Clermont Planning and Zoning Transcript 8/4/26
10:15 Good evening. I call to order the August 4th meeting of the Clermont Planning and Zoning Commission. Will the clerk please call the role?
10:25 Commissioner Tedona, present.
10:27 Commissioner May, here.
10:29 Commissioner Ansua here. Commissioner Neim present.
10:33 Commissioner Colby here.
10:34 And Commissioners Hoisington and Kramer will be out.
10:39 Please stand as you are able for the pledge of allegiance.
10:44 I pledge aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation
10:52 under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. You may be seated.
11:03 Thank you. I'd like to remind everyone um to have your [snorts] microphones turned on when you are speaking tonight.
11:08 If you are speaking from the lectturn, the microphone should already be on.
11:13 Please speak clearly so those in the audience can hear you as well as the people online. And as a reminder, this
11:20 is being recorded and broadcast on the city's YouTube channel which is city of Clermont.
11:28 Commissioners, you should have received the minutes from the July 7th planning and zoning meeting. If there are no
11:35 additions, corrections, I will entertain a motion and a second for approval.
11:43 I'll make a motion to approve the minutes. I'll second it.
11:46 Have a motion and a second. All in favor?
11:49 I I. And the chair votes I.
11:55 Before we move into unfinished and new businesses, I just wanted to uh remind commissioners to report any disclosures
12:02 uh regarding any of tonight's agenda items. Please report which agenda item.
12:07 If there's any subject material um that you have talked to somebody about um please disclose that any exparte
12:15 communication, written or verbal commission or investigation site visits or expert opinions received. Um so please be sure to do that.
12:25 Uh we'll now move into uh commissioner reports. I will start with commissioner Tadona.
12:31 Thank you, Mr. Chair. Can you pass that down?
12:38 Good evening, everyone. So, I wanted to start my report by uh paying a little homage to a General Gordon R. Sullivan.
12:46 He is a former US Army Chief of Staff from 1991 to 1995.
12:52 He was a staunch believer in deliberate, proactive and strategic planning. He also coined the phrase and wrote a
13:01 national bestseller uh by the title of hope is not a method.
13:06 So the first thing that I usually bring to a meeting is the Florida Highway
13:13 Safety Crash Dashboard. So in 2025 there were 5,484
13:20 crashes. I particularly highlight bicycle crashes and fatalities. In 2025
13:27 for Lake County, there were 97 bicycle crashes and six bicycle fatalities.
13:35 In 2026 so far, crashes are pretty much in half.
13:42 Bicycle crashes are almost onethird, but we've got four bicycle fatalities.
13:49 I'm not a master at statistics or numbers, but to me, we've got half the amount of crashes and almost the amount
13:57 same amount of bicycle deaths, which I I think may either represent that there are more too many cars on the road or
14:06 perhaps maybe our bicyclists might be getting a little careless. Uh my wife and I attend church in Mount Verie. Uh
14:15 we take 50 to 455. Go up past those two circles and then go through the circles to the left.
14:24 When you go up 455, there is the South Lake Trail and the only thing that identifies it as a bicycle crossing is a
14:33 yellow blinking light. So a bicyclist has to go across the trail, across the street, up a path, and then can follow
14:40 that path. They can choose to follow that path. I can't tell you how many times I enter both of those traffic circles with bicyclists on my right side
14:49 or on the way home. They're in the middle of the street cutting across traffic to get back onto
14:56 uh the South Lake Trail going to Lake Aapka. So, that's just me in a nutshell.
15:03 I'm not too sure who winds up getting to be or hope we could get to be more careful, either the bikers or the
15:10 drivers. In front of my fellow commissioners is an article from the Clermont Sun.
15:17 Nice little local paper. And the headline says Lake County projects $77 million revenue loss under the proposed
15:25 tax amendment where that tax amendment loosely speaking basically either reduces or eliminates our real estate taxes.
15:37 According to the Clermont statistical information, city of Glermont, cler.gov,
15:44 in 2000, the census said that there were 4,368 homes. In 2010,
15:52 that jumped up to 12,730 homes. It was estimated for 2017
15:59 to be 14,167 homes. And if you do a little math, which I was actually pretty good with in
16:06 grammar school, uh, we're at somewhere around 19,000 homes 2026. What's your point, John?
16:15 So my point is, and I've hammered this to death, um I think if some thinking was done
16:24 when Clermont and Lake County started to explode and they started looking into impact fees, mobility fees, different
16:32 kinds of shities against developers or working with developers to maybe say, "We're going to approve your property,
16:41 but you kind of got to upgrade a park." Um, there would be, humor me, tens of millions of dollars
16:49 sitting in an account, interestbearing accounts from the year 2000. That might have not have been the answer to this,
16:58 but certainly losing $77 million means our infrastructure is going to take a huge impact, which is money we already
17:07 don't have. And it just would have been nice instead of hoping for the best from 20 from the year 2000 that we would have
17:15 done something strategic and actually planned for this and made sure we had funds available. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
17:21 All right. Thank you, Commissioner May.
17:27 Thank you. Um, first of all, I want to to congratulate uh David Kobe u in regards to uh the hobnob that that was
17:35 very well put together. Um it was a lot of people. I had a chance to speak to a lot of the uh candidates and I think it
17:42 was a great opportunity for the city to be able to speak to the res to the uh different candidates. So um congratulations on a well well done
17:50 [clears throat] event this year. Um also uh wanted to say that I attended the the PNZ workshop that was done here. Um it
17:59 was among the commissioners as well as DPZ. They wanted to get our input on the downtown action plan. So, that was a a nice uh gathering. Um, and I also wanted
18:08 to uh just congratulate any of the new businesses that are coming to Clermont and thank you for uh choosing our city.
18:14 It's it's nice to see um some new some new restaurants and and retail coming into our city. So, I appreciate that.
18:22 And then I also coming back from a long vacation, well a long time away, uh came up to this beautiful mural that I don't
18:31 know if anybody have seen in downtown, but it's it's it's just incredible. It's created by Milin Creatives downtown Clermont. It's right outside um city
18:39 hall and you can see it. It's just a beautiful thing. So I just wanted to uh make sure that people stop by in downtown and take a look and take a
18:46 lecture. But other than that, that's my report. Thank you.
18:49 Thank you, Commissioner Ensu. Thank you, Chair. Uh, no report at this time. Commissioner Neck.
18:56 Yes. Uh, thank you, Chairman. Uh, most people in the audience know me. For those that don't, my name is
19:03 Commissioner Neck. I'm also an advocate for the safety and the roads of Clermont, you might say, but I'm al
19:12 focused on South Lake Cook Clermont. Uh it's been brought to my attention
19:19 about school is opening up. So please do drive careful. Number one. Number two, I
19:25 fought very hard to get on board with the county and the school level to get a crossing guard on Hartwood Marsh and Hancock.
19:36 And I don't know if anybody knows from South Clermont, Hancock's going to be opening soon. But that's not the problem
19:43 I have. The problem I have is Windy Hill, the school itself, uh they're letting out their students
19:52 very around 4:00. The crossing guard that I got uh that I received from the
19:59 county and the school board unfortunately is not there. So these poor youngsters, all right, have no
20:06 crossing guard. So for any parents that are listening to the video at home or anybody in the audience, if you want to help me, it's very simple. Just go to the county level, write a nice email.
20:18 Myself, I'll be at the county commission meeting next meeting they have and I'll be bringing this to their attention and
20:26 hopefully they'll expedite this before school opens. Uh [snorts] besides that, the hobnog was uh very impressive. There
20:34 was a lot of good candidates there. I had a lot of good discussion and it's election year people. So please, a lot
20:42 of men and women died for the right for you to vote. So please make sure you register to vote. This is your town.
20:49 Let's preserve it. Let's keep it clean on safe. Thank you.
20:52 Thank you, Commissioner Neim. And uh for my comments, I I want to thank my fellow commissioners uh for attending the event and the and the kind words. Uh but the Chamber of Commerce, the organization I
21:01 work for, we can only do that with partnership with the city. So, I want to thank the the city council and and and the city manager for for making space
21:08 available and and having a forum where people can come out and meet the candidates. So, thanks to all that supported that. All right, we will move
21:15 into new business. Um, we will hear from the city on on each agenda item. We'll then hear from the applicant. We will
21:23 open it up for public hearing and then there will be discussion and action by the commission. So, we will start with agenda item number one.
21:37 Good.
21:38 Good evening, planning and zoning commissioners and guests. Nick and Zos, development services. Uh, this is agenda item number one, elite veterary
21:45 specialist conditional use permit. The applicant, elite veterary specialist, is requesting a conditional use permit to allow a veterary clinic to operate
21:54 within the M1 Industrial Zoning District. The subject property is located at 235 Hatteris Avenue, Sweet
22:01 100 within an approximately 78 acre parcel. The subject property is located within established industrial office
22:09 area and is surrounded by a compatible uses typical of M1 zoning. Uh if we can just look here at the map, I uh outline
22:19 in this is uh in yellow the subject parcel off of Hatteris and Citrus Tower Boulevard. and a zoomed in portion off
22:28 Patteris Avenue. This is the existing building and that is the subject parcel.
