Parking garage meeting transcript 8/13/26
10:46 welcome everybody to the garage. special technical advice.
10:54 We appreciate your involvement being city manager here. I just wanted to thank you all for volunteering your time
11:02 and helping out this very important decision that you guys make and we appreciate your
11:09 time and effort you're going to be doing to help us out.
11:15 With that, I'm going to turn it back over to All right. Then I'm gonna immediately turn it over to Zayn. If you all don't know about Zayn Ortel, he's Hello.
11:23 right up there. And he gets the honor get started with a lot of stuff is to talk about the sunshine because not
11:32 everybody's familiar with how we work and how that impacts y'all and how you communicate um once we get outside of of official meeting like this.
11:41 Yes. So, uh, you all should have a document in front of you that has a, uh, information on sunshine laws and public
11:49 records laws. This is super important, uh, just because any correspondence you all have with each other cannot be about
11:56 this parking garage, everything in the state of Florida is under sunshine. So, everything is exposed. Every conversation that is had um, is subject
12:06 to scrutiny because Florida has some of the most vast sunshine laws in the country. Um, additionally, anything you put in writing uh via text, email, etc.
12:17 in relation to this parking garage um is subject to public record. So, I always caution if you don't want it to be seen,
12:25 don't send it. Um, if there's any more questions, uh, we can go over that. You all have a simple overview of what it
12:35 is. Uh, I imagine most of these things won't be too pertinent, but we don't want anyone getting in trouble. There are, uh, monetary fines and potential civil fines for breaking sunshine laws.
12:45 So, protect yourselves, protect the city, and we appreciate y'all for, uh, for doing this. All right.
12:54 This is like you're going to be going out today looking at the various sites.
12:58 It's very important that you don't talk to each other about these sites while you're out there. So, just listen to assuming we're going to be out there.
13:06 We're going to try we're going to try to get out there, but you know, weather peritting and other things. We'll see how the meeting goes.
13:14 Okay, perfect.
13:15 That if we're all together, we can ask staff a question and I'll hear the answer.
13:19 Correct. You just can't talk to each other.
13:22 And that's that's actually a great question. But we don't have any.
13:36 I'm sure somebody can follow us with a with a phone. We we discussed that option.
13:43 Our capabilities are not there. And and to piggyback off of what Dan said, um you also cannot use a third party to
13:50 circumvent uh sunshine laws. So, if you want to deliver information, let's say Jordan wants to deliver information to Anna about the uh
14:00 design of the parking garage and you use a staff member to relay that information, you can't do that. So, be very diligent about that. Um, and just
14:09 be cautious when you're having communications.
14:12 Yeah. What about so if if if we're looking for an answer
14:19 and we maybe there's a subject matter expert. So like if we ask a question do we report it here or we just don't ask the question?
14:28 You can ask questions to people just no no one else on this board.
14:31 Okay. So um is there like is the expectation we would bring that information and report who we spoke to?
14:39 Yes.
14:41 Uh, and we have staff that can answer a lot of questions. Um, so anything you all need, everyone on staff is accessible, so reach out to them.
14:51 No, that was kind of my question, but also I guess if we have a question individually, we can email you. Yes.
14:58 Whoever answers it copy the whole Okay. Perfect. Thank you. But you're free to talk to others.
15:05 Not, you know, it's not like you're on a count of silence when you leave the committee and you can't somebody who you respect, you know,
15:14 is it appropriate to communicate with a council member?
15:19 You are allowed to talk to the council member, but they will disclose that some you're ultimately making a recommendation.
15:29 How about the CRA? Would the same thing apply because the CRA like obviously some council members are there, but
15:36 there are other two members. This might go before We should not discuss the CRA is not making a decision
15:45 council. So CR speaking of the CRA.
15:54 Okay. Any other questions about law?
15:58 Okay. At this point, um I'm gonna give an overview, but the first thing I'd like to be able to do is have everybody be able to introduce themselves to the
16:05 entire committee. So if you council
16:15 strong just general troublemaker Jordan's uh business owner in downtown
16:24 what's your business coffee in the west builds in our sub
16:34 historic village I'm not actually not on the committee on Right. And so the way that that will work is we welcome you to be here, but
16:42 you won't be speaking at No.
16:47 Evan Picasso, uh, real estate guru, Rocky Dano, Chick.
16:58 Uh, Keith Mullins, former council member and a downtown merchant for 22 years. Outstanding. Okay. I'm Nathan Norris.
17:06 I'm the director of economic development uh for the city.
17:09 Jim Adams, owner of Clermont Orthodontics in downtown Clermont.
17:14 You already know Dan and Zane. Um I did want to point out that Juliana Green is
17:20 also on this committee had a mother had an issue that required her immediate
17:27 attention. So she's not likely to be here today unfortunately.
17:32 Okay. Um, I just want to give an overview before we uh get into appointment of chairman and vice chairman who's going to lead this and
17:40 remind everybody uh why we're here and what we're doing. I've got a few notes to share. Um, the first is uh why are we here?
17:53 Uh we have a uh essentially a directive a resolution that was passed by the council that they wanted this body to
18:01 provide direction and recommendations to them on two things really. One are
18:08 concept plans and the other is an estimated budget. Okay. On parking
18:15 garages that would be uh on two different locations we've identified.
18:19 One is seventh in Minnola on the city land there and the other is behind this building behind the city hall. So the
18:27 idea is once again they've requested plans that doesn't mean one plan per site doesn't we're not limited that way.
18:34 These are these are plans. So we're not limited to one idea or approach committee can say well we've got an idea for what would be an expensive option.
18:43 We have a idea of what would be an expensive option. They have an idea of what would be well suited for a partnership with private entity. We
18:51 could we can do anything on this committee we really want. They want ideas. Okay. So that's the that's the first thing. Those ideas once again are
18:59 for concepts. It's not for a specific idea that's fully meted out. Um you know
19:06 so that's you know it's not a specific plan not just ideas. So we would they expect uh visualizations to show those
19:15 and they've given us some budget to try to generate those visualizations. So it's really going to be up to us to guide that and they want estimates. So
19:24 it's going to be once again it's estimates. It's not a a precise budget.
19:28 They're going to be uh looking at a general ballpark figures is what they
19:36 need. Um, as you may uh know, um, the reason why they wanted to do this is because we've had a series of different
19:44 issues come before the council which have uh uh are very complex. Let's say they're complex and and how they have to
19:53 be figured out. And um, this is one of the and the challenge is is that they don't have a body like this to help sort
20:02 of go through complex issues ahead of time. It becomes very difficult to do it just in 30 minutes up on the dives. And
20:10 so the idea is they really want this committee to give them some good ideas for where they can hit, what their options are. That's our job, not to tell
20:19 them what to do. It's just tell us tell them what we think their options are in the best way we can. Um, like I said,
20:26 it's largely because believe it or not, designing a parking garage is a very complex thing.
20:34 Okay? It wouldn't be a complex thing if it were out in the middle of nowhere.
20:38 But as soon as you stick it in the middle of a town center, it becomes super complex because it's impacts upon everything around. And we'll talk about
20:46 that in a little, but that's the number one reason is because there isn't one solution to this issue. There isn't one way to pull this all out. There's
20:55 numerous ways and then there's numerous impacts. And as a group, hopefully, you know, none of us knows it all. so everybody can contribute a little and hopefully get us to where we need to be.
21:07 Um the second reason why we have this committee is ultimately bound up in that that first thing of saying let's try to save ourselves time and money. You know
21:16 there's been a common it's only been last October but you know people have struggled with some ideas that we had 15 years ago and they haven't been
21:24 implemented yet. Park and Garage was one of those ideas that came out of the 2015 plan that the city of Clermont went
21:31 through and it hasn't happened yet for a variety of reasons, but the idea is let's save our time and money by uh going ahead and coming up with really
21:39 good concept plans. It's a common problem that a lot of communities have is that they don't come they don't focus enough at the concept stage the idea
21:47 phase and so everybody gets you know at odds because um you know their particular issue isn't adequately addressed. that's our job to sort of
21:55 adequately uh deal with certain objections that some people may have to certain solutions. Um I already mentioned there's no uh uh perfect
22:04 solution. Uh we're we're dealing with a parking garage and the first question that may come up is do we need a parking
22:11 garage? Okay, that's really not our task, but it's one of the things that we we get to to deal with is um you know,
22:18 how much of parking do we need? Um my background uh is uh somewhat been involved with these issues in the past.
22:29 And I just want to say very briefly that um parking is I believe is best viewed
22:36 as a piece of acquired infrastructure for downtown to to work well just like
22:43 electricity would be or access to water or sewers. It's an infrastructure item.
22:49 Um, and uh, unlike some of those other utilities, it's something that works best when it's
22:56 managed. Okay. And that's one of our challenges as a city right now is we, you know, our our management, we really don't manage parking right at this time.
23:05 And and and what was been learned over the last few decades is that it's actually um, parking is uh, really
23:13 handled best by dealing with the notion of supply and demand. just doing a core economic argument. Meaning that um if
23:22 you've got a parking problem, oftentimes that means people say you don't have enough supply. And that oftenimes means
23:30 because people aren't um paying for it or they're not, you know, so their behavior gets immediately changed as you
23:38 as you toggle back between supply and demand and try to to get done. If you want to read stuff on your own um or
23:46 videos on the subject, you're you're happy to do so. There is someone who just passed away about a year and a half ago that was considered the the guru in
23:54 the United States on the topic. His name is Donald Shupe. Shou P. So if you want if you're just into this and you're
24:02 wondering how do we do this stuff, do you want to say something?
24:06 Yeah, I just wanted to add I don't know if this breaks sunshine law, but I have those books. So if anybody wants them, I happy to them.
24:13 Okay.
24:15 I I I've got his books as well, but he is he was the uh you know he was sort of the Babe Ruth, although
24:23 he he called him the shootute dog of parking. Um but uh so and he had shistas, but he was a hilarious guy. So
24:32 he's entertaining to watch, but I didn't understand parking until I actually met him and learned about how it works. So
24:39 that may be something you want to do on your own time before the next meeting.
24:44 Um the the last thing I'll mention about um why the committee and that is is that because it does uh greatly impact the
24:51 functionality of the downtown you know that's that's sort of that what I was telling you about infrastructure it's how it functions it's not just how it
24:59 looks how a downtown can look does impact the functionality but that that's a thing now the downtown just going on a
25:07 side tangent for a quick moment downtown just you know I think it's important for us to keep the big picture we're looking at the parking issue. The downtown,
25:16 whether we like it or not, is uh similar to how other cities downtowns impact the overall city. And that is it's often times seen as the identity for the town.
25:26 It's often times seen as the heart of the town. And so how we do this doesn't just impact people in the downtown, it
25:32 impacts the entire city and how others beyond our city who may be visiting viewers. That's important. It's also,
25:40 you have to understand that our downtown serves as an amenity for uh our restaurant, our our residents that don't
25:48 even live in the downtown. It it is uh you know the heart many different ways, but it's a place of gathering where people come. It's where they want to
25:56 entertain people and they they bring people out of town. So, it's it's not only our identity, it's an amenity. And the last thing is that we have been
26:05 going through a comprehensive plan. that comprehensive plan. Um, we reached out to community to asked them what their concerns were and many of you
26:12 participated in that. It was funny because oftentimes it was difficult to people to tell us what was on their minds until we said, "What's the number
26:20 one problem in our town?" And we said traffic. It's almost like a chorus. Um, so what's downtown have to do with
26:28 traffic? It's one of from a comp plan perspective, it's really important because you'll note that when you're in
26:36 a town where you have an interconnected network of streets, you essentially don't really experience much traffic,
26:43 real traffic, and so it's an oasis from people who get frustrated being on 27 and 50. So through the comp plan, we're finding, you know, we're going to be
26:51 looking at ways to build up the uh the greenways network that we already have, make it easier to get to the downtown.
26:57 Uh the whole idea is that um uh we've got to have parking infrastructure that supports the idea that people can come here and easily enjoy the experience of
27:07 not having to be in a car uh when they're they're they're doing their other other things they want to do. Um the final thing I'll mention are some of
27:16 the issues that I think that we're going to have to address. Okay. And I I would hope that um this committee can sort of
27:24 go about this somewhat systematically, but understand that as we go through what we're doing is is essentially it's
27:30 a design process. And for those some of us are linear thinkers. We think of what's step A and step B and step C and
27:38 D E and F and all that. That's not how good design works. Okay. To design something, you actually have to go in a
27:45 circle. You start at one place which may be you know step A but then you go to B and the C and then you have to go around
27:52 the circle a couple times to make sure that you're you're designing what works because as soon as you design something let's say we were concerned about the
28:01 height of a parking garage as you think you've decided what the appropriate height is what's the next thing that happen okay well you know you might run
28:09 into a budget issue that says well you know we we can't do it at that height for budget reasons or whatever and so you have to go around the circle a couple times So that's essentially what
28:17 we have to do. Um uh we will talk about systematically we can look at different elements that we know will greatly
28:25 influence the design of a parking garage. Okay. One is the obvious thing we've already been tasked with which is where's the location. And so coming up
28:34 with one of the pros and cons of one location over another is really important. Okay. Then we have the second
28:41 item which is going to be essentially the amount or the size. So one of the things we have to worry about there is
28:49 what's the demand going to and uh uh and we can get into that uh further but just the the short note is we're looking at
28:58 the demand not just today but in the future. It's infrastructure. It's like building the the water plant before we actually need water.
29:07 Um we have you know we talked about height um cost is an impact. Um then we have to think about the um the specific
29:17 impacts upon the downtown as a whole as well as adjacent properties um and on other
29:24 things like even events. you know, this isn't all just about physic physical things that sometimes how does it impact the events that we currently have that
29:32 we we we enjoy and things of that nature. So, when we think about impacts, one of the things to keep in mind is
29:40 that a downtown unlike most of the suburban areas in Clermont are um has certain advantages and certain
29:48 disadvantages in comparison to a suburban location. Okay. The uh uh an advantage would be that uh and a downtown area tends to be more vibrant.
29:58 There's more people walking around than you would the suburbs. And so how you design a partner garage can either
30:05 increase that the vibrancy or decrease it because if it makes it an example of
30:12 humans bore really easily and if they get bored what happens? They're just going to give up and they're not even going to walk. We don't want to walk
30:20 around unless there's something interesting to see. That's why artwalk is such a great thing is it adds interest to where you're walking around.
