Clermont City Council Workshop Transcript 7/7/26

7:11 Um, commissioners, you should have received the minutes from the June 2nd meeting. If there are no additions,
7:18 corrections, or questions, I will entertain a motion and a second for approval. I have one tiny correction.
7:25 Go ahead. On the very last page where it says motion to recommend approval of ordinance 20261-021,
7:34 we already approved that on the page before that needs to say 26 2026-022
7:41 because we've already got two 21 on the page before that and we uh combine them together. So one tiny correction.
7:48 Okay. Are there but that I'll make a motion to Are there any other corrections?
7:53 I'll make a motion to approve with the correction. with the correction. Okay. Do I have a second? Second. All in favor?
8:00 I I.
8:01 That is unanimous. Uh we will now move to uh commissioner reports. I will start to my far right with commissioner Hoisington.
8:12 Um oh I I attended the city Junth
8:19 program. Um it was very very good. Could I invite everyone next year to please find time to come down and celebrate Junth with us? And that's all I have.
8:28 All right. Thank you very much, Commissioner Kramer.
8:31 Thank you. I just want to begin by saying how pleased I am to see the ordinance around dark sky compliance tonight. So, this is one of the first
8:40 times I've really looked forward to one of these meetings because I think a lot of people know that that's been something I've advocated for a long time. Um, but I also want to recognize
8:49 and thank our staff and the legal department for the considerable amount of work that went into bringing this ordinance forward. So, um, I appreciate
8:56 this opportunity for us to have the discussion tonight around something I feel very important. Thank you. Thank you, Commissioner Neck.
9:03 Yes. I'd like to thank all those patriots for coming out in the weather for Fourth of July for the Clermont 250. Uh, once again, thank you and thank
9:13 you for showing your support. No other report. Thank you. And Commissioner Ensuo, I just want to apologize for being a bit
9:20 tardy. I spent the fourth of I spent the 4th of July taught uh potty training a 2-year-old. So, it's been a it's been a
9:27 lot of fun. So, yeah. Yeah, for sure. For sure. You are president and account for it.
9:33 So, Exactly.
9:34 Thank you for making it. Um I just wanted to to point out one community event that we have coming up, the Lake County Hobnob. And um the venue host is
9:43 City of Clermont. Alo at the Clermont Performing Arts Center on Monday the 27th will be a hobnob where people can meet people running for city, county,
9:52 state, and federal office. And that is a free event and it's from 5 to 7:30. So I just wanted to make that known. Uh
10:00 before we move into unfinished and new business, uh commissioners will report any disclosures they have on any of
10:08 tonight's items. Please report which agenda item, subject matter, and identify the person's groups you may have communicated with. Um, if there is
10:17 more than one, please report them individually. As a reminder to commissioners to be transparent with the public, disclose any exparte
10:26 communication written or verbal in commissioner investigations, site visits, expert opinions received and
10:33 communications um being read tonight into the record must be disclosed um at the public meeting um where final action
10:41 will be taken. um by making disclosure any such activities, actions and communication shall not be presumed
10:50 prejuditial and allows persons who have opinions to the contrary a reasonable opportunity to refute and respond. Um so
11:00 um if anybody would like to make disclosures, I'll start to my far left.
11:03 Um Commissioner Ensua, any disclosures you would like to make? No disclosures at this time.
11:08 Commissioner Neck, no disclosure at this time as well.
11:12 Commissioner Kramer, no disclosures.
11:15 Commissioner Hoisington, no disclosures, sir.
11:18 And the chair has no disclosures at this time either. Um, having addressed the the disclosures, uh, we'll now move into
11:26 unfinished and new business. Um, before we have the city staff and applicant um, present, um,
11:34 um, we will now need to handle um, the items of the agenda individually. So,
11:42 um, we will start with item number one and we'll hear city staff on item number one, which is is resolution 2026-021R.
12:06 Good evening, planning and zoning commissioners and guests. Justine day with development services.
12:12 The applicant Peacock Partnership is requesting a conditional use permit to allow for a veterary clinic to operate on a property that is currently
12:20 undergoing site review. The property is located at the southeast corner of South US Highway 27 and Citrus Tower Boulevard
12:28 intersection within the Governor's Lake Commerce Center plan unit development.
12:33 On your screen, the parcel is outlined in yellow.
12:39 and just a zoomed in view of the parcel.
12:44 The applicant is proposing to build out a new animal clinic with the future multi-tenant shell building. The clinic will operate entirely indoors and offer
12:53 services such as checkups, diagnosis, dental care, and minor surgery to small animals. No overnight boarding or the
13:01 treatment of large animals such as livestock will be provided. Business hours will be Monday through Friday from 7:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m. and Saturday from
13:09 8:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m. The clinic will be preparing a waste management plan that includes an internal pet relief area. In the future, they may add an
13:18 outdoor relief area with a monitored waste station.
13:29 And just to show the concept plan, they will be going into a future multi-tenant building.
