:16 intensive or disruptive than any other C2 commercial uses.
57:20 Staff has reviewed the request for small-cale comp plan amendment resoning and conditional use permit and finds that the proposed comp plan amendment
57:28 meets the requirement that the city is capable of serving the property and is consistent with the city's comp plan.
57:34 Staff has finds that the proposed zoning at this location is compatible with the uses in the area and the requested C2 general commercial designation is
57:43 consistent with the city's comp plan and land development regulations. And when evaluating a request for a conditional
57:49 use permit, section 101-212 of the land development code requires the specific development standards be
57:56 met. Staff finds that the proposed use can meet the general standards for approval. The proposed automobile dealership and related uses will not be
58:05 detrimental to the health, safety, or welfare of the surrounding community and will operate compatible with the commercial corridor. Therefore, staff
58:12 recommends approval of ordinance 2026-038, ordinance 2026-039, and resolution number 2026-044R.
58:24 And that concludes SAS presentation.
58:26 Thank you very much. I'd like to invite the applicant to come up and tell us about your plans. Come on up and state your name and address.
58:37 Uh good evening, Mr. Chairman, commissioners, staff. Uh my name is Jimmy Crawford. I'm an attorney with Crawford Modic and Holt. Our address is
58:46 702 West Montro Street, Clermont, Florida. And I do represent the owner and the applicant, the owners, two of them, and the applicant uh in this case.
58:56 Um I have with us tonight representing the owner developer Tad Dixon uh and two
59:04 uh civil engineers from KPM Franklin, Robbie Moon and Phil Hollowman. And when the questions get rather technical and
59:11 you need engineering kind of answers, I'm going to call those handsome young men up to take over for me. Um,
59:19 we agree with the staff report. We have worked hard through several concept plans. Our original grading proposals
59:26 were significantly larger than what um we wound up with after working through with staff. And I only have a few points that I would like to emphasize.
59:38 Um, the first would be here. I've got a little cheat sheet. Sorry.
59:47 Um, this is from the county GIS map with my very sophisticated uh drawings and
59:57 visual aids. Um these are 12 existing vehicle dealerships
1:00:06 uh along the along this corridor. It's almost it's a right at 2 miles from the Orange County line to Napleton which is
1:00:14 this one. Um there is Napleton Dodge and then we have two uh boat dealerships and
1:00:22 a golf cart dealer that are in the three and four location there. Uh, five is CarMax, six is Tesla, seven is Toyota,
1:00:32 eight Chevrolet, nine Hyundai, 10 Mazda, 11 Kia, 12 Honda, and we are the red uh
1:00:40 dot right there across from Autoplex Lane.
1:00:44 Um, the existing entitlement is really important for this one because this is
1:00:53 part of the John's Lake Landing PUB that has been developing over the last 20 plus years along there. Um, and the
1:01:02 existing entitlements include for this parcel 161,000 square feet of C2 uses in
1:01:10 the county. Um, we are planning that this 43,000 square foot building and I
1:01:17 know the engineers have looked at the traffic and we've also submitted a traffic study or traffic report uh to the the uh city through that as well.
1:01:28 And I know it's a substantial reduction in traffic compared to the 161,000 square feet of commercial that we have
1:01:36 entitled in the county. There is also importantly an unlimited wall and
1:01:44 grading allocation in the existing PUD. You could grade there's there's no limit for
1:01:52 the county for that. It's grandfathered in from oh I hate that word. I'm sorry.
1:01:57 It's vested from the counties or or the JPA regulations that existed prior to that.
1:02:06 Um, we are offering to limit our building size to the 43,000
1:02:14 square feet, limit the walls and the grading to the minimum that are required. This if you you drive past it all the time. I'm sure almost all of you
1:02:22 do. And it's a very challenging site. I believe almost 80 feet of fall from one corner to the other. and it has
1:02:31 artificial grades on three sides because of road building and subdivision building. Um, we also have offered to um
1:02:41 restore the lake if you've noticed it's rather degraded and grown over and silted in. And then build and donate the
1:02:50 lake amenity which will include include a walking trail, a parking area, um, and the ability to, uh, we want to do some
1:02:59 kind of small dock and pier, but that's subject to permitting by the water management district in the state. So, we have to see about that, but definitely
1:03:08 walking trail, boardwalk, parking area, picnic area, that type of thing. Uh, we are also doing extra landscaping for the
1:03:16 walls that face highway 50 and also extra space. The code requires 5t between the walls. Honestly, there isn't
1:03:26 much landscaping that you can plant that will survive and will not destroy your
1:03:32 walls with only the five feet. So we are proposing 10 feet between the walls. So we can plant substantial landscaping.
1:03:41 You still can't do live oaks. They're going to spread out over a 30 foot roof coverage over 20, 30, 40 years. But you
1:03:50 can do podacarpus, you can do bamboo, you can do crepe myrtle, you can do all the palms, you can do all the kinds of
1:03:58 things that will minimize the view of that wall from uh highway 50, which is the only place that people will be able to see it from.
1:04:08 Um, importantly, and as Commissioner Tedona was saying, uh, at the beginning of the
1:04:15 meeting, you know, we we are a bedroom community, and that's kind of a bad word. Tax-wise, it's really a bad word.
1:04:22 It may be a whole lot worse tomorrow.
1:04:24 We'll see. Um the the their the two major commercial
1:04:32 generators uh of taxes for South Lake County and Clermont are auto dealerships and
1:04:38 multif family. Uh multif family are actually valued each usually a bit higher. They go up to 60 $70 million of assessed value for a 300 unit complex.
1:04:52 Um, but if you and you might if you want to follow along. If not, I can put it up here. Page 70 and 71 of the
1:05:01 packet is part of our statement in support where we analyzed
1:05:08 the tax revenue and the employment from the auto dealerships that are along that corridor. Now, uh, Toyota of Clermont,
1:05:17 um, paid last year Lake County $253,469
1:05:24 for property tax. The city received over 72,000 of that one year. In the last 10
1:05:32 years, Toyota's paid Lake County a million8, of which the city received approximately 507,000.
1:05:41 Lake County schools received approximately 700,000 over the last 10 years. Um,
1:05:48 if you assume that the other nine dealerships are similar to that, and I didn't go through and analyze each
1:05:57 individual one because honestly, some of these numbers are not available very easily for all of them. Uh but that means these 10 dealerships have
1:06:06 contributed approximately uh $18 million in property taxes to Lake County over 10 years, of which the city has received just over 5 million.
1:06:18 Um the schools have received right at 7 million for these 10 dealerships over the past decade. And I would note that
1:06:26 these assessments go up every year. And in the last three to four years, they've been going up 10 15% per year. Um, so
1:06:36 these will only get larger. Another public benefit is employment. Toyota of Clermont employs over 200 people. The
1:06:45 salary paying website Glass Door lists the dealership average pay as a sales associate 56 to over $100,000 per year.
1:06:58 Product specialist 51,000.
1:07:00 Finance representative 88,000. These are the averages from the website. Service
1:07:06 advisor 65,000. Service technician $25 an hour. Administrative $24.50 an hour.
1:07:15 Uh the Census Bureau says the average income for Lake County residents is 38,577.
1:07:22 It's clear that the dealerships provide quality paying jobs for Lake County with the ability to move up in the system as
1:07:30 as you're there. Uh if the other nine dealerships have similar employment numbers, which a few are bigger, several
1:07:38 are smaller. So I'm just trying to this is just an average and my uh best estimate as to what that means that
1:07:46 these 10 ex existing dealerships employ approximately 2,000 individuals most of
1:07:54 whom are uh residents of South Lake County at salaries substantially higher than the Lake County average. Um lastly,
1:08:04 I would note that the use is also consistent with the proposed comprehensive plan as it exists right
1:08:12 now. This would be uh an allowed use uh at this location. And that's all I
1:08:20 wanted to add to the staff report. We'll be happy to answer questions from commissioners as well as my technical support people. and then we would like
1:08:29 to hear from the public and have a chance to respond as well.
1:08:32 Yes. Thank you. Uh I'll give you an opportunity to respond to anybody from the public and then before we bring it back to commission. Thank you very much. I won't go far.
1:08:39 Thank you, Mr. Crawford. All right, we will open it up for public comment at this time. If you'd like to um make a comment, ask any questions, please come
1:08:48 up and state your name and address, please.
1:08:57 Good evening.
1:08:59 My name is Joy Zubkin. I live at 17405 Cobblestone Lane in Magnolia Point. I've
1:09:07 lived there for 37 years. I've been here a long time. I've lived here since we've had Orange Groves and I've seen the
1:09:16 development of this community for a very long time.
1:09:21 I've also heard promises from earlier commissioners, from the city mayor, from South Lake um
1:09:30 president of the South Lake Hospital that said that they were very interested in controlled growth. And this was a community that I think deserved to have
1:09:39 controlled growth. And I think the last thing that we wanted for us residents here was to have what you would consider
1:09:46 maybe a Pine Hills situation where there was car dealerships after car dealerships after car dealerships after
1:09:53 fast food restaurants and fast food restaurants. But that's what we have. In fact, some people in the Orlando area
1:10:01 consider Clermont Alultimont Springs West.
1:10:05 Alimont Springs West, as you know, is very, very congested.
1:10:09 We have the same situation here. Up until the time where state road 50 became three lanes in both directions,
1:10:16 we had miles and miles of traffic going way into Clermont. And I live in Magnolia Point and there are traffic
1:10:24 accidents in the intersection of Magnolia Point and a Boulevard and 50.
1:10:28 And there are traffic accidents that block the whole intersection. And there's traffic accidents that go into in front of Deer Island and in Oakland
1:10:36 area which back up that that whole State Road 50 area. But more importantly on Saturday and Sunday I can't get from my
1:10:45 house to Publix. I think you all know where that is without sitting in traffic for 10 minutes.
1:10:55 Now, there is an interchange in the median right where this property is where there's an opening that you can do a turnaround.
1:11:04 Right in that area, there's the Tesla dealership, there's the Toyota dealership.
1:11:10 Cars compete, leaving those dealerships and challenge
1:11:16 cars on State Road 50 to rush bum them and cross the street dangerously.
1:11:24 and causing accidents. And the cars coming down State Road 50 kind of realize this. They see these cars down the slope. They see them coming out.
1:11:32 They see what they're going to do. And you have to anticipate it or else you're going to get into an accident. And there's a lot of us that leave an opening and allow people to pass. But
1:11:41 now you're going to have a another car dealership. And I'm glad he put that up there. You've got 13 car dealerships up
1:11:49 there all in less than a mile from each other. Less than a mile. That's Pine Hills.
1:11:58 And you have no way of controlling traffic based on what we see now.
1:12:05 So, not only you're going to have cars rushing traffic across State Road 50 coming from the north side, but you're going to have cars rushing out from the
1:12:13 west side. and you're going to have a median in the middle that's opened where they're going to try to jog in there.
1:12:21 So, you're going to have a big huge concern about ingress and egress in this property.
1:12:29 The the the the the picture that uh Mr. Crawford put up
1:12:36 showed an ingress or egress that kind of swoops down along his property or his pro proposed property and around the new
1:12:45 development where all the condos or apartments are and out to Magnolia Point Boulevard. We do not want any additional
1:12:53 traffic entering Magnolia Point Boulevard's entrance at all. We are an upscale community. We have high-end
1:13:01 homes there and we don't want any additional traffic in that in that entrance way area ever again. We're
1:13:09 dealing with enough what we have. We have cars right now in that development next to us that again because of the median in on that drive rush past
1:13:18 incoming traffic to the Magnolia Point and try to beat the traffic causing
1:13:24 accidents. Now our concern is traffic.
1:13:30 Our concern is this is a b this is more hardscape without landscape.
1:13:36 Our concern is that as you know we have a Toyota dealership that has a skyhigh sign. Um all the other dealerships have
1:13:44 their signs low. We don't know what kind of sign they're going to post.
1:13:48 We have got more hardscape coming in in the first part of entering Clermont.
