Clermont City Council Workshop Transcript 7/8/26
7:11 Um, commissioners, you should have received the minutes from the June 2nd meeting. If there are no additions,
7:18 corrections, or questions, I will entertain a motion and a second for approval. I have one tiny correction.
7:25 Go ahead. On the very last page where it says motion to recommend approval of ordinance 20261-021,
7:34 we already approved that on the page before that needs to say 26 2026-022
7:41 because we've already got two 21 on the page before that and we uh combine them together. So one tiny correction.
7:48 Okay. Are there but that I'll make a motion to Are there any other corrections?
7:53 I'll make a motion to approve with the correction. with the correction. Okay. Do I have a second? Second. All in favor?
8:00 I I.
8:01 That is unanimous. Uh we will now move to uh commissioner reports. I will start to my far right with commissioner Hoisington.
8:12 Um oh I I attended the city Junth
8:19 program. Um it was very very good. Could I invite everyone next year to please find time to come down and celebrate Junth with us? And that's all I have.
8:28 All right. Thank you very much, Commissioner Kramer.
8:31 Thank you. I just want to begin by saying how pleased I am to see the ordinance around dark sky compliance tonight. So, this is one of the first
8:40 times I've really looked forward to one of these meetings because I think a lot of people know that that's been something I've advocated for a long time. Um, but I also want to recognize
8:49 and thank our staff and the legal department for the considerable amount of work that went into bringing this ordinance forward. So, um, I appreciate
8:56 this opportunity for us to have the discussion tonight around something I feel very important. Thank you. Thank you, Commissioner Neck.
9:03 Yes. I'd like to thank all those patriots for coming out in the weather for Fourth of July for the Clermont 250. Uh, once again, thank you and thank
9:13 you for showing your support. No other report. Thank you. And Commissioner Ensuo, I just want to apologize for being a bit
9:20 tardy. I spent the fourth of I spent the 4th of July taught uh potty training a 2-year-old. So, it's been a it's been a
9:27 lot of fun. So, yeah. Yeah, for sure. For sure. You are president and account for it.
9:33 So, Exactly.
9:34 Thank you for making it. Um I just wanted to to point out one community event that we have coming up, the Lake County Hobnob. And um the venue host is
9:43 City of Clermont. Alo at the Clermont Performing Arts Center on Monday the 27th will be a hobnob where people can meet people running for city, county,
9:52 state, and federal office. And that is a free event and it's from 5 to 7:30. So I just wanted to make that known. Uh
10:00 before we move into unfinished and new business, uh commissioners will report any disclosures they have on any of
10:08 tonight's items. Please report which agenda item, subject matter, and identify the person's groups you may have communicated with. Um, if there is
10:17 more than one, please report them individually. As a reminder to commissioners to be transparent with the public, disclose any exparte
10:26 communication written or verbal in commissioner investigations, site visits, expert opinions received and
10:33 communications um being read tonight into the record must be disclosed um at the public meeting um where final action
10:41 will be taken. um by making disclosure any such activities, actions and communication shall not be presumed
10:50 prejuditial and allows persons who have opinions to the contrary a reasonable opportunity to refute and respond. Um so
11:00 um if anybody would like to make disclosures, I'll start to my far left.
11:03 Um Commissioner Ensua, any disclosures you would like to make? No disclosures at this time.
11:08 Commissioner Neck, no disclosure at this time as well.
11:12 Commissioner Kramer, no disclosures.
11:15 Commissioner Hoisington, no disclosures, sir.
11:18 And the chair has no disclosures at this time either. Um, having addressed the the disclosures, uh, we'll now move into
11:26 unfinished and new business. Um, before we have the city staff and applicant um, present, um,
11:34 um, we will now need to handle um, the items of the agenda individually. So,
11:42 um, we will start with item number one and we'll hear city staff on item number one, which is is resolution 2026-021R.
12:06 Good evening, planning and zoning commissioners and guests. Justine day with development services.
12:12 The applicant Peacock Partnership is requesting a conditional use permit to allow for a veterary clinic to operate on a property that is currently
12:20 undergoing site review. The property is located at the southeast corner of South US Highway 27 and Citrus Tower Boulevard
12:28 intersection within the Governor's Lake Commerce Center plan unit development.
12:33 On your screen, the parcel is outlined in yellow.
12:39 and just a zoomed in view of the parcel.
12:44 The applicant is proposing to build out a new animal clinic with the future multi-tenant shell building. The clinic will operate entirely indoors and offer
12:53 services such as checkups, diagnosis, dental care, and minor surgery to small animals. No overnight boarding or the
13:01 treatment of large animals such as livestock will be provided. Business hours will be Monday through Friday from 7:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m. and Saturday from
13:09 8:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m. The clinic will be preparing a waste management plan that includes an internal pet relief area. In the future, they may add an
13:18 outdoor relief area with a monitored waste station.
13:29 And just to show the concept plan, they will be going into a future multi-tenant building.
13:37 The property is governed by ordinance number 2020-24, which allows for mixeduse development with C1 light commercial uses. The
13:46 veterary clinic may be comparable to retail or medical office use with this within this district due to the services being offered. Additionally, the parcel
13:54 is situated between commercial development on the north, south, and west sides of the parcel, while Lake Falter provides a buffer on the east
14:02 side. The nearest residential use is approximately 1,00 ft away across South US Highway 27 and the nearest veterary
14:11 clinic is approximately 1 and a half miles away, south of the Hart Hartwood Marsh Road. Based on the site's
14:19 locations and surrounding uses, staff finds the proposed use compatible with the district and would not be more obnoxious to the existing permitted uses.
14:29 When evaluating a request for a conditional use permit, section 1012 of the land development code outlines specific development standards that are
14:37 required to be met. Staff has reviewed the application and finds the proposed use can meet the general criteria for approval and would not be detrimental to
14:46 the health, safety, and welfare of the surrounding community. Therefore, staff recommends approval of resolution number 2026-01R.
14:56 This concludes staff presentation.
14:58 Thank you very much. Uh we now like to hear from the applicant.
15:10 Good evening, commissioners. My name is uh Jim Graham. I'm with City Vet. Um our the applicant is actually Peacock Partnership. That's their our architect.
15:20 Um but yeah, really I'm just I'm just here to answer any questions you all may have. Um and we really think we'll be a
15:28 great uh service and an amenity to the community.
15:32 All right. Well, thank you very much and please stand by because the commissioners may have some questions. Be happy to. Thank you.
15:37 Thank you. All right. Uh we'll now um um open it up for um public comment. Uh
15:45 if there's anybody here um who would like to come up and and speak in the the public hearing section of our meeting, uh please come up at this time.
15:55 Anybody like to speak on this item?
15:58 Hearing no one, uh, we will close the public hearing and we will go to the commission. So, I will start to my far right with Commissioner Hoisington.
16:08 Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Um, I in reviewing this, I see that it's built within the multi-tenant space. The
16:17 hours are reasonable. Um, when I first started reading, I was worried about um the waste management, but they addressed that. They're not going to service any
16:26 large animals. The one question that I had, the staff report says that the clinic will not provide overnight boarding or offering care to large
16:34 animals such as livestock etc. But then in the resolution 202621R
16:43 section 2 number three it talks about
16:50 um when it's medically necessary for overnight observation and monitoring may be allowed on site overnight.
16:58 So I'm wondering why is there a conflict between that statement and this one?
17:04 So that was put in as a in the occurrence of something happening
17:13 that they have that just for medical necessity. Um sometimes at least from my
17:20 previous experience uh animals will come in late or like right before a clinic is closing that could have an emergency situation.
17:31 It's a lot better for the animal if they're able to help the animal in that case, which may bleed into
17:40 extending the overnight or extending their business hours or potentially overnight depending on if they need to be
17:48 one surgically evaluated and then to um find a facility for them to actually give the overnight like an ER,
17:58 right? And I understand that. Yeah. And when I read that there will be no overnight, I thought, what if there's an emergency with an animal that the
18:05 surgery did not go as well or the owner can't pick the animal up? The the the applicant has stood up. Maybe he can uh expand upon that.
18:13 I just wonder why the report was different than the resolution.
18:17 Sure. We we we tend to make a designation between boarding and hospitalization.
18:25 So, for example, a a you know, you wouldn't go to the hospital and say, "Hey, I I I need a room for the night."
18:32 Um, similar situation, a a customer cannot bring their pet to us and just say, "Hey, I'm I'm going on vacation. I
18:40 need you to watch my pet overnight." That that's not going to happen. So, yes, if there are any medical procedures, really, the only time an
18:48 animal will be kept overnight is in regard to a medical procedure. and then that customer is paying for that medical
18:55 procedure. They're not they're not build for boarding or anything like that. And again, they just can't bring their their pet to us and say, "We'd like you to
19:04 keep our pet overnight." And in most cases, if if those animals um are kept overnight, they're sedated. They're in
19:12 their kennels. They're they're nice and comfortable and hopefully resting and recuperating. Okay. Thank you. Thank you.
19:19 That's all I have. Okay.
19:21 Thank you, Commissioner Kramer.
19:24 Um, I think this one's pretty straightforward for me tonight and um, I think Commissioner Hoisington brought up most of the things. I only had one question says more for staff.
19:34 Um, because it's a multi-tenant commercial center. Are we satisfied that the parking calculation accounts not
19:42 only for city vet but for the cumulative demand once the remaining 10 spaces are occupied? So currently right now they
19:50 are over the amount I believe they're providing 96 uh spaces and for just the retail towards the north and the vet
20:00 they're required 27. So they are more than enough currently. We are unsure of the use on the middle tenant so far.
20:07 Well you answered that quite nicely just thank you very much. That's all I have. All right Commissioner Neck.
20:14 Thank you Mr. Chairman. Uh, number one, I'd like to point out to staff that online, the exceptional plan is online, but it's not in my packet.
20:26 Are we saving money? I asked this question numerous times. I'm not here to beat up my staff. I think they're doing a phenomenal job, but it's not in my packet.
20:37 Okay?
20:39 And maybe it's not in my packet. Does anybody else have it? No.
20:44 All right. cuz you know I'm a stickler for that. That was a very good question, Mr. Kramer. And I'm sure that you got that answer by looking online.
20:54 So my question to staff is, are we going to be doing away with our packets and just doing everything online or are we going to be more thorough and making sure we get a full packet?
21:06 Okay, that's number one. Number two, I would like to ask the applicant in your own words, how is this going to benefit Clermont?
21:18 How's it going to benefit Clermont? I I assume that a significant portion of your residents are pet owners. Um, we
21:27 provide really top-notch service and on top of that, we're we're a little different than other vet providers. Um,
21:35 a lot of your national corporate providers, say a Bfield, um, number of the others, the the vet is
21:42 just an employee. At our locations, our vet is an owner. They are a partner with
21:49 us at City Vet. So, um, you have a veterinarian that's going to live here,
21:56 work here, play here, and be a part of your community as we hope that this clinic will be and be a good good service provider to your community.
22:06 That was a great answer considering that you have a lot of vets and clinics surrounding you from Hartwood Mos
22:13 straight on down. that that is something that when we look at a potential new location, something that we do take into
22:20 consideration, we look at at the overall population within a certain radius around that site and then also look at
22:29 the competition and we would not have chosen this location if we didn't think that there was demand and the growth
22:37 that would would uh make this clinic successful. Now, being a pet owner, I would like to answer uh ask one question
22:44 uh to follow up on uh Commissioner Hoyston's question. Uh if there is an overnight stay on late procedure or
22:54 emergency procedure, will there be any staff members?
22:58 Um, oftentimes staff may I if if we end up offering urgent care at this location, staff very well would be there
23:06 till maybe 10 or 11:00, but usually staff does not stay overnight. As I mentioned, the the pets are often
23:14 sedated and then the clinic will open back up at 7 a.m. and staff will be right there.
23:19 So that's a 9-hour non-supervision of the animals. Correct. While they're in their kennels. Yes.
23:25 Okay. No other questions? All right, Commissioner Ensu.
23:30 Thank you, Chair. Uh, M Mr. Franklin, correct? Mr. Graham.
23:34 Mr. Graham. Sorry. That's okay. I'll give you all a card. Thank you. No, I appreciate it.
23:37 Make sure you check with me. We'll we'll get you get you some nice initial discount customers. No, no, no, no, no. I'm sorry.
23:47 Get me in trouble.
23:48 I'm in a little trouble as it get me in trouble. Sorry.
23:51 Don't worry. I I actually don't have any questions. Everybody actually asked everything that I was concerned about.
23:57 um mainly just the parking in that area in general. So I I think uh this is open and chat and parking is a very important issue to
24:05 us as well. Um usually um I I I think we're still in the process of of
24:12 actually negotiating this lease. We usually make sure that we have a couple either shortterm or reserved parking
24:19 spaces for us right in front of the clinic for a couple of reasons.
24:24 um one if there are any animals that are um that that can't they can't you know the owner has to pick them up and carry
24:32 them in especially if they're a larger animal or also again if if the animals uh you know uh immobile and they're
24:40 bringing them them in for euthanasia um uh so yeah that that's one issue and yeah I think the other issue is that
24:49 most of our appointments we don't do a lot of walk-in So most of our appointments are scheduled or or there's often a drop off and
24:58 pickup uh time period. So there aren't a lot we're not very parking heavy.
25:04 Great. No, that's good to hear. I know there's a couple of other vet offices in the area that get a bit swamped either from double scheduling or whatnot. So
25:12 it's nice to see that you are thinking about doing a temporary drop off or spot for for your uh for your patients. So,
25:19 yes, we that's something we're always looking for. It's it's the the property owners that we lease from that that don't always like that so much.
25:28 Yeah, understandable. Thank you. Thank you.
25:31 Uh I just have just a clarification on the timing. Somebody does bring their their dog in before your closing time of 6:00 and it is emergency and you have to
25:39 treat them, you're still locking the doors at 6:00, you are you are closing for business at at that time. Even if you're extended.
25:48 Yeah. I mean, well, I mean, if if we're if we're extended, we'll we would have we would be open to urgent care. So,
25:55 say, yeah. So, our normal appointments, say, for example, yeah, our our standard clinic hours are 7 to 7 and then, but
26:02 then if we open for urgent care, we may stay open till 9 or 10 10:00 p.m. Um, but again, not knowing just yet whether
26:10 or not this location will uh have urgent care. Um but yeah, normally normal business hours, yeah, we'll we'll close.
26:18 No more regular appointments, none of that. Only only urgent care. Okay. Can I ask a quick followup? Yeah, go ahead.
26:25 Um so you've mentioned that twice now about if it'll have urgent care or not.
26:29 What usually determines in y'all's y'all's perspective what is urgent care?
26:34 There are a number of factors that go into that. Again, number one is competition. if we've got a lot of other vets or if all of our nearest competitors are already offering uh
26:43 urgent care or if there's say um uh an emergency hospital nearby, we probably
26:51 wouldn't offer it. Uh say if there was a a veg, veterinary uh yeah, I can't remember the acronym for veg, but it's
26:59 uh uh yeah, veterinary emergency group or something like that. So, if if they have one of their hospitals nearby, we're we're probably not going to going
27:06 to do it. Um, so yeah, it's just it's just a matter of really looking at that and also our veterinarian and their
27:15 staffing if they can if they can handle handle it from a staffing standpoint.
27:19 Mr. Chairman, if I may, just one more quick question, please. Sir, uh, just curious uh, because I've been
27:26 to a lot of vets in Clermont and I actually had to go outside Clermont to find a good one. Uh, what's the largest?
27:34 Now, I know you say you don't have livestock. What is the largest breed that you would take?
27:40 The largest breed of animal or what animal and the largest that you have experience with?
27:47 Now you're getting a little outside of my in my realm. I'm I'm our vice president of real estate. I'm not even I'm not even I'm sorry. I'm I'm not a veterinarian. I'm not I'm not so sorry.
27:56 You spoke very well about the other questions, but No. Okay, I get it.
28:01 Yeah. I mean, normally it it's really just household pets. Occasionally we get an exotic say say say say say say say
28:07 say say say say say say say say say say say say say say say say say say say say
28:07 say say say say say say say say say say say say say say a bird a snake you know iguana but in terms of size no we're we're
28:14 definitely not taking any you know I nobody coming in with a goat or yeah things like that no we're
28:23 well the reason why I'm asking you got rottellers you got oh yeah no yeah I mean their size of goats some of these
28:30 no I'm just asking because I want to know pretty much after I read that staff did a great job on explaining everything if you had the capability of keeping such a large animal overnight.
28:41 Yes, that's why I'm asking that question.
28:42 Absolutely. Um gosh, I wish I I was just at uh um our Lake Nona clinic today and yeah, we have we have a number of range
28:52 of size of kennels and and some of them are I'd say literally about as wide as this podium and yet you know full you
29:01 know just there's nothing above it. So there's, you know, a human can open the door, walk into it, and and the the pet has plenty of room.
29:09 Okay. Thank you. You mentioned you have a lot of experience because you have a number of facilities. How many facilities do you have?
29:16 Um, we now have Okay. Over or we have 83 city vet locations um in 12 states right
29:25 now. As I mentioned, we um we have two open here in the uh Orlando area, one in
29:33 Lake Nona, one up in Castleberry. We actually have another one under construction further south on Highway 27 down in Davenport.
29:43 And this would be our fourth location here in the Orlando uh greater Orlando area.
29:49 Great. Thank you. Uh can I ask one question?
29:52 Go ahead. Um it just piqued my my curiosity. You mentioned that um if the animal the pet
30:01 has to stay overnight because of complications from surgery that at some point they are they're left there alone.
30:11 What if that animal goes into distress from the time that the last staff person goes home to the time that you open up at 7 o'lock in the morning? Does the
30:20 owner have any type of way of visually seeing their pet to know if the pet is
30:27 okay during the night? I mean, what happens if there's an emergency and no one's there and then you get there and there's been complications that no one was there to attend?
30:36 Um, okay, great question. First off, I don't I I'm almost positive our staff would not leave any pet that was not
30:44 stable. Um, I even know I I I if it our our Lake Nona clinic actually on the
30:53 bottom of our door has has recommendations for the nearest emergency clinic because that clinic
31:00 does not do urgent care. Um, so, so yeah, I I'm I'm almost positive that
31:07 that none of the staff would would leave if if we had an animal that was not stable and then would transfer them to a
31:17 a a hospital that would be able to provide them the proper monitoring and
31:24 observation uh if necessary. Um, and we actually have a couple of hospitals like that. We don't have one here in the
31:33 Orlando area. Um our our hospital brand is called Arista. Um we have one of
31:40 those in Dallas, Atlanta, and um we've we've got one that's about ready to open in Jacksonville.
31:49 Okay. So that explains that I mean I would think that a staff would not leave if a animal is in distress, but I'm
31:56 saying anything could happen. things could happen an hour later, two hours, something happens to that animal during that time when there's no one there.
32:04 That was my concern. Not not that a staff would leave and a patient was not stable, but what happens when there's no
32:11 one there and the animal may go into distress? How does the vet, the staff,
32:18 the owner knows that their pet is now in distress and there's no one at the facility? As far as monitor, as far as I
32:27 I'm aware, I've I've not heard of any incidents where we've we've lost a pet due to overnight care.
32:35 All right. Any other questions?
32:39 All right. Hearing none, I will entertain a motion. I would like to set a motion of resolution
32:47 2026-021R for the city vet conditional use permit.
32:54 Do I have a second? Second. A motion in a second. All in favor?
32:59 I I. And the chair votes I. It's unanimous. Thank you very much. Thank you very much, commissioners. Appreciate your time.
33:11 All right. We will move on to item number two when staff is ready.
33:19 Good evening, planning and zoning commissioners and guests. Justine Day with development services at the direction of the city manager's
33:27 office and city council staff is proposing an amendment to the land development codes in order to provide for lighting standards within the city
33:34 limits. Land Development Code sections 24-12 and 11512 provided regulations for lighting to illuminate properties
33:43 without subjecting adjacent properties to unnecessary and unreasonable reflection or glare. However, these
33:50 sections of the code do not provide standards to measure by or enforce when reviewing development applications. The proposed amendment would repeal these
33:58 sections of the code and replace them with a new chapter that would then establish enforceable standards for outdoor lighting.
34:05 The new chapter would be created to align the city's outdoor lighting regulations with modern model standards published by Dark Sky International and the Illuminating Engineering Society.
34:15 While resolution 2026-2R would help implement the standard set forth in section 129-4D
34:24 of the new chapter. If the amendment is approved, the city would provide for a phased implementation and retrofit plan to bring all new and existing
34:32 non-conforming city-owned and city leased outdoor lighting fixtures into compliance with the new chapter by no later than September 1st, 2031.
34:42 Subject to coordination with Duke Energy and other applicable utility providers, the city manager or designate shall
34:49 conduct an inventory of all city-owned and or leased outdoor lighting fixtures within 12 months of the effective date and shall provide annual updates to the
34:58 city council until compliance is achieved. Any other existing non-conforming outdoor lighting shall be brought into compliance with this
35:06 chapter no later than the earlier of when the fixture is replaced, removed, or substantially modified or by September 1st, 2036.
35:15 This would be applicable to all new outdoor lighting installations and all replacement of existing outdoor lighting fixtures within the corporate limits of
35:24 the city of Clermont, including residential, commercial, industrial, institutional, and municipal installations except as
35:33 expressly exempted within the proposed regulations.
35:36 The proposed amendment in order to fully support the dark sky initiative and minimize glare, reduce light trespass and lessen pollution of the night sky
35:44 would be applicable to all properties within the city limits. With this amendment, there would be a cost to upgrade and replace the fixtures, which
35:52 is unknown at this moment. The potential savings would be long-term electricity consumption. Both the proposed new chapter and the resolution to the code
36:01 would help provide consistency with the submittal regulations within the land development codes and is consistent with the city's comprehensive plan. Staff
36:09 recommends approval of ordinance number 2026-25 and resolution number 2026-22R.
36:18 This concludes staff presentation.
36:20 All right. Thank you very much. At this time, I'll open up the floor for public comment if anyone present would like to comment on this.
36:30 All right, hearing none, I will bring it back to the commission and I will start to my left with Commissioner Ensuo. Uh, thank you, Chair. Honestly, I love this.
36:39 I'm glad that was something we're finally taking a look at. I know long time ago it was more of just an idea and I'm glad to see that uh city manager's
36:48 office, the council and staff are taking a look at this. So, I don't have any really burning questions for it.
36:55 Thank you, Commissioner Neck. Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Uh, yeah, I read through uh majority
37:02 thoroughly. Uh, tried to nitpick it, but I gota my hats off to staff for doing an excellent job on this. Once again, like
37:10 my fellow Commissioner Kramer said, I mean, this is long overdue. Thank you.
37:15 Thank you, Commissioner Kramer. Thank you, Chair. Just a couple. You guys know I I'm so excited about this um because I
37:23 I'll remind you that my neighborhood is the first neighborhood, the older neighborhood to completely convert to dark sky. So, I feel like we're kind of
37:32 leading the way where I'm at and that you guys are catching up to that. So, I'm really excited. So, I went through this pretty thoroughly and to the point where my eyes are a little bit blurry.
37:42 Um so, I'm going to ask a couple of questions just to because I I want to help you guys get this right. So uh my first question was um
37:52 and this is a little tiny one but section 1294C
37:59 I'll give you a minute to find that talks so 4C talks about light trespass
38:07 and it talks about vertical and horizontal whichever is great so it's I won't read all the details of but it talks about foot candle measurement the
38:15 property line vertical or horiz horizontal. And then it goes on to talk about um later on in
38:25 G2 it talks about a finished grade ground level with the light registering portion of the meter held parallel to the ground and pointing upwards. So
38:33 that's how we measure horizontally, but I never saw a standard in here for how we measure vertically. So it's a little tiny thing, but we talk about how we're
38:42 going to measure horizontally and vertically. and and I didn't see vertically addressing there. So, I'm just pointing that out to you. Um
38:51 and then and and and Justini did a great job referencing um Dark Sky International and IE model standards. Um
39:00 and those are the technical guidance documents that you guys use to establish um the numerical thresholds. I see that.
39:07 But I want to make sure that those challenges are not challenged or challenged in the future. So my question
39:14 is the ordinance repeatedly states that the standards are consistent with Dark Sky International and the illuminating
39:22 engineering society but the ordinance does not identify which model ordinance publication addition or technical
39:29 guidance document report that supports those specific numbers. So just a little more specificity. You you reference the
39:36 document but you don't recommen ref reference where where you got that we can add that into it.
39:43 It's an easy addance. I think later on you'll find that if somebody challenges this that having that specificity will help you.
39:50 So and actually this is the Can you guys hear me? This is the city attorney. Yes, we can hear you. City attorney is on the phone.
39:58 Yeah. Could I just jump in on that point, Commissioner? Um, sure.
40:02 This this is obviously a very technical detailed ordinance in front of you with
40:08 a lot of proper nouns and um that's one of the things we struggled with in the city attorney's office actually and
40:16 that's because the the original thought was to actually kind of defer and
40:22 incorporate the Dark Sky International standards. In other words, not to have the actual numbers in our own ordinance,
40:30 but just to kind of almost outsource it to Dark Sky International. And I made the decision in drafting not to do that.
40:39 In other words, I think you as the city of Clermont should be able to choose your own numbers, you know, and because we we don't know necessarily when Dark
40:48 Sky International is going to change their standards. So, I didn't want to just defer those decisions to them. I
40:55 don't know if this helps you at all with kind of how you're looking at what you just said, but that is the basis for why some of it's worded the way it is.
41:04 Thank you, counselor. That really actually that really does help because it's it was me worrying about your comfort level, how you can hold this, how you can u defend this in the future.
41:14 But if you're comfortable with it, I am as well. Okay. Uh
41:22 and then in section 1296D, all new outdoor lighting installations
41:31 subject to this chapter shall incorporate adaptive controls. And I just want to be clear, does that include single family homes for the adaptive
41:40 controls? I saw in the very next statement it said that it would like um landscape lighting on residential units
41:47 to turn off at 11, but is that asking people to turn off their porch lights um
41:54 and things like that? I just was vague to me. So it it would include for both commercial and residential.
42:02 It it would be for any outdoor lighting fixture. So, if that's the porch light, um the landscaping does have um a
42:11 section in I believe the exemptions as well where it talks about certain lumens they just have to shield and make sure it's not visible from the other property
42:20 lines. So, that's something that we can look at if you think it's a little bit too much, but um it would be for both
42:28 residential and commercial. I I I see that a lot of this looks and feels a lot like what Groveland has done. And I I I've been over in Groveland, I've seen
42:37 that they even on new facilities where you're building a porch and you've got your porch light, they actually have a small like cup coming down to block that
42:46 light, which they had to actually go figure out how to how to address the new standard in their area. So, um luckily
42:54 they've worked through a lot of these problems before us.
42:57 Um, I'll jump in on that one, too. So, there
43:05 there are some similarities in this draft to to Groveland. It's it's definitely not a word for word. I don't even think it's I wouldn't even say it's
43:12 50%, but there are some things that are Oh, I've been told that I can speak quieter. Okay. So, um there are some
43:22 things that are similar or identical to the Groven ordinance. And part of the reason for that is Dark Sky International has model ordinances and
43:31 laws that they want people to adopt. So some of those have been uh adopted liberally.
43:38 Thank you. Um that's all the questions I have. Chair. All right. Thank you very much.
43:46 Commissioner Hoisington.
43:47 Thank you. Um I would also like to commend staff for all the work that you put into this. Um, I am a process person, a timeline person. So, I
43:56 appreciate it seeing that you have your process of how you're going to identify, you have your timeline of when things going to be done and I appreciate that.
44:03 So, congratulations and for moving this forward because I know it's been a long time needed and coming. Thank you.
44:10 Great. Thank you. Uh, yeah, I'd also um, you know, like to thank the city manager, the city council and and staff for a great effort here. I think I think
44:17 this is going to make a big difference in our community. So, thank you very much. Um, at this time I will entertain a motion on item number two.
