Parking garage meeting transcript 8/20/26

0:03 And I think our first act is to look at and approve the minutes
0:15 and chairman if you could sign them as well. Copy that. Thank you.
0:19 Motion to approve minutes from August 13, 2026.
0:24 First and a second. All those in favor say I. Any opposed?
0:33 And then from there we go into uh discussion of design priorities. And I think
0:41 yes. So uh I sent you all an email uh yesterday morning uh with lots of information, a lot of uh older studies
0:50 uh the information on the Pinfrock site and the city hall site. And um I asked you to send me whatever priorities you
0:58 have, top five. Um and I got some of them and I'm going to go over them and it I tried to shorten them um to make it so there no duplicates and it was
1:07 concise. And if anyone's priorities that I listed on there are not accurately representing um what you said, let me
1:15 know and I will adjust it uh on here. So um these are what we're going to be voting on today. Um uh and it is
1:24 accessibility to downtown uh flow of traffic, security, number of spaces, maximization of spaces while keeping the
1:33 beauty of downtown, mixed use, uh ADA accessibility, alternative parking methods, substation for fire/ police,
1:43 design matching current downtown aesthetics, reduction of pedestrian hostility, flat level retrofitable
1:50 garage, intentional artwork with Claremont roots uh making it lined uh
1:58 attractive design blending in uh top level to be shaded uh full-size parking spaces so the size of the parking spaces
2:07 versus the amount of parking spaces um solar panels and retail on ground level.
2:14 So some of those are similar to duplicates but there's a little nuance in between them. So um that's the extent
2:19 of it. So, uh I I think do you want to open up for discussion? What's what's pedestrian hostility? Same.
2:27 Yeah. Yeah. Um do you want to take that one?
2:31 Uh yeah. So, uh we kind of consider our downtown between seventh and eighth in Montrose in Minnola. That's the square.
2:41 Uh and people walking around that square. Um, we want to build the parking garage
2:48 structure if it goes into that square in a way where it doesn't impact the pedestrian walking. Uh, because there
2:56 could be potential blind spots and things like that. So, we just want to be uh intentional with the design with pedestrians in mind.
3:06 Okay.
3:10 Uh, but no, like I can I can walk diagonally through the parking lot to get to the post office.
3:19 So if a parking structure goes there, I'll I'll have to do a right angle. But is that considered hostile or are you thinking about blind spots where I might get get by a car?
3:29 Yeah. So like as the cars are exiting the parking garage, uh you you have blind spots from the sidewalks.
3:36 Okay.
3:38 Any other ones that anybody has questions about? all pretty straightforward, I think.
3:46 Cool.
3:48 Um, and one thing I I want to note is uh I think last meeting there was a little bit of confusion about the resolution. Thank you.
3:56 So, specifically the resolution is to create designs for the sites, not to pick out a location.
4:02 And I state this because it's specifically related to the designs of what we're doing and what works best on each site. Um, and so I bring that up
4:11 just to make sure that we're all in alignment.
4:14 And that was one question I had. I I thought last meeting we were kind of debating two things,
4:20 which on reading the motion at first. I did think we were to do both, make a recommendation
4:28 and provide the best possible use for both. But I think that clears it up for us. Our job is really to do the best
4:37 presentation for both sites and then present both to the city council.
4:42 Yes. And we will be meeting, Nathan and I will be meeting with uh the designer next Monday and he should be at our upcoming meeting so we can give him
4:51 feedback based on the conversation today.
4:56 So our next next thing if everybody's if everybody's ready to move on is ranking these priorities.
5:01 Yes. And the way we're doing it is a little bit different than standard voting or ranking. So you get 10 total votes and so you can put 10 all on one.
5:11 You're really passionate about uh aesthetics. All can be all 10 votes can be go to aesthetics. Um so weigh them
5:20 how you feel is appropriate and then I'll aggregate and then we can discuss after that.
5:26 So one thing that may need to be added because I don't know where everybody's at with it or how council presented it.
5:33 um is the pay option.
5:38 Do we need to suggest that or is council is that how that's going to work with the rest?
5:46 I mean for me that's an absolute that you have to have that in there.
5:52 But there's other folks who are like no it should be free. So I think there's a conversation to be had there. I think that would be you all. Okay.
6:00 It would be you all saying, "Hey, this is an opportunity for part of the design is that, you know, if you're wrapping something, it is part of the design.
6:10 Should it belong to this list?" To Todd's point, should it belong to this list? Like, I know you get those from emails.
6:16 That's why I was asking was whether we need to because that's going to be a top I mean, that's a top Yeah. two or three for me. I think we should.
6:24 So, you think it should be paid for?
6:29 So, Sometimes we have to connect all the dots. If the CRA borrows the money, I think the CRA should say whether they're
6:36 going to charge or not. So, I think that the mechanism needs to be there for that. I'm not here to tell the CRA that they have to charge. I think that that's
6:45 something that they should do. Um, but if they're borrowing the money, they have to decide how they're going to pay for it. And I don't think that shouldn't be a blind
6:53 that that shouldn't be something where all of a sudden the CRA is like, well, we would charge if they would have put in the parking meters for or the Yeah, I I agree with you. I'll say 40%.
7:04 Uh let's pretend one of the levels like you're you're a business downtown and you have 40 employees and you want them
7:13 to be able to park. So there should be a spot where you can have private parking for this group and the rest is free to
7:20 the public, but there should be a reserved spot for regular users. And that was something that
7:29 I've had other conversations just because I've been at this longer where people who have businesses downtown
7:38 should either have their staff purchase a package, some type of a package. Um or the
7:46 employer employer is sponsoring that or however that is. Because when we say that, okay, because we talked about the
7:54 $3,000 per spot, yes, we're underelling that, but we also know that a restaurant is
8:02 going to want more spots. They're going to have more staff. You know, Bill, Bill's talking about his turnover and how many people he has, you know, at one
8:11 spot. And that that's sort of what we need to do. I mean, I don't think we need to dedicate spots to them, but they certainly need to have Would you?
8:19 So, what I will say is is that is technically a design element and it could be a yes or a no whether or not
8:26 this committee falls in that. If I were having a wedding at the brewery and I knew I had 200 guests coming,
8:35 I would want the ability to reserve 200 spots on Friday night from 7:30 to midnight.
8:43 But I think that's a CRA conversation, not a committee conver I think it needs to be in the recommendations of design is potential for reserve section.
8:54 Right. I don't have any would it be sufficient to say we're on the same compatibility with paid options or something to that effect.
9:05 It's a very broad concept like to Mr.
9:08 Tower's point. This should be a CRA, but we should address in the design that the design should be compatible with potential meters and things like that.
9:16 It's in the thin frog. Can you pull it?
9:18 If you pull up the thin frog, they actually have the wording in there.
9:21 Yeah, for the paid thing. I remember it's there. I just don't remember what it is.
9:25 And then that way at least we have a single wording.
9:34 I don't we call it call park parking blocks is kind of the term set and that's a design element if we're
9:43 creating like four blocks. So it's like four spaces is that about normal size of something like that. So that's a design element because that's the size of the
9:50 spaces. So I think that would be under your other but if those spaces have limited access you have to have a
9:58 card or something to get in there then that's part of the design correct as opposed to just those are reserved I go park on the top level where it's free
10:07 yes that is part of the design the mechanical operational element of it will be up to the CRA and council but
10:14 the actual design portion of it for that yes falls under design could we add a line to park blocks into
10:23 this, you know, ranking list is decided if we have consensus from everyone.
10:29 Yeah, there's there was a couple things in the fence one. Bathrooms are not on here. Restrooms are not on here. Okay.
10:35 Um and that was one that I think as a committee to have that conversation because I wasn't really sure. I mean, I know there's a bathroom around the
10:43 corner, so we need to know that the city is planning on keeping that at the corner of 8 and whatever that is over by Hill. And there's also one on south.
10:53 Yeah. You just got to make sure that they're not that they're adjacent of of where they are.
10:58 Well, I think that's part of what you put into it as part of our recommendation. If we go no bathrooms, the city then has to council would have to state that we have no intention of
11:07 removing those other facilities already in place.
11:11 It was just a design element that Finn Frock had put in and that's why it was in my mind and then the paid part was the other part. So, I mean, I don't
11:19 how how do you feel about like what I'm struggling with is
11:26 I mean, we we can't reserve enough parking spots for all the businesses.
11:32 If there's a certain number available to be reserved and it's first come, first and when they're reserved that you'd have to reserve them for a month, a year, whatever it was.
11:44 I think the the I mean it's great to say we'll reserve 20 spots for Suncrete for instance, but maintaining that security,
11:51 getting people out of that when they park into it, getting them towed, all kinds of I think it'd be an administrative nightmare to actually do
11:58 that unless we had a parking attendant, which I'm sure the city would not want to have paid for.
12:02 Well, those three spots behind uh the art wall that are 15minute only. Yeah.
12:08 I mean, they're not being policed, so they're not 15 minutes. I guess more an idea for employees rather than guests.
12:17 Like could a business apply for like a validation to the parking garage further employ more in the weeds
12:25 then then we should get it's more just if we have consensus to put it on here the Yeah.
12:33 And then we figure out how it would look.
12:35 My suggestion would be to put it on the top floor because nobody's going to want to park in the sun. So if let's say we say well we're not going to do shading
12:43 over top there's going to be a top floor an employee is So then we would need a motion to add it right or is it it's okay if you all are in agreement.
12:52 Are we in agreement? I had the opportunity to talk to Mark Hutchinson, a Winter Garden economic development uh manager director, and he gave me some
13:00 insight on how they currently run the garage, why it's why it's where it's at, how they the design elements they put
13:07 into it, and also to this subject, how they're planning on charging for it in the future. Yeah.
13:12 Because of the concern about the new amendment three.
13:17 And I don't know if we can put it in if we're all in agreement to actually say paper parking should be in there which I think most of us are then the way
13:25 they're considering it is proximity to downtown like their garage is centrally loc centrally located
13:33 but even on the garage floors like the lower garages you're going to pay more than you will on the upper floors. So, it may be a and the further away that
13:40 you're in their regular public parking, uh, also in street parking, it'll be like a tiered plan. They're not going to manage this at all, but I think they're
13:48 hiring a company to do this and using an app.
13:52 Um, yeah, which is most major. I was I was in a parking structure in Vancouver, Washington last year was brand new.
14:01 And at the elevator corner was a computer terminal. You you parked your
14:09 car and you took a little thing with you and when you got ready to leave, you scan that. You scan your credit card. A
14:17 merchant could give you a voucher and scan the balance on there. So, so it's all going to be computer controlled.
14:24 And I didn't notice any human attendant at that time. So, but in that little corner where they had bathrooms and elevators and payment collecting all in
14:33 one spot, what was the name on that? What was Okay.
14:38 What's the wording you guys become? Some sort of pay or reserve parking
14:45 the possibility of I don't I don't like reserve because that could muscle out some people that
14:53 really can't afford it as a business.
14:55 It's more like a management it could be more difficult to manage.
14:59 Perhaps we can just I don't know what the but I do like the lower floors being a
15:06 certain amount, the upper floor is being free maybe for you know whoever wants to park there that kind of thing. Back when I worked in I worked retail a long time
15:14 ago at Soras Mills Mall over massive mall in South Florida. There was an issue with employees taking off the parking spots that are closer to the
15:21 mall because of course we arrive at 7 8 a.m. and by the time the uh the fines arrive there's no more parking. So what the mall did is they designated the
15:29 outer perimeter as the employee parking behind that line. So I think what Mr. Howard said is perfectly reasonable using the top floor of the
15:37 garage as a fake ass but employee parking that would be a reasonable strategy to go about it. Um but maybe
15:44 we're going a little bit into the nitty-gritty details.