1:13:53 the beautiful hills of Clermont showing landscape that's barely there.
1:14:00 We were promised when those car dealerships were coming in that there was going to be beautiful landscape.
1:14:04 Well, you have a tree and you have a bush that sits this high off the ground.
1:14:09 When you look at the Tesla dealership, you have lollipops as trees and little round balls on the ground for for for sh uh shrubs.
1:14:18 That's not beautifification. That's not pleasant to to to see.
1:14:23 As residents, when I was here initially, you could look up at the sky at night and you can see all the stars. Now you have white pollution. You have light pollution.
1:14:35 You can you take away all of the the wooded areas that you did to build the development next door and you have this little wooded area that's left that's
1:14:43 very very precious where this property sits. You take away the wooded areas and you have noise pollution. Those trees
1:14:51 protected the neighborhoods from the noise on State Road 50, which is now three lanes each way, six lanes and turn lanes.
1:15:01 So now when you look up at the sky, you see white.
1:15:06 You can't even even see the moon some nights because the car dealerships have their lights on full blast and you can't see anything.
1:15:14 Sometimes you can't see down the road because of how much light is in your neighborhood. Ma'am, I've been quite generous on your on your three minute Okay.
1:15:21 over. So if you could also I'm going to also tell you that if the commission is going to continue to allow this property
1:15:30 to be developed this way the commission has the means of curtailing some of the
1:15:38 property the development of the property or and beautifying the property by shrubs and trees and appropriate views
1:15:45 from the road which look beautiful and enhancing and not what we see right now in car dealerships.
1:15:51 Right now, we don't know anything about what this car dealership is going to look like really much. The the renderings today don't tell us anything.
1:15:58 We asked the commission to table this until we can get more of our community in front of the commission to talk about this further before they they move on.
1:16:08 We want you to consider the noise pollution, the light pollution, the controlled growth, parking lots as dealerships, the first two miles of State Road 50.
1:16:18 and um again to table this this discussion until we can get our community in front of you and you can hear us better. I I believe this this uh
1:16:26 issue was scheduled in some other time but then it was moved this time so only a few of us are appearing but I'm sure there would like to be more of us. Thank you.
1:16:34 Thank you.
1:16:37 Please come forward and state your name and address please.
1:16:43 We do have a three-minute timer. I will be generous with it but but do try to make your point. AB: Absolutely. Uh, good evening, commissioners. My name is
1:16:51 Alif Dreesbach. I live um 16910 Cedar Valley Circle. It is literally that red line on the bottom of that screen. Um, less than two years ago, oh, I'm sorry.
1:17:01 I am an attorney and a lifelong resident of Central Florida. Uh, less than two years ago, my husband and I p purchased our first home and it was that that
1:17:09 address. Our backyard faces that exact area that this proposal is meant to affect. Uh my family and our neighbors
1:17:17 uh will be affected by this decision from what we will see from our homes.
1:17:20 Obviously that is directly our backyard as well as our neighbors. What noise we will hear uh the light the lighting we experience at night which we already
1:17:28 have a significant amount of and most importantly likely add to the hourlong roundtrip uh it takes me to drive my children to school which should only
1:17:36 take 30 minutes. Uh we understand that commercial development is allowed here but that permission has historically come with express limitations. Um,
1:17:45 the county zoning documents for John's Lake Landing specifically exclude dealerships, car washes, and automobile
1:17:53 repair. I believe this was mentioned by the uh applicant. Uh, the very uses being requested here. In 2015, county staff explained that uh prohibited
1:18:01 commercial uses had been inadvertently omitted and recommended restoring them to correct that error error. And those exclusions appear again in the 2020 and
1:18:10 2021 ordinance packet. So, there is a a legislative history and intent to preserve that exclusion in this area. We don't see anything that has changed that justifies removing these restrictions.
1:18:20 Um, the county deliberately restored and repeatedly carried forward those restrictions. Um, our neighborhood has already seen an
1:18:27 influx of car washes and chain restaurants nearby. We have one directly across the street, uh, a car wash. Uh we understand that each application uh may
1:18:35 be considered separately but the residents experience the combined effects of these uh of these developments. Uh we would uh request
1:18:43 that you consider these cumulative impacts. Uh annexation changes the government responsible for the property but it does not by itself explain why
1:18:51 these previously excluded uses are now appropriate and I have not heard anyone present any sort of uh presentation about why those should be uh changed at
1:18:59 this time. Uh so we respect I respectfully ask you to recommend denial of all three requests and preserve the existing exclusions um giving the
1:19:07 families that live there now um useful uh use of their land essentially.
1:19:14 Thank you. Come on up, sir.
1:19:29 Good evening, ladies and gentlemen. My name is Tom Simmons. I live in Magnolia Point, 17500
1:19:36 Cobblestone Lane. I've heard words like we need a commercial business in Clermont. We need more of them.
1:19:46 I hear words like safety and yet none of you have really addressed the safety. the safety of the
1:19:54 people who live in Clermont. I see up there all the car dealerships and they certainly present an issue by themselves.
1:20:03 Does anybody talk about the two to 3,000 cars that come out of Katskco?
1:20:10 Does anybody talk about people coming through the red light? If you put a police officer at Magnolia Point and 50,
1:20:18 I'll bet you he could write a 100red tickets a day. As I was coming here this evening, sitting coming out heading
1:20:27 south in the westb westbound lane, two cars came flying through the red light. Talk about safety.
1:20:38 Forget about how much traffic. How much has anybody done a study? Two to 3,000
1:20:44 cars a day out of Costco alone. Forget all the other dealerships.
1:20:51 Does anybody care about the safety of people who live here? I've lived here for 14 years. We moved from Bay Hill out
1:21:01 here. And do you know why we moved? To a great neighborhood with great people and the safety of children. I brought my
1:21:09 daughter out here because we had a pedophile living a couple doors away.
1:21:15 A great neighborhood that's being jeopardized by its safety. Do you realize behind Dunkin Donuts are all
1:21:23 medical buildings and the people who go to those buildings are people like me, disabled people, old people, people who
1:21:32 need help. Yes, we drive probably slower than other people. Yes, we're more cautious than other people, but that's
1:21:40 that's why we came to Clermont. And now commercial businesses are flooding that twomile stretch. How many people
1:21:49 come from Groveland every place else to get to the turnpike? How many people have you done a study?
1:21:57 Please, I implore you, think about the safety of the people who live in that
1:22:04 area, and I'm one of them. And I certainly don't want to be a statistic that you someday read about. Thank you for your time.
1:22:14 Thank you. Anybody else like to come up and speak?
1:22:26 What was that gentleman's name? Simmons. Simmons.
1:22:33 So, Rich Crotch, 17526 Cobblestone Lane, Clermont. I I agree with what people said previously. I'm not going to
1:22:41 reiterate yet and take up your time, but just a couple things. Um, I didn't I just learned about this meeting. I
1:22:48 guess the date was changed or something, but if if there's going to be more traffic coming out on Magnolia Point
1:22:55 Boulevard, that's a serious problem. Um, yesterday about 4 or 5:00, I was coming
1:23:02 out of my house, wanted to turn left. I waited for seven minutes to get through the light there. Seven minutes. if you
1:23:10 put more traffic on there, it's just it's just not possible. I mean, that's
1:23:17 just not fair to the residents. And the second thing people have talked about is safety. And I really would ask you to think about this because if you're
1:23:26 coming out, you know, if you're coming out of the Toyota dealership and you're trying to turn left, it's a real problem at certain times of
1:23:33 the day. I mean, I come out of the toy dealership occasionally. I don't even try to turn left. A lot of times I go down to the light and do a U-turn
1:23:41 because it's just there's six lanes of traffic. It's it's just incredible. And now you're going if you add something else that coming out they're going to
1:23:49 want to you know they're going to want to turn across all that traffic. You're going to have a lot of accidents. So I'm assuming if you decide to go forward you're going to have to seriously put in
1:23:58 a traffic light there. I mean, if you don't, you really you really have a safety problem that's
1:24:06 not fair to the the people that are going to those establishments, but more importantly, as was said, the people
1:24:14 going up and down 50, it's it's it's a bit of a gamble at times right now. So, if you decide you have to go forward,
1:24:21 man, I hope you put a traffic light in for just for people's safety. Listen, living in the area, I'd hate to have another traffic light, but it's the only
1:24:29 way to go cuz otherwise you got a real problem. So, and I just want to say I shouldn't say this, but I've been w
1:24:36 sitting back there watching you guys and the body language wouldn't suggest a lot
1:24:44 of engagement with with the people talking. So, just I just hope you're really listening to what people are saying here, but safety and you don't
1:24:52 agree with what I'm saying. I'm sorry, but No, I'm just shaking your head between what you're saying. I'm I'll address you on my comments.
1:25:01 Okay. But safety is important. And please, more traffic on Magnolia Point.
1:25:06 You got to do Boulevard. You got to do something different. I mean, it's just crazy what what we as residents are putting up with with the changes that
1:25:15 were made several years ago to that road. So, thank you. Thank you. Next.
1:25:28 Name and address, sir.
1:25:31 Joseph Buckman, 12817 Magnolia Point Boulevard. Uh, I've lived here for 27 years in that neighborhood and one, two, three, and four were the only things that existed when I moved to Clermont.
1:25:42 Uh, we were told, uh, let me step back.
1:25:44 Magnolia Point has one ingress and egress road. That's it. That's what the county and the city had approved back
1:25:52 then. We fought Kramar uh over the road.
1:25:58 Uh, some of you may have been on the commission at that time. They wanted to put in a roundabout right there to, you know, there's no room for it. We were
1:26:05 promised, uh, oh, we're going to get a new monument sign. It's going to be real pretty. That never came. Uh, the where
1:26:13 five where five and six are at was an old sand mine that was supposed to stop operations and become a neighborhood years ago. That didn't happen.
1:26:25 Yeah. It's not before my time. And and so we're upset about this. One thing is that we're upset that this meeting is on an election day. Why is that? Uh we got one day of notice for this.
1:26:36 Did you find something funny?
1:26:38 Yeah, I do. Because you're upset. I'm upset because I'm sitting up here for seven years on election day when I should be home watching the results. Yeah.
1:26:46 All right. So, thank you for your service.
1:26:49 You really You and the last two gentlemen should choose your words very carefully. Is that a threat? This is the time for public comment.
1:26:56 point point of water.
1:26:58 So, I was part of the pliff group that stopped another car dealership from coming in there. We were told, "No, it's not coming in. You're not going to have
1:27:05 another high use uh operation in that area." Now, we're talking about it. Why?
1:27:11 That was part of that original plaintiff's agreement.
1:27:15 We're going to file suit if this is allowed to go forward without more input from our neighborhood. It's going to happen. So, I'm just giving you fair
1:27:22 warning. That's coming. I would recommend, as my neighbor Joyce said, postponing any decision on this until you can get more of our members here.
1:27:30 Thank you. Next.
1:27:44 Um, hello, my name is Morgan Hull and I live at 13442 Gordon Way and I'm John's Lake Landing. Um, I want to give my
1:27:52 opinion on the car dealers car dealership idea. Um, I love the idea for the trail for this project. I think everyone should have an opportunity to
1:28:00 get outside and walk around a nice place. I don't think everybody should have access to yet another car dealership. Um, across the highway is a
1:28:08 Tesla deal dealership and just a few minutes down the highway is two more dealerships or well 12. Um, I think this
1:28:16 area should be zoned to a C2, a C1 instead of a C2.
1:28:21 I live in the neighborhood behind the land and I ride the bus every day to school. Um, every weekday my bus drives next to the land and drops a student off
1:28:28 in the driveway driveway for the house on the land. Once it is developed, I would not want to see a car dealership, a car wash or heavy machinery on the
1:28:36 land. Um, if this area is zoned to a C1, I would see a church or a nice restaurant or a
1:28:43 bakery or something. Um, our neighborhood has expressed interest in more service uses and restaurants. We would be able to drive a golf cart there
1:28:51 or just walk over to the areas. There is a man that walks every day along the highway um highway 50 for exercise. I
1:28:59 would love if there were like wider sidewalks in the area to make it more accessible for everyone. By design, if there was a trail there, it would have
1:29:06 to be accessible by the highway, but that doesn't help the people who live in the apartments or the many neighborhoods surrounding the area. Um thank you for listening your consideration.