13:37 The property is governed by ordinance number 2020-24, which allows for mixeduse development with C1 light commercial uses. The
13:46 veterary clinic may be comparable to retail or medical office use with this within this district due to the services being offered. Additionally, the parcel
13:54 is situated between commercial development on the north, south, and west sides of the parcel, while Lake Falter provides a buffer on the east
14:02 side. The nearest residential use is approximately 1,00 ft away across South US Highway 27 and the nearest veterary
14:11 clinic is approximately 1 and a half miles away, south of the Hart Hartwood Marsh Road. Based on the site's
14:19 locations and surrounding uses, staff finds the proposed use compatible with the district and would not be more obnoxious to the existing permitted uses.
14:29 When evaluating a request for a conditional use permit, section 1012 of the land development code outlines specific development standards that are
14:37 required to be met. Staff has reviewed the application and finds the proposed use can meet the general criteria for approval and would not be detrimental to
14:46 the health, safety, and welfare of the surrounding community. Therefore, staff recommends approval of resolution number 2026-01R.
14:56 This concludes staff presentation.
14:58 Thank you very much. Uh we now like to hear from the applicant.
15:10 Good evening, commissioners. My name is uh Jim Graham. I'm with City Vet. Um our the applicant is actually Peacock Partnership. That's their our architect.
15:20 Um but yeah, really I'm just I'm just here to answer any questions you all may have. Um and we really think we'll be a
15:28 great uh service and an amenity to the community.
15:32 All right. Well, thank you very much and please stand by because the commissioners may have some questions. Be happy to. Thank you.
15:37 Thank you. All right. Uh we'll now um um open it up for um public comment. Uh
15:45 if there's anybody here um who would like to come up and and speak in the the public hearing section of our meeting, uh please come up at this time.
15:55 Anybody like to speak on this item?
15:58 Hearing no one, uh, we will close the public hearing and we will go to the commission. So, I will start to my far right with Commissioner Hoisington.
16:08 Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Um, I in reviewing this, I see that it's built within the multi-tenant space. The
16:17 hours are reasonable. Um, when I first started reading, I was worried about um the waste management, but they addressed that. They're not going to service any
16:26 large animals. The one question that I had, the staff report says that the clinic will not provide overnight boarding or offering care to large
16:34 animals such as livestock etc. But then in the resolution 202621R
16:43 section 2 number three it talks about
16:50 um when it's medically necessary for overnight observation and monitoring may be allowed on site overnight.
16:58 So I'm wondering why is there a conflict between that statement and this one?
17:04 So that was put in as a in the occurrence of something happening
17:13 that they have that just for medical necessity. Um sometimes at least from my
17:20 previous experience uh animals will come in late or like right before a clinic is closing that could have an emergency situation.
17:31 It's a lot better for the animal if they're able to help the animal in that case, which may bleed into
17:40 extending the overnight or extending their business hours or potentially overnight depending on if they need to be
17:48 one surgically evaluated and then to um find a facility for them to actually give the overnight like an ER,
17:58 right? And I understand that. Yeah. And when I read that there will be no overnight, I thought, what if there's an emergency with an animal that the
18:05 surgery did not go as well or the owner can't pick the animal up? The the the applicant has stood up. Maybe he can uh expand upon that.
18:13 I just wonder why the report was different than the resolution.
18:17 Sure. We we we tend to make a designation between boarding and hospitalization.
18:25 So, for example, a a you know, you wouldn't go to the hospital and say, "Hey, I I I need a room for the night."
18:32 Um, similar situation, a a customer cannot bring their pet to us and just say, "Hey, I'm I'm going on vacation. I
18:40 need you to watch my pet overnight." That that's not going to happen. So, yes, if there are any medical procedures, really, the only time an
18:48 animal will be kept overnight is in regard to a medical procedure. and then that customer is paying for that medical
18:55 procedure. They're not they're not build for boarding or anything like that. And again, they just can't bring their their pet to us and say, "We'd like you to
19:04 keep our pet overnight." And in most cases, if if those animals um are kept overnight, they're sedated. They're in
19:12 their kennels. They're they're nice and comfortable and hopefully resting and recuperating. Okay. Thank you. Thank you.
19:19 That's all I have. Okay.
19:21 Thank you, Commissioner Kramer.
19:24 Um, I think this one's pretty straightforward for me tonight and um, I think Commissioner Hoisington brought up most of the things. I only had one question says more for staff.
19:34 Um, because it's a multi-tenant commercial center. Are we satisfied that the parking calculation accounts not
19:42 only for city vet but for the cumulative demand once the remaining 10 spaces are occupied? So currently right now they
19:50 are over the amount I believe they're providing 96 uh spaces and for just the retail towards the north and the vet
20:00 they're required 27. So they are more than enough currently. We are unsure of the use on the middle tenant so far.
20:07 Well you answered that quite nicely just thank you very much. That's all I have. All right Commissioner Neck.