30:27 It's why between seventh and eighth is the core of the downtown right now because you have buildings that create the charm of an outdoor room and then it
30:35 has narrow building facade widths all up and down it to keep our interest like and so there's all sorts of functional
30:44 design details associated with how you design the parking garage um that we will be talking about, but it's it's it
30:53 gets back to if you've got to create an interesting place or it can kill things.
31:00 If you're walking up and down Mantros, if you're walking east, where do people stop walking? Okay, they sort of stop
31:08 walking right about midway in this building. And the part part part of the reason is because the charm of the
31:17 outdoor room falls apart when we have two suburban buildings sitting back across the street and we're saying, "Okay, we're coming to the end of what's
31:24 interesting." Whereas, if we go in the other direction, okay, it's it's like it's pulling you down the other direction because that's where the
31:31 action, right? So, will this parking garage play a role in that? We also have the complexity of um um well I won't get
31:40 into all the details but it's uh um there's also the impact upon funding that we have to you know I sort of mentioned it was cost as an impact upon
31:49 funding um there are certain ways we can design a parking garage that will result in our ability to have a public private
31:57 partnership more likely than not okay because those people are going to have certain interests you know they're we do a public private interest public private
32:06 partnership you're going to have to be looking at um how does the revenue work okay and that's that that's going to be an important consideration so uh dealing
32:15 with all those uh issues is going to be uh I I think what we can uh uh how we can logically go about dealing with a
32:24 committeewide design exercise because otherwise it could be really boring and lousy and and and uh not be much fun. That's uh that's the overview.
32:34 Any questions about why we're here or anything else that I talked about before we move on.
32:41 I have a question on are are you able to sh I'm sure you are, but like will there be a part in the process where you share
32:49 what the lumber yard, how many spots are they adding and also any additional
32:56 demand, maybe what's happening at West End or you know that that type of stuff. Okay. Um that's an excellent question.
33:04 The answer is yes. So um this inaugural meeting is designed to identify all those things that we have to figure out.
33:11 As an example, I didn't forward to you the existing plans we have for both of the sites that we already have.
33:18 Okay? Because I sort of wanted to have everybody have a sort of a fresh start, a fresh look at it, thinking about it.
33:25 Um but clearly everybody needs to digest what's already been recommended on both sides. Um because, you know, uh we we
33:32 haven't gotten there wasn't overwhelming consensus in the previous councils that considered the one at the city hall or
33:39 at this one. Um so we've got to come up with something better is the answer and that includes understanding cap you know
33:47 what our current capacity is and what future capacities may be. Um, we uh I
33:54 still I will say this as it relates to that. Um,
34:04 I don't want to cut to the chase too much, but the issue the primary issue is
34:11 um that can help inform the amount that we could need in the you know in the foreseeable future of a certain you know
34:21 2035 or whatever it may be, we can sort of go along with that. Um but at the same time, um if we look at what we need
34:30 today, that's not a fair sort of thing because the whole point of the reason why there's great interest politically
34:37 in this is for to get additional development. So that's one of the good things that we can try to figure out
34:45 especially right now we've got resources we've been given where we can um starting what that amount of need will
34:53 be if we built out a certain amount of the downtown and and so that very much is within our wheelhouse of what we've got to decide.
35:03 We don't have a long time to figure it all out, but I don't think we have that many questions in the big scheme of things to to figure out. kind of
35:12 following up on this because my question is also if you watch the city council meeting there was some funding for the
35:20 designs and I was wondering if we also have funding to gather data because I think that all the decisions that we make should be for the design should be
35:27 data informed and that will be either research or consulting.
35:32 kind of question, right? We've been given uh I think the the important thing is for us to identify the questions that we
35:40 want answered that our committee can't answer.
35:44 Okay? And then we reach out to our resources uh about how it can be done.
35:50 So I'm I'm less worried, you know, they want to get they want to make an informed decision. Okay? They don't want to wait forever, but they want to make
35:59 an informed decision. So I don't think asking for certain things and once again it's not we don't need it to the level of uh pre precision okay we need an
36:09 overall idea okay what do we expect on this question that question is that fair
36:15 all right other questions just a comment a couple things uh you
36:24 mentioned about traffic um that's really a relative issue I come from And trust me, the traffic here is
36:33 nothing. I mean, it flows. Okay. Now, if you're a long time resident here and with all the influx of new residents,
36:41 yeah, you're going to see an increase in traffic, but it still flows. I'm 27. I'm going
36:49 50 may jam up a little bit during rush hour going to work, coming home from work, but relatively speaking, this is
36:56 the traffic is nothing. Okay. You can still get around. And what's nice about this community, it only takes five or 10 minutes to get to anywhere you want to
37:04 go. As opposed to Orlando, it takes half hour, 45 minutes. Okay. So, quality of life is better because of that. Um, now
37:12 in terms, you mentioned something Nathan as far as uh we want to attract businesses downtown. Okay. Presently the
37:22 parking situation I see on a day-to-day coming work every day there's ample parking. Okay. Like for example, the
37:29 parking in front of my space at uh 7th and West Mola Avenue.
37:36 Um at times it gets full. There's spill over onto the lot one block north of
37:42 that. So I never see it a problem with parking during a normal business day or even on a weekend. We got the farmers
37:51 market that gets a little busier. It's when we have major events, but the major events are with When I was in Orlando, we had a major event party is always a
38:00 hassle. Major events. So, I think the main issue here is we want to promote
38:08 businesses coming here just like I foresee that plot one block north of 7th and West Mola
38:16 as an excellent place for restaurants, uh, a little park area. It's a nice plot of land. Granted, I know an individual
38:25 or a family owns that, but develop that for any parking. So I think parking garage primarily is for future business
38:33 to entice them to relocate or start downtown.
38:37 Yeah. And I think to like the demand, how much does Patrick's projected project at West End? How much is that?
38:44 Is that going to be any additional parking or is there going to be a need for additional parking?
38:49 I would like to know is it all surface parking? Are they putting a garage there?
38:52 No, he's it's a zero zero parking requirement.
38:57 grandfathered in where he can build zero lot line essentially no parking requirements able to use whatever the city has available for on street parking or service lots.
39:06 So that's a net like we need more for that in that regard.
39:11 I I agree with what you're saying because of your type of business because your customers have appointments
39:18 and they will find a place to park. If you're a retailer that depends upon walk in or convenience,
39:26 I'm a half a block from you, right?
39:28 I have a Okay, my customers have a parking problem, which means I have a parking problem.
39:35 When I get to work at 9:00 on a Tuesday morning, Montro is full.
39:40 The city hall parking lot is full, right?
39:43 Because of the church school, right?
39:46 So my wife there's Yeah. A lot of time my wife just drops me off. I can't park downtown to work with what business you own.
39:55 I have a wine shop right here across the street. Okay. Yeah.
39:58 But but my customers want to come in, buy something, and leave, right?
40:02 They don't have an appointment. It's a convenience thing, right?
40:06 So, they need to park close, right?
40:10 Because you and you're a different business. We have different customer needs, right? you know, they'll go to the mall and walk a mile, but they won't walk a
40:19 block downtown, right?
40:21 So, we we have to be aware of attracting new businesses, but also maintaining what we get. I I got my mail this
40:30 morning and a piece of mail belongs to my neighbor. So, I took it next. It's It's a salon and it's less than a,000 ft. So, how many parking spots does code call for?
40:43 three four.
40:45 So thing with that though is that change the code so that they can buy the part.
40:52 Okay. An existing an existing business who's been there for years if they have a a 750 foot
41:01 store. What is the city code for parking spaces? I think it depends on the business. Okay. Restaurants are double.
41:09 It's just a regular retail service. is somewhere around three or four spots. I I don't know what it specifically is.
41:16 It does vary.
41:19 Yeah, it's a very condensed because if you go into like standard retail, if you make your way down 50, you're parking like at a restaurant, you're parking seven spots per thousand. It's kind of like the general what you want.
41:30 Yeah.
41:31 But in a 750 foot space, there were eight women and the store was only half full.
41:40 deliver chairs that didn't have customers. So that's what existing businesses are putting up with is high
41:48 density users in buildings that were built with low density codes.
41:54 So we we have a shortage. So not only do we have to build spaces for the businesses that we're trying to attract,
42:02 but we have to go back and back fill for the businesses who are here.
42:07 Plus, you got to have room for your employers. always got a part.
42:11 Yeah. Well, a hair salon, which there are five around my store, you've got a stylist, a customer, and a customer waiting. So, it's three spots per chair.
42:21 And a lot of these salons have five to eight chairs. So, that's how you keep such great hair. Yeah, I get my haircut.
42:30 They were probably discussing it, but not this meeting. But so and it really as far as needed information um I just like to get a a census of downtown employees.
42:40 I have that's a big issue.
42:42 Yeah. I have 19 I have 19 total employees. Um I would say probably five or six are on site at any one time or as much as 12 you know at one time
42:52 and I have people I also have the overlap of shift changes. So at sometimes I can have I can have a greater impact downtown than for instance like a salon instead.
43:04 even you and then you go right next door. It's that same continuation of Yeah. And and a lot of our So that's what I put in my application is I to to
43:12 get the right aside for what's going on West End and what's going on at Lumberyard, which I understand is going to have its own net parking. As far as
43:20 to be able to discuss this intelligently, I need to know how many employees we have downtown on any given day because like you said, you you have appointments. You see the daytime stuff.
43:31 I see everything. I we don't start getting busy till one or two o'clock and then and then during the evenings when all your employees are gone and perhaps
43:40 yourself is gone, that's when a lot of this stuff comes to a head. Now in the eight years ago, Monday through Thursday, nothing.
43:50 Monday through Thursday at night time it can the the top parking lot is full 7th minola and the and the Hoya property is
43:57 starting to fill up it doesn't ever get full generally during the week but it does start it you can see it building over the year right so even
44:06 I would like I would like to know how many of us who are just here that no customer is not a single customer how many parking spaces does downtown
44:14 Clermont need now and with all these attractive all this intent more business like you talked about. How many can we
44:23 project coming forward? Like you said, this new West End thing is going to have how many parkings? But I think there's also business.
44:31 Yeah. So that that right there could equal 50 or 60 parking spots.
44:35 If you go two cars, two cars for every apartment, possibly three.
44:40 downtown retail if it's a salon in there and they have eight chairs. Well, there's another 16 to 20 20 parking spots with customers and management and
44:49 everything. So, there could be hundreds of spots that we have, you know, because the city likes to uh talk about how many we have, but we don't talk about how many we use, just what our par is like.
45:01 What what is the par level daily here Monday through Thursday and then on the weekends from employees? because I can say I contribute to, you know, on a on a
45:08 busy Friday night, I contribute to 120 parking spots. C can I um just you mentioned downtown and
45:16 Nathan, do we want to use the CRA as what's considered our downtown area or do we want to consolidate it to a different area?
45:24 Why is it important?
45:27 Uh because there's a number being asked for who is downtown employeewise.
45:32 I would think a couple different answers uh for you.
45:35 First off is that I believe the last study was done two years ago. Um how long? Pretty recent.
45:43 Yeah. Yeah. Pretty recent.
45:45 It will give us a a pretty good ballpark of where we are. And it may be something
45:52 that we can do to ask somebody to well in any survey we've done either recently or in the past no one's ever asked me how many cars like how many
46:00 employees I have how many you know what's the overlap at 3 p.m. when I have a shift change between the two the three restaurants
46:08 and and the bar and the brew staff when they're going home.
46:11 So there's no real I don't have an idea of an eb and flow here in town between I can see it but I can't put a number up. I don't know how
46:19 many people is are employed downtown and what the you know what the overlap is between the two and four o'clock hour or
46:26 the five and seven hour when you have when you have shifts leaving especially in the retail space and the bar space or
46:34 the restaurants like Pepes their dinner staff comes in probably around four and for that period of time you have almost double the amount of employees that they
46:42 have maybe five to six at one time now there's 12 for a short amount of And so all this has to be if you're going to say about where you put this thing and and how many spots you need.
46:55 We don't even know what our par level is just the staff downtown and then then we can talk about what the
47:03 what the natural order things are going to be going for like you said the 2035 or something like that. If we do add x amount of businesses, well, if we have
47:12 data on how much, like I'm sure your wine shop doesn't contribute a lot to employee parking, you have one or two employees. But hello.
47:22 But but I but I know during a a Friday night I staff I have two during the day and then I have four at night. So that
47:30 for a brief period of time there's six people and then plus customers. I think this has to be part of the criteria
47:37 because what I'm hearing is that there's too many moving pieces to accurately tell how much is needed to accurately forecast how much is needed.
47:49 I think one of the design criteria for this garage is how it ties into a general transportation strategy because I know the development that's going to
47:56 Western Plaza. I was there at the planning and Sony commission. Those residents are not going to have two to two to three parking. They're not going
48:04 to have two to three cars, but they're gonna have at most one or two. How can the city encourage them to have zero?
48:13 Because people downtown, I live downtown, like I have I do have a car because I need it for groceries. But people who live downtown, we are very comfortable living a car life or a
48:22 car-free lifestyle if you give us the option. So this has to tie into other transportation strategies to make sure that the parking that is built is for
48:31 the people who come here to enjoy our downtown, not for us. And right now, one of the issues with that development is that for example, the downtown the city
48:39 council doesn't really have a strategy for things like employee parking or overnight parking. These are things that need to be discussed, but I'm not sure
48:48 if that is really up to us. It's more like but we can consideration
48:54 well the city has a code for how far from your store yes what counts as employee parking and what
49:02 counts as customer parking we should be we should be aware of the code I think so are we changing the code as well
49:10 I'm just saying we need to be aware I think there's several I think that let's bring it you say
49:17 no I was going to say I think there's several vote right now. There's like grandfather compared to Kirk.
49:26 Um, so, so you brought up a good point as far as our employees where they park
49:33 and a parking garage, not only to promote future businesses and have them have a place for all those customers to park. I think a short-term solution so
49:42 we can give our customers someplace to park. Like for example, I would have no problem in having my staff and myself
49:49 park in that lot across uh was West Vanilla on the north west corner. It's
49:56 dirt. I don't care. Um I would direct my staff and I will also park there to
50:03 create spaces for customers. And if if it's a short-term solution, we can create more spaces. We just require our
50:12 employees, hey guys, Sure, you may walk a little bit, but it's good exercise. Yeah, but it saves.