1:29:15 Thank you.
1:29:28 Good evening. I'm Katherine Hol. I live at 13442 Gordonia Way. Uh I'm speaking
1:29:35 tonight about the same proposal. Uh I have a different view though from others that have spoken. Um I'm actually for
1:29:42 the annexation of this property into the city and the extension of the utilities.
1:29:47 it abupts existing um city property. Uh I do recommend that you keep in mind that there is a regular sewage smell in
1:29:56 this area and I don't know if that's um from the pond or just bad utilities, but hopefully utility extensions would help
1:30:05 improve that or the restoration of that pond would improve the smell in that area. Uh, as part of the annexation, I'm
1:30:13 also hoping that the city can enlarge the sidewalks and possibly provide a bus shelter in that area as we do have bus riders that take the transit.
1:30:23 Um, the only other part is the comprehensive plan uh supports sufficient commercial and office sites
1:30:30 to serve the existing and projected population. This property is considered an infill site and should follow smart
1:30:38 growth patterns. Uh these ideas include a grid, pedestrian and transit access as well as encouraging internal trips.
1:30:46 The dealership per the application says that the trips will be driveby and that does not support the comprehensive plan of internal trips. The applicant is
1:30:55 proposing an amenity to create a recreational trail which is accessible from the highway. Per smart growth ideas, the ungated neighborh
1:31:03 neighborhoods should have a connection to this proposed trail and access to services and retail to encourage internal trips such as pedestrians, children, and elderly and by golf carts.
1:31:17 If you decide to continue forward with this project, a conditional use permit could be approved, but I propose a couple of additional conditions for your resolution.
1:31:28 I recommend the existing large trees should be protected as much as possible.
1:31:34 The development should work with the topography instead of creating three tiers of landscaped retaining walls. Why not use that to your advantage and have your inventory on different levels?
1:31:46 Working with the land instead of against it. Instead of landscaping all of the retaining walls, could artwork be added, creating something visually of interest from the highway?
1:31:56 If access must come from the highway into this site, a deceleration lane should be added, although I think that would be rather difficult with the way the bridge is there and the culvert.
1:32:09 I would also suggest that the city may not want to consider taking
1:32:17 on the amenity of the pond and the recreation trail because it is a landlocked property. The only access to that property would be from the highway.
1:32:27 And if you're trying to promote sustainable design and interconnectivity from all the other neighborhoods, either
1:32:34 add paths for the other neighborhoods to access the trail or figure out a different solution before you undertake
1:32:42 that as something else that you would want to spend money on for maintenance. And that is everything I had. Thank you. Thank you.
1:32:50 Anybody else? Any other public comment?
1:32:59 All right, Mr. Crawford, before we bring it back to commission, would you like to make any It's It's totally up to you. I I We can either do your questions or I can respond here.
1:33:08 Well, why don't why don't you respond?
1:33:09 The the people came out and had and had um some questions, observations. Uh probably responding to them would be good.
1:33:16 Thank you. And I think I would ask Robbie Moon or Phil Hollowman one to come up because some of these are technical traffic kind of questions that
1:33:25 I want to do. Um Robbie, give your name and address for
1:33:35 the record and talk to me about the traffic that is permitted now under our existing zoning and compared with what we're proposing.
1:33:43 Yep. Uh good evening. My name is Robbie Moon, 6300 Hazeline National Drive, Orlando, Florida 32812.
1:33:52 And then yes, so as I understand the existing entitlement is aundred 61,000 square feet, which has been
1:33:58 entitled since, I believe, 2005 when the PE was first written. It's been amended since then. Those trips under general
1:34:06 commercial use would generate average daily trips of 8,300 trips. the the car lot, I'm sorry, the car dealership at 43,000 square feet only generates 1,200.
1:34:15 That's a 85% reduction. And that's average daily trips. I think what's most important, I'm hearing that the evening trips, you know, when you're busiest. So
1:34:23 in the evening, a 161,000 square foot, you know, general retail would generate 800 PM trips. That's within, you know, the peak trip hour from 4 to 6:00 p.m.
1:34:34 800 trips going onto the road. the car lot, the car dealership, I apologize, would only generate 100. That is a 86%
1:34:41 reduction. So, this, if this project were to be approved, it'd be a great reduction of traffic on the road and help satisfy some of the safety concerns, not putting all the a lot of
1:34:50 trips on there. If it was going to, you know, I've heard, you know, like restaurants being put on here, C1 use, those would likely generate more trips
1:34:58 than the 161,000 general retail. So, this is a very low intensive, you know, traffic generating use. Uh with
1:35:05 regarding to the you know u the topography I understand the city code you know prefers 15 foot cut and fill
1:35:12 maximum you know cut and fill areas within one spot. But as previously contemplated and analyzed in this PED that's a challenge. There's probably
1:35:20 around 70 ft of dropping across this property which is around you know maybe 12% slope over 600 feet. So if you were to try to work with those 15 feet you'd
1:35:29 only be [clears throat] able to get like you know terraces 100 150 ft wide. the Wendy's to the east of this that that lots like 200 feet wide. So you can
1:35:37 understand trying to tear the terrace this with 15 foot maximum cuts would make it unattainable for development.
1:35:43 Not to mention when you have to connect those lots you're going to have steep driveways. Having one pad with the with the excess cut and fill allows for a
1:35:51 longer more gently sloping road for fire access trucks. The fire marshall wouldn't be able to get between you know lots that are dropping 15 feet every bit.
1:36:01 And then and for the and I think also the walls allow for a unique opportunity versus just a sea of pavement from the road. The the walls will be actually
1:36:09 elevated above the road. So you'll drive by and see this, you know, the the the walls not looking down on pavement. And then to the property to the south of us
1:36:17 where there's the residences, they are actually above us about 20. So they're they're their finished floors from west to east range from 150 to 170. We're
1:36:27 looking at maybe 130 135 within our development. So they'll be, you know, anywhere from 22 to 35 ft above us.
1:36:33 We're in a bowl. So any sound lights will be dampened by the walls there and they'll be actually looking above us.
1:36:38 Not to mention, there's going to be landscaping and screening, too. You know, I'm sure they have fences as well.
1:36:46 Robbie, the um the safety issues out on Highway 50, who controls when we go for a driveway permit, what kind of process is that?
1:36:57 Yeah, that will require a driveway connection permit through the Florida Department of Transportation.
1:37:02 And will they address and look at any of those because I know the the exact crossover that they're talking about. Y and it does get a little wacko. Yep.
1:37:11 That's not an engineering term.
1:37:12 Yeah, but um yeah, there will be traffic studies which we'll be submitting to the city as well, but they'll they'll very looking closely at that looking at the cross
1:37:20 connection. I believe connecting the State Road 50 and Good Herth road actually helps separates the traffic. So there's actually routes to the south, to
1:37:27 the east, and to 50. So you know, versus having it all go on 50. So you're actually these trips we're talking about 104 and a PM could be distributed 30
1:37:36 each way versus 100 going right there, you know, off one driveway on 50. So I'm hearing most of the concern is on 50. So I think this interconnectivity is what we want, you know, to greatly reduce it.
1:37:46 Now, there was concern also about um traffic going out to our east in the subdivision going through the roundabout
1:37:54 and over to Magnolia Point. Have you looked at what percentage of the traffic we think might do that or is that come at the site plan approval stage?
1:38:03 I think that there's a methodology has been submitted and the traffic reports being written now. So, we can't speak to that exactly right now.
1:38:09 Okay. Um, but the C2 uses that are allowed, this is roughly an 80% traffic reduction from what would be allowed. Is that correct?
1:38:20 86%.
1:38:22 Um, have you dealt at all with the trees on on the site? I know there aren't very many large trees and the ones that are
1:38:30 are at or near the wetland buffer and the uh flood plane. Have you looked at that yet or we Yeah, this area was I think it was
1:38:37 planted pine. So, a lot of that's already been harvested. There's a few remaining trees there, but I think you know the natural aerial along the wetlands will be remaining because we have 25 foot buffer for the St. John's
1:38:46 River Water Management District. So, those will be preserved.
1:38:49 Okay. Um well, hang around because I bet you we'll have some questions from the commission.
1:38:54 All right. [clears throat] And you I sympathize with everybody regarding the
1:39:02 traffic for that. We've [clears throat] talked about it over and over. It It is bad. This project is not an agricultural
1:39:10 land without any entitlements. It's it's already entitled as part of a PUB that is more than 20 years old now. Um and
1:39:18 what we're proposing is a significant reduction in intensity. It is a use that was not allowed 20 years ago. Gosh, I
1:39:28 know it's a long night. Everybody wants to get home and watch results.
1:39:32 When we did the first new dealership, Toyota along that route, um
1:39:40 the county attorney, the city manager, and several other
1:39:47 luminaries and dignitaries came to my office and sat us down and said, "This is not going to happen. We're not going
1:39:55 to have that." The mayor at that time um wanted to restrict car dealerships and
1:40:04 that led to the Plaza Kalina settlement that allowed only one more car dealership over in Plaza Kalina which still exists today.
1:40:13 The situation has just trained changed enormously in the last 20 years. the new car dealerships and some of them are now
1:40:23 15 years old and they're still in great shape. It's not a Pinehill situation. 50
1:40:30 years from now, I don't know what's going to happen, but the furniture stores that are along there may be the
1:40:38 first to go in my opinion. and um the substantial
1:40:46 tax revenue and jobs that this industry has has given us in addition to the
1:40:54 traffic, but less traffic than if you just stripped out shopping centers all along the way and fast food restaurants.
1:41:02 Um, and again, we're all kind of hamstrung because it's an FDOT road and nobody can do anything changing it without FDOT's
1:41:11 permission. Um, we would be happy to try to answer any other questions that you guys have and I'm going to step back.
1:41:17 All right. Thank you so much. Well, that that closes the the public comment um part of this. Thank you for trying to respond to some of those questions. I did want to thank everybody for for
1:41:25 coming out and and and making the the comments. I know this is a very personal and and emotional um issue for for folks
1:41:32 and I I do want to remind you that we are just a recommending board. Uh we are not elected officials. We are we are citizens like yourself and we are tasked
1:41:40 with with making a recommendation and um the final action is voted on by the city council. So um but we will uh do our
1:41:48 best to get our questions answered and and um and uh try to take action on this this evening. So, um, with that, I'll bring it back to the commission and I will start with you, Commissioner Dona.
1:41:59 Thank you, Mr. Chair. Okay. No, go ahead. Okay.
1:42:08 So, I I do feel compelled to respond to some of the folks in the audience. Go ahead.
1:42:14 I've been on this commission for two years. Anybody who's consistently come to these
1:42:21 meetings or watched them on the videos has known that I complain about traffic.
1:42:30 I've been down in Clermont 8 years.
1:42:36 We can't use traffic based on our old codes.
1:42:42 So, we switch to life safety. Anybody who's been paying attention, who's come
1:42:49 here consistently knows that
1:42:56 when you lean into your microphone, when you maintain eye contact,
1:43:04 when you take notes of what people say, that means you're engaged.
1:43:12 I'm probably one of the most engaged commissioners that's ever sat here because I have the same problems
1:43:20 in terms of traffic and safety and life quality.
1:43:24 What I will say in the beginning I felt it was good to see for a change
1:43:34 that something went from urban to commercial.
1:43:38 We can agree to disagree, but all things, all research, all data,
1:43:44 all kinds of forecasting shows that Clermont needs some sort of commercial andor industry.
1:43:54 Now, while something like this would provide highpaying jobs
1:44:02 and some sort of ability to live, work, and play in
1:44:09 Clermont, I've heard everything that you've said and I will say if everybody recalls
1:44:18 somewhere over about a year ago, there was an instance in Wellness Web
1:44:25 where a developer wanted to put up a store, a gas station, and a car wash in the middle of a neighborhood.