20:14 Thank you Mr. Chairman. Uh, number one, I'd like to point out to staff that online, the exceptional plan is online, but it's not in my packet.
20:26 Are we saving money? I asked this question numerous times. I'm not here to beat up my staff. I think they're doing a phenomenal job, but it's not in my packet.
20:37 Okay?
20:39 And maybe it's not in my packet. Does anybody else have it? No.
20:44 All right. cuz you know I'm a stickler for that. That was a very good question, Mr. Kramer. And I'm sure that you got that answer by looking online.
20:54 So my question to staff is, are we going to be doing away with our packets and just doing everything online or are we going to be more thorough and making sure we get a full packet?
21:06 Okay, that's number one. Number two, I would like to ask the applicant in your own words, how is this going to benefit Clermont?
21:18 How's it going to benefit Clermont? I I assume that a significant portion of your residents are pet owners. Um, we
21:27 provide really top-notch service and on top of that, we're we're a little different than other vet providers. Um,
21:35 a lot of your national corporate providers, say a Bfield, um, number of the others, the the vet is
21:42 just an employee. At our locations, our vet is an owner. They are a partner with
21:49 us at City Vet. So, um, you have a veterinarian that's going to live here,
21:56 work here, play here, and be a part of your community as we hope that this clinic will be and be a good good service provider to your community.
22:06 That was a great answer considering that you have a lot of vets and clinics surrounding you from Hartwood Mos
22:13 straight on down. that that is something that when we look at a potential new location, something that we do take into
22:20 consideration, we look at at the overall population within a certain radius around that site and then also look at
22:29 the competition and we would not have chosen this location if we didn't think that there was demand and the growth
22:37 that would would uh make this clinic successful. Now, being a pet owner, I would like to answer uh ask one question
22:44 uh to follow up on uh Commissioner Hoyston's question. Uh if there is an overnight stay on late procedure or
22:54 emergency procedure, will there be any staff members?
22:58 Um, oftentimes staff may I if if we end up offering urgent care at this location, staff very well would be there
23:06 till maybe 10 or 11:00, but usually staff does not stay overnight. As I mentioned, the the pets are often
23:14 sedated and then the clinic will open back up at 7 a.m. and staff will be right there.
23:19 So that's a 9-hour non-supervision of the animals. Correct. While they're in their kennels. Yes.
23:25 Okay. No other questions? All right, Commissioner Ensu.
23:30 Thank you, Chair. Uh, M Mr. Franklin, correct? Mr. Graham.
23:34 Mr. Graham. Sorry. That's okay. I'll give you all a card. Thank you. No, I appreciate it.
23:37 Make sure you check with me. We'll we'll get you get you some nice initial discount customers. No, no, no, no, no. I'm sorry.
23:47 Get me in trouble.
23:48 I'm in a little trouble as it get me in trouble. Sorry.
23:51 Don't worry. I I actually don't have any questions. Everybody actually asked everything that I was concerned about.
23:57 um mainly just the parking in that area in general. So I I think uh this is open and chat and parking is a very important issue to
24:05 us as well. Um usually um I I I think we're still in the process of of
24:12 actually negotiating this lease. We usually make sure that we have a couple either shortterm or reserved parking
24:19 spaces for us right in front of the clinic for a couple of reasons.
24:24 um one if there are any animals that are um that that can't they can't you know the owner has to pick them up and carry
24:32 them in especially if they're a larger animal or also again if if the animals uh you know uh immobile and they're
24:40 bringing them them in for euthanasia um uh so yeah that that's one issue and yeah I think the other issue is that
24:49 most of our appointments we don't do a lot of walk-in So most of our appointments are scheduled or or there's often a drop off and
24:58 pickup uh time period. So there aren't a lot we're not very parking heavy.
25:04 Great. No, that's good to hear. I know there's a couple of other vet offices in the area that get a bit swamped either from double scheduling or whatnot. So
25:12 it's nice to see that you are thinking about doing a temporary drop off or spot for for your uh for your patients. So,
25:19 yes, we that's something we're always looking for. It's it's the the property owners that we lease from that that don't always like that so much.
25:28 Yeah, understandable. Thank you. Thank you.
25:31 Uh I just have just a clarification on the timing. Somebody does bring their their dog in before your closing time of 6:00 and it is emergency and you have to
25:39 treat them, you're still locking the doors at 6:00, you are you are closing for business at at that time. Even if you're extended.
25:48 Yeah. I mean, well, I mean, if if we're if we're extended, we'll we would have we would be open to urgent care. So,
25:55 say, yeah. So, our normal appointments, say, for example, yeah, our our standard clinic hours are 7 to 7 and then, but
26:02 then if we open for urgent care, we may stay open till 9 or 10 10:00 p.m. Um, but again, not knowing just yet whether
26:10 or not this location will uh have urgent care. Um but yeah, normally normal business hours, yeah, we'll we'll close.
26:18 No more regular appointments, none of that. Only only urgent care. Okay. Can I ask a quick followup? Yeah, go ahead.