50:18 I was I wasn't really talking about the details about what I just I guess what I said really too long is we just needed a census downtown.
50:27 I think it's a lot more interrupt. I'm not going to interrupt. Okay.
50:34 This committee was given 60 days to come back with the recommendation.
50:37 That's why I don't want to get into too much of the details.
50:40 I want I want to make sure you keep it at higher level. So the it through transportation engineers has a manual of parking and that's how we do it and we
50:49 we do it based on the parking recommendations of it.
50:53 For instance, a retail might have 250 space return office one for every 300 to
51:00 get a downtown employee parking. We would have to probably use the IT game based on because while your your
51:09 business may be open today, tomorrow may be a different business with a whole different part. So, it's hard to say.
51:15 It's hard within 60 days to go around to every business and ask how many employees they have today, which could change tomorrow, it could change next
51:22 week. It fluctuates a lot. So, I would recommend using the ITB manual based on land use to give a rough estimate of
51:30 what so that would that guide say a salon with eight chairs has x amount of stone.
51:37 In other words, future land use like you're talking about, it's a salon with a bar the next day.
51:42 Um, Correct. And turn into a restaurant, which is a much higher.
51:47 So, is that is that something that you would be able to have for us by next meeting if we just said we have x amount of
51:55 commercial space and that's broken down into these three different subcategories and based on the current use, this is
52:01 what based on whatever that code is would be what's required.
52:06 We we could probably we could definitely try to get that meeting next week. So, the concern is that
52:13 When a development comes in, we approve it based on commercial. We don't say this is going to definitely be a restaurant. It's
52:22 definitely going to be a salon because we know that changes over time. So, we do it based on the average that's done by
52:30 I think we need to know where we're going, but we also need to know where we are. And to to be I'll I'll play devil's advocate.
52:39 The reason it's a swan today and a bar next week because the swan didn't have enough parking. Awesome. Okay. Would that count?
52:46 You want to say something before I intervene? Because now I'm gonna have to Yes. Uh no, I'm sorry. Like I guess you got to go.
52:52 Yeah. I I've got to go to another meeting. I just wanted again thank you all for for being a part of this is a big tax. As you guys can tell, you're getting into the weeds and it's going to be a lot to discuss.
53:02 It is. It is getting a lot of attention.
53:05 out here today interviewing us about this committee and about what they're going to be doing. So it's a very important important position that you
53:14 guys are all greatly appreciate that staff will be here to help you with any any resources that we can we're happy to help.
53:25 I do have one other request then if you're able to get that together would you be able to also give us a current count on our current surf available surface parking spaces? So in June of
53:34 2024, there was a study done that that showed roughly 11 and that's what I was going to bring up was that June that June of 2024 study is
53:42 actually reasonable and it'll answer most of the questions that were being asked here. So if if you guys can send that out to everybody because I'm familiar with it. I mean I've read it.
53:52 The the big issue and this comes back to what Bill's talking about. This comes back to what you're talking about.
53:58 As we start landing on a number, wherever this garage is, it has to be
54:05 large enough to accept that capacity because we're going to lose some surface. So, if there's 100 spots here and 100 spots there, there goes 100
54:13 spots. And the crux of the parking study was that if we lost either that dirt lot
54:21 or that dirt lot, which we were renting, then we would be over capacity during some of our peak hours. And I know this
54:31 because I've talked to Bill before and I'm going to assume the same as for yours that during those events during
54:39 when there's that big influx of people that's when dollars come in. Again, yours is, you know, my kick goes to you.
54:47 Um those are the you know, I have an appointment. I show up at one o'clock on Thursday afternoon and that's what we
54:53 do. Um, but in those biggers, it's got to just be percentages. And you know, everybody's talking about what Patrick's
55:02 doing with that. Nobody's even talked to him about the hotel that's coming behind that that takes up the rest of the block
55:10 and a half. And so, um, Dr.
55:16 with police department, um, Kasa, Dr. Kasava, he would like to square that off.
55:24 They can probably give you the numbers of a rough estimate of how many employees and what that parking would need for that entire
55:33 block. I mean, that's a big piece of property. If he redevelops it the way that he wants to, that's I mean, that in
55:42 in of itself will probably eat up everything we do on the garage. This will not be the last garage. I mean, it's just we we've got to land on
55:51 something and land and be able to build it and do it correctly. But this is not the end of our parking issues because there's a lot of land that way. I mean,
56:00 it's hard to go that way because of the historic, but there's nothing historic that way. I mean, be honest.
56:07 Thank you everyone. Good luck. Thanks.
56:11 See how big his smile was as he was like gonna go check.
56:18 All right. Now, um Okay, I want to intervene because y'all are getting into things that are important, but then
56:26 again, they're not the most important thing necessarily. And I want I want want to get the context. So, you may be wondering, well, how do other cities manage parking effectively? All right.
56:35 And it's and so I'm going to give you the the quick little elements that you're going to see people using successfully. Okay. And the first thing
56:43 is that you know the the premier book on it is actually it's title is the high cost of free parking. And we have free
56:51 parking everywhere. And what that means is that nobody has you know we have plenty of business owners we know who have employees parking right in front of their businesses. Okay. On occasion.
57:01 Okay. The may be a few but it's happening. Why is because it's free and they can be there forever. And so uh uh
57:08 the whole parking reform effort happened because Stanford University's economics department was having a parking problem.
57:16 And they found out that the city wasn't or the university wasn't using the law of supply and demand. They said, "Well, why don't we charge until people aren't
57:24 willing to park there?" That was the basic premise. And so that's when they stumbled upon Donald Sh who was a UCLA professor who was, you know, from
57:32 England. He was knee deep in all this stuff for a long time, but nobody would read anything because it was so boring.
57:37 Okay, what he was talking about. So, he came up with essentially three different key elements that you'd have to have.
57:43 Okay. And the first is is that um you should only charge for parking if uh you don't have enough, right? If you don't
57:50 have enough and and so the question became, well, how much is enough? And the idea is if you're a retailer, let's say you've got the wine shop out here,
57:58 you want a spot that's close to your business all the time. You don't want it to be where somebody says, "Well, I'm not going to come by your shop anymore
58:05 because I had to park three blocks away." So, what they come up with and they determined was what they called the
58:12 85% rule. 85% rule was I could, you know, I could always, you know, at least uh uh there was typically 15% of parking
58:22 spaces were available within a block of a business. If we can get that, all we got to make sure is that we're we're charging enough. And often times it's
58:30 called variable rate parking. It's cap it's we're capable of doing it because of technology today. But the idea is someone's never going to say I couldn't
58:39 find a spot. They may say I don't want to pay for it. So well guess what for a downtown business owner that's not exciting to say my customer has to pay
58:46 for parking in order to come buy a bottle of wine for me. Right? They say I'm not doing that anymore. Well so how
58:53 how did they deal with that? They came up with a parking benefit district.
58:58 Okay. Because what the if the city manages parking for example and they get all the funds, they generally want to take it and do with whatever they want
59:06 with it, right? But instead what they when they the first time this was really done on a citywide level was in Pasadena, California in old Pasadena and
59:14 and uh they realized, oh, we have to have a parking benefit so that all the revenue that gets generated from the
59:21 parking goes back into the district. If you don't do that, it disfavors the the downtown merchants, which isn't fair.
59:30 And so that's a So you have the variable rate pricing. You've got that. Then you've got the other issue is we have different types of parkers, okay? We
59:37 have some people who need to be there all day, okay, or or at night, whatever.
59:41 And so that's when you get into um you know, you get dedicated parking spaces, you get permitted parking spaces, you
59:50 have all these different categories. As an example, if you put uh one of these parking garages here, um let's say you take the space that's right behind this
59:58 wall where the city hall employees uh go. So the city all of a sudden would be if they do a public private partnership, what happens? They've got to pay monthly
1:00:07 parking bill, right? To whoever whoever's managing it or they pay that amount up front, whatever it may be, somebody's going to be paying because the parking spaces aren't for free.
1:00:17 Okay. While we can uh pay you Todd referenced the the $3,000 that people can say, I'll give the city $3,000.
1:00:24 Well, it's going to cost more than $3,000 to create a spot in one of these parking garages. Okay, it costs tens of
1:00:31 thousands of dollars typically per parking spot um in a garage. So, that's a that's a component. So, that's in a
1:00:40 nutshell the core sort of management techniques that other cities have used.
1:00:44 This isn't controversial. We know how to manage it. It just it has to be managed and that's the pain. Right now we haven't had to manage anything. We just say let's build another parking garage.
1:00:54 So let's get to the point of we're we're tasked with figuring out you know recommendations for building another parking garage is uh uh Dan said I think
1:01:04 it was Dan uh this our job isn't to figure out parking for the next 50 years in the downtown. It's to look at one
1:01:11 location with one parking garage and say, "What should that be?" That should be influenced by our needs. Okay? They
1:01:21 didn't ask for us. The council didn't say, "Tell us what our needs are." They said, "Show us a design that we can
1:01:28 embrace." Okay? But so I'm not saying it's irrelevant. It's just not the only thing out there that we have to worry about. We have to come up with what is
1:01:36 the what is the uh uh what is the right solution? each of these locations and that right solution isn't necessarily
1:01:43 going to be perfectly matched with whatever we come up with as far as what demand's going to be at this point in time or that point in time. As an
1:01:50 example, we could say of the last proposal over on seven in Mola, I think had and somebody can correct me if I'm wrong, but I think they had three
1:01:59 different estimated budgets for three different heights of parking garage. Right.
1:02:05 Okay. And those three different ones Okay. And so it's not equal. Let's say if you're the dentist next door, is it going to be five stories? Is it going to be three stories? Is it going to be one?
1:02:15 What is it going to be? Okay, those are that's another factor, not the only factor to consider, but it's an impact upon adjacent property owners. And so,
1:02:23 you got to factor that in. So, that the you know, and that would be, you know, I I know just in hearing people speak that
1:02:31 having it too tall is a concern by some people in a particular location and it wouldn't be in another location. So just
1:02:39 that that's why this is complex and I just want to I want to make sure that's clear. But our job is just to come up with what's the best solution and it may
1:02:47 be different numbers that we're worried about and that's okay. It's different.
1:02:52 We get a different number over on 7th and Mola than we get on the city hall.
1:02:57 They don't need to be the same. We just get to come up with concepts of what we think will work and why and then justify. So when I talk about the design
1:03:05 issues that or perhaps the issues we have to address there then becomes opportunity for the committee to sort of
1:03:12 prioritize them by stating why what what is the it's just and what we would call that in the design exercise is these are
1:03:21 the design considerations and this is the priority. The idea is that if you're building a house Tim you've got a um you could say it's too small or it's too big. What's the perfect size of a house?
1:03:32 There isn't a perfect size. Okay. And so you're just saying that was really important that it be small. Okay. Great.
1:03:39 Then let's articulate that. Let's say this lady says this is we looked at everything and on this site this these were the priorities that we think should
1:03:47 guide not control. This is what's you know because you're giving a sort of a gut reaction or you can give multiple ones but we said you know it's the same
1:03:54 thing if we think um revenue is the number one issue or it's not an issue at all. We just state it. we considered it,
1:04:02 move on. We don't we don't have to be wed to any one one thing. So that's why I don't want to get into overall do we
1:04:08 need the parking and um uh how much matters but it just doesn't matter because there you know we saw today I
1:04:17 don't I guess it came out yes last night the Winter Park the Orlando u
1:04:25 Orlando simple I think came out or maybe it was the business came out with an article about Winter Park is another parking garage and they talked about the
1:04:32 needs and all that sort of stuff and they're just going through the same exercise but it's not the first and it may not be the last it's just where they
1:04:39 are today. Any questions about that? I mean could a proper recommendation be
1:04:49 we need a public parking garage and then a private time
1:04:56 we can make any we can Yeah. And what what I'm saying is that we I really think it's important we don't have to have one recommendation. We could say we
1:05:04 think these are the options. Remember you can get buy in both polit you know politically you get buy in often times
1:05:11 when you give people uh you know an opportunity to choose like you can't make a meaningful choice with all you've
1:05:19 got is one choice. That's not really a choice. It's like it's either this or nothing. And that's not a very good thing. But what if we come back and say,
1:05:27 well, you know, we we could see it working this way or this way or this way. We like this way the most because of X. Great. Let's do it. But it's not the only way.
1:05:36 Um, other questions?
1:05:38 And making a recommendation, whatever that is, you had mentioned about whether is there any slight limitations known now about how high or how many floors we can go on either side.
1:05:49 Theoretically, no. Okay.
1:05:52 I've I've heard rumors that on this on the site next to city hall there's underground rain storage
1:06:01 tanks it would be expensive to replace if they choose that site I would be curious if that's true I've also heard
1:06:10 rumors about the senior about underground utilities that would have to be moved or
1:06:18 what's it called part of the sales agreement when they bought the land is it could only be used for parking so if there are
1:06:26 things that have to be addressed that cost money. I think we should be aware of that also. Right.
1:06:32 I didn't want to ask you out there because it's hot.
1:06:35 It is hot. I'm delaying that. Well, because we're we're making progress in here. As long as we're making progress in here, we don't immediately have there's any special features or things.
1:06:45 There's like Yeah. You can't build a skyscraper because it's sand, you know.
1:06:51 I I will tell you that and you know, I I imagine we'll end up someplace around here, but you know, historically, there
1:06:59 was a a a desire that was expressed by the community not to go higher than a certain height in the downtown.
1:07:09 Historically, what do you say?
1:07:11 It's 55 55 ft because this building is about 55 ft. So, is that three stories roughly?
1:07:18 It used to be lower than that. You can go you can go four. So, when They did this concept over here. I think their
1:07:26 max height and it was a little bit it was right at the top of the height and I think they got 475.
1:07:37 Don't quote me on that, but I think it was 475 parking spaces on that one over there.
1:07:41 That's it has to do with the reach of the fire truck, doesn't it?
1:07:45 It's really the people because we've got the ladder trucks now that can go. I mean, so it's not an issue, but That was
1:07:52 the issue on the hospital point where that has been resolved with with department. They've got all the toys now.
1:08:02 Think think at at one time the mayor didn't want anything taller than a tree.
1:08:06 Yeah. Don't but he's not here anymore.
1:08:09 Don't prank Chief Fazelle's heart and tell him you can't go buy you know 200 foot ladder truck.
1:08:18 So, there may be special situations we should be made aware of that that would impact it.