1:44:36 At that time, there were only three or four people that came from the neighborhood cuz they were in absolute shock of what was coming.
1:44:44 and they cited traffic, safety, lights,
1:44:51 kids crossing the street, and that
1:44:58 project was tabled. So, I don't have any questions, but I would suggest that this
1:45:05 project is tabled until some more people from Magnolia Way could be here. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Right.
1:45:14 Commissioner May to answer the the gentleman as well. Um
1:45:22 I just want to let you know that we are listening. I do take notes, a lot of notes. Um I love when the community
1:45:31 comes out to speak. Uh, one concerning thing that came out of
1:45:37 two or maybe three individuals, three same thing just learned about this
1:45:44 meeting, one day notice of meeting just found out about this meeting. So,
1:45:51 three people. So my question to staff is notice was sent out as required with the
1:45:59 new requirements based on what the council Yes ma'am.
1:46:04 The 400 ft 500 the 500 ft. Okay. All right.
1:46:11 We go out to 500 as our standard. Perfect. And then uh Mr. Crawford.
1:46:17 Yes ma'am. Uh did the owners, developers, the developers, did
1:46:23 they meet with the community prior to coming prior to you all?
1:46:28 We have not at this point. We wanted to wait for the planning and zoning and we thought there would be plenty of notice
1:46:35 out. Um and then we are planning on either meeting with or at least speaking with the neighbors that are on
1:46:44 the south side. Those are the ones that are most impacted. One of whom uh was is is here tonight. Um
1:46:53 there's no other residential that's that's close. Um but we're happy to meet with anybody and
1:47:03 everybody that that wants to talk about it and try to explain the things same things that we've explained here tonight.
1:47:11 Well, I mean there's a lot of residential. I'm I'm looking at the map.
1:47:16 So, yes, I will disclose that I have my computer. I am looking at the property. Um I do see if you guys can put that up.
1:47:24 I do see the Thank you. the residential um community that um the young lady I think she was the attorney. Yes, that
1:47:31 your backyard is going to be a parking lot. Um you have Westfall uh apartments.
1:47:39 Uh then when you go down you have Magnolia Landings which I think is the lady behind you. So you are completely
1:47:47 surrounded by residential because there's only one in one way in one way out um a pure residential besides the
1:47:55 office um on that. So may I don't have a a scale to know exactly but this is a permanent open
1:48:05 space buffer over here. Um this is is open space right now and it's full commercial across from us and on the
1:48:13 east side the only abuing residential we have right is to the south the one row of town homes
1:48:20 right so I will uh acknowledge that there is one abuing but in regards to the surrounding right
1:48:28 to the south and to the southeast yes is residential um the Toyota dealership
1:48:37 that people keep talking about and I see all the dealerships across the way.
1:48:41 There is really nothing behind them. Um but this particular site there is tons
1:48:48 of residential properties um that is walkable to a site that could be a site
1:48:57 that could create that walkability golf cartish
1:49:04 um bikeability that we're hoping to get um for the city
1:49:11 or it could or it could be Costco's competitor BJ's or somebody that's entitled they can just go right in and
1:49:19 build it and do another two or three thousand cars and you know Costco is not walkable. I'm I don't like it either.
1:49:26 Um, so I I mean we I believe we need to compare
1:49:32 the harm that any development of this type is going to have on abuing
1:49:41 neighbors and those close and traffic with what we're allowed to do as a matter of right. And we think we're
1:49:48 downzoning it rather significantly is we think.
1:49:52 Right. Well, that comes to the exclusion that the young attorney had brought up, which was a question that I had.
1:50:00 So, in the original uh PUB that was entitled under the Lake County ordinance 202132,
1:50:08 it did exclude adult entertainment, gas stations, automobile dealership, automobile parts stores, car washes, and automotive repair.
1:50:16 Yes. So, why is that not coming forth? You're changing the square footage. Why are we asking for the new use?
1:50:25 Because it's the highest and best use for the property from a a free market standpoint and and a business
1:50:32 standpoint, and we're willing to give up all these other concessions to add back in the auto use, but is it the highest and best use for
1:50:40 the neighborhood? And that's where I have to kind of look. So, going back to, and I know we're looking at three
1:50:47 different options. We're looking at uh an uh we're doing an amendment to the smallcale comprehensive plan. We're doing a reszone and we're also doing a CUP.
1:50:57 Right.
1:50:57 So based on the granting permits for a CUP, which is what I have to go by because it hasn't been changed yet.
1:51:05 Number one, will not adversely affect will the site not adversely affect the official adopted comp plans of the city?
1:51:11 That I'm still trying to get more information on data.
1:51:17 uh will the property not be detrimental to the health safety or life safety you would say right life safety or general
1:51:25 welfare of persons residing or working in the vicinity based on what I'm hearing it could be the use will comply
1:51:33 with the current regulations and conditions specified in our codes for such use it's looking you know we're
1:51:38 looking at C2 um for reszone and then the proposed use may be considered
1:51:45 desirable at the particular location. Um so number two and number four for me
1:51:56 is it you know safety wise because of the traffic noise pollution
1:52:03 uh light pollution um you know uh general welfare person or actually health environment I'm thinking
1:52:12 you know the car wash you know that's there's a water consumption uh issue on this Um,
1:52:18 uh, it's a repair shop, environmental, you know, there's hazardous materials being used at a repair shop. Um, you
1:52:26 know, just a lot of things that come up, uh, here. Um, really kind of looking at this excessive noise pollution. I mean, if there is a car wash, you know, you
1:52:34 have vacuum stations, tunnels, you know, a lot of noise in that sense. Um, you know,
1:52:44 I know my fellow commissioners have more questions, but right now, you know, I have to I'm just listening, looking at
1:52:52 what, you know, objectively at all the data. So, I will continue to listen um and hold my opinion. So,
1:53:01 thank you for that. I I would just say that we first of all your decision and the city
1:53:09 council's decision has to be made on the compet substantial evidence that's before you. The only planning evidence
1:53:16 we have is from the city's planners who say that it is consistent and it does meet all the requirements
1:53:23 without um competent substantial evidence otherwise which neighbors can certainly
1:53:30 stand up and testify about things like quality of life of their neighborhood.
1:53:35 They can't testify of anything that is well they can it's not competent substantial evidence if it's subject to
1:53:42 expert testimony like uh civil engineering traffic engineering all of those type of things we have to go by
1:53:49 your experts and our experts uh to do that and impact on the neighborhood
1:53:56 has to be measured against what is already allowed and it's a 80 80 plus% traffic reduction from what's allowed.
1:54:06 Um, I like I say, I do sympathize, but this is a much less intense use in many ways than what we're already allowed to do.
1:54:17 That's just our presentation opinion. I Yeah, one more just for clarity, just it might
1:54:25 help the commission. Um the staff, if you can put up the map
1:54:31 of the uh car dealership, there's no um section or separation on
1:54:38 where the car wash will be and where the repair shop would be.
1:54:43 It doesn't show. It just shows a building. Um I don't know. I'm not done.
1:54:51 I'll be done. Vincent is the the car wash facility. And I would note that it's not a public car wash. It's not like the car wash across the street.
1:55:00 It's it's only used for customers of the dealership and to prep the cars when they're selling them and that type of thing.
1:55:07 And where is the repair shop? It's both is the They're both at the same place. Yes.
1:55:14 Repair. Okay. That's it. Thank you very Oh, service is going to be over here. I'm sorry.
1:55:20 This is the drive-thru where they drop off on the on the back of the service.
1:55:23 All right. So, repair is on the side and car wash is on the side.
1:55:26 And again, this is 25 to 35 ft lower than the the row houses that are behind them.
1:55:38 Sorry.
1:55:39 Well, he said the houses are above 22 feet or 20 35 ft. Is that what you said? About 20 35 ft above. Yeah.
1:55:44 So, they would be looking down then into a parking garage. I mean, a parking lot. I mean, they're going to have a fence.
1:55:49 They'll be looking above it. You know, over the fence. they find their fence and step over the wall. Get closer.
1:55:55 Yeah. I mean, they'll I mean, they have a fence in their backyard and they'll be landscaping on the wall, so they'll be looking over it. If they go out of their backyard and there's also a 20 foot
1:56:02 perimeter buffer around those houses within the peed. So, those houses do not physically abut this property. There's a 20 foot buffer between the property there. Okay.
1:56:12 So, that puts, you know, these car wash facilities, everything probably 150, 200 feet away from the houses. Okay. Thank you. That's it.
1:56:19 All right. Thank you, Commissioner Neim.
1:56:22 Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Uh, first I want to say one thing. I want to clarify my words. Commissioner Don has said it the right way. All right? I see a lot of
1:56:31 brand new faces in here. Okay? I see a lot of brand new faces that majority of you don't even come to
1:56:39 city council meetings. If you did, you would have noticed me and majority of these commissioners go up there and we
1:56:47 fight every single day. Okay. Well, fighting's a bad word, but I'm from New York, so I'll say it like that. Okay. We
1:56:56 debate with the council. Okay. Like Commissioner Dona did say, we cannot
1:57:02 deny a project on traffic, but I found loopholes that we could deny it on safety. Okay. So, for those gentlemen
1:57:10 that come up to that microphone and say, "I was in front of commissioners. You weren't in front of me."
1:57:17 So that's why I say choose your words very carefully because you're insulting me. I come up here every day and I fight for Clermont on over density, high
1:57:26 density. I fight for traffic. You could ask anybody. You could ask Mr. Jimmy Crawford. Ask all these commissioners.
1:57:35 That's all I do is fight for the city of Clermont. I'm getting tired. And then I got to sit here when I want to be home
1:57:42 on election day. And then you turn around and say, "Why did you change the date?" I'm going to get you that answer
1:57:49 right now. Staff, when was the first notification sent out to Magnolia Point?
1:57:58 We have our cars. It's too far away. They They didn't go to Magnolia Point.
1:58:02 It's outside the So, they got no notification. It's outside of the 500 ft.
1:58:07 Uh the closest property owner in Magnolia Point is 1,500 ft away.
1:58:14 So, Magnolia Point got no notification about this project coming up.
1:58:20 That is the only notification would be the yellow signs that were posted, but again in front the small ones because we didn't change it to the big ones yet.
1:58:28 We we on the property, man. Please let me explain this to you guys.
1:58:32 Magnolia Point is 1500 feet away. We upped our distance and we went out 500 feet and we met that requirement.
1:58:41 I'm just a little confused because I thought I sat in that city council when Councilman Bane did say to reach out to
1:58:50 the surrounding HOAs if they fall within the 500 ft. So if we I didn't hear him say that. I did not
1:58:58 hear him say that. Be careful when you choose your words to me. I'll go back to the video team. Yeah, I'm confident if it if a HOA property falls within the
1:59:08 500 ft, then we would reach out to the the HOA.
1:59:12 So, as far as I'm concerned, I'm basing my decision tonight that these people were never notified.
1:59:19 If they were within the 500 ft, they were notified. Come on, just answer the question.
1:59:23 Were they notified? No, they weren't, cuz they didn't fall in the 500 ft. All I had to do is speed along 50 like everybody else does and look at a little
1:59:30 sign that's about the size of this piece of paper. I can't answer you already spoke, ma'am. I can't you can't you can't rebut, ma'am. That's up to the
1:59:38 chairperson. You could ask him. Okay, that's number one. Okay. The main concern I have and thank you staff. I'm sorry, John. I had an emergency at home.
1:59:47 I would have made it and I would answer these questions with you. Okay. But I could not make yesterday's meeting. uh
1:59:54 to the applicant. What dealership is being put in? Explain that to me.
2:00:00 We're under a confidentiality and we're not able to. It's not one of the other 10 that are there. I'll tell you that.