15:48 Yeah. because like management instead of the design and I think when it comes to design the most common thing I've seen is there is a way
15:56 either you pay with your phone uh depending on the area they could be uh pay on foot as well especially with cash
16:03 because prefer to pay with cash often times and also there's the meters like by the elevators where the rest of
16:10 amenities are so as you are coming back you just pay for that also was it mentioned in Vancouver. Yes, I'm
16:19 sorry. I have terrible memory. I'm tired. So, in Cocoa Walk in my in Coconut Grove, Miami,
16:27 that was very common. Like you would go into the parking garage, you would watch a movie, and at the movies, you would just press a button, you would get a ticket, and that was your waiver for
16:36 How about we just call it electronic parking management?
16:41 So, we should design it so fees could be collected in the future if they want to.
16:47 They can do it however they want because then we're not tying anybody's hands. I mean, you've been on council before where you're like, why did they make this rule? This is dumb.
16:56 The closest to the elevator is the ADA. Let's charge them lots. Exactly.
17:00 So, just so we have the correct wording that we're all voting on. Are we saying basically we want them to have the
17:07 capability to do some sort of electronic parking management? could recall like a fee friendly design, a fee friendly, you
17:16 know, that could welcome if a fee was to apply. Yeah. And I'm talking nominal fee myself.
17:24 We're not trying to charge you $20 a day. I mean, we're not the airport.
17:28 We're deciding if it's I mean, I'd also like to see it as a design feature where just like over the Disney park lots where you can tell how
17:36 many parking spots are in there, but that's that system looks expensive. The sensors. Yeah, those are very cool. It does, but it's my gosh.
17:42 But it is super handy. So telling how many are in each each floor. So and where on that floor you you have a
17:50 I think even where I'm from originally in Columbus, Ohio, East Town Center, there just would say how many are available in the garage. That's it. Not
17:58 how many are on each floor means eight story garages. And it would just say there's eight 80 parking spots left in this garage. And you just got to figure
18:06 out where they are. And that's probably pretty easy because all you're doing is counting.
18:10 It's a car count in and out, in and out, out in and out.
18:12 Let's shoot Let's shoot from the moon and say we want every spot to have a green or red light in it and let city council pair it down based on budget. I mean, it's not an option.
18:19 Yeah, it's not it's not Yeah, we we're not worried about the budget, right?
18:22 Okay. So, so we have the fee and now we also have another thing we're adding, right?
18:28 Maybe call it like intelligent parking management or something like that. Just leave it open.
18:33 Capabilities for fee based and intelligent parking.
18:37 Yeah, even even parking.
18:40 I'm good. Like you could have it Monday, Thursday. Everything is free. Why?
18:45 I think they can kind of tie together just under a management system.
18:49 I think electronic parking management covers all of that. Yeah.
18:52 And then we're just easy to be able to say, you know, you guys can buy the $200,000 system or the $500,000 system.
18:59 When you build the walls, put the conduit in 100%.
19:02 Yeah. So, the base electronic managing system and then in parentheses smart or
19:09 intelligent because I do think I don't think that's as hard as we think it is. Yeah.
19:16 It's a lot of conduit on the ceiling.
19:18 That's about it. But even even that's expensive these days. So, it's all life.
19:22 I was going to say it's Bluetooth. I mean, I can't imagine that it's that hard to tie that one little sensor that it's either full or not full. I I just Yeah.
19:32 One more question. Do we need a motion to add that in? No. No.
19:36 As long as we're we're just in agreement, right?
19:38 Another question is we have on this list mixed use and retail on ground level.
19:45 On this mixeduse, doesn't it just apply implies that it's retail and parking or no? You could have apartments up top there.
19:53 There's multiple things that could happen with that versus one one was specifically ground floor mixed use. It could be on the second
20:00 floor, be on the third floor. So I wanted to differentiate those on there because those were what was asked. So there is a slight nuance difference.
20:08 And the line is going in with the retail on ground floor also. That's it could or it could just be the outside. So that's a little different as well.
20:16 So with um is there stipulation on the Seventh
20:24 Street site that would disallow retail that it has to only be parking.
20:30 That's a great question. I don't know the answer, but I'll find out.
20:33 This is where we're going to get into the weeds a little bit, too, because let's assume that we're going to
20:41 maximize, like Bill talked about, we're going to maximize parking. Well, there's still that front piece right there where all those parking spots are that face
20:51 Oyola. Is that also No, that's West West Minola.
20:55 So, we already have all that parking that's there, the slanted parking. So, you know, we could put a 10-ft sidewalk
21:04 in front of that with some smaller spaces, candy shops, looking for those small
21:12 600, 800 square foot little blocks to keep people walking along there.
21:18 So, you just lose that parking. So, you're losing whatever it is, 20 or 30 parking spaces, but you get full retail
21:24 walkable drawing people along there. um which was to your point that if there's nothing there, there's nothing to draw people. So, you still draw people along.
21:34 Eventually, that other side is going to be wrapped. I mean, there's no way that they're not doing retail facing
21:40 Westminola from the De Hoya property. Um you know, depending on who ends up with that and in all likelihood that ends up
21:48 wrapped on three sides. You know, it's got to face the water, it's got to face the art lock, and it would almost have to face West Montro. With the De Hoya
21:56 property though, too, with the current code in place, if I'm the developer, I'll pay the $3,000 per parking spot I'm
22:03 supposed to have before I ever build an integrated,000%.
22:07 Unless you're doing a hotel or you're doing a little maybe a small I believe that a Hoya I believe that a Hoya property, like my property is excluded from that 30,000.
22:16 Yeah, exactly. So, like why would why would I build parking into a site that I'm not required to and if the city has a garage across the street?
22:26 I mean only be like looking at the is it the KDson report?
22:33 Yeah, that was a parking. Oh, yeah. So the the parking study. Yeah.
22:38 I mean and I know it's not on job, but we're going to have a pretty serious parking
22:45 problem in the future as other things develop. Isn't the lumber yard self parking? Lumber yard's fine by itself.
22:52 It's fine.
22:54 17 spots for 393 units in addition to like a 60,000 foot retail space.
23:02 It's not a net positive, it's a net loss. We're losing 75.
23:06 Okay. Then I mean this is way when it was first approved it was self parking.
23:11 So in that report which it could have changed. Yeah. Like they could have updated it but in that report it said they plan 317.
23:20 I have heard that there may integrated parking.
23:24 There's supposed to be some type of a poker parking phase too.
23:27 This scared me, but it may have changed some.
23:32 Well, when you read that and I hadn't read it again in a while and then I was like, golly, on events we were 900 short or 800 short or whatever.
23:41 And I was like, you know, that that part even when I was sitting on council reading this didn't click with me until I read it again and I was like, holy
23:48 cow, that's a lot of people that Bill can't bring in or, you know, that that mullet or you know, whatever business,
23:57 that's a lot of every car has two people. That's 1,800 people who didn't make it downtown.
24:02 Well, when you're looking at Lumberyard, police station, minola in seventh, and then miscellaneous small
24:09 lots that could be developed, that total need jumps up well past 650 right there.
24:17 So, you know, I'm I'm looking ahead and I'm like, my gosh, it maybe should be this and that. But that's not a no. You know, we don't
24:25 I think with the lumber yard, the lumber yard's disconnected so much that if the lumber yard does fall short on parking based on their commercial space, they're
24:32 going to park in the dirt lot at the rowing club. They'll park in the parking lot on the other side of Victory Point.
24:39 You're not going to park either here or except the Miniola to go down to the commercial space that whatever that ends up inside.
24:47 And they brought that up because and they also brought up waterfront where there's ample parking but People are not parking there.
24:55 You're talking waterfront parking.
24:56 Yeah, waterfront to to walk. But like if we could at some point figure out a shuttling, you know, but I I looked at
25:04 it and I was like, "Yeah, I mean it's really lost. At Chick-fil-A, we call it a lost opportunity
25:11 and like at my hammock location, I'm acutely aware that I'm losing probably a million in sales because of
25:19 the design of my parking lot." And you're going to run into that put a garage in.
25:25 So here's my motion for a garage at Hammock Sprouts and walk. I will pay for the shuttles downtown.
25:34 We're going to end up having that conversation. That's the nice part about having this. This isn't an either and or that it can be both that you're going to
25:42 design the best one that you can because you may end up with both.
25:46 And I know Jason's gonna listen to this and be like, Todd, shut up. Um, for Jason to redevelop that, the city
25:54 has to sell that back at a million half dollars to him. A million half dollars for a one and a halfacre piece of property that has all of that infrastructure already on it. The
26:02 infrastructure alone is close to a million dollars. Easy. Because that parking lot that we did between
26:08 um between Salt Shack and whatever it's called now um used to be historic place. Yeah. So that little one
26:16 that shoehorned over there was just the infrastructure side, not including land, was about $800,000. Yeah.
26:24 And that was three years ago money. Um and this one's a little bigger, a little more infrastructure. So, you know,
26:32 trying to sell that a if I was on council, that is not the vote I want to make. Um that's going to be an ugly vote to sell that back to him to redevelop
26:40 that. But it may be one where you say, you know what, we're going to do this one first and we're going to end up having to do that one second because there's not another acre and a half in
26:49 downtown with the exception of the post office.
26:52 But that's where I I would love to know if if it's possible the stipulations in the agreement because built like if the if the
27:02 decision is to build behind here first, it might immediately make it a non-issue. It might immediately have to be sold back. So, no, no, no, no, no.
27:12 So, it has to be a parking lot. That's the end of the story. If we want to do something else, because there's been all this conversation of, oh, we want to
27:20 have it become something else. It has to go back to him to develop it.
27:26 And it which brings me to the point that does this mixuse that contract is really important because does that mix use
27:33 messes with that? because as long as it stays as a parking lot right now and it gets built as a parking garage, we're not obligated to sell back. But the
27:42 minute we start talking about this mixed use and apartment, it may mess up with that cont.
27:46 I believe that to be true and I also believe and this is why I love clarification.
27:52 I also believe if work starts here, it there is a trigger that he can immediately ask for.
28:02 in the contract. I don't know. It's been a while since I read the agreement. I'm sorry. There is he can buy it back for a period of 10 years following three conditions.
28:14 He can actually request to buy it back at any point. So currently he doesn't want to buy it back.
28:21 If the city would want to sell it, he has an option to buy his like first choice at the price that he sold it for for a period of 10 years. And I I cannot
28:30 remember the third one, but That's a question that I had. Can we actually do retail at the bottom? Because their
28:38 agreement does say that the uh city did purchase it for with the intent to use as parking as a parking structure. Does
28:47 that mean that we cannot have anything else but parking? I'm not sure because I So maybe like let's take it a step back because I have a question for the city
28:54 attorney and I think we're kind of like going into the weeds a little bit. You could take the parking spots and build.
28:59 So, but I do believe the structure has to be parking.
29:02 And if you keep that structure and then you just move a piece out, it's no loss.
29:08 I mean, you make sure you have a six or eight 10 foot sidewalk, whatever you want with small shops on the front and
29:16 it's still retail. And you could do it one story, you could do it two stories.
29:19 I mean, you know, you could there's nothing wrong. There's not enough one-bedroom apartments in Claremont. I can promise you that for people who need
29:27 four, five, six00 square feet of I mean you could build a small great little apartment up top over a shop.
29:36 But I think because we're meeting for the next five by the weeks or four weeks it knowing the stipulations by next meeting will help
29:44 us to design where this mix used in retail downstairs may not be a problem here. We just bring it up on seven may be a problem on seven as part of the design.
29:56 with anything in mind without the stipulations and then if we find out it's not a possibility I will let you all know but as we're having
30:04 this conversation I think we should continue as if trying to put okay retail as part of I think the conversation would be with
30:13 public works and Stony along with um probably public works to say hey
30:19 what's here can we build across the top of this stony's going to know what's there. I mean, if there's a bunch of infrastructure under there, Stony is
30:27 going to be like, "You are not building on top of all of my sewer and water pipes." I mean, that would just be that would kind of we stop here.