26:25 Um so you've mentioned that twice now about if it'll have urgent care or not.
26:29 What usually determines in y'all's y'all's perspective what is urgent care?
26:34 There are a number of factors that go into that. Again, number one is competition. if we've got a lot of other vets or if all of our nearest competitors are already offering uh
26:43 urgent care or if there's say um uh an emergency hospital nearby, we probably
26:51 wouldn't offer it. Uh say if there was a a veg, veterinary uh yeah, I can't remember the acronym for veg, but it's
26:59 uh uh yeah, veterinary emergency group or something like that. So, if if they have one of their hospitals nearby, we're we're probably not going to going
27:06 to do it. Um, so yeah, it's just it's just a matter of really looking at that and also our veterinarian and their
27:15 staffing if they can if they can handle handle it from a staffing standpoint.
27:19 Mr. Chairman, if I may, just one more quick question, please. Sir, uh, just curious uh, because I've been
27:26 to a lot of vets in Clermont and I actually had to go outside Clermont to find a good one. Uh, what's the largest?
27:34 Now, I know you say you don't have livestock. What is the largest breed that you would take?
27:40 The largest breed of animal or what animal and the largest that you have experience with?
27:47 Now you're getting a little outside of my in my realm. I'm I'm our vice president of real estate. I'm not even I'm not even I'm sorry. I'm I'm not a veterinarian. I'm not I'm not so sorry.
27:56 You spoke very well about the other questions, but No. Okay, I get it.
28:01 Yeah. I mean, normally it it's really just household pets. Occasionally we get an exotic say say say say say say say
28:07 say say say say say say say say say say say say say say say say say say say say
28:07 say say say say say say say say say say say say say say a bird a snake you know iguana but in terms of size no we're we're
28:14 definitely not taking any you know I nobody coming in with a goat or yeah things like that no we're
28:23 well the reason why I'm asking you got rottellers you got oh yeah no yeah I mean their size of goats some of these
28:30 no I'm just asking because I want to know pretty much after I read that staff did a great job on explaining everything if you had the capability of keeping such a large animal overnight.
28:41 Yes, that's why I'm asking that question.
28:42 Absolutely. Um gosh, I wish I I was just at uh um our Lake Nona clinic today and yeah, we have we have a number of range
28:52 of size of kennels and and some of them are I'd say literally about as wide as this podium and yet you know full you
29:01 know just there's nothing above it. So there's, you know, a human can open the door, walk into it, and and the the pet has plenty of room.
29:09 Okay. Thank you. You mentioned you have a lot of experience because you have a number of facilities. How many facilities do you have?
29:16 Um, we now have Okay. Over or we have 83 city vet locations um in 12 states right
29:25 now. As I mentioned, we um we have two open here in the uh Orlando area, one in
29:33 Lake Nona, one up in Castleberry. We actually have another one under construction further south on Highway 27 down in Davenport.
29:43 And this would be our fourth location here in the Orlando uh greater Orlando area.
29:49 Great. Thank you. Uh can I ask one question?
29:52 Go ahead. Um it just piqued my my curiosity. You mentioned that um if the animal the pet
30:01 has to stay overnight because of complications from surgery that at some point they are they're left there alone.
30:11 What if that animal goes into distress from the time that the last staff person goes home to the time that you open up at 7 o'lock in the morning? Does the
30:20 owner have any type of way of visually seeing their pet to know if the pet is
30:27 okay during the night? I mean, what happens if there's an emergency and no one's there and then you get there and there's been complications that no one was there to attend?
30:36 Um, okay, great question. First off, I don't I I'm almost positive our staff would not leave any pet that was not
30:44 stable. Um, I even know I I I if it our our Lake Nona clinic actually on the
30:53 bottom of our door has has recommendations for the nearest emergency clinic because that clinic
31:00 does not do urgent care. Um, so, so yeah, I I'm I'm almost positive that
31:07 that none of the staff would would leave if if we had an animal that was not stable and then would transfer them to a
31:17 a a hospital that would be able to provide them the proper monitoring and
31:24 observation uh if necessary. Um, and we actually have a couple of hospitals like that. We don't have one here in the
31:33 Orlando area. Um our our hospital brand is called Arista. Um we have one of
31:40 those in Dallas, Atlanta, and um we've we've got one that's about ready to open in Jacksonville.
31:49 Okay. So that explains that I mean I would think that a staff would not leave if a animal is in distress, but I'm
31:56 saying anything could happen. things could happen an hour later, two hours, something happens to that animal during that time when there's no one there.
32:04 That was my concern. Not not that a staff would leave and a patient was not stable, but what happens when there's no
32:11 one there and the animal may go into distress? How does the vet, the staff,
32:18 the owner knows that their pet is now in distress and there's no one at the facility? As far as monitor, as far as I
32:27 I'm aware, I've I've not heard of any incidents where we've we've lost a pet due to overnight care.
32:35 All right. Any other questions?