44:29 Chair, I'd like to make a motion that we approve ordinance 2026-025
44:37 and resolution 2026-22R, Dark Skyland Development Code Amendment.
44:47 Second.
44:49 So, we're we're I'm sorry. you. We're doing 025. We're just just the O25. I'm sorry, 025. We'll do them individually. I I I'm
44:58 assuming I'm sorry, council. We need uh we need individual um You're right.
45:03 motions. Um that yes, they're two different items on our agenda. So, I'll amend my I'll amend my motion. I'd
45:10 like to make a motion that we approve ordinance 2026-025, Dark Sky Land Development Code Amendment.
45:18 Second.
45:21 We have a motion and a second. All in favor? I I.
45:24 And chair votes I. That's also unanimous. Thank you.
45:28 All right. We will move to um to item number three. Resolution. Oh, I am sorry.
45:37 Now I will make a resolution. Now I'll make a motion. Right. Right. Right. Right.
45:40 To approve ordinance 2026-022R under the Dark Sky Land Development Code Amendment.
45:48 Okay. So we have a motion for the resolution. For the resolution. Do I have a second for the resolution? Second.
45:55 Motion second. All in favor? I. I. Chair votes I. Okay. We will move to item number three.
46:06 Good evening planning and zoning commissioners and guests. Nicks Development Services. This is agenda item number three, land development code amendment surrounding property notifications.
46:16 At the direction of the city manager's office and city council, staff is proposing an amendment to the noticing requirements for certain land use and
46:24 development applications. Currently, the requirements are for public notices to be mailed to all adjoining property owners within 150 ft of the subject
46:32 property. There are several sections in the code that address this 100 foot requirement. In an effort to enhance public awareness and participation along
46:41 with keeping surrounding surrounding property owners and stakeholders informed, an increase in the written notification requirement is being
46:49 proposed at a distance of 450 ft. This is a 200% increase in the written notification requirements. No changes
46:56 are being proposed to the existing newspaper publications or the posting of signage on the subject property. The applications that would be affected by
47:04 this include conditional use permits, variances, resonings, future land use map amendments, and live local act
47:12 projects. In addition, if any property within the 450 ft radius of the subject property is governed by a property owners association, such as a
47:20 condominium association or homeowners association, notice shall also be provided to such association. This
47:27 language is also being added to better inform the community of the proposed land use changes that may impact their properties and or communities. Staff
47:35 recommends approval of these proposed changes contained within ordinance number 2026-026 since it finds that it would be in the
47:44 best interest of public and citizens of Clermont. That concludes SAS presentation.
47:48 Right. Thank you very much. I'll open it up for public comment. Would anyone like to speak on this?
47:55 Please come to the podium. State your name and address.
48:02 Thank you, Mr. Chair. Bryan Bane from uh the Clermont City Council Seat 2. Uh just am here because I think it's
48:10 important as someone who sat up there before. um when a council member is involved working with staff on an
48:18 ordinance that that council member come here and let you know why they are working with staff on that and and the
48:26 rationale behind the proposal. And so that's what I'm doing here today.
48:30 letting you know that uh as someone who sat up there on PNZ for two years, as someone who's now been on council since
48:38 November, um we've heard it, you've heard it from residents that um the
48:44 radius that we currently use to go out is pretty minimal.
48:50 And um it literally um could mean one, two, five houses that get notified in a
48:58 neighborhood. And so in working with staff um what I understand from uh the
49:05 mapping software that is used that if you plug in a number it can automatically do that for you. So
49:12 there's there's no manual process because initially I would I I I I had suggested that if any house in any
49:20 neighborhood was included that the entire neighborhood get included and then it became a well what if we we
49:28 because now we have to manually go through and figure out which houses are all in that neighborhood. If we miss one that puts a big responsibility on the
49:34 city for missing that house. And so we then determined how could we do this with a radius that
49:42 actually made an actual uh positive net effect. And so we looked at 450 ft which
49:50 is a 200% increase from what we currently are doing at 150 ft. Now staff policy or their practice is that they
49:59 actually go an additional 50 ft. So with this, if you approve uh as a recommendation to the city council and the city council then approves would
50:08 actually get notification out to 500 ft uh of a neighborhood uh surrounding a
50:15 project. In addition to that, what we did include also as language is to say
50:21 that if any parcel in that radius is in an HOA or a condo association,
50:30 then notification must also go to that homeowners association or condo association. So that then kind of
50:37 allowed for additional notification for folks in that neighborhood, putting some responsibility on the homeowners
50:44 association or the condos association to notify their members of a project that's taking place nearby their their
50:52 residences. So um we added that language in here. And I'll also say that in doing this and working with staff, I learned
50:59 that notification does also go to the Lake County schools and the board of county commissioners. And so, uh, there's quite a bit of notification then
51:07 that would go out, um, from this. So, I think it is a, uh, a good effort for us to respond to the concerns we hear from
51:15 our residents and, uh, also address the transparency and engagement that we all strive to increase and have in our city.
51:24 And I'll answer any questions you might have. Thank you.
51:26 Thank you very much. Uh, is there anyone else in the public who would like to comment on this?
51:32 All right. Hearing none, I will bring it back to the commission for any comments or questions. Start with you, Commissioner Hoington.
51:42 I'm sorry.
51:43 Um, glad to see that this is taking place. I I just had the one question.
51:48 Why not 500 ft? But I'm glad to hear that you already do the additional 50, so I'm good. Thank you, Commissioner Kramer.
52:01 I look for typos. I look for lack of clarity. Um, this looks like good
52:07 policy. Um, I like like Mr. Bane said, this is something we've needed for a while and
52:16 and those of us sat up here for any length of time realize that we we were excluding a good number of our citizens
52:22 from um being notified. So, I I look very favorably on this. I I I
52:30 don't have any red lines or yellow lines or anything to to nitpick. So, thank you. Thank you, Commissioner Neck.
52:36 Yes. I have an obvious question. Uh it's directed to Councilman Banees.
52:44 I think it's I think it's just Bane without an S on the end. I think it's just Bane.
52:50 I I know him well enough. I could call him Bane.
52:52 I don't think people want two of me around here.
52:57 This is the first time ever at a planning and zoning meeting I ever saw a councilman come up to the podium as a public speaker.
53:05 So could you explain to me I mean are you part of the architect to this? Could you for clarification?
53:13 Yeah. So right after the election last November, I met with all the department heads and one of the department heads was Mr. potential. And I brought up to
53:22 he and his team that I would I would like to move forward with uh some revisions to this notification policy.
53:29 And it took some time to understand all the ramifications and the nuances of how that process works and who pays for it
53:36 and how it goes through the process and and after lots of back and forth, we settled on the the number that we could both agree to. Um, and then staff took
53:45 it from there, working with the city attorney to actually revise the language and actually bring you the ordinance change that's in front of you today.
53:53 I'd like to say thank you from most of the residents in my area for accomplishing this task. I mean,
54:02 questions were always asked to me over the past seven years. How come they only go out to 150 ft? And I said, well, they're being lenient. They go to 200.
54:11 It all depends on the community. And thank you again for putting the language in that it has to go directly if it's a
54:19 gated community to HOAs or to condominiums and so on. Thank you Mr. Banees.
54:26 Thank you Commissioner Ensua.
54:29 Thank you chair. Thank you for bringing this up. Uh Council Member Banees Banees Bane. You got me saying it now.
54:37 We need to say people's names right around here.
54:40 No, you're right. We did talk. Yeah, you're right. Um, the only question that I do actually have is more for staff and I think it's more just for my own edification.
54:47 Um, you found it for the code enforcement.
54:51 Is there a reason why it's not included in in this amendment or is it I just noticed that that's the only one that's
54:59 not affected, but I wasn't sure if there's a reason why. Do we send notification?
55:04 Yeah, I don't believe they don't they don't Oh, we don't send notifications for voted for some cases. Yeah.
55:09 Okay. They just give you Okay. They just go to your Yeah, that's just to the just the for the property.
55:13 Okay, gotcha. Okay. Okay. Okay, that makes more sense. Thank you for that.
55:17 Um, that's the only thing I had. Great job, guys. Good process.
55:21 All right. Um, I love everything about this. However, I do have a question about that extra 50 ft. Is that like a
55:28 best practice or is that an actual policy within your office? Kurt, could you just explain that extra 50 feet? that that's a best practice
55:37 that our department does just to make sure that we cover.
55:41 Well, my my only concern here is that we do the extra 50 feet because Kurt's a great guy and does the right thing and goes the little extra.
55:50 However, I would feel more comfortable if we had something that said 500 ft and
55:57 and and and so do you understand my my concern? I do.
56:04 Here's the issue. If we say 450, you have two parcels that meet at a corner here and that that radius is right here.
56:12 We're going to air on the side of caution and catch that extra 50 ft. So if we if you're 500, you're saying then you're 500. We're going to go to 550. Yeah.
56:23 We're always going to go bigger because we don't want to miss a property by inches. So we're going to air on the side of We've always done that. It's
56:30 always always worked for us. No one's come back to ever said, "Hey, I was not in this 150 ft."
56:38 We're just ering on errating on side of caution there. So, whatever the number is, we're always going to go bigger. Okay. Just to make sure we capture that.
56:47 And that's relying on the great people that we have working in your department today.
56:52 So far that I know it's been working for 24 years. Okay.
56:58 I I expect it to continue on, but uh yeah, I mean, okay. practice.
57:05 All right. That that was just my I mean it's it's a best practice. I I appreciate that you're that you're going to 500. I'm just looking 10 10 years 20
57:13 years down the line and oh well we you know well good luck if they get caught with a you know missing a piece of property by
57:20 a couple inches and it could throw the whole ordinance off whatever we're advertising. You could just throw it off and okay it could be repealed and we're not going to have that.
57:28 Okay. um that that was the the only concern, but it is a a huge uh improvement from from from what we had before. So, thank you for uh for for taking the time to do that.
57:39 Um any other questions from any commissioner.
57:44 All right. At this time, I will entertain a motion. I'd like to uh set a motion for ordinance 2026.
57:51 A motion of approval for ordinance 2026-026 surrounding property notifications 450 ft land development code amendment.
58:03 All right, we have a motion. Do we have a second? Second.
58:07 Motion and a second. All in favor? I I.
58:11 And the chair votes I. That's also unanimous. All right. Um, any other
58:18 business? Staff, do you have any any other business?
58:24 All right. Can I have a a motion to adjurnn? Motion and second. Second.
58:30 We are adjourned. Thank you.
59:06 Hey, hey, hey.
59:50 a a
1:00:53 Heat. Heat.
1:01:16 Heat.
1:01:35 Heat.
1:01:51 Hey.
1:02:07 Hey. Hey.
1:06 Heat. Heat.
2:57 Heat. Heat.
3:48 Council
4:02 will not be voting on any issues at the workshop meeting. The council also reserved the right to discuss additional items or delete items from the tenative
4:10 agenda. Um we hopefully and right now on the thing on the agenda is proposed physical year 2026 27 budget discussion.
4:21 Um I'm asked that hopefully we can move through this thing pretty quick this morning. I know I I need to be out of
4:27 here about 11:30 uh 11:45 and do a lunchon real quick at 12 and try to be back here about 1 1:15 or something. So
4:36 um and during that time I think it's been set up for you all to be served lunch at that time. Am I right? We have one. Yeah, we'll have.
4:43 All right. Anyway, we'll go ahead and open up with with a prayer if you don't mind.
4:48 Heavenly Father, we come to you once again to say thank you. Thank you for allowing us to see another one of your glorious state. Oh father, they never seen before, never be seen again. Oh
4:57 heavenly father, we just thank you for the opportunity to serve your people here in the great city. However, Father, as we we thank you for the opportunity
5:06 as we gather here today to begin the budget workshop for the city of Clmont, recognize that every decision we make
5:14 affect the lives of our residents and we ask for your wisdom and guidance.
5:19 As your words say in James 5 and one, if any of you lacks wisdom, let him ask God
5:25 and it will be given to him. Lord grant us wisdom, discernment, and unity as we carefully consider how to steward the
5:35 resources entrusted to our self.
5:40 Help us to listen with respect, lead with integrity, and make decision that serve the best interest of our community today and for the future generation.
5:49 Bless our city staff, bless our council, bless our first responders, and bless all the residents of the city of Clema.
5:57 May we all continue to look to the Lord for your wisdom and guidance and all the
6:05 decisions you make for them better people to consider clear and all these things we ask in Jesus name. Amen.
6:12 Amen. All right.
6:22 Yes.
6:26 Thank you, Mr. May there just to give you format the plan is to finish today at 4:00 because there's going to be a
6:34 planning and selling meeting here in this room so that staff need some time to set up here. So that's the plan and
6:41 then again we'll gather again tomorrow at 9. Daniel Webster will be here at 8:30 for anybody that would like to meet
6:48 him in the lobby here tomorrow morning to say say goodbye to us before his turn. So he'd like to be here. He'll be
6:58 discussing the grant got us as well. I want to make you aware July 21st there is a strong possibility we will not have a quarrel to have a workshop that day.
7:10 So just want to make everybody aware of that. We're having some scheduling conflicts for the workshop on July 21st. Okay.
7:18 Okay. All right. So we we couldn't change that day.
7:24 That's what we try to change, but trying to squeeze it all in. Okay. Yeah. Just people traveling right now.
7:32 The budget you have in front of you, uh, the finance department, the staff, as you know, have worked many hours to give
7:39 you a budget to present it to you. Lots of negotiating, training, horse training, and changes. So, we are eager
7:47 for your input. We've created a budget where we can live off of our adorum and the things we have coming in for our
7:55 income, but we would have to make some investments for the capital projects and different projects that would have to
8:02 come out of our reserves. So, we put this in front of you for you to tell us what you would like to have happen for our different projects. You've expressed
8:12 an interest over this past year on many, many of these things we're presenting to you. We just want you to have an understanding of all of this
8:20 collectively together, what that looks like. So, we're eager to get your input on that. Our current reserve, and I'm
8:27 going to let Scott get into these more with you, but we're right around $24 million.
8:33 We're projecting that we're going to have our rate of growth this year as of right now from the property appraisers office looks like it's 10.6.
8:45 To give you perspective, last year we had growth of over 340 million
8:53 and that was a 10.9% growth. But to give you perspective, we actually had more growth this year. We saw growth of $392
9:02 million. So even though the percentage is lower, it's because we have a higher rate of value. But Clermont's
9:09 continuing to grow. Uh there's been annexations this past year. There's been lots of new growth that has taken place
9:17 as well. Uh we are in a strong stable position financially and I think with wise decisions will continue to be in
9:26 that situation in a good stable position. So we're not looking with fear at this but with optimism and hope
9:35 continue to work diligently to look at all the cost savings we can make. Uh this budget is not uh laying off any of
9:44 our current employees. So we continue to be diligent to look at other things that we can look at because we have a great
9:52 work team here and we want to continue to make sure Clermont stays healthy and strong for many years to come with the
9:59 great employees that we have at Clermont. So I'm very grateful for all of them. But uh we should be very proud of them. They're doing a great job and
10:07 I'm very encouraged with all the changes and shifts and they're looking constantly for new ideas how we can save money what we can do even even beyond
10:16 the budget we will continue to look for cost savings that will be our goal continuously it has since I've been here they continue to look at that so even
10:25 after this has been printed we're still looking at options and opportunities so thanks for letting me just open up with you to share a few things with you and I
10:34 will let Scott take it from here with his presentation and the plan is to the parks department and wreck to share
10:42 and then they'll tag along with that trails with Jim Mayworm and then police is going to share and then fire and
10:49 public services and then the other departments to follow as well. So, we'll see how quickly we can get through these with you, but we hope that we've
10:58 answered your questions as we go through this and if you have further questions, please just let us know. We'll do our research and due diligence between
11:06 sessions or the next day. So, Thanks again for the chance to share with you guys today. We appreciate all your due diligence and all your work you're doing
11:14 in this. I'm going to turn it over to you.
11:20 Thanks, Rick. I'm gonna check hopefully this picks me up. Uh thank you, Rick.
11:28 I'm going to give you about an 8 to 10 slide presentation uh to give you a 30,000 foot overview of document before
11:36 you and where we are in the process and talk a little bit in depth about what resources are available to city council
11:42 both currently and in the future. Um just a uh a PSA for our uh crowd.
11:50 The documents that the council has before them is also available on the city's website of the finance department links. is bringing that up as we speak
11:58 on the monitors here within the council chambers u including all the department presentations which directors will give to you over the next couple days and
12:06 this presentation as well in the appendix section um it limitations doesn't allow us to stream this but I'm
12:14 going be over the next few moments working off this then of course be glad to answer any questions you have next slide
12:22 so first off just to set the table where we are in the process of As you know, we have workshops scheduled over the next two days. The one thing that we do
12:31 absolutely need direction on from the city council coming out of these two meetings is direction on the maximum millage rate. Uh as a reminder, this is
12:40 the uh rate that will bring before you in the form of a resolution at the July 28th meeting. This represents the
12:46 millage rate uh the proposed millage rate that will be advertised by the Lake County Property Appraiser to all the property owners in the city of
12:55 Clermont. uh that rate will be as the name states the maximum rate. Uh after passage and before we conclude this
13:04 process in September, council will still retain the right to reduce that rate, but you'll be establishing at the July 28th council meeting what that maximum
13:12 rate is. Do you need direction on that these two uh meetings and the trend and budget hearings are already scheduled in
13:20 September. a reminder those are Thursday evening meetings on the 10th and the 24th and that'll wrap up this process.
13:29 All right. Uh just first a few general highlights about the proposed budget for you. Beginning with the general fund on
13:37 the surface you just look at total revenues over total expenditures. It's presented to you at a deficit of $6.5
13:44 million. As you'll recall, we recently passed a uh comprehensive budget policy.
13:49 Within that policy, we included a a definition that how we define what a structurally balanced budget is. And
13:58 essentially, it means taking out your non-reoccurring items on both the revenue and expense side. When you go through that exercise, uh we get that
14:07 deficit down to approximately $1.5 million within a reasonable range. um given that we are conservative with
14:14 revenue projections and given the status our reserves which I'll talk about in more detail here in a few moments.
14:22 Another highlight of this proposal is the creation of the communications department which was previously discussed at city council meeting. We have a full budget prepared for that
14:31 which the city manager's office will go through on their segment of these workshops. And then uh finally at the end I'm going to talk more in depth
14:38 about this but as Rick said we have uh a healthy fund balance reserve. We have a number of high-profile pro projects and
14:48 services that are in the current year budget that for various reasons are not still not ready to move forward with completely. So those are not included in
14:56 this this proposed budget for you. But we're going to discuss a solution where if these are still priority projects for
15:03 the council, how we can dedicate funds towards that for the point in time when are ready to move forward with
15:13 in terms of revenues. Uh as Rick said, uh double digit growth again this year.
15:18 This is actually the fifth consecutive year of double digit growth, which is amazing. And I don't know that another city in the county could could say that.
15:27 Um, one thing important thing to note here as it relates to the Laurum, it is lost in all of the discussions and the
15:35 news about the uh, ballot initiative that that's on related to um,
15:42 in November is a change in how the state calculates what the maximum village rate is and it's a pretty significant change.
15:52 In prior years, uh, anything above the above the roll back rate and up to a certain point higher than that, you
16:00 could still pass with a simple majority vote. That has changed. Now, effective this year is that anything above the roll back rate now requires a twothirds
16:09 vote of council. So, partly out of that reason, so for instance, the current year, our millage rate is 4.59%.
16:17 Um the roll back rate that we have already received from the Lake County property appraiser is 4.36
16:24 partly out of concern for that uh new voting requirement on the maximum village the budget before you is presented at the roll back rate of 4.36.
16:34 Now, if the council would so choose to adjust that rate, whether higher or lower for a frame of reference, if you
16:42 were to adjust it 0.1 in either direction, it's a change of approximately $700,000 in revenue to the city general funds.
16:53 On the enterprise side, uh we're in the new fiscal year. This will be the last of a fiveyear rate ordinance that was
17:00 passed back in 2023. So the rate adjustments have already been established for the water and sewer funds, 3% increase on the water rates,
17:10 8% increase on sewer rates. And then on the sanitation, the city a number of years ago established that will follow the uh Florida Public Services
17:18 Commission rate change on sanitation that'll be at 1.5% adjustment in the new year. I'm sure you can think for
17:26 yourself, what is the status of the rate study? Uh we are very close to concluding that process and uh Stony may be able to speak more in detail about
17:34 that when we get to the public services portion.
17:38 Before Scott, let me ask a question back on the last slide. Now make sure I understand this is because you're saying now um even if we were to try to keep
17:47 the mill rate the same as it is now 4.59, we had still two vote now with the change.
17:53 That is correct. any anything above the roll back rate requires a two. Yeah, that is a big change.
18:01 All right.
18:04 Okay. In terms of personnel, um, and all the directors when they present to you go into more detail. This is a summary of the requested new positions by the
18:13 directors. In total, 17.5 positions at a total wages and benefit cost of $1.4 million. And you can see here how we
18:21 have that split. Nine individuals with general fund impact of $612,000 and on the enterprise side 8.5 and an impact of $831,000.
18:32 Um in your department uh presentation included a work chart and personnel counts and again the directors will be
18:39 able to speak more specifically in detail about those when we get to those sections.
18:46 In terms of capital in total we presented a plan to you at $44.6 6 million um with a fiveyear projections out within the capital section in college.
18:58 Next slide. Uh the way that is broken down on the governmental side, 19.6 million in projects and here's a list of
19:05 just some of the high the higher profile projects that are included. Keep in mind this 19.6 is not just general fund.
19:13 About 6.8 of that is in general fund. um my governmental cap activities. I'm also referring to the impact funds fund 320.
19:21 Um those resources as well. Um so as as you see we've included uh sidewalk street resurfacing of 1.5 which I
19:30 believe is the same amount we had in this current year. We've included Bishop Field and Fire Station 2 and five
19:37 projects as well. And then on the enterprise side, $25 million worth of capital investments. We have rebudgeted
19:45 for Hartwick Marsh. It's in the current year. Did not begin that project, but we have rebudgeted reclaim storage at $4 million and the sanitation bank for station of 3.1.
19:56 These are just a few of the projects that are listed in.
20:02 As we go through this process, can we somehow identify what are projects that were in the 26 budget that were not
20:11 completed and therefore are moving forward 27 because at that point it seems to me and
20:20 I wonder if we all say the same way that if we're using any reserves that were created by not funding those
20:28 projects It's not like we're increasing, we're not necessarily increasing the
20:36 government as a whole. We're just moving that money forward into the fiscal year 27. Other words, I don't want a sense
20:43 that we're punishing staff for not getting things done necessarily in a in a particular year. Some of these
20:51 projects take longer. So, but I'd like the public to be aware this is kind of a rollover project. Does this make sense?
20:57 Yeah, I think it does. But I think it if we're going to do that, I think we have to identify where the initial funding came from because the initial funding
21:05 may have been reserves. So if it was reserves and it's being rolled over as reserves, it's still starting from reserves. That's fair.
21:13 And so I think that that's part of the conversation. If we want to have that, we should talk about where the initial funding came from as well.
21:19 Yeah. Because I think one of the biggest challenges we're going to have is really how do we handle these unrestricted reserves?
21:27 And the simpler that we can make that process, I think the better for us and also for the public who sees how we're
21:34 handling that money because we do need to do something with it, whatever that is. And so it seems like some of these rollover projects might be might create a clear way for us to communicate that.
21:46 I think I asked you a month or so ago to go ahead and break that all out and kind of go back when I had with you a couple
21:54 months ago to go ahead and look at all the projects that was not completed in 26 that we had budgeted for so we get a
22:01 breakdown on I think you've already done that for us what she's ask a couple months ago. There's not a
22:10 simple paid adment within your budget that would um summarize that for you, but we could easily produce it.
22:21 All right. Uh good transition. The last section of our presentation is talking about the general fund and the unassigned fund balance. Again, these
22:30 are uh unassigned fund balance is a portion of the overall fund balance of any funduh which are discretionary
22:40 dollars available to the city council to dedicate to towards whatever uh services or projects that you see fit. And this
22:48 has been much discussed topic over the years. And this slide gives you a five-year history of the evolution of of our unreserved fund balance within the
22:56 general fund. So if you follow it down, as city manager alluded to, um this is as of the conclusion of our most recent
23:03 fiscal year, the total unassigned fund balance was 36.6 6 million. Now, you do a calculation to back out what portions
23:11 required by policy um to stay in reserves, our rainy day fund, if you will, or emergency fund, whatever,
23:19 however you want to describe it. Um that brings our unassigned amount down to 23.8 billion.
23:26 This current year, we're projecting we're going to be pretty close to be right on balance on both revenue and
23:33 expenditure sidevious. The actual results obviously is to be determined.
23:38 Um, but for the purposes of our budget planning and this topic, we're going with this figure of 23.8 million.
23:45 Scott, what is the 25% of of operating costs?
23:51 Well, and I guess that's my question. I noticed we 25% is 12. Does that mean
23:58 operate cost? I thought I went through the budget operate this coming year 25.
24:12 And one of the other questions while I'm thinking about it is the fact that I anticipate you going to probably end up with a lot of deck services
24:20 like a garage talking about this kind of stuff. Uh I know I talked to you before about increasing 25% to 30%.
24:31 To do that was that when you go out look that service would that help us with better interest rates when you show it was higher reserve.
24:40 Well status of of reserves is certainly a factor among many factors when rating agencies or banks review our financial position.
24:51 So, well, can you tell me what that figure would be if you went to 30%.
24:57 Yeah. Uh, just add one of the $12 million another $2.5 million.
25:07 But uh I'm just you know thing I'm not quite sure what we did with that services but that was to help us with the lower interest rates because we that
25:15 in over the years that's hard for me to say a analyst but as I said mayor the status
25:24 of our reserves is certainly a factor in their process. Typically in in this, sorry to get off my tangent, but um
25:32 typically the last true rating that the city of Clermont did for any type of issuance was nearly 20 years ago. Most
25:41 issuances nowadays are in the form of private placements with banks.
25:45 Okay. So for instance, when we did the 2024 issuance for the wastewater treatment plant, we had banks bid on what that administrator would be. did
25:53 not get a credit rating agency credit agency rating for that issuance. That's been pretty typical.
26:01 Scott on that because I I share the same questions about what we should be holding. Um can you define operating expenditures for me and I'm looking at
26:09 the fund summary where we have personnel operating capital debt grants and other is it personel and operating? It's personal and operator. Correct.
26:26 Okay. Then uh last slide. So question is as as Rick alluded to, what is to be done with that um unassigned fund
26:35 balance? Um, as I said at the outset, we have three high-profile projects and services that are in the current year
26:43 budgets that uh are still in a stain of not ready to move forward with those being EMS transport, potential land
26:52 purchases downtown, and the parking garage. Um, so since we have not included those in the current year
26:59 budget, um, what we are recommending the council is entertain the idea of through the of a resolution, make an adjustment
27:08 on the city's balance sheet. Move those funds, whatever funds you determine uh are necessary from an unassigned fund
27:18 balance account into an assigned fund balance account. In other words, in layman's terms, making a statement via a resolution saying, "We are going to save
27:26 $6 million of this or whatever it might be, $6 million of this underserved fund balance for this specific purpose or $5.3 million for this specific purpose.
27:38 Therefore, whenever we get to the point in time to where those projects or services are ready, you've already got a nest egg, if you will, available and
27:46 ready to dedicate towards them." Uh these are three examples that I pulled for the presentation simply because they are in the current year
27:54 budget and we're not moving forward with them as of yet. Um but we could take that approach with any type of project or any type of service that the con
28:02 council means work. Um if though following this example we were to follow that and based on the projections within
28:10 this initial proposed budget that would reduce that unreserve fund balance down to $6.5 million. Um, so you're you're
28:18 closer to that 33%, excuse me, that 25% requirement within our policy and you're making a state a public statement that
28:27 uh we are reserving these resources for future use questions
28:36 with regard to the resolution. Um, and I know our city attorney's not here, so if we defer uh till does get here, we can
28:47 essentially doing the resolution. My understanding is we legally we can't tie the hands of a future council
28:56 but we're but it is making a statement essentially that while these
29:04 15 million in your example 15 rough million dollars there of fund balance unreserved fund balance.