30:36 One option then, too, is to I don't know who's got the the diplomacy, but to approach Mr. Stringfeller
30:44 and if if the parking structure include retail units, split the rent with him. Now, come to a new agreement.
30:51 I don't know. Can the city be a renter or landlord to personal to his apartments and things like that?
30:57 Does that Mr. Shrinkfell is probably listening right now?
31:02 Yeah, 100% is because the thing to me retail on the ground floor makes sense at seventh in
31:09 Minnola but not behind city hall.
31:12 Can I can I add that actually I was the person who said mixed use precisely because of that because mixed use doesn't have to be multiple floors. It
31:21 can be just retail which makes total sense to do accept minola doesn't make as much sense here in here there are other considerations there are other
31:30 options that we could explore so I didn't want to confine myself to just retail because I don't think just retail is going to thrive with this space in
31:38 just the soda street as it is right now so that's why I used well I think the soda side here just stays garage you don't do anything
31:47 with it because you're looking at a storage facility and a class B C retail building that's you know built in the 70s 80s you know on the seventh street
31:56 side maybe it's not retail it's brownstone type of you know condos that are twotory walk up type of condos because if you
32:04 look at the original city plat maps for here um all of our we could pass anybody wants to see this but but all the lots
32:12 actually that run north south our streets seventh eth all of that we actually had deep lots that faced our
32:19 the seventh eth and all those it wasn't about Mola Montro those those roads there so it was all about going north south
32:26 going to the lake you know that's what you want to see I'm going to the lake that's what you know that's the view well and again like our our job is blue
32:34 sky so if we think hey a brownstone a row of brownstones would work
32:44 there you go you have the beautiful mural that's
32:50 So it's like if you have the right people I I mean I see it all the time.
32:59 So that way you don't have this giant fourtory massive structure you're looking at
33:06 those homes then can be condoed whatever sold off simple makes a little money for the city.
33:13 I think I'm sorry I would love to keep talking about this but I think we haven't completed this exercise. I definitely want to go into the details.
33:20 Yeah. So we need to vote. Maybe we need to complete the exercise. Yeah.
33:26 Everybody has 10 votes 10 on one or you can divide them up.
33:31 Say does that mean if something doesn't get any votes it gets dropped from the list?
33:35 No, not necessarily. It's more so just so we can focus on what you all care about. I I did have one question uh
33:42 about like let's say um how many handicap spots per That's a code requirement.
33:51 So that's not even a it's not even Yeah. Same with like the ADA accessibility. That's a code requirement. Okay.
33:56 So let me one comment on the number of spots. Um when I talked to Mr. Hudson at Winter Garden. He said that the city when they built originally a three deck
34:05 or threele garage, they wish they put four or five of them in hindsight. So when they build a second, right?
34:12 They're going to they or they're going to the And the ADA accessibility on there was actually like extra ADA accessibility. Yeah.
34:20 Um so it was for the purpose of going above and beyond what the code requires. Yeah.
34:27 That was me like extra like putting more disabled parking than the code currently requires us to do because I hear so many
34:35 times people with disabilities or with families with disabilities that they say over and over again that we don't have enough disabled parking. So, I figured we're building garage, let's go above.
34:45 And sorry, just real quick, another clarification because if I were to read this, it wouldn't be clear to me.
34:49 Alternative parking methods was also something that I added because I wanted to see bike parking and specifically a bike parking garage and also golf car
34:58 parking because that's a good transportation method for people who live nearby by not near enough to walk here.
35:06 So, excuse me, not alternate parking methods, alternate vehicle parking. Yes. Okay.
35:13 Thank you for clarifying.
35:17 And just the feedback that I got on the ADA because I got chewed on this. Um
35:24 the big part on the ADA accessibility was for side load vans. That was
35:32 I didn't get a lot of complaints directly about ADA, but for the sideload vans, there was not enough room, not enough parking.
35:41 for those folks who are trying to get wheelchairs in and out.
35:45 Um, so that was the one that was a how do you design this into here and whether it's up here over there, I don't
35:53 think there's a big difference because of the topography, but there's some that are down the hill
36:00 on the Oyola and the feedback I got from the folks who were disabled were like, "We can't make it up that hill. We And I was like,
36:09 "Oh, I I totally get that." Because there's no handicap parking on the street, is no, you cannot. There's not enough room to do this.
36:16 And you try to get somebody who's got a van who's trying to get there. There's very very Well, the only one is in front right there by um the the other brewery.
36:25 Yeah, I think there's one over in VP's parking lot, too, where they have a side set, but a couple here.
36:33 Yeah, there are enough handicap spots. We actual handicap They're all in the ring and they're not minimal.
36:40 Yeah, the old hand less than 10 for the art wall here. I know I didn't see that report till about an hour ago.
36:46 I don't think it was less than I thought.
36:49 Could have question could a concept for like behind city hall also include the circus lot
36:58 like if we wanted more uh handicap parking like designate that lot more to handicap parking.
37:06 I I don't think that falls under design. Okay. But what is the requirement?
37:14 But if I understand your question, for the sake of argument, we we put a fivetory parking structure behind city hall.
37:22 Could we then go over to the place we didn't use and add handicap here?
37:27 That is a the answer is yes. But that does not fall under this per.
37:32 It's not our commitment. But it's a good idea.
37:34 It's a good idea. Yes. I was on track to No, I get it.
37:38 It would also kill parking over there normally for when it's when handicap parking isn't needed. So any because that lot will fill up first. If
37:46 this you can have a 10 storage garage here and that lot will fill up first. Yeah.
37:51 Okay. So staying on task, we just want us to put a number in front of and distribute your 10 votes. Distribute your 10 votes.
37:59 We're not ranking them. We're just picking 10. Just picking 10. Okay. I'm ranking them. That's okay.
38:08 You want to start telling
39:08 Can I get more votes?
39:11 You can buy 3,000 for 3,000. Sorry, I didn't bring my checkbook. We take credit.
39:20 Yeah, I didn't bring that either.
39:21 Apple, but there is a two and a half% credit card.
39:28 It's a convenience fee. Did you know? Yeah.
39:37 I did five.
39:44 I I feel what you're saying about that turnover at your like, you know, delineation point of your day with your
39:52 team because that's what kills me. At 2:00 I could have 30 people working inside and
39:59 25 coming in and I only have 40 something spots.
40:05 People probably drop it on if you bring it to me and you guys can we use that dirt mingle for just a moment.
40:12 I am sorry for the mess that I is that your lot. I tried to buy it and uh it's
40:19 not allowed under my contract with so I had to step away from it.
40:28 You're not allowed to buy a dirt lot.
40:31 If I buy it, I can never lease it back or sell it to Chickpoint.
40:41 For a million dollars a year, does it make sense to buy it and then keep it and then you're never going to lose money on land?
40:49 No. But they assured me they would purchase it for us and now the price is a lot more
40:57 than a million because they came and ask so trying to see if the price comes back.
41:06 But I I it's it's a big issue, you know, just having enough have to take care of your customers.
41:13 I mean, we we have more like nine to 10, maybe 12, but not not 30, but still it's the same issue. That's, you know, they all they're not related to each other.
41:22 They're all going to drive separately. Who owns that?
41:25 Uh I was Marvin was kind of my intermediary. Okay.
41:31 Um if it's who I'm thinking of, it's not it's not that that's not the problem. Chick-fil-A is mostly the
41:39 problem. I would lock it up now knowing what I know. I would go back and purchase it personally.
41:47 Knowing you know now I'd go back and purchase the owner.
41:51 Well, because it's what you've got deep restrictions on it, right?
41:54 So, yeah, because it's really it's like 0.96, but only usable.
41:59 So, he should have told one of us. We're just Yeah, the but the owners aren't unreasonable because you know them.
42:06 Yeah. Yeah. I've met with them before and they're not I'm not buying large. Do you know Angie Langley?
42:14 Yeah.
42:15 That's your contact. That's I would talk with Angie and say, "Hey, you know, where are they at with this?" And she knows them pretty well. So, she
42:23 facilitated a meeting with me with them and um like I said, they're not unreasonable.
42:30 Good. Sure. Sure.
42:33 Yeah. I biggest regret was not trying to lock up where five guys But I had no money back then. I was broke.
42:42 We were all at that point. You're like, "Oh, man." It wasn't really a regret. I could have done nothing about it.
42:48 Yeah. But at least you're on the south side of the road and don't have the sun coming through your window.
42:57 You know, you just got to go ahead and plan on Minnola now. Figure out where you're going over there. I'm too old for that.
43:06 You don't have another one in you.
43:10 you know, I consulted two and they're building a third.
43:19 We've got a a sister company of ours is having some financial issues and um I kind of stuck my toe in the water
43:28 yesterday and I was like I don't want to spread my wings any further but I can't not spread my wings
43:36 because it affects me in an indirect way and I was like you know if I need to step in here then I will. I mean Chick's looking at both grills and so at some
43:45 point if they make a decision they may force my hand but almost impossible to get a third
43:53 um and if I really Yes. And if I did I would probably have to give up the airports and the airport
44:00 is a consulting so I don't hire or fire or train. I just go there and tell them what they're doing wrong. It's great.
44:07 But you could have an arms length friend who does it for you. You could go with a current theme and do a a double face Chick-fil-A Waffle House.
44:23 Keep telling everything. Yeah. Lot of numbers. Is this part of the agenda?
44:30 Yeah. So, this is something I kind of just put together. This is so kind of how we determine in the real estate development world like what's
44:37 what's our end goal. So, you know, kind of just gave some bullet points for each thing. I think a lot of that was kind of covered in the list uh that was put in
44:46 front of you earlier. But the second page is just kind of a a problem solving.
44:52 You know, how do you get from what the problem is, identify your problem, and then how do we get to the to the end? And that's kind of those six steps.
45:01 And usually everybody falls on their face between step five and step six.
45:06 I think that's when you get to that call to action. So helpful having yourself and Todd here who you know can help us
45:13 with there's not really a height requirement but there is like you know it's not written but there is they're not going
45:22 to go yeah there is absurd on the maximum height on the one that Finrock did was 55 but it wasn't actually the top floor
45:31 that was actually the little tower that they put on there which is a nice design element and so it went 55 which I from access.
45:38 The code used to be occupied floors and I think they just went to total feet. Yeah. Several years ago.
45:46 So, and a lot of it has to do with how high can the fire truck reach, which I which is Yeah, that's been settled. I mean, Chief
45:54 Ael has plenty of money. He'll buy whatever whatever height you want.
45:59 Mega trucks, you know, on that. I go back to something that Bill had talked about at the last meeting and after he said it, I
46:07 was like, you know, because I wasn't at that point until the more I thought about it and read back through this is that I really do think we ought to
46:14 maximize it. And after hearing what you said with Winter Garden, maximizing
46:21 what we have would be smart as far as height wise goes. Reading that study, I was shocked at how inaccurate I feel it is.
46:32 And when they say there's a thousand parking spots, I'm like, where? Waterfront Park. Yeah.
46:39 And all the grass along Waterfront Park and and West Avenue.
46:43 The gentleman at Winter Garden, he told me that you've been to Cricam Winter Garden. There's that dirt parking lot and baseball field. 12.
46:50 That's the closest to a big attraction which is the crooked cam, but it's the least popular lot of anybody who goes
46:57 there. It's the last to fill up. Now, he said part of it is probably it's dirt, but he said most of it is they will park
47:04 anywhere else besides there and then when everything else is full, that's when people start going to that spot even though it's the closest.
47:12 So, why do they fill that?
47:14 It's still baseball. I don't know. maybe they don't want to spend the money, but they're, you know, they're right now in a different position we are. They have a parking garage and now they're worried
47:22 about how they're going to pay for everything else downtown with this potential budget hole that they're going to have. And now they identify parking as more of a, you know, to support local
47:31 businesses, but now as a as a revenue stream to fill other holes that are going to be open with property taxes.