2:00:07 I know. See, I got a little problem with dealerships myself. I do. But I can't tell somebody you can't build on your property if you're allowed to build on
2:00:14 it. I do understand. But what I can do is deny this project because you're asking for a reasonzoning. Now, I could
2:00:22 tell you right now as an advocate for South Clermont, when we spend our hardearned money and our life savings to
2:00:31 buy a house, we do our diligence and work to see what's around the property. Absolutely.
2:00:36 And if I'm looking at, let's say, Magnolia Point, which was never notified,
2:00:43 and I see, oh, it's a PUD for low urban.
2:00:50 I said, "I'm safe." And now you go ahead and show me something, Jimmy.
2:00:55 Oh, well, I was just Go ahead. Show me something.
2:00:57 Sure. This is the original PUD and then the amended PUD phasing plan and do
2:01:05 that. And the language of the PUD shows track M right here as 161,000 of C2
2:01:13 uses. So, anybody who bought after 2005 and did their due diligence would expect a major commercial development to go on that property.
2:01:29 Okay, Mr. Jimmy Crawford. Touche. Oh, I'm not arguing. Touche. No, no, listen. You're the commissioner.
2:01:35 I'm asking questions because I'll simply just say denial.
2:01:39 Sure. So, I want to know before I reach my decision because right now I'm not I I'm don't I don't like the variances. Number one. Okay, that's number one.
2:01:47 Number two, since I know you're involved with the DPZ, is this going to interfere with their plans?
2:01:53 I I certainly don't believe so. The we went through the new comprehensive plan and uh it's consistent with the use at
2:02:01 that location. If we develop it after the plan is adopted and there are additional architectural or other restrictions, we'll have to comply with
2:02:09 those and variances.
2:02:17 Mr. J, we we are entitled to much more than what we're asking for.
2:02:22 But you're asking for a variance and I don't mean to cut you off. I develop it in the county and Clermont owns his property. Correct.
2:02:31 No, Clermont does not own property. All right. I wanted that for the record. Okay.
2:02:36 I wanted that for the record. Please let me ask my questions. Sure. So, who owns this property right now?
2:02:41 Uh, Kraar Groves, Inc., I believe, owns part of it and one individual part of it. It's city property. No, it's in the county.
2:02:49 County property. Yes, it is. So, did you go to the county and ask for this?
2:02:53 The JPA envisions that if we're adjacent, we come to the city and that's that's what we're doing.
2:03:03 Um, we could ask the county to change the use to auto and try to do that or we could just go in and sell it to uh
2:03:12 somebody who wants to build 160,000 square feet of commercial on it. Okay.
2:03:18 Done. because I'm not on according to your conceptional plan which we don't know what's going in
2:03:25 there. Do you know how many bays of repair and where the bays are going to be facing? Is it going to be facing towards their homes? Are they going to
2:03:33 be facing out towards 50? Cuz I doubt it's going to be facing 50.
2:03:38 There's 76 spaces where so the bays the bays where that you pull in spaces per bay and there's 76 bases. So
2:03:46 it's 38 bays. Is that 38 bays? Is that sound right? 38 bays. 38 bays. And where are they facing?
2:03:53 They're going to be facing the community. Well, they're inside. They're And they face.
2:04:02 Okay. I'm sorry, Jimmy. You know, I wasn't born last night. Okay. And I'm being serious. Yes.
2:04:07 You go to any dealership, you show me one dealership that keeps their garages closed in the summertime, right? Some do and some don't. I
2:04:15 certainly agree. And these do open east and west. They do not open north and south.
2:04:22 Well, that stores 50. That's why you want to keep it away from 50.
2:04:27 Well, we also are cognizant of our owners to the south. So, they only have a wall. They
2:04:35 don't have um bays facing them or that type of impact.
2:04:43 Okay. So, they weren't notified. You're telling me the bays are pretty much going directly towards the sound would
2:04:50 go if the garage is open towards their communities because I believe the young lady came up and says she's running on a property line.
2:04:58 Well, yes, sir. I I disagree. I mean, the the only people the only
2:05:04 residents within the 500 ft are here and we're not facing anything sound producing toward them. The bays are
2:05:13 I thought you said the bays were going over there.
2:05:15 The bays are on the on the on the south side.
2:05:17 No, I'm sorry.
2:05:20 That's where the finger was pointed when I looked. Please answer that.
2:05:23 All right. Uh Tad Dixon, 1300 Country Lane, Orlando. Thank you, Todd.
2:05:27 Uh I wanted to explain this is a fully enclosed sales and service center that it will be airond conditioned to 72
2:05:35 degrees and the doors are high-speed doors. So when a car goes in, they open as quick as they possibly can and automatically go down because of the
2:05:43 cost of conditioning the space. So we're talking about a total of two or three bay doors that are high-speed. And
2:05:51 again, the owner and operator of the facility is incentivized to keep those doors closed because they are cooling the facility. And that's the expectation
2:05:59 for automotive good automotive technicians in this day and age.
2:06:03 Could you I'm sorry. Let me come close to the microphone. Could you point your finger exactly where they're going to be entering these bays?
2:06:10 Where they're going to, excuse me, enter? Where do they go in?
2:06:12 Where's the enter and exit point of these bays?
2:06:14 You can just these doors.
2:06:16 Anyway, okay. Uh, right there, okay, is an entrance and then right there is an exit.
2:06:23 So, there's none on the south side of the building. No, not shown here. Okay.
2:06:29 Sometimes I make mistakes cuz I I saw the finger. I thought it was over there. It could be. I'm I make mistakes.
2:06:37 Commissioner Nimick, I have noticed a trend in not only automobile dealerships, but auto repair all the way down to break and tire shops that have a
2:06:47 very hard time recruiting good mechanics. And the AC enclosed areas are
2:06:55 a huge thing for recruiting the mechanics. So, yes, it cost them more money, but it does help eliminate noise to the neighborhood.
2:07:02 I understand where you're going, Jimmy. I believe you me. I get it.
2:07:05 But, see, the problem I'm having is the Volkswager dealership. Okay. They said they were just going to have a display over there.
2:07:12 Okay. There's a display and there's over 25 cars sitting along 50.
2:07:17 Well, okay. So, what I hear from that podium and what I see with my own eyes 5 years later is different. I didn't represent the V.
2:07:25 I know you did. I know that. I know that. But another question to the gentleman over there.
2:07:31 Okay. There was no traffic study in my packet. Yeah. Yeah.
2:07:36 The traffic is two steps. They submit a methodology and that is currently in review right now. And I understand there'll be a traffic study in time for the council.
2:07:44 Thank you. And you said the traffic study will be handed over to the city.
2:07:48 Is that going to be the city council or is that going to be just to the city staff? because I have to base my decision tonight without a traffic report
2:07:56 and go to city staff and then put it through your packet.
2:07:58 So the city council is not going to even gonna be able to look at this traffic study as well.
2:08:04 They they will certainly if they put it in the packet. I mean I don't know is it going to Okay, let me revise my question. Is it going I love these word
2:08:12 games because I can stay at poo all night. Okay. And you know I can. Sure. Um that's a staff question.
2:08:21 So, we sent this the methodology to our traffic engineer. It's a tier one. Uh, so it wouldn't be going to council.
2:08:27 We'll we'll get it during the site review process.
2:08:30 When was this sent to your traffic engineer?
2:08:33 The date. Why didn't we have it in our packet?
2:08:36 You have the memorandum that was included in your packet.
2:08:38 Could you read that to me for the record?
2:08:42 Uh, I can read this la this last when it was sent to them. when it was sent. The date's October 30th, 2026.
2:08:50 And today's the election day, November 4th. That's right.
2:08:55 Five days. And it takes how it takes what, a week or two? Two weeks to get a traffic study. We sent it out to our engineer.
2:09:02 Our consultant. All right.
2:09:05 But I I can get the Did you catch that one? Any other commission? Cuz I didn't catch that one. It's on page 169 of your packet.
2:09:12 On which on which packet? I got three packets in front of me for this property. One complete packet has all the pages. So, it' be 169.
2:09:22 I'm looking at it right now. It says 169.
2:09:27 I figured Mr. Tona, Commissioner would have found it and I didn't find it.
2:09:33 I know we didn't. We do our diligence up here. Okay. So, that's a traffic study.
2:09:42 Okay. Highway 50.
2:09:45 Uh, listen, I mean, I really I really would like to suggest to the community that you guys should have been here for
2:09:54 the DPZ cuz if you get upset about this, you got to see what's coming your way, too.
2:10:00 Okay? Cuz you think you got traffic now, you're going to have a lot more. And for the record, I was the only one opposing it.
2:10:10 Question. Yes, please.
2:10:14 Um, so battery does it's not working. Okay, there we go. Um, you pointed out a
2:10:21 document right here that says want page 169 and I do see it as the SR50 car
2:10:28 dealership methodology comments online in the agenda packet. Um, so is that what you're referring to?
2:10:36 That says that says um, is it in the It looks a little different, but it's on There it is. Yeah. KDson and Associates. Third packet. The third item. Yeah.
2:10:45 Okay. Thank you.
2:10:46 I just wanted to clarify that for you, Commissioner.
2:10:48 No, thank you. Thank you, council, because when you get something on a Thursday and you got to read through everything, personal life comes first.
2:11:01 But on a serious note, I don't like this project. And I'm going to be honest with you. So, Mr. Simmons,
2:11:08 wherever you are out there, you should be really, really do your homework and find out who's on your team and who's not on your team before you make allegations.
2:11:19 Seriously, cuz I'm tired of this. I have no further questions. I'm ready to vote.
2:11:25 All right. Thank you, Commissioner Kramer. Thank you, Chairman Kobe.
2:11:33 So like Commissioner Teddona, I see the potential commercial value in this.
2:11:40 While John, I like I know you like to go after the big whales. I like to go after the smaller whale this the big fish but
2:11:46 not the big whales. Um, I understand
2:11:53 the impacts on traffic and I I really appreciate Jimmy you taking us through that methodology.
2:12:00 um letting us understand what the potential is because to be clear a BJ's
2:12:07 could go in there and often those there's a reason why you see a McDonald's next you know Hardies next
2:12:15 to a McDonald's somebody already did the demographic study and said CVS and Walgreens somebody else did the homework so um
2:12:23 80% reduction so you guys are projecting only a 100 cars a day is that what I heard Did you say uh peak hour trips? Peak hour trip,
2:12:32 evening peak hour, which is what the methodology usually uses as the critical number.
2:12:37 Thank you. And I did go back through and and um look through this as far as does it is it consistent with our future
2:12:44 comprehensive plan that is right now with the state of Florida being reviewed. And it does seem to fit. It's
2:12:51 a very very aligned um opportunity there. Um
2:13:06 you say that there's one of the residents made very good comment about trying to to save a few things like the um the topography
2:13:14 and especially the existing trees. So most most of those trees that that are down near that lake and everything, that's
2:13:23 what you're you're trying um to build a small park. Can you um paint a little bit I'm Yes.
2:13:32 paint a little bit better vision of what this park point because he'll know better than me and I appreciate that. Um,
2:13:46 okay. I have to be very on this one.
2:13:51 Well, one that doesn't show it that shows the existing. Oh, there we go. Okay.
2:13:57 Yeah. So, what I'd like is can you take if if the applicant could paint a better picture for me of of what what what
2:14:05 we're going to get out of this as a bonus with some paths and parks and whatnot.
2:14:12 Parks, can you please request reass?
2:14:15 Can you paint a picture for me so I can understand what it is? I understand that you were proposing some enhancements, a park and a trail and so on. Paint a
2:14:24 picture for me so I understand what that's going to be like.
2:14:26 Yeah. So up here near the lift station, we'll call it like call it a trail head, there's a space for uh I think four or five parking spaces, including one ADA space, right?
2:14:34 And then we, you know, since we control maybe a third of this pond here, we're discussing bringing there's existing, you know, kind of a dirt road here that
2:14:42 serves as house using that as that's going to be the toe of our slope, the toe of our work, maintaining that existing buffer along the wetland and putting a trail there around there so individuals can walk around the trail.
2:14:52 And I think they discussed certain lake management to clean up the water there.
2:14:56 I'm not sure what other items they've talked about like bubblers like you know clean it up get some more oxygen in the water.