32:39 All right. Hearing none, I will entertain a motion. I would like to set a motion of resolution
32:47 2026-021R for the city vet conditional use permit.
32:54 Do I have a second? Second. A motion in a second. All in favor?
32:59 I I. And the chair votes I. It's unanimous. Thank you very much. Thank you very much, commissioners. Appreciate your time.
33:11 All right. We will move on to item number two when staff is ready.
33:19 Good evening, planning and zoning commissioners and guests. Justine Day with development services at the direction of the city manager's
33:27 office and city council staff is proposing an amendment to the land development codes in order to provide for lighting standards within the city
33:34 limits. Land Development Code sections 24-12 and 11512 provided regulations for lighting to illuminate properties
33:43 without subjecting adjacent properties to unnecessary and unreasonable reflection or glare. However, these
33:50 sections of the code do not provide standards to measure by or enforce when reviewing development applications. The proposed amendment would repeal these
33:58 sections of the code and replace them with a new chapter that would then establish enforceable standards for outdoor lighting.
34:05 The new chapter would be created to align the city's outdoor lighting regulations with modern model standards published by Dark Sky International and the Illuminating Engineering Society.
34:15 While resolution 2026-2R would help implement the standard set forth in section 129-4D
34:24 of the new chapter. If the amendment is approved, the city would provide for a phased implementation and retrofit plan to bring all new and existing
34:32 non-conforming city-owned and city leased outdoor lighting fixtures into compliance with the new chapter by no later than September 1st, 2031.
34:42 Subject to coordination with Duke Energy and other applicable utility providers, the city manager or designate shall
34:49 conduct an inventory of all city-owned and or leased outdoor lighting fixtures within 12 months of the effective date and shall provide annual updates to the
34:58 city council until compliance is achieved. Any other existing non-conforming outdoor lighting shall be brought into compliance with this
35:06 chapter no later than the earlier of when the fixture is replaced, removed, or substantially modified or by September 1st, 2036.
35:15 This would be applicable to all new outdoor lighting installations and all replacement of existing outdoor lighting fixtures within the corporate limits of
35:24 the city of Clermont, including residential, commercial, industrial, institutional, and municipal installations except as
35:33 expressly exempted within the proposed regulations.
35:36 The proposed amendment in order to fully support the dark sky initiative and minimize glare, reduce light trespass and lessen pollution of the night sky
35:44 would be applicable to all properties within the city limits. With this amendment, there would be a cost to upgrade and replace the fixtures, which
35:52 is unknown at this moment. The potential savings would be long-term electricity consumption. Both the proposed new chapter and the resolution to the code
36:01 would help provide consistency with the submittal regulations within the land development codes and is consistent with the city's comprehensive plan. Staff
36:09 recommends approval of ordinance number 2026-25 and resolution number 2026-22R.
36:18 This concludes staff presentation.
36:20 All right. Thank you very much. At this time, I'll open up the floor for public comment if anyone present would like to comment on this.
36:30 All right, hearing none, I will bring it back to the commission and I will start to my left with Commissioner Ensuo. Uh, thank you, Chair. Honestly, I love this.
36:39 I'm glad that was something we're finally taking a look at. I know long time ago it was more of just an idea and I'm glad to see that uh city manager's
36:48 office, the council and staff are taking a look at this. So, I don't have any really burning questions for it.
36:55 Thank you, Commissioner Neck. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Uh, yeah, I read through uh majority
37:02 thoroughly. Uh, tried to nitpick it, but I gota my hats off to staff for doing an excellent job on this. Once again, like
37:10 my fellow Commissioner Kramer said, I mean, this is long overdue. Thank you.
37:15 Thank you, Commissioner Kramer. Thank you, Chair. Just a couple. You guys know I I'm so excited about this um because I
37:23 I'll remind you that my neighborhood is the first neighborhood, the older neighborhood to completely convert to dark sky. So, I feel like we're kind of
37:32 leading the way where I'm at and that you guys are catching up to that. So, I'm really excited. So, I went through this pretty thoroughly and to the point where my eyes are a little bit blurry.
37:42 Um so, I'm going to ask a couple of questions just to because I I want to help you guys get this right. So uh my first question was um
37:52 and this is a little tiny one but section 1294C
37:59 I'll give you a minute to find that talks so 4C talks about light trespass
38:07 and it talks about vertical and horizontal whichever is great so it's I won't read all the details of but it talks about foot candle measurement the
38:15 property line vertical or horiz horizontal. And then it goes on to talk about um later on in
38:25 G2 it talks about a finished grade ground level with the light registering portion of the meter held parallel to the ground and pointing upwards. So
38:33 that's how we measure horizontally, but I never saw a standard in here for how we measure vertically. So it's a little tiny thing, but we talk about how we're
38:42 going to measure horizontally and vertically. and and I didn't see vertically addressing there. So, I'm just pointing that out to you. Um
38:51 and then and and and Justini did a great job referencing um Dark Sky International and IE model standards. Um
39:00 and those are the technical guidance documents that you guys use to establish um the numerical thresholds. I see that.