47:37 Yeah. Do something to your point. So that's when if if he had they have three now, but if they had four or five and
47:45 they could charge for that, then that's even more revenue. And the city of Claremont is potentially going to be facing the same issue um just like them.
47:52 And but they already have a garage. So if we're going to if you're going to spend the money and it's I think it's
48:01 you're going to put three three floors up to maintain a a number that is nobody can really say whether it's a real number or not. as far as height goes or whether it can be broken.
48:10 I can tell you 100% it's 53 feet.
48:13 Now, the city can break that. The city can do whatever they want, but for blue sky, why why wouldn't our suggestion be
48:22 maximum and I'm and I'm not a developer, so like I said, but I I think it makes if if it cost you X amount of dollars to put up three stories,
48:29 it's not an extra 20% to put up that fourth story. Maybe it's just this is a good segue into the votes because the number one uh priority is
48:38 actually the number of spaces from everyone. So that's what our focus should probably be on is that as we continue to have
48:46 conversations. Uh number two is mixed use.
48:50 Um number three is traffic flows. So designing it so traffic is uh easily
48:58 maintained. Uh, number four is accessibility to downtown and number five is a three-way tie between maximum number of spaces.
49:11 Apologies, sorry. Um, the attraction of it and uh pedestrian hostility and making sure the pedestrians stay safe.
49:19 So, those are the priorities uh based on everyone's cumulative information.
49:28 And I think one of the nice parts about doesn't matter which one you do. This one I don't think there's as much pedestrian hostility over there. I can
49:36 see it. Um, but if you're able to move those cars in and out and you bring in
49:43 the that east west corridor pathway, um, you
49:51 eliminate a lot of that because you're going to be moving up and down the artwalk along with the east west corridor. And, um, it makes it nice that
50:01 you kind of have that pedestrian walkway that's completely away from all cars really. You're not near any roads.
50:09 You mean the trail?
50:11 No. So, Oh, okay. I know what you mean. Yeah.
50:14 So, the east west is going to go, you know, because when VP red does what he's doing, that's going to go across
50:22 ETH through VPs and then he's going to angle it all the way up to Montrose along the back side of his property. Um, and then it comes all the way to seven.
50:32 It's already designated for um there's 10 foot of walkway, 18 foot of space between um Stringfellow's current building and
50:41 where the garage would go. So they're 18 foot corridor goes there. Um but it would be walkable and so it would be a
50:49 continuation of that brick that's there if they choose to do it. I would do it almost be like a nice cover. that I 100
50:57 I would make it as as friendly to sort of the artwalk as as possible and then
51:04 Jason still has the opportunity for that whole strip of land that he owns where the behind the airream yep where the airstream is he can
51:12 develop that I mean because at one point our conversation was flying the garage over top of his property and still allowing him to do that but
51:20 then did you have Yeah. How much uh
51:28 infrastructure can we apply to this design? Like say police guy for a parking structure there. We wanted
51:36 to turn west minola between seventh and eighth into a pedestrian walkway.
51:43 You might ask that question a different way.
51:46 Yes. Um would it be within the view of this committee to apply a design uh adjacent to the
51:56 parking structure that would include uh roadways and pedestrian walkways? Is it on the property?
52:04 No. No.
52:06 So I have a followup question because I assume that we had some leeway because
52:12 Mr. Howard, you mentioned that we would going back to his conversation. Yeah, that that is part of what I talked about was being able to remove those spaces
52:21 that are sitting on West Manola and using those for that retail.
52:27 So, we have to stay within the way I've interpreted is we have to stay inside the lot, but there will be
52:34 solutions that are that have to be had by council that does because if council wants mixed use, then you can say here's what the
52:41 opportunities are. We'll have already we can still have those opportunities fleshed out for them. Yes.
52:47 We may not make a recommendation, but yes. Yeah.
52:50 I mean, right now you got that's a with the 45s, the sidewalk, then the setback easement for the
52:57 parking lot on on Minnola. I mean, that's that's a lot of lot of land. And then you just do parallel or you just
53:04 don't do any on street parking on that side, you know, on the south side.
53:09 100%. And just do a nice walkway through there. with with canopies, blades or something coming off the retail sites.
53:15 You have that kind of covered walkway and it's I don't want to go like super like into details of that design, but I would say
53:22 that if we're increasing the number of potentially shops because we're doing mixed use a big issue that I mean that
53:29 we have downtown is loading zones delivered vehicles. So that has to be taken into account in the design. For my
53:36 for my purposes, I can't we can't close Minnola because I have semi down there with grain and pickup kegs and basically
53:45 unless there was some accommodation made for me behind my building. No, we wouldn't close it.
53:50 Yeah. Well, I I when he first said about making it, I thought, you know, closing Mola would be from a pedestrian standpoint. Great.
53:59 Excuse me. When you said those spots where you might put skinny little retail, are you talking about what is currently grass or what is currently parking spots?
54:08 Both. Because you'd be able to back up to the parking structure, wherever the parking structure has to end.
54:15 And that would be either be a sidewalk and then the rest can be.
54:17 So you would squeeze a building between the bricks and the parking structure. Sure.
54:22 With a nice where these 45s are on this side of the street. That's what we're talking where
54:28 these 45 spots come into there because that's they parked inside the rightway so you could technically because it's city owned property
54:37 you could come up but again there's an infrastructure issue that'll have to be dealt with at a later point in time but that's that's kind of what we're discussing.
54:44 Yeah. I just don't know what's under there or where they put that one suggested putting a parking structure years ago
54:51 a parking structure there and they told me there was too much infrastructure under the ground. to make that feasible.
54:58 It's more like sure as long as it goes more and I think this conversation is
55:06 better done in we talked about depending what happens with the problem that we have to deal with.
55:13 But that's where putting a dumpster back there so I can get rid of my dumpster put a building up behind once you start the conversation then city have access from the back. Okay, there's $10 million of here and there.
55:25 We're not slow.
55:30 So, if I could have something back, that's fine. But it's Yeah, I just could also It's a big ride away. Otherwise, I'd be out of business.
55:39 That's that was supposed to be the trail, I think. So going so we've got number of spots mixed use or
55:47 possibility traffic flow accessibilities and then the attraction of it tied with pedestrian possibilities.
55:56 Are we recommending mixed use to both locations or just the mini?
56:00 So I I mean I think what he said is if we feel like seventh should be mixed use
56:07 we should put it even though it might There might be a stipulation.
56:12 Sure. Okay. Can we and I'm pretty sure there is a by next meeting. Can we have an answer from the city attorney?
56:18 I'll talk about when I said mixed use at 7th and Minnola. I was thinking retail office
56:25 over here. He's thinking residential. So I think I had not considered residential. That sounds a lot like Winter Park.
56:32 You can actually have both because there's network units. I'm thinking for example of Tokeno. Again
56:39 there is a building. It's a condo and it's a parking garage but it's wrapped with apartments and the ones that from
56:47 the street they are limp work and you can actually have a little shop there and I think that could do well even on
56:54 the uh back and on the sides. Now on the front there are other possibilities.
57:01 That's what phase two of the lumber yard was supposed to be when it was approved.
57:05 It was you worked, you lived and then there was a parking lot. opportunity for a business owner to live and have
57:13 business there at the same time. And I'm telling you, the ones that I have seen in Miami, Coral Gables, Grove, they just
57:20 they if they are for rent, they are not on the market for mall. Same thing as they are for sale. It's crazy how fast they go.
57:26 So, we have uh we have consensus for mixed youth use for both sites. Is that Yes.
57:33 Yes.
57:35 The attorney stops it. Sorry. I'm just I don't think so. I'm not totally on board act seven because and and my point is if the number one issue is number of
57:44 spaces the minute you start considering that mix use you you realize that you're taking away from the number of spaces right
57:51 we realize that's sorry one of the issues that was discussed last week was because what parking
57:59 garages are they're just giant structures that don't make you want to continue down that path. So once you get
58:06 to the edge of the parking garage, you're just like, "Oh, I don't need to go any further." And then you exclude businesses further down whether you know
58:14 that that's kind of what the the purpose of doing the retail is to continue people to move through to go what's next? What's next?
58:24 I'm more on board with the retail than the living. The mixeduse living is where I'm getting caught because if the number
58:31 of spaces is our number one priority and creating those spaces that mixuse with residential creates opens a whole new can of warm you sorry.
58:41 So have you seen the seventh the coffee seventh whatever I have seen.
58:45 Okay. So there's an apartment above that. So that would be is that yours? I didn't realize it was yours.
58:54 So the view from the roof. So anyway, for everybody, that's essentially what they're talking about was because I was
59:01 involved in I was on council when that came. Yeah, I think it's fantastic. I think seven is fantastic, but I think if the number one
59:09 priority is to create parking spaces, the minute you go into that, you've taken away from this parking spaces.
59:15 I'm not a super fan of adding anything over here besides parking garage. I'm just I'm not I don't
59:22 And from a city perspective, the city's not going to want to be a landlord. The smart move on this and this is what we
59:29 talked about with De Hoya's property. Go in, put in the city infrastructure, break it up into whatever pieces it is and then allow
59:39 somebody to purchase that and build what they want just like what you did. And you make it so that that size because you had an issue with yours that was
59:46 like 50 square feet short of our code or something because I dealt specifically with your property. It was 50 square feet over under. Yeah. Your your top living. Yes.
59:58 Yes. Yes.
59:58 So we had to do uh because I remember that coming before me and I was like are we really arguing with her over 50 square feet? And they were like yep. And I was like okay this is dumb.
1:00:07 That's a closet. Well, because she was putting a a walkway there so she wasn't using up her full land so that she could get her trash cans in and out or whatever it was. And
1:00:16 I remember when it was presented to me, I was at a point sitting on council going, "This is stupid. Why would we not just go ahead and approve this?" And we had
1:00:23 to go through the motion, but I remember seeing it going, "This is such a cute little design." And like I say, when when I
1:00:32 think of the the East West Corridor, I see a small retail, maybe a bike
1:00:39 rental, you know, like you park a car, you rent an electric bike, and you go downtown.
1:00:45 Yeah. I I sit the the retail I see on the south side of the parking structure is amenities.
1:00:54 Please, no more coffee. Uh on the north side, people might agree on, you know, on the north side, I could see some other
1:01:03 types of retail, but I I don't see any large retail at all. I see little Wait a minute. I don't see anything.
1:01:10 I see a little candy shop. Those little 400 mom and pop first time business popcorn.
1:01:18 Yeah. Yeah.
1:01:20 Especially now that is being redeveloped. So we lost one of our incubation hubs basically. And also
1:01:28 what's the name of the the exchange building? Yeah, the exchange. Thank you.
1:01:32 Also that one apparently the vendors that were thereum are not being renewed because I don't know exactly what's going on.
1:01:39 Cancel the leases but in a respectfully we are here to solve the parking problem not the retail space problem.
1:01:46 However, parking is a trans it's a important piece of infrastructure but the only thing that it does is not just parking. If we just want parking we can
1:01:54 make the the simplest ugliest maximum number of spots.
1:02:00 But it's not Well, but I think the challenge comes But so the challenge to me is I've seen parking garages to be honest. That
1:02:08 stopped me and I was like, "Wow." Like I saw one that was um the exterior was almost like treated cedar wood out
1:02:16 in Portland. It absolutely looked gorgeous.
1:02:19 Um you uh using different forms of lighting or uh you know building art along the the building. I I think we're
1:02:28 arguing a little bit and I'm almost 95% sure there's a stipulation on seven that we can't
1:02:37 well if it if it I won't speak for Jason. Jason, you can text me if you want. Um, but
1:02:44 if it came down to the garage going in his preferred spot next to his on his former property, but they he had to make
1:02:53 a side deal with the city to allow that original agreement to be amended. I'm sure he would be at least willing to talk about it,
1:03:00 but I'd be more willing to say that would be a recommendation as long as we also say let's go up. Yeah. So then let's go let's add that fifth floor.