1:08:24 Okay. I was going to show you real quick um the previous proposals on both sites.
1:08:32 Um Chuck, I'm having a hard time mirroring. We're not chang
1:08:40 Oh, it should be because that's the correct answer. I think we make sure it's on the HDMI. Our taxpayers paying
1:08:48 for HBO Max staff watch Hulu during today.
1:09:03 Okay. While he's doing that, um so I'll just show you um the graphics. Those are the easiest things to read, but as Todd
1:09:11 was saying, um you could go uh up to four stories and then you know the top story essentially is an additional level. The uncovered parking at the top
1:09:20 if you wish. Um you'll see how that was handled differently time and I think that this is going to go way off topic
1:09:28 top topic and kind of throw people for a loop. Um, but our parking, we almost have to have a futurist discussion
1:09:35 because our our need for parking and our the way we're going to drive because of self-driving because of the way shared
1:09:43 use and all of that is going to impact us is going to change the way this garage gets used probably at the right
1:09:52 when we get paid off. Um, but it will change over the next 20, 30 years the way that we use it. So I think we ought
1:10:01 to be cognizant of that of can we make it multifunctional whether it be for
1:10:09 parking of like retrofitable how do we repurpose it 30 years from now that that that's more of it is
1:10:17 it's like can can we put solar panels on the top to power the chargers for the electric cars on level three.
1:10:24 I mean there is no supercharger in Clermont. No superchargers whatsoever in play. Yes, sir. Is there one now?
1:10:32 Yeah. Tesla at Tesla dealership at the dealership.
1:10:37 But for the longest time, we because my wife's got a Tesla and she's had to go to before the Tesla dealership was there, she had to go to Walmart or something.
1:10:47 I don't think it's Is it No, it's BP. You put the holes in.
1:10:53 Oh, well, I do too, but All right, let me just for those who haven't seen this, we will ship this out
1:11:01 to you along with some other information. Um, but this is the seventh and Minnola site over there. And then this, um, I'm just going to orient you.
1:11:10 Is my head in the way? You're good. Good enough.
1:11:13 All right, good enough. All right. Um, so this is the artwalk right here. You can see the Airstream right here. So
1:11:20 this would be where Minnola is here and Seventh is on the other side. And what you're seeing here is um
1:11:28 so that's essentially we're standing in front of that's if you're s if you're standing on this my sidewalk that's pretty much what you would see you looking at
1:11:37 right okay so that's that I won't go into all the the the details too much um
1:11:43 but this was uh the this was the the one that was conceived of as just being nothing but parking um you can put uh
1:11:52 other things we'll see other examples I think of how it could be treated. This is if you're uh looking right down to
1:12:00 seven. Here's here's a walkway that was designed there, but that's looking uh you can see where air stream is, but that's looking east, right?
1:12:13 This one. Yeah. Right there.
1:12:16 Yeah. So, that pedestrian walkway that's going to the right would be in front of your building. So there's an agreement to have a 10 foot
1:12:23 walkway that goes across the front all the way over to eight. So between seventh and eight there would be a And you're saying that's 100% parking.
1:12:32 No retail along the walkway.
1:12:35 Uh essentially that's correct. That is all parking. That's But we can recommend something different. That's right. Yes. I strongly adise.
1:12:43 Okay. And yeah, just for terminology purposes and it's not porative really.
1:12:48 This is considered what is mostly a a naked parking garage, meaning there's nothing covering it up except um here the idea is to use art to cover it up.
1:12:58 We can use art wherever we go. Um but it's it's it doesn't have a liner building of any sort. Typic you know a
1:13:05 lot of times uh where there's important important front as an example um Minnola is a very important street to the
1:13:13 downtown. So you would want you don't want a blank facade on there because a blank facade essentially is boring. To
1:13:21 increase the vibrancy, you want to have something going on there. So it could be um a business, but it's it's typically
1:13:28 very shallow businesses that are in small spaces that might occupy. It can just be the first floor. Some liners go
1:13:36 all the way up on a park. That's not really important for the urbanism or for how the the functionality of the street is. But those are the different ways and
1:13:45 you'll see the city hall one had a liner building on one of its sides where that side is important. But we'll see that.
1:13:51 But um so so that's that. All right.
1:13:55 Now, what's the advantage of a naked parking garage is that it costs less.
1:13:59 You get more parking for you know you're all about the spaces. You get that. The downside is that it's not as interesting
1:14:07 to walk by. All right. And that can cause somebody to say, "Okay, I'm stopping. I'm not going to the next business." And so this is five stories. Is it parking on top as well? So six.
1:14:17 Yes. All of them are going to all of them have it would be hard to find a parking garage that doesn't have parking at the very top.
1:14:26 Nathan, you mentioned earlier that some designs will encourage public private partnership, others will discourage it.
1:14:32 What would this be? What would this um determination on that was there
1:14:39 the public private partnership. Well, there's not a straightforward answer
1:14:46 because it depends how much the city wants to put in. city either has to pay a huge amount upfront or a huge amount
1:14:54 on a monthly basis, let's say, to to do employee parking or something like that, or they're going to um uh they're going to um audit.
1:15:06 Well, no, no, no. So, those well that that's still paying, but the other issue is how much are people going to pay for parking? As an example, if you go to
1:15:14 Miami and you say, "Okay, well, how do they manage parking in Miami?" Well, very wrong. They get like a $2 fee
1:15:22 just they call it a service fee just for getting into the parking garage. Okay.
1:15:27 And then how much do you pay per hour to be in the parking garage? And so it becomes a you know because anybody who wants to manage it that's what they're looking for is the long-term revenue.
1:15:36 And so we can design it. Now it may be that the land is so valuable like it is here on Minnola for example that all of
1:15:45 a sudden that is very valuable as a line. If you put a liner right now, as an example, facing Dodto Street back
1:15:52 here looking, you know, that may not be very valuable. It might be valuable overlooking the city hall park right here, facing your wine shop. That would
1:16:00 be valuable. And so that's where the numbers start changing. Okay. Tampa.
1:16:08 That's right. Okay. And so we're just seeing this more daylight. This is on seven going down um to the de hoyos in the lake going this way. So this is Dr.
1:16:21 Tim's spot right here. It just wasn't there. That really sucks.
1:16:27 So you guys are right now you're saying that because right now he's got about five foot walkway here and you're saying
1:16:34 there's going to be eight feet here from building to building building to building 10 feet and then so that's your yeah that's your
1:16:42 frontage and and so that's um and that's that's where it comes in. So that's building to building.
1:16:48 But if it was a liner instead of a stairway that would give you a a retail for it.
1:16:54 It could but then Once again, you're beginning to see how complex this is because as soon as you do that, you've uh there's they talk about the
1:17:03 bays of parking. Just think about when you're in a parking garage, it's a it's a bay. You you're driving and you typically go left or right and then once you cut down a certain
1:17:12 amount of footage, that reduces your flexibility to do it and then it becomes more expensive.
1:17:19 And then you want to go higher and and then other people are like, "Well, no, that's going to look ridiculous at my shop." That's one story on Montro and
1:17:27 it's going to pop up and that's what everybody's going to see.
1:17:30 But our job really isn't to to to figure that out. We're we're just trying to figure out the proper place for a
1:17:37 parking garage and possibly with and suggestions of what it looks like. Not if there's going to be a row of shops there because those shops in a hallway
1:17:46 basically are not going to be that's I I would never put a business in a hallway like that, a 10 foot area. So that's not really appropriate for us to consider
1:17:55 because that's part of the design though. So you would you would put the shelf put them on
1:18:03 but if you look at these designs it can only empty out on the seventh or onto right and if it's empties out on Minnola I think you go in on Mola and maybe come
1:18:11 out but you can't if you take a right hand turn or lefth hand turn come out on Mola you're you're dumping all that traffic going downtown not out of town.
1:18:19 So to shove the building essentially shove the ground floor back to accommodate future shots is I don't
1:18:29 think we have 60 there's no way in 60 days we can get all that information to decide whether that kind of structure is
1:18:36 is is viable because we we would have to have studies done and we'd have to have things redesigned to figure out if
1:18:44 retail should go in this. Facades are one thing, but I don't think we should be concerned about a 10-ft walkway between two two buildings. Not at this point. Not in 60 days.
1:18:54 The building wouldn't move back. The the shops would be actually incorporated into the buildings. So, the first or second floor, maybe first would be your retail and then the parking on the upper
1:19:03 two or three floors would then extend above what those shops are.
1:19:07 But the limited amount I've studied about parking garages is that, and I'm not an engineer, but those cars have to get up somehow. They have to go. They
1:19:15 have to There's so if you ever been I'm sure we've all been in many parking garages and there's long runways to be able to make those turns that keep going all the way up.
1:19:22 Well, that's when you do a helix style which is kind of it sits like this like the Orlando airport.
1:19:28 Yes. So that you're as you park you're actually you're on grade going up. The only actual flat areas is where you make your turn to go up to the next grade
1:19:37 that goes up. I mean, I don't have a problem with a helix, but I know that anybody who lives within two blocks at 10 o'clock at night is just going to be hearing the squealing of tires going around that thing all the time.
1:19:49 Yeah. But, um, no, I mean, just you go in Orlando airport, you go up the the thing there, it's your tires just naturally on the as your your car is essentially sliding a
1:19:58 little bit because it's such a steep turn. Such a sharp turn.
1:20:01 No, I think I think for simplicity sake to keep us on track Yeah. Let's just build a park and crash.
1:20:06 Don't Yeah. And I would argue that's not your that's not your job. Your job isn't to build just it's to build the park and garage that
1:20:15 suits the context. That's why I said this is complex because you're balancing different things. One of the things is how it impacts the the buildings around you.
1:20:24 Right.
1:20:24 Okay. And if this causes people to stop from walking to somebody else's shop for whatever reason when it could be
1:20:32 just the opposite. So once again, nobody needs to wed any to any one thing. Okay, it doesn't have to have all liner. Okay,
1:20:42 but it could have some and you may determine that's really important and we'll show examples of you know but my point was
1:20:50 let's just build a parking garage. Let's not worry about having retail on the bottom or something like that. Let's maximize
1:20:58 we try to build a parking garage to maximize parking downtown.
1:21:03 No, no, no.
1:21:05 Because you can break it can it can a badly designed parking garage will break the experience like the the side not the
1:21:11 sidewalk sorry but the um right is how big this is thank you
1:21:18 like people don't walk past I want to say 60 ft with nothing going on and a parking garage just nothing going on that's why you put shops it's not just
1:21:26 out of whimsy you need to have something on the first floor in that particular area because that is that first floor is way too valable to the parking that is
1:21:36 well that's revenue pay for the garage rent that's right there also it's super complex also it's not just about parking
1:21:43 it's not our job to fix the complexities that is his job so we can just tell him we want retail he has to figure it out
1:21:50 are there any like um so things that we might argue about or we might recommend that are never going to happen so for
1:21:58 instance what if I say oh let's do bottom floor all retail Let's go wake stories up and you know
1:22:06 that's never going to happen. So those parameters I don't know about you guys but would help me. Yeah.
1:22:12 So because my immediate thought is let's keep going like you know but it we know that's not okay. I I don't think we know.
1:22:20 Okay. I think we we've heard Yeah. Yeah. Because I've heard three stories.
1:22:24 Oh no. It can't be more than 55 ft is I can tell you from sitting on council going past 55 ft becomes serious heartburn for a lot of folks.
1:22:34 That's we don't care about that.
1:22:36 Well, that's it ended up to be five parking garage stories. Four. So Patrick what Patrick wants to do with the hotel
1:22:44 over here um because they want to do an open air roof with the gazebo. the gazebo top would
1:22:54 actually top out even though it's an open air.
1:22:57 So, you know, he was within, I don't know, five feet of the max height. And I told him, I said, "This is a fight that
1:23:04 you're just going to have to have. Who knows?" But that would be, you know, his concept is the tallest building in downtown
1:23:12 right now because of that. And it's just one of those that you're like, "So, what is his what is his top height?
1:23:19 Is it I think it was 58t." 58. And that's off topic.
1:23:23 Yeah. But it was it was within 3 ft. And he was like, "You going to argue with me over 3 ft?" Once it becomes 3 ft, then the parking garage go another.
1:23:32 Yeah. Because to your point, our job isn't really to solve the complexity.
1:23:37 Our job is to make the best recommendation. And if we think it's eight stories with retail on the bottom,
1:23:45 that should be our recommendation. I'm not saying it is. I'm just I think that's fair.
1:23:50 I want I will remind everybody that there was a building that was approved at 70s something feet and people howled about it. It was as unpopular as the
1:23:59 lumber yard. Um council proved it I think.
1:24:03 Well, how tall is the lumber yard? It's got to be taller than it's still it's still within the 55 stories I think is is what it is.
1:24:12 The other thing you have to take in consideration is once you get above like five, six stories is the foundation for that to to support that load. cost it it becomes cost prohibitive, right?
1:24:23 We're really looking at realistically five or less.
1:24:27 Yeah, that helps. Just and five is still tall or taller than you know we could argue what the current
1:24:34 council where their heads are, but that's we we can this committee doesn't even have to agree. We can say here's
1:24:42 the pros and cons of this. Here's the pros and cons. But it doesn't make sense on either lots, whether it's city hall or 7th of Minneapolis, to build anything
1:24:49 under the maximum we can build from a cost perspective.
1:24:54 Oh, yeah. If all you were concerned about is the most efficient cost per per uh per unit of parking, you're correct.
1:25:01 But that's not that's that's not all concerned about.
1:25:04 But rather than going eight stories here, I'd rather go four here and four three blocks further. But that's but
1:25:12 that's you know it's just like building a you're a developer right?
1:25:15 So it doesn't cost uh if you have a fivetory building and you put up um four stories and then you say well we
1:25:25 want to add the is the extra story 20% more or of the entire building cost or is it a lot less? A lot less.
1:25:32 That's what I mean. If we're going to build a park garage, it has to be to the maximum spot because if you don't if you don't build it as high as you can go,
1:25:41 then the second garage that's going to come down the road is those. You want to say something?
1:25:46 Yeah. So, and I have a little bit of extra knowledge just because I've already seen this.