22:35 Elite veterary specialist is proposing a specialty veterinary clinic that will provide advanced medical and surgical care beyond general veterinary services
22:44 with a spec specific focus on opthalmology. The clinic will operate entirely within the building and will be limited to small animals only consisting
22:53 of canine and feline species. No large animals such as horses, cows, swine, or other livestock will be permitted. The
23:00 clinic will offer ops and surgical procedures, but will not provide boarding of animals. The clinic's hours of operation will be 6 days a week,
23:09 Monday through Friday from 8:30 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. and Saturday from 8:30 a.m. to 200 p.m. Should the clinic wish to
23:18 provide a designated outdoor area for animal relief or exercise, the area must include a waist station managed by the clinic with animals monitored, leashed, and not left unattended.
23:29 Based on the clinic specialization, operating parameters, and proposed conditions, staff finds a veterary clinic to be appropriate for the
23:37 location and consistent with the intent of the district. When evaluating a request for conditional use permit, the land development code section 101-212
23:46 requires specific development standards that are required to be met. Staff has reviewed the application as submitted in accordance with the development
23:54 standards criteria and finds the proposed use can meet the general criteria for granting a conditional use permit. The proposed use will not be
24:03 detrimental to the health, safety, and welfare of the surrounding community.
24:07 Staff recommends approval of conditional use permit with the conditions contained in resolution number 2026-026R.
24:14 And that concludes SAS presentation. Thank you.
24:18 At this time, we would like to hear from the applicant.
24:31 Do I need to hit anything?
24:32 Okay. Good evening, commissioners and chair. I'm Angie Langley with Langley Consulting Group representing the applicant who is here, the owner of the
24:41 the business. and he did such a great job with the presentation that there's really not much for me to add, but we're happy to answer any questions that you may have.
24:50 Thank you very much. Uh, please stand by for questions. Perfect.
24:54 All right. At this time, I will open it up for public comment.
25:01 Last call for public comment until we bring it up to the commission.
25:06 All right, we will uh bring it to the commissioners and I will start to my far left and uh we will work our way down.
25:13 Starting with you, Commissioner Teddona.
25:15 Thank you, Mr. Chair. Uh just one question. Um it does say advanced medical and surgical beyond general
25:23 veterary services, but the vet wouldn't turn down an animal coming in and needing something. Correct. I am going
25:32 to ask Gerald to um who's the owner to answer that question. That has not come up in any of our conversations, but good question.
25:41 Just curious.
25:44 Hi, good evening. My name is Gerald Swinger Vargas and I own Ali Veterinary Specialist. We have multiple locations in South Dakota.
25:51 Um because we're advanced medic uh veterinary medicine, we specialize only in opthalmology. Okay. If there's any
25:58 emergency that arises, we normally refer back to an emergency hospital nearby. Okay. That we have convenience with them. Okay. Cuz we don't we don't do any of that.
26:06 But you already have that relationship set up. So if I come in with my dog who's not sleeping, well, you could refer me to someone. Correct.
26:15 Okay. Thank you. I have no further questions. All right. Thank you, Commissioner.
26:19 Commissioner May, good evening. I'm going to be asking you a question. [laughter] I'll stay right there.
26:25 So stay right there. Yeah. Um, so I understand that it is an advanced medical surgical care for opthalmology and it's by appointment only. Correct.
26:34 There is no walk-ins.
26:36 There will be walk-ins if there is availability. But most of our clients are referred by other veterinarians around the area. Okay.
26:42 I mean, usually people have issue with their pets. They go to their general doctor and then they'll refer them back to us.
26:49 And so, usually what they do is they drop off the pet and then wait. time they come in they either drop off the
26:57 bed for surgery I mean the pet for surgery or they um or they wave to be evaluated. Okay.
27:02 But most of the time they get an evaluation first and then we suggest surgery or not.
27:07 So you usually have about one or two patients a day.
27:11 Yeah. Well just during that specific time.
27:13 Uh we see about um maybe a two patients per hour. Two patients per hour. Okay.
27:19 And we have a board certified opmologist resident as well.
27:23 Perfect. So usually about 10 maybe 10 cases a day. A day.
27:27 A day. Okay. Um and just asking because of because of parking. So it seems like you have adequate parking there. Yes.
27:34 Um so in regards to recovery, will the um pets um the animals be able to
27:41 relieve themselves outside? I mean, how does that happen afterwards?
27:45 Um we don't say any overnight pets, so they usually go back to their um with their owners. um during the day if they need to go outside, we will have a
27:52 designated area fenced in to be able to take them out.
27:56 Okay, perfect. And have you identified an area at on at this location?
28:00 There is a door right behind the building that has actually grass area.
28:04 So right can you show us on the with your um just point over here. Okay. So sorry it's
28:11 confusing. This is the that's the front.
28:14 Which one is the front of the building here? This is the front of the building. So it's literally right here.
28:17 Right there. Okay. Okay. Perfect. Um, I think that's it for me in regards to
28:28 questions for you. So, um, you answered the questions that I had, so I appreciate it. Thank you very much. Okay, perfect. Thank you, Commissioner Ensua.
28:36 Thank you, Chair. Um, so this is essentially the same thing. I want to say it's very similar to what we approved I want to say two meetings
28:43 back, I believe. And I know that former building was a health and wellness center itself. So I don't have any I
28:51 don't have any questions. I think it's a good fit for for the area. So thank you. Commissioner Neck.
28:59 Yes. Hi. I have a question for the applicant. Uh you said you'll be walking the animals.
29:07 Where exactly will you be walking them through the parking lot? No, there is a grassy area right behind the building uh with a rear door. Exactly. Right there.
29:17 It looks like there's kennels there.
29:18 That's according to this. It looks like it's sectioned off. Is that one large area? What was the question again? I'm sir.
29:27 Okay. Do you have the conceptional plan that was submitted to us?
29:40 See on your top left of the building, you see those little lines going down one. [snorts] Mhm.
29:50 You see that? So, is that going to be one large area or is that going to be separated like kennels?
29:55 No, we don't we don't have any kennels at all. We I didn't ask that question, sir. I asked if there's going to be sections. That's what I asked.
30:03 No, it's just No. So, it's going to be one large area.
30:06 One large area and you're gonna be walking no those animals in just in that section number of staff. How many staff do we have? Yes.
30:13 Um probably it's going to be about five. You're only going to have one shift. One shift. Yes. No further questions.
30:21 Thank you, Commissioner. Um I did want to disclose I I did speak with Angie Langley. she did call me earlier today just to let me know that she would would
30:28 be here today. We spoke briefly about this. Um I really don't have any questions or or concerns. This does seem to be a perfect spot for for this to go
30:37 and giving what uh the nature of that that neighborhood and what's around there. So um I don't have any questions for you.
30:45 So I will bring it back to the commission. Um if there's any Mr. Chairman another another question, Commissioner May.
30:54 Yes. Thank you. Um just one question to the staff. So under just looking at the code because I have to understand the
31:01 code. Um under section 125337 which is under M1 um
31:08 M1 uh CUP. So it's not the allowed but it's on the CUP side. It says vet clinics or kennels provided that all
31:16 animal services and confinement areas including runs are in AC and sound attunity buildings. That's not part of the conditions. Is that something that
31:25 you guys are requiring under that section?
31:27 We put in in the in the conditional use permit in the resolution that there will be no boarding. So that's only for boarding. I just wanted
31:35 to get clarification. Thank you very much. Yep. That's all I needed.
31:38 Okay. Any other question? Commissioner Neck, did you have Yeah, I just I'm I'm sorry. I'm a stickler for that. What What are those lines
31:46 in your walking area on the exceptional plan? It's your building, isn't it?
31:55 They they don't own the building, so they'll be leasing a portion of that.
31:59 And this is an older survey, so uh as we go through site review, we'll we'll get more detailed of uh what's in the the
32:08 rear of the building of where they'll be putting that fence.
32:10 I understand it. So, how old is this conceptional plan up?
32:14 This is not a conceptual plan. This is a survey of an existing How how old is this survey?
32:20 It says 2009. It was signed 2009 and we're in 2026.
32:25 It's Avenue and known as West End Plaza is located at the southwest corner of Westminola and 8th Street
32:34 Avenue. The existing 7,400 ft square foot building would remain and be incorporated into the site design and
32:42 layout. The request is supported by a settlement agreement between the city and the property owner identified as contract 2025-00009A
32:52 which retroactively amends a comprehensive plan to allow for the bonus density up to 40 units per acre when a project qualifies under a
33:00 community benefit agreement. The settlement agreement also exempts the development from minimum parking requirements. The proposed 16 unit units
33:09 result in a residential density of 25.2 2 units per acre which exceeds the base density of 25 to 20 units per acre
33:17 threshold and therefore requires a humidity benefit agreement. The applicant has identified three public benefits as part of their density bonus
33:26 request. One, public access to the courtyard managed and controlled by the trust. Two, public art installations.
33:33 And three, a sidewalk connection to enhance the pedestrian access.
33:42 This is a elevation of the buildings uh two of the buildings that's off of 8th Street.
33:51 This is a view of the courtyard that is being proposed.
33:58 Here we can see this is the corner of south uh of Minola and ETH.
34:04 And then lastly, this would be the view off of Minnola Street.