39:07 But I want to make sure that those challenges are not challenged or challenged in the future. So my question
39:14 is the ordinance repeatedly states that the standards are consistent with Dark Sky International and the illuminating
39:22 engineering society but the ordinance does not identify which model ordinance publication addition or technical
39:29 guidance document report that supports those specific numbers. So just a little more specificity. You you reference the
39:36 document but you don't recommen ref reference where where you got that we can add that into it.
39:43 It's an easy addance. I think later on you'll find that if somebody challenges this that having that specificity will help you.
39:50 So and actually this is the Can you guys hear me? This is the city attorney. Yes, we can hear you. City attorney is on the phone.
39:58 Yeah. Could I just jump in on that point, Commissioner? Um, sure.
40:02 This this is obviously a very technical detailed ordinance in front of you with
40:08 a lot of proper nouns and um that's one of the things we struggled with in the city attorney's office actually and
40:16 that's because the the original thought was to actually kind of defer and
40:22 incorporate the Dark Sky International standards. In other words, not to have the actual numbers in our own ordinance,
40:30 but just to kind of almost outsource it to Dark Sky International. And I made the decision in drafting not to do that.
40:39 In other words, I think you as the city of Clermont should be able to choose your own numbers, you know, and because we we don't know necessarily when Dark
40:48 Sky International is going to change their standards. So, I didn't want to just defer those decisions to them. I
40:55 don't know if this helps you at all with kind of how you're looking at what you just said, but that is the basis for why some of it's worded the way it is.
41:04 Thank you, counselor. That really actually that really does help because it's it was me worrying about your comfort level, how you can hold this, how you can u defend this in the future.
41:14 But if you're comfortable with it, I am as well. Okay. Uh
41:22 and then in section 1296D, all new outdoor lighting installations
41:31 subject to this chapter shall incorporate adaptive controls. And I just want to be clear, does that include single family homes for the adaptive
41:40 controls? I saw in the very next statement it said that it would like um landscape lighting on residential units
41:47 to turn off at 11, but is that asking people to turn off their porch lights um
41:54 and things like that? I just was vague to me. So it it would include for both commercial and residential.
42:02 It it would be for any outdoor lighting fixture. So, if that's the porch light, um the landscaping does have um a
42:11 section in I believe the exemptions as well where it talks about certain lumens they just have to shield and make sure it's not visible from the other property
42:20 lines. So, that's something that we can look at if you think it's a little bit too much, but um it would be for both
42:28 residential and commercial. I I I see that a lot of this looks and feels a lot like what Groveland has done. And I I I've been over in Groveland, I've seen
42:37 that they even on new facilities where you're building a porch and you've got your porch light, they actually have a small like cup coming down to block that
42:46 light, which they had to actually go figure out how to how to address the new standard in their area. So, um luckily
42:54 they've worked through a lot of these problems before us.
42:57 Um, I'll jump in on that one, too. So, there
43:05 there are some similarities in this draft to to Groveland. It's it's definitely not a word for word. I don't even think it's I wouldn't even say it's
43:12 50%, but there are some things that are Oh, I've been told that I can speak quieter. Okay. So, um there are some
43:22 things that are similar or identical to the Groven ordinance. And part of the reason for that is Dark Sky International has model ordinances and
43:31 laws that they want people to adopt. So some of those have been uh adopted liberally.
43:38 Thank you. Um that's all the questions I have. Chair. All right. Thank you very much.
43:46 Commissioner Hoisington.
43:47 Thank you. Um I would also like to commend staff for all the work that you put into this. Um, I am a process person, a timeline person. So, I
43:56 appreciate it seeing that you have your process of how you're going to identify, you have your timeline of when things going to be done and I appreciate that.
44:03 So, congratulations and for moving this forward because I know it's been a long time needed and coming. Thank you.
44:10 Great. Thank you. Uh, yeah, I'd also um, you know, like to thank the city manager, the city council and and staff for a great effort here. I think I think
44:17 this is going to make a big difference in our community. So, thank you very much. Um, at this time I will entertain a motion on item number two.
44:29 Chair, I'd like to make a motion that we approve ordinance 2026-025
44:37 and resolution 2026-22R, Dark Skyland Development Code Amendment.
44:47 Second.
44:49 So, we're we're I'm sorry. you. We're doing 025. We're just just the O25. I'm sorry, 025. We'll do them individually. I I I'm
44:58 assuming I'm sorry, council. We need uh we need individual um You're right.
45:03 motions. Um that yes, they're two different items on our agenda. So, I'll amend my I'll amend my motion. I'd
45:10 like to make a motion that we approve ordinance 2026-025, Dark Sky Land Development Code Amendment.
45:18 Second.
45:21 We have a motion and a second. All in favor? I I.
45:24 And chair votes I. That's also unanimous. Thank you.