1:03:10 And also to Anna's point, um if city council just wanted a box for parking, it would have been approved already. We wouldn't have had this committee.
1:03:22 Well, that's that goes back to those six steps I said that you have is city council can't get past step five. They
1:03:31 can't get to the to the finish line because they're all afraid. I don't say afraid.
1:03:35 Um They just can't make a decision that they feel is probably the best one. They keep second guessing it, I think is what
1:03:44 it is. And it's the funding. You have meet in the middle that they, you know, for funding there. It's a lot of questions of we have this pot. What are we going to use it for?
1:03:51 Yeah. Browse this way. It's powerful.
1:03:55 The seventh site, uh, I think it's calling 472 spots,
1:04:01 right? and basically four stories kind of.
1:04:06 Okay. So, does that mean we add another 100 and something if we go up one more story? I'm in favor for that.
1:04:12 Yeah, it's 470. It's 470 minus the 80 that are already there, 85 there and then and then we have to take away the 85 from the De Hoya property because one
1:04:21 day sooner or later that that will not be a parking lot like it is now. So, that'll be something. So really, you're netting maybe
1:04:29 220, 230 if you go with the But if you go one story higher, you're probably getting closer to 600 maybe.
1:04:36 And did did that drawing have fly over to Mr. No, that one doesn't.
1:04:40 No, I um is to pick him pick him up on the fly.
1:04:46 Yeah, because it doesn't because we it's not within it's not within the lot.
1:04:49 We're not allowed to touch it. So, like I think I could say if we we got a another story, then we can maybe look at some small.
1:04:57 I'm gonna tell you that on the I think we should maximize it. I like the 475. It comes in at 13 million. Um I
1:05:07 think that's doable. Um I think if we get too far outside of that, then we start adding too many stories. If we
1:05:15 start 16 million was a hard pill to swallow for council. So when we start talking about Council's going to go. Council had a hard time with 16 million.
1:05:23 That's part of the reason it wouldn't move forward. This one back here was 16 million however many years ago. When was that that one done? That one was 16 million.
1:05:32 Finrock got this one down to 13 million for almost 40% more spaces. I mean, that's a big deal.
1:05:40 Ever look at this though? Because Finrock does the pre-cast where here this was a custom casting place 100%. But that's that was the
1:05:47 difference. And this is why that didn't get built was because it was $16 million. They got this one down to 13 for 500 spots. And right here on seven, right?
1:05:57 Seven. We're talking about seven.
1:05:59 Yeah. So, and when we start talking about the Hoya property, it's going away at some point for sure.
1:06:06 I saw today there are a bunch of yellow poles across from CBC that are look permanent. um they're bolted into the cement and our sign for parking is gone.
1:06:18 And I did question one of the council members who was leaving and said, "Hey, what's going on with that?" And the
1:06:27 thought was that we no longer have a lease with them. So that's a hundred spaces that's gone out of that
1:06:36 and so the maximization of the parking spots because in my vision
1:06:43 That property across is going to be developed as retail and they're going to have it facing both the
1:06:51 street and the water. And so that is what is going to pull people past the parking garage is there be retail
1:06:59 already. And so that would allow us to beautify the heck out of the outside of the parking garage but absolutely make
1:07:08 it as massive as we can. And going into that, people are not going to go past
1:07:15 seventh anyway because that goes into the historic section. And this comes back to what you were talking about that
1:07:22 right now you feel that the center of the city is between seventh and eth.
1:07:28 Well, seventh and probably it's going to become seventh and the lumber yard soon.
1:07:32 The problem is it's going to be seventh to west and it's going to happen very quickly because All of the development
1:07:40 is going to be to the west. There's not going to be anything to the east because there is nobody who's going to say, "Yes, we want to go tear down all of our
1:07:50 historic." And that is really the only historic. when you start going west and if you look at the old houses there, the old stuff that way
1:07:58 and also what they were doing with the with the um plan when Darren Gray first put that plan out,
1:08:06 they were running Claremont all the way out to 12th Street. That whole all of those old block homes, every piece of
1:08:14 land over there was going to get bought up, consolidated, and reconfigured all the way to 12th Street. Because when I
1:08:21 first saw that I was like Paramont really going to be that big? I mean I didn't have a I mean I think that's that's eventually where it's going to go. You get a lot of
1:08:29 them over there that were renters and again someone like me who's a developer if I was on the residential or smaller commercial side start putting blocks together and build Exactly.
1:08:38 But I mean when when I first saw it you and you're talking that was done in you were you were on the council at that time.
1:08:44 There there have been several thing the uh there's a dry lake bed there between 10th and 11th. Y
1:08:51 that's been proposed for development more than once.
1:08:55 I think pieces of it in the 100year flood plane.
1:08:58 I saw remember when I first moved here I was like that'd be a great spot for rush. Yeah.
1:09:03 Can we take it back to the maximizing the space? Yes.
1:09:07 I had a couple of concerns. One of them is safety because I understand that you are including you Jordan actually your
1:09:15 own merchants. So you have businesses here. I'm a resident. So me and my neighbors, we walk here, we bike here,
1:09:22 and even with the traffic as it is right now, sometimes drivers are not the most considerate of people. And seven, with
1:09:30 the trail is right there. I see kids swimming, not only children, actually.
1:09:33 The other day, a lady almost ran me over uh with an electronic motorcycle. Mhm.
1:09:38 Like 70 years old or so. She was having the time of her life with that thing like but like she almost ran me over. I was right there at the
1:09:46 pedestrian crossing. She saw me. with lock like with lock eyes like zoom right past. So when you say 500 parking spots
1:09:54 at that location that is concerning to me because even with the number of cars right now sometimes I feel unsafe like
1:10:01 sometimes drivers just blow past the stop signs. Another thing I hear that
1:10:08 the east side is the historic side of Claremont. That is true. It is historic.
1:10:14 I don't want to be morbid though. Most of neighbors there. The residents are elderly and your heirs typically they
1:10:21 don't keep the house. There is two vacant not vacant two condemned properties on Oola right now on that side we're updating the code. Are we
1:10:29 sure that that's always going to stay as it is currently or do we think that with the updated code that can change and by placing a
1:10:38 massive parking garage there that is just maxim maximize parking no mix use or anything? Are we foreclosing on that?
1:10:46 So those are a couple of things that I want to you to consider from tra from from a traffic standpoint.
1:10:53 No matter where we put it, it's going to create more traffic. Mhm. There are fewer though.
1:10:58 I I wish that I could conceive where one end of the building was in and the other building was out.
1:11:06 But on both of these locations, I think your in and out's going to share seventh street.
1:11:11 Uh Mola is a wider street with a right with a wider right of way than Dodto.
1:11:19 So I'm partial to Miniola as an access east west street.
1:11:25 And there's far less stop but we're not but when it come when it comes away from what we need to do the only thing we need to do is we need
1:11:34 to say best on seventh best but yeah given current data and trends I think down the downtown hub is moving
1:11:43 west not east so if we're going to make a recommendation was 475 so I would say for either
1:11:51 location no less than 450 I I I think we need to kind of set a with the wording of if if the city is
1:11:59 willing to amend the height maybe like shooting for the star trying to get even more.
1:12:05 I don't think we should put a number on it. I think it should be I'm saying a minimum.
1:12:08 It's well minimum's fine but I I don't think we should go maximum.
1:12:11 I'm not giving a maximum. I would say whatever they can afford one that'll be I think first and foremost in their mind and on the location they pick. So if
1:12:20 it's more expensive to build here and it it cost X amount per spot because they have to pour it in place or cast in place then that's going to set the
1:12:26 number for us. If it's on Minnola and it's Finrock and they're doing the the pre-cast stuff then maybe they can go
1:12:34 higher for the same amount of money. I'm just saying our recommendation yes has a have a minimum which this one right now is well below at least the original
1:12:43 plan. And that's why I said that I think a they should be comparable. If we're going to make recommendations for these things, a they should be comparable and
1:12:51 b we should be forward looking knowing that we've probably lost a hundred over here. Yeah.
1:12:57 We're probably going to lose 100 over there depending on what happens to the Hoya property. But that Deoya property was $3.5 million. 3.5 I think it was 3.5
1:13:06 was our offer on that. There's no way that's going to be a $3.5 million parking lot.
1:13:12 I mean, we only got 500 and something to work with.
1:13:15 So, here just real quick, guys. So, we're looking at seventh in Minola. You know, we're talking about maximum height. You You're talking about putting
1:13:23 a fivetory structure right in the middle of everything that is a one-story structure. This just clad cast or
1:13:33 pre-cast structure that's just going to be painted tan, maybe have some peel and stick brick on the side of it. Is that something you really want to have?
1:13:42 right down in the center. Well, it won't it won't be the center.
1:13:47 As we said, it's if things are going west, it won't be the center.
1:13:51 Five years from now, it could be the corner.
1:13:53 Does anybody care that the Winter Garden parking garage is aesthetically pleasing?
1:13:59 They don't. And they want a parking spot and it's there, but it's but it's behind everything. It's not in the middle of everything.
1:14:06 Yeah. But what's Patrick going to on VP?
1:14:09 What's his height? He's going full height there. Three stories.
1:14:12 His hotel hotel is gonna be his hotel is going to be 53. He needs whoever
1:14:20 is going to be more than I'm just just saying because everything that you're backing up to that is on is all the
1:14:28 historic stuff one two story. Just want to just bring that up.
1:14:31 Well, that's a great point and I think if it's built within the next year or two it would stick out. I think looking
1:14:38 forward at the landscape of what it will become, it won't stick out as much.
1:14:44 That's what I That's why I say we're building for 20 years from now. We're not building for And I do have a question. Maybe Todd,
1:14:51 you'll know this. The other two residential properties, they're on Lake in Minnesota.
1:14:56 Has anybody talked to those people about potentially selling?
1:15:00 Uh, you're talking about right there at the corner.
1:15:02 I mean Cathy's old place, right behind the parking lot. They so the guys who developed the corner of Oyola and 7th.
1:15:15 So they put in two big homes, two rentals.
1:15:19 It was Oso Contracting. Jason Stringfellow used actually used to own it. He sold it to them.
1:15:26 I can almost certainly guarantee they're not going to care because they're using that for a home site with a and they
1:15:33 didn't have they right. They were well they were going to use it as a home site with a rental just like they did with the other ones.
1:15:40 What I'm saying though is if you want to maximize that's just looking at it from an aerial
1:15:47 standpoint if you could gain that extra half acre 3/4 of an acre that it is right there. You could get a parking garage that can go from seventh all the way to Lake behind this building.
1:15:57 Yeah. If you buy Dr. uh Early's old place and if you take out the place I mean I'm just for city.
1:16:08 It's great. It It's great idea outside of purview. Yeah, we just have to make that.
1:16:13 But again, you're getting further and further from the merchants.
1:16:16 I think Yeah, I don't think it's I don't think it's unreasonable to say that if the city's going to spend money and time and effort to do this, they should put the most amount of parking spots a site can handle.
1:16:25 So, I think that's like number one for either site. What we're saying is a minimum of 472 or more.
1:16:34 Right. Well, I said 450 in case they wanted to because they were pull there was things to pull away where they might would pull away from the police station
1:16:43 which I don't really support. And then there was bathrooms which would pull some away. So there were some pullaways in case they were. So how do we do we
1:16:50 need to make a motion for each point you want to add or can we because we're having a design okay done and that's when we'll make the
1:16:59 if everybody's agreement that it's going to be no less than 450 then we know that we can say hey we're going to do I agree for this site for that site
1:17:07 I'm sorry% it like anybody else disagree I 100% agree on the number with as far as on seventh and and many
1:17:16 like it just so you wouldn't even vote for the 72 not there just because until that time comes where someone else sets a standard
1:17:25 in the area that says this is this is what the height's going to be then then that would make sense because you're
1:17:32 looking at you know if you listen to when Mr.