34:10 The conceptual site plan also includes a covered gallery supported by structural beams extending up to 10 feet into the
34:17 public rideway along both the north and east side of the project. Due to this structural encroachment, the applicant is required to obtain a rideway
34:26 utilization permit for approval. staff finds the requested CUP is consistent with the intent of the central business district, supports mixeduse urban
34:34 infill, and aligns with the city's comprehensive plan by encouraging redevelopment and increased residential density in the downtown core. When
34:43 evaluating a request for a conditional use permit, the land development code section 101-212 requires specific development standards
34:50 that are required to be met. Staff has reviewed the application as submitted in accordance with the development standards criteria and finds a proposed
34:58 use can meet the general criteria for granting conditional use permit. The proposed use will not be detrimental to health, safety, and welfare of the
35:05 surrounding community. Staff recommends approval of conditional use permit resolution number 2026-025R.
35:12 That concludes SAS presentation.
35:14 Thank you. At this time, we would like to hear from the applicant.
35:27 Hello, I am Patrick Bianke. Um, I'll give you 821 Westminola Avenue. I am the applicant for this uh project. Mr.
35:36 Gonzalez did an excellent job presenting it. I will um defer to any questions.
35:41 I'll answer anything that you you might have. Um, I will say that yes, we are um looking to do the density bonus.
35:48 However, we are not looking to maximize that density. So, it actually allows up to 40 units per acre. We're only doing 25. Um, so it's not like we're going in
35:57 with the bare minimum or asking for the maximum. It's a happy medium in between.
36:02 We think it's going to increase the walkability and and vibrancy of our downtown. So, thank you.
36:07 All right. Thank you very much. All right. At this time, we will open it up for public comment.
36:16 Please come. we can line up at the microphone.
36:27 All right. Uh Anna Sinclair 575 West Miniola. Thank you very much. Hope you're having a lovely day. Um to begin with, I want to preface this by saying
36:35 that I support this development and nothing that I say is should be construed as me being in opposition. I just have some questions to the applicant and also we should have uh
36:44 take some things into consideration for these types of develop development to work well and the first one would be um
36:51 this will be constructed on the existing parking. It is a corner lot in a downtown area very close to the trail and the lakes. The type of resident that
37:00 this is going to attract, the type of tenant is going to be active people who are very comfortable walking, biking,
37:07 Ubering, um ordering their groceries from Instacart. So my first question to the applicant is is there dedicated bike parking for sorry it's kind of weird.
37:17 Yeah. What why don't you we will take all the comments and then then after suggestion bike parking to the after all comments are made then then we'll let Mr. Bianca
37:25 suggestion to the applicant that you can ask bike parking for residents. I lived in a building very much like this except it did have an elevator but it broke all the time and I'm telling you having to
37:34 haul your bike upstairs is kind of difficult. Um so that will be the first thing. Um also this is not under the purview of the planning and zoning
37:42 commission or the applicant themselves but I would say that we need to start managing our curb. You are very dedicated res uh residents here.
37:51 I'm I'm sorry. Say that word again.
37:52 Managing the curb. Sorry, the side I'm talking about loading zones for example because unfortunately downtown in the morning we get a lot of delivery trucks uh that
38:01 blocks traffic uh we need spaces for ride share for deliveries if we want to grow up these are things that we need to start managing and you can start
38:09 advocating for uh regarding parking specifically something that the city could consider would be charging for overnight parking because again there's
38:16 no parking here there's free parking on the street you kind of want to distance uh disincentivize that um we need
38:26 strategies for uh employee parking. We need sufficient disabled parking. Um if anybody wants to know more about parking strategies, actually I have this
38:34 wonderful book that I can lend you. I would be happy to to share. Uh going back to this specific development, um I would like to know if this is dark sky
38:42 compliant. I know we don't have a dark sky ordinance, but it would be wonderful if this were dark sky compliant. I would like to know if the landscape is going
38:49 to be done with flora natives. Um, also beautiful masonry building. I love it. I would love to see more vines. Moving on
38:58 to quality of life. What I saw on the application was that the front doors open into the apartment to maximize the space. It would be nice if they opened
39:07 out. Um, also for safety reasons. Um, in regards to living in apartments, one of the things that can make or break your
39:14 experience is insulation. So, if the applicant could go over that. And lastly, aesthetics. I'm a sucker for
39:22 this type of aesthetic. I'm not gonna lie. I would just like to see color on those buildings. Uh light colors and
39:29 whites are very common here. But again, this is very close to the artwalk. So, it would be nice if I had to see more color. And that's all the comments that I have. I'm sorry for things. Thank you.
39:38 All right. Thank you.
39:39 Ask a question or should I call um I can't right because we can we come back to our comments. Um go ahead, sir.
39:49 Yeah. My name is Jeff Davis. Uh, our family lives at 847 West Minnola Avenue and we have been dealing with a garbage
39:58 issue with an existing building that maybe this gentleman owns and nowhere on this plan talks about waste management.
40:07 We're really concerned with that. And it's not only this building, but I think the city and a whole has a problem with waste management. And I have sent
40:16 several pictures to the um to the council here and I don't know who shared these pictures with you. Now I've
40:24 showed these pictures and it for for several years it does not get cleaned up. There's rodents and if the garbage
40:32 continues like that and you're going to have extra residents there, we're going to have a big big problem.
40:37 Okay. Just to be clear, we are not the city council. We are a recommending board that that recommends things to the to the council. recommend that you know
40:44 they look at my emails and they take care of the trash. That's all. Thank you, sir.
40:51 Sir, sorry. One one one quick question. What address were you at? 847 West Miniola. Okay. Thank you.
40:59 47. And Mr. Nei, did you have a question for the the previous um speaker?
41:04 Yeah. Uh uh Miss Anna, I believe. Uh I'm just curious. You brought up colors. What colors would you suggest?
41:15 I mean, you know, saying I like different colors is nice to say, but what colors do you have in mind that would fit?
41:22 I don't have a specific color. I'm sorry, I interrupted.
41:26 What colors would you have in mind that would adhere to the downtown area?
41:33 I would ask the architect to come up with suggestions. Just saying that this is coastal uh southern coastal white color is very common there but you also
41:42 see some light colors. I would like to see more color simply because it gets really really bright here in the summer and a white building is difficult to look at.
41:52 Okay. Thank you. Thank you for your opinions.
41:54 Thank you. Do we have any more public comment?
41:57 All right. Mr. Bianke, would you like to uh respond to some of those comments? Yes, I would. Thank you.
42:05 All right. Um, with respect to the trash, the city has entered into an agreement with a few
42:13 property owners, myself included, which has a designated area in which trash will be collected in this
42:21 particular lot in case. It'll be right behind the building um the existing
42:28 building. if we could put the site plan up.
42:35 So, in this corner here, uh the city, if you notice, there's a bunch of uh fence currently there. They're going to be
42:42 constructing a communal trash site, which I believe they're going to go with dumpsters at first, but eventually it may be compaction.
42:50 Um so, that is where the entire half block and area will be able to utilize that um and will be built accordingly.
42:57 So that that takes care of the trash issue. Uh with respect to common waste.
43:03 Um as it relates to parking, as the staff report alluded, as part of the settlement agreement, this particular
43:11 project is exempt from parking, but it doesn't alleviate what what some have questions like like Miss Sinclair.
43:19 And I do believe uh that there has to be an effort and there there is an effort currently as to what kind of solutions we can solve with respect to parking.
43:29 Obviously everybody's knows about the garage, right? Um but there are other solutions like ride share that Miss Sinclair brought up. There are other
43:37 solutions like designated uh delivery areas like downtown Winter Garden has.
43:43 Um, there's other solutions like two-hour parking verse having parking passes. Um, and that's what I would consider for this particular location.
43:53 Keep in mind that these units are onebedroom. So, it is not designed to have
44:01 huge families and things like two, three bedrooms and stuff like that. They're they're one unit, one bedroom per unit.
44:09 Um, so you're going to see a lot of transient. You're going to see a lot of people who might work at a local business on the bottom floor or around
44:17 the downtown that just want a place to be able to walk and bike. Um, we do have
44:23 bike rack location which is going to be in this bottom area here. We're going to
44:30 put bike racks, but I also want to uh harp on the extension and the walkability factor. I actually brought um we could put this up.
44:41 Um yeah, so you can see where part of the community benefit and what was discussed is
44:50 leaving that 10-foot strip, which currently is a water utility easement on the south side of the project here. Um,
45:00 I could have paid about $100,000 to have it relocated, removed, and and actually occupied it a square footage. We opted
45:08 to not do that for number of reasons, but the most re the most pressing reason is the fact that we really have to harp on the walkability factor of downtown
45:17 and being able to get from 7th to 8th over to west easily, right? So, you have kind of this north,southeast, west access, which you know, everybody knows
45:25 the art district and the art walk um with the intent of going to the lake.
45:30 Well, this actually creates a unique opportunity to be able to connect from 7th all the way to not only my project, but further on down. So, we're reserving
45:39 that space south, the most southern parcel to be able to have that future connection point um which goes all the
45:47 way behind the post office to West Avenue. So that's part of that community benefit um that we're we're leaving. So
45:55 um with respect to how doors are swinging and things like that, I mean that's going to come down to architectural design, design pressure, Florida building code, all the things
46:04 that go with that. Um that'll be more in the architectural phase of the project.
46:09 So two of the other comments, um do you have have anything to say on the dark sky or the the Florida native landscape?