29:13 we're going to reserve quote unquote it for these projects.
29:20 But if a future council decided they wanted to use that for something else, what would be the mechanism by which
29:29 that council would have to do that if we go the resolution route versus just leaving it in the fund?
29:36 Well, I will certainly defer to Mr. on that question. They just repeal the I was say my assumption is is that we have to that council would have to
29:45 go essentially undo the resolution and and then allocate the funds. So, it does add an extra little layer in there, but
29:52 it really doesn't it reserves it, but it doesn't put it in a lock box if we're talking about that if if you remember that back in 2000.
30:04 Um, and uh and you know, lock that away for just that project only in forever perpetuity.
30:11 Okay. Well, and what I like about it is we're communicating to the public what we what we see as viable projects,
30:20 good projects, but we're not putting staff or even ourselves in a place where we're saying we need to hurry up and do this right now. It's more this is what
30:28 we see for the future of our city and this is what we deem appropriate. And frankly, we've talked about, you know,
30:35 elections before. It allows the public to say we like that, we don't like that.
30:40 We we want to make a change. we don't want to make a change. And so I I do like the idea of not having this carrying over us for another year. I
30:48 consider it a priority from my perspective to address what are we doing with these funds, these public funds.
30:55 And if it means we're setting it aside for the future, fine. Um I like the idea that there's some sort of resolution that we I like that mechanism that staff
31:04 came up with is my point. So I but I do agree. I think it doesn't tie the hands and and we all know that going into it.
31:11 It's not it's just what we think is appropriate and then the public can comment on it. I guess
31:20 just a quick question on the on the 25% that's mandated. Is that mandated in a lock box type of thing that we have to
31:27 have that amount of money that can't be touched or can that be you know polluted and then refilled type?
31:35 So it is The 25% is by internal policy.
31:40 That is that is parked within the unreserved category of the fund balance. Now I we
31:49 could very easily based off that policy move that into a assigned or reserved
31:56 concern. We haven't historically done that and that's muddied the discussion around what the available fund balance
32:04 is. So that is one we probably should be doing. But we have been very, you know, good about communicating that.
32:15 That concludes my remarks. I'll be glad to answer any other questions 30,000 foot view if you have any. Thank you so much. Thank you.
32:22 Thanks. Morning.
32:38 Pull up my presentation.
33:56 Hi, good morning. How are you?
34:00 So, in our current year review, um, our gross revenues, our gross revenue is continuing to increase. So, we've been
34:08 going up about $200,000 a year every year pretty consistently. We'll probably exceed that. Um this year
34:16 you guys you guys can um we're through the first six months
34:24 we're about $160,000 gross revenue above um last year's first six months. Now that doesn't mean we're going to be $320,000
34:32 is our revenue is seasonal. We do bring in less money over the summer because we don't have shows and fields are closed
34:40 things like that. Um our signature events, our net revenue on signature events has continued to improve. Um
34:47 Corey and Heather done a great job on getting sponsors for a lot of our programs. So a couple of our programs actually on on the operational budget
34:56 side actually did better than break even. So our Halloween event, light up, and the parade enchanted forest all made
35:04 money. Most of our events again are are doing better than they did the year before.
35:11 um the jazz festival in the first year we did we were $69,000 expense over revenue but we do think that over time
35:19 we could get much closer to break even on that between um increases in attendance more sponsors increases in ticket revenue so that we do feel good
35:29 about that there was a lot of great feedback on that um our performing arts remains strong our hard rental revenues
35:36 up $75,000 through the first six months of this So your contracted program revenue is up, boat parking revenue is up and then we could go you guys.
35:48 Keep going.
35:50 Bryan, I'm sorry. Can I just a clarification because the in budgeting parenthesis typically means deficit.
35:59 So are these all deficits?
36:00 Those are the net. I'm sorry. Those are the net. So um yes, the parentheses is a deficit. Correct.
36:06 Okay. So all so like for if I'm reading this correctly then national night out correct the debt.
36:10 So so the thanks for we'll go back to that. So national night out two years ago our net deficit was 2140. Okay.
36:21 This year our net deficit was 13.
36:25 Okay. So the ones in the black then were actually the ones that were in the black. Okay. Correct. Thank you.
36:28 I just want to make sure I understood that correctly.
36:30 The ones in the black made one on the operational side. Thank you.
36:42 Okay, so projects completed. We resurfaced the pool. We resurfaced the basketball courts at Waterfront Park and Pal. We resurfaced the Keer shuffle
36:52 board and we replaced shade the shade fabric of the splash park. Projects in progress, the artificial turf shelter,
37:00 which was just awarded, Hancock Park restroom in um That's a That's impact fees that's
37:07 paying for that. Um it's going a little slower than I hope. They the engineer we're working on capacity and the
37:15 engineer was originally calculating capacity based on the parking lot and the parking lot does not cover the
37:22 capacity of the park. So that has that had to be redone. So that's what the that's took the hold up on that and Bishop Field will start the committee on that project's on hold.
37:35 What's that going to happen?
37:38 The engineer. So there's restroom going um near the quad, new restroom going near the quad and out of impact fees. Um
37:47 the engineer is calculating capacity based on um doing a lift station and all
37:54 that kind of stuff. So the original the original numbers on whether this station was required was based on the parking
38:03 lot. estimated number of using the park based on the parking lot but the parking lot does not is not sufficient for that park being
38:12 full so it has to be recalled um field we know about projects on hold
38:20 so we talked about converting all the fielding port lights to LED we went through the RFP process the RFP has been
38:27 scored in conversations with the city manager um we're holding on that for budget reasons
38:34 a lump sum if we pay a lump sum. The final figure is not negotiated.
38:40 So that is Freddy would do that, but the lump sum would be around $2 million.
38:45 Without it, this is around it's not and if we paid it out over time depending upon how many years and what the lump
38:52 sum was be 200 to $400,000 a year based on again how many years and what the final total was. So that is on hold for
39:01 budget reasons. Victory Point Playground is also on hold for budget reason. We're going to get to a little bit more of that in a second. Um the property at the
39:10 BW dealership is I'm really honestly no progress has been made on that because obviously not sure what we can do with
39:19 that property and the city hall stage that project was canceled a couple weeks ago. So where where need in the middle?
39:28 Need in the middle is is still still there. It's it's going. So, min still
39:37 it's part of next year's plan. It's still going with this year's plan. I think there's going to be a presentation. I'm pretty sure Jeff was
39:45 ready to do a presentation in July at the end of this month or beginning of next month.
39:50 Are we doing anything with that million dollar grant we did?
39:55 Is there is there a time frame where we have to utilize that money? Um there I've spoken to Lwell about that. They
40:03 just need to know when the money is going to be used because of for their reasons. So I told them, you know, don't expect dirt to be pushed in the next
40:10 couple of months. So they're they're aware they're aware on that and they're waiting further construction. Um so the thing with the live well money is for
40:19 the tiered seating and they are expecting the restrooms to be part of the project and live well. So so you all know to
40:26 clarify on that they have to spend 5% each year as a foundation. So what
40:33 Bryan's referring to and he says, you know, for their own internal purposes, it's for them to manage their cash flows to make sure that they're hitting their
40:41 5%. So from what I gather in my conversations with representatives of Live Well, they don't necessarily
40:48 they're not necessarily saying you need to spend the money this year, but they are saying please tell us if you're not going to spend the money this year so that we can give that money away. not
40:58 that money, but give that amount away this year and we'll put you on next year's docket. So, they're just in good faith saying, "Keep us on what your
41:06 plan." And are we getting penalized because we're not spending it? So, we can go back to the well. We're not we're not um Oh, I don't know if the city as a whole
41:14 is getting penalized because the money is sitting not penalized money but penalizing you know we want to get an additional but us
41:22 not utilizing it. Does that give them a statement that we don't need it a year ago and yet we're not we're not moving on it.
41:31 So can we move on that portion?
41:34 That's that's honestly council's that's it doesn't not going to cost taxpayers anything
41:42 and we can you know have this project you know even if it's that tier project have it incorporated in the overall plan or something but at least show some good
41:51 faith that we're getting something done instead of being like the government and just you know it's one step forward and five backwards you know u as Bryan said
42:01 if I'm not mistaken in July we should be having a presentation from from uh how uh with where we stand with everything
42:10 was engineering and everything how we uh uh I guess
42:19 direction looking for direction from us to which way to go from there and I'm thanking how last he
42:26 have our council meeting um So, we're going to go back to the Victory Point playground for a second.
42:36 So, the number one, there's number one on the bottom and number two on the top.
42:40 So, I have reached out to several contractors that are that have piggyback eligible contracts to build a playground. Um, we
42:50 have $250,000 budgeted in this year's budget. This again this project is on hold with board in place and due to grading the area
42:59 that was number one which was my first choice came back at about $500,000 and the area number two on top came back
43:06 at a little over $400,000. So again this is on hold for budget reasons. I also know um just to let you know I had a
43:14 conversation with Patrick at Main Street last week. I know Main Street was interested in funding a Victory Point playground. Um I know we did something
43:23 similar with Kanas and and expansion of filter. So council council's interested in letting
43:30 Main Street funded and certainly doesn't hurt my feelings.
43:38 Well, Bryan, I I I hear that and I know people ask about playgrounds down here, but I I I sit here and I look and say,
43:46 "We going to put another brown right here in Victor for we got one less than a quarter mile uh right there at West Beach. Why don't we just extend that one
43:55 a little bit to create?" I think this I think the idea behind this is this one's much closer to being in the middle. I know that I've had
44:04 conversations with different people from the public about how when you are downtown in a warfront park and you're extending through the downtown area that
44:12 when you have a 5-year-old or three-year-old that going the walking so west beach park is a is a long walk when
44:19 you when you're going past house. So that was a reason that we looked at Victory Point as a as an area for a playground something that was
44:28 substantial um at Victory Point. So I didn't want you But again, when I was talking to the contractors and another
44:35 staff was talking to the contractors, some of the stuff that was coming back was we need something. We're going to do something a bit point. It needs to be big and bold. I don't want to swing set around. We want something substantial.
44:47 So, um, when the screen comes up, there's a there's a an example.
44:56 How does how does council feel if if um it's in the budget for 250,000
45:03 um if Main Street took over the bidding out the responsibility for
45:11 construction of this project? Are we comfortable with staff allocating some of those funds that we already have budgeted toward it to to supplement or
45:20 to give Main Street like a seed kind of grant so to speak so they could try to go get it matched somewhere? I like that.
45:28 I I do agree. And to answer your question, Tim, the uh I've got three young children and they're very active
45:35 and we go downtown a lot. We go to church downtown. So, we go to farmers market every Sunday and it's kind of
45:41 their afternoon alley and they never go to West Park. I mean, it's just it's just too far and you're going past so
45:50 many houses and kind of open space and it's just too far for the kids. Um, if anything, if we go that direction, we tend to go to Haywapa
45:58 because it's a bigger park and we can take the dog and you know, it's it's under the shade and so it's just kind of there there's more likely to be people
46:06 because it's a larger park. So, I think that having something in downtown whether there's maybe other sites in downtown. I
46:14 know Main Street's looking to partner with us on the one on 12th and is it Montro?
46:21 Um, and even that is kind of outside of kind of the downtown activity, I think.
46:27 So, wherever we put it in kind of the central downtown area, I could be supportive of that. I'd also support if we wanted to put that on CRA board to maybe fund it through the CRA.
46:36 I like that idea, too. Well, and that yeah, I was going to ask about that because I think this comes to a philosophical question of what is the
46:44 overall parks plan and I know that, you know, we've had fire do their fiveyear, police do theirs. I think I think parks is is
46:53 going to be coming or we're going to have one. Um, I think it might make sense to look at this from the bigger picture standpoint
47:01 of what is the overarching plan for our neighborhood parks? Um, and what is the
47:08 role in particular of within the CBD, uh, the central business district and the CRA? Can we get the CRA more
47:17 involved and engaged with these projects? And, you know, um, I think I said out loud uh, at a meeting that I
47:26 had asked our city attorney about the composition of the CRA, right? and um you know I I view this as an opportunity
47:34 for them to really take ownership of what's happening within that redevelopment area and provide guidance
47:42 in a in a kind of like in a P what PNZ does for developments they could do for within the CRA provide that first level
47:49 of review conversation recommendations and then it comes to the council with all that information I like that idea and then we have that final
47:57 discussion there um might might that be something we would want to
48:06 still do, but also think about it from the standpoint of how does it fit into the overall plan for the parks?
48:12 Um rather than, you know, spending 200,000 here when really it makes more sense if we've got West Beach, Victory
48:21 Point, the tot um
48:29 are we better serve, you know, kind of pooling those resources to make sure that we're not overlapping. And there might be some duplication we need to do
48:36 just based off proximity because kids aren't going to want to, you know, we don't want kids necessarily walking miles to go teeter totter, right?
48:43 But but also to make sure that, you know, we're providing good ample opportunity and capturing the place of
48:51 it as well. So that if if there's something unique about the place where the park is that could okay let's draw something here that this is where
48:59 you go for that yes in addition to some of the other traditional things and then this is how west fits in or this is how the top lot
49:07 fits in this is how meas in the middle you know that finally takes off how that fits in all these key uh uh and all
49:16 these other different things and not to mention if we get the deoyas properties eventually Um, there is that second
49:22 piece that is off of Oyola that I know people have talked about some sort of recreation or parks. I just think that we could really be more comprehensive
49:31 with it rather than just, you know, throwing money. I I want to do something, but I also want to make sure that we're doing it in a in a
49:38 concentrated or or collective way with a plan.
49:43 Are we comfortable if we spend a couple minutes on this right now? Is is that good or do we want to put this to tomorrow?
49:50 I'd love to engage in this and continue.
49:53 Um, I completely agree with everything that you said, Bryan, but what I'd like to see is if we
50:02 can move forward with some sort of process and maybe it's like a workshop in August where we could bring in the CRA members.
50:12 We can call it a joint workshop so that it can be public and then maybe invite in Main Street, invite in the
50:21 people that work with us. Something where yes, maybe we break it into two parts where we're talking, okay, here's CRA, here's downtown, which is part of
50:29 the overall recreation plan. The reason why I like August is because we need to make final decisions September. And so
50:37 I'm thinking if we could set up something in August with the CRA and community members, stakeholders in the
50:45 downtown area and then also the stakeholders who work with us. I'm thinking everyone who's ever bought a ticket to the performing arts center
50:54 like literally emailing out all these people to say, "Hey, we're having we're bringing now the MRPA study. We want to talk about we could address it in two
51:02 parts. How do we handle the CRA moving forward? Do we want to break it out into a different composition than it is now?
51:09 And then also the parks plan so that we can have final answers on the issue of parks and recreation when we come into
51:15 the budget for 27. And maybe even from that, I could see a group of people who are working on how we kind of talk about a recreation committee. I could see a
51:24 group of people working on what's our five-year plan for recreation and we're going to hear about trails. I think that's going to end up being part of that conversation. How do we feel about something like that?
51:38 I think it's a great idea.
51:39 I mean, I think, you know, it is we need to get somebody that can do like a 50,000 view of it. Like, you know, because we're picking one part, but how
51:47 do we know where all of these parts could be? I don't think uh either of any of us can know that, but we need to get somebody that does have that knowledge.
51:57 And to your point, Bill, about not wanting to be the government one step forward, five steps back, I I resonate with that. I agree with you. And I think
52:04 what I'm sensing from this group is desire to make sure that when we're spending the taxpayer dollars that we're doing it with wisdom and temperance and
52:14 that can be slower. I don't feel like we're intentionally not moving forward with something as much as we don't have
52:22 the information that we need to be able to make a high level decision which is what we need to be making so that the lower level decisions are easier and and
52:31 it's just us saying oh yeah that's consistent with the vision. Um Mr. Vaner do we have a workshop in August?
52:40 Is it already scheduled or is there anything on the agenda yet?
52:45 Okay. So, we have August 18th for a workshop. Do we want to call that as a joint CRA? How do we feel about that recreation and joint CRA workshop?
52:55 Yeah, I I I agree with that. And we can kind of uh get some ball rolling and have that conversation. I'd love to get
53:01 our current CRA member input on composition of the CRA and and also downtown businesses. So, may I suggest a little earlier?
53:11 Yes. On that?
53:12 Yeah. I I my opinion with workshops is that you know we we we can we can um do those when when the the folks who were engaging because it's not business.
53:23 We're not actually voting on an item. Um that we could, you know, do that a little bit more flexibly. 10:00.
53:31 Well, I will say I don't mind that for the CRA, but I think if we start talking about the parks and recreation users, we
53:38 may run into people who are used to doing their that come five o'clock and later.
53:45 Well, just because th those are the people who run the leagues and they tend to do nighttime activities. So, they either work during or day. I'm sure if they're
53:53 off they'd be happy to to come. Um, but they tend to be people whose business runs from kind of 5 to 10 at night.
54:00 What time do we think about maybe starting at 3 and that way the business owners can be here during business hours and then
54:09 and then or two? Yeah, they can take a little more time.
54:14 So that way if the recreation starts around 4:30ish, that gives them a chance to 3:00.
54:22 Yeah, we're talking about the 21st of August. 18th of August.
54:27 But Bryan, I want you to keep keep in mind that uh reason I asked a a question earlier about uh Victory Point in the
54:35 playground is because when that playground in in West Beach was established, we looked at Victory Point. We had a company called Kaboom.
54:46 I'm not sure if you're familiar with it, but they specializes in parks and everything.
54:51 And we went throughout the city at that time and uh we looked at Victory Point.
54:56 They looked at West Beach. We looked at several areas throughout the form and they they settled on that one at West Beach.
55:05 That's how the parking get there. They actually put it in us for for spring. That'd be great.
55:11 Yeah. Well, that's why I went in West Beach. That's why I question because Victory Point was looked at as a little skeptical for for park at the time.
55:20 Okay. Uh we did look at Victory Point. I was on the humility on the staff and everything that went through the city at the time. with Kaboom. Uh they came
55:28 through and uh they actually did that whole parking in two days, you know, once they Saturday, they came in got the volunteers Disney and everybody came in.
55:38 So that's why I'm saying why don't we expand on that one rather than going back to Victory Point. I can't remember what what it was about Victory Point.
55:46 They they they said was wasn't good for us.
55:49 Well, I think both are are great locations honestly and that's why but I like the idea of engaging with the
55:56 community members. Um I think I think that's the kind of thing that would be addressed in the workshop for sure. And
56:04 are we comfortable with these three work for everyone? I know you said it's a two.
56:09 It is primary election day. I don't know if that Yeah, August 18th is primary election day. I forgot about that. Yeah.
56:17 Well, that'll get everyone downtown. Okay.
56:19 So, I I don't think we have a primary.
56:22 No. Well, we don't we don't have one in the city, but there are items on the ballot that our residents will be voting on. Well, then more people will come.
56:30 And I know that we've had PNC meetings in the past on election day because those fall on that first Tuesday of November and typically PNC meets on that
56:39 first Tuesday. So, we do have a history of doing that. Um, but I just I throw that out there just for people's
56:45 schedule understanding that we may run into some issues with people's availability. Um, depending upon their
56:53 working polls or when they vote just told me she's not going to be here that day. Yeah. Oh, well, that's one.
57:00 Can she participate remotely? No.
57:04 Okay. Are there other dates in August that week before it's counsel? agenda.
57:17 You're going to need more than it's a bunch of
57:27 I mean, if we know we're going to do it right now, all we have are four first readings and a final
57:35 nuisance abatement. I mean, There's not that much on it right now.
57:40 If we We're talking about 25th. The 11th. Sorry. Oh, the 11th.
57:44 Yeah. I I'm fine having a meeting on that day.
57:48 I mean, if we don't have a lot else added, I would I don't know why we could necessarily do it at 5:30.
57:59 I just want to note there is talk of a close session on the 11th of August.
58:05 It's going to be a busy day.
58:11 Well, is that for sure?
58:14 That has been suggested by our city attorney and really have a time keeper so we all stay on point and get it done in an hour
58:22 and they go if you're committed to it being done. I think we can. I think we all committed to it being done and I'm fine with that.
58:33 if we want to do what do we think about maybe doing that and having a parks workshop at 5:30 after the meeting. So, we do two o'clock, do our meeting. It
58:42 doesn't look like it's going to be terribly long. And we call a parks workshop at 5:30 so people in the public can come.
58:53 5:30.
58:54 It's committing us to two and a half hours. But right now, like I said, the only thing the only things on the agenda are first
59:02 readings. And I think that sounds fine. We have a little um some little updates for us to keep going.
59:10 It's going to be a long day. Does that work for you?
59:13 The 11. Can you text Jimmy and make sure he's available? Is she allowed to do that? That's fine.
59:18 It's just maybe staff. Maybe staff.
59:25 And 5:30 is the park one. Is that what we're asking? Is that Did that work? So we do two o'clock CRM meeting.
59:34 Do we have to call that as a joint meeting and the close session?
59:42 The close session would be I believe around 2 or 2:30. Is that correct?
59:46 That's going to on the 11th minute. That's the 11th.
59:50 That's when that attorney is coming. So it matters that we give him a certain Mr. W. Yes. Yes sir.
1:00:00 I know.
1:00:04 I was trying to hide a little bit. Look like camera.
1:00:09 Sorry, I walked in. I wasn't quite privy to what you were discussing. Well, we're just trying to figure out we've got a I
1:00:16 think what we're talking about is the overall parks plan, a desire to have maybe a fiveyear plan so we can make
1:00:23 short-term decisions that we know they're consistent with the fiveyear plan, but also the CRA and how that plays into it and the possibility of
1:00:32 changing composition CRA board. And so then the pressure of obviously we're in budgeting so we want to have a final
1:00:40 budget and we want to be done with these kinds of decisions before the final budget comes around. So we're actually dealing with the issues of how to call the right meetings at the right times.
1:00:49 We know one of our survey members is not here on the 18th which is a workshop date. Could we do the close session on the 18th?
1:00:57 Is that a possibility?
1:00:59 What if we do the close session on the 18th and we reserve it for the recreation meeting? Can we do that?
1:01:05 That's the only Tuesday that hasn't been verified with the outside council firm, but I could do that now while we're sitting here.
1:01:13 Why don't we look at the the parks and rec on the 18th or do we like trying to do it after?
1:01:18 I'd like to do it after August 11th.
1:01:25 So preferred August 11th 2 o'clock CRA 3 o'clock council 5:30 parks and wreck workshop and then the 18th shade session if it works.
1:01:34 If it works. Yes. And what time would that be on the 18th? I'm good anytime. Okay.
1:01:42 And as long as am I able to participate via phone? Oh session.
1:01:47 Okay. I'll be at a conference but I'll take the call. Yes. Okay. clock for you.
1:01:56 Is that three? Yeah. Yeah, that's fine.
1:02:07 Okay.
1:02:13 Could we just do that whole thing by teams? Do we have to be in person? Yes. You have to have a forum in person.
1:02:21 Sorry. It's a real resource.
1:02:28 I'm I'm just being offended. Um Okay. I just thought it might make it easier for that attorney as well. Can he show up by teams?
1:02:35 Uh because um they they could they want to be here.
1:02:42 Is it the same attorney as Doug Noah N O? And I know that there's a second attorney they want to bring. I'm not sure who it is.
1:02:56 Oh, and then the question when we do the CR meeting, does it need to be a joint workshop? Does that matter since it's all the same five people?
1:03:04 You're asking, normally we would do a workshop and we'd all be there and the CRA board to be there, but since the CRA board is comprised of us plus two, you need to have a workshop.
1:03:12 Uh, you want the CRA to be a part of this?
1:03:15 Oh, and then notice workshop. Yeah. Or should we make it a meeting?
1:03:22 If you want to make decisions, if you want to take action, then it's got to be a meeting. If you just want to
1:03:30 discuss it, I think I think a workshop is better at first and then we formulate the decision and then make make like notice that
1:03:38 we're actually making the decision and who would make a decision on the composition of the CRA? Is that the council or the work or the CR? It's a good question. It's the C. It's the council.
1:03:48 So joint workshop Tracy, did you catch all that?
1:04:01 All right, derailed the perks there. Hey, you brought up that.
1:04:07 Well, it all did. T I had a profession. They're like Easter eggs. You find the good ones? You find the easy ones?
1:04:16 All right. All right.
1:04:17 All right. So this is this is just a rendering of an example just to swing back of what um $4 to $500,000
1:04:26 of a playground equipment with board and play services would get us. So that's not a final design of anything. It's just an idea of what that is.
1:04:37 Do we have a way to publish this in like the mom's groups or publish it in the mom's groups on Facebook?
1:04:44 Yeah, it's part of the part of the packet.
1:04:53 Um, not not requesting any additional staff in the new fiscal year.
1:05:00 Are we filling the position that was vacant?
1:05:04 Um, so we're it's there. Um, we classified it a little bit. parks,
1:05:13 recreation, and tourism manager. We're holding it until after the November election. And if the if the measure
1:05:20 fails, the property tax measure fails, we'll fill it at that time. If it passes, we will be
1:05:29 so of the 33 FTE that you currently have, how many are vacant? Is it just too?
1:05:38 Well, I have an administrative assistant who gave notice. um as of beginning of next month and that position will be
1:05:47 held and it'll be picked up by other staff until November and one of the rangers which is part-time gain notice
1:05:54 and that'll be held also. So we have five parttime rangers right now instead of six. So two and so as of next month two and a half are held.
1:06:03 Okay. Thank you.
1:06:04 I might be grabbing a stump skunk and if I am I apologize to everybody in advance. Um, has there been any conversation with the police chief about
1:06:13 what we got now? Community I'm so sorry. What do they call chief? Community what?
1:06:20 CSOS. CSOS. Community service. Thank you. I want to use the right name.
1:06:24 Community service officers, which are different but have similarity in their public facing function with parks rangers.
1:06:34 And to me, there seems to be a potential for efficiency if there was only one
1:06:40 group of people that had public facing functions and I don't know how to do it. I'm not
1:06:49 telling you how to do it. It just have YouTube chatted is my real question.
1:06:54 Just just briefly mentioned, but I think we're on the page right now that the the rangers serve an essential function that
1:07:01 is different than what the positions So when we get to when we get to closing
1:07:07 parks and and managing that aspect of making sure restrooms are maintained,
1:07:14 making sure tournament rooms are satisfied, checking on grills and things like that.
1:07:21 There are certain things that the rangers do that position isn't, but we didn't have any in-depth conversation about it.
1:07:27 Is is anyone else interested in seeing kind of comparison of what those two positions do or am I on
1:07:36 I don't know if we supposed to, you know, sometimes it could be micromanaged.
1:07:40 That's true. Yeah. But I'm thinking if if we're funding positions in the budget, like one of the questions is for
1:07:45 another cso. And so although we're not requesting more positions in parks and recck, we are requesting more positions
1:07:54 on the cso side. And so for me to understand the request, I want to be able to put my judgment on it. wonder it's but if I'm out of line
1:08:03 I'm out of line. So that's I don't think I think we need to leave that with the police department and not
1:08:10 not um try to mix that with with parks and banks. But I did have a question on
1:08:17 personnel because you hoping that maybe I'm not reading this right but when I look through the budget uh through your budget on page 111 you saying arts and
1:08:26 recreation personnel you're actually reducing it by two uh people six. It's it's just a shift in where
1:08:35 they're budgeted because we have the three divisions. But as we get into this, we have we've had four divisions.