1:17:36 was here and council councilwoman Strange her whole thing was is it beautiful? Is it something that makes me want to be here draws me here?
1:17:47 And when I think about something the structure that size based on the renderings we've seen is it's it just doesn't appeal and pull me in.
1:17:57 We could find a way to skin it.
1:17:58 Is there any decay? But is we talk about we talk about parking garages as if they're a park or a nature something a
1:18:06 na a natural feature that people would come and see? It's a parking garage. So is anyone can anyone have any behavioral
1:18:13 sciences data before us that says a parking garage either is pushes people away or draws people in? I think it's more like it does it doesn't do either.
1:18:24 Well, I think Nathan last meeting he from his years and years of experience of doing this, he said that parking garages kind of don't attract people.
1:18:34 Well, they're not supposed to. It's where they park their car. Businesses around them. So, walkab I think walkability begins when you arrive. It's
1:18:42 not You don't go to some place to then walk to someplace else that's attractive. You want to be in the center whether and my recommendation for if
1:18:50 it's behind the courthouse or behind city hall here would be you'd have to do something to get them from there from here all the way over there and then
1:18:59 further down west because if we're talking about walkability and we talk about how walkability ends at the at the parking garage.
1:19:07 I don't necessarily agree that that's important because the walkability will begin when they get out of their car.
1:19:14 Right. And that's like the winter garden parking garage. Same thing. It's set back behind everywhere. You walk out of there, you're on their kind of brick back side of everything and then you walk down through that cut that's urban
1:19:22 on plan and then boom, you're in the middle of there's a lot of homes around that.
1:19:26 There's and Mr. Hutchinson talked about that on the phone yesterday and I would I encourage everyone to give him a call.
1:19:31 He said he'd entertain any call for any questions. But there was there was a big discussion about this and he said it was all political. He said people were coming in saying we don't want a parking
1:19:40 garage and he said now they they build a bigger one in that same spot and it's not a very beautiful parking garage.
1:19:45 But I think to move the conversation ahead we should hear from each person where they land on it because I think you're firmly maximize maximize you guys
1:19:54 are maximiz it's not you could build it as far as
1:20:02 I think reach consensus. So if it's like we have what eight well maximum but yeah but I'm saying if you're going to put a threestory parking
1:20:10 garage on that piece of property down there on 7th of Minnola I think that is a waste of money because it's going to be it'll be full up all the time and
1:20:18 then and everything spreads out when development is going to keep going and we're already going to be stories over here and make it
1:20:26 financially work because there are they're having to pull down electric. There's a lot of things that are going to go into
1:20:34 Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. You can't just go up two stories. So Yeah. But again, that's not for our concern right now. Our concern
1:20:41 it it's not. But if we're only designing two stories, that is part of the design.
1:20:46 That's why I say that that's why you have to have that maximum number. And for me, I'm simple-minded on that side of it. It just has to get as many. We're here to build parking garage.
1:20:56 I'm not here to build retail. And I'm not going to tell the city that they have to be retail owners. If I was sitting on city council, I don't want to
1:21:04 be a landlord. I don't want that hassle of I'm gonna put in the infrastructure.
1:21:09 I'm going to sell the blocks off and then I'm going to sit pay the taxes.
1:21:13 I would agree with you on a li as a liability issue. Yeah. Well, well, 100% on that.
1:21:18 They'd rather have somebody else carry the liability. If the city council is going to continue to approve developments with zero parking, you
1:21:28 know, 16 unit developments with zero parking and also zero parking applies to
1:21:34 De Hoya, then I feel like we should recommend they build the maximum parking spots. It's a party management discussion.
1:21:43 Hoya does not supply de Hoya does not get zero because I know VP just did VP does because they're existing. So
1:21:51 there was a there was a but but still it's it's a trend.
1:21:56 It it can pay the $3,000 and not which is 20% of what we need.
1:22:03 But my understanding is that 3,000 is not for everybody. It was for certain ones that were grandfathered in specific
1:22:12 area or anywhere in that I don't know that the whole for the CBD CBD and there's always extenduating circumstances based around each one.
1:22:20 Yeah.
1:22:20 But we can't get caught on the 3000 because the 3000's there with the idea that we increase the property values and we make money
1:22:28 on the tax on the taxes and on having people downtown sales tax. You're you're we're trying to build something and engineer something that works for a downtown.
1:22:40 But just for ease, can I get an idea of like how you two feel and how you feel about that statement of what one of our
1:22:49 recommendations would be would be regardless of the know how many designs per site can we get? Can we have one that does on each?
1:22:58 Three on each. So, we can have one that maximizes the amount of space, one that is kind of a little bit more moderate and has maybe builtin retail or
1:23:07 something like that. So, I don't I won't really know until I see it sort of thing, but I don't think they can draw it until
1:23:15 we tell them what to We have to give some guidelines. Yeah.
1:23:18 So, uh we can say for it does appear there's consensus for at least 450 on this site. Is that true?
1:23:27 100%. Okay.
1:23:29 And when you say that site, the city hall site. Okay. Yeah.
1:23:32 So we can tell them 450 spaces and so that will at least give us a shell of what it looks like. Minimal thing.
1:23:40 Yep. Minimum 450. So for the other site, we'd also need that so we can have a general guideline to give them because let's say
1:23:49 if it's not the 475 that it was before and not everyone agrees on that and ends up being 425, it will change a lot of it.
1:23:57 But some of that issue and this is where it comes. You need how many people here? Nine people. You need
1:24:06 five votes. So I mean at the end of the day you're counting votes. You know which way is it going to go?
1:24:11 There are people who are going to walk out of here. Tim is not going to be happy with anything that happens over here because it's going to be in his front yard. And I 100% get it.
1:24:20 I I believe the orthodontist is off the committee. Yes. I should have updated.
1:24:26 Dr. Adams resigned from the committee last Friday.
1:24:29 Uh if you're still on the committee and did that uh and uh talked to the media about his beliefs on this, that would have been a sunshine violation. But
1:24:37 because of Yeah. He resigned. It was He's He's circulating a petition to to move people away from that.
1:24:44 My kid was in there and he goes, "Hey, Dad, he's against the garage." I was like, "I already knew that cuz I didn't get to go." That's that's what I got.
1:24:51 So, his his building faces Seventh Street.
1:24:54 So, so we can ask for three drawings for each side.
1:24:57 Correct. So why don't we like city hall we've got one motion that we feel good with that motion but one recommendation is at least 450 spots.
1:25:08 What else would we like and then they can incorporate those into the three drawings for that.
1:25:14 Right. So I think it would go to the number two priority mixed use. So what type of mixed use and what size?
1:25:22 I love the idea of like micro retail. Um since all these incubator spots, West End Plaza and Downtown Exchange are no
1:25:30 longer being used that way, we would we should um foster new entrepreneurs and
1:25:38 give them a space that is reasonably priced to start businesses and and maybe as you said, they could do the
1:25:45 apartment, you know, on this side. On this side, I feel perfectly comfortable doing this one for now. We build the mixed use on that side. Again, I have
1:25:54 I agree with you on this site. I'm just concerned about the water to certain it is. It is buildable. Okay. Good.
1:26:01 And so my concern with over here is I would build a garage that at least similarly matches city hall.
1:26:10 Um so for me, these are two different aesthetics, but I would match city hall as a business owner. And I mean I know
1:26:18 there's a lot of business owners here. I wouldn't put a business at REI. I mean, this is not where I would be trying to put. Which way would the business be facing? Would it be city hall?
1:26:26 But I think that's really for them to help us decide. The thing is, I think if it's the right business, it people will come.
1:26:33 And if I was starting over again and I saw a 500 square foot space priced reasonably, aesthetics of the outside of
1:26:42 the building would be my least the least of my concern.
1:26:45 It would be actually starting the business in the space.
1:26:48 So I don't think we really should care too much.
1:26:52 So we've got a minimum of 450 spots mixed use and then we're kind of asking them where and what type like what what
1:27:00 direction would it be facing and would it be apartment and you know u small retail
1:27:07 they can play with it different designers kind of let them do their thing that they do you know it I think it's on seventh street. The only the
1:27:15 only area you have there, Seventh Street, you're not going to face it west.
1:27:18 Do we want to put in there that it should somehow match with city? Because I I think it should if it's on that side. I think it should somehow match the city.
1:27:28 For this one, I think it should 100% tie to city halls.
1:27:32 You guys, the aesthetics should match with it matching city hall's aesthetics
1:27:42 now. I don't feel it could be wrapped, it could not be wrapped. I am kind of okay either way. I understand that we
1:27:50 don't think retail is going to succeed there. However, from previous planning and soding commission meetings, I have seen that at least it's a trend downtown for a medical professional professional
1:27:59 to come in and they purchase purchase a house and then they turn it into a medical office. In fact, though that section is professional so I think offices on that side.
1:28:09 Yeah. Or else even like a dentist office where you are going to make an appointment, you're going to go that business, an accountant, something like that.
1:28:18 Something like that could work. Service type of business, right? And if it's free coffee, I'm walking.
1:28:23 So like, you know, like because I I'm looking for, you know, she may do something yesterday that it is an advantage in the sense that no,
1:28:31 generally speaking, professionals, people who work in offices have higher salaries. They purchase more goods from downtown. I think that would work well.
1:28:39 So, what specifically do we want when we're talking about mixed use? Because I've heard a lot of ideas, but I just want some clarification. I'll let you know there's first floor mixed use,
1:28:47 there's lined mixuse, you put on the second story, third story. Do we have any general idea? And also size-wise, how
1:28:55 per personally I business professional on that site, retail commercial on that and I'm with you on the same. So, give me the street so I can so we can write.
1:29:05 So, City Hall would be Seventh Street.
1:29:07 Seventh Street. Uh, the other one I see mostly Minola Street and some really small ones on what do you call the pedestrian pedestrian.
1:29:20 So, no way you're going to get city hall that 18.
1:29:24 No, because your your parking is right there. Your ingress egress is right there.
1:29:30 You don't think there's room for next to the sidewalk?
1:29:33 Yes. So, I think they asking on this site right here.
1:29:38 It would be it's considered service retail. Service retail.
1:29:42 So that would be like accountants dentist on the seventh street for the city hall parking garage.
1:29:50 And we want this lined or do we want this as an entire floor of this? No, it's lined. Line short like you said 20 by 40.
1:30:00 Yeah, like 40 foot depth I think would be kind of what you're looking. That's what 20 by 40 is.
1:30:05 That's 800. So you're talking about 4 to 800. That Yeah.
1:30:09 That price where somebody starting their business can afford it cuz Yeah. Okay. Did we get many votes for restrooms?
1:30:17 No. Oh, we haven't.
1:30:18 I don't think I've ever seen a restroom in a parking garage. Yeah. Seems like a safety hazard. This one is walking signal. You can't use the street.
1:30:26 Well, the rest is closed.
1:30:28 On the outside. You can put it on the outside. Maybe you you have a bra thing, don't you? There's one right there.
1:30:35 What's the conditions of that if it's not locked? Oh, is it does that lock?
1:30:38 Yeah, they issue with them.
1:30:43 Yeah, during events there there are some management conversations we can have about that.
1:30:47 So, um that that can be part of the design, but there was Well, I'm just thinking real quick just out speaking out loud if we know like
1:30:56 are the conditions of the restrooms across the street there are they good, bad, okay? I mean, is it
1:31:05 something where there's so that building has reached its useful life? Does it get knocked down that extensive parking lot and then maybe you build new restaurants, too?
1:31:13 There were some issues a couple years ago where that the drains were not installed properly and they backed up.
1:31:21 But I haven't heard that complaint in quite a while. The the complaint I hear now is they they forgot to lock them. Yes, that's the issue there.
1:31:30 So, did we finish the use for the city hall.