46:17 Yeah. So, I mean, some people would would crown me the king of Florida Native Landscape. I mean, as you know, I'm the president of Clermont Main Street. We did a hu huge Florida native
46:26 initiative in downtown. We're going to keep that going. I literally converted my entire house to Florida Native as well. So, I do have butterfly gardens
46:34 and will be constant of Florida native butterflies, things like that. Um, where families will be able to enjoy whether it's eating, shopping, or just hanging
46:42 out in what I would consider a micro park.
46:46 There's a method to your madness. Chairman, uh, yes. Uh, number one question. How does this benefit
46:55 downtown Clermont or the city of Clermont?
46:59 Oh, how long do you have? Um, so I mean, let's talk about the business side of it. I mean, from a we don't really know
47:07 it uh moving forward. So, that's the business side, the big initiative. Um, I think this kind of encapsulates what the
47:14 comprehensive plan is going to be in the future and kind of what all of our sharet discussions and everything that have been happening over the months and months and months. I think this this
47:23 encapsulate that as well as a formbbased perspective. Um, walkability, bikeability, that economics of trying to
47:30 get everybody to be able to connect to each other as opposed to just an isolated project on certain blocks, I think is also important. So, as you see
47:39 this project, you'll see that there's openings and what we call accesses on 8th Street on Minnola being able to
47:46 connect that that community benefit as I alluded to from the 7th, from the ETH to eventually West. I mean, there's so many reasons why this is a benefit.
47:57 Good answer. Uh, you made a comment before. I'm just a little brought brought actually made me write
48:06 write a question down to ask you. You made a comment uh on the previous on the property that's there right now. It was cheap, quick, and easy.
48:15 Okay. I fell in love with this project.
48:18 I really did. I like the aesthetic view of it. Uh I'm probably going to get in trouble for saying this, but I mean the
48:25 yumble lumber yard apartments, that's going to be an eyes saw downtown. All right. It's going to bring a city, a major city look into the downtown area.
48:37 When I opened my packet, when I received it, I couldn't believe it. I said, "Finally, somebody with common sense
48:45 that's going to actually create and build something that will benefit the aesthetic view of
48:54 Clermont." Now, somebody brought up the colors and all that.
48:59 That's a touchy situation because she might like black, I might like white.
49:05 Okay. So, that's basically you and the citizens of Clermont. You'll be working with them. That's the That's my question. Correct.
49:13 Yeah. Well, there's definitely nothing cheap, quick, or easy about this project. Any any urban new urbanism infill project is difficult. Obviously,
49:22 as you may know, I don't have anything to do with the lumber yard. I appreciate your sentiments about the project. Um, we do think it adds I I think we can
49:32 hold to I I think we can hold to our record that we've never done a bait and switch. Um, as you might know, Montro
49:39 Street Market, which is a food hall in town that we bought in 2018, is something that we came forward on.
49:44 Similarly, you know, you see the School of Rock project and so on. All things that we've done in downtown, we've never never took the easy road. Um, I think
49:54 quite honestly the opposite. I think this, if you look at the history of all the projects we've done, we love being the pioneer. Um, I think this does that
50:02 with the design standards. I think, you know, if we support the design standards like you see here, I think that we have to put our money where our mouth is and
50:11 and perform and do it. Um, so no, there's there's no quick, cheap, and easy out for us. This is what you will
50:19 see. Great, great answer. Uh, as the gentleman came up before, you know, I'm a stickler for waste.
50:28 All right. You're talking about 16 apartments, even though, let's say, man and wife, boyfriend, girlfriend, boyfriend, boyfriend, girlfriend,
50:36 girlfriend, whatever. And, uh, they're going to accumulate a lot of garbage.
50:43 All right. So, could you be more specific on, you know, I believe you said you're first going to start out with a dumpster
50:50 and then you're going to go Could you explain that more detail to myself, the board, and the public?
50:57 So, currently right now, um, the code is where there's, think of it like a residential roll can
51:05 if you will, and the city has a fee schedule associated with how many, let's say, one roll can leaf. one, it's not
51:13 aesthetically pleasing to have a ton of roll cans in downtown. Um, and two, that there need there needs to be some sort of communal and frequency of pickup,
51:22 more commercialized than really residential can. So, they do the compaction, it's even better, right?
51:28 Because it's compacting it down. So, they have went to other cities that do similar things and they felt that this was the best for it. But that is the
51:36 location right there. But that is the location right there near this project.
51:44 Great. Uh where the garbage the waste would be. What is to the west or what is directly on the side of them?
51:56 Are you saying like here in this area? Yep.
52:00 I believe it's the gentleman's home that came up here. There there's a house uh that is there. I believe they live in the back. I think there's a ADU on the
52:09 property. Um I don't think the front of the place is habitable. Um but the back certainly is. And so I think they're
52:16 just in the renovation process of of possibly making that their home.
52:21 Okay. Uh I think I'm pretty much wrapped up. I I do have to disclose I did talk to Mr. Bianke about this prior to this
52:31 meeting. All right. Uh I did have the opportunity to speak with planning and zoning on all the pro on all the projects. I'll have to sit at every
52:39 project comes up today. All right. I declined to uh meet with them. That was my choice. Uh I do just want to commend
52:48 you one more thing on who came up with the idea of balconies. I love it.
52:56 I mean think about it. I mean you go down to the lumber yard. It looks like New York City book skyscrap, you know, skyscrapers.
53:03 This is this is bringing the south back to Clammont. I love it.
53:10 Well, I I think that in any concept or design, even when we events that are going to happen and and so I think this
53:17 project would be it would be a detriment to this project if it didn't have it on all of the sides. Um facing courtyard,
53:25 facing looks really good at this point. Uh only two very quick questions. Um and one actually is more so for staff. Um just to remind me, City Hall is 53 feet high.
53:37 Correct. Yeah, it's right.
53:40 It's right. Yeah, right under 55. Y that's all I needed from you, Nick. Um back from Mr. Bianke, um remind me
53:47 because I'm trying to double check and look in through here. How high is this project going to Yeah, we are not above the threshold, which is 55 ft. We are under that.
53:55 Okay, great. Um, our largest portion of it is going to be um that point on the corner. Um, which I think is seated at 48 ft or something.
54:08 But we're under the 55 ft threshold.
54:10 Perfect. Perfect. Um, and then I guess just the only other thing I really have is, um, obviously your neighbor to the
54:17 west at 847 is somewhat concerned about trash and I know he's talked to, um, the
54:25 city manager a little bit, but just, you know, continue to be a good neighbor and if they have any issues, um, try to do what you can to make sure you can alleviate them. Absolutely.
54:34 Be great. Um and then finally, this is more so not necessarily due to this project, but more so I guess to the west of it as well. Um for the west end, is
54:44 there going to be any um future consideration on I don't want to say buffing it, but you know, I guess
54:51 essentially tying it into what you have here at West End Plaza, like the current existing building. Yeah.
54:57 Yeah. Do you have the interior looking from ACE?
55:01 I do. If you don't So you can kind of
55:13 Yes, we absolutely connected. If you go to the site now, you'll see that we had pulled a permit to uh put in the storefronts in their respective
55:21 locations. So this allows those tenants in the existing building to interact and be a part of that courtyard. Um so
55:29 that's what you'll see. And then that whole facade, which was once a mural, now it's primed and painted white, will be a mural again. Um, to what that mural
55:38 would be, we don't know. This is an interpretation of what it could be.
55:42 Perfect. Perfect. Okay. Yeah. No, this is great. I mean, from a even from a community benefit agreement uh
55:49 perspective, you know, the city always loves it when applicants can work together and and provide something in return other than just bringing more
55:58 development to the city. So, this is great. Um, planning looks amazing and zoning looks well thought out. So, great job.
56:07 Thank you. Thank you, Commissioner May.
56:12 Thank you. Um, I just wanted to let everybody know that I just had a brief conversation. Um, didn't have my packet, so really wasn't a lot of conversation
56:20 on this, but I did speak with with Patrick earlier last week. Um, so anyways, I do have a lot of questions.
56:28 Okay.
56:28 First of all, um, thank you for putting together such a great package for us to visualize what you're planning to do on this on this site. It's exciting.
56:40 Just wanted to say that. Um, but I do have some questions that um were brought up that added to some of the stuff that
56:49 I'm going to be asking you. So, first thing, is this a for sale or for rent product? your apartments, the 16.
56:57 It's all for rent. It is for rent. Yeah.
56:59 Okay. Perfection. And then, so you're the type of tenants that you're gonna be marketing to, I guess, is mostly people
57:07 that work in downtown, kind of have the lifestyle that uh Miss Sinclair was saying, kind of the outdoorsy
57:15 professionals. I guess that's what you're looking for.
57:17 We we believe that is the target for sure. Absolutely. Do you have any rents pricing now in regards to what you're looking at?
57:27 No, we don't right now because of cost of construction cost of construction obviously es and flows. Um, of course,
57:36 we are the engineering team assuming that this gets approved not only here but at council uh will kind of give me
57:43 the idea as to what materials we can use whether that be cold form steel, tilt wall, whatever it is. Um, and at that
57:51 time we would be able to assimilate how we can you know charge for rents. Um, we we don't have any idea we'll be
57:59 comparable to where everybody else is at.
58:02 Yeah. And I think adding the courtyard and the balconies will add on to that.
58:07 So those were, you know, great ideas in regards to the benefits.