1:08:40 We'll have three divisions. It doesn't change the doesn't because we're going to combine um the performing arts division with the art with the art
1:08:49 division to that's how we're going to change the numbers. But we went through I went through with my staff and with
1:08:57 human resources on where the most logical place is for positions to be budgeted and there were certain positions that were
1:09:06 places that didn't make as much sense and I don't know you know it's just a matter of historically like we had rangers and you know certain times we
1:09:14 had rangers budgeted out of the arts division which they had really no business being there. I'm not sure how they got there. I think they were kind
1:09:22 of spread throughout the divisions. So, I just put them all. That's some of what happened.
1:09:27 The office manager was budgeting and moved that position to 572 parks and recreation division. That was it. It's
1:09:35 not really a It's a shift. It's not a change.
1:09:38 Yeah. But I'm looking at last year, you saying you had 12.5 people, excuse me, in the AR. This year, you look only looking for 10 10 and a half. So, you're
1:09:45 reducing it too. But I also see a proposed increase in personnel cost of $131,000.
1:09:52 If we're reducing it by two people, why why we got such a high increase in personel?
1:09:58 Well, I'm just looking at what I'm reading here.
1:10:00 No, I I know I I don't do the as far as the actual salary numbers and that if you look on page 17.
1:10:09 Okay. on the arts and craft got personnel cost of last year was only 8.96
1:10:16 but then you ask in 27 you asked for one uh 1 million27 which is $131,000 increase but then when I look at your
1:10:24 personnel charge on page 121 26 you had 12 and a half people and then 27 you're asking for 10 and a half so
1:10:32 that's two people reduction but 131 so where where's the cost coming from trying to figure out mayor I can help Bryan with that
1:10:40 question. The proposed budget and this is true citywide of all departments. Um the two driving well there's actually
1:10:48 three variables that that drive increases in personnel costs beyond staffing changes. Uh one is we do include a presumed increase in health
1:10:58 insurance and uh at in this case this year 7%.
1:11:04 And in the case of vacancies or new positions, we make the presumption that that position will be filled by a person
1:11:11 who elects to choose the most expensive option. So it's a conservative budgeting approach. Second variable of course are
1:11:19 pension contributions which is at a fixed rate but is driven by changes in salary levels. Then the third level, our
1:11:26 third variable is uh we do have a midyear um anticipated adjustment in salaries
1:11:34 based off the annual merit reviews. Um we presume that at the highest level as
1:11:41 authorized by the city manager. Now of course based on the individual reviews that actual percentages could be slightly lower but we do budget it at the highest level possible.
1:11:52 Well and and If you look at page 120 and 121, you can see 2.5 increase in parks and rack.5
1:12:02 decrease in special events. So now we're in net two. And if you come to arts and recreation center, you see 12.5 to 10.5.
1:12:09 So it's two reductions. So I see the shift. Uh but when you ask that question, what stands out to me and and tell me if I'm reading this wrong or if
1:12:18 I'm thinking about it wrong because maybe I'm thinking about it wrong, but it seems to me that all of the swim and lifeguard related positions.
1:12:31 I hate to sh I'm sorry on, but it seems like they would be more appropriately
1:12:39 allocated under the Arts and Recreation Center versus Parks and Wreck. And if I'm wrong, I'm wrong. Um, but it seems like that's where they live.
1:12:48 I did. So, yeah.
1:12:51 Well, you go back and I can say I guess what I'm looking at is you're right. You got the arts and record. If you look at
1:12:58 everything, everything broke down a record. You go back and you got the parks and recreation as well. The budget for that. That's all broken down, right?
1:13:08 Okay. Um I would looking at that as well. I would think uh I thought about the same thing.
1:13:15 Why aren't the uh lifeguards under arts and wreck? Yeah.
1:13:20 However, you think about it because we also have waterfront park. that we used to provide water. Uh we used to anyway I don't know if we still provide lifeguard down there or not.
1:13:30 Uh we don't have life water parking. So um so yes and I thought about that too.
1:13:37 I was I'm thinking about um the ark is as kind of two separate entities meaning
1:13:45 the gym and the pool is parks and recreation and the rest of it is the ark. That's how I was that's how I was thinking of it.
1:13:56 But then again, I still go back and I like to say when I look on page 121 arts, recreation, arts and rec personnel
1:14:05 and extra personnel, you're asking for 10 and a half reducing it by two. Then again, I go back to 117
1:14:14 where you have soal the budget part. And Mr. But I I hear that because down in uh bottom 117
1:14:22 I see the uh one two guess account 12300 group insurance. I see the increase $158,000 of life insurance. Thank you.
1:14:33 But still that's that's only a $45,000 increase in health insurance. You're still looking at well if you take the 45
1:14:41 you're still looking at almost 90 90 almost $85,000 increase in personnel cost. I'm just
1:14:49 curious why why such a big increase in personnel and that do not that's not the only one I saw that never worked well
1:14:57 but so and I'm just trying to figure out why did we that due to pay raises or
1:15:04 what could that be like vacancy factor do you
1:15:12 factor that in and that's what that increase is that in the event let's say there is a vacancy of two personel, but
1:15:19 you want to budget for full capacity. Is that correct?
1:15:22 In this particular case, I believe that is true. Uh, as I said a moment ago, when vacancies exist or a new proposed
1:15:31 position exist, we conservatively budget for those vacancies. Um for instance to
1:15:38 put numbers to this um currently our um family insurance coverage and nine hits
1:15:47 I'm about to put out a number that I don't know spec exactly but I believe the family health insurance uh total cost is in the upper 20s handily. Yeah.
1:15:59 Whereas if someone came and that's how we budget for those scenarios. That's just what we need to pay. That's not what the employees are paying. That's the total cost actually.
1:16:07 So employees are paying portion of that.
1:16:10 Correct. Yeah. However, that that whoever fills that position may elect only to take the employee portion and
1:16:17 not to help the full family portion which is significantly lower cost. So that that is just a budgeting philosophical approach that we take to be conservative.
1:16:27 But you say we we uh health insurance you budgeted at 7%, right?
1:16:33 That's correct. We're anticipating 7% 7% we don't know I know one year we did seven 8% and it came in at 27% 15% a
1:16:42 couple years ago and that is one of the difficult challenges we have in our budgeting is that we don't know that number until after the budget process is completed.
1:16:51 So we're making an educated guess based off of uh uh the data we have year to date. Uh this year was even a little bit
1:16:59 more difficult to forecast given that we're transition to a new health insurance provider. Um but we are
1:17:06 confident as we sit here today in that 7% projection.
1:17:09 Yeah. And I think I read somewhere in the bud but you use 7% but that was across four all the departments right.
1:17:15 So yes sir. Okay. But still, I I'm just I I I hear what you're saying about you can budget
1:17:23 for allocation, but I'm still looking at page one 121 where you have your personnel and you actually eliminate two positions.
1:17:31 I I actually But I don't I think I don't think they've eliminated it though.
1:17:35 They've shifted it. They they took two out from somewhere else and put two in someplace else. Is that the simp Let's shift that cost in to somewhere else as well.
1:17:45 Okay. Uh because when I sit back and I look at what you had last year like in 25 uh with the 12 and a half people, you only had 896,000.
1:17:55 Yeah, he's he's right. I see what you see. See?
1:17:58 Yeah. If you look at page 117, it's the arts and rec center. And if you compare it to
1:18:06 page 121, you can see it is the arts and rec center, the division of parks and recreation is showing a loss of two staff.
1:18:16 And when we look at that, um, okay, well, part of it could easily be we're reducing part-time attendance.
1:18:25 The part-time staff member would make significantly less than the position that we're adding, which is a manager position. But I thought we Okay. So, we had a maintenance manager.
1:18:35 That's the one that got shifted to the recreation and tourism manager. So, that should be the same pay. I I I see what
1:18:42 you see. Um, so if we look at let's look at parks and recre.
1:18:52 So, this is Yeah, I think he's right, Jonathan, that we just don't have the match in the
1:18:59 allocation of the employees because we show two personnel increases on page 120 for parks and recck. But if we look at
1:19:07 the proposed budget on page 112, we see um a net change
1:19:23 and that's something that I work with finance team.
1:19:27 I think um you convinced me with the gym as a pool. I see you now. Thank you. Um,
1:19:34 can we consider I'll tell you the name of that building go crazy because everybody calls it
1:19:41 something different. If we can get on the same page with the department, what I'm hearing you say is what we're calling the Arts and Recreation Center on page 117.
1:19:51 Those expenses are a combination of the building itself and the operations of the performing arts center.
1:20:03 And I don't and I'm sorry I don't have the I'm not looking at what somebody needs to know.
1:20:08 So So my question and this is probably as much for Scott as anything else because I want to without scaring anybody I just want to
1:20:17 have clear picture of what are we spending on performing arts versus what are we spending on
1:20:25 recreation and right now unless I'm mistaken performing arts is bearing the the financial apparent financial burden of
1:20:34 the entire building which recreation i.e the pool and the gym are benefiting.
1:20:42 So, if there's a financial function, Scott, of being able to allocate the gym
1:20:49 and the pool expenses under arts and recreation, excuse me, under parks and recreation, in other words, Scott's page
1:20:58 112 and 113, and then allocate the performing arts center. And then we
1:21:06 need to figure out how the uh rentals play into that. Are those or are they performing arts? That way we can
1:21:14 understand what we're spending on performing arts versus arts and witness
1:21:22 center because this building does all of those things. So there are operating expenses associated with each one of those functions. They share the benefit of one building which is convenience.
1:21:33 But I want to make sure when I'm seeing the budget for parks and recck, I'm able to distinguish this service that we're providing to the public,
1:21:41 what each individual service costs with the wisdom that they all share one building.
1:21:47 And so we may be getting efficiencies in one place that have inefficiencies in others. But then we can actually be comparing what is parks and wreck, what
1:21:54 is performing arts, what is rental facility because we kind of have a city center and performing arts center and a
1:22:02 recreation center in one place but they have operations associated with that. So I'm trying to to make sure that's clear
1:22:10 and the naming keeps me confused and off balance.
1:22:16 I'm seeking clarity. Not today. It might take you time.
1:22:23 Well, I'll say this. When um Mr. Foreman approached us at the beginning of this budget cycle about consolidating the two
1:22:31 divisions, there was no reason for us to object from an accounting or finance perspective. Um now, if it's the will of
1:22:39 the council for us to redivide that, we can quickly and easily do that. Well, I see it as a management function.
1:22:45 I I understand your perspective completely and I see what you're It makes sense what you're saying, Bryan.
1:22:51 Maybe you can and again I expect you to have it today. It's just I would like to get some clarity on it
1:23:01 because I and I'll speak in Mr. Bay as we're talking about, you know, a five-year plan for parks and there's an amount of
1:23:09 money that's allocated that the taxpayers pay for one building.
1:23:15 One building, but that building serves a lot of different purposes. And so I think we need to be able to make informed and fully transparent and
1:23:23 biased decisions as we move forward with a five-year plan on what that one building is providing,
1:23:31 what we like, what we could do better, what we could do different, and to explore all the options for the taxpayers. I want to scare people
1:23:39 listening. I just want to have all the information and to have it be clear. And right now I don't it doesn't feel clear.
1:23:47 And it could be that I've just done so much. I accept that as a possibility. Is what I'm saying making sense to you?
1:23:54 It does make sense. I do think when you dig into the budget, there are items that are specific to performing arts
1:24:02 that are that are not. But that's when you get into the line coded spreadsheet.
1:24:11 I'm assuming special events is more or less performing arts, right?
1:24:15 Special events. So 574 is special events is not performing arts. Performing arts is part of 575. Performing arts had been
1:24:24 its own division of 579 and we enrolled those expenses into 575 to be part of
1:24:31 the arts division. And now part of this I will tell you that in
1:24:40 been in I've been director multiple municipalities and and had some budgets that were larger than this that were just one division or just one budget and
1:24:49 I've also been in other cities where it was four divisions. So, you know, me going away, I was trying to
1:24:59 um group the ark as much as possible to say, "Okay, this is this is how much the ark costs, the building." The building. Yes.
1:25:07 And all the things that happen in it.
1:25:08 Yes. But I did, but you're correct in that I did separate out the life the lifeguards and the part-time attendants
1:25:16 back there who were saying, "Okay, um, give me your five bucks to go use the pool." Scott, is there a way for us to
1:25:24 create a building budget that has sub accounts in it for rent versus rental versus um performing arts?
1:25:36 Is that another way to develop?
1:25:39 I believe we can accomplish that through our um project coping system and we do a lot there are examples particularly in
1:25:46 public services where we uh do some accounting and budgeting based off location some very similar concept that's what I'm thinking because we do
1:25:55 have the traditional recreation services but then have this unique thing of performance and then we also have a
1:26:02 rental facility and so those are distinguishable in the world of recreation Yes.
1:26:11 The other things, and this is probably more for Scott, what I would like to see before the final vote is on the
1:26:18 recreation side, the revenues as well as the expenses because we saw them in the report, which
1:26:26 was great, but they're not in our packet. So, the packet only includes expenses, but I think there are revenues associated like show high expense, but
1:26:35 then there's a revenue that puts So maybe you can see it and I think the revenue is part of the what's available online. Correct Scott.
1:26:48 So I know that there was because I looked at this online the online version and I actually have so I'll show quick
1:27:11 In your budget book, you turn to page number 23. Is it 23? Yes, sir. I thought I saw it somewhere.
1:27:22 These are the accounts within the general fund. And there is a section
1:27:29 near the bottom of the page, cultural recreational total. Got it.
1:27:34 You can see your boat ramp fees, your CPAC tickets, the items that were being discussed.
1:27:39 And there's So, and there's like $750,000 there. And then there's another area where there's rental fees and other
1:27:48 stuff. That's where the other I think that's what threw me is I said, "Well, those could be rental fees for like the city center, for example.
1:27:56 And I'm I'm not even criticizing as much as I'm trying to figure out how you want to break this down to make it easy to follow.
1:28:03 Well, I and I understand what you're saying because that one of the problem I had well I guess I knew it was there but I just couldn't remember because when I
1:28:12 started I went front to back and I got I got back there and I was I got there and I had to keep flipping back and forth,
1:28:19 okay, to try to look at revenues to expenses and everything. So I think um What what you're saying is in the future
1:28:26 we put everything the revenues for each department there with the expenses and instead us having to go back and forth.
1:28:35 And so say you guys are kind of the first thing I was looking at. So we are able to run off the mun report on all
1:28:42 our revenue. So we have charges for cultural charges for services, performing arts center which is our
1:28:50 tickets, light up revenue, jazz festival revenue, rents, victory point revenue, splash
1:28:58 park revenue, what we get from the rowing facility, um facility fees from the performing
1:29:06 arts, killer building revenue, pool revenue, gym revenue, field revenue, Highlander building, waterfront park,
1:29:14 park pavilions, camp out. So all this stuff is all this stuff is clear on this document.
1:29:22 You know what? For my purposes and my request, if it's well, if you Rick, if you could print that off, I'll just put it in the book. If you can have it
1:29:30 printed, I'll just put it in there and I'm good for this year because then I can see it. And then for you, Bryan, if there's things that
1:29:39 Let me get clarity. Is everything what's listed as arts and recreation center related to the building when it comes to
1:29:46 expenses. In other words, roof maintenance, cleaning, all everything whether it's the gym or the pool, all of that under the center. Correct.
1:29:54 The building related expenses all live under the center.
1:29:57 Correct. Okay. So, person not all personnel, but all the expenses operating and facilities. I have to
1:30:05 check on I have to I believe the pool is under the I have to want to go back and look. I believe the pool is under.
1:30:12 So that's just what I'm trying to get clarity and then I can break it down and run it by you and make sure I'm reading it right. But I find it to be hard to follow. And then
1:30:20 but I think for this I don't know if I necessarily if it's easy to print the revenues for every department I think it's good to have. Yes. Yes.
1:30:28 For me the ones that don't make revenue you know zero I guess. I mean, but for this one, it is interesting to know what the revenues are that match
1:30:36 the expenses because I think it can be misleading when you look for different expenses.
1:30:41 And that's why I'm going at the beginning of the presentation. That's why I pulled up the net revenue on the events because that's great.
1:30:49 Yeah. But like I say, Scott, uh I know you had to set because I looked at revenue right off the bat when I looked in into the budget and everything. Of
1:30:56 course, I get back all expensive. I'm trying to go back and forth and figure out all this. the personnel cost. I'm
1:31:04 really curious to see in that arts and recreation when I see that big of increase and you reduce personnel why we got such a big increase in person.
1:31:13 So I think it's just an administrative function.
1:31:15 Yeah. Yeah. When you go back and you go back and look where he say move two people over to parks and wrecks, you have a reduction in personnel cost.
1:31:24 Yeah.
1:31:26 So I I went by and I looked at insurance. I the increase in insurance I see a bike
1:31:34 guard and all that I see all that broken down as well but this person right seem a little high when you get rid of
1:31:42 rid to it I'm like can we be paying you guys this much more money
1:31:49 so anyway um it's good uh oh the other thing I uh I did want to question back on your
1:31:58 capital expenses uh capital budget This 12 I don't know who got you go first.
1:32:11 I volunteered. Oh, okay. Um All right. So, proposed highlights.
1:32:21 So, $75,000 has been in public services for quarters that was moved over into parks and recreation. There's $65,000 in
1:32:29 originally for a fiveyear strategic plan. It could be a master plan. Shane did send me something this morning on a
1:32:37 little brief document on what a master plan would look like. So that's at council's direction on where they want
1:32:44 to go, where you guys want to go with that. I added place your AI is not a sole source. So there are other um there
1:32:52 are other softwares that do similar stuff but I had money for place so that we can like figure out how many people were really at July 4th. I mean it was
1:33:00 there was a lot of people there but how many people were really there place will help us know that and where they came from. Yes. We had a lot of people from out of town.
1:33:09 Yeah. Um the Christmas tree and sips and salsa have been in the CRA budget. they have been moved into um out of CRA into
1:33:18 general fund and we just talked about performing arts and art in the same division. So um capital proposal Hancock
1:33:28 Park uh field five so we have the four together field five tenses at a distance that serves nobody which is it's too
1:33:36 short for slow pitch and too deep for fast pitch. So, we're going to relocate that and bring that in. So, that that's um that's the same distance as the other
1:33:45 four fields there. That would also there is a is there anarchy over that? Why would there be over that? Don't the guys use it?
1:33:53 No. No, they they play Felter. Oh, really?
1:33:56 They play filter. Felter has 300. They don't use that at all. They only use Hancock Park one year when there's something going on at Felter in that
1:34:04 field. It was before my time, but the fence is too shallow for Can we make it deeper?
1:34:10 If we made it deeper, we'd have to relocate the light poles that are in the hellfield. That's a that's a much bigger expense.
1:34:19 So, um, we've had a temporary fence up for years. Was a temporary fence sitting there and then land not doing anything.
1:34:28 We actually had a plan that was reduced when we talked about um kind of cutting back on some of our
1:34:35 projects to make to cover all our expenses. We had other things that originally planned for the space outside the relocated fence like new batting
1:34:43 cages and storage things like that. Um at Park Pow there's $40,000 for irrigation renovation design because
1:34:52 that irrigation is as old as I am. Um, so me, so this just the design based on
1:35:00 what we heard a few weeks ago from South Lake Wood League. I did ask um the awarded vendor for Felter Park to give
1:35:08 us a price on what it would cost just to protect four infields at pound. It was $1.3 million. There's nothing in the budget for that, but I'm just noting it.
1:35:17 Um, so I'm not proposing that we do it.
1:35:20 I'm just saying if we wanted to t the infields of pow that's what it would cost.
1:35:25 Well um um well that going to be one of my question because here you only had the 40,000 you wasn't sure anything else
1:35:32 and I just curious because we need to do something in fields. Um, like I say a couple weeks ago and like I said way back in March when I was out there I
1:35:41 requested some work be done because those fields were very unsafe for our kids out there right now condition and we need to be doing something. So if we
1:35:50 maybe not do them all maybe I would like to see if we can put it in the budget water to we got four fields out there
1:36:00 and the soccer field and the are you counting the field.
1:36:08 Yeah, T-ball.
1:36:10 All in the that artificial turf is just for the four main field. So, the larger field and the three little league fields.
1:36:18 Can you get with Donna at Livewell and see if they might be willing to help us?
1:36:23 And I I only bring this up because we really do serve a lot of South Lake County. It's not just Clermont. So that
1:36:31 is yeah that that is when we talk about the lily the fields that lily is using it is primarily used by little there's very little other usage
1:36:40 they do have it is a large amount of people that are not clown residents this is something I think um potentially lake
1:36:48 county IST funding and and if sufficed request that
1:36:55 I think that's something that would be Um, you know, there could be some funding reports.
1:37:03 Well, the park was actually when it was first built years ago, it was built as little that's primary purpose and
1:37:11 everything. But like I said, when I was out here in March, excuse me, I went on the field and I condition I box in a hole. It's it's very safe.
1:37:24 But does that include the temporary or the I call them temporary mounds. It's really small, but we interpret the lower.
1:37:32 Yeah, I know what you're talking about.
1:37:33 I know you're talking about the temporary mounds. Um, is it temporary mounts are not that they wouldn't move the needle on that,
1:37:41 but I know Did the gentleman give us support for Bishop? I know that was part of the I did not talk to him about what it cost
1:37:49 to do Bishop. I was just I just got I think L would be very interested in engaging on this.
1:37:57 And I don't know what the county's position is on funding, but I hear they don't have money. So
1:38:11 trying to spend your money.
1:38:13 But yeah, but we need to I would like to see something. We can go back and put something in your bud to try to do something different.
1:38:22 I will Astro Turf is the right thing to go right now with just some kind of maintenance and everything to get them in condition. I know they fall season
1:38:30 get ready to start September is they're August. That's that is part of the thing with um little they start the end of they're the end of
1:38:37 January until they're just wrapping up now and then they're off for like a month and that's it and then they're August to November again. So there's not a lot of down time on those fields.
1:38:47 Yeah. spring and fall season. So it's August, they gonna start again, but then they start in March as well. So trying to get that work done.
1:38:59 Um, so air conditioning units, there's 21 air conditioning units at the AR. So
1:39:08 they're all like they're almost 20 of them were put in in were manufactured and put in in 2015. One of them was
1:39:17 actually 2013. This one is this one that we're in store in coverage rooms one through six. We've had a few major
1:39:24 repairs on it recently. So, we're going to need to this is going to be something that's going to be pretty much an every year thing that we're going to be
1:39:31 replacing units now going forward. So, like police replaces cars, we're going to have to replace air conditioning units at New York. Um, and then a small
1:39:41 dance floor replacement. That one's kind of beat up. So, that's a very minor number. Bishop Field where you know we've talked about the committee and
1:39:48 then meets in the middle of the veterans first responder memorial uh the stage main stage that I need to
1:39:58 have some attention to yeah thank yeah but I had screws and everything else I stomp my to almost tripped on screws coming up out of the
1:40:06 floor when I was up there for Memorial Day. Okay.
1:40:10 All right. I'll make sure I'll make sure that and uh it needs some attention up there.
1:40:15 I'll make sure. I know they just painted it, but I'll make sure they they're checking all the scoops.
1:40:21 And um that's the budget. We actually spent less on FY25 at the end of the
1:40:28 year than we did in FY24. We'll see what FY26 looks like in a few months.
1:40:36 And Morning
1:41:02 everybody. Um, just to give you a quick update on sidewalks, bike paths, connectability.
1:41:10 City staff has heard the council frequently mention their desire for a more connectable community via
1:41:18 multimodal opportunities. To that end, um I think you're all aware that we've looked at current projects like the
1:41:27 blocks construction. We evaluated that for the opportunity to put trail in and we're waiting pricing for a bike trail, a painted bike trail.
1:41:38 So, we're looking at existing projects to try to do what we can to provide opportunities. Additionally, staff is
1:41:48 working with a private Facebook group who are a bunch of cycling advocates, I
1:41:55 guess to say that, u have decided that they'd really like to work with us and
1:42:02 come up with some connectable plans based off of some of the work that DPZ has done.
1:42:09 They're actually very valuable, very informative with city staff and giving us a lot of good opportunities and
1:42:18 ideas. The group is chaired by Valerie Shoot. Um, lots of members, lots of engagement, interaction.
1:42:28 I believe the hope is that they will they will provide um opportunities and
1:42:34 areas potentially small projects where we can develop further connectability.
1:42:41 We have a lot of existing opportunities in the city but there's always gap points. Right now we're busy evaluating
1:42:50 a lot of the gap points, you know, where we can improve and things of that nature and giving us a lot of recommendations.
1:42:57 To that end, um, in the infrastructure budget, which we'll get to in public services, we've increased the budget for
1:43:06 sidewalks and connectability, modest $200,000 additional to begin some
1:43:14 seps coming good effort from the citizen.
1:43:23 I think I saw in the budget sidewalks you had 500. So you increased it 200. So we my original Yeah. My original
1:43:31 discussion was based off our master side of plan. So we were at I believe 375. Okay.
1:43:37 So we spend we have $75,000 that we teamly budget for designing new sidewalk areas. There was difficult
1:43:46 grades for the engineer engineering firm. We had $200,000 which was an increase to really get into
1:43:54 neighborhoods to try to finish an entire neighborhood instead of building sidewalks one by one. Let's just blanket
1:44:01 and do a whole neighborhood. And then the additional $200,000 can be applied to sidewalks or any connectability
1:44:10 projects. My anticipation is some of these projects will be fairly major require engineering to accomplish. Some
1:44:18 of them will be rather simplistic that you know with the purchase of supplies inhouse staff can probably provide what
1:44:26 we need. So you know we're going to work with the group and take recommendations from them. Um they're the users so like
1:44:35 to tailor what our efforts are to what they come up with. Yeah.
1:44:41 I know in your budget I hate to get there because you know you had distant avenue in there. Uh I'm assuming that's going east down the pit.
1:44:51 Absolutely. That's that priorities for design. We are budgeting for construction next year and that
1:44:59 construction budget's $100,000. We still haven't got the design for from what's that Prince Edwards to uh Drew Avenue along Pit Street as well.
1:45:09 Next year. Next year. Some response too.
1:45:15 And I know I got a lot of people come and thank thank me for the ones that for the what we did on East Avenue connection to East Avenue and Miniha.
1:45:26 But we still got a lot to do on Miniha. West Miniha. Yes. know about that.
1:45:34 So, but I think one of the problem we run into on many I think some of the neighbors don't want you to do the sidewalk inter.
1:45:44 So, so far in the in the areas that we've worked, we haven't crossed that, but historically
1:45:51 we have met with people and suggested and been, you know, essentially run out of town. It's torches and all. So, you
1:46:00 know, we anticipate that before really before we invest any real funding, we do hand out flyers and
1:46:09 request people feedback. You know, what if we put a sidewalk in and what you think your front yard is, which is
1:46:17 actually city right away. How would you feel about that? It's never been here for 45 years. Now, we're going to put a sidewalk in. You know, if we've got some
1:46:25 strong emotions, we can we can sidestep that and move to a different spot because we have plenty of spots. Someday we'll have to deal with it
1:46:34 over there sele we've accomplished quite a bit in house.
1:46:48 Now we've run we're running into a spot where there's a lot more obstructions and obstacles, but it's some of that's
1:46:56 going to be necessary to deal with to to make those final connections to give a complete system so people can actually
1:47:04 well I was I was thankful because when I left Fourth of July fireworks on Wednesday on Saturday night came up
1:47:11 third and I came down because I couldn't get out the East Avenue was so backed up and I saw a lot of people walking down the sidewalk. walked over here. I see
1:47:19 all that we put in last year. I know we call headaches about it, but we got it done, you know. So, I say thank God for sidewalks and people not walking down the street.
1:47:28 So, it utilized toward sidewalk expenses. I'm glad to
1:47:38 hear this being done. Maybe the kids don't have to walk to school. Uvenue.
1:47:47 Crazy, man. We may already had accidents. Couple people got killed.