1:31:34 Well, I was I'm sorry. I was I was incorporating restrooms into mixed use. Okay.
1:31:38 Oh, because I was saying you're talking about, you know, what would you build? Yeah. Number one and number two. Mixed use.
1:31:46 Based on code, there may be some bathroom requirements if there's a number of retail, but well, they would have to have their own.
1:31:55 That's not single.
1:31:57 You do single sort of thing. So, there's That's mechanical.
1:32:02 Yeah. And I think Winter Garden, they got some sort of concession because they they only had
1:32:10 the second story restrooms for a while down there and the individual stores didn't have public restroom yet.
1:32:17 So they all shared that restroom. Yeah.
1:32:20 Okay. So Seven Street I think Mrs. street.
1:32:23 I I was just going to bring up if we going to suggest three per site would one of them not have the mixeduse
1:32:32 model because I don't want to hit a such a hard roadblock with council that if they don't want to be landlords if they
1:32:39 don't want to manage we going to make a suggestion on all three models on each site with this mixed use that may create
1:32:46 a roadblock for us that they say that's not what we signed up for.
1:32:50 So I think that would be Anyways, because if there is the restriction in the seventh site, yeah, we need to have one drawing.
1:32:59 That's just Yeah. And I think for both.
1:33:01 Is there anything else over here that anybody's really dying for? So, we got mixed juice and we've got a maximum height. I think that's that
1:33:09 I do, but kind of that Well, then what else? you're going to want to add in and no I said like this is something that I want to kind of like bounce off you and
1:33:16 yes I agree with you like probably we should one of the design should be so then one of the recommendations is one design to just be parking
1:33:24 maximize the other one just parking lot
1:33:32 build your best box on this side on the seventh
1:33:40 city So, we have the north side of a garage, which will be the south side of that green. I was thinking that it will be a good spot to have something that is
1:33:49 maybe more civic, more entertainment in nature. We're losing our library. Um, I don't know if this will be a good opportunity to have a small library
1:33:57 there. The problem is that libraries don't make money. Another option would be to try to get like a public private partnership to have like a theater, like
1:34:05 a cinema. I saw one in uh Coral Gables which is run by the Coral uh cable
1:34:12 cinema our cinema. So there's the cinema and then on top of that the city built like an eight story parking garage. The city runs the garage but too big. I'm
1:34:22 not saying that we should build but I appreciate what you're saying. Yeah.
1:34:25 Uh but basically just a spot so that people can go there and they can we could have like stand up company. They could rent that out do like have
1:34:33 speeches. they could like watch a movie, things like that. Something that people can use on that side that looks nice and
1:34:40 that hopefully activates that part because they rejected the idea of the this spot. I feel because of the the
1:34:49 mental image about not going higher than city hall, I think we're limited.
1:34:54 And if you start putting in theaters and libraries, Yeah. you're really sacrificing some parking.
1:35:00 And you have to remember that the feeling of city council recently is not to be putting in amphitheaters and
1:35:09 things like on the waterfront to do exactly what you were talking about.
1:35:14 So to convince they say no to the waterfront, but let's go ahead and take it away from the parking structure. I I think that'd be a hard thing to say.
1:35:22 Yeah. One last final idea, and this is going to be a stretch, but we rent the van. We drive all the way to the Trader Joe's headquarters and we somehow
1:35:30 convince the CEO to put a Trader Joe's right there. We'll be heroes. We can go all the way 15 floors. Oh, that's easy. All you need is people with income.
1:35:39 So, here's here comes the problem. And this goes back to what Bill was talking about with Amendment Three.
1:35:46 I don't care what anybody says, amendment three is going to pass. It's just going to pass.
1:35:51 And I'm just going to tell you that the idea that city council is going to build
1:35:58 retail at that cost is just I I cannot imagine them saying yes in the
1:36:06 conditions that they're going to be with amendment three. I I just don't see how they do it.
1:36:12 I I agree with you. It's unrealistic. I think it's an interesting conversation to have and I don't think that it's wrong to say, "Hey, here's a design that
1:36:20 you can have. I'm going to 100% tell you I don't know how they do it. I don't know how they get around it." The de Hoya property, the conversation was we
1:36:29 buy it, we put the infrastructure in, we cut off the piece that we need for ArtWalk. And then our infrastructure is
1:36:36 in and it's sold. And we make enough money because we broke it into blocks that are purchasable for the average amount of
1:36:44 utilities and like Yeah. So all of that stuff's moved.
1:36:48 We've already having conversations where the city could give them a design build here. We've already designed this. You
1:36:57 can move in here. You know, all of the infrastructure is already in and we've already done all your
1:37:04 architecture. It's approved. It's a fast track. You can be up and running in six months. I mean, that's an amazing
1:37:12 opportunity for a business who's coming in with dollars to say, "Look, I got a, you know, a million dollars need a lot
1:37:20 and two stories or three stories, whatever they end up with." So, the the arts are definitely underfunded in Claremont.
1:37:28 No, 100%. And I don't think it I don't think it hurts us to ask for one design perhaps to include
1:37:36 something like that. It doesn't again they can reject it immediately but our
1:37:41 job is present three great sus you're not going to get that underneath if we felt like that was a great idea.
1:37:54 Why not at either location? Why why just that one?
1:37:57 It's a different vibe. I I know if it makes sense. In my mind, that area is so valuable that it kind of has to be
1:38:05 retail. It has not retail. It has to be commercial.
1:38:08 Hey, were you here when we had a theater downtown?
1:38:11 I was not. I know. I know that the black box was here downtown.
1:38:15 And I think it can be like a great thing to have. You guys agree with that putting it in that garage.
1:38:21 Yeah, sure. This was just my observation. I'm hoping to I think the Hoya needs to put a roller rink at the top of their building. I
1:38:29 mean, when you start when you start allowing businesses to come in here and as successful as the roller thing was up
1:38:36 at the art, if somebody comes in here and wants to put a nice facility for
1:38:43 arts or whatever the case may be, it needs to be privately owned. Um, what's the one in downtown Orlando that's really nice? Dr. Phillips. Dr. Phillips.
1:38:52 Is that Is it the Dr. Philips Performing Arts Center. So, we went there southside. Holy cow.
1:38:59 And they had multiple things going on.
1:39:01 So, I get it. But even as busy as it was there the one night that I've gone, cuz I'm not going to Orlando that often, I
1:39:09 guarantee you they're still losing their ass on it. Just like they do with the convention center. I mean, that convention center is so
1:39:16 No, you're wrong. I will on the convention center. 100%.
1:39:21 Well, see, so you only got part of the The convention center has been $3 billion since the inception, but has actually spun out $30 billion in revenue.
1:39:29 Wow. Back to the county. The arch. I'm big in the TD stuff.
1:39:33 So I I've always been told that the convention center.
1:39:37 That's the spin that people want to put on it.
1:39:40 But the convention center itself doesn't pay its own. No, we got we're tax. We're in Orlando.
1:39:47 It's not even in the same city or county. It's like I could say I contribute to downtown because I bring a lot of people downtown, but it doesn't help me pay my
1:39:56 own bills. Yeah, it's I don't think we have enough people that are are wanting that. I don't think it's wrong to say
1:40:05 one of the drawings to include some type of but I you know again if they turn it down that's not up to us.
1:40:10 Sure. You know if residents want it then they should come out.
1:40:14 Park Pal's got paid for by residents not by tax dollars. Oh, no.
1:40:19 Residents paid for that in old Claremont. We did that a lot. Yeah.
1:40:25 Claremont wanted something. We had some land and we went and said, "You know what? We're going to fund this through our own collections." I I have a daughter in the arts.
1:40:34 Yeah.
1:40:35 And I've looked at how do you make a successful theater where you work with
1:40:42 kids or right there with you.
1:40:46 It's an education. Yeah, but if it doesn't if it doesn't pay keep the lights on then
1:40:53 park is actually the name of the fun just the shell of a parking garage
1:41:00 and one with public utilities library or it's a little easier to say.
1:41:05 Can can everybody get behind this? We say three drawings. One is pure parking power. That's what we're concerned about.
1:41:12 One is going to be mixed use and then one is going to include some sort of public utility like library or theater or something.
1:41:21 I did want just for your direction. I know we talked about on Seventh Street of this project there would be some sort
1:41:29 of service retail space. Is there another street that we would recommend a different type of mixed use?
1:41:38 You're talking here on city hall?
1:41:39 Yes. Yes, sir. I mean it would either be seventh or doto and I think Dodto just doesn't have the I mean you got a storage facility across the street.
1:41:49 So you so so we're fine just saying yeah because that storage facility is in or was in discussions to turn it into town homes I think.
1:41:57 So anything it's never going to be on on the south side I think has to be appointment you going there on purpose.
1:42:07 Yeah. Whereas on the Minola Street, you're oh gee, look, here's a new store. I haven't seen it before. I'll go in. So, right, you've got two different types of
1:42:15 businesses because I'm like I'm probably the like when I happen upon a parking garage, we go to Dr. Phil for every show.
1:42:26 I'm just I don't care what the parking garage looks. I'm just so happy I found one. Oh, 100%.
1:42:31 Yeah. I will pay. Tell me how much to pay you. I will pay you right now. I'm probably not the average customer either because I think you are I think you are. It's
1:42:39 it's what I talked about the guy at Winter Garden. He's you know people don't care when I walk out
1:42:46 very much if you live next to an ugly parking garage that was 20 bucks I think to park at the expensive I was going to say I think I paid 20 bucks when we were there. I was
1:42:54 like but then when I walk out and I'm walking to the Dr. Phil and I'm like wow they really did a great job with the lighting here. I love this brick. So like it both
1:43:01 have a place but I think if you're coming downtown looking for parking you care about parking first 100% and then you want to look at everything else. So, I think we got to mix both.
1:43:12 But I think when when we find that parking garage and we pull in and we get out of our car, immediately there's a feeling
1:43:20 that you're right. No, you're like, gee, this is this is a pretty nice parking garage.
1:43:25 You know, I'm not bumping into the car next to me. Yeah. You know, I feel safe.
1:43:30 Yeah. And there's one parking garage that it's like you press the elevator and you wonder whether you'll make it down downtown Orlando. and we hate that
1:43:37 parking garage and we like the other one because it's, you know, so is that everything that we're looking for at city hall?
1:43:44 So, we're looking for one drawing parking only, one mixeduse, one with some type of artistic or community aspect to it.
1:43:53 Yeah, that works.
1:43:54 And I think all of this like we'll revisit this next week when we get some of the stipulations on Seventh and Minnola.
1:44:02 Who who thinks for Seventh and Minnola by a show of hands we need to ask for 450 parking spots?
1:44:13 Bill, do you have a vote? Hold on. Jason just texted. Hey, hey, hey.
1:44:18 As a minimum, you should be very careful with that, Bill.
1:44:21 Bill, be very careful with that. That text becomes that text becomes part of four 450 or
1:44:29 more minimum I would go for seventh in mini.
1:44:34 Yeah I would be interested to see what is the by by current code what is
1:44:41 the maximum height you know if if we go with a 9 foot ceiling instead of a 10 475 was their maximum they went above it
1:44:50 only because of the roof. Now they could have gone to a fifth story but then the whole structure would have been above it. Yeah. Okay.
1:44:56 But but but I think the starting off point is we have how many votes that we want to ask for? So that's four to four.
1:45:04 Wait on he's count.
1:45:09 So then we would still put that in there. Yes. That would be to majority. Yeah.
1:45:14 Um what else? And I feel like we're going to mimic some of the same things because I think
1:45:22 we're we do want to ask for is mixed use possible and what would it look like?
1:45:28 So on that one I and I would go mixed use on that one specifically retail ground floor small apartments
1:45:38 similar to the way that I love what she did with hers and great on that one if we could mimic coastal style that would
1:45:46 with what's being built in the parking lot of West End.