2:15:01 So these larger trees along this buffer correct will be able to stay. Correct.
2:15:07 It's it's only these and are these pines mostly or uh these are all planted pines
2:15:14 that have been harvested. Um there are some along the rightway but those can't be saved because of topography.
2:15:21 Very likely. We will have to study that.
2:15:23 But correct. Right now, I don't think believe those I don't believe those are being included to be saved. Just the ones along the wetland buffer along the west.
2:15:29 But you are committing to saving as many or saving as many of these large trees in that nature area as possible to preserve that that look and feel.
2:15:38 Correct? Yes, sir. Okay.
2:15:46 No further questions, Chair. Thank you, Commissioner Hisington. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
2:15:56 There's been lots of discussion on this on this project. Um, when I first started hearing the restoring of the
2:16:04 lake, walking trails, extra landscaping consistent with existing
2:16:12 businesses that are there now. Thought, yeah, that sounds good. When I hear people come up and say, "I've been here
2:16:20 30 years. I've been here 12 years. I moved here because of
2:16:28 I think I'm the only one in this commission that was born and raised here in the city of Clermont.
2:16:34 When 50 was two lanes, when it was called gym of the hills, when we enjoyed the orange groves and smelling of the blossoms.
2:16:48 And over the years, people have moved here.
2:16:53 So the quiet, sleepy community that I was born and raised in changed before my eyes.
2:17:01 And I hear you say, "I moved here. I've been here 30 years." Well, those of us that were born here,
2:17:09 look at you that moved here, created what we have today.
2:17:16 And with growth comes pain.
2:17:23 I don't want to see Highway 50 turn into a car dealership lane. When we got the
2:17:30 first one, we thought, "Oh, we got the second one and now we have how many?" 10. 10.
2:17:38 Those of us who were born here, we put up with those who move here and then complain about the traffic.
2:17:51 Well, you are cause of the traffic when you move here. Not that we don't welcome you, but with growth comes pain.
2:18:05 And if a builder comes in and follows the guidelines, some of us are going to like it and some of us are not.
2:18:18 But we as a commission want to make sure that it fits in the design that of a place we want to
2:18:27 live. We want to make sure there's safety.
2:18:30 We want to make sure that the traffic is cut down as much as possible.
2:18:35 But I'm going to say it again, but with growth comes paying and with change.
2:18:41 And we all have to learn how to live within that to where some of us are going to be happy and some of us are not.
2:18:50 When you talked about the jobs, Mr. Crawford.
2:18:53 Yes, ma'am. and the salaries. My question is, are those jobs going to people who are driving into these
2:19:01 locations or are they local residents that have already lived here that are getting those jobs?
2:19:08 And I don't I tried to find more information on that and other than going and and asking the current dealerships
2:19:16 where their people live, I can't say. I would say you can't not hire somebody because they live over in the Orange County line. Correct. But we would
2:19:25 definitely we try to recruit from the local population and they don't want to drive up and down Highway 50 either. So,
2:19:34 um we think we'll create around 200 jobs that are about 150% average. Oh, thank you.
2:19:42 Larger than the median income for uh Lake County. Okay.
2:19:50 And as a potential business coming into the area as a
2:19:57 builder, instead of just checking the box and say we went out 500 ft, we put the signs up that are required to ensure that you have a happy neighbor.
2:20:10 Why would you not prior to this meeting with the residents to hear what their
2:20:17 concerns are? So when it comes to this meeting, a lot of those questions and concerns are answered.
2:20:23 Um but not let them come here and say, "Nobody talk to us." Yeah, I understand you met the requirements. you did what was required of you to do.
2:20:31 But if you're going into an area where you know that there may be questions, where there may be unhappy neighbors, take that extra step to show that you
2:20:40 want to be a good neighbor and meet with meet with the residents.
2:20:44 Yeah. Uh I take your advice to heart. I would say that all of the residents
2:20:51 along the south got a notice and and there's one resident that that came Um,
2:20:59 but we're happy to go to their community and do a meeting. Um, I will say I've done more than 50 of those in my career.
2:21:11 And you, other than the communication, which is good, you're not going to make everybody happy. There is just simply no
2:21:20 way to do it. But communication is very important, and we're going to do a better job of that. That's true.
2:21:27 Um, I feel for the residents that are there. I mean, I I understand how you're feeling and right now I am not at a
2:21:36 point to where I can support this until the other residents have had an opportunity to be heard. I mean, it may
2:21:45 go forward anyway, but I think we owe that to them to listen to what their concerns are. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
2:21:53 If I might, Commissioner Hoisington, then I would love to see the code changed because what my clients do is
2:22:02 they come in and they look at the code and they say, "All right, here's the requirements we got to meet." And if
2:22:09 this count, this commission and the city council wants something different, we need to know and we need to know before
2:22:17 tonight. Um, we'll comply with whatever notice requirements. A lot of local jurisdictions require community meetings in certain instances.
2:22:29 We do not and Lake County does not. Um, and but that's the disconnect.
2:22:38 And you know what my clients want, including this one, is predictability and certainty. We'll jump through the hoops. We just need to know what they are.
2:22:48 Thank you.
2:22:49 Thank you very much. I think all of us up here are concerned about who found out when when people found out and I think uh Commissioner Neim, you had some specific questions.
2:22:56 If I may go ahead, Mr. Chairman, I'd like to follow up. So, for the record, according to this what you're showing on the screen, goes 1 2 3
2:23:05 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 plus another 14.
2:23:11 I'm going to take a good guess that they're within the 500 ft level. Were they notified?
2:23:18 Staff Yes. Thank you. Okay.
2:23:27 So, Jimmy, you're a good lawyer. You're a very good lawyer. I I will give you that. Thank you.
2:23:34 But, you know, I'm also I'm a good commissioner when I put my teeth in something that I don't like. Sure.
2:23:40 So, we're definitely not going to see eye to eye on this one.
2:23:43 And I don't care if I'm showing my poker hand right now, but uh I'm ready for a vote. Mr.
2:23:49 Chairman, after your question, sir. I'm sorry.
2:23:51 There you have a question. Commissioner May, I have one question. Um, ma'am, I'll pick you. Yes, ma'am.
2:23:58 What would you like to see on that site?
2:24:01 A C1 project, not not a another dealership. What is I mean restaurants you know Pla Bella
2:24:10 Plaza Kina when that was spoken for and develop and getting ready for developed you know was ready and planned to go
2:24:19 forward when Winter Garden Plaza started you know their big uh development and of
2:24:26 course that put the kibash on Bellacina and and everyone was very excited about the look of Bellacina Plaza the Italian8
2:24:34 design the restaurants to shopping and we're acceptable of that type of traffic expecting to have more traffic cameras
2:24:43 or traffic lights and and you know to design around that kind of environment ingress and egress better than what we
2:24:50 have now and that didn't happen. So when you have parking lot after parking lot
2:24:56 in the first not even a half a mile into Clermont, what does that show the people who are coming into Clermont and
2:25:05 maybe want to move here? You know, and I addressed this with the mayor um when they were building the development next
2:25:13 to Magnolia Point years ago. You know, I was the person that said to the mayor, if you're so happy about people moving
2:25:22 into Clermont, where is the sign that says, "Welcome to Clermont." And I said, "There's no kind of statue or notice that that that tells people that
2:25:30 you're in Clermont. We want people to love Clermont just as much as we do.
2:25:34 I've loved Clermont for 37 years, you know, and and I watched and I was concerned about growth." And I've been
2:25:41 to these meetings and I've been to the county commissioner meetings and I have argued about stuff that was interfering
2:25:48 in our livelihood and our housing and possibly depreciation of our neighborhoods, you know. So, I don't
2:25:56 want to see another parking garage and I don't want to see another car dealership and, you know, something more beautiful and more more welcoming to the community
2:26:04 than just sitting cars, a slab of concrete.
2:26:08 I appreciate it. So, see one just like the other person. Anything else, Commissioner? That's it. Thank you.
2:26:12 All right. Any other commissioner have a question before we entertain?
2:26:16 All right. Um, so I'm good. Okay.
2:26:22 All right. Um, at this time, uh, I'll entertain a motion.
2:26:26 I would like to, uh, set a motion on, uh, Okay. Let's see.
2:26:34 We're going We have to do individuals, correct? Yes.
2:26:38 Yes, sir. Okay. So, I'm going to set a motion for item number three, ordinance number
2:26:47 202638 to be tabled
2:26:53 and request staff to reach out to the community
2:27:01 or request city council to make a decision if they could reach out to the other community since it's going to be affecting their backyard.
2:27:09 because it's their only entry and exit point. That's that's my motion. Is that okay? You understand that?
2:27:17 I understand it. Um, one thing just to consider is you won't deal with the annexation, for example. Now, they may
2:27:25 withdraw. I don't know what they'll do, you know, if um the reasoning and other stuff doesn't move forward. City council
2:27:32 has purview over annexation, right? The only reason I bring this up for your motion is that um the city council could
2:27:40 conceivably move forward with annexation.
2:27:43 Um but by tableabling this you will delay the new zoning
2:27:50 that correct put in just FYI. I mean that's I don't know if you've contemplated this scenario.
2:27:56 You have. Okay. That's all I just wanted to point out. But thank you, council. I appreciate tableabling it to the next meeting.
2:28:05 I think a month would be sufficient enough to get to their people to reach out.
2:28:09 All right. I base my decision on the applicant and also the citizens that it's affecting.
2:28:16 Okay. So, we have a proper motion. Is there a second? I'll second a motion.
2:28:21 We have a motion and a second.
2:28:24 I have a question. So, in regards to um tableabling, do we table all three?
2:28:32 You can. I mean, I would ask you to do it individually just for the record in case there's some kind of different discussion and that kind of thing. Perfect. Thank you.
2:28:40 Okay. Question.
2:28:41 So, we have a motion and a second. I will call for the vote. All in favor? Could we do a roll call on this vote?
2:28:48 You sure? Thank you.
2:28:50 I would like to request a roll call on this vote, clerk. Commissioner Tidona.
2:28:59 I. Commissioner May. Hi. Commissioner Neck. I.
2:29:07 Commissioner KBY. I. Commissioner Kramer. I. And Commissioner Hoisington. I.
2:29:16 May I ask a point of order question? And it's probably for the city attorney.
2:29:21 It we have applications that have been advertised and scheduled for uh city
2:29:29 council. Um it it we we are not in favor of trying
2:29:37 to postpone those. Um that said, we won't go forward with the annexation without the zoning because we have
2:29:45 existing entitlements that we have to protect. Um I I would request
2:29:53 and it's you guys are the commissioner so do however you want but I would request uh that we move forward with
2:30:00 either no recommendation or a recommendation for denial.
2:30:04 I have heard we have heard the issues that you have brought up and we will do our best to resolve those before city
2:30:14 council but we would appreciate a a recommendation and an ability to move forward.
2:30:20 I don't know if you have to give us that or not. I don't I've council I've never seen one that was stuck at P&Z.
2:30:27 Staff wants the PNZ commission to make a recommendation. Staff does not want the P&Z commission to table it. And this is
2:30:34 something staff has talked about in other contexts, but it's a commission decision, right?
2:30:39 And it is my opinion that the city council cannot take up the matter without the recommendation of PNZ.
2:30:47 Understood. Um there's a statute that says how long you have and how many times you can ask us for more information and we'll just have to look at it. But um we will do our best.
2:30:59 If I may, Commissioner, may I just make a comment? Jimmy, like I said, you are a good lawyer, but I'm also a good commissioner. Being up here for seven years, I know the rules.
2:31:07 I respect that. Thank you.
2:31:10 All right, that takes care of item three. Um, item four. Let's see.
2:31:20 You wanted to take it or I'll take it?
2:31:23 Sure. Item four, ordinance number 2026 039.
2:31:29 um in favor of tableabling this with the same stipulations as I stated in
2:31:36 same stipulations the community has to be involved. Yes.
2:31:40 I'll second it. Motion second. Any discussion?