1:47:54 Well, if the council provides the funding, we'll do our darnest to spend it for you.
1:47:59 Well, you say it's on the book for this year. This one, I'm hold you, you too.
1:48:02 I've been looking for that one for almost 10 years.
1:48:04 It's right there. It's right there. I have no neighborhood objections yet. But if there is one, well, I know my sister's over there on
1:48:12 Distant and she came to me and told me she don't want a sidewalk on her side of the street. I say, "Well, I think we we going to put the sidewalk whether it's on your side or the other side, it's
1:48:20 coming." So, I appreciate your participation.
1:48:25 I mean, it's we got so many kids in the elementary kids walking to the school academy, walking down another road and the traffic speed over there and that
1:48:34 has become a uh become a main thoroughare because a lot of people use it as shortcuts there when
1:48:42 they come to Marie Academy. have come up cut through all of the neighborhood.
1:48:48 So, well, and it connects the Northwest and the Northeast because it's the only way to cross 27 without crossing 50 and 27.
1:48:55 That's an important that's an important connector. Uh I fully support the effort of Mr. Maywe. I love that it's being
1:49:02 driven by the public. Um a lot of these a lot of these ladies and gentlemen are doing as I understand it. Um,
1:49:11 you call them audits, walking audits, walking and biking.
1:49:14 Walking and biking audits. So, they're literally going into the neighborhoods that are connecting the parks, connecting to schools. How do I get there? What I feel comfortable with my
1:49:22 child riding their bike to get there and to be and I think it's great. I love it.
1:49:27 I want to support it. To that end, I think this is probably for the city manager or deputy city manager. Um, I think something that could support us so
1:49:35 that it's not entirely on the taxpayers would be if there was maybe a fund to the community foundation.
1:49:43 Uh, I mean that's why it exists. you know, if we could help identify if someone needs to I don't know how the process works, but if there was a fund,
1:49:51 then we could notify we could notify, you know, business owners, um, philanthropists and the community that they could donate to that fund and maybe
1:50:00 match what we're putting in because I think that there's a lot of grants for trails and sidewalks and safe access to schools. Um, so I think that if we are
1:50:09 investing, which I fully support, I would like to see a mechanism by which the private sector could invest and also
1:50:18 we now have a grant writer that we're applying for grants because everything we put in becomes matched to something else. Then you can take that and you can
1:50:26 match to something else and you can multiply your money to the larger grant organizations if you start by matching small. So I I want you I want you to be aggressive with this. That's how I feel.
1:50:38 But I'd like you to be aggressive also in seeking out of grants and and not getting the private sector in this because I think there's a lot of people
1:50:46 in our community who would be willing to say I'll throw some money into that pot to help kids have a safe way to ride to
1:50:53 school to help you know single moms to help have access to jobs. I think there's a lot of people support that if they knew how to do it.
1:51:00 Yes. and and by having it housed at a foundation rather than in a city account,
1:51:07 um you you I think entice or increase the opportunity for people to leave uh
1:51:16 and dedicate funding after they pass their estates. Uh they can allocate some funds for those accounts to be utilized
1:51:25 and and then that way they are I think there's a a terminology used industry where it's it's earmarked essentially
1:51:33 where it can only be used specifically for certain things. Um, and communities do that. My previous community that I
1:51:40 served uh had that at the foundation and that's how people you know if someone felt very passionate about parks
1:51:48 rather than give to the city coffers they could give to the foundation and then the foundation through their board could determine how best to utilize those funds to enhance the community.
1:52:00 Oftentimes it was through the city but there were occasions where it wasn't. uh maybe through through the Little League Foundation or whatever else, something
1:52:08 another private entity, but I think that's a great way to entice that and also show that the city is looking to
1:52:14 partner with folks. Um and it does take that partnership to do that. I agree.
1:52:21 I I think that this is too big for us Yeah. as government. Yeah.
1:52:26 But I don't think it's too big for us as the people.
1:52:31 I'm sorry. I think I cut you off, Chandra. No, no, you're fine.
1:52:37 Keep in mind like a lot of area we concerned with like uh many chestnut street when I really caught my eye on
1:52:46 Saturday night. I was coming back as I got home just went around the world come out chestnut. They caught my eye. They
1:52:53 didn't have any side really no sidewalks over there as well. But back in the days when they built these communities sidewalks was a thing.
1:53:00 That's correct. Now, now we talking about more walkability. So, sidewalks and things and one of the other things which I know uh we're in the process of using for blocks which you block branch.
1:53:11 Yes. how we got some of them out there like a park on the blocks everything two or three different blocks we use upgrade
1:53:18 infrastru continue to use them thing but I don't
1:53:26 know what other areas in clip out we can use block grants for now other than that one area
1:53:34 it is a fairly limited CDBG yeah Yeah, we outpriced ourselves so not too many
1:53:42 places which is the success of the program.
1:53:48 But we we we have taken advantage of it over the years and everything and I'm hoping we can get it done with glass
1:53:57 stone water treatment and upgrade uh blossom mobile street from Highway 50 back down is designed currently. It's in design.
1:54:07 Yes. Good.
1:54:09 We include sidewalks along there. I think I heard you say as well. Yes, absolutely. Okay. Yes, sir.
1:54:15 I do just have one bigger picture question for staff, Bryan, um Mr.
1:54:21 forman, city manager, city attorney. um with with regard to recent legislation that was passed at
1:54:30 the state level and some of our special events, what what are we looking at for
1:54:37 planning for next year and how any of that legislation may affect the the
1:54:44 dollars we're allocating for some of our special events specifically related to the to the DEI initiatives or as the governor puts of the anti-Dei.
1:54:54 Well, with that with regard to that legislation specifically, I'm not actually aware of anything that the city does or has planned that would run a
1:55:04 foul of that legislation. Okay, that's what I'm asking is that I think that there's public conversation relative to
1:55:11 whether or not municipalities can continue to promote or plan or or
1:55:18 allocate funds for events that fall into those categories that I want to make
1:55:24 sure that we are looking at so that we can justify and be able to bolster and
1:55:32 say we do want to invest in these because of the impact that they have on in our community and and the celebration that it brings. Uh I just want to make
1:55:40 sure that that's part of the conversation.
1:55:41 The way I interpret the legislation is that um it doesn't prohibit us from celebrating different parts of the
1:55:49 community or different people with different backgrounds. Um the way I interpret the legislation is it would prevent us from allocating funds or
1:55:59 sponsoring events that uh might have the effect of um
1:56:07 some kind of by way of inclusion excluding. So for example, by adding special weight to a different type of
1:56:14 person for a job or if that makes sense or or giving preference based on weights or just because we want
1:56:23 to include underrepresented groups for uh use in a park or something like that.
1:56:28 But to the best of my knowledge, I don't think we have anything like that. So special events are kind of from your understanding are are not in that same category.
1:56:37 Not not if it's uh undertaken as a matter of course. Okay. And if that makes sense.
1:56:43 Yeah. Absolutely. I I I support them. I just want to make sure. Yeah. Yeah.
1:56:47 Well, that's why I don't have concerns and I've talked to city management about that.
1:56:50 Great. Okay. Thank you. That was the only bigger question I had.
1:56:54 Well, I know I saw you sent I saw a message where you said Simpson and Saucer and Junth. Okay. I remember doing
1:57:03 discussion up in Tallahassee. Sips and salsa was one of them real areas that they they I thought they were targeting.
1:57:10 Okay. In the discussion up in Tallahassy. So when you send that email saying I saw where you said hey they
1:57:17 continue to s I have zero. I have zero. I mean, I I personally I think that that
1:57:26 misconrs the legislation. I sips and salsa. I mean, I listen, if if something like sips and salsa is subject to it, we're all in trouble.
1:57:34 Yeah. Well, and I guess that was the concern because when we was in Tallahassee doing the discussion, Simpson also specifically came up with
1:57:41 the discussion up in Tallahass and and and you know, I am aware of that, mayor, but I think that that was a part of the conversation about um maybe
1:57:51 the more extreme interpretations of it and and I think I'm not saying right. I mean, look, the courts will decide, but ultimately there hasn't been any case
1:57:59 like that or any challenge about that kind of event. I don't anticipate it because um I I just can't. It's my
1:58:07 opinion for better or for worse that it doesn't apply to I happy just in the saying it won't certainly not fine with me.
1:58:15 There's no way that's a great event but just I was just surprised when you sent it out saying it didn't I know we're in
1:58:24 Tallahass time we Tallahass one part of one of the areas that Pacific I'm not going to be a legal road like the You guys keep talking about pitchforks.
1:58:34 No, I won't do that. All right. Anything else? Anyone else?
1:58:40 I just wanted to Historic Village was under parks and wreck and uh I thought we also did a grant. Maybe it's through the CRA.
1:58:49 Historic village is I don't historic village has not been a budget that I've been involved.
1:58:57 Who does that?
1:58:59 public services room apo
1:59:12 I thought we also did a grant to this village is that not everybody remember is this conversation for
1:59:21 if we can I just I'm curious or if this is the only thing that we're Well, I guess that's probably CR.
1:59:30 I guess the question then it is in our parks and recck section of the budget.
1:59:35 So, if it's not Mr. Foreman, who oversees the budget? The 573.
1:59:43 Yeah.
1:59:44 All right. That's what I want to make sure.
1:59:46 Well, and maybe so one thing that took me a while to get used to and I'll just speak it to everybody is our parks and
1:59:53 recreation is actually split between the two Yes.
1:59:58 parks and recreation department and public services.
2:00:00 And so I think that's a bigger conversation we should probably have at some point about whether or not that's the best way to move forward.
2:00:07 Yeah. And so so that is do we want to do it during public services or another day? I think I don't know I don't know that it affects how we
2:00:15 budget this year, but I think it's probably a good conversation for us to have in preparation for next cycle to be able to say whether or not these funds
2:00:24 should be separated like that or it should be done differently. Yeah, I agree with you.
2:00:30 Another day, Mr. Mayor, might we take a brief break?
2:00:42 Well, uh, it would be 7:00. I was hoping I can go for 30 more minutes because it done 11:30 break for lunch. Okay.
2:00:49 Because I need to leave 11:30 or so. We went by 12. Hope to be back in about 1:15. Okay. Do you mind if I step out briefly?
2:00:57 I think I can hear it on the speaker.
2:00:59 Okay. See, can we I was going to ask that question. Can we get your presentation in the next 30 minutes or so?
2:01:07 We'll do our best. All right. Police. Police.
2:01:26 All right.
2:01:44 You're switching slides.
2:01:53 Good morning everyone. John Gracie, police chief also members of command staff help to assist in any answering questions you guys may have. our current
2:02:00 year in review. We we received our reacredititation in June for the eighth consecutive time. That was a unanimous
2:02:07 vote. We began crisis intervention training for the entire agency. What that is, that's a training program designed to help law enforcement engage
2:02:16 uh more effectively with people who are experiencing mental health issues.
2:02:20 Unfortunately, it's their first. So, that is a agencywide initiative that started this year. Thank you, council,
2:02:28 for the last budget year. gave us the new body camera program with Axon which included the train simulator and the translation capabilities. The
2:02:36 translation capabilities came online July 1st. So that is a welcome asset. We also started the ebike patrols on the
2:02:43 trail in downtown area. We heard a lot of requests for that. I promise as manpower got to the levels it should be at we'd be able to do that uh during the
2:02:52 summer. We have two two officers out there. We have officer Diaz and officer Harris patrolling the trail in downtown area. City managers expressed these
2:03:00 heard positive do positive comments about the fights. Uh we've added new community engagement events. I'm not going to go through all of them. I give
2:03:09 just a couple. Uh we have pop schools with cops coming up. We have the uh teens police academy coming up. And then we did hoops with cops this year where
2:03:18 we went out into the community instead of just having one centralized location.
2:03:23 next Thursday when we're at Felter Park and then we completed the strategic plan. So we began that implementation
2:03:31 and then the bottom one is an exciting one uh the acquisition of 48 meridian barriers. Those are the vehicle born attack barriers.
2:03:40 Those were given to us through a partnership with Flee and the Florida Department of Emergency Management. So that's a got six trailers full of those barriers. That's a $1.5 million acquisition that taxpayers have to pay.
2:03:52 the blueberry and the red bars. I saw correct those were the red barriers. The fourth of July celebration was the first time that they were deployed when we had
2:04:00 our events first Saturdays Christmas events. Next slide please.
2:04:08 Here's a break of the uh police department. I'm going to use my work.
2:04:16 We currently have four captains. They are both they are all giving their assignments. Captain Strickland oversees our patrol uh division which is the
2:04:25 largest division within the police department.
2:04:28 Captain Draper oversees sports services which has criminal investigations, street crimes, traffic and then our
2:04:35 criminal intelligence unit as well as evidence. Captain Corbett has our uh professional standards and legal
2:04:42 services. So we oversee all our IIA the accreditation processes our records division and then any grants that we
2:04:50 receive we have that will bring in a significant amount grants and funds so he's responsible for all of those reporting and then the administrative
2:04:58 services captain is captain s overseas community services school resource officer program the training division
2:05:05 and then recruit where are these on the this is a a very small breakdown. I can
2:05:14 give you this one if needed, which is the more
2:05:26 any questions about the proposed highlights.
2:05:36 We're seeking two additional police officers. These will be field personnel.
2:05:39 Uh most likely these will be K9 officers. I believe we can get the K9's through seizure funds for France and
2:05:47 then the reason for the K9 request is right now we have one K9 officer. So someone needs out vacation whatever the circumstance is. We have zero K9's
2:05:55 available and at the mercy of Brooklyn Lake County open which have expanded response times.
2:06:03 We can expand traffic stops longer than they're supposed to be. So 5 10 15 minutes at most. And then you're looking
2:06:10 at if we suspect there's narcotics in the vehicle, we're not able to do that.
2:06:14 Um when we look at criminal apprehensions delaying the time, these are personnel there unnecessarily. We
2:06:22 are able to use drones, but at some point I think we have put a video person in into a bush area or something like that. The K9 is the preferred method to try and get that person out.
2:06:33 the one community service officer, that person would be assigned to our criminal investigations division. We have seen a significant increase in the number of
2:06:40 frauds that uh we we see throughout the city. So, this person would be responsible to assist with some lower
2:06:47 level crimes that our C our current detectives are assigned. They would assist in writing subpos to the banks to get bank records. They would also be
2:06:56 able to assist in writing preservation letters for evidence such as off of social media platforms and different things like that. So they would be a
2:07:04 valuable asset in the CI division. I say C because our detectives, they receive certain benefits through the collective
2:07:12 bargaining agreement. This would be a cost savings for us instead of me having to put another detective inside of the division. This is a civilian position
2:07:20 within there that creates us some flexibility and they can the case still gone. I'm going to have Captain Corvette come up and talk about the records
2:07:28 specialist. I think you'll also hear uh Tracy talk about the significant increase public records
2:07:36 and then he'll describe what we've seen on the police department side. Uh I will say the the axon redaction is much better than what we have with utility.
2:07:44 However, we've only had that for six months. So, our personnel are getting trained up on that and working through the body cam request as quickly as
2:07:52 possible. and I'll have to go over to you.
2:07:56 Thank you. Good morning. The um city and the police department have seen massive increases in public records requests.
2:08:05 Looking at 2022 through year to date 2026, the police department's uh portion of
2:08:13 the overall public records request has increased from 30.7% to 61.5%
2:08:19 of all city public records requests going belong to the police department and the numbers themselves have jumped up substantially.
2:08:28 In 2022, the total city public records requests were 566. Year to date, this year they are 1,392.
2:08:38 The police department's uh portion of that going in 2022 from 174
2:08:45 to 856 this year to date alone. That is a uh
2:08:52 146% increase for the city, but a 392% increase for the police department. And the requests are becoming more and more
2:09:01 complex. Um, many of those are coming from presumed YouTubers who want body
2:09:07 cam video. That body cam video being subject to redactions and other kinds of things taking a a longer amount of time
2:09:16 as well, not simple requests for someone's report, which would be much easier and quicker.
2:09:23 the police department's public records request um if they remain on track this year
2:09:29 could hit 2720 for the city. 1,670 of those would be the police departments.
2:09:37 So at at these rates, police department handles 61.5% of all city public records requests. They're more complex than the
2:09:44 average requests. The police department receives 3.7 times as many requests as the next busiest agency.
2:09:52 and more requests than the next seven highest volume departments combined.
2:09:58 Um the police department has already processed 69 more requests than handled during all of 2025 despite being only halfway through the year. So at these
2:10:08 rates, our record staff is becoming overwhelmed. Uh and therefore each request is taking longer. Uh I believe
2:10:17 this has also put more strain on the city clerk's office. So we hope to alleviate that by asking for this additional uh one person.
2:10:28 Then finally you see the comm apologize.
2:10:31 Finally you see the communications coordinator said share with other departments.
2:10:35 We were going to put in for one and then it was brought up that we would share this position with parks and rec the fire department and then split the the
2:10:43 cost of the salary amongst the three departments. I think all three departments agreed to that.
2:10:49 It makes sense for us to move forward if approved.
2:10:56 Capital capital proposals. The biggest one right now you'll see it's the replacement vehicles.
2:11:06 In years past, you've seen requests of eight, nine, 10 vehicles. Eventually that eventually that catches up.
2:11:13 We're at the point where it's started to catch up. We have some stats that we can share when it comes to police vehicles.
2:11:19 I think that we have found some uh creative ways to fund the replacement of some of these vehicles so that it's not all coming out of the general fund. Uh
2:11:29 purchase of new vehicles if new personnel are approved that would come out of impact fees. A purchase of an armored vehicle. We potentially be able
2:11:36 to use impact fees. We're also seeking out a grant. Uh the Wasi grant is the one we're eyeballing right now. We haven't had much success with that grant in the past.
2:11:45 However, the current armor vehicle we have or some people call it the tank or the rescue vehicle uh that we have is 20 years old. The maintenance costs are
2:11:53 rising. The AC is not reliable for our personnel. So, I can probably limp it along for another year or two, but at
2:12:01 some point we're going to have to replace that vehicle.
2:12:05 And then the remodeling of NAR to create additional offices and storage closets.
2:12:09 But this is this is an expansion of our records division. We were able to get most of our files digitized. So now
2:12:17 we're able to take out all these rolling cabinets. So what that would look like is a storage place for our traffic unit.
2:12:25 Right now they have their stuff stored inside a room that's really allotted for two supervisors. That would create future space for our traffic unit to
2:12:33 expand. We house an IT person within the police department. This will give us a more suitable uh office space for the IT
2:12:42 person and then eventually the second office would be a a community service officer supervisor that is more in the future. So we're looking at how can we
2:12:51 more effectively utilize the space within the building at this point
2:13:02 since um you're there by the Do you think it's about time for us to
2:13:09 be maybe looking at u addition to the building here in the next what 3, four, five years or so?
2:13:17 With the growing amount of growth and everything we have.
2:13:21 I I don't think right now is the time to look at expanding HQ. I think we have some really good ideas down in station
2:13:28 five with the proposed annexation or future annexations. Maybe it's look at station 5's joint public
2:13:36 safety buildings. Maybe maybe we need a larger footprint down there. U we're looking at that. I think once we finish
2:13:45 the building off in the boat ramps over at Waterfront Park, that'll provide us a space on the west side of town and then
2:13:52 we look at what happens on the east side of town. I think the the way to move forward is to look for ways to where we can substance
2:14:00 in that area. I don't think expanding HQ right now is is the way to go.
2:14:07 That's just my opinion sitting here today. Let's see what Olympus does.
2:14:11 Let's see what other organization other projects that are being discussed right now brings to fruition and then we can definitely have more inepth conversation.
2:14:21 Well, substation I agree substation would probably be the best way to go where we have different substations throughout the city rather than but at
2:14:29 the same time we steady going u bring up a good point by well this way because I think we both been team with the fire
2:14:38 department down there and having some substation so you're saying you need a bigger footprint than what we anticipate I think right now with what Olympus is
2:14:46 proposing is sufficient I think for future conversations of proposed annexations or future annexations that
2:14:54 may be in the works it would be wise to ensure that we have the ability to possibly expand that building if necessary.
2:15:05 You said the uh boat ramp u I know we got in the budget to do the tier and everything. So you'll be able to use that looking at other house that'll be able to use that as substation.
2:15:15 Yes, we can jump right into the capital project. Yes, sir.
2:15:22 So, this is one of those projects that will probably carry over into the 2027 budget funded through impact fees by
2:15:30 both fire and community. It's looking at two boat docks, one for the fire uh boat, one for the police boat. And then
2:15:36 that old uh house or building from Bell Ceramics that's left there, we're looking at turning that into office
2:15:44 space that could be used as an command post, also storage space for FD should they have to a water rescue or something like that.
2:15:53 They'll be able to speak more to what their their vision for that is. But that's the program,
2:16:01 but also it can be also office basically evac.
2:16:16 Another thing I got is the 18 vehicles we're trying to replace this year. I mean, I know we we we sat down a couple
2:16:23 years ago and try to come up with a plan and how many vehicles we need to replace each year. U
2:16:33 we have that many vehicle now. We got to be going 18 again. I will give you this.
2:16:39 I will keep you brief. Uh a brief mileage overview is we have 21 vehicles that have exceeded the 100,000 mile mark. We have six vehicles over 90,000
2:16:48 miles. 17 vehicles have crossed the 80,000 mile mark. And then uh in total 44 vehicles are have surpassed the
2:16:56 80,000 mi mark, which means they're probably going to hit that 90,000 or above mark in the upcoming year. The 80,000 mark is generally recognized as a
2:17:05 point which maintenance costs and reliability concerns begin to increase.
2:17:09 We work with the barn to uh identify vehicles that need to be surplused. They give us uh recommendations on vehicles
2:17:17 that need to be surplus and then move forward from there. Replacing 18 vehicles a year is puts us on a path to
2:17:24 replace the entire fleet over the course of seven years.
2:17:28 I think that's the lack of maximum we put on the vehicle seven years. So is saying he's not you're doing it looking
2:17:35 at mileage and not like years. I think that's what we were plan we had, we would replace them every seven years.
2:17:42 We were looking at at mileage and then we started looking at years. I would say this, the vehicles vary. If it's assigned to a patrol squad, okay,
2:17:50 and they're out there driving every day, those vehicles are going to get worn out a little bit faster. If it's an administrative spotter, let's say a
2:17:57 detective, my car, it's not going to acrue those same miles that patrol vehicles. I think by identifying a
2:18:04 number of vehicles to replace that number could be lower some years based on when administrative
2:18:12 vehicles were purchased and when patrol vehicles were purchased but I don't think it would ever exceed that number of 18. I think we're going to hover
2:18:19 right around that 15 16 17 18 mark on So maybe we need to go back and look at the replacement at at mileage rather
2:18:26 than years whatever you feel comfortable with or whatever public service or maintenance sake they do
2:18:34 well it it sounds like for correct me if I'm wrong it sounds like for planning purposes patrol vehicles probably should
2:18:41 be planned on every five years whereas administrative vehicles should probably be on a sevenyear cycle.
2:18:48 And then you have the outliers that but we have I thought we adopted a policy on this did we not?
2:18:54 I'm I'm remembering what you said. Seven years we do a policy.
2:18:58 It's a it's about 90,000 is when we start looking at 100,000 they should be replaced. 90,000 we're looking at replacements 100,000 they should
2:19:07 I think I think we had adopted the prior we first started saying every seven years a replacement. I think we
2:19:15 calculated what we had at the We replace any seven to 10 vehicles a year.
2:19:21 I can go back and look. I do not remember a policy on the years. I do remember a policy
2:19:28 I think what we base everything on. But maybe what we need to go back and look at mileage what's the average mileage of patrol and
2:19:37 like you say it's it's kind of hard to estimate. So it can vary based on their own assignment based based on a number of
2:19:44 factors. five year on a patrol as Miss Crane say maybe five years on patrol and the rest of them seven years.
2:19:51 Well, it seems like it would be like when you get your oil changed, you know, 4,000 miles or every six months, right?
2:19:58 So, if we say whatever the mileage is or five years, whichever comes first. Um,
2:20:05 Mr. W, do you or who handles the preparation of police policy? Is it someone internal to you or internal?
2:20:13 Internal. So, and I think that including that with our budget process to make sure we update that policy.
2:20:20 Is that a resolution? How do we do that? Or no, we just about policy.
2:20:25 What kind of what exactly are you proposing?
2:20:28 Well, like we have an employee handbook that we approve. It's the whole book personnel policy.
2:20:32 So, I don't remember if we've approved police policies since we done it.
2:20:39 No, we you have actually in a way. Um you do approve the CPA
2:20:45 we approve and that does have a lot of policies but that would mostly pertain to the
2:20:53 union offic we had the policy discussion around the
2:21:00 cameras u there was policy discussion around we need to clearly have a policy around public records requests I mean do these
2:21:09 policies are they written and do they exist this.
2:21:13 So that's what I'm saying. I don't think I've seen mostly. Yes. I'll just make one qual and that's on the public records. I the way
2:21:22 I view it just from the city attorney's purge is um but first of all I don't think you've heard it's accurate. Um the
2:21:28 city is overwhelmed by them. But u I think we're still working out some of the procedures and how we respond to
2:21:35 some of them because it is a an interplay between the police department and the clerk's office and my office,
2:21:43 frankly. Uh some and sometimes it's subpoenas. It's not even just public records requests. We're getting subpoenas from all these personal injury
2:21:50 cases and things like that that we also have to be able to um so that is going to require some policy oversight from you at some point.
2:22:00 Well, and that's you know, we have a $22 million budget. I mean, so we're we're using $22 million of the public's money and I just want to be sure that that we
2:22:09 are being responsible with our duty to the public and approving $22 million of public
2:22:16 spend and making sure there's corresponding policies that protect our officers and the public.
2:22:27 I hear what hear what you're saying but we need that kind of f record that some of them I don't know how high in depth
2:22:34 they are and what it's costing the time it's costing what it's cost to do the research and everything else and I guess one of the thing we need the public to
2:22:42 understand is the fact that they shoot up the cost of things you know public yeah and I'm not understand the policy we need to have that policy there in
2:22:50 place how we handle this but wow it's I think that's if we going to address the public records requests independently. Are we okay?
2:23:02 Because I'm specifically referring to a policy.
2:23:09 How does our police department govern itself publicly our mission from a 5year plan incorporating that and just how do
2:23:17 the policies support the vision so that the budget supports the vision and the policies as well? I mean they go hand in
2:23:25 hand and I feel like that's one area that we've done the plan so it's good budget and so policies the third piece
2:23:32 of that stool from my perspective as council but I I always thought we already had all
2:23:41 that policy in place but this with this addition to all these public record requests we need to really read address that issue because there are policies
2:23:49 out there on how they handle everything and I know Mr. Okay.
2:23:57 One of the question I wrote down is subject matter. What's a lot of the subject matter for public record request? Now, of course, I think I heard
2:24:06 say something about that. on what's the average time to complete one of you know it varies based on the body
2:24:15 redacting body camera is the most tedious task that they do and it vary and I'll give you some basic
2:24:24 examples that maybe it'll give you a better understanding let's say it's a traffic stop and there's two officers traffic stop last 15 minutes is a simple
2:24:33 citation just a normal engagement there's very little the computer screens, driver's license
2:24:40 information, stuff like that will get redacted. The rest of it's going out.
2:24:45 Now, if you were in a more in depth call, we use the homicide where you have 20 plus officers with body camera
2:24:53 footage. You have interviews, you have all that. The request is for every body camera
2:24:59 video available. you were looking at hours of video that has to be reviewed and
2:25:07 then there's particular laws to all of it when it comes to the inside of a residence when it comes to
2:25:14 juveniles when it comes to all it's very intricate how it has to be done with the law and tracing we do the best
2:25:22 we can with make sure that we're following the law to the best of our abilities if there's exemptions that exist then the exemptions but it varies
2:25:32 based on what it is. So you can see if this a single camera it's very easy when you're talking multiple cameras it becomes a little bit more tedious
2:25:41 as it goes on. 20 minutes with two cameras turns into 40 minutes of having to look at the camera and make actions.