1:25:51 Um, thin front goes into this and when you multiply out the cost per space, that second story ends up to be about
1:25:59 the same cost per parking space. So, um, it's a little bit less, but there's not a significant savings each one you go
1:26:06 up, even though you get significantly more capacity. So, I think once we get further along in this presentation and
1:26:13 I'll do that, but the Benrop and I didn't meet with them. I didn't poison the well. I never dealt with any of that. So, I just want to make that
1:26:21 clear. Um, but what I did ask was for them to be able to meet with staff and kind of give a concept of how to build
1:26:28 it in the most efficient or in the most cost effective manner and they did that.
1:26:34 That's how they came in at what 12 million um where the previous estimate was 16 million. So they came in and they
1:26:42 tried to help the city come up with a design that was the most cost effective because essentially that's a you said it's a fivetory building.
1:26:52 This one is with a top deck market six, right?
1:26:55 Yeah. This is a a looks like a fourtory but it operates as a fivetory. on the top, but essentially it's a four story
1:27:04 because we're losing the ground space that's already on there now. Same with same with city hall. We're losing we're losing the parking.
1:27:11 Yeah. So, we're losing 100 spots. Well, but it's not.
1:27:15 That's right. That's that's right. But to get back to your your your larger point that you were making, uh the job isn't to maximize, you know, to get the
1:27:24 lowest cost we can because the options that are actually before the council are to also includes doing nothing. So if
1:27:31 they don't like it at five stories maximum, you know, efficiency, then what
1:27:38 it's not solving the problem that is causing this to happen. So once again wetting ourselves just a one
1:27:46 one criteria is the challenge and that's why this would be so hard to do just politically uh on a dis where people
1:27:54 imagine we were talking right now what should what should it be so let's just get through these two and then um once
1:28:01 again the idea was to to use paint to make it more interesting and you use paint or landscape to make uh places that otherwise
1:28:10 that is looking toward um 10 building is up here on the left. That's the 10 foot walkway.
1:28:18 That's right.
1:28:19 Put some vines up the other side as well that building.
1:28:22 Okay. So, that was the universal.
1:28:27 No, Disney Springs.
1:28:31 That's right up there against that kind of stuff.
1:28:37 So, this was the presentation that was given You can see this is behind the city hall. You see the city hall park.
1:28:45 Here's Dodto. Here's seven. And uh this was one of the options. And this was I
1:28:52 guess it was two stories with a third deck open for
1:28:59 um and what you'll see as you get out here large a larger site. That's the difference. This is uh what that option
1:29:07 looked like at the corner of seventh in Dotto right here. So this is the the church is right over on this corner.
1:29:15 This was also the naked version. Then they added uh
1:29:22 what was I wasn't here. What was this described as though?
1:29:25 I don't remember what it was, but they put trees and bun stuff up top.
1:29:29 Yeah. Well, they should at least have shade cloth. I don't know if you've ever been to the Tulsa airport,
1:29:37 but the the top deck was all covered with shade cloth.
1:29:41 Okay. In Florida, I think that should be a law. Yeah.
1:29:44 But yeah, they were doing an activation, a rooftop activation.
1:29:48 So, was this roughly the same number of spots? No, it's like 300.
1:29:56 And was there a reason you got your solar covered on this one? solar.
1:30:01 So that's the solar over on the right up on the top deck. So there's different options.
1:30:07 Once again, that's what's going to happen is everybody's going to say, "Well, what if we do this? What if we can say consider this? Consider that this might
1:30:15 be the call." So the conversation on this one was that going too big would overpower city hall.
1:30:23 That was the that was the kind of the crux of the back and forth was that if
1:30:29 you go too big it it just to work city hall and that's our biggest building and so that was
1:30:36 and they were it's an office building not I wasn't in on that argument but
1:30:43 what what was the net amount of spaces after we lose the parking existing there?
1:30:48 I'm not um I'm not sure. We'll find out though. you know, we we all these proposals, but my big point
1:30:57 just to the committee to consider is that neither of these proposals was embraced and so the opportunity is to come up with
1:31:05 So when you're saying embraced, the council didn't love either one.
1:31:10 Um I would, you know, that that's difficult standard to really answer objectively, but I think it's fair to
1:31:17 say if they had embraced it, we wouldn't be here today.
1:31:20 Yeah. That's from 2021, I believe, is what that is.
1:31:25 Ultimately, you're hurting cats because the council is you have council members who don't believe we have a parking issue. You
1:31:33 have council members who want it in certain spaces whether it's there or not. And you have council
1:31:41 members who are practical who are just like, I don't care where you put it, but we need it. And so that's I think that's where you ran into
1:31:49 council running the gamut, everybody having a different point of view. I was kind of like, look, you know, land here, land there, I don't care. We need it.
1:31:59 Um, you know, I had preference, but at the end of the day, you know, it was just to move it forward. And I think that's how this kind of got forward was,
1:32:07 you know, at some point something's got to be done. And the problem is it hurts the downtown merchants if we don't get this done sooner rather than later
1:32:15 because we know we're going to lose a hundred spots and we're going to lose 100 spots in front of bills or we're going to lose 100 spots over here during
1:32:22 that that time and yeah we can bring in trolley trucks or we can do whatever we can to mitigate it but it's going to
1:32:29 suck for two years. I mean it's just going to and I think trying to get the suck over sooner is better.
1:32:37 Now Todd on this stuff there you recall the day have any proposals or designs where they turn the corner and maybe actually tied
1:32:45 the garage into city hall itself to make it look like one continuous structure? I don't think so. And again,
1:32:53 this one was not done. This is not an apples to apples comparison. Um, you know, if you went to
1:33:01 and I don't know that throat could even I guess we could ask them to look at it and kind of get a
1:33:08 you can get because you can build to there's pre pre-built sections which is what friend prop does that's what
1:33:15 savings comes in and then you can custom I think this one was custom and I think that's where the price tag the price tag
1:33:22 on this was um and so there's just different pieces and parts so we're not going to these
1:33:31 are not apples to apples for sure yeah if I throw my two cents in here Um,
1:33:39 when I was first, you know, talking to Nathan about this and each other in talking about downtown
1:33:45 area, uh, I'm of the mindset campus, but higher, maximize spaces, okay, have it
1:33:54 next to the city council building. Uh, we can maximize spaces and actually increase the number of spaces, be greater than having parking garage on
1:34:02 seven. The thing about having on seventh street, one, it's going to buy businesses. business along the building
1:34:09 that I'm in. You may say, well, you got that little walkway walkway to where?
1:34:14 Okay. There's nothing pulling people from the center of your strip, you know, the the center of downtown to seventh
1:34:23 street. The walkway ends up at residential house. There's no nothing pulling people that way. So, these businesses are going to be affected. And
1:34:32 do you want to have the parking garage be the centerpiece of downtown? To me, that's not what downtown's all about.
1:34:39 You know, it's got the charm. It's got you can see out you can see the uh lake from where you stand down there. And the
1:34:47 other thing too that was brought it to my attention, I was talking to one of the the consultants that were advising uh Nathan
1:34:56 as far as where this garage. I didn't think about this. They say, "You want to put a parking garage that it's going to promote people walking through the
1:35:04 business area." And if you got a parking garage right at seven and west and say they're going to the wall, okay, there's
1:35:12 not they're not they're not walking through the retail areas. If you put it in, you know, right next door here, they've got to walk through all the retail areas on their way to the water.
1:35:23 So that's more exposure to the business.
1:35:25 Well, so I'll introduce this later, but I have a parking I have a study from I'm not sure it was done by the gentleman. He might have been credited on it though.
1:35:32 they might have quoted him, but um about how far people actually will walk and but so like you're you're a um a
1:35:42 dentist or any kind of professional is a is a time thing. People will go there if they have a dental appointment, they're going to go and they're going to find a spot at, you know, compeller high water.
1:35:52 They have to they have their appointment. But on the retail side, on restaurants, things like that, there's options for people if people have to
1:36:00 walk if they know to get to uh downtown like Minnola and anything further because that is the corner of the the zone.
1:36:09 It's so now they're going to have to to get to my place and this is where personal interests can can cloud these this this discussion. Are they going to
1:36:17 walk if a family wants to come for pizza and a beer? Are they going to get walk into the garage like that? through all that unload their car with a stroller
1:36:26 down an elevator then walk two and a half blocks or three blocks to my space when they can go to another place then park outside and walk right in.
1:36:34 So there's intent. So look at Winter Garden. Winter Garden is a perfect example.
1:36:39 But Winter Garden also has many many spots around that garage and so yes it's Winter Garden is great.
1:36:46 Yeah. But they put Winter Garden behind all the retail so it's out of sight. In fact, I parked in that park garage many times, you know, in the past. All kids
1:36:54 and I I want to But did you try to park closer to say can before you went to the garage? Absolutely. Absolutely.
1:37:02 And that and that's my point. This is a lot of money. It's a lot of public money, right?
1:37:06 And it has to be in place. And I wish it was a third option that wasn't near me so I didn't have something that would say this is my option because it's close
1:37:14 to me. But it's a lot of money to spend for something that city city workers are going to park into in the daytime. And
1:37:22 on Monday through Thursday, not many other people are going to park in because all the downtown businesses, especially on Montro, they empty out and
1:37:31 now it's what's left is my spaces downtown and beyond. Like going down the lumber yard, that's all going to be activated too with a hotel down there
1:37:38 and things like that. So the further you get away from that parking garage, the less impactful that garage is. And so if
1:37:46 it's less impactful but costs more money, I think it's not I would say if that's the only garage we're going to build in the next 10 years, then we
1:37:54 shouldn't build it at all there. We should wait and see what develops because in 10 years we'll know what's going to happen downtown. Maybe it has to go even further past me. Maybe it has
1:38:03 to go down near the lumber yard somewhere. But if it's only going to be city hall or 7th of Minnola and four
1:38:11 four of the seven days a week it's only going to be used by city employees most of the time that $16 million is wasted money.
1:38:20 This is a parking management discussion actually because again it doesn't matter how many parking garages we build in downtown. If we don't manage it we will
1:38:28 always have a parking problem. We need an overnight parking strategy. We need parking uh window parking strategy for employees and that ties into the parking garage.
1:38:37 My employees will they will park around. That's just how people are.
1:38:41 But if our objective was to build a parking structure that will draw more business, I think seventh in Minnola will have a
1:38:51 more positive impact on the doa property than building behind city hall.
1:38:57 Let me introduce a concept that isn't, you know, intuitive.
1:39:00 Uh, but it really does come into play here. And that is the difference between like if I go to Walmart, okay, I'm usually not trying to park super far away from the front entrance.
1:39:12 I'm like everybody else. I'm looking for the closest spot. Why? Because the experience is completely miserable uh walking through a surface parking lot
1:39:20 of a large suburban conventional development. However, I'll use the opposite craziness is if
1:39:28 I'm in Paris and I get to park within two and a half blocks of the restaurant where I want to eat that night, I feel like I hit the jackpot. Why? Because the two and a half block walk is a joy.
1:39:41 Okay? And that's why when we start talking about how does this this parking garage meet the street, how does it fit
1:39:48 its context? If it's not there's they usually call it walk appeal, like sex appeal. Oh, does it have walk appeal?
1:39:54 Does it have sex appeal? If it has walk appeal, we're not complaining about a a block or a two block or even a threeb
1:40:01 block walk. If it's interesting and beautiful, okay, and has the vibrancy where I see other humans wanting to hang
1:40:08 out. It's really interesting if you just come downtown and you start uh uh especially when it gets a little more activity of people walking around in the
1:40:17 evenings and just see where people stop walking.
1:40:20 Okay? Like they don't want to go by little police station, you know, what I call the the Darth Vader building or whatever. It's coming out at you, you
1:40:28 know, ran out of street and so does where it stops over here on Montro. It stops right in front of the city hall and then you can go in seventh and eighth and there's similar things.
1:40:37 That's one of the advantages of the Patrick Bianke's 821 Miniola project is it's going to be making the connection
1:40:45 um from Montras down to the water feel like that that was nothing to go one I get to Minnola and it's going to feel
1:40:53 great. Okay, because I'm not complaining about having to walk. The other issue that we didn't talk about that's probably should be on the issues has to
1:41:01 do with uh shade and to what extent does it provide shade. Um you can see it right now on Montro. I love it this time
1:41:08 of year to see the battles of people walking against one another and the sidewalk and who's gonna who's going to
1:41:16 stay under the canopy versus go out into the sunshine. People are fighting for that and it's raining every all that other stuff. But the the point is is
1:41:25 that um it does if we don't create a cool cool space to walk. People won't walk a block, you know, in in some
1:41:34 places because if you measure a block, our blocks are about the distance of, you know, the far farthest away a Walmart parking, you know, parking
1:41:42 space. And so if we don't have that walk up, whereas if I go, you know, it's if I go to Montress, no, I'm it's it's
1:41:50 pulling me along the way because of the different I'm saying. So, I don't want to get all touchyfey about it, but it's a science. And that's why if you want to
1:41:57 know how to build a a downtown, all you have to do is look at how, you know, you can go to the Mall of America in Minneapolis, in Minnesota, and they knew
1:42:06 how to get people to keep walking and walking. Your Chick-fil-A, Chick-fil-A started in the malls. Okay. What do they know? Everything about the design of the
1:42:15 inside of the mall was not guessing. All those little bubbles in the ceilings aren't just security purposes. They're
1:42:23 measuring where people stop and turn around and all that stuff. So this walk appeal thing is is I'm serious as a heart attack about it. And that's why
1:42:31 has to be done if we don't make it interesting all the way around especially in the core box. I brought this up just to mention
1:42:38 it gets a little depressing. I don't want you know we were talking about the numbers. Everybody's concerned about the numbers. Well the idea is what could
1:42:45 make um this this block uh better is if this isn't a surface parking lot. If it's actually buildings and places that
1:42:52 you want to go visit for whatever reason, if it's just old buildings, we lose all that parking, how do we make that up so it's within close enough
1:43:00 proximity to for people to have viable businesses in but it's undoubtedly better. We can go to and and what's the
1:43:07 most interesting place to walk around in Lake County right now?
1:43:11 Nathan, I'm going to interrupt you there because I keep hearing people say this.
1:43:15 The fact of the matter is that you guys have an agreement with Jason Strengthfellow that that's going to be a parking lot. That's all it's ever going to be. And
1:43:23 it goes or else it goes back, right? So he gets that back to purchase and he gets it back for $1.2 million.
1:43:30 Everybody's going to howl. Jason's going to be happy. And so we keep having this conversation. Jason doesn't want that land back. He wants it to be a parking
1:43:39 garage. So, we kind of throw that and I'm not being mean, but it's it's a red herring that you keep throwing that not you, but people keep throwing that in.