2:31:45 All do you want to do? All in favor? I I I Anyone opposed? That's unanimous. Oh, we have one opposed.
2:32:00 Commissioner Kramer is opposed. That's item number four. Item number five. Okay, Jenny.
2:32:08 For item number five, resolution 202644R, I would recommend a tableabling based on
2:32:15 the same criteria of the other two that the folks from uh the residential area need to be brought in for their opinions.
2:32:25 Do we have a motion? I second and a second. All in favor?
2:32:30 I I I I I oppose. One opposed.
2:32:36 All right, that takes care of those three items. We are been here over two almost two and a half hours. We're going to take a fivem minute recess.
2:32:51 I got to get circulation.
2:33:03 [snorts]
2:33:06 Yeah, I'll pull it off for you. I'm going to use the restroom. Listen.
2:41:14 and I will ask staff to come up and present item number six and item number seven.
2:41:27 Good evening. Planning and zoning commissioners and guests Justine Day with development services.
2:41:34 Chris Leopard on behalf of Kimley Horn and Associates, Inc. is requesting annexation, a small-scale comprehensive plan amendment, and a resoning on the
2:41:42 subject parcel to develop a multifamily apartment complex. The property is located northwest of the State Road 50 and count county road 455 intersection.
2:41:52 At this time, staff is presenting the proposed map amendments for recommendation. The annexation of the property will pres be presented to the
2:41:59 city council at a later time. On August 27th, 2024, the property owner entered into a utility agreement with the city
2:42:07 to receive water and wastewater services. As part of the agreement, the property was required to be developed in accordance with the city standards and
2:42:16 proposed concept plan. The applicant is now requesting to designate the property with the most compatible feature land use category and zoning districts to satisfy these requirements.
2:42:27 And just to show you um where the property is located. Um on your screen you should see the site and then to the east is going to be the city limits and
2:42:36 then not directly abetting the property but a little bit lower to the south there is also city limits closer to State Road 50.
2:42:44 And here's the property again outlined in yellow.
2:42:48 The property is currently undeveloped and is designated with the planned unit development uh future land use category under Lake County.
2:43:03 This category permitted a residential development program specific to the property which consists of an apartment complex with up to 212 dwelling units
2:43:11 and associated amenities. The applicant is proposing to designate the property with the city's commercial future land use category to align the property with the city's com comprehensive plan.
2:43:26 This category allows for residential uses at a maximum density of 12 dueling units per acre, which the proposed apartment complex does not exceed.
2:43:36 Additionally, this category allows for supportive accessory uses, parks, and open space.
2:43:47 The property is currently zoned PUD under the Lake County um under Lake County and is governed by ordinance
2:43:54 number 2026-32 which permitted a multifamily apartment complex of up to 212 dwelling units and
2:44:02 associated accessory amenities. The applicant is proposing to designate the property with the C city's PUD district
2:44:09 to maintain the existing entitlements approved by Lake County.
2:44:15 These entitlements would be transferred by a like forlike city ordinance with small adjustments made for code references.
2:44:23 Just to show you what the map would look like if they did go to PUB.
2:44:38 When reviewing the subject property and the surrounding uses, staff noted that the majority of the surrounding properties are already developed, making this property an infill site. Existing
2:44:47 uses within a quarter mile of the subject property include uses such as automobile and truck sales and services,
2:44:54 child care center, hotel, motel use, and retail shopping center. Additionally, the location may provide residents with
2:45:02 the ability to walk or bike to these establishments for occupational or daily needs while offering additional housing options to the city's residents. The
2:45:10 proposed change to the city's commercial future land use category is consistent with the comprehensive plan and aligns with the existing uses and land uses
2:45:18 within the area. The proposed PUB zoning district is compatible with the adjoining properties as required by the comprehensive plan. Therefore, staff
2:45:26 recommends approval of ordinance number 2026-041 and ordinance number 2026-042.
2:45:34 This concludes staff's presentation.
2:45:37 All right. Thank you. We would like to hear from the applicant.
2:45:46 Good evening, Mr. Chairman and commissioners. My name is Chris Leopard.
2:45:51 My address is 200 South Orange Avenue, Sweet 600, Orlando, Florida.
2:45:58 Uh, thanks for reviewing the project and, uh, I'm here to, uh, answer any questions. Uh, again, as the staff
2:46:06 report indicated, uh, we sought approval through the county and, uh, per the
2:46:14 utility agreement, uh, we're required to, uh, submit an annexation package to y'all. So again, here to answer any questions. Thank you.
2:46:27 All right. Uh would anybody from the public like to come on make a comment?
2:46:32 Please come up. State your name and address. Welcome back to the podium.
2:46:40 Uh Katherine Holt, uh 13442 Gordonia Way. I'll make this easy and quick. Um I like that they're putting a sidewalk in.
2:46:49 Uh they probably should put a sidewalk off the backside because there's only one a two access points off of the main
2:46:57 road and so there's a daycare not too far from there and people who may want to live in the apartment complex may want to have access off of the trailer
2:47:06 someplace to another road. Uh the other thing would be I know there was a TIA that's still underway it looks like in
2:47:15 the packet and as part of that I would ask that they also consider the queuing and the
2:47:23 uh tractor trailers that come from CarMax because they come out onto this road probably about where their access
2:47:30 point is and that area as a whole is very congested but mostly it's because people are cutting signals
2:47:39 So, it's easier to come from um Ray Good game, go through the intersection, do a U-turn, and you can still beat the
2:47:46 signal out and turn right back on to 50 instead of waiting the five minutes. So, there's a lot of um potential conflicts and things like that that a TIA doesn't
2:47:55 necessarily for their development would have to include, but I think the queueing and the access and the extra trips and things like that just need to
2:48:03 make sure that the lanes are long enough for whatever is proposed in this area. So that's all I had.
2:48:10 All right. Thank you. U would the applicant like to respond to that?
2:48:15 Uh yes. So regarding the the first comment on the sidewalk, uh you know, we'll have a a sidewalk on on the uh
2:48:21 west side of the road from the north property line to the south property line. We uh it will include a sidewalk
2:48:29 along our entire uh property line. So, uh, and I believe that there are a couple sections, uh, north of the
2:48:36 property that will be, uh, added as well to allow access to the north north and the trail system.
2:48:45 Uh, in regards to traffic study, a traffic study was prepared previously and submitted through the county and uh,
2:48:53 through the JPA review. So, uh, any of the required improvements, off-site improvements, uh, would be implemented
2:49:01 with this design. At this point, I I don't think there was any any, uh, required improvements,
2:49:08 uh, besides our our driveways into the site.
2:49:12 All right. Uh, anybody else uh, anyone else want to make a Okay, I will close public comment. Um and for um our
2:49:22 commission, we'll bring it back and I will start to my right. We'll go Kramer Hoisington. Then we'll go down to John Dona and come all the way back and end
2:49:30 with Commissioner Neck. So, Commissioner Kramer. Thank you, Chair Colby.
2:49:39 So, why uh why commercial future land use for apartments?
2:49:46 Is that I'm I'm looking for an answer from anybody. John, that I'm just it's based around the surrounding uses
2:49:53 of the um property and the future land use category. So, let me just put that up real quick. Thanks, Justine.
2:50:04 So, when reviewing projects, you want to make sure that the surrounding properties uh
2:50:12 don't that they match, right? That they conform to each other and they're compatible. So um when
2:50:19 reviewing their uh PUD um future land use category and saw that the um PUB uh
2:50:28 ordinance has like the actual existing entitlements in which they can be um buil built out. the uh staff noticed
2:50:36 that the um proposed plan met the condition the commercial future land use category and um thought it would be
2:50:45 better for them to do a commercial future land use category than keep the PUD because it meets the category and
2:50:52 then also for potential redevelopment not saying that it will be but like we don't know what's going to happen in 50 years um this area may change uh they
2:51:02 might want to redevelop a bit for commercial. Thanks, Jesse.
2:51:10 Anything else? One moment.
2:51:19 Actually, no further questions. Okay.
2:51:22 Commissioner Hoisington, he asked my one question I have about commercial for apartments. So, I'm good.
2:51:31 Okay. Did you have a comment? Well, I I I just want to add I mean, typically when you have uh multif family
2:51:38 apartments, those usually are considered commercial and not residential. Um part of the there's a lot of reasons for that. One of them is that um one of the
2:51:47 functions of these units is income production. It's it's it's not necessarily owners residential. Um that's one of the big reasons.
2:51:57 All right. Thank you, Commissioner Teddona.
2:52:01 Thank you, Mr. Chair. Can I uh I'll be quick. I'll be real. I promise.
2:52:09 So, I asked Google AI, my subject matter expert.
2:52:15 What's the apartment vacancy rate in Clermont, Florida, and the current rate is 12% to 13.7%.
2:52:24 So, I asked Google, is that number high?
2:52:28 and it said yes, it's ex considered exceptionally high. Clermont is currently experiencing a textbook supply
2:52:34 glut due to rapid apartment overbuilding outstripping local demand. A healthy
2:52:41 rate is in Orlando, which is 5.5 to 6.3%. We're double that.
2:52:50 So, I asked Google, could you do me a favor and cross reference the original Breitbart article that I brought in with
2:52:58 that assessment of the apartment vacancy rate and basically the key paragraph for
2:53:05 me is developers are building for a population that won't exist. Developers in Clermont are tearing up local space
2:53:14 to construct multifamily units based upon recent hyper growth trends. Carney,
2:53:21 who was the author of the Breitbart piece, argues that the expert class consensus demanding endless building is deeply narrowminded.
2:53:31 Developers are aggressively building supply just as the peak demand curve is actually beginning to permanently
2:53:39 flatten. [snorts] And then it goes on to I I asked would we be better off um looking into commercial properties in
2:53:48 the form of three to four story buildings and yeah I realize I'm talking to a computer but it also lists out some of the other stuff.
2:53:58 The second page comes from a article out of the Orlando Business Journal and I had to read it over a couple of times.
2:54:10 So SeaWorld is actually fighting an apartment complex plan
2:54:18 and SeaWorld is basically saying it would directly impact its parks operations, traffic,
2:54:26 security and guest experience. So a play on words but those that description basically talks about Clermont. It
2:54:35 would something like this would impact our operation uh infrastructure traffic which I know we can't talk about uh
2:54:44 security let's call it safety and guest experience would be life safety um they also cited that there was an
2:54:52 incomplete traffic study from the developer when I look at this and I consider Clermont's life quality
2:55:01 issue emergency life safety emergency infrastructure emergency and that we need more commercial development. I
2:55:08 mean, this would be a perfect parcel to put a corporate building in here. But instead, what we have is the cookie
2:55:18 cutter, one lane in, one lane out on Hardle Road down by 455
2:55:26 where we're going to have somewhere in the neighborhood of 200 to 600 cars coming and going. Uh, I'm familiar with
2:55:35 that area cuz that's the road I go to church on. I don't really know what we're going to wind up doing to try to direct that traffic out of there, but I
2:55:43 do know that right down the block is a bike crossing where you've got people on
2:55:50 the trail crossing traffic. And with all due respect, we've got just as many irresponsible bikers who are who are
2:55:58 riding in the street as we have cars that are not looking out for bikers. So, I don't really, again, have too many
2:56:07 questions. I just think we could do better. It's just a cookie cutter development that's just going to
2:56:15 make uh Hardle Road look like the next hardwood marsh road. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
2:56:22 Thank you, Commissioner May.
2:56:27 Thank you. Um, can you show me from this map here? Uh, you were talking about sidewalks. Uh, but you were talking about it, but I couldn't figure out.
2:56:37 Yeah, just let me know. Yeah,
2:56:39 [snorts]
2:56:42 just right there.
2:56:44 Is there a trail um on the back end of that property? Do we know? because it
2:56:51 looks like there is. But um is there a trail that runs you're talking about the property right here?
2:56:58 Yes. What is that? Is an abandoned uh railroad track, right?
2:57:01 That is correct. Um it is owned by Lake County. It is not improved for a trail.