2:25:47 And just so you know I mean public records requests are one of the things that keep city attorneys up at night because it's one of the ways that
2:25:54 you know if we do do something wrong could expose us to attorneys. There's a private cause of action for that. That's why we really are trying not to take
2:26:02 chances with it both in terms of personnel and policy.
2:26:08 I know what is the cause of this is a massive increase this year compared to last. Is this like a cycle thing or is this are we constantly going up?
2:26:20 I mean YouTubers were around last year but there's more anybody. It's not like a litigation type
2:26:29 request like on a motor vehicle accident trying you know ascertainate a fault but this is just just just for knowledge
2:26:37 knowledge and views like uh everybody who wants to see what the police are doing it's like if you're going to catch news that's how you do it whether it's a
2:26:45 good video or a bad video however it paints law enforcement they're going to get views based on
2:26:52 people people want to see I know you like my home camera, you know, something happened. They look, first thing they do, come ask me. I go
2:27:01 back and look sometime. I spend hours just like this weekend. I've been going back reviewing some footage and some things happening. I spent about six
2:27:10 hours so far and still haven't gotten all the way through yet. You know, one of the policies they had before was it last year where they said they wanted to be able to access your ring cord.
2:27:22 Remember there was a well they have a we would allow that to happen. No we have
2:27:28 we cannot access your camera your ring camera right we can't but if we provide if you provide us the if you provide us
2:27:36 the information on how to contact you then we can email you and then you would edit that ring camera to the request that we had.
2:27:43 But if we provide it to you it becomes a public record right the video if I send my ring camera video to the
2:27:52 it becomes a public record discoverable by anybody.
2:27:57 No, not necessarily. I mean, there are still exemptions that would apply even on something like that.
2:28:03 So, like internal. I mean, I don't know what kind of where the camera's pointed and what it shows, but it may not necessarily be it it would be a public record, but it may not be distributable.
2:28:14 Most of your request is mostly for body cameras. All right.
2:28:18 Body cameras, case reports, the normal stuff. like you had mentioned some traffic reports people were involved in
2:28:24 those cases and a lot of our body camera requests are from out of state.
2:28:30 So part of the issue that I see is we have so much information now we have we have so much data
2:28:38 as a society because we have and I'm not knocking them but because we have public records
2:28:45 laws that make that data public we now have to have personnel, humans, to go
2:28:54 through the data in order to produce it when requested and then when you add to it the curiosity.
2:29:02 So I imagine the original intent of the public record law is to make sure that the public is protected from the police.
2:29:09 It's second amendment. These things exist for for a very good reason.
2:29:14 But then when it's used for entertainment is where Now, we're paying
2:29:22 for people to be entertained and that seems inconsistent with the purpose of the law. So, I'm not going to battle the law here today. We're not
2:29:30 legislators in Tallahassee. Um, but I am curious, Mr. Law Tracy, does your microphone can you have a microphone in
2:29:38 case how are jurisdictions around, let's just say the state of Florida, but I would open it up to the entire country. How
2:29:47 are jurisdictions handling these public records requests without simply adding a million dollars to their budget for personnel? Because
2:29:56 that's the trajectory that we're on when we start adding.
2:30:01 You have one person with the volume that you're talking about. They're doing 10 records requests a day. If each one takes six hours, that's 60 hours a day.
2:30:08 Well, it's a consequence of the law.
2:30:10 Look, I mean, we we are the tail being wagged by the dog. The law exists. It's a state law.
2:30:16 It really wasn't. I mean, and in terms of you, let me just say in the origin of the law, I'm not really sure that it really had to do with police, by the
2:30:24 way. I mean, I think that might have been part of it, but I think the law part of it was just corruption, local government, um, you know, deals and
2:30:31 things like that, documents. But I think um what one of the things that can be done and that has already been done here, you already have it is a
2:30:40 resolution with a policy for people making those requests to put a deposit down for the amount of time. We have to make a good faith estimate of the time
2:30:49 in terms of staff that it'll cost. And so you might have to put $200 down before we do anything or $2,000 or $20,000 given the scope of the request.
2:30:59 So that is one of the main safeguards that we get.
2:31:04 It's we don't just get 10 requests and then run off and start doing it necessarily.
2:31:08 I don't see the line item for public records requests on the revenue side to correspond to the number of people that we're dealing with which will be a
2:31:17 question if we're following that policy.
2:31:21 We are not trying to point the numbers the math's not mapping on that.
2:31:26 Um which means our polic may not be sufficient enough to support the needs
2:31:33 of the citizens. Now, I want to state if it's a citizen asking for information about the government, as far as I'm concerned, give it to them for free.
2:31:41 That's my position on the subject.
2:31:44 But when you start getting outside of the citizens of Clermont or someone who's not involved in a lawsuit, I mean, now to me, this is starting to become a business.
2:31:54 And if it's a business, then they should be paying the cost of running the business.
2:31:59 I really want to address that point because I I um I think all things being equal in a world that doesn't have costs, you can
2:32:07 do what you just said, give the information for free. The problem is if someone comes in with a request that takes two people spending two weeks to
2:32:15 gather all the information, you're take you're using taxpayer money from everybody else to subsidize one person's request for information. And that could
2:32:23 be worth tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands of dollars. How is that? I mean, how is that a good use of taxp money? It's you, me, and everyone else
2:32:31 paying for one person making 100 requests that totally consumes the time of the entire department. I'm I'm I'm It's not necessarily a straw person
2:32:40 either. This is actually what they're dealing with. There are, you know, tons of YouTube. It's not even just YouTube.
2:32:46 It's just the quest gown up. technology chat GPT has democratized this process for which I actually was a
2:32:54 good thing. I mean it does increase transparency but it also increases the work on the department. So that's why you have to have the people making the
2:33:02 request at least bear some of the cost because of that if that makes sense.
2:33:07 It's not for the good faith and I don't want to waste y'all's time but that's the economics main deter and the other thing is what
2:33:14 what creates a problem is to help them deter. But also, you have to be more specific because somebody requests so out there, you know, a waste of time trying to find something.
2:33:23 Well, but when you make a request, you don't know what is out there and you want to capture it all and not have it to be um you don't want to be a when you're making a request.
2:33:33 So, that's why the law requires if it is vague and unspecific, we need to ask for clarifications. And that's also something we do. The reason why I bring
2:33:41 this up and why I asked if we could treat it separately, which I appreciate um us doing, is
2:33:49 and maybe this will be addressed in the subscriptions update for later, is it seems to me if we keep doing the
2:33:56 things the way that we've been doing them, it's just going to become overly burdensome. This is not policing. What you're what we're talking about right now has nothing to do with why all these
2:34:05 gentlemen and ladies went into this police profession. I mean, this is not policing. this is administrative entirely. Bless you for doing it because
2:34:12 the paperwork you deal with, I don't I couldn't do it. Um, that being said, I think it behooves us
2:34:20 as a council and also a people to
2:34:27 uh embrace in many ways that this is where we're at and find a technology solution that helps minimize the number
2:34:36 of personnel because this is not going to get better. This process is not going to get better.
2:34:43 Now, you have the toughest challenge, I think, because we're dealing with public records associated with police in this context, but it's going to come up in
2:34:51 the clerk's office as well. We need to make sure that we're not curtailing the law, that we're complying with the law,
2:34:58 but I truly believe there is some way using technology, some way using systems, some way using structure and
2:35:06 how we do business to the public records easier to process and it's not going to be the way we've
2:35:13 always done it and I'm not going to come up with a solution.
2:35:17 We have been looking at software the past several months and there's some redact
2:35:25 as accurate as you want them to be. So we do continue to keep looking and it could change six months from now.
2:35:32 It might be at a later date see how we want to handle that because I'm quite sure the police
2:35:39 department have special stipulation on him and what can be given what is that and everything else so they work together they work together and come up
2:35:48 with some policies for us kind of adop Mr. Bang, you have any input?
2:35:53 Um, I do have a question about the uh impact fee fund. Um, I don't know if this is just for you, Chief, and it's
2:36:01 fire as well. Um, but when I'm looking at the impact fee numbers for the fiscal year for as being proposed, police and
2:36:10 fire are down 16 and 14% respective, but wreck is up 18%. So, I'm just curious if
2:36:17 our growth rate is basically the same as previous years.
2:36:22 Why do we have a significant decrease in police and fire rec or police and fire impact fees but not wreck impact fees?
2:36:34 Great question.
2:36:41 Mr. B is your question in regards to the revenue growth.
2:36:45 Yes. Unlike page page three is what I'm looking at specifically.
2:36:49 I tell you what, Mr. Scott, maybe it's good time to go ahead and take a break and you can go and check that out and and then we can give the answer that
2:36:57 when we come back after after lunch I think Deb had lunch back there. Uh I would suggest I think one of the reasons
2:37:04 that because basically we collected a lot of the recreation impact fees I mean fire impact fees uh couple years ago
2:37:12 over $3 million of fire impact fees. Um, but this my understanding is fiscal year
2:37:20 27 is what we're going to collect in fiscal year 27. Is that correct? So this is the fund itself growing.
2:37:28 Think of it like a savings account.
2:37:30 Well, so it's growing and being spent at the same time. So it's showing you the net.
2:37:34 But but your question actually isn't the net though because I'm reading this as the revenue for police impact fee 150.
2:37:45 The revenue in fiscal year 27 is $641. Not that not the net balance.
2:37:54 My initial response and I'll have to verify this during the break, but my initial response is there are different calculation methods um for police and
2:38:03 fire versus parks. parks is more of a flat structure whereas uh there's a lot of variables based on square footage for police and fire impact fee calculations.
2:38:15 But again, I'd like to verify that during break.
2:38:18 Okay, that's what Yeah. and and that looks consistent with previous years where where wreck was higher. But this
2:38:25 is my first opportunity at at this table asking that that question about, you know, why the number is so different for
2:38:33 police and fire as compared to um to rep.
2:38:37 And can you point us to where the fund balances are, Scott? I'm sorry. I know they're in there. Page number one.
2:38:44 I know that I saw page one, very first page. There we go. Yeah.
2:38:50 And I have other questions, but I'll save it for after lunch. That's fine.
2:38:56 We try to be back uh I'll try to be back by 1:00. We'll be back one shortly after one.
2:39:41 Heat. Heat.
2:40:04 Hey, hey, hey.
2:41:13 Heat. Heat.
2:42:30 Heat. Heat.
2:43:00 Heat. Heat.
2:44:40 a a
2:45:27 Heat. Heat.
2:46:43 Hey. Hey. Hey.
2:48:14 Heat. Heat.
2:48:35 Heat. Heat.
2:50:08 Dire.
2:50:58 Heat. Heat. Heat. Heat.
2:51:30 Heat. Heat.
2:52:06 Hey, hey, hey.
2:52:59 Hey. Hey. Hey.
2:53:37 Heat.
2:53:56 Heat.
2:54:30 Heat. Heat.
2:55:13 Heat. Hey. Hey. Hey.
2:57:22 Heat. Hey. Hey. Hey.
2:58:10 Heat. Heat.
2:59:07 Heat. Hey. Hey. Hey.
2:59:32 Heat. Heat.
2:59:56 Heat. Heat.
3:01:36 Hey. Hey. Hey.
3:02:04 Heat. Heat.
3:03:41 Hey. Hey. Hey.
3:04:11 Heat. Heat.
3:07:56 Heat. Heat.
3:09:27 Heat. Heat.
3:09:48 Heat. Heat.
3:10:36 Heat. Heat.
3:11:54 Yeah. Yeah. Heat. Heat.
3:12:36 Heat. Heat.
3:13:38 Heat. Heat. N.
3:14:18 Heat. Hey. Hey. Hey. Heat. Hey, Heat.
3:14:49 Heat. Heat.
3:16:08 Heat. Heat.
3:16:56 Heat. Heat.
3:18:12 Heat. Hey. Hey. Hey.
3:20:38 Hey. Hey. Hey. Hey, hey, hey.
3:21:09 Heat.
3:21:28 Heat. Hey. Hey. Hey.
3:22:48 Heat. Hey. Hey. Hey.
3:24:27 Hey.
3:24:37 Hey. Hey.
3:24:54 Heat. Heat.
3:26:25 Heat.
3:26:45 Hey. Hey.
3:27:03 Heat. Heat. Heat. Heat.
3:28:30 Heat. Heat.
3:28:50 Heat. Heat.
3:29:39 Heat. Heat.
3:31:14 Hey. Hey. Hey.
3:31:47 Heat. Heat.
3:33:01 Break.
3:33:25 Ah. Heat. Heat.
3:35:36 Heat. Heat.
3:37:37 Heat. Heat.
3:38:07 Heat. Heat.
3:39:45 Hey. Hey. Hey.
3:41:34 Yeah. Yeah.
3:41:51 Heat. Heat. Heat. Heat.
3:42:22 Heat. Heat.
3:43:59 break. Hey
3:44:29 Heat. Heat.
3:46:06 Heat. Heat. Heat. Heat.
3:47:33 a
3:47:53 a Heat. Hey, Heat.
3:48:23 Heat. Heat.
3:49:35 Hey, hey, hey.
3:51:08 Come here.
3:52:06 Heat. Hey. Hey. Hey.
3:52:40 Heat. Heat.
3:54:10 Hey. Hey. Hey.
3:56:07 Heat. Heat.
3:56:45 Heat. Heat. Heat. Heat.
3:57:15 Hey, hey, hey.
3:57:43 Heat. Hey, Heat.
3:58:10 Heat. Heat.
3:58:33 Heat. Heat.
3:58:57 Heat. Heat.
3:59:37 Come on.
4:00:34 Make me feel.
4:01:07 Okay. discussions from this morning. Uh first off, when we left off, a question was asked about the calculation on
4:01:15 impact fees. Had a discussion with the manager over in voting services and they confirmed that I was partially correct.
4:01:22 First off, commercial properties uh only applies to the calculation for PD and fire department. It does not apply to
4:01:30 fire. And then you say, wait a minute, P and fire but not parks.
4:01:36 Parks. Okay. Yes. For commercial properties on the residential side, it obviously does apply to all three units.
4:01:44 Um, however, the calculation is different. On the parks calculation, it's based on number of bedrooms.
4:01:52 On the fire and um police side, it's based off square footage of the facility. So, all those variables factor
4:02:00 into why you could see differences and projections and actual um collections between the three.
4:02:07 Second update for you is I had a quick conversation with attorney Wall. The question was posed by council member Bane about whether or not a resolution
4:02:16 to assign fund balance um would tie the hands of future councils. Of course, the answer to that is no. Um they would just
4:02:24 simply take a updated resolution by a future council, not necessarily to reverse um the previous action, but just rather to update the action.
4:02:36 And then third item um question or statement was made by council member Strange about a lack of any budget line
4:02:45 items on the revenue side for the collection of fees associated with record requests. Um we are tracking that
4:02:54 unfortunately through an administrative error. It's not showing in the proposed budget because it was an account created this year. We will rectify that and
4:03:02 include it in your updated documents following all the workshops. Um to give you an idea, uh based off year-to- date
4:03:09 collections, the budgeted number will be roughly $10,000.
4:03:13 So, we are tracking it. Sorry for the error. Um but it'll be an increase of $10,000 in anticipated general fund revenue for next year.
4:03:23 That concludes my updates. Okay. Thank you.
4:03:32 All right.
4:03:35 We back already done before anybody else.
4:03:43 We had a number of the public during the break bring up some suggestions on how to hold public records requests.
4:03:51 Uh I don't know if we are open to that.
4:03:54 We give the public a couple minutes to speak.
4:03:56 Is there going to be public comment here at the end?
4:04:02 If you all want public comments, you can have public comments.
4:04:06 I'm for the public. If they want to come and participate, if you want to a workshop and I always feel like
4:04:14 workshop is that's the whole idea behind workshop to hear from as many people as possible. Want to say three minutes?
4:04:22 Well, as always, three minutes. Okay.
4:04:28 Uh it's open. Okay.
4:04:32 30 minutes for public comment at this thing uh on on the PD. Yeah. Okay. Is this?
4:04:41 Okay. Okay. Uh Danny Paige Clermont. Um I actually wanted to just briefly touch on the items that they that the police
4:04:50 department have brought up. I'll just just lend some information for their suggestions. Um, in no particular order,
4:04:57 um, they're wanting a communications coordinator uh, position. I was under the impression that a PIO covered that.
4:05:04 I'm not understand why they need a separate one for that. Um, I'm thinking the PIO can handle that across the board
4:05:12 throughout all departments. Um, the CSO position, uh, I find that a strange title. I used to be a community service officer in another state for 10 years.
4:05:22 Um, and what they're wanting to utilize that title for doesn't uh really correlate with what a cso does. Um,
4:05:31 and I was just wondering if maybe we could turn that into like a volunteer program where a volunteer comes in and maybe takes that over and does that.
4:05:37 It's not a hard a difficult job to to have somebody do or even a part-time to make it
4:05:45 more cost effective. um the armored vehicle situation. Um do do they have
4:05:51 any um documentation or where they can show that we actually use that armored vehicle in a situation where we even
4:05:58 need to replace it? Um I've heard public kind of giggle at it to begin with. Why do we even have this they call the tank?
4:06:05 Um have we ever utilized it? And if we have, how many times? And I think that's something that you should be looking at um for cost being that they want to
4:06:12 replace it. I think it's it's it's ridiculous in mine's personal opinion.
4:06:17 Um, they're talking about remodeling department. I know he didn't say he wanted to add on per se. Uh, how many
4:06:24 captains do we have? He he mentioned there's several. How big are the offices? I've never been back in there.
4:06:30 As far as a captain's office, if an office is big enough, can we just put uh two captains in an office just to help
4:06:36 alleviate with with expanding even a little bit or or anything like that? I mean, the bigger precincts and bigger cities, there's a big room with
4:06:45 everybody shoved in there except for the cheap, right? Um, and then replacement vehicles. Um, I I I I didn't know I didn't hear anybody really ask, they're
4:06:53 specifically saying 18. Um, are those collectively uh marked units or and or and administrative units like and and if
4:07:02 they're both which one? Like nine admin one admin or and nine marked units?
4:07:09 Which one? Um because And I've always had an issue with take-h home vehicles for our administration because I I know for a fact because I've had uh people
4:07:17 reach out to me that some of these people are utilizing these take-h home vehicles and specifically admin for personal use which puts you uh wear and
4:07:24 tear on these vehicles and ultimately the taxpayers have to pay for. I'm not really understanding if they live in especially if they live within um if
4:07:32 they don't live within the Clermont jurisdiction why they would even be allowed to take our vehicles out of jurisdiction. That also puts more wear and tear. They do have their own vehicles. That's real questionable for
4:07:41 me as a taxpayer. And lastly, the uh the uh the records. Um I talked to Tracy uh
4:07:49 and I do understand that she's going to have that on her budget tomorrow in regard to software programs or redactions to these public records. Um
4:07:56 which is real helpful. I know Caitlyn um who does public records there in her office is is is really intelligent on
4:08:04 these things and has developed her own kind of situ like program that she's developing. Um but I I did so I guess
4:08:11 that's going to have to wait until tomorrow to really get into you know the logistics of that and discuss that. But just from my own um solution with that
4:08:20 well first of all I just wanted to state just to track this um it talk about the entertainment uh you know reasons for
4:08:28 these body warning camera footage. Um it's not really for entertainment. I know some of these auditors um that are that are really that have like a ton of
4:08:37 followers. I I do talk to them. I know them and I know why they do it. It's not really Is it ultimately going to be entertainment? Sure. But first and foremost, it's to show um the the
4:08:46 corruption that that is within police departments, not just obviously in Clermont, but across the United States generally. And so I just think um just
4:08:55 to look at it from a point of uh how do we fix things or actually how did we get here? Uh Corbett talked about how you
4:09:04 know like they've gone up substantially all these requests and it's for YouTube, but How did we get here? We got here because there's questionable things that
4:09:11 our law enforcement are doing. They're very questionable things and that's why people are requesting body warn camera footage. It's not just for fun. It's because there's an issue why they're
4:09:20 even requesting it. And so I had suggested as a solution, I just want to get that out of the way because if they were more honest and did their jobs properly, we would have less body camera
4:09:28 footage um request. Um but to wrap it up for a solution for that other than what she's going to be presenting tomorrow
4:09:34 with the clerk's office is um is to to is to um take a controversial issue like we had that murder, they're innately
4:09:43 going to know that people are going to want to request that body warn camera footage. So, if we can just nip that in the butt right off the right off the front end and go, "Okay, we know a ton of people are going to be wanting this.
4:09:53 Let's go ahead and just get that on the foyer system ahead of time and then have it open to the public to go to and they don't even have to bother the clerk's
4:10:01 office, the PD for that body warn camera footage because it's already been uh viewed, redacted, and up there for the public because they know it's coming,
4:10:09 right? They know that influx of people wanting to see that what happened with that homicide is coming. So I think that's another way that we could offset
4:10:16 the the you know just piling on with public records is and you know get that out there already on live and there are a few body warn camera footage I think
4:10:25 probably know about that body warn camera footage that's already on you just out there for that have been requested a ton of times so that's just out there for anybody and it's already
4:10:33 done and ready to go. So I think that would help alleviate some of it as well.
4:10:38 So that's that's all I have to say but tomorrow is going to be interesting because I know has has a really good uh idea of the software program.
4:10:48 Thank you. Anyone else? Anyone else?
4:10:58 What else?
4:11:09 Oh, they are going online. Okay. No, he says no. going online. So, so we all right y
4:11:18 did you want to did you want to address any of that?
4:11:27 What I can do is I can gather all the information that was presented for the questions that were asked and then I can come back and read that information or
4:11:35 edit it maybe tomorrow or a different time present all that information.
4:11:42 Well, let me if I mistaken on the replacement vehicle. I think she me replacement vehicle said 18. I think most of the things you mentioned gave
4:11:50 the number how many mileage some have this and that gave the number to come up with 18.
4:11:55 Right. Correct. It was all based on and for take home vehicles
4:12:03 if I'm not mistaken be limited or how far they can they both be able to stay they have to stay within 70 mile I think for
4:12:11 that's correct 40 miles 30 miles 40in 40
4:12:17 40 it's 40 okayriv I don't think that's
4:12:27 if it if they are using it for private use that would be outside of the policy. Yes, we would be able to excuse me.
4:12:34 Do you have a policy to audit that kind?
4:12:43 Many of the units have GPS on them.
4:12:50 There is there is no trail. And when they when they fuel up, doesn't they have to put in the mileage and all that, too? Say again. I'm sorry, sir.
4:12:57 When they refuel, they they required to put in mileage every time they fuel up. That's correct. Nobody's checking it.
4:13:06 And the other thing I think when we we started this uh take home vehicle, I think it was also officer responsible insurance.
4:13:15 There is no insurance writer for the insurance office insurance.
4:13:24 Correct.
4:13:25 Many of them like Geico and State Department that provide insurance on no additional cost some
4:13:40 if you can go ahead and look at all this. I think I saw somebody p as
4:13:47 CSO and armored vehicle. U I can say for a fact that I know it's been used a few times like at the murder you mentioned
4:13:54 it was used at the murder uh couple other uh incident they headed out. So
4:14:02 and when you do uh serve once like the two you served in my neighborhood a couple weeks ago uh I think you use it in as well.
4:14:11 Correct. It does get used for that. I would much rather just get the numbers, be able to say, "Hey, this is how many times we've got used it each year." Obviously, it's used in its name, you
4:14:19 know, certain hurricane responses like that.
4:14:23 Well, I know it hurricane when Milton came through and we flooded out down at
4:14:28 uh Thank you, sir. down at uh Emer get a lot of people out out of the flood as well, which came in hand.
4:14:42 All right. Thank you, sir.
4:14:44 And Chief Edison, I was going to add that we do use the the armored vehicles as a as a rapid response during during a time when the the apparatus and
4:14:53 ambulances are unable to respond. Uh we have currently have five in the county.
4:14:57 Uh one of those being armored vehicle and during Milton we had a period of about six hours in the fire trucks and
4:15:04 ambulances couldn't respond and that was a very busy unit in our area. a bunch of heart attacks and other patients and we're able to get them transported to the hospital so get treatment.
4:15:15 It's a transport vehicle.
4:15:17 Uh we use utilized as a we put Yep. We put a couple paramedics on there with one of our officers to drive it and you
4:15:24 know the patient was bad enough and they could get them stabilized they put them in the in the vehicle take to the hospital.
4:15:31 How do we do that without a COPC?
4:15:34 uh they made an exception based on the circumstances and that was done through county em in cooperation with the county. So if we have rapid response
4:15:42 vehicles, there are circumstances where we can use them without having to see a piece of they do have to be you know there has to be something you know there like storm
4:15:51 or something like that. Normally they have to be we have to have a license you know any other time.
4:16:02 Correct. Yeah. 35 miles an hour is the limit for normal emergency vehicles high profile and it's dangerous that they're
4:16:10 out there. These vehicles are last I saw the wind ratings was like 220 mph for impact and other keep out there.
4:16:31 Do we know what they can sustain the armor? That's the 220 for impact rating.
4:16:37 It's 220 m hour, right?
4:16:42 That that was the that was the spec from uh I believe when we looked at the MRA and the Bearcats, that was the manufacturer specification for impact rating. They're basically military vehicles.
4:16:54 And there's five in the county right now.
4:16:56 There is between us and the sheriff's office. So that's what we have available.
4:17:00 Are we softly. I believe so.
4:17:10 Thank you. In the hot seat now, sir.
4:17:31 to go. All right, you're in charge. We can get started, sir. Okay.
4:17:39 Good afternoon, council. Um, I just wanted to start off by saying thank you for having the opportunity to be part of this conversation. uh it's not something that's always been available to
4:17:47 directors and I think I speak for my fellow directors that it is appreciated to be able to come and talk about this as well as some of the things that we
4:17:54 have going on in the department have that opportunity for people. So just want to say thank you. Um so to start with I'm going to go over a little bit
4:18:03 of what we've done uh for the past year or so. Um last year we ran approximately 8,500 uh incidents and we're seeing that
4:18:13 number grow by about 7 to 8% a year. So we're on track this year to run 9,000 calls. But so kind of you know what
4:18:21 really put it in perspective was you know looking back at history department going back to our our 2000 census we had about 9,000 people in Clermont and that
4:18:30 was the time calls because they probably a couple calls a day and now you know we've gone from a couple hundred calls
4:18:38 total annually up to pretty quickly going to be tracking 10,000 calls. So we're we're we're definitely getting busier out there at
4:18:46 the field. Uh with that, we're also maintaining our ISO classification, the public protection classification of one,
4:18:55 which is the best in the industry. And the other thing we have to do on an ongoing basis uh is we have to maintain our accredited status. We get evaluated
4:19:03 uh in detail every five years. We do have to we we do have to submit a compliance report to show that we are working on all the things that uh that
4:19:12 we're supposed to be working. It's a it's an ongoing process. It's part of our business model. It's how we conduct business and we will be actually going
4:19:20 through a review cycle next year. So, we're gearing up for that. Um we've identified service gaps and we've
4:19:27 created the models on how we see we can fix some of those things. We shared that with council. some of the heat maps where we showed we had specific areas of our jurisdiction were having
4:19:36 deficiencies and response times we're one of those that we're working to address uh hopefully later this week is
4:19:43 the uh the station now on its way uh everything looks to be on track that we could have crews in there as soon as Friday. So, you know, just stay in touch
4:19:52 with uh with Paggra for Start. See where they're at on CO as soon as the CO's happen. We will have a truck down. Truck is in service. The crews are ready.
4:20:02 We're just waiting for that occupancy so that we can move in and start providing service. So, if council is not aware, uh
4:20:09 we had some challenges with the temporary site down there. It was supposed to be completed back March uh due to delays that are beyond our
4:20:18 control. the property has not been made available for our general contractors to start doing any silver design or anything else. We're still waiting on information from Olympus to get started.