1:45:49 So yeah almost bring some of that in there. New Orleans kind of. Yeah. So, it kind of all looks the same.
1:45:56 So, let me ask you a question. And Patrick, if you're watching, I apologize.
1:46:01 Um, are we sure that those will be built? I know they've been approved, but there's no dirt being moved yet. And so,
1:46:10 do we want He hasn't even put in a permit yet. Those are just conceptions.
1:46:15 Yeah. Yeah. And so we want to try to match something that might not actually be.
1:46:21 So council will decide whether they like ours that we're just giving recommendations. They can they can obviously say that was the worst group we have ever appointed.
1:46:32 So should we say we do want it to match the the idea of the surrounding property?
1:46:38 Isn't there a the study though that's due in October that addresses some of this too, right? the new downtown plan they're going to come up with from DPZ.
1:46:46 Yeah, Patrick's is absolutely going to get built.
1:46:49 DPZ is not going to get down into the fine nitty-gritty that it has to look New Orleans style.
1:46:54 They're going to get into how it interacts with the roads and the sidewalks and that kind of thing. But, you know, for me,
1:47:03 one of the things I would say about Claremont is that when I was on council especially that I wanted to be eclectic and a little bit weird. You wanted
1:47:11 people to look at it and be like, "What the were they thinking?" Kind of cool where you look at it and be like, "Okay, that's not the direction I would have gone, but that's really
1:47:19 cool." And if I had tons of money and own downtown on all my second and third floors, I would have balconies to watch the Christmas parade.
1:47:29 Yeah. So if we're going to put a parking structure on Minnola that the Christmas parade goes down somehow on the Minnola
1:47:37 side, there has to be an area doesn't go down anymore that you can watch the parade go by. So a balcony.
1:47:43 Well, not necessarily a balcony, but at least an opening between the walls or Well, that's usually you'll see that.
1:47:50 Well, that's what I said. Having a 10ft walkway is going to be up on the top down.
1:47:54 We need to have it. It's mute over here, but on that building and can we charge people?
1:48:01 Yeah, but but there should be a there should be a viewing area of things going by on the street.
1:48:07 So, with that said, let's talk about seven specifically. Mhm.
1:48:12 I don't know if we use all the three options that we have with such hard lines of this is mixeduse, this is
1:48:21 building only, this is whatever the third option is going to become another conversation. I have a firm belief that
1:48:30 even being innovative innovative that the without mixed use option is going to
1:48:37 weigh heavily in terms of cost and execution. So why not use two out of the three options which without so much of
1:48:47 the mixeduse conversation but more I can get behind that all day. what what you know what he said an observation the
1:48:55 council is looking for how can we make it beautiful and not be an isore but how can we keep you know I don't know if I'm
1:49:05 100% on board of using spaces for this mixed use because I am afraid the city is not going to take on the commitment
1:49:11 of managing all this real estate sell them all this yeah they would either sell them off or they would use a third party real estate management
1:49:19 company to manage I'm with you that we can't make that decision until we get the feedback that was being asked for
1:49:26 earlier by Rocky that can we even do anything with that because I'm not going to support taking away any parking spaces from over
1:49:35 here. I mean, we can't lose that lot, right? So, if we can build onto the front of it and sort of wrap it, I'll 100% support that if it's a if it's doable.
1:49:44 I mean, in the interest of time, it's 449. Do we want to table yeah table seventh until next week when
1:49:53 we know the stipulations I think that would be that would be wise right because right now we can't keep discussing this with
1:50:00 one design which is the pair down design maximum parking so at least the designer has something to work with and yeah they can start on something they can start with the one without
1:50:09 mixed use my thing for mixed use is revenue stream n I don't know if that should be the driver I think paid parking would be enough.
1:50:20 Yeah, you got paid parking. The other thing that just recently came that came to fruition is in last week's Orange
1:50:27 County TDT citizens task force. They are going to give money to the Citrus Bowl to build a parking garage.
1:50:34 Oh, they need the Citrus Bowl does not put heads over there.
1:50:37 The same thing with Dr. Phillips and all these other things that they're doing.
1:50:41 So what that's done is that's actually set a precedent where Lake Countyy's TDT funds a whopping three to four million dollars. The city of Claremont can then
1:50:49 go and ask Lake County, you're too far south. No, no, you'll get it. You'll get it.
1:50:54 You'll get it because the events that we host here with all the sports stuff because that actually does bring tourism
1:51:02 in here whether it's the rowing, the triathlons, all those things. So that's your revenue stream on top of Allison has that number and we produce I
1:51:11 think it was 70% y of the TDC dollars and we get less than 50. Yeah.
1:51:18 And we pushed hard for that. Well, she has pushed because she knew those numbers back and forth. She has pushed really hard and it's still an uphill
1:51:25 battle. So just because it's there doesn't mean we're going to get it. And plus with amendment three is already going to be there.
1:51:33 Yeah. TD is restricted by um statute.
1:51:38 It can only be used market and or enhance. No, I mean what what funds a TV?
1:51:43 Well, see the what funds that that that's a bed tax. It's a 4% bed tax.
1:51:49 The committee who oversees the bed tax allocation is made up of a couple appointed politicians
1:51:56 uh event people, collective people. And when I was there, rather than people who had events and
1:52:04 generated, you know, we have an event, we've got a thousand people coming to town, they're going to pay bed tax. And
1:52:12 they say that's great. But then the hotel years were the ones who decided how to spend the bed tax.
1:52:19 And they were very, very frugal giving money to the event people.
1:52:25 They would rather give coupons to the hotel people. Okay.
1:52:29 So, it was like you had your generators and you had your collectors and the collectors were in charge of the dispensing and that's what Allison run
1:52:38 up against is we collect it but they tell us how to spend it. Gotcha.
1:52:44 But yeah, if if it's available, it's a good idea. So, I do think that we're kind of we're at a part where we've got
1:52:51 a lot accomplished for city hall and then once we have the pure stipulations, a lot accomplished for that one, too. I
1:52:58 mean, if we can't make that choice, that's going to be a stony can you do anything with the front of that, either we can or we can't, right? Yeah. And and then I think if we
1:53:07 can't and the only thing we can do is try to maximize parking, then maybe we lean more about the pedestrian
1:53:14 hostilities, the beauty of the out like I think then we kind of push it toward. Yeah.
1:53:20 Because that's going to solve some of her, you know, how do we put that art in there? How do we make it interesting?
1:53:27 How do we make it weird? I mean, at the end of the day, I love Have you been interesting because like I Have you been to Seattle? Mm- Weird's not always good, man.
1:53:38 Not that weird. Find out next month.
1:53:41 Eclectic is what Main Street around 10. You'll find out. My wife here and walked to Lumberyard.
1:53:50 Now, we were we're trying to get miles in. I underestimated how far it was from here to Lumber and you were going downhill.
1:54:02 Yeah. See how far it is when you come back.
1:54:04 because we had to come back. We got stuck without cars. But so, so I agree like it's kind of it we're an odd city and that a lot of the growth I think is going to be pulling toward that area.
1:54:16 So in my mind before we did all of this, you had a parking garage at 7th in Minnola and you
1:54:25 had one at West in Minnola. You came in on Minnola, you went to the parking garages, you went out on Minnola and you either hit East Avenue or you hit 12th
1:54:33 and you were out. And that was the way that you brought people in and out. And you could still close West Minola for for Bill and all of those vendors. You
1:54:42 could close all of Montro. You could close all of 8th Street and you could have a big giant downtown party and pile as many people
1:54:51 in here and really not have a lot of interaction between pedestrians and cars because they're coming in off the two
1:54:59 main roads. I mean, well, the reality is this is a great problem. I mean, 10 years ago, no one came down.
1:55:07 Remember what I what I said when I got approved for down here? I said I could come and sit on uh they asked me how I like uh the downtown. And so my wife
1:55:15 before we agreed to come here, we we came down two nights, two Friday nights in a row with food and we sat at
1:55:23 right around 7 p.m. One time on on Montro and the other time in Mola where we were going to end up.
1:55:30 So they asked me how I felt about it. I said, "Well, it's it's a nice town. I believe in your plan." I said, "But you know, I could kill two people and sit on their bodies till 7 a.m. on mantros and
1:55:38 no one would find me. Well, that was the same thing I heard Jimmy Crawford say as well. You know, back in the day, you could actually set up a card table in the middle of the road and and play cards.
1:55:45 But I said, "My my problem with with that is," and they said, "You just killed two people." I said, "No, I'd have to find two people to kill."
1:55:52 So, the actual busiest place in downtown in the old days was at that parking lot when it was the Elks Lodge.
1:56:01 And that's what I hear. Yeah.
1:56:02 That was what you know, that was it.
1:56:05 Yeah. You had well you only had Elks what they called on the corner. I don't remember what it was before that Rusty something.
1:56:12 That's it. Grunts and then Rusty Fox and then you had Rusty Fox all the way down there which was Billy's or something. I mean could be way way back.
1:56:21 Grunts was Bob's at one time.
1:56:23 Yep. I mean, this is a great I mean, the problem is and I was shocked at the amount of usage on event nights and
1:56:31 but then I was also shocked at the number of parking spots that are still open and trying to get people to walk even you know
1:56:39 it's like we have a big issue like at least from my perspective we have a big issue with just transportation management overall.
1:56:46 Yeah, that's how we have a shuttle problem. I almost stopped because I was like, man, if we could find a way to shuttle people from waterfront
1:56:53 like Maldora has freebies for example. I don't know if you have gotten those, but those are very useful. Like freebies are like these small very teenytiny electric
1:57:00 vehicles almost like golf carts and it is a company. It's like a private public partnership.
1:57:06 They have advertising. No, it's it's free for the person. Like they make their money out of advertisement and the city pays them uh some amount of money,
1:57:14 but basically it's a shuttle and some cities have it like a circular small shuttle or sometimes you can order one.
1:57:20 So you weren't here when we had the trolley.
1:57:23 I was not here when you had the here for a year and a half.
1:57:26 It's that parked in in the pit down there for what nine months and they sold that.
1:57:31 But we have to find a way to effectively allow people to move around downtown.
1:57:36 Yes. So the We may end up having to well we won't but council may have to have that conversation of how what are we going to
1:57:43 do when we lose these parking lots because if we've lost that one and we lose this one there's 200 parking spots gone that is really tough place. So
1:57:52 maybe they do do a and it's neat because we looked at it they use tuggers so the things that they pull airplanes with that's what pulls those little
1:58:00 trolley sets. So you have a tugger and then you have just little things and you can rightize it for the event. Um the
1:58:08 conversation that we had and it went sideways for politics reasons. Um but when we when there was a discussion
1:58:17 about taking the historic village and putting it under um what committee are you on?
1:58:25 Main Street. So, putting that under Main Street, they would have been able to store all of that stuff there and they
1:58:32 were going to be doing walking tours as well as tour tours for downtown. So, they had all of this stuff planned out
1:58:40 and then whatever happened between Main Street and that. So, there is a possibility
1:58:47 that that comes back up one day and it really should because the historic village would be better under Main Street. Main Street would then have the
1:58:54 ability to store the infrastructure that they need to be able to do those walking tours and then also be able to park people. And Mr.
1:59:04 Ellis has that depression over here that used to be West Lake. Used to be the junkyard for that you could park at.
1:59:13 I It's in the flood plan. Yeah, I know what you mean.
1:59:15 But you could park there as long as it's not flooding that night. Um, you also when we did the fire department took
1:59:23 over the old um facility, the old repair facility. Um that was one of my things was that I wanted to make sure that that
1:59:32 grass parking stayed there because you've also got the baseball field there. So you could just run down that road, pick people up, and come back in.
1:59:39 So there may be something that council has to look at to to feed the vendors in that meantime. I agree with that.
1:59:46 But what that is, that's a council issue, not a I have to go back to work. Uh, should I just keep working on the No, I think we're meeting this meeting. All right.