2:57:07 It is not part of their conceptual trail map at this time. But it but does it connect to a trail? No.
2:57:14 I don't believe so. Okay.
2:57:17 Not at this time. if that's something that you if that's something that we want to reach out to Lake County to see about
2:57:25 improving, they could potentially do that. But, um, based on Lake County's trail maps, this is not not It's not even close. Okay. I just
2:57:34 wanted to It looked like there was something behind it, so I wasn't sure.
2:57:37 It looks like um I just wanted to know if that was a trail.
2:57:42 Just more information, old Highway 50 was also connected to that portion as well, was it? Okay.
2:57:47 Yes. Perfect. Um, so understanding the I guess the utility
2:57:54 agreement was in place uh August 27th, 2024 17.89.
2:58:01 Uh, PUD is already in place from Glake County showing apartments for 212 multifamily.
2:58:08 So commercial would be um I guess the next compatible uh based on what's around as well as the
2:58:16 unit count. with uh with commercial which is 12 units to the to the acre that allows for apartments, condos or
2:58:22 town homes, live work or ALF um lighting per se. Are you guys going to
2:58:31 be doing blue lighting, blue sky or lighting as part of this? I think that's a new code.
2:58:37 Yeah, our our photo photo our photometrics would be consistent with the with the with the new standards or with the code. Yeah.
2:58:45 Question though, it's interesting. I was going through the conditions. Um, and you guys added some extra conditions.
2:58:50 Are these conditions that were required by the county? I mean, um, I do like that you're doing an environmental assessment dated within six months of
2:58:58 the date. So, I appreciate that because I don't see that a lot. Um, so I do like that you guys put that in as a condition.
2:59:07 The other thing that was interesting was this overlay district area site design standards. What where did that come from? I mean that is a Lake Aapka basin
2:59:16 overlay district. Can you explain why that was put in there?
2:59:25 So that is so the property already has existing entitlements with Lake County.
2:59:31 All we're doing is trying to take those entitlements and put them into the city's formats. Um Lake County's overlay
2:59:39 district is the Lake Aapka overlay district. Um that one does align with this property. Um they've had to go
2:59:48 through probably multiple reviews in order to ensure that this conceptual plan matches with their design standards
2:59:55 for that overlay district which may affect the way that the layout is
3:00:01 currently. So we have decided to keep that in there to ensure that their
3:00:08 conceptual plan is maintained based on what was presented during the utility agreement um meeting as well as um what is consistent with the entitlements through Lake County.
3:00:19 That's actually the answer I was looking for. [laughter] Okay. And then um I do appreciate that you're doing perpetuity for preservation
3:00:26 of common open space using conservation of open easement. You brought that over.
3:00:30 That's good. Bear management. That's an interesting I've never seen that before.
3:00:35 City approved bear resistant garbage carts or dumpsters. Do we have a bear problem and that's in that location.
3:00:42 Just just a interesting condition. I've never seen that one before.
3:00:46 So, I'll just clarify. Um, we are taking what was in Lake County's PUB. Yes.
3:00:52 And that is in the Lake Apopka overlay, which that's standard language under Lake County. instead of totally taking
3:00:59 it out. If we took it out, you would never know about it. It's a way to capture what came over from Lake County and it's in there.
3:01:08 Yeah. No, I I So, this is the first time I've seen something like this from I mean, you've been on here longer than me, but out of the two years I've
3:01:16 been here, this is something new. So,
3:01:19 [snorts]
3:01:19 um I don't think I have any other issues.
3:01:23 Uh like kind of type of pedestrian. Okay.
3:01:27 So all access management shall be in accordance with the comprehensive plan.
3:01:30 It says the developer shall evaluate the city of Clermont. The need for and type of pedestrian crossing improvements on
3:01:37 CR455 the cost mitigation. What does that mean? Is that are you planning to do a pedestrian crossing to go to the Publix
3:01:46 or is that I don't see it on your plans here. So that's number 11 page 226.
3:01:57 So any pedestrian crossing, they would have to work with Lake County to come across there. Um it's probably early in
3:02:05 the in the design process. Now when they come through for site review, that is the time when we coordinate with Lake
3:02:12 County and they would come up. That's why it states in there um in terms of need type of pedestrian crossing.
3:02:22 Yeah. Number 11. So, public works would be the one. Lake County Public Works, of course, would be the driver on that.
3:02:28 That I would like for uh you guys to continue that. I think it'll be great to have a pedestrian crossing, especially a Publix.
3:02:35 Um for safety issues. Yeah. So, I appreciate that. Um other than that, I do not have anything else. Um I like the project, so I appreciate it.
3:02:46 Thank you.
3:02:48 Thank you, Commissioner Neim. Is there anything left to ask?
3:02:52 Whoa. Well, I'm telling you, that's why I like on last. I mean, going straight from Paula to Michael to John and to Jenny. I mean,
3:03:00 it's great, but I just want to pretty much uh
3:03:09 So, why didn't you go to the county and ask for this?
3:03:13 I [snorts] mean, it's nice going last because you know what my questions are going to be. You should have an answer.
3:03:17 Uh, this this was submitted and approved uh by Lake County. So, we do have an existing approval from Lake. That's the answer I was looking for. Good.
3:03:25 Yes, sir.
3:03:26 All right. Staff, is this interfere with DPZ?
3:03:31 I know it's on one side of it's on the other side, but um in terms of that, it's still in Lake County, so more than likely they did not
3:03:38 analyze it, but I can't fully answer that question.
3:03:41 I understand that because they were infringing on waterfront property. All right. Uh sidewalks. Back to the applicant, please. Yes, sir.
3:03:51 Answer these. Good.
3:03:53 You said the daycare center. The young lady out there was asking that question. Where you putting these sidewalks?
3:04:00 So, we would have the required access to the to the rightway, right? And so, from the rightway, you can then go wherever
3:04:07 you want to go. Uh but we will have sight sidewalks for the pedestrians to navigate the the community and then we
3:04:16 would have sidewalks to the rightway if they want to go to the the daycare. If there's a sidewalk to the daycare, they can get there.
3:04:26 All right, that's one nice walk. A lot of steps for that one. So there's going to be no wall around the property
3:04:32 security. So the deter this site like a lot of sites in in in this area will you use walls. We will have walls.
3:04:42 So it'll be a gated community.
3:04:43 No, no, there well it'll be an open community but walls.
3:04:47 I'm talking about uh retaining walls, right? Uh okay.
3:04:51 So sorry I I we just to make up the grade. We have retaining walls throughout the site that are consistent with the the city of Clermont requirements.
3:04:59 Right. I went I went to the site. I see what I'm assuming what you're doing.
3:05:04 Uh the most important question is where's the egress?
3:05:08 The emergency egress for emergency vehicles. I only see one in and out.
3:05:13 Uh well, there's there's two. There's one on the there's one on the north and one on the south. Uh yeah, two here. Well, cuz I'm looking at this one.
3:05:21 Yeah.
3:05:22 And there's nothing on that. So, I might as well throw this away then.
3:05:25 Yeah. I mean, so at one point with the Lake County, it was is contemplated to be Yeah. because I just wanted for the record that this
3:05:33 conceptional plan doesn't coincide with this conceptional plan.
3:05:38 I at least want to make a comment on that. The colored document that you have showing the conceptual plan that is per
3:05:45 the utility agreement. So that is the conceptual plan that was shown during um city council meeting for the utility agreement. The one in black and white
3:05:54 has gone through a couple updates. So, that is the most up-to-date plan and that is what is um consistent with their
3:06:03 existing entitlements with Lake County and what they would be doing if it's approved.
3:06:08 I understand. I just wanted to state for the record something should have been on it so it doesn't confuse the commissioners up here. All right.
3:06:17 Because I saw it on the black and white. I just want to know on the record why it wasn't on the color. And that's the answer I
3:06:26 was looking for. No further questions, Mr. Chairman.
3:06:29 Yeah. Um, for the time just while we're on that, there is an arrow up there. Is that is that arrow supposed to show that like that just for feature reference?
3:06:38 Like at the top of the the the drawing that he that he's mentioning there there's a two-way arrow up there. Is is
3:06:46 that supposed to is that supposed to let us know that that is Yeah, the the the north drive into the
3:06:54 site is that's primarily for emergency access.
3:06:57 You know, I I understand, but I'm just asking from from the the sta the staff standpoint, if we if we see something like that, does that does that tell us that that that is an access point or
3:07:05 that's just uh No. If it's zoomed in a little bit more, um John will do it for me. Thank you. Um,
3:07:13 it calls it out as emergency access. So, yeah, I'm good. I'm good. All right. Um, I'm I
3:07:22 I'm all set. Do any other um commissioners have any questions they'd like to ask?
3:07:28 Yeah. I just want to confirm there will be a sidewalk along the entire west side or I'm sorry, the entire east side.
3:07:36 East side.
3:07:37 Yes, there will be a sidewalk. It will be in the right of way. It would be a public sidewalk within the rightway that's that is constructed as part of this development.
3:07:46 Okay. Because I because I just see a sidewalk that goes in within the thing, but I just wanted to make sure it's on record. Okay.
3:07:54 And that neighborhood is open to the public. So, Right. They could just walk in to Yeah. I We've got to have an we we we
3:08:02 have to have a I want that for the record.
3:08:04 A a a sidewalk to the community. We we we have to I'm saying if Okay, I'm sorry to ask this question. If the public is walking
3:08:13 on that sidewalk, do they have access to enter your community? Absolutely. Simple question. Yeah, they can come in.
3:08:21 That's that's what I want for the record. Thank you.
3:08:25 Okay. Uh if there's no other questions, we can entertain a motion.
3:08:30 I'll make the motion to approve ordinance number 2026-041 Hardle Hills Smallscale Comprehensive Plan Amendment. Okay, we have a motion.
3:08:41 Is there a second on that? A second.
3:08:45 We have a motion and a second. Any discussion? All in favor?
3:08:51 I I nay. and chair votes I.
3:09:00 And item number seven, I'd like to make a motion to approve ordinance number 2026-042, Hardle Hills Reszoning.
3:09:11 We have a motion. Do we have a second? Second. Motion and a second. All in favor? I. I. I. I.
3:09:18 Chair votes I. All oppose? Nay.
3:09:22 All right, that takes care of item number seven. There is one more item.
3:09:26 Um, one non-aggenda item, uh, John Cruz requested a brief staff report about expiring terms for the Planning and Zona Commission.
3:09:35 Thank you, uh, Mr. Colby. Um, so I just wanted to let you know that there's four seats that their term ends the end of
3:09:43 this year. Uh those seats are seat two uh Commissioner Kramer, seat three,
3:09:51 Commissioner Hosington, seat four, Commissioner May, and seat six, Commissioner Teddona.
3:09:59 So, between now and November 20th, uh if you would submit a letter of intent to the city clerk's office if you
3:10:08 would like to remain considered for the planning and zoning commission. And um the city clerk's office will also be
3:10:16 putting that out on the website within the next day or two. Uh so I just wanted to let you know those four seats are
3:10:24 will be um up for reappointment at the end of this year. And um everybody have a happy Thanksgiving and I guess we'll see you in December.
3:10:33 Just a letter, no relication.
3:10:35 Uh again, I'm just getting what the clerks told me today. Just a letter of intent. Perfect. Thank you.
3:10:43 You may want to just double check the the website, but that is what was conveyed to me this morning. A letter of intent.
3:10:50 Yeah. And then Yes, sir. It would be to the clerk's office. It would be um should be Tracy
3:10:57 um And then it goes to council for a vote. Correct.
3:11:00 Yes. The the procedure, the way it works is then at the December 8th meeting, um it'll be brought forth to city council, the number of people interested in the
3:11:09 positions or the seats. Uh sometimes they'll give you the opportunity to get up and speak and then the city council
3:11:17 members make the make the vote or they make the motion and vote on the seat and appointments during that meeting.
3:11:24 All right, sounds good. Anything else?
3:11:26 All right. Can I have a motion to adjourn? I'll set a motion. All right, we are adjourned.