4:20:28 So, we had some conversations with the Santi Apartments working with Tegra and we have struck a deal with them for us
4:20:35 to have six months of free rent and one of their carriage houses. So, when the crews go down there, we're going to be moving in two onebedroom apartments and that's what we're going to be operating.
4:20:45 So, it's a little bit of shifting, but it's uh it's taking care of the challenge that the apartments had and it's getting us a presence down in the area where we know that we need to have
4:20:54 the service of the appeal for the community. So, we're excited about that.
4:20:58 How many apartments? I'm sorry. How many apartments working out? Uh just two. Just two.
4:21:05 Yeah, they're they're one bedrooms. It's actually a carriage house. Uh it's kind of an ideal setup for us. We get the entire building. Uh downstairs there's
4:21:13 four single car garages. So that'll be good for like storing bunker gear for exercise equipment, other things. And then on the second floor, that's where
4:21:21 the that's where the apartments. The way that the guys has got it set up is that one side will be used for like cooking and dining and the other one will be for
4:21:28 like relaxation day area. And then the crews will be able to sleep in the bedrooms.
4:21:33 And do you have a price out for after six months?
4:21:36 I want to say it's like 3,600 a month for the whole thing. for the whole and we get used to the clubhouse. So,
4:21:44 you know, we finally get, you know, another facility there. There's probably going to be some drone that they want to stay.
4:21:51 We might be changing the industry. Who knows?
4:21:54 And operating out out of apartments, the engines and the apparatus going to be stored there as well, kept there as well.
4:22:00 Yeah, we we're going to be putting our platter truck down there. So, that's that's where we're going to be operating out of. Just looking at the number of taller buildings that are down in that area,
4:22:08 right? Uh we found we were getting better coverage. Uh also the station two that the crews there are that's becoming one of our busier stations and I'd
4:22:17 rather put the mileage on a million dollar engine than a $2.5 million ladder truck. So that's one decision. It's going to make good operational sense and
4:22:25 make good physical sense to put that truck down there.
4:22:31 So one of the other things that we worked on that we're all familiar with is the uh the EMS transport feasibility study that still in progress. We're
4:22:39 currently working on the CFCN application for to present to Lake County. You know, Scott talked a little
4:22:46 bit earlier about the uh the resolution for the budget. Um, one of the things we're recommending is the uh
4:22:53 the budget for the EMS transport that be included in that that resolution so that that money is earmarked and available if
4:23:01 we get or when we get into the transport. Uh, but it's not at the same time it's not taking up and their inner general kind of like we did last year.
4:23:12 So staffing and leadership uh we uh received a safer grant that allowed us to hire 15 additional firefighters that is ongoing right now. Uh we've to date
4:23:21 have completed two firefighter orientations. Uh we're gearing up to do a third one. Probably won't happen until January. Uh we currently have five open positions uh that we need to get filled.
4:23:32 So we'll be looking through that in January along with any any other changes that come about. We promoted our three
4:23:39 battalion chiefs and we placed battalion 103 in service. Uh that has been a game changer for us. I can tell you that when we have all the fire activity over the
4:23:48 Fourth of July weekend. Uh that was that was just immensely helpful. We had you know literally we had four fires happen
4:23:56 within about an hour and a half of each other. And uh it was we had one fire here in Clermont where there were no Clermont units on it because it was all
4:24:03 dedicated to the structure fires. It was you know later that evening we had we had a structure fire happen in
4:24:12 Clermont at the same time that the all the units from Clermont were dedicated to other fires that were going on at that point. So we had an in Clermont.
4:24:19 So we had Drone Bola and Lake County come into that fire and I believe it was Chief Hoey was right just down the road from the street. So he went down there
4:24:28 and took command of the scene. So he for a period of time there he was the only Clermont firefighter was on that person. That's that's how busy that
4:24:35 Saturday got serving Clermont fires or they were pulled outside Clermont for other fires.
4:24:43 It was like one little both.
4:24:46 We had fires in Clermont. We had fires just on the periphery of Clermont. I think most of our units in prison.
4:24:54 We did. Yes, we did have some in the prison.
4:24:57 Uh yeah correction the correction institute up by the winery
4:25:04 the correction in county up on 27 next to winery.
4:25:12 It was hit by lightning on Saturday as well. So you had that one, you had another one and then you had one here.
4:25:17 You had about three going at the same time on Saturday.
4:25:21 Did we get help from our surrounding department those? many old roads on the LA county.
4:25:28 It worked out. We had good coverage. It just it took more than during that time period to cover some of our some of our faults. That that's why we have these agreements in place.
4:25:41 And then you had another you had another fire Sunday night was uh we had one we have one later that evening where the crews actually saved
4:25:50 the woman that was trapped inside of the uh inside of the house. Um, that one became very quickly became a very complex fire, but from the the report
4:25:59 that I got on that fire, they they probably were down to seconds uh before that lady would not have been a viable thing. So, she was, from what I heard,
4:26:07 she was literally in the only spot in the room was not on fire.
4:26:12 The crews went in there were able to grab her, get her out. Um, she was taken to the hospital with smoke inhilation injuries, but aside from that, looked
4:26:19 like she may have recovered. So, that was of cases where we have true s well I I apologize and thank the chief
4:26:28 yesterday that bad mouth because I think at the end ceremony I may mention that we hadn't had a house fire structure
4:26:35 fire in so long due to y'all work out advance and doing things in the community and not here with all the so
4:26:44 well what happens in a lot of cases uh we are able to respond so quickly that we literally will get it get the fire out and under control Uh you know you
4:26:53 really before the rest of the units get on scene. You know case in point one of the fires that we did have on Saturday was somebody was discarding fireworks
4:27:00 into a trash can inside the garage trash can on fire. Our crew were able to get there but can out so it was confined to the can didn't spread to the garage or
4:27:08 any other part of the house. That's we see that a lot with our responses.
4:27:16 So, and uh we we completed a promotional processes uh for getting the fire station 5 open. What actually right now
4:27:25 we're going through another promotional process. Uh what happened? We we exhausted our lieutenant our engineers list. So, we're having to re repost
4:27:33 those so that we can fill the remaining positions. We promoted battalions up that created some vacancies with lieutenants and
4:27:42 we're still trying to get the folks needed to do it. So it's kind of created some challenges with us. We've been working through human resources. We had
4:27:49 to overhire on firefighters. We had to have firefighters fill everything promotions took place. So few challenges there we're working out as far as how we
4:27:58 make that work with an HR system, but they've been a good partner with us moving forward and just making sure that we have all these people there that you
4:28:06 know we're able to hire. It's a it's a little non-traditional. Uh typically uh if we have like a lieutenant position become vacant that we have to fill that
4:28:14 position before we can go and hire the replacement. Um in this case because of the number of positions we've looking at shared with the city manager's office
4:28:21 that was going to create roughly about a half million dollars in additional overtime expense. So that's why we started doing this non-conventional
4:28:29 method of fire and bringing additional personnel on. We have more firefighters than we're supposed to have right now.
4:28:35 Once the motions take place all the numbers back.
4:28:41 Thank you for your so on our facilities apparatus and infrastructure uh we we are placing
4:28:50 station five into service and we are uh we are just about wrapped up with the temporary fire station. I believe the
4:28:58 date that we have set for that is July 27th to have that available for crews to move in. Uh We're down to getting the
4:29:06 water line hooked up to the building and we need to get the sprinkler system installed. We have to have it in there.
4:29:11 So, as soon as those things are done, we'll be ready to move in. Uh we do have a contingency plan at the ark if it's for some reason doesn't meet that
4:29:18 deadline and that that will allow us to stay on track with demolition on station two. So, we get that project.
4:29:27 We took delivery of a new pumper and a new aerial apparatus. The pumper went online engine two last week and the
4:29:35 aerial is still in the process of being outfitted. Uh we're looking at about three or four weeks before we'll have that road ready and that will be going
4:29:42 down to station five as a permanent aerial down and we transition to 5 in supply. That's
4:29:50 in progress now. The new trucks that are coming in are coming in with 5 in and the rest of them we are we are swapping them out. So to kind of let you know
4:29:58 what this what the background on that is, we we traditionally have carried 4 in fly hose. You can get 1,000 gallons
4:30:06 using the 4 in and a and a 3 in supplement line for about 600 ft by going to 5 in. Uh we're going to
4:30:13 increase that distance to 2,000 ft. And in shorter distances, we'll be able to fully use the hydro system that we have.
4:30:20 Uh we've got a lot of hydrants that will easily provide 2,000 gallons a minute more. And it'll it'll allow us when we finally do have a large commercial fire
4:30:29 or something equivalent to that, we'll have we will be able to tap into the large system that we have and be able to do a lot more than what we can with with
4:30:38 the for that car today. And it's also standardized everywhere else in Lake County. All the other departments are caring 5. So that's going to make us a
4:30:45 little more interoperable with our response partners.
4:30:52 Okay. Okay, we advanced the fire station 2 renovation, planning and design.
4:30:56 That's ongoing. Like I shared, we did the 27th of the month, but we should be uh on track with that as far as demolition. And they're estimating about
4:31:04 10 months to uh get that building completion to move back into.
4:31:09 And we constructed a new training structure uh that's currently being constructed. It's a Trop over at the training center. And we got a few others
4:31:17 we're looking at in the future, but this will be the first one actually go and start doing some some training again props. We also completed the classroom
4:31:26 upstairs, the locker rooms for personnel change in. And we added the uh we turned the old base where they used to work on
4:31:34 the trucks into a fitness area for the firefighters.
4:31:39 And we are beginning construction on the uh utility building out there. It's professionally referred to as the tank building where they used to have
4:31:47 chlorine storage and a few other things there. So that's going to be like an instructor's prep area when they get done. We had it evaluated. We found out
4:31:56 there was no in the building. So that dramatically reduced the cost of us being able to do it and we got a contract currently starting work on that.
4:32:05 So over the last year we were awarded both an AFG and safer grant. The AOG grant is that's going to be one of our
4:32:13 safety initiatives. That's where we're going to be putting the direct source capture systems on the trucks to take out a lot of the carcinogenic materials
4:32:21 out of the exhaust that not exposing our firefighters to it either at the stations or on scenes. And we discussed
4:32:28 the safer grant earlier and we do have applications in now for a AFG and safer for next year. And those applications
4:32:37 awarded to us will go towards the firefighters, the equipment being for station six.
4:32:43 And this past year we implemented a new record management system. Uh timing on that really worked out. Uh this year
4:32:50 they went from the different system over to the DAR system which is the federal system on what we how we have to report
4:32:57 on fires and our older software that we were under was behind the ball as far as getting the system ready to make that
4:33:05 change over there. And the system we changed to was once pack as far as being ready and and it just made that
4:33:13 transition over a lot more seamless and we're seeing a lot of other things that are that are helping with that. We're getting ready to roll out artificial
4:33:20 intelligence for report writing. So, those are some other features that they're going to help. We've got some guidelines there to make sure that we're not replacing our people writing the
4:33:29 reports. We're giving them assistance with getting them written correctly.
4:33:33 been a been a huge help with with having a new system and we acquired a second uh SCBA cascade
4:33:41 system. It's that's where we fill the air bottles, the firefighters variability and the fires. I'm a big proponent of when you're talking about
4:33:49 things that are critical for that type of work. One is, you know, one two is one and one is none. And this this will be helpful with us having it over at the
4:33:58 training facility. It'll it'll make it easier when we're doing drills where we're utilizing air packs and it'll also give us a backup and put one of those systems down.
4:34:07 And we also are working to expand our firefighter cancer reduction initiatives. Uh we have started a new uh personal protection equipment clean
4:34:16 system. It's using it's utilizing liquid CO2 to clean market gear. Uh it's some it's it's a technology that I saw a few
4:34:24 years ago. And one of the gaps that we noticed is that uh there's a requirement out there that our gear has to be inspected and serviced at least once a
4:34:33 year. And part of this cleaning that that that inspection and service takes place any repairs need to be remade.
4:34:40 They're done at the same time. Uh but one thing that uh was really interesting with this cleaning technology is that it will remove things that the standard cleaning mechanism will not do.
4:34:52 There's a there's one of the cases that the vendor shared with me where they had a set of gear they had been on some kind of fire gear got exposed to some type of
4:34:59 chemical. It stained the uh the gear a dark almost a grayish black color and washed twice with the with the
4:35:07 traditional extractors and they still had the staining on the gear. They put it through the CO2 cleaning and it looked almost like a new set that came out and it pulled out. It looked like
4:35:16 black sludge that they took out of the machine. It was at least a quart of that came out one set a year with that clean
4:35:23 system. So, one of the things that's uh been really interesting about it is that technology and not only does it remove all the contaminants, but any of the
4:35:31 free POS materials that are in the gear, it'll pull that out of the gear. So, it's it's something that's, you know, you know, we're looking at it as something that's really going to help
4:35:39 keep our fires protected. So, we're doing that once a year for set of gear and we're just utilizing the normal extraction for the other times or if we
4:35:47 have a set that we're get a couple ago, we had a we had an incident where it got exposed to diesel fuel. We had to throw
4:35:55 the gear away. So, we have something like that, we sent there to see if they can't get it back to a serviceable state.
4:36:02 And uh we're in the process of replacing uh aging staff and support vehicles. We've just got rid of our Impala, right?
4:36:11 That's in process. And we've got a number of other vehicles that have just been too costly to keep around. High high mileage vehicles some have access
4:36:19 to 50,000 miles longer, you know, 12 to 14 years old. So that's that's one of the other things we'll see in the upcoming budget.
4:36:29 Chief, we didn't we didn't never set you up on a replacement schedule on your vehicles, but we did it as well.
4:36:35 We have it for the uh for the fire apparatus. We have not fully built that out for our staff vehicles. That's something that we're in process on
4:36:42 doing. Uh we're we're going around surveying the fleet that we've got. um you know just some of the changes that we've had kind of you know threw some
4:36:51 new uh you know wrinkles into things like you know adding second battalion um we had a we had a vehicle that was the backup for battalion vehicle but now
4:36:59 that we had the second battalion now we need another backup for battalion so little things like that we have to just but yes so we are we are working on that
4:37:08 that's one of the things that we want to do is if anything uh you know you know not just vehicles but we want to look at generators and other things we want to map those out make sure We're assessing
4:37:17 those on an annual basis to determine the conditions so that we can map out when we might think that we need to replace those things.
4:37:26 So this is our current organizational chart. Um we are currently up to 116 full-time equivalents. uh 96 of those
4:37:35 are personnel in the field and the other 20 that's made up of administration, prevention, training, EMS, you know, all
4:37:43 the professions that keep the folks in the field doing all the framework that they do out there. So, in the proposed budget, we we are asking for one
4:37:50 administrative position. That's a administrative assistant. This is in response to some conversations that we've had with human resources and some
4:37:58 of our other departments and we're looking to have better coordination the increase coming through administration.
4:38:10 So some highlights uh we have uh the three and a half million for fire station 2 renovations uh including the housing of the station technology
4:38:18 infrastructure fire fire safety improvements uh that's in our current budget. U another thing we're looking to do is to complete the design and
4:38:26 engineering for fire station 5. That's the one that will be on Scopia Road, the permanent facility. Uh we're looking at a three three bay station design uh to
4:38:36 support up to 10 people, multiple apparatus, and we're also looking to include a substation for PD so they have
4:38:43 space and as well as having a community meeting space that could also be utilized for firefighter training.
4:38:49 So, station six, uh that's the property up on Old Highway 50. Uh we are looking at a uh design that's going to include a uh I call it a temporary building, but
4:38:58 it's a little more robust than a temporary building. and uh looking at the technology uh station setup requirements and everything that we're going to need and that's going to allow
4:39:07 us to do that today to a fairly attractive price point. All in we're looking at a little less than a million dollars to get the get that station up
4:39:14 and operate and then uh we're going to be continuing with development on our public safety training facility. Uh we're looking at
4:39:21 adding additional props, uh logistics, storage facilities, uh additional site improvements, infrastructure upgrades, and uh different equipment for training.
4:39:30 And we're also having more conversations with the police department to ensure that we've got coordination. A lot of
4:39:38 the stuff that we use for training, it can be used for the PD to present as well. So we're one of the things we're looking to do is master plan the site so
4:39:46 we kind of get an overall vision of what we want to see out there.
4:39:50 to develop the facility that station or the training facility train facility is there any I'm sorry southern police
4:39:59 and I don't need to speak for the chief um in some conversations I had with the chief and deputy chief there was a
4:40:07 request for or or a desire that if we had some sort of substation some sort of place for the police on the west side of
4:40:14 town that might be helpful have these conversations come would you relative to that facility at
4:40:22 all? Is there any opportunity to support?
4:40:25 There's definitely opportunity. I don't know that we've had that specific conversation, but there we've got plenty of room. There's no reason
4:40:31 not sorry, but I think that came up somewhere. I don't know what you need.
4:40:37 Yeah, we talking about just a chance. I don't know.
4:40:44 Still are we still looking at a training facility out there for them? focus as well. Absolutely.
4:40:50 Yep. Yeah, we had a meeting with him last week where we kind of went through all the possibilities of what could be out there and you know a substation is something that you know I mean that's that's a very easy.
4:41:01 Well I know earlier we talked about the waterfront the building down there trying to make a little station out of it as well when we was talking when the
4:41:09 chief was up here before when he did the boat ramp for the fire and police.
4:41:12 There's another building that we talk about maybe using that as a office space as well down on waterfront at waterfront.
4:41:21 Well, and there had been a there's a local charter school uh that has expressed an interest. They
4:41:28 have a city that they work with down south where they built a 6 through 12 school, but for students who envision
4:41:37 they might be interested in being police officers or firefighters. So students come in, they're either on the blue track or the red track. And the property
4:41:46 they showed me struck me because it looked just like our West Park.
4:41:52 It looked almost it was almost like they took the property that we have there for the training and they were showing it to me and
4:42:00 so I thought that could be something that we might be interested in, you know, allowing in the future um to help
4:42:07 support also the recruitment of our police officers. We got cadets right cadets and everything. I don't know about Yeah, we we have a junior cadet program.
4:42:18 It would correspond stuff like that. It would work with them. I don't know if anything's come from that, but I shared the information with staff.
4:42:28 It seems fun.
4:42:31 That's a great idea though. We're keeping all options open. You know, we we've even had conversations with Lake Tech to see if we could somehow be like an extension of what they're doing down
4:42:39 here in South Lake County, talked with director Thomas that you th out a concept that I know that they're doing
4:42:46 in a high school EMT program and we were having discussion if we got where we were able to do minimum standards at that facility, we
4:42:54 potentially could take some of those students and run them through a Clermont Fire Academy where they would get certified as firefighters.
4:43:01 So those are all ideas that we're talking about. So it's going to take some time to develop the new facility over there, but you know what whatever
4:43:09 direction we go. We we're keeping everything open and we're looking to do whatever is going to be in the best interest of the city or community.
4:43:16 I like the idea that young people in Clermont might say, "Hey, I want to be a firefighter. I might want to be a police officer." And as we continue to
4:43:23 improve the benefits and the environment for our police officers and firefighters, why not keep those babies close to their mama?
4:43:32 We're already doing a little bit of that. We've had probably we've had two two junior cadets already that you know we're actually we're
4:43:41 sponsoring putting them through the the scholarship we have with Kuanas and the Tony Foundation.
4:43:49 Tony, I think you asked what he does. His foundation does sponsor firefighter.
4:43:54 He does EMTs and the Kuanas does the firefighters. And what we did is I got both groups together and we had conversations that why don't we just
4:44:02 split it. Um and so that you know when we do that I just send emails out and you know they they say okay sponsor that
4:44:09 candidate and then they send money directly to the schools. So the recipients get to go and you know they
4:44:17 have it% on the side right now it's working but anything
4:44:25 comes up So on our 2027 budget um the for the EMS
4:44:33 transport we have compartmentalized that off the side and like I said earlier the request is is that the funds for that get dedicated through resolution and not
4:44:42 included in the general fund budget. Uh but for that program to get the first two ambulances operational, we would be looking at 15 firefighters and EMS
4:44:51 trained lieutenant to help make that that division fully function. That is what is included in there in terms of personnel with transport budget.
4:45:00 Um the next item says we have two FTE requests. Uh we have we have reduced that down to just the administrative assistant. There's some change to coming
4:45:09 with a uh with marketing coordinator. I just had a meeting with the police chief and the parks director yesterday and it looks like that's something that can
4:45:17 kind of fill that gap. Right now we're kind of in a weird space where you know our person is doing all our fire safety
4:45:24 and education is overwhelmed. Um but whether it's to the point that we need another person to help kind of the
4:45:31 question. So we've decided to pause on the request for another fire life safety educator and we'll see how this
4:45:38 marketing position works out. looks like about 25% of their time can fire departments. I think that'll that'll satisfy the immediate need and we can
4:45:47 just see where we're at go forward with that program.
4:45:52 As we talked about earlier, we're looking to replace aging vehicles and units. The bigger boat that request we
4:45:59 had in there, uh we are pushing that out a year and working with the city manager. Uh there's still a little life left in the boat to be even though it's
4:46:08 really not best vote for us. You know, we can it's not a it's not a critical need to have that place this year.
4:46:18 We we've had a couple water events this year more than I think usual.
4:46:24 What was your experience of our equipment? And I remember in when the rowing events happened, there were a couple incidents
4:46:32 where boats were crossing the rowing line.
4:46:35 Was your team involved? Maybe I should have thought to ask that. We generally anytime there's a there's a big event out there like they're having road championships or any of that kind of
4:46:44 thing, we'll have our fire boat out there uh for ones that kind of happen spontaneously like if there's just people down at the you know the boating
4:46:51 accident or you know drowning incident at the at the beach or something like that. The other program that we have in place to assist with that is our surface
4:46:59 water rescue program. And that's where we have about 80% of our firefighters in the field are certified as as basically
4:47:06 as technical or rescuers for doing, you know, water rescue. So that's not just, you know, swimming after the victim.
4:47:13 They're trained to do grid searches. Uh we have these small handheld devices that are they're basically a handheld sonar where they can they can look like
4:47:21 out to 100 ft underwater which is immensely helpful in the uh with the tannon that we have in our links and uh
4:47:29 we've seen the the success of that program almost immediately uh we we had one where unfortunately we weren't able
4:47:36 to save the life of the individual. We did get a heartbeat back. There was no brain activity. So there was there was an opportunity for closure with the
4:47:43 family. He had a brother that was serving in the military over in Germany.
4:47:46 He was able to fly back when his brother was still medically alive and then there was a continuation of life and the family did a you know donation after
4:47:56 they stopped ventil. So but we've also seen a lot of instances where that program has resulted in saving victims.
4:48:03 So we we have found that that's probably the the best way we get our we get our truck there. We've already got rescuers on board. They can immediately go in and
4:48:11 go to work. They've got trained to be able to go subsurface to go down the bottom to find a victim to go out to the searches. We got the equipment to help look and have found that to be a highly effective way of doing doing.
4:48:24 Do you have the equipment that you need or you said the boat's not perfect?
4:48:29 The boat we're looking to get something that's a little more tuned to what we we need to do and you know talking to the city manager. I mean that's something we
4:48:37 can you know we can we can wait a year on that.
4:48:40 the one we have I mean it it will it will serve the basic purpose u you know some of the challenges we have is that when the water levels do rise we cannot
4:48:48 get bridge so we're kind of stuck in you know lake Mola we can't go you know we can't go to the other lakes without watching it from another boat ramp and
4:48:56 other locations there's a number of other things where that just you know wasn't the wasn't the best boat for us to buy it's a it's a good watercraft
4:49:04 it's just it's not best suited Is there a chance to resell it? And there is what we need.
4:49:14 I chief, you want to speak on that? I know you got more.
4:49:18 I mean, I appreciate pushing it off. I appreciate the impact budget.
4:49:23 But if there's a way to get a better suited apparatus, we have a perfectly good one. Might have swapped possible.
4:49:31 Yeah, that was about a $300,000 purchase. So, that's that, you know, that was one of the reasons we're looking at
4:49:37 So we So we did get a quote for them to take off
4:49:48 in the realm of 250 to 300
4:49:57 just I don't know if you ever seen like old war boats where it's like the landing
4:50:04 craft Dday and the whole front comes So that's what this boat basically is.
4:50:08 So it can go down in the water and you can just bring people in. Our current boat has a tuna doors on the side. So you really have to manipulate people around. So if they have like spinal
4:50:16 injury or something, we have to be careful. It's just not easy. And the boat that we're also purchasing for
4:50:24 purchasing. Uh we'll also have Are we seeing any sort of I know we
4:50:32 recently implemented the different fees for the boat.
4:50:35 Are we How are we seeing on the revenue side of that? And might some portion of our boat ramp towards the purchase of a vehicle?
4:50:49 Well, you're not making that much, but I don't know. We Well, Scott, I don't I think one time before we asked that question. I don't think the fees could
4:50:56 be used or can we use the fees for go towards purchase of the boat?
4:51:03 That's who needs it. Off the top of my head, mayor, I do not know. I have to look at the ordinance. Okay.
4:51:08 Um the revenues are strong. U trying to find the number now, but my recollection is in a range of 80 $80,000 per year.
4:51:18 So that was before we raised some of our area users, right?
4:51:22 We have the new revenues, the new fees this year. Yeah, we do. Yeah.
4:51:30 It just effects ago. Yeah.
4:51:42 So about 110,000. I don't know. There might be something.
4:51:52 Well, well, I know that's what we used to collect, but with the new fees, I'm not sure where we are because we just implemented them. And I know some people come to me,
4:52:00 they say they don't use this boat rack anymore. going after because it's free.
4:52:07 I'll be glad to look at the ordinance, see if it outlines use of fees. But along these same lines, we do um bill
4:52:15 quarterly Lake County for some reimbursements related to police and fire department voting activity. So, we do get some reimbursements from them.
4:52:25 Could certainly mark those funds for Yes.
4:52:30 often called I Lakey.
4:52:52 So you know that big the boat we have now trailer.
4:52:58 So a lot of inflatable.
4:53:07 Yes.
4:53:20 So, one of our other big initiatives that we got is uh focusing on our firefighters health and safety cancer prevention initiatives. So, we talked
4:53:28 about a few of those already. the diesel exhaust capture systems that we're looking to put on the trucks. Uh that'll largely be offset by our FEMA funding.
4:53:36 We're just having to go through a few steps to make sure we got the approval to buy the equipment we're buy and it's been a little challenging with some of the shutdowns trying to get coordination
4:53:45 with our FEMA which during normal times this can be challenging. Uh some of the other things we're looking at is the like decontamination that we talked
4:53:53 about. We've got some additional equipment we're looking to get at the stations, ultrasonic cleaners, those types of things. Uh looking at different
4:54:01 respiratory protection systems for I know we're looking at a different type for our prevention staff. You know, understanding when they go out for a
4:54:09 fire investigation there, we still have to be concerned about ball casting, you know, within a structure. So rather than
4:54:17 giving them the air packs which are are very costly, we're looking at something that's a little bit easier for them to wear but also gives them the protection
4:54:24 they need for much more attractive price. And then uh we're looking at the replacing some of our thermal imagers.
4:54:31 Some of those are getting end of life and need to be replaced. And then we'll talk about the bubble gear cleaning and inspection programs.
4:54:39 Um we're also another program is uh maintaining our operational readiness uh through staffing improvement orientation
4:54:48 and uh we're also incorporating that into our standard cover plan. That's something that next year we're looking to bring in a team to do a train the
4:54:57 trainer with our staff to effectively train them on how to write a good standard to cover and then now you know once that's done and the folks we have train the next generation that comes up.
4:55:08 So it's kind of I think it'll get us going with that. And then modernizing our technology and our workforce development
4:55:16 initiative. So, so, you know, some of the stuff that that we're looking at like the recruiting, I mean, that's something we're worth finding. We're have we're having to get very creative.