58:10 Um, do you have I know this is separate to the existing building, but do you have
58:18 plans in the future to add on to your existing building that we're looking at here, the the one-story West End Plaza
58:25 that we know of? We we had thought uh before this was even realized we had thought about you know just using the
58:32 existing building going up with it and so on. The reason why you don't see it now is one because of the density bonus right so that that whole community
58:41 benefit thing there's calculations that go into that but also I think stacking all of that on one lot is not
58:48 necessarily conducive to the best project. And so as we're looking at it and we're, you know, we're kind of analyzing what the focus really is going
58:57 to be. The focus for this is if you're on Minola and ETH is going to be that corner building, right? So that's the
59:04 the trophy uh if you will of the project. And then similarly inside it's it's the courtyard. It's the the the
59:12 mural. So could we we couldn't now because we'd have to come back, you know, before commission to to get that
59:20 approved, but we just don't think it's probably the best use uh uh for this project and the output and the outcome that we want to see here.
59:30 So you're going to keep that as a kind of like a it's not really a food hall. I mean, you have it separated, but in regards to what you're planning on the
59:38 first floor, um, I understand that you're going to be doing retail and restaurants, but based on what we have here, first level building floor plans,
59:46 you know, in blue, commercial space, I don't know if you want to bring that up.
1:00:02 So in in blue I see you know there's everything separated by the square feet the 1398 1440. Are you looking at
1:00:10 splitting those into two sections? Is one going to be one restaurant? Is one going to be a retail? I mean is this
1:00:17 going to be all split up into various I guess it's going to be depending on what the tenant wants. Is that Yeah, I think everything's on the table to the extent that we could put a
1:00:26 firewall in between two uses. Yeah, we could do that. Um, I see where we could do that. I will tell you that as you
1:00:35 know, as a land owner in downtown already, I mean, we have a waiting list of people begging to get in. I mean, it's not just me, it's it's everywhere.
1:00:43 Um, downtown Clermont is is special and it's highly soughta. So, I ultimately don't know what the mixture of uses will
1:00:51 be for this site, but we could absolutely split it if if it needed. And what that really does is it also makes
1:00:58 it a little bit more affordable for the small business. You know, if they can sustain themselves in an 800 foot space, then we're going to do it. You know, I'm
1:01:07 not going to force them into a 1500 foot space and make them pay uh to be in a space that they really only need 800.
1:01:14 And I do that with every single one of our tenants as we analyze what they want to do and where they want to do it.
1:01:21 So on the ones that you may have restaurants because you did list restaurants as a possibility, will you have outdoor seating um on some of them?
1:01:30 Is that the reason why you're doing the galley? Well, the galley I think you're doing it because of the balconies, but is there going to be some outdoor seating as part of this project?
1:01:39 Yeah. So, I don't know if you can see it quite on there, but you'll notice that the buildings are offset. Um, well, I
1:01:47 I'll tell you that the buildings are offset 5T from the property line.
1:01:50 So, the reason why we did that is because we feel that there is value add to have outdoor seating. Um, I don't
1:01:59 know if you can zoom in. Is that is that legible there?
1:02:03 So, you can see where where it is. Uh Mhm.
1:02:07 it's set off 5T. And then also the downtown does have a code which is the like a cafe style permit where you're allowed to utilize the sidewalk um and
1:02:16 any portion thereof as long as you uh leave for wheelchair accessibility.
1:02:21 Believe it's 4T. Um so we we have that room if you will to play with. But yes, and really the arcade style buildings
1:02:30 which is the overhang that you see with the pillars. Um, I mean that's cover, that's shade, that's all the things. And then you have the courtyard, right? So
1:02:38 you have all the outdoor seating. Um, in the renderings you'll see they're next to the raised bed gardens.
1:02:44 And so the retail is going to also open up to the courtyard in the back. Absolutely.
1:02:48 Oh, it is. Okay, that's great. Um, I guess going back to I think what was
1:02:56 brought up, dedicated pipe parking. I know bike storage is a plus in that. I see that a lot in some of the buildings that my developers, you know, build. Um,
1:03:03 a lot of it is also in, you know, they like to have them interiors because of the weather. I know you stated that you might do, well, you will be doing bike
1:03:11 racks, but is there any possibility? I'm not I know it's not a condition, but you know, sometimes um having a bike
1:03:19 designated area that's kind of covered, you know, could be a suggestion. It's just because of the weather. I mean, you
1:03:26 saw how it rained and so I know you said that there might be some bike racks. I know you have bike racks now at Westland by the coffee shop, but I wasn't sure.
1:03:35 Yeah, they're like temporary. Yeah.
1:03:36 Yeah, we we definitely will have bike racks to the extent they're covered. I I think there needs to be a more global push in the entire downtown with having
1:03:44 it. I mean, we have the trail literally running through our downtown, so it it only makes sense, right? um you know
1:03:52 across the street right there's the bathrooms across the street that area should I mean be realized for that cover uh by covering
1:04:00 so it could be something more communal for the city I I think it should be a communitywide initiative to have that placed throughout the entire downtown
1:04:09 and then uh I think the other question that was brought up which I think you had answered was the loading zones in regards to
1:04:17 because I see a lot of it in winter gardens as well um the big trucks, especially if you're going to have a restaurant, you know, the big whatever those big truck, you know, the trucks.
1:04:26 Where do you think that is going to happen? Yeah.
1:04:30 I mean, we have I see that um you know, there's there's sideway parking, I guess, on ETH and then kind of diagonal
1:04:37 parking. Do you have a an idea of a designated area for you know, the truck loading, you know, for the food as well as, you know, loading zones for people?
1:04:46 I mean, you know, we have to consider the handicaps, you know, people. And um so I don't know if you have any ideas of that since that was brought up.
1:04:59 So So I know you had talked about a a communal area, but um yeah, I So what I'll say to to the
1:05:07 delivery aspect of it, like restaurants, it's currently a free-for-all in downtown. So they drive up 8th Street, they pull on to Montrose, they go on
1:05:15 Minnola. Minnola has the largest right of way in your downtown. In in my downtown, too. And so if you look at uh
1:05:25 north of the boundary of the property, you'll see that ginormous [snorts] apron that goes into the parking lot. So that
1:05:33 actually won't be needed. Um, so I I think in partnership with the city and really public works and kind of an overall comprehensive
1:05:42 plan for deliveries because I agree with you. There has to be designated deliveries.
1:05:48 You know, I I would personally, Patrick hat, not any other hat, think that big trucks and semi shouldn't park on Montro at all. I think we have to have back
1:05:57 alleys and utilizations and otherwise where if you see even in Winter Garden, they have designated parking spots where the semi will pull in and then they
1:06:05 just, you know, octopus out and bring the various deliveries to whatever they're delivering to.
1:06:11 So, I think there needs to be more of a comprehensive plan. I think this project kind of forces that issue a little bit.
1:06:17 Uh, I think we have the issue now with all the restaurants and businesses that we have, but I think this definitely brings it back in the forefront and a
1:06:25 underutilized ride ofway in this current section north of this parcel could be adding more parking, dropping loading
1:06:34 zones. I don't know what that looks like, but that'll be a conversation for public works and and that team.
1:06:40 Well, I see the city manager, so I'm happy he's here and he's listening, so these are good conversations, you know. Um I'm trying to think of anything else.
1:06:49 Um so are there's no elevators in this building. It's all walkups.
1:06:53 Correct. All walk-ups. So perfect. And then I understand that you are exempt uh based on the settlement agreement. I
1:07:00 wasn't sure and I I'll wait for [snorts] the attorney when he gets here. Um wasn't sure if that is since he's here.
1:07:09 Christian. Um I understand that there's a settlement agreement which basically exempts him from minimum parking requirements for the entire project. So
1:07:18 should that should that exemption or should that language also be included under section two as a condition
1:07:25 basically saying because it talks about the benefits that he's providing um in the agreement but it doesn't say anything about exemption. Should we add
1:07:34 that language as well in the resolution itself or does the I mean settlement agreement itself just takes care of it? It
1:07:42 it does. I mean there's it's it binds us. It binds them. Um I'm all for
1:07:48 memorializing things if if that's what y'all deem appropriate. I thought I guess it was talked about in the staff report.
1:07:57 Yeah, I thought it was in the warehouse.
1:07:59 Yeah, it was in the staff report, but it's not in the Oh, yeah. Yeah.
1:08:06 last sentence here where it says uh an overall development would be exempt from the minimum parking requirement. Got it. Yeah.
1:08:13 From the uh settlement agreement. And I think that is sufficient. Okay.
1:08:18 Yeah. And then the community benefits um that's already in I understand that you're going to be doing the the the the
1:08:24 courtyard open to the public. Um, but it's under the trust and it will be controlled by you all. Um, artwork,
1:08:34 where is that artwork? Is that going to be in the courtyard? Is that going to be all over? Is it going to be in certain sections of the buildings? I mean,
1:08:42 so it's definitely no secret that I I uh I love art. Um, you know, our if you look at the side of Yummies, there's a mural there. There was a mural on the
1:08:50 Weston Plaza building. But the the locations that art could be installed other than freestanding sculptures is
1:08:58 the facade here as well as so we actually own the building to the south.
1:09:04 So this as well that area which is currently the comic controller side. Um so those are two locations that could be
1:09:14 [clears throat]
1:09:14 um designated for art. There will be art in this project.
1:09:19 Right. It just you're going to include it. Just doesn't they don't mandate what you have to do. You're just going to do it. Yeah. So, perfect. And we don't have to put that in the resolution as well
1:09:28 because it's part of the community benefit agreement. It is. So, I see that community benefit agreement.