45:28 All right. We will move to um to item number three. Resolution. Oh, I am sorry.
45:37 Now I will make a resolution. Now I'll make a motion. Right. Right. Right. Right.
45:40 To approve ordinance 2026-022R under the Dark Sky Land Development Code Amendment.
45:48 Okay. So we have a motion for the resolution. For the resolution. Do I have a second for the resolution? Second.
45:55 Motion second. All in favor? I. I. Chair votes I. Okay. We will move to item number three.
46:06 Good evening planning and zoning commissioners and guests. Nicks Development Services. This is agenda item number three, land development code amendment surrounding property notifications.
46:16 At the direction of the city manager's office and city council, staff is proposing an amendment to the noticing requirements for certain land use and
46:24 development applications. Currently, the requirements are for public notices to be mailed to all adjoining property owners within 150 ft of the subject
46:32 property. There are several sections in the code that address this 100 foot requirement. In an effort to enhance public awareness and participation along
46:41 with keeping surrounding surrounding property owners and stakeholders informed, an increase in the written notification requirement is being
46:49 proposed at a distance of 450 ft. This is a 200% increase in the written notification requirements. No changes
46:56 are being proposed to the existing newspaper publications or the posting of signage on the subject property. The applications that would be affected by
47:04 this include conditional use permits, variances, resonings, future land use map amendments, and live local act
47:12 projects. In addition, if any property within the 450 ft radius of the subject property is governed by a property owners association, such as a
47:20 condominium association or homeowners association, notice shall also be provided to such association. This
47:27 language is also being added to better inform the community of the proposed land use changes that may impact their properties and or communities. Staff
47:35 recommends approval of these proposed changes contained within ordinance number 2026-026 since it finds that it would be in the
47:44 best interest of public and citizens of Clermont. That concludes SAS presentation.
47:48 Right. Thank you very much. I'll open it up for public comment. Would anyone like to speak on this?
47:55 Please come to the podium. State your name and address.
48:02 Thank you, Mr. Chair. Brian Bain from uh the Clermont City Council Seat 2. Uh just am here because I think it's
48:10 important as someone who sat up there before. um when a council member is involved working with staff on an
48:18 ordinance that that council member come here and let you know why they are working with staff on that and and the
48:26 rationale behind the proposal. And so that's what I'm doing here today.
48:30 letting you know that uh as someone who sat up there on PNZ for two years, as someone who's now been on council since
48:38 November, um we've heard it, you've heard it from residents that um the
48:44 radius that we currently use to go out is pretty minimal.
48:50 And um it literally um could mean one, two, five houses that get notified in a
48:58 neighborhood. And so in working with staff um what I understand from uh the
49:05 mapping software that is used that if you plug in a number it can automatically do that for you. So
49:12 there's there's no manual process because initially I would I I I I had suggested that if any house in any
49:20 neighborhood was included that the entire neighborhood get included and then it became a well what if we we
49:28 because now we have to manually go through and figure out which houses are all in that neighborhood. If we miss one that puts a big responsibility on the
49:34 city for missing that house. And so we then determined how could we do this with a radius that
49:42 actually made an actual uh positive net effect. And so we looked at 450 ft which
49:50 is a 200% increase from what we currently are doing at 150 ft. Now staff policy or their practice is that they
49:59 actually go an additional 50 ft. So with this, if you approve uh as a recommendation to the city council and the city council then approves would
50:08 actually get notification out to 500 ft uh of a neighborhood uh surrounding a
50:15 project. In addition to that, what we did include also as language is to say
50:21 that if any parcel in that radius is in an HOA or a condo association,
50:30 then notification must also go to that homeowners association or condo association. So that then kind of
50:37 allowed for additional notification for folks in that neighborhood, putting some responsibility on the homeowners
50:44 association or the condos association to notify their members of a project that's taking place nearby their their
50:52 residences. So um we added that language in here. And I'll also say that in doing this and working with staff, I learned
50:59 that notification does also go to the Lake County schools and the board of county commissioners. And so, uh, there's quite a bit of notification then
51:07 that would go out, um, from this. So, I think it is a, uh, a good effort for us to respond to the concerns we hear from
51:15 our residents and, uh, also address the transparency and engagement that we all strive to increase and have in our city.
51:24 And I'll answer any questions you might have. Thank you.
51:26 Thank you very much. Uh, is there anyone else in the public who would like to comment on this?
51:32 All right. Hearing none, I will bring it back to the commission for any comments or questions. Start with you, Commissioner Hoington.
51:42 I'm sorry.
51:43 Um, glad to see that this is taking place. I I just had the one question.
51:48 Why not 500 ft? But I'm glad to hear that you already do the additional 50, so I'm good. Thank you, Commissioner Kramer.
52:01 I look for typos. I look for lack of clarity. Um, this looks like good
52:07 policy. Um, I like like Mr. Bain said, this is something we've needed for a while and
52:16 and those of us sat up here for any length of time realize that we we were excluding a good number of our citizens
52:22 from um being notified. So, I I look very favorably on this. I I I
52:30 don't have any red lines or yellow lines or anything to to nitpick. So, thank you. Thank you, Commissioner Neck.