1:43:48 It's not an option. So, we don't have a conversation with him, but for him, it's not an option. That's not what he wants to do. That's going to be a parking lot.
1:43:58 It's or else it's going to block anyways. Okay.
1:44:01 100%. But let me counter that. And I've had plenty of discussions with Jason and he he's not he's not on the committee or anything,
1:44:09 but um it's my understanding historically the city told him no when his first idea was to build buildings.
1:44:18 No, he has there is there is an actual he he was approved he and his son was approved as I have
1:44:26 I was actually invited to maybe go in there. I've got the develop beautiful plan. I've got the development plan doesn't matter either place.
1:44:37 The walkability of seventh street is the least walkable from from seventh from Montrose to Minola is the least attractive pedestrian center downtown.
1:44:50 Okay. So it doesn't matter where you put it. You're going to have to include well street improvement. But once again, our
1:44:58 job is to come up with the best parking garage for 7th and Minnola and the best parking garage for the city hall.
1:45:03 So there I don't think there's a there's not an argument about it. I I'm just trying to emphasize the importance. It's the same thing as this mural. Have you all seen the new mural?
1:45:13 Transforms the experiences walking by that area. Okay. And so what else would you do? Well, then all of a sudden it
1:45:20 becomes really important. Um how do you close off the city hall park? This this city hall park is almost never used.
1:45:27 Okay. But it depends what what what we put um uh uh you know how we deal with the parking garage over here. And that that could influence whether it gets used or not.
1:45:38 Council just shut that down. So I said your council just shut that down. So we used was used first Friday. They would have a band out there every Friday.
1:45:46 First Fridays and every farmers market.
1:45:49 Oh well no but like is a park I mean it's used for Yeah, the grass cracker.
1:45:56 It's like, well, there's no shade. Okay. Um, and it's not interesting because if I look toward your your your block of
1:46:04 businesses, I can't see in the buildings. So, it's like a blank facade.
1:46:07 And then if I looked over on this side, it was a blank facade forever. At least now I've got paint that looks a little interesting.
1:46:14 And then and then if I look toward um the the the the south, I see all the power facilities and it's just not a place where I want.
1:46:23 If I look to city hall. I've got these nice steps, but it's always all these blinds. I was I was supposed to pull them up today actually. Um anyhow, these
1:46:32 blinds make this like a blank wall. So, it's a dead space. So, we can change what I'm saying is that just through the design elements, we can change that.
1:46:41 There's been several drawings for park.
1:46:43 Yeah, we did.
1:46:45 ugly. This we did we just had a beautiful one and it was half a million dollars and the city council just shut down a month and
1:46:54 I was like really y'all just shut that down.
1:46:55 So wait, they've already they've already paid for it or they just allocated it? No, we had a concept for um for awnings
1:47:03 over it with a stage. So a permanent stage so that you could use it all the time and um for whatever reason it's more of a lawn than it is a park.
1:47:13 It's just, you know, it's not public park would be would be generous right now.
1:47:17 Well, they were talking about putting It's no wonder it's not used right now. Right. Right. Right. But that's right.
1:47:21 But it's partially because in a downtown one of the key elements is that feeling of an outdoor room and it hasn't been
1:47:29 defined in a long time because remember when city hall was built Jets auditorium is still there, right? Yeah. So, we're not fixing that
1:47:37 today. I'm just saying that's another element to how do you deal with the parking garage on city hall. It should
1:47:45 have it should enhance the opportunity for this to be a special gathering spot which I think it will be. Right now most people say well where's city hall um
1:47:53 park like I don't know where is it you know I guess it's by the city hall but we don't need to go on on our our job is
1:48:02 just do that. So Nathan, if I could comment on something that you said that really makes sense, the Walmart parking lot analogy. That's really true. We're not building a in a Walmart parking lot.
1:48:12 In other words, we're not worried about parking close. We parked far away this asphalt parking lot. It's the ladder that you were talking about.
1:48:22 That's exactly what most people do when they come down to downtown. Like my wife and I, you know, if we go to dinner,
1:48:29 whatever, literally. If you just come up here real quick. Let's say we put the parking garage here.
1:48:35 This is the area we would come in. Let's say we're gonna Where's your Where's your shop at? Your restaurant?
1:48:41 Uh right here.
1:48:45 Right there. You're right here. So like my wife and I, we go to downtown CL for an experience. So we'd come here, we
1:48:53 would come over here, we'd walk through the walkway here, and we'd be introduced to all these businesses down here. We have dinner at your place. Never even go
1:49:02 down here, walk along here. So, it's more of an experience about drawing. If we have it here, people are drawn to all this experience, new businesses.
1:49:13 When I when people come to downtown, we're not just going to one place. We're going there for an experience. And that's I really want to try to keep the charm with it.
1:49:23 Well, I I agree with your concept.
1:49:25 That's I think you're correct. But if you came down with your wife and you had a and you had a stroller, your first you would first check to see if if that
1:49:34 parking lot across the street from me is you would not intentionally park further away on a summer night when it's 90 some
1:49:41 degrees and then walk three blocks. It would be your second choice. Correct. But it's still a choice.
1:49:46 I know. But right now we have a a parking lot that costs $125,000 to put in that's right across from my
1:49:53 business and other businesses and people will go there first. And then when that's full, then they will go to the
1:50:00 parking garage. It cost the city 14 to 16 million dollars to put up. And so if you're going to spend the money, I think
1:50:08 it's highest and best use first. It's just like, you know, it's a job of any HOA to to keep property values up.
1:50:16 That's the crazy thing about that parking lot that you bring up.
1:50:19 That parking lot will fill up before the on street parking. So the you talking about this one? Yeah. the that main parking lot fills up before the on
1:50:27 street. As easy it is to get into those parking spaces, that parking is just human nature for whatever reason. But I
1:50:36 was here went and had some sun squishies at his place the other day and I laughed because I was like, "Holy cow, that parking lot is full." But they're on
1:50:43 street parking both parallel and the other was open.
1:50:48 I think most people are probably going to the businesses that are along on the south side. No, it was just packed up.
1:50:56 I don't know what you had going on. There's a pile of people there.
1:50:59 Yeah. Well, when I come to work in the morning, sometimes I swing by the post office and as I drive down Minnola, I'm always amazed at how full that parking
1:51:08 lot is at 9:00 in the morning. And it's all employees.
1:51:12 I think we keep getting into this adversarial about which spot's better.
1:51:16 And that's not really the scope of what this committee is for. It's finding the best solution for both spots and letting council pick.
1:51:24 That's right. Just once again. So, but I think it's important that everybody have the discussions here. So, that's why I didn't want to clamp.
1:51:32 Well, essentially that job is all is mostly done. We could pull with we could pull around the edges with what either parking garage would look like whether
1:51:39 it's going to have solar panels or rooftop area like because the money's already been spent on or at least some of the research has already been done on
1:51:47 both locations as far as you know 7th of Minneapolis is the newest one but back in 2021 someone put a lot of time into
1:51:56 the one behind city hall and so there's none of us are are designers or engineers we can say all right well we
1:52:03 want we want more art, maybe we want a facade, maybe we want a rooftop or rest bit area for people to go in, things like that. But
1:52:12 what what are we going to do to either location that and that's what I'm trying when I started out talking earlier, it's like what are the parameters we have to
1:52:20 decide if both locations already have an existing plan in place that need to be tweaked obviously for aesthetics and
1:52:28 things like that, but I'm not a road engineer. I don't know if it's better to empty out the seventh of Miniola garage on 7th or whether it should all go out
1:52:36 on Minneapolis. I don't know. It's not my it's not my purview and I have no experience in that. So, I don't think anyone here does.
1:52:43 So, aside from recommending maybe by a consensus vote which one would be the best location, it's like what is our what is our job in 60 days?
1:52:52 And that's what I'm worried. I don't want to have study after study done because that's already been done. What what's our job in 60 days?
1:52:58 Let's let's Yeah, let's let's There's a couple that there's a lot there. First thing is that uh the job
1:53:06 isn't to say uh necessarily which one's better.
1:53:09 Yes, it's to come up with plans and estimates and and give your reasoning why you chose the plans you you came up with.
1:53:18 Right. So that's it's not here's one, this is what you got to do. It's no here are your options.
1:53:25 Well, you've done this a long time, right? Um well, if we were to say we don't like any plan on like we don't like the existing plan for 7th of Mola, we want a new plan.
1:53:34 That's right.
1:53:35 How long would that take to develop a new plan? Go out because it wouldn't be it wouldn't be foc
1:53:44 as as an example. I was involved in the most recent in the the 821
1:53:51 I was involved in the design process helping guide that in that case. Um, those were all concepts. That wasn't
1:54:00 like a those weren't architectural drawings for even though it was add precise detail. That was a concept. That was a very heightened level of concept.
1:54:08 We could come up with something less than that. Um, but remember, we're they're going to see the different concepts and then uh they're going to have to make a decision about okay.
1:54:19 Oh, let me back up. You don't know. We didn't talk about this before.
1:54:23 We're the intention of the council is to put out an RFP for someone who's going to build a parking garage and
1:54:32 potentially do a partnership whatever they're going to put out an RFP for somebody to build something after us right
1:54:38 after us to see you know if there is someone going to be able to come in with a real bid just like Finnfrock came and
1:54:46 said we want to be able to do that. I expect FinTrock and others to be in that RFP. So, they're not going to be involved in our process. I know that
1:54:55 sounds crazy, but that's that's a legal thing that would potentially disqualify them from participating. We want them to be able to participate in that. But we
1:55:04 have an RFI out. Correct me if I'm wrong, Z, but we have an RFI out right now for someone who's simply going to be
1:55:12 able to provide technical expertise in detailing what that RFP is going to say.
1:55:19 Okay, that's that's my understanding of how it works. So that's not our job.
1:55:24 What we can do, our biggest thing is to raise the issues. Okay, and that is is you you've you've already raised a bunch
1:55:31 of questions that we don't know answers to today, but we need to get those. We have the flexibility as a committee to spend money to get some answers that are
1:55:40 ballpark answers in a relatively short amount of time. We have Do you have a concept of what we would spend that money on?
1:55:46 Um, we could spend the money on visualization. So, somebody is actually going to be respond. It'd be ideal if the same person that's doing the visualization on seventh is the same.
1:56:00 And you do do we have a so so you were saying that the seventh
1:56:07 they came back at a lower price because some of that can it was already pre-constructed.
1:56:13 So, Frock specializes in is pre-cast, right, sections.
1:56:19 And so instead of trying to design a very custom here's your ramps, here's, you
1:56:28 know, your parameters, Bren Brock worked with the city and said, "Hey, you know, if you sketch this out and you do it
1:56:35 this way, here's how you maximize this at the least amount of money." If for those who don't know, I'm fairly conservative fiscally when it comes to
1:56:44 that stuff. And that was important to me was to get the most garage. For me, I am
1:56:50 I was a maximum garage. Let's see how many parking spaces we can get in here.
1:56:56 Let's make sure that we've got um plenty of of handicap. We get a lot of complaints of the handicap and where
1:57:04 it's at being downhill. That's one of the things I love about the Seventh Miniola is that it's right in that heart. You can really go over to Sun
1:57:13 Creek and not have to go downhill. You can still get to Montro and not have to go up the hill. Um and so as a council
1:57:20 member, I had a lot of complaints about the way our step was set up. Um there's things that you don't see on here with
1:57:27 walkability. Um having the east west corridor and Patrick has agreed to run it up through his tie back into Montros.
1:57:37 Longterm, something's going to end up happening with the post office property.
1:57:42 I mean, that's that's already well over its useful age. Um, that will be bought way over here. Um, it's possible to
1:57:51 bring that east west all the way over to West Avenue. So, you'd be able to go walk from West.
1:58:00 Yeah. So Patrick's already essentially agreed to bring this all the way across here because the
1:58:08 walkways already here. He's going to bring it through here and kind of kitty corner it up to Montrose. Depending on what happens with this big piece of
1:58:16 property, you can bring it all the way across and you'd essentially have I believe from one side to the other along with the artwalk if you get to the Hoya
1:58:23 property from north to south. There's some really cool concepts, but you can't get there. We have to build a garage.
1:58:31 The stuff city put in an offer on that property. It's a reasonable offer. It was a fair market
1:58:39 value offer and just haven't taken it yet. So, are we ever going to get a full north south
1:58:47 um art lock? We don't know that. You know, hopefully, sure. But what is the de Hoya property going to look like?
1:58:53 Certainly smart money is to wrap it up the art walk across West Minnola and
1:59:01 have an entrance or have something on the other along with a beautiful facade overlooking away. It's the most valuable piece of property in downtown Clermont.
1:59:09 But is it fair to say that the parking garage behind this building
1:59:18 is more expensive for fewer spots? the way it was designed. Yes. Could Brent prop do something different? Okay.
1:59:26 Probably. Yeah. So, that could be modified if this because it sounds like 375. So, they were getting 125 spots per
1:59:35 floor. So, if we could go as high as what we could theoretically get more parking spots right there in theory.
1:59:44 It just would have to be redesigned. And then I I agree with the walkability and then the conversation will be and we
1:59:51 all know this will be water capacity. So water capacity on this side of Montro
2:00:00 goes to center lake and water capacity on that side of Montro goes to um Victory Point.
2:00:09 So that's depending on capacity over here. Can that affect it as far as the footprint? And it does. And that's
2:00:17 something that is beyond, you know, I'm not an engineer. I don't know what that is. Todd, do you remember why the city council
2:00:25 didn't do a parking garage sale on like what was the Was it just the money?
2:00:29 It was the It was really, really expensive and they just never landed on it.
2:00:33 Well, I'm sure it's not cheaper now, but is it that was it just the money?
2:00:36 It was the money and the concept of not being able to go all the way up. They just couldn't get Again, you're hurting cats. just kept kicking the can down the road.
2:00:44 Nobody wanted to spend the money.
2:00:46 Nobody wanted nobody wanted to be that council member that said, "I did it to be It seems like back then there was a solution for it and the solution wasn't
2:00:53 taken." And I I heard about the same thing about the vault that the fabled vault. I love to know it's actually there, not underneath the
2:01:01 There is. Oh, yeah. Yeah. So, there is there is a water vault over there. Yeah.
2:01:05 Exactly where it's located. I do not know. Um the conversation was that it would be adjacent Um exactly where it's at, we don't know.