1:09:32 Perfect. I think and then you're not required to have a traffic study or school concurrency because of the agreement as well. Correct.
1:09:40 Um I I I believe that to be true. I will say that in 2024 the city did have a traffic study done. Um, I did bring it.
1:09:48 Um, it essentially it included this lot and it it kind of realized the surplus of parking in downtown as a whole and
1:09:57 what it would do if this parcel were developed. So, if you were to take that number that they dedicated in that study
1:10:05 minus the there's still a surplus. Um, they also did include the Friday night food truck. We don't have food trucks on Friday night. So that, you know,
1:10:13 obviously makes it better in any developer's favor in that regard. Um, so yeah, perfect. Okay. I think, um, you already
1:10:21 talked about Dark Sky. Um, Florida natives. I understand what you've done already through Main Street. Great job on that. U, so I can understand that
1:10:29 you'll probably be bringing in the Florida natives as well. Um, not sure about the open outdoors. That's I guess that's a a building code, which you
1:10:38 know, and I think Oh, um, There was a question on I have to remember I had it in my head.
1:10:50 We can come back to you if you want. And yes, please. Thank you very much.
1:10:54 All right. Thank you, Commissioner Teddona. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
1:10:59 Just a couple of things. Um so for for me, this this project is the
1:11:07 epitome of hope that I talked about earlier. Uh, in the first sentence it says uh 12 or more dwelling units, but
1:11:15 then in the second paragraph it says 16 residential dwelling units. So the Brooklyn in me says that if somebody
1:11:22 comes with the right amount of cash, it's a two-bedroom apartment, not a one-bedroom apartment.
1:11:28 We're hoping there's no guarantee that everybody who lives here is walkable or
1:11:35 is going to take a bicycle. Um, we're hoping that people from downtown live
1:11:43 here to work and walk in downtown that a guy from Brooklyn doesn't come down and live here and work in Orlando.
1:11:53 We're hoping that with the one bedroom, it's one person in that bed, not two people or three people that have two or three cars.
1:12:04 We're hoping that the residential and commercial garbage is going to be walked
1:12:12 maybe the equivalent of a half a block, 3/4 of a block around the corner and be placed there and not generate more garbage.
1:12:21 There's no traffic study.
1:12:24 So, and in spite of your settlement agreement, which I can't over overrule or anything, I just think that's this is amazing.
1:12:32 All you have to do is look at page 39, the picture at the bottom.
1:12:38 Okay? And this is without talking about loading and unloading when the restaurants show up or my mega store
1:12:45 shows up in there or I take over the whole first floor. But if you look at the bottom of page 39, we don't know
1:12:53 what day, what time of the day that picture was taken, but there's only five free parking
1:13:02 spots. And what we're going to do is we're going to do approximately two to four stores per building,
1:13:10 which is a total of 8 to 16 stores. 8 to 16 employees, maybe two shoppers per store,
1:13:20 which is going to give us about 32 cars that we're hoping don't show up to this building to come to work and to shop. in
1:13:30 addition to the 16 residential cars we're hoping don't come and live here.
1:13:38 So on any given day, if hope despares us, there's going to be 50 cars around that block.
1:13:48 So I really don't have a question. It's more like it would have made more sense to me if there was a parking garage on
1:13:56 the first floor with parking sec with your apartments on the second and third.
1:14:01 So that this way parking is contained, not contained on a street, not like growing up in Brooklyn where I got to
1:14:08 park five blocks away just to walk to my house. So I really don't have any questions for the developer, but this is
1:14:15 kind of the reason why I don't talk to developers. Thank you, Mr. chair. Okay.
1:14:21 Do you have any I do. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Absolutely. Um so this is the parking study. I will give this as part of the record. Um that
1:14:30 was done by the city on July 24th. Um it doesn't fit. I don't know. Maybe zoom out a little bit. Um what you will see right there. Perfect.
1:14:41 Absolutely. What you will see is uh mini old A Street is identified in there where if fully developed that it's a
1:14:48 change in supply of 18 cars. Um you know I don't make the IT manual. I I think it's somewhat silly. I think everybody
1:14:57 should read the book. Uh I was killed by a traffic engineer. Um and and so but
1:15:04 with respect to the supply and the overall supply of downtown and I will include that the additional
1:15:11 possibilities of the rightway usage on Minola as identified with where the current vehicular curb cut is. Um I
1:15:20 think this dramatically increases. Um now as far as a garage, a garage wouldn't fit on this property. This property is far too small. These
1:15:27 buildings may have the perception to be extremely large. Um, but 1,400 and change square feet for commercial on one
1:15:36 floor is actually quite small. Um, so to the extent that we have 16 uses on the
1:15:43 retail floor, I don't see it. I don't think it mathematically makes sense, nor does do I think that the usage makes sense. Now,
1:15:51 with respect to Mr. Chair, I'm not calling for a parking garage. Number one. Number two, on the design,
1:15:59 uh there are four doors per side per building. So four* 4 is 16.
1:16:05 Yeah. But you have to have two means of egress. Okay. So that's still eight.
1:16:09 Correct. So it could be eight is is the highest use really of the the first floor. But you have to have two means of egress. Um now with respect to the
1:16:18 upstairs, I did bring I don't know if you had in your packet, but uh I did bring kind of what that layout looks like. if you want to zoom out a little bit.
1:16:29 So, as you see, I mean, the unit size is small.
1:16:34 I don't see any way, you know, drawing a twobedroom or a threebedroom unit unless
1:16:44 it took the entire floor. So either way, it's still meeting that single bedroom
1:16:53 threshold. Now, if there's three people that sleep in the bed, I mean, you know, have fun.
1:16:59 Then shouldn't that number say 12 16 and not 12 or more dwelling units?
1:17:03 Well, it's per floor. So, two units per floor. So, one building will have four units times 4 16.
1:17:13 Then why does it say 12 or more dwelling units? Why doesn't it say 16 units?
1:17:18 So the 12 or more dwelling units per acre is actually the density calculation that the city uses in their code. So if you take the 68, if you will, and then
1:17:27 you amplify over the 12 units, that's where you would get, oh, I can only build seven. That's where the community benefit agreement comes in that actually
1:17:34 allows anybody in the central business district up to 40 units per acre. So the
1:17:41 density that we're asking for now is 25.2. So, it's just over half the allowable on the density bonus.
1:17:54 Okay. Uh, any you good? All right. Um, any other um questions? I'll let you go.
1:18:00 Yeah. I don't want Well, go ahead. I I I just have I My questions have been have been answered. I just my two observations are
1:18:09 are are one um you know, this is this is a beautiful project. I just think this is um amazing and I was able to visit some other communities with city staff
1:18:17 last December and and and and look at areas that people want to be in and and and just what it does for the community.
1:18:23 So I I I applaud you for this and and also you know your your quality projects that that that you have done. Um I'm I'm
1:18:31 not worried about you running out of money. I I think you you you folks have done a done a really great job and you've only only done quality. My only recommendation I I don't know that you
1:18:40 guys have ever done anything quick and easy. I would I would uh maybe maybe say that what you had done was temporary, but but I don't think you guys have ever really done anything quick and easy. You
1:18:48 you you did it um really on a temporary basis, but but congrats on on it. Great.
1:18:52 And I will disclose that we've never talked about this ever. So um um I see you everywhere, but we've never talked about this surprisingly. Yeah. Thank you.
1:19:00 You're right. You have something else? Yes, I do, Commissioner.
1:19:07 All right. I'm uh I'm sorry. I'm I'm back on this uh sanitation with the waste. Okay.
1:19:14 Okay. On the west side of the building, if you could put that diagram back up there, the
1:19:22 staff, please. Here you go. If you could zoom in just on the left side of the building, please.
1:19:27 I'm going to use the bigger one that's Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Byak. All right. Now, here you go. That a boy. That a boy.
1:19:39 We're looking at 15 feet is your your Tilly. I mean, your Eastman, right?
1:19:50 Yeah. Then, thank you. I thought it was me.
1:19:52 Well, yeah, that that's just the the circle section that you see the lines.
1:19:56 There's there's Okay. And where I'm sorry, you didn't finish. You're limited access. That is
1:20:04 where the dumpsters or the garbage are going. Correct.
1:20:08 Are we planning to build a wall there or is that going to interfere with
1:20:16 the garbage pickup to satisfy the surrounding neighbors?
1:20:21 So, I'm not trying to make you spend money, sir. I'm finished.
1:20:24 No, no, no. So, so I actually donated the land for free to the city. Um, that section. And what they're doing is
1:20:32 they're reconfiguring that section so that you're pulling on Miniola and and my understanding and that would be more
1:20:41 of a city question is that it will be entirely enclosed, right? Like a dumpster enclosure um because there's certain fire ratings with combustible
1:20:50 materials and things especially so close to either property, right? Um so yeah, I think that answers your question.
1:20:57 They're reconfiguring that area for dumpster usage.
1:21:01 Okay, that perfectly answered my question.
1:21:03 And it will be the exclusive use for dumpsters, right? Okay. Uh, real quick. So, for the record, all these tenants
1:21:13 will be taking their garbage and waste, walking out of their building, three stories down, walking across the shaded,
1:21:22 not across, going around the shaded area because that building is still going to be existing and they're going to be responsible for throwing out their own garbage.