52:36 Yes. I have an obvious question. Uh it's directed to Councilman Baines.
52:44 I think it's I think it's just Bain without an S on the end. I think it's just Bain.
52:50 I I know him well enough. I could call him Bain.
52:52 I don't think people want two of me around here.
52:57 This is the first time ever at a planning and zoning meeting I ever saw a councilman come up to the podium as a public speaker.
53:05 So could you explain to me I mean are you part of the architect to this? Could you for clarification?
53:13 Yeah. So right after the election last November, I met with all the department heads and one of the department heads was Mr. potential. And I brought up to
53:22 he and his team that I would I would like to move forward with uh some revisions to this notification policy.
53:29 And it took some time to understand all the ramifications and the nuances of how that process works and who pays for it
53:36 and how it goes through the process and and after lots of back and forth, we settled on the the number that we could both agree to. Um, and then staff took
53:45 it from there, working with the city attorney to actually revise the language and actually bring you the ordinance change that's in front of you today.
53:53 I'd like to say thank you from most of the residents in my area for accomplishing this task. I mean,
54:02 questions were always asked to me over the past seven years. How come they only go out to 150 ft? And I said, well, they're being lenient. They go to 200.
54:11 It all depends on the community. And thank you again for putting the language in that it has to go directly if it's a
54:19 gated community to HOAs or to condominiums and so on. Thank you Mr. Baines.
54:26 Thank you Commissioner Ensua.
54:29 Thank you chair. Thank you for bringing this up. Uh Council Member Baines Baines Bain. You got me saying it now.
54:37 We need to say people's names right around here.
54:40 No, you're right. We did talk. Yeah, you're right. Um, the only question that I do actually have is more for staff and I think it's more just for my own edification.
54:47 Um, you found it for the code enforcement.
54:51 Is there a reason why it's not included in in this amendment or is it I just noticed that that's the only one that's
54:59 not affected, but I wasn't sure if there's a reason why. Do we send notification?
55:04 Yeah, I don't believe they don't they don't Oh, we don't send notifications for voted for some cases. Yeah.
55:09 Okay. They just give you Okay. They just go to your Yeah, that's just to the just the for the property.
55:13 Okay, gotcha. Okay. Okay. Okay, that makes more sense. Thank you for that.
55:17 Um, that's the only thing I had. Great job, guys. Good process.
55:21 All right. Um, I love everything about this. However, I do have a question about that extra 50 ft. Is that like a
55:28 best practice or is that an actual policy within your office? Kurt, could you just explain that extra 50 feet? that that's a best practice
55:37 that our department does just to make sure that we cover.
55:41 Well, my my only concern here is that we do the extra 50 feet because Kurt's a great guy and does the right thing and goes the little extra.
55:50 However, I would feel more comfortable if we had something that said 500 ft and
55:57 and and and so do you understand my my concern? I do.
56:04 Here's the issue. If we say 450, you have two parcels that meet at a corner here and that that radius is right here.
56:12 We're going to air on the side of caution and catch that extra 50 ft. So if we if you're 500, you're saying then you're 500. We're going to go to 550. Yeah.
56:23 We're always going to go bigger because we don't want to miss a property by inches. So we're going to air on the side of We've always done that. It's
56:30 always always worked for us. No one's come back to ever said, "Hey, I was not in this 150 ft."
56:38 We're just ering on errating on side of caution there. So, whatever the number is, we're always going to go bigger. Okay. Just to make sure we capture that.
56:47 And that's relying on the great people that we have working in your department today.
56:52 So far that I know it's been working for 24 years. Okay.
56:58 I I expect it to continue on, but uh yeah, I mean, okay. practice.
57:05 All right. That that was just my I mean it's it's a best practice. I I appreciate that you're that you're going to 500. I'm just looking 10 10 years 20
57:13 years down the line and oh well we you know well good luck if they get caught with a you know missing a piece of property by
57:20 a couple inches and it could throw the whole ordinance off whatever we're advertising. You could just throw it off and okay it could be repealed and we're not going to have that.
57:28 Okay. um that that was the the only concern, but it is a a huge uh improvement from from from what we had before. So, thank you for uh for for taking the time to do that.
57:39 Um any other questions from any commissioner.
57:44 All right. At this time, I will entertain a motion. I'd like to uh set a motion for ordinance 2026.
57:51 A motion of approval for ordinance 2026-026 surrounding property notifications 450 ft land development code amendment.
58:03 All right, we have a motion. Do we have a second? Second.
58:07 Motion and a second. All in favor? I I.
58:11 And the chair votes I. That's also unanimous. All right. Um, any other
58:18 business? Staff, do you have any any other business?
58:24 All right. Can I have a a motion to adjurnn? Motion and second. Second.
58:30 We are adjourned. Thank you.