2:01:15 But you would have to deal with a water ball. But is the waterfall big enough to expand that parking area as well because if you're impervious space grows, you
2:01:24 have to have capacity. So that capacity conversation has not been had that I know of. But I mean, yeah, for the for the city
2:01:32 council, if they really wanted to go, if they are going to vote, regardless of what we say, for it to go behind city hall, that's fine. but it's going to be
2:01:40 more expensive. And I'd like to know the true reasons and why it wasn't done to begin with because essentially if the if
2:01:48 it's the if it's the inclination of the current city council to put it behind city hall to maybe have the least
2:01:55 offensive parking garage you can have, right? Then this job is already done for us. We can then we can talk about what it's going to look like and maybe the
2:02:03 special features it may have updated to current things. But right now, I don't know why we don't have a parking garage under construction behind city hall.
2:02:14 That's my it. And if there's a real fundamental reason aside from the money, then we as a group should know that so
2:02:22 we don't spend our time and do all this brain damage and arguing back and forth about which location is best. If the true location really should be behind city hall.
2:02:31 Question for you. And then we can just as high as city hall is, how many floors could you build to at least match the height of city?
2:02:40 Probably on this one probably four.
2:02:44 Um and and I think that the nice four and then you park. So that one was five. This one four.
2:02:52 Okay. Um so net three and I well right now say three. Um, I think some of this the interesting part
2:02:59 that goes through this is there's a lot of moving pieces and a lot of moving parts. I am of the firm belief
2:03:07 and I'm not opposed to it being back here, but I'm also of the firm belief that 7th and Mola is better long-term
2:03:16 knowing where development is going to go. That's my personal belief. Um, I have had arguments with Allison over this.
2:03:25 I'm sure I disagree with with Nathan on this. Um, but from a future growth standpoint, I think that is a better
2:03:34 location. Um, and I think that's the argument that we have to go through. We have four business owners here.
2:03:41 Yeah. So, we have four business owners who who are all going to bring a unique perspective from a unique business. And
2:03:48 I think that's for us to all land on, you know, we're not all going to agree.
2:03:54 There's going to be somebody in this committee that's going to be like, "Ah, they all suck." And that's fine. Um, but ultimately, we just need to be able to
2:04:02 try to move in a direction. And, um, you know, like I said, I'm not opposed to it being back here.
2:04:10 I've been through a little bit more time, effort, energy on this one over here. So, I mean, I obviously have no police, but if this one turns out to be
2:04:19 the committee, I mean, I'd stand behind it to say, "Yeah, I was on that committee. This is where the committee went." Had some disagreements, but this ultimately was the best location. And I think we have to move that.
2:04:28 If I if I may, like I think we keep getting hung up on why hasn't the garage been built before? And as somebody who watches city council religiously, it is
2:04:37 very hard to figure out exactly where they're going. And that is that is current city council.
2:04:43 This is this city council is completely different to the one that took the decisions that they made before. So, who knows how they would have voted if they had had this proposal for this particular parking garage behind here.
2:04:54 Regardless, our job again is not about the placement of the garage or the best spot is to think of the best design that
2:05:01 tie the best with downtown for that specific spot. And I think we're getting uh we keep getting hung up on that. And
2:05:08 cost is important, but it is not the only important factor. I would say the aesthetic of the place is very important. The reason why uh Mr. Patrick
2:05:16 Bianke got that development approved in Western Plaza is because it looks beautiful.
2:05:22 Like there is a lot of utility when a a building looks beautiful like a building that is ugly can't just break the the experience of Yeah. So
2:05:30 I mean I agree with everything you're saying and I think I came in here and probably it sounds like you too. I don't have a dog in fight. I don't care. Like
2:05:38 I I want the best site, but but inherently I can't see how the city
2:05:46 the parking garage behind this building is inherently better if it's smaller.
2:05:51 And I also wasn't impressed with the look of it to be honest. The Seventh Street, the renderings looked better. Like they're more interesting.
2:05:59 They're newer.
2:06:01 Okay. Yeah. Yeah, they're newer and and I just think that's but also I would say subjected to I 100% I'm not sure anybody's going to say
2:06:09 that's a beautiful parking garage it looks good but you're not going to say wow I you know I love that structure but I do think like the art the use of
2:06:18 the artwork and then whatever else we come up with but if if they could show me a visualization which I know we have money for
2:06:25 of the city hall that was bigger and beautiful I like I think I could be pulled there because like typically we came down for
2:06:34 food truck. I parked on fifth as far away as I could by the church in the church parking lot and walk.
2:06:42 I'm okay with that. Um but I don't think I'm the normal person. I think the normal person is going to circle until
2:06:49 they find the closest spot, you know, but what I'm looking for is biggest bang for buck and the beauty element, too.
2:06:58 Right now it seems obvious that Seven Street has that has both and that's part of the job this committee is to design them.
2:07:07 Okay.
2:07:07 So create what they are. So whatever they are right now they can change entirely and all's purpose is to design. Yeah. That helps. Yeah.
2:07:15 I I will make an observation. It's clear based upon what we've heard today. I think that cost is something that's very
2:07:24 important. Okay. We knew that coming in, but we also know it's important moving forward. Okay? You all don't have to make the decision about whether it's going to be, you know, paid for or not.
2:07:35 Um, you just have to come up with the the best thing. And I would recommend based upon what I've heard is that you do give an option, which is if we want
2:07:44 to maximize the amount of parking we can get for the dollar, this is what we would do. I think you also need to look
2:07:51 at it as I'm not going to go into it right now. This is objectively like I can come up with objective reasons why this is uglier than what has been done
2:08:00 by the thin frock proposal. Okay, there are different elements that make you say gh that doesn't feel good. I'm not going to go into that but it's obvious. So you
2:08:08 had that gut reaction. So the gut reaction would be what if we had something that was if I own the land across the street I'm excited that it's coming in.
2:08:18 Yes. I wouldn't be too excited if this were right across the street from It looks very utilitarian. 1980s Boca Raton.
2:08:27 It's pretty good. You're just kind of like, okay. All right.
2:08:32 So, um, so I I want to try to uh wrap things up sooner than later once you get
2:08:40 but but we need to elect a chairman, a vice chairman to run the future meetings. What are the duties of the chairman, the vice chair?
2:08:49 Uh they will uh serve as the essentially the moderators of uh the future
2:08:56 meetings. I didn't mean to inject myself so much. I just wanted to try to be efficient about raising the different issues um and get us on a good track
2:09:05 which I think we're in a better position than when we started. But regardless, the idea is that yeah, they would essentially guide the conversation. may
2:09:13 not be any different from what we had today, but um we were tasked in the resolution to identify a cheer person and a vice chair person.
2:09:24 So um does anybody want to make a Nobody's volunteering. So we got to nominate.
2:09:34 You're not perfect.
2:09:35 I'll defer it to Yeah, you just have to do a nomination. I'll nominate um Broky to be chairman.
2:09:44 I would second.
2:09:45 I don't know the rules, but I'll do my best.
2:09:47 Yeah. So, so you get a nomination, a second, and then take a vote. Oh, so you got a second.
2:09:52 You got a second from whom? So, we're second I'm chair of much of a committee, so
2:09:59 it's it's not our Okay. So, do we take a vote? Take a take a vote. All in favor?
2:10:06 All in favor? I I'll make a nomination for Keith to be vice chair.
2:10:13 Second. All in favor?
2:10:22 What are the perf? You get the part in the building.
2:10:27 You will be the guy who has to give the presentation.
2:10:31 Well, Rocky the Stapano is the one who led the committee. I hear there's a budget and I don't see sandwiches.
2:10:36 I didn't tell you that we're going to have a dedicated parking spot for the chairman parking garage.
2:10:42 So special technical, you know. It's funny because like we've come downtown twice in the last three weeks and then
2:10:49 somewhere else because we really couldn't find parking, you know. So it's like odd because like I I think there's two like several problems.
2:10:59 The sneaky parking spot. I'm going to get away my sneaky park. That's the customer being have a parking problem.
2:11:05 That's fine. Everybody can know. Most people know about it. So the sneaky parking spot is actually parked in the essentially the dirt lot next between the boat house and victory point and
2:11:14 that puts you right there on the path check and then you come in. So for me, I live off 12 street. So that's my always if I
2:11:22 know it's busy here, if I'm coming down for like food truck or or you know farmers market stuff, I just park there.
2:11:29 I know I don't even have to look. I can pull right in there. Boom. I'm there.
2:11:32 I'm here to walk around. What's What do you see at your business as far as like do you get that? Do you feel like you lose customers business?
2:11:39 Uh I I don't feel like I lose. Uh my customers love walking all of downtown.
2:11:46 So we get a lot of foot traffic of people who been from Costa Nostra or farther down uh the wine shop. We have
2:11:55 people who come all the way over to our side of town after they visited you with their wine. Things like that.
2:12:02 It it really depends upon what business you're in.
2:12:05 Cuz a cup of coffee is open. So he's got it's less of an issue. A case of wine is 38.
2:12:17 Talk to the sit.
2:12:23 They need to make all of the on street parking two hours or less and that will stop employees from parking out there.
2:12:30 Well, you never park in front of your business. You park in front of your neighbor's business. That's a downtown tradition.
2:12:39 CRA into the parking conversation allows them to start making those rules and those recommendations and that that's the ideal way to do it and Nathan
2:12:46 touched on that earlier was that there h somebody has to start managing.
2:12:50 Is it the CRA or there has been four parking downtown at least twice in the last 30 years. They
2:12:58 put the signs up, it ruined them. They took them down. They put them up. Uh so it's it's gone back and forth.
2:13:06 They did it two hour.
2:13:08 They may been two. Yeah. Because the sewing store had three-hour classes and the women by the time they unloaded
2:13:16 their sewing machines and came in and sewed, they had to go move their car. So it it was sewing store is gone now. So I mean it's really industry specific.
2:13:26 Um you have several if you have two hours pick an hour two three four that means somebody has to monitor it.
2:13:35 Sure.
2:13:35 So do you have a police officer who can come downtown every three hours and pass out bicycle and
2:13:43 I mean there's there's money to be made. usually.
2:13:49 All right. Now, when do we when and how do we meet?
2:13:55 All right. And and I'll Yeah.
2:13:59 The intent was to meet weekly at the same time. This group, unlike the Bishop
2:14:06 Field Committee, actually can be here at a particular time where it doesn't have a conflict. If we could have this
2:14:14 meeting every week at this set time that would be ideal. Um I guess is it possible to zoom in or or in case we are out of town?
2:14:24 Uh I think it is. We can. Yes, we have that capability. So yes, in fact next week I'm going to be at a funeral so I can't
2:14:33 be here um for it. That's okay. Zayn will be here. I'm sure Dan Matis will probably try to get people as well um
2:14:40 from a staff perspective but uh the idea is every week and so what we can sort of map out is and right now it's up to you
2:14:48 all this is your committee um I originally thought we would go walk out right now um we can do that or and I can
2:14:56 do it informally if you want but they otherwise that's that's not going to work well but oh let me let me put this we should
2:15:05 either here or we all go on a walk. I'm hesitant to go on a walk without you all having the opportunity to have access to
2:15:14 the the resources that we talked about today so that you can sort of essentially do a little homework better
2:15:22 understand you know the size of the sites what people have said in the past. So we can give you a little more context. And then
2:15:29 what you can do next week is uh when you meet is try to identify, you know, confirm as a group all those issues that you think should be resolved. Okay?
2:15:41 Whether it's questions you have or a category of concern.
2:15:46 It's clear we're going to worry about cost. We're going to worry about um you know the number, the height, whatever it may be. But come up with your list. So
2:15:54 that I think that's going to be helpful for the council to see, oh, okay, they they looked at this and then and then so the identification of all the questions
2:16:03 that have to be answered would be helpful if you can mail that down by next week because essentially what you want to be in a position of doing is
2:16:11 being able to ask for help after next week for consultants or anybody else that needs to be engaged immediately so
2:16:19 that we can get meet the 60-day deadline. Does that make sense or No, if I want to put something out to the Can I just email everybody?
2:16:27 No.
2:16:30 So, what do I get a city hall address or something?
2:16:37 There's not really a mechanism to do that. It would have to be publicly done here. Um, if there's something information you want delivered, what you
2:16:46 can do is you can deliver it to staff and print it out and deliver it at the meeting. Um, but it would you'd essentially be very very it's very gray.
2:16:58 So I would not recommend.
2:16:59 Can can we send an email to people with information like you or me send it to them?
2:17:04 You can send it directly to staff. Uh, we cannot. No, that's using a third party to distribute information.
2:17:11 Can we distribute information without if it's independently sourced? So like me saying we're gonna send you certain
2:17:19 things during this meeting. I'm allowed to send them certain things.
2:17:22 We are absolutely allowed but he can't send it to you and then you send it to all of us. Yes. Okay. Got it.
2:17:28 Although you could give you could present it to us at an open meeting.
2:17:35 My point is that that gives us seven more meetings that there's seven more meetings to wrap this up.
2:17:41 That actually the the council meeting it's supposed to be at will be September 22nd.
2:17:50 So five that's not 60 days but
2:17:58 no create and I so like I I'm ready to make requests today as far as like I want to
2:18:06 know what's wrong with that site. I want to know if there's a ball under it. So if we can if we're going to recommend that like and can we recommend that can
2:18:14 we suggest Then start evaluating the grass or the they can't be involved. Who's our backup? Nobody.
2:18:21 So who would be the backfinder here?
2:18:25 It's then going to end up being staff because if you bring in a thin frock and they can't thin frock poisons the well. They can't
2:18:34 bid on it and you're not going to and you definitely Benrock is the biggest garage builder around here and they do the
2:18:41 cast. We do not want city council even beyond us can't say to henfrock we want you to do this scratch I thought we
2:18:53 get to it's not going to yeah well we can get these the questions you have likely been raised in the past
2:19:00 and we will coordinate with our other staff who are very familiar with what happened then and if we can't find the answers then we can reach out to those
2:19:08 who we know are not going to be part of the RFP in communicating. You said communicate with staff. Yes. What what email address?
2:19:15 So, you can email me or Nathan. Okay.
2:19:18 Um and we will get it to the correct party if you want the answer. Okay.
2:19:22 Um and we'll we'll get answers for you and your response will be get your email address.
2:19:26 Yeah. I'll send it all to you. I'm CC on everything that was sent out. Okay.