1:21:30 Absolutely. It's no different than like a rural house where you, you know, have to haul your trash can all the way over to the end of your 1500 linear foot
1:21:39 road. Um, it's very substantially similar in that, you know, I do believe that the city is going to provide black
1:21:47 uh like dumpster wheel things where you can throw in your trash and wheel it.
1:21:51 That's my understanding that they'll disseminate that to all of the businesses. Yeah, exactly. Um, you know, but yes, it will be that that simple.
1:22:02 Okay. No further questions.
1:22:03 All right. Commissioner May, did you formulate another question?
1:22:06 No, actually, he brought up the question that I was going to bring up, which was the tenants and the retail and the restaurants. They're going to be throwing their trash basically to that
1:22:15 dumpster. So, you're So, who is going to be managing the apartments? Is it property? You're you're going to be a property manager. Are you going to have a third party property management company taking care of the apartments?
1:22:25 Yeah, we will fully manage all of our assets. You know, I'm a licensed real estate broker. I have all the softwares that that that help that. We have 112
1:22:33 tenants now. Um, so yes, we we are going to manage that ourselves. The city code also overlays what that looks like too.
1:22:42 Um, you know, to the extent that they throw trash out their balcony and say somebody else's problem, we can't do that, right? I mean, I'm being
1:22:49 facitious, but it's really that simple where these restaurants at the end of the day, they're going to go and they're going to put their their their waste there in that area. That'll be a designated area by the city for trash.
1:23:01 Got it. Enclosed with the wall so that this poor gentleman doesn't have to deal with that. So, you know, I've seen
1:23:08 cases, you know, dealing with my apartment developers where they have those containers with the wheels. So, I was
1:23:16 just wondering because sometimes property management will take care of it.
1:23:19 Um, you know, they leave their Yeah.
1:23:22 You know, they leave their trash outside in the basket and then the property management comes in, but those are larger. So, I was just unsure. So, it's
1:23:29 I would like to see hopefully that come about to make that I can't see that.
1:23:34 But, um, but other than that, um, I I like your project. So, beautiful. Thank you.
1:23:40 All right. Thank you. Any more questions from the commission? All right. I will entertain a motion at this point.
1:23:45 I'll set a motion for approval for resolution 20226-2025R
1:23:52 West End Plaza Conditional Use Permit. All right. Do we have a second? I'll second.
1:23:59 We have a motion and a second. All in favor?
1:24:03 I I I nay. Chair votes I. That passes four to one.
1:24:12 Yeah, good job.
1:24:14 All right, we will move on to um item three and four will be presented together.
1:24:21 Oh, good. Love that.
1:24:28 Good evening, planning and zoning commissioners and guests. John Cruz, Development Services. This is agenda item three and four, which is the Louisa
1:24:36 Grand Smallscale comp plan amendment and resoning.
1:24:41 Uh on the display outlined in yellow is the property that we will be focusing on. And again this is a zoom in uh 27
1:24:50 and this is the entrance into the subdivision.
1:24:54 The city as the applicant is requesting a smallcale comprehensive plan amendment or resoning of the subject property as a followup to the staff initiated
1:25:02 annexation request. The parcel has been platted, developed and is receiving wastewater services from the city.
1:25:09 Central Water is provided by Sunshine Water Services. The property, approximately 30 acres, consists of the Louisa Grand subdivision with a total
1:25:18 lot count of 75 single family homes. The subdivision has been built out and is completed. On October 28th, 2025, the
1:25:27 city council approved the annexation of the subject property with the understanding that a small-scale comprehensive plan amendment and reszoning at a future date and time
1:25:35 would occur to designate the property with the applicable future land use and zoning designations. Staff is proceeding to complete the process at this time.
1:25:46 So, the first thing we'll discuss is the future land use.
1:25:53 Um the subject property is currently designated with Lake County urban low density future land use category. The current density under the Lake County
1:26:02 designation allowed four dwelling units to one net acre with the final plat approved at 2.45 dwelling units per
1:26:09 acre. The compatible future lane use designated on the city at the existing density would be the low density residential which allows for three
1:26:17 dwelling units per one acre. And again on the top uh this is currently uh in Lake County urban low and then it will go low density residential in the city.
1:26:29 The majority of the surrounding properties have been developed and consist of single family residential developments on the west and south sides of the subject parcel while the north
1:26:38 side contains a mobile home park with similar residential uses and the east side is currently undeveloped. The change in the future land use to the
1:26:46 city's lowdensity residential does not propose a conflict between existing uses and land uses within the area. The proposed future land use is consistent
1:26:54 with the city's comprehensive plan and its goals, objectives, and policies.
1:26:59 Staff recommends approval of ordinance 2026-9. Now, we'll focus on the resoning.
1:27:10 Again, uh this is the parcel.
1:27:13 The property is currently designated with Lake County as a plan unit development district and is governed under ordinance 2015-3.
1:27:22 In order to encapsulate the current entitlement, city staff is proposing to reszone the property to plan unit development. And again, this is the
1:27:30 parcel with the city zoning proposed zoning and plan unit development. The transfer of the Lake County PED ordinance into the city's peed ordinance
1:27:37 is like for like with small adjustments made for code references. The change in the zoning district to the city's plan unit development district does not
1:27:45 propose a conflict between existing uses and land uses within the area. The proposed zoning district is compatible with adjoining properties required by
1:27:54 the city's comprehensive plan. Staff recommends approval of the resoning ordinance 2026-20. That concludes staff's presentation.
1:28:02 All right. Thank you very much and we will open it up for public hearing at this point. Would anyone like to speak on this subject?
1:28:12 All right. Anyone? All right. Hearing none, I will bring it uh up to the commission um for comment. We will start with you, Commissioner Ensua.
1:28:22 Thank you, Chair. I don't have any I don't have any burning questions on this uh on this project.
1:28:29 Okay. Thank you. Do you have any questions? comment. I'm going to you, sir. You are confusing me. You realize that.
1:28:37 Trying to trying to keep you in your toes, Vinnie. Yeah, you ain't kidding. I apologize out there to the audience.
1:28:44 Uh, no, I don't have any questions at this time. Chairman didn't want Mr. Ensuing never to be first.
1:28:54 Commissioner May.
1:28:58 Nope. uh Lake County low density four units to 1 acre which is what it is now.
1:29:02 Final plat was 2.4 units. Is that what you were saying John? That that is correct.
1:29:08 Okay. And then so we're going to the city of Clermont for three units to the acre. So that would be if that was a
1:29:16 vacant site it would be 3 * 30 which would be 90. But you're saying that they're they're completely developed out right? So they're de they're they're developed.
1:29:24 It's platted. There's homes out there.
1:29:26 But uh address your question earlier, it would be a lowering of approximately 30 dwelling units overall if it was still Yeah.
1:29:35 in the county to the city.
1:29:37 So yeah, I was just wondering because I still see some vacant land there. So I was just wondering what that was.
1:29:43 The vacant land is storm water retention bonds. Perfect.
1:29:46 So they they won't be developed anytime that we're aware of.
1:29:51 Yeah. I have no issues. I guess the homeowners are happy to be part of the city. So I'm assuming so that's it for me. Commissioner Teddona.
1:29:59 No questions, Mr. Chair. All right. I will entertain a motion.
1:30:06 Mhm.
1:30:08 I'll set a motion for approval on ordinance 2026-2 uh 020 for approval.
1:30:21 Oh, it's 19. 19.
1:30:22 Oh, 19. Yeah, we're going to do them do them separately. So, Dash, I'm I'm totally sorry. Why don't we try that again?
1:30:29 Oh, you got good jokes today.
1:30:33 I'd like to set uh a motion for approval on ordinance 2026-
1:30:40 20 uh 029. Am I Am I Am I Am I Yeah.
1:30:54 Sorry, I got confused. It's not easy doing that. Ordinance for approval 2026-019.
1:31:03 Okay, we have a motion. Do we have a second? Second. All in favor?
1:31:07 I I chair votes eye. That's unanimous. Do we have a motion for the next item?
1:31:17 I will Oh, wait. Does his motion still carry?
1:31:21 Yes, we that was that was unanimous on on on the on the first item for uh item three passed unanimously. I'm looking for a motion for item number four.
1:31:31 Okay, gotcha. Sorry. Sorry. I was just double checking. Um I'll [laughter] I'll have I have a motion for I will make a motion to approve ordinance 2026-020.
1:31:42 I'll second it.
1:31:43 Have a motion and a second. All in favor? I chair votes I. That is also unanimous.
1:31:48 I was just All right. Item number five.
1:31:56 Good evening again, John Cruz Development Services. This is agenda item five, administrative adjustments
1:32:03 land development code amendment at the direction of the city manager's office.
1:32:08 Staff is proposing an amendment to the land development code in order establish procedures for administrative adjustments within the city limits.
1:32:16 Section 101-104 of the land development code currently governs the granting of variances and includes provisions for administrative
1:32:25 variances. However, these only apply to minor deviations associated with already approved developments. The code also
1:32:34 provides limited minor variances in specific situations such as landscaping adjustments or accommodations for historic structures. Despite these
1:32:44 existing tools, the code does not offer a broader mechanism for minor dimensional or development standard modifications that do not warrant a full
1:32:53 variance review. The proposed amendment repeals and amends section 101-104
1:32:59 PNB to establish a new administrative adjustment process authorizing staff particularly development services
1:33:07 director to review and approve minor deviations from certain development standards through a clear consistent and streamline streamline procedure. By
1:33:16 establishing administrative adjustments, applicants will have a more efficient path for resolving small sight specific issues without requiring a full public
1:33:25 hearing before the city council. This improves customer service while ensuring all modifications remain consistent with the intent of the land development code.