4:55:25 Uh, one of the things that we did recently, uh, we actually went out to an academy and I had the division chief of training go out there and gave him the
4:55:34 authority to make job offers on the spot. And we literally hired five people that were in fire school. And it's kind of interesting because everybody else
4:55:42 kind of caught on the same thing. By the time that class graduated, every single person in that class had it was already on payroll somewhere in Clar Lake County.
4:55:52 So, you know, it's there there's more jobs out there right now than there are candidates. So, we're having to get creative. That kind of goes back the
4:56:00 other thing we're talking about, you know, looking into the high schools, you know, trying to find people, especially I love developing local talent. You
4:56:08 know, there's a much higher likelihood that they're going to stay here for careers. You know, we don't see a lot of turnover. Our department is, but we want
4:56:15 to maintain that fold. So, like I like hiring local we can. But yeah, we're having to get creative. We're
4:56:23 continually revamping, you know, what we're doing and, you know, trying to find new ways to go out there, you know, attract group people, you know, into the department.
4:56:34 Yeah. kind of looking over the upcoming fiscal years uh for 2027. Uh one of the big projects we have is the fire station
4:56:41 2 renovation expansion. Uh another big one we've got in the 27 budget is the fire station 6 build. Then we have the
4:56:50 fire station 3 design services. So we don't actually want to do any work. We just want to go out and do the planning to figure out what do we need to do
4:56:58 there. uh when we started looking at the number of projects we had going one we know it's going to be costly and the other thing just with the volume of
4:57:05 keeping up with all these projects we felt that was better back in the 28 budget to take a look at so this will allow us to go and take a look at the
4:57:13 facility we know you know one of the the big issues we have there is we still have all the work up here on the bay floor and we do want to get that into a
4:57:21 clean space so we'll figure out what that solution looks like get a number that we put to it and we'll bring that back next
4:57:28 And then one thing that has already been talked about a little bit in 27 is we do have the uh the fire department and
4:57:35 police department renovation. Right now we have that as a 50-50 split. Uh we really don't have need of building PD's
4:57:42 looking at but there's also been some conversation that maybe parks comes into that conversation since they've got the
4:57:50 folks the rangers that go along the trail there. That might be a that might be a location for them as well. So, but we would like to see this go forward. I
4:57:57 can tell you that since they came here in 2019, be talking about boat houses, boat docks, and everything else. I, you
4:58:05 know, I would just like to see us make a decision and make a commitment to either go forward with it or say no, we're not doing the project. It's been, you know,
4:58:14 it's been on our radar for a long time and it's it's one of those things is out there. So, is that the best location?
4:58:21 I I think it's a great location. you know, it's right there at the ramp. You know, if we actually have to launch for a rescue, that is that that would be that that would be a best option for us.
4:58:33 We literally could take the truck, we could park it right there where the building is at. We could just pick the crews, they go out, they hop on the boat, they drop, and they're out to that. That would be the quickest way to
4:58:42 launch that boat for a rescue if we have something going on in the middle.
4:58:46 Wouldn't something on the west side of the lake be closer section? Well, he you have to think that if it's an emergency, they're likely
4:58:54 going to be coming out of station one, which is over Fifth Street. So, I mean, they could be over there at the training facility, but that probably would only happen if there's actually training activity going on.
4:59:03 We already we already have a building there. We already have a boat ramp. I mean, not a boat ramp, but ramp next door, you know, do here already. So
4:59:12 yeah, it it needs a lot of work, but yeah, I mean it's it's a good location and uh you know that you know we've identified that that that would be the
4:59:19 optimal way to do it to you know launch rescue if we had to.
4:59:23 But I agree. I mean we had a story on on the water there and whether we have to hold it down there to try to launch it in the water take more time and
4:59:31 everything. So just jump down west side. Can we incorporate this into
4:59:40 the two dots that we just approved funding for?
4:59:46 Well, the two dots we approve funding for the little dot. Well, this is a whole separate dock down here. Well,
4:59:53 now the building is different from the dock anyway that we just approved down there. We just approved the one off the second street and the one off third street.
5:00:02 Yeah, it was up there too. that took place those two. Well, you always had the one at Waterfront Park, which is what we say off the third street when you first come down third street far.
5:00:11 You had the dock there and then you had the one off the second street if you come down second street, first street.
5:00:16 And this little boat house, the little house has always been there. People been trying to get us to for years as the council that they can
5:00:24 turn it into a rental house and everything all we've been talking for years about
5:00:30 turning into a smoked up and everything for fire fire and police.
5:00:36 I was wondering if the two that we're already building can't be just expanded slightly larger footprint
5:00:44 saying we're already two years. Well, the one the one that's we we've been placing a lot of residents use utilize this.
5:00:53 I mean, it could be designed. I'm not suggesting it would be design.
5:00:58 I'm just thinking I know driving pierce is very expensive and it takes time and all those things versus if we just change the design of something that we have that might be more.
5:01:11 Yeah. I mean, I'm just trying to get a picture in my head. I'd want to go out there and take a look at it because part of what I look at too is you know what's
5:01:18 how easy is the truck going to be able to access it because park fire truck is you know there's going to be a place to park without obstructing streets or
5:01:26 anything else and we have a boat ramp I'm not saying it doesn't exist in the other location put eyes on going to the pier she she referring me to you you're
5:01:35 moving closer you're more in line with the res people swimming whe it's a little bit more isolated away
5:01:44 from people as well because it's closer to the ramp. But love the conversation.
5:01:52 Yeah. Well, I I mean I have no problem with I know when Chief was up here, he he mentioned it as well. Of course, like I say, taking the house. We talked about doing a lot of things the house and then
5:02:00 we're going to take it and again go back and use it as a substation as well. We was talking about cheap.
5:02:12 So looking out to fiscal year 28. Uh that's where we're looking to start doing the planning for our fire station tour facility. That's another one. We
5:02:21 have a number of issues there. We have not only the exercise equipment in the bay floor, we also have the gear out there. Um, that would make sense to push
5:02:30 that out because, you know, that probably need to have a talk with the county since it's a sheriff facility and their folks are out there as well and
5:02:37 see how that's going to look, who's going to pay for what, who's going to be responsible for maintenance and all the other things. And then, uh, station in
5:02:45 fiscal year 29, uh, that's when we're looking at doing the planning for the renovation on station one. Uh, we know that's going to be a pretty extensive
5:02:54 project. We're not only looking at doing the uh the side for the firefighters, we've been able at that station at least we've been able to get the the exercise
5:03:01 equipment off the bay floor, but we still, excuse me, we still have refrigerators around the bay floors. We still have gear that's not being stored
5:03:10 properly. So, those are two things we're looking to do there. And then we're also looking to basically redo the cabinet all the partitions and completely remap
5:03:18 the space there. Uh the way it's set up right now, it's not very efficient for doing the the work we need to do as far as running departments. We like to see
5:03:27 that space get maximized so that we're we're getting better.
5:03:31 What was the last renovation of station one?
5:03:36 I don't think aside from being added on to I don't think you've ever actually done renovation ever.
5:03:43 When was it built?
5:03:49 Well, they added you we added something to it, but I don't think Yeah, the admin was added. Initially, the admin, you know, worked out of the side where the where the crews are now.
5:04:00 When was that?
5:04:01 When they opened in 99, you know, the where administration is today is is a completely new building was added. That was what about 2010?
5:04:10 I thought it was 101 89. Okay. 08 or 09.
5:04:16 And when the first permanent fire station
5:04:26 station one no station
5:04:38 has it section three no ma'am other than the AC's and then there was
5:04:44 remodeled for mold issues with the ACS every couple years.
5:04:52 We've had it done a couple times. No, the building itself.
5:04:55 Oh, the building the building was done after five. I want to say it was closer to 200.
5:05:00 Oh, that building I thought it was a seven. I think it might have been seven. It was uh I remember station three the um the
5:05:08 portable that we were in was just after I got hired it was seven. Okay.
5:05:25 Well, well, one another problem was when when we first built station one, we didn't have much land there. So, we had to acquire some more land there. Still private land.
5:05:37 That was before me. I was I think five.
5:05:40 And I can tell you all the people we got that got all the land from we were limited on the land because it wasn't short after we built it. We were able to
5:05:48 acquire some more land well and for purposes of you know
5:05:56 looking at having six stations when the grows at seven you know seven stations if the stations
5:06:03 are each lasting 15 20 years before they need renovation. I mean, we're looking at realistically now you've been talking about vehicles, but now we're talking
5:06:11 about building renovation on a cycle that we need to be paying attention to.
5:06:18 So, I mean, that's something I would suggest moving forward, we start maybe allocating like one of the things that struck me
5:06:26 when we made the change to the plan for fire station 2 was because there was debt service in the budget. There was a million dollars in the budget for debt
5:06:35 service. If we just continue to put a million dollars in the budget each year to go towards capital, then as we need
5:06:44 it, we don't have to do a bond and debt service. We can just pay it and fund it.
5:06:50 So, it's something for us to, I think, be thinking about because as we're looking at this and going, "Oh, yeah. It's 20 years." 20 years.
5:06:58 Yeah. They're all pushing that 20 year mark.
5:07:02 And some of that, too, when we're designing stations, you know, we can we can plan for the future a little bit and avoid that that big ticket item.
5:07:10 I'm sure they thought we were planning for the future back then, too.
5:07:16 We did a lot of we did a lot of building because that's one, you know, when we
5:07:23 raised the thing when I came in in 2020, we had no funds available to do any of that. And that's what we had to look at.
5:07:30 how how we knew we needed to do station two and everything, but how you going to do it without service?
5:07:39 I was referring more to like now we're more aware of not having equipment on the floor, you know, aware of the
5:07:46 effects of the car, all of those like those are things that we were aware of as a society 30 years ago.
5:07:55 Of course, we've taken care of that and there's still more to be done. Thank you.
5:08:02 So, going into our capital proposals, I'll go through this quickly here. Um, we talked a lot about the firefighter health and safety. That's going to be
5:08:09 one of the big uh big themes that you're going to see in there. Uh, the training facility and equipment. Uh, we do have some money in there to take that to the
5:08:17 next step. Uh, technology rescue and water rescue equipment. We've got things in there to expand those programs. Uh, thermal imaging replacement program.
5:08:26 It's just that's one of our programs we've had in place for a few years and we need to take care of this year. Um, reserve 107. This is our last reserve
5:08:35 truck that we're outfitting. That was another thing that I started changing several years ago. Our reserve trucks had no equipment on them. So, we had to
5:08:43 take a unit out of service. We were spending one two hours to move equipment from one truck to another truck. When that truck's out of service, it can't go on a call until it gets all the
5:08:52 equipment on the other apparatus. turn and do it all over again the other other direction. So, we were losing a lot of productive time. We had units
5:08:59 unavailable for calls and we also found that when we got into disaster situations, if we had a need to put additional units in service, we couldn't
5:09:07 put those in service because they didn't have the equipment available on the calls. So, we for a while now have been putting we've been equipping our oldest
5:09:14 trucks, uh, the ones in the reserves now. That's the older items are on those trucks, not the newer stuff. New stuff stays on the new trucks. But now, when
5:09:22 they swap out, It's a matter of grabbing a radio, their computer, some of the medical equipment, and put it on the truck. And it's a it's 10 or 15 minute process. So, it makes it a lot easier.
5:09:31 So, this will be our last reserve that gets outfitted. And then what we'll do going forward is we'll buy new trucks with new equipment and then we'll just eventually phase stuff out as it goes out of the fleet.
5:09:42 How many do we have in reserve? We have four reserve trucks right now.
5:09:47 So you typically want to see you want to have about half the number of frontline trucks you want to have as reserves.
5:09:55 This page and fire station two that's another one big problem.
5:10:04 Next page the uh
5:10:12 other big ones we got here is that we talked about the direct source capture system heavy rush truck that is on order. You'll see that item being carried over into the next budget year.
5:10:22 And one thing that's new that's in there it's a little bit of a price tag. It's about $160,000. Uh this is a reserve specialy apparatus basically for our
5:10:31 heavy rescue. Uh what we're finding is when that truck has to go out of service, uh it has so much equipment on there, it will not fit on any of the reserves.
5:10:40 Uh you know, when you put the firefighting equipment on there that's needed, you don't have room for all the rescue equipment. So what we're
5:10:47 proposing now, a brand new heavy rescue is going to run probably about 2 and a4 million. So what we're looking to do,
5:10:54 think of a used beer truck. So sorry, what' you call it? Beer truck. Delivery truck.
5:11:00 Okay. So it literally it just it's it's got all the storage space. It won't it won't be we won't have fire suppression
5:11:09 on there as far as pump of water, but we can put all the rescue equipment on there and we can keep the services that that that unit delivers in service when
5:11:17 it has to go out of service. That makes sense.
5:11:22 So that's that's just a lowcost way of having something that can back up our heavy rescue when it has to go out for service to where we can keep the equipment and the capabilities available.
5:11:31 So you still need an engine or a tower for the water suppression.
5:11:36 Well, we have we have reserve letters, but you've got the you've got that specialty equipment as well. Yeah.
5:11:43 Is there a chance that it's probably pricewise better to do what you're saying, but is there a find a heavy
5:11:52 somewhere that's been used, but still not at this price point. Um, you know, we've looked at different options. I mean, we could we could acquire one. Um,
5:11:59 these trucks, uh, then there's some good opportunities out there to to get these.
5:12:03 And, you know, this is just a very, very lowcost way to have a backup for that unit.
5:12:08 And this isn't a this isn't technically a reserve. It's more portable.
5:12:14 It Well, it would be a reserve. I mean, it would go in service when the would go out of service. And this allows us to maintain our ISO.
5:12:22 Um, it really doesn't impact ISO because ISO is just focused on firefighting. And what this truck is designed for is all
5:12:30 the other, you know, the the technical rescue disciplines, the confined space, high angle,
5:12:37 um, complex extrications, all the other things that we can run into.
5:12:50 So basically I can say this just a temporary back off in case
5:12:58 even though I can't carry all the equipment right no I I appreciate the creativity I think it's we asked for innovation
5:13:11 I think leading with the beer truck threw me off a 14.
5:13:28 Well, it did.
5:13:33 Title we have is multi-roll specialty support apparatus repurposed hazmat unit for 160,000.
5:13:45 I like I just wanted to take some time to
5:13:52 explain that it's a it's a bigger bigger dollar amount. No, I wanted to just uh kind of outline what the thinking was on that and what purpose it's going to serve as a department.
5:14:02 If we had to choose, which one do you think is more important for the citizens of Clermont, the backup to the heavy or the both?
5:14:13 Well, uh, considering that right now we don't have backup to the heavy rescue and we do have a vote, um, actually I had this conversation with city manager,
5:14:22 my recommendation was to keep this unit in in the budget and push that capital section page.
5:14:40 Who's that picture?
5:14:44 They're all This is the milary special.
5:15:04 So, the last item on this page, uh, we have some of the vehicles that we were talking about that need to be replaced with the fleet. Some that we're looking to purchase and then we've got some
5:15:13 command staff vehicle replacements. One of those being a replacement for my vehicle that actually will get repurposed as the backup for the temps.
5:15:26 Okay. for the fire training facility. Um looking to do more to develop the site because with getting some more infrastructure out there, getting some
5:15:34 training props built about refurbishing the uh fleet building and renovation of the pump house and the
5:15:42 storage train storage and a briefing facility. We're also looking to do a
5:15:48 drill drill container project that was uh previously approved under fire impact fees and using the uh
5:15:57 basically modified shipping containers to build that and then also looking at the security infrastructure for the site. We're doing some of the fencing
5:16:05 some of the boundaries and whatnot out there having a access control gate that allows access for anybody needs to go
5:16:12 out there. And then looking out at 28th we're looking a classroom expansion and a multi-story field tower
5:16:21 that also would be done with chipping containers.
5:16:26 So, BMS transport, I know we've covered this uh in a lot of details, so we probably don't need to go through this too much, but this is the uh this is the capital underneath that project.
5:16:39 And then this is the fiscal summary.
5:16:41 This is looking at all of our different, you know, for fire, transport, and this is without transport being included in
5:16:47 there. And we're showing a shift from the current budget year to next year.
5:16:52 It's a increase of 8.5% to the total budget for the fire department. Also like to point out that there's a number
5:17:00 of items in here that uh are do have a pretty pretty hefty price tag that are that are onetime projects. Uh you'll see
5:17:07 it in the operating expenses and And when you look at what those items are, they feel more like the capital purchase, but they're below that $5,000
5:17:15 threshold. And a lot of that is from outfitting a reserve apparatus and getting fire stations out, that sort of thing. So, those are things that we
5:17:23 don't have to come back and buy again next year. So, those we'll always have some in that that purchase area, but this year with some of the projects,
5:17:31 we've got a much larger amount. So, that's that's attributed to something that increase,
5:17:37 but we also for out this year 26. We're not going to see anywhere near that number, right?
5:17:47 We had close to that like two didn't get off as we expected.
5:17:58 So I think a lot of Yes. Yeah. majority of the capital
5:18:04 expenses like fire stationation there's about 600 700,000 vehicles that
5:18:13 are getting reappropriated 15 facilities so a lot of these projects are splitting fiscal years so we're just
5:18:21 rebudgeting them I midway through and we had about 1.5 in
5:18:28 capital outlay at the mid so since March spent much of our capital taking delivery of the new pumper truck.
5:18:39 you guys a total of what we spent March in the current the current fiscal year and some of those requisitions are still
5:18:47 on but if we're anything we've anticipated
5:18:52 delivering this year that has not been this is obviously the budget is what I'm
5:19:01 saying because I think and when I look at this as a citizen I go okay we're spending a lot in capital but I think the reality is We contemplated two and
5:19:09 five and those are going to roll over into 27. Correct.
5:19:14 We bought the trucks for two but we haven't bought the trucks for five.
5:19:17 Those are going to be 27 truck. Excuse me. Yes.
5:19:25 Apply a grant for the truck for six.
5:19:29 And we've gotten some grants already for some of those expenditure. Correct.
5:19:34 We got the saber grant of the budget for the direct source capture. That's just so we can expense the grant.
5:19:44 We apply for grants for renovation to station back to see if that comes as
5:19:54 we have the opportunity to t.
5:20:01 So Scott, when we come to the next are we 45 or 60 days right now on recording?
5:20:09 Which one is it? 45 is our state, but we've been there. We were getting
5:20:17 close to 45 at one point. I'm wondering if next month we get an updated actual fire
5:20:24 because I think the budget is throwing me a little bit.
5:20:30 We end up with 3 million that we didn't spend at capital.
5:20:34 Yeah. The Q3 report would on our traditional schedule be presented to council at the second meeting in August.
5:20:43 Okay.
5:20:50 Chief Ger just reminded me of one other thing. Um I know we talked about it in the presentation for uh for the transport, but we are going there's
5:20:58 going to be one and a half million left in that account in the year. So that that money is going to be available to go back into fund balance or over into
5:21:06 the allocated amount for the transport project or whatever you choose to do.
5:21:11 Yeah, I know this one's a little trickier. That's why like parts I want to see the revenue on
5:21:18 this one. I think the actuals will help us and the public. see what we're looking
5:21:25 how these numbers are moving around rather than just the budget numbers.
5:21:28 Yeah. And we did a lot of work. I mean, we went back and we looked at a lot of things and, you know, we knew that with hiring additional firefighters, things like training was going to go up. Um, we
5:21:38 went back and re-evaluated this, you know, how we're doing and what kind of training we're doing. And what we actually ended up with is even though
5:21:45 our training budget increased uh we saw a reduction in the cost per firefighter on the train because you know some of the efficiencies we built into the
5:21:54 system. So you know the sharing act we went through a lot of functional areas to make sure that we were we were being as efficient as we could as we were going forward. We're growing and there's
5:22:02 going to be a lot of ripple effects with putting addition staff on. Well, and so the staff doesn't strike me as much.
5:22:09 That feels very logical. The growth in staff operating is double from 2025. And then talk about capital. So you know
5:22:17 that is high level. Talk to me about operations.
5:22:21 Yeah, that's that's where I was making the comment about the some of the expenses in there feel more like capital than they do uh operating. So to give
5:22:28 you some numbers, uh we've got 1.4 million in onetime purchases. That's 63,000 for IT equipment for fire station
5:22:36 2. 262,000 for outfitting fire station 2. Uh 42,000 for IT equipment for
5:22:43 station 6. 118,000 for outfitting fire station 6. Uh 124,000 for final reserve
5:22:51 outfitting. Uh professional services for fire station 6, 750,000. And then the sipsy cap program, the train the trainer
5:22:59 I talked about, that's 55,000. So I think like we were talking about correct it would help me and also I think the
5:23:07 public to be able this is more for Scott I think than it is for for you gentlemen is be able to see what's related to the
5:23:14 new five what's related to the new six to some extent what's related to two because that's a once every 20 year
5:23:22 expenditure so that we're all understanding what is this kind of once in a decade expense versus what's normal
5:23:30 operating I think because you know the numbers don't track personnel increase compared to operating capital but there's no reason for that
5:23:38 correct so being able to communicate the reason for that I think you could probably drop that number by a million and you know it would be closer
5:23:46 to being representative of what you would see in a typical that's and that's so we can say this is five this is six this is the two renovation these aren't normal but
5:23:55 they're normal in the context that we have capital buildings that we and that's exactly what we broke this out you know got a 23% increase in operation expenses when that's growing
5:24:03 is not the case. You're not going to have that 4.5 coming around every single year and you know that we got to pay for
5:24:12 you said you talked about is that am I missing it?
5:24:16 No, I just uh one of the things we did is I wanted to have a list of those projects so we could share what those costs were so you could you know connect
5:24:24 those dots and understand that you know while it's 4.5 million in operating the actual number on what's going actually operating cost is going to be a lot lower than that.
5:24:33 Exactly. That's what I'd like to communicate.
5:24:36 I think people will like what we're doing, but if we lump it all together, it'll just look like spending versus
5:24:44 Yeah, we're always we're always going to have those little projects. But when you're talking about outfitting fire stations and designing fire stations, those are big ticket items and they're
5:24:53 going to inflate that number for that year. Exactly. Okay. Thank you. Appreciate it.
5:25:01 I just have one clarification question.
5:25:04 chief or Mr. Boore. Um, with regard to the the slide where you talked about the proposed fiscal year 27 highlights and the 16 FTE for EMS transport.
5:25:17 Um, those 16 FTE that's included in the 5.3 carryover that that might be proposed as as earmarking for reserved.
5:25:30 That is correct.
5:25:31 Okay. So, it's not actually it's being proposed in 27, but it's not new funding in 2017.
5:25:37 It was Yeah, it was originally in our budget, right? And, you know, conversations with the city manager, we decided to pull that off to the side and
5:25:43 recommend that that be funded, you know, outside of general.
5:25:48 Is there any in your capital for 27 for EMS? Is there any expenditure that's new in fiscal
5:25:57 year 27 or is is it everything is in that $5.3 million budget.
5:26:01 Everything is in the 5.3. So there's no new in in the budget and general fund. There's nothing for transport.
5:26:07 Okay. Um and then the other question within the 525 EMS transport budget, we
5:26:14 have uh some personnel expenditures in there. Is that the division chief or That is correct.
5:26:21 Okay. I just want to make sure that that's where that that's that's the only exception there is I do have one person salary.
5:26:26 Right. And we and we approved that. I just wanted to make sure that's where that was being allocated for. Okay. Thank you. That was my only question.
5:26:42 So, just one thing to share with council. Um, I've already had some conversations with the city attorney, uh, talking about our application
5:26:49 process and, you know, how we want to be positioned to approach the county for that request. And, uh, it through that conversation, one of the things that,
5:26:58 uh, we we identified is that by having a resolution that is basically funding that program if we get it off the
5:27:05 ground, we felt that that would be a strong add to our case when we go to the county to make that request. Um, another thing that I'm working to do is to get
5:27:13 with procurement and have the RFP out there for a medical director just so we have all these pieces in line and we can go in there we've got the plan so if
5:27:21 we've got the plan we've got the funding we've got the medical director all these other things that we have to have we pretty much you know show the county we're ready to go you know we just need
5:27:30 the certificates so we can go to the state and apply for the ALS license that we're going to
5:27:45 I mean, I I'm very impressed with the way you you know, you're handling this whole situation with, you know, planning ahead, making sure that, you know, it's
5:27:52 almost like a game of chess, but you're you're making moves, anticipating that there is an empty space there, but you have something that's going to be going
5:28:00 right into that. So, we're not going to be vulnerable there. U I'm totally for EMS and federal fire
5:28:08 influence. I think that's one of the functions of government is to protect lives and this is what we're doing now.
5:28:14 doing it in a fiscally responsible way, too. So, just say to I think we're doing a good job and I
5:28:22 think we're going ahead and you're anticipating uh the moves that county might do and we're we're going to stay on top of that
5:28:30 so we can move rapidly then when when the time comes to get this done.
5:28:34 We're seeing a lot of advantages for us as well outside of the transport piece like you know conversations about station six as to how we proceed with
5:28:42 that. You know, one of my recommendation so that we can kind of do a based approach on how we get that station up operating and regardless of whether
5:28:50 we're doing transport and we could still put we would call a you know quick response unit right and so we could you know get you know some firefighters in that location
5:28:58 get it operational have them available for calls and whether that's transport unit or non-transport unit that's another conversation but it doesn't
5:29:06 necessarily have to change what we purchase and what we put in place I love the idea and I I realize conversation usually around transport
5:29:14 and that the county comes into that. Um, but I I want to be clear with the four of you and the staff that I love the the
5:29:23 quick transport units as a way to get paramedics to the citizens quickly and
5:29:31 they happen to be firefighters. So, in my mind, it's great. You're getting the best of both worlds. And so the fact that we can, correct me if I'm wrong,
5:29:40 but depending on depending on the apparatus, we can get two to three quick response units for the price of one depending on the apparatus.
5:29:48 Yeah. Two of those to one engine.
5:29:50 It it allows us. But if we need a heavy, three or four transports, right? So or ladders. I mean, we need the equipment
5:29:58 we need to fight fires. There's no doubt about that. But when 80 plus percent of our calls are medical response, I'm
5:30:06 fully supportive of I I'd be very interested in seeing what it would look like to get four rapid response units or
5:30:13 quick response units so that we could move at stations where we have two apparatus, move find two, move one to
5:30:21 the new five and six and then back fill the two now missing apparatus and the two new stations with the quick response
5:30:29 units. And now we can if that serves the public, you know, the chief's opinion.
5:30:35 But I would be for a I would almost enjoy seeing another version of the budget that includes
5:30:43 that because it allows us to save money on the firefighting.
5:30:49 And so that's just opening stations and having six people working instead of four people working or two people
5:30:56 working. So that rather than eight people at each station. So, it saves the citizens the money, but they get the
5:31:04 benefit of the quick response. And we also now have one or two apparatus spread throughout the city in the event
5:31:12 of a fire. So, I see it. Yes, transport is part of that and it creates the opportunity where it's a logical
5:31:18 extension of that, but to me, it's all about the six-minute response time, right? And I I still as I sit here and
5:31:27 we have a 9minute response in Mer Ridge and I consider how many homes are there and how much they paid in impact piece
5:31:35 and don't have a police station or a fire station for what they've paid. It feels unjust. And so I can't undo
5:31:44 whatever led to those impacts being used on other projects. But I do feel like as I sit here I have influence over
5:31:53 and a quicker response time and can we do it how do we do it cost effectively and I think the quick response units are a great solution to doing it cost
5:32:01 effectively and effectively.
5:32:04 Yes. So so for me it's not just about the transport as much as it is getting the quick response.
5:32:12 So I'm I'm in support of those units whether we have transport or not. So I want I'll point out too, it does not mean they do not have firefighting
5:32:21 capabilities. This means that they have unlimited firefighting capabilities. So the people assigned to that unit