2:19:30 So, anything is it don't send it just to Z and don't send it just to me. Send it to us both.
2:19:37 But, but this is a fair ass like Yes.
2:19:41 And and we would have to make basically you have to nominate that question and then be second, right? No.
2:19:48 Just add it to the agenda for only motions is those kind of things.
2:19:51 I'm just saying if we have five meetings, Rocky to get to come up with even if we even if we all agreed it's going to be one location the other. Five
2:19:58 weeks is a lot is a short amount of time to say, "All right, well, we all agree that it's a part it's a city hall site.
2:20:04 We're still not paying." That's not even your job.
2:20:06 Well, no. I'm saying maybe the best two sites as fast as possible. But even if we have to go now we have to address we have to engage Finnfrock for any changes we would like
2:20:15 to see to make the best suggestion for seventh min right no so a brand new firm yes that has to come into this and evaluate
2:20:24 the only thing we have no we're just making the recommendation and then they send it out to a bunch of fit
2:20:37 from an angle can you Yeah, we have firms on that.
2:20:46 Yeah, we're just saying we know the the city hall site is the best site. Here's
2:20:52 what we wanted to show the best of both sites, the city.
2:20:59 Right. Right. So, I think that's what we need to figure out for next meeting is we're going to look at these two sites.
2:21:04 We think that the garage should look like this. It should incorporate these key functions on both sides.
2:21:10 On both sides and then we go back to Zane. Zayn gets with our our staff or our vendors that are on retainer
2:21:17 when we say to design when we say our job is to recommend changes to both sites or what both sites should look like not either not which site is best.
2:21:26 Correct.
2:21:26 So how do we without using Finrock and without using any without talking to anybody directly that's city staff's job. Do we in a paragraph say we would
2:21:35 like a parking garage to have these aesthetic features and and and whatever else we can come up with and that's the
2:21:43 extent of what we submit because well that that's that's our next week and then staff would then in the week leading up to our next meeting we would
2:21:51 hopefully have some drawings to us to review and go this looks good we like this we don't like this change that we want yes
2:21:59 but but I would think we start these are no these are fresh designs Yeah, we can't use Finn Frog's design.
2:22:05 So, no, you could, but you can't talk to Finn Frog. You can go, okay, I'd like Finn Froerence that design with other designers, but we have a request for information.
2:22:13 You have a request for information out, right? Or that's right, for somebody else, but it's not our job to be perfect. It's our job to give concepts of what you would like to see.
2:22:23 You should have we should have two or three minimum two concepts for each location.
2:22:27 I think a good idea exercise. No, no. A picture essentially it's going to look something like this. That's it. That's
2:22:35 what the designer is going to do. It's a conceptual design.
2:22:39 I was wondering that's right. We're not going to get into how do we how do we get our concepts into reality?
2:22:48 So, what we can do is if everyone wants to individually send us what your ideas are over the next week, we can have them all.
2:23:01 everyone else's ideas. Yeah.
2:23:09 Over email for the next week. Uh so we can discuss those. So whatever priorities are, please do not CC anyone else on the uh emails.
2:23:17 Well, we we were all we were all blind copy, so we're all good. Beautiful.
2:23:20 Yeah. So sort of how this started, just so y'all know where I came from on this.
2:23:26 Well, that's a beautiful garage. So this is the garage. This is the garage I started with. All that black.
2:23:33 So this is a this is done out of laminated wood. Um so it was a really cool concept. I went super deep into
2:23:42 this. This is where started. This is what my concept was to have a Seventh Street. It was like this is cool. People
2:23:49 are going to drive here to see it. It's the coolest garage I've ever seen. It's never been built by the way. It was a concept.
2:23:57 But anyway, um, so I think some of what we can do is say, hey, you know, we we
2:24:04 like these architecture pieces that can go on these. So, back to what you were talking about is, you know, do we like
2:24:13 it? Do we like the glass? Do we, you know, there are different things and you can think outside of the box. How do we put um pieces onto it? But like I said,
2:24:23 this was where I started with a parking garage and um yeah, so there's lots of
2:24:32 stuff out there. Uh but yeah, looking at it from a sustainable wood structure and
2:24:39 so there was a cool factor to it. Nobody had ever done and then one other thing I want to share as well.
2:24:47 I'm in Exactly.
2:24:49 In my line of work, we do resort conference style hotels which include parking structures. Our current
2:24:56 price right now is about 20 to $25,000 per parking stall for a cast in place.
2:25:03 So that's different than Finn Frog's pre-cast where they just bring in panels that get bolted together into the structural steel that just
2:25:12 So when you get into the weeds of like it looks like this, it's got some weird designs into it. Then you're starting to
2:25:21 cast in place and then that number gets there. So you said 365 spots that's $7.5 million at $20,000 installed. So just
2:25:31 for reference what was that for 20 20 to 25,000 23.5 Yeah.
2:25:40 Okay.
2:25:40 And that's from Well Building Company which is one of the largest builders here.
2:25:44 Do we need to add our discussion whether we feel it should be free or I don't think so.
2:25:53 Yeah, I think that that comes out.
2:25:56 That's the city council will have to worry about that.
2:25:58 So, where I where I landed on that was to send that back over to the CRA because the CRA oversees downtown and if they want to
2:26:07 make those recommendations, if they want to charge for it, let's just put that in their lap and that way we don't have to be the bad guys.
2:26:14 But there's going to be an argument over whether I think people There needs to be a level of a
2:26:22 No, it should be everywhere. Even at the at the beach, like when I'm out running in the morning, it is full of people that are there running and biking. And if you look, they're all they're all county.
2:26:32 What's what's Winter Park or Winter Garden?
2:26:34 It's all free, but it's it's a totally you get what you pay for.
2:26:39 Well, I think you like what's what works required, you know? I think we kind of have to discount
2:26:46 their part. C can I ask? So, and this is more just personal. So, when the hotel gets built,
2:26:55 what is their required parking? Are they going to use the parking garage? Can we charge them to use the like it's going
2:27:02 to pay us $3,000 per So, he has per spot. So, he has no parking required.
2:27:08 Then he'll park use up that parking. I mean, it's a great deal for him. So, how do we change it?
2:27:14 That's council. Oh, we need parking management.
2:27:18 So that's as as an example. So if that hotel doesn't get built and how many hotel rooms anybody know?
2:27:28 It's small. It's a boutique. Like 30 or 40 probably under 50.
2:27:32 Yeah. I thought it was 48, but it's it's it's one parking spot for roof.
2:27:36 Which side is this? It'll be all of on top of It'll be on top on top of where street
2:27:45 around to Montress Mont.
2:27:50 So if he has no park his way out of it, you can buy your way out of it. And this process will bring realistic
2:28:00 value to the park. You know, the cost of parking $3,000 not going to cover the In hindsight,
2:28:08 it's price cheap. What I'm saying is that if he's maxed out 30 30 boutique hotel rooms, staff of four or five at
2:28:16 any one time, that's 40. But let's just say it's 40 spots a night. Where are those people going to park? Are they going to park at
2:28:24 the at the parking structure behind city hall three and a half blocks away or are they going to park in the in the seventh mini flat parking space and take up all
2:28:33 that spots all the spots for all the all the customs? I believe there's a conversation benefit agreement that
2:28:40 needs to park that. So I don't answer. Okay.
2:28:46 They can valet it and put the parts in the garage. Okay.
2:28:50 And that's where I would that's where because we had they had an agreement with with Clermont Brewing Company with the church across the street.
2:29:00 That's how they got approved. And then that changed when the church decided to build school and they lost a lot of their spots. So now all that got dumped
2:29:09 out onto the street or elsewhere. I assume they would park in the city hall parking garage or they park there now.
2:29:15 So that's I mean these agreements are are they're not static or they they they're not permanent. they're kind of
2:29:23 flu they they're flexible down the road when and another agreement is made for
2:29:30 additional you know like I said they had the church and then then they didn't so just so everybody knows the parking
2:29:37 fee was and the reason the parking fee got put in there was to allow businesses to
2:29:46 expand. So, what we wanted to be able to do was um any of these singlestory buildings to be able to go up to a second story that easily
2:29:55 and not have to deal with parking issues. And some of this comes into the CRA. What's the CRA's rate on taxes?
2:30:04 It's significantly higher 10%.
2:30:07 It's Yeah, significantly higher CRA or 10 mil. I think it's a 10 mil.
2:30:11 And so, it's the same tax bill.
2:30:15 It's just that the C Yeah. So, by increasing that CRA revenue, it helps with that
2:30:22 that parking garage. And that's why I lean on having the CRA manage it is because it comes in under them. And
2:30:31 that way, the people who are the taxing agent and the people who are running the parking are the same people and they have to balance their budget that way.
2:30:42 So there there was a a method behind that madness um to allow management all in one spot and oversee
2:30:51 it and they're responsible. So if they say we don't want to charge for parking, well they're going to have to figure out how to come up with that thousand, you
2:30:58 know, $10,000 a month for the parking garage because some of this is going to get bonded. I mean
2:31:06 city council is not going to come off $12 million. They're just not. So, you know, maybe they do six and they bond six and they go, you know,
2:31:14 was the parking fee conceptualized with the idea that there would be a parking garage one day downtown or
2:31:23 let CRA and when the conversations with friend was that have it built so that the technologies
2:31:32 there some of what Nathan was getting to so that you can say as use increases prices go up. So you have that
2:31:39 fluctuating um and you can build that into whatever system you have there.
2:31:46 Is the CRA allowed to run parking structure?
2:31:50 Yeah, it's their I mean in the old days there were only certain things the CRA could do by by statute and I didn't know running
2:32:00 parking structures. Are you reinsured for that?
2:32:03 I don't know. It's the CRA. The state may resolve the CRA. Either way, it's their dollars. CPT says yes.
2:32:11 So, it's their dollars. Then it must be true.
2:32:13 Yeah. So, it's their dollars. They're the ones who have to control it. But, so going back to the reason that we set it
2:32:19 at 3,000 was to a let's get some movement on these other little
2:32:26 buildings. Um 3,000 was an easy number and the idea was that if we could
2:32:32 increase the value of existing buildings by increasing the height that we could increase the dollars going into the CRA
2:32:41 which could then fund more parking. So there it wasn't a there was kind of a a longer term look at it but I know that
2:32:50 3,000 does sound low. in in the 90s it was 1500 and downtown was depressed so they did
2:32:57 away with it to encourage business to come downtown and then what 2000 something you brought back to I think you need to write a history book
2:33:05 so it's it's going on here how how many current parking spots are we already answered that at seven
2:33:15 so what about right now currently behind about the same because we have to factor And well, you're losing 100.
2:33:24 Well, and if we build at city hall, kind of Jason develops his, we lose that, too.
2:33:32 Maybe not immediately, but Jason may not want to develop it and the agreement will end up it's just going to be a parking lot. That's why I would Well, that's the thing, too.
2:33:42 Just that the if the city builds this garage and Jason doesn't want to do it, highest and best use is not a surface lot. the
2:33:50 city sell that lot to somebody who can sell it.
2:33:53 He has an agreement with it. So there is a Well, that's the thing. If Jason doesn't want to do it, just because you have an agreement doesn't mean agreements can change.
2:34:01 He has to agree to make That's what I'm saying. I mean, there there's that could always happen down the road, right?
2:34:06 No, I mean my my thought I guess my thinking is he would buy it back and then develop it because that would be good.
2:34:14 But remember, if he does that and we lose the Hoya property to whatever development goes in there, that's almost 200 spots in the heart of where people
2:34:22 shop and eat. Now at that point though, you probably have enough revenue to justify additional parks and structures. So
2:34:30 it's taken 10 years even to get this far. I don't think a second structure I might be, you know, the whole thing.
2:34:39 Does he own the old police station? He sure does.
2:34:42 The old post office. I mean, we're just I mean, I'm just We have talked to the guy on the post office. So like I said, Does the post office not own that?
2:34:51 No. So, it's a guy out of Jersey. Oh, it's a ground.
2:34:53 It's an old guy out of Jersey who's like, "Well, you know, why don't you just uh imminent domain?" And I'm like,
2:35:00 "No, we're not imminent doing the post office. All right. Are we done?
2:35:08 I I I think we're done unless uh you know, you guys want to have a conversation or anything else?" I'd like to add one last thing. Uh, I
2:35:16 think a good exercise going into the next meeting will be kind of think about it as we're building a garage no matter what on both sites.
2:35:26 What features do you want to see in both of those sites to make it the best garage possible? Don't worry about the
2:35:33 cost at this point. What is your key features you want on those sites?
2:35:40 And it's funny because that might be the recommendation I would come up with. You need two girls right now. You know both, you know.
2:35:48 Well, that's fine. But you also believe in unicorns. That's right. I do.
2:35:53 You guys say like, "Okay, we're going to get a a visualization overnight or something." It takes a while for somebody to come up a designer to come
2:36:02 up with what is a real worry with five.
2:36:06 So, once again, it just it just means that it's uh what's the designer want?
2:36:11 The designer wants you to tell them what your priorities are. They don't want you to say, "I want the best looking garage of all time at the very cheapest cost." Okay? Remember, what is it? Good.
2:36:23 You know, you can have good cheap and fast and get two out of the three. So, they need good direction. That's why I
2:36:30 was trying to focus on just what are those criteria? What do you want to say about each one of them? Um and and and
2:36:38 and so go look at them, think about them. Um but I don't think we have anything else to discuss today. And I don't want to walk the site right now.
2:36:47 Um we're all going to walk out the door.
2:36:50 You're going to see it. Take a right when you leave the parking lot. You'll see the other site.
2:36:54 No, it's not just seeing. It's it's understanding the context of how it impacts um the properties around it.
2:37:01 Just in the same way that if we looked at the uh you know, when we look at the visual they've already done. They're
2:37:08 not, you know, they're not uh you wouldn't want to have your building
2:37:15 across the street and some on some of the sides of those. You'd like the parking, but you may not like the structure and what it does to your business or your home.
2:37:24 Tim, I didn't need clarification. That walkway that go in front of your building from garage to your five foot walkway in front of yours is 18 ft.
2:37:34 18 ft.
2:37:34 Yep. So there'd be a 10ft dedicated paver with grass strip on each side or whatever on each side. So there'd be 18 total feet.
2:37:45 So it wouldn't be on top of your Okay. So I think you guys can just motion to adjurnn.
2:37:52 Second. Favor.
2:38:02 This is who knew parking would be this much fun.