1:33:35 This type of procedure is used in other municipalities such as Semino County, city of Mland, and Miami Day County and is occurring in many more jurisdictions.
1:33:45 The ordinance establishes criteria, submittal requirements, and parameters for allowable administrative
1:33:52 adjustments, ensuring that the flexibility provided remains predictable, fair, and consistent.
1:33:58 Adjustments would be limited in scale and may only be approved where they do not create adverse impacts, do not
1:34:06 substantially alter the character of development, and are in harmony with the intent of city regulations. Six review
1:34:13 standards are incorporated into the process in which all six must be satisfied with substantial evidence.
1:34:19 Failure to meet any of one of these standards will result in a decision of denial.
1:34:25 And for some examples is uh to illustrate how the proposed administrative adjustment framework
1:34:32 would operate. Uh for example, a rear yard setback. The standard's 25 feet.
1:34:38 And in the table here on the display is is some of the the potential uh administrative uh adjustments would work
1:34:47 and the MAC and and the maximum um sorry about that. And the maximum so for a
1:34:53 rear yard setback uh if it's 25 ft a 25% administrative adjustment could reduce the rear required rear yard setback by
1:35:02 6.25 ft. So therefore it would be a rear yard setback at 18.75.
1:35:09 Uh, another one would be the sideyard setback, say 7 and 1/2 ft. A 25% administrative adjustment could reduce
1:35:17 the required side yard setback by 1.875 ft. So, the adjusted side uh yard set
1:35:24 back will be 5.625 ft. And finally, the the final example is the maximum retaining wall height,
1:35:32 which is standard 6 feet. A 35% administrative adjustment could increase allowable height by 2.1 feet. So the
1:35:40 adjusted retaining wall height is 8.1 ft. These examples demonstrate practical flexibility for applicants while
1:35:48 maintaining reasonable limits and ensuring that modifications remain consistent with the development patterns and safety standards of the city. The
1:35:57 proposed amendment is consistent with the Senate's ongoing effort to strengthen and modernize the land development code by providing a clear
1:36:04 and efficient method for addressing minor dimensional challenges without requiring formal variance proceedings.
1:36:11 This administrative adjustment process enhances flexibility for applicants while preserving staff oversight and maintaining adherence to established
1:36:20 planning principles. Staff recommends approval of Ordinance 2026-029. That concludes staff's presentation.
1:36:28 All right. Thank you very much. I'll open up for public comment. Seeing no more public in the room, uh we will close public comment and we will bring
1:36:35 it back to the commission and we will go in a straight line this time. We will start with Commissioner Tona and work our way back. Stop with me.
1:36:43 She doesn't like to be first. Okay.
1:36:45 We're going to start with uh we're going to start I don't want to confuse anybody, Vinnie. We're just going to go in in a straight line. Commissioner Teddona. No questions, sir.
1:36:53 All right. Commissioner May, I have questions.
1:36:59 [laughter]
1:37:01 John, the uh define what's a a small site. So, a small site would be anything like a single family, a duplex. Uh who
1:37:11 who who is this is this would be generally reserved for like single family lots. Um, it's
1:37:19 not for a housing developer to come in with 150 lots and say, "Hey, I want all my rear yard setbacks reduced." No, this
1:37:26 is more on a sight by sight, case byase basis. Okay.
1:37:33 Thank you. And then who is the development service director? Is that you, Kurt? That that would be uh Mr. Kurt Kurt Henchel.
1:37:41 Wow. So, you have another title, Kurt.
1:37:44 [laughter]
1:37:45 So, I was just wanted to find out who that person was. Is that five titles now, Kurt?
1:37:49 [laughter]
1:37:51 Uh, private road gated entry. I just had a question. What What is requesting me?
1:37:55 Okay. Our current code now requires an applicant to come before city council to request private road gated entry.
1:38:04 However, from historically from a staff's position is if they want a gate or private road and take care of all the
1:38:12 maintenance, we're definitely supportive of that. City Council's been supportive of that. So really, this is just more of them asking for it. We document it and
1:38:21 if it meets the city's requirements right away with and so on and so forth, then that would be something that development services director could approved.
1:38:30 Perfect. And then I've been through an administrative uh adjustment um back in the day uh when I had to do something
1:38:37 with my house at a city. the requirement at that city on in regards to adjoining neighbors
1:38:45 um was defined a little bit better than what it is here. So I know we're saying adjoining neighbors and we always want
1:38:53 to make sure that the neighbors you know um but I think that um we should define the neighbors you know as the contiguous
1:39:01 property owners usually that's what the cities do. I don't know if you want to add that, but contiguous property owners as well as neighbors across the street
1:39:08 because I think a lot of people would um you know be affected by that. Um because this one just says adjoining neighbors.
1:39:16 So I know that there's somebody that could be like 50 feet away or 70t I don't know but just a little
1:39:24 bit better definition on that. Um, but other than that, um, and I believe you have to have unanimous
1:39:32 consent as well on the neighbors. So, I'm not I don't see anything here that says you have to have unanimous consent or support. Is that something that you
1:39:40 guys are not looking at versus the other cities? Because I know Miami date county does and I know Maitland does.
1:39:46 Well, that's something that um we would want the letter of support from the adjoining neighbors. Um, and if you have
1:39:53 a neighbor, particularly in the previous application, we talked about the trash. Yeah.
1:39:58 If he says no and everybody else says yes, then you're trying to split the difference on that. So, we would we
1:40:06 would have to just review it on a case by case basis. Okay. I think that's fair. Good answer.
1:40:11 Yeah, I think that's fair. And other than that, I have no other questions. So, thank you.
1:40:16 You're welcome, Commissioner. I just want to say thank you guys for uh whipping this up and making the change. I think it's uh it's
1:40:24 been needed for a bit. So commissioner, thank you, Mr. Chairman.
1:40:33 Uh I do regret not meeting with you yesterday, John, because when I looked to solve her, I said, "Oh." And uh by
1:40:41 the time I found out, you already went home. So I'm going to ask a tedious question.
1:40:48 So these are for the new projects being built. So everybody else would be grandfathered in to the old rules.
1:40:58 For the record, for the record, no. Um if it's stuff already built and if they wanted to um Oh, okay.
1:41:07 do something in the rear like a rear shed. Okay.
1:41:11 Um that that potentially would be placement because an existing tree. then they could go through the administrative
1:41:18 adjustment. So it it it's for every property owner that has the ability to come through the process, right? Because I've been at several
1:41:27 council meetings where we granted uh the setbacks to be less than what
1:41:35 they are even according to this and I sitting in that audience I couldn't believe the approvals that they were
1:41:42 getting. So they would be grandfathered in because they're not doing nothing to modify their approval.
1:41:51 So I'm just trying to understand you. I'm sorry.
1:41:54 Um if if they already received the variance. Yes, it's that's already been done.
1:42:00 Okay, that's his fault. He's confusing me, too.
1:42:03 All right. Uh well, you confused me. You just used the double negative, though, and I'm really confused now. It's okay. Not doing nothing is doing something.
1:42:10 Plus, how's that sound? All right, David. Uh, I'm just a little curious about this retaining wall height. I'm sorry, John.
1:42:19 This is This is my sticula. Could you explain to me perfect example 67 feet of
1:42:26 a retaining wall? That's a little bit I would say 10t higher than this building or 9 ft higher than this building.
1:42:36 So to explain these numbers here, it seems like the requests for retaining
1:42:42 wall height are two common heights over the 6 foot. One is the 8 foot. So if you
1:42:50 look at the 35% that gets you to the 8 foot and then the other one is the 10 foot which is the 67%.
1:43:00 However, if you notice, in order to get the 67% to request that, it has to be inward facing, which means the walls facing inside the project.
1:43:11 Um, and the it it topography changes.
1:43:16 We came up with a 50 foot of fall within the site. So, it's that that's the parameter that would have to be looked
1:43:24 at in order to for that percentage to be granted.
1:43:30 It was a typo on on our end.
1:43:35 No, it just didn't say percentage. I thought it said foot. Okay.
1:43:40 Okay. You understand? On the other page on on the table, it says 35 says 67
1:43:48 cuz all I had was deja vu of hooks. The apartments on Hooks and that's when I said 67 feet.
1:43:57 But that's a percentage. have it on the bottom. We can we can add the percent in there.
1:44:02 Yeah, please. So we don't confuse the city council any more than they are.
1:44:08 Yeah, I'm sorry, council. Did I amuse you over there? I'm not on the city council.
1:44:15 Okay. Oh, you're never confused.
1:44:19 To the contrary. [snorts] All right, Commissioner, are you you done?
1:44:26 Oh, you're back to me. Yes.
1:44:28 Yes. You're you I just want to make sure you were finished. All right. And I have no questions. Next.
1:44:35 So, I will entertain a motion. No, John.
1:44:42 I will I will submit a motion to approve ordinance 2026-029. Do we have a second?
1:44:50 I'll second. All in favor?
1:44:52 I I I I chair votes I. It is unanimous. All right. Having no more business, we have a motion to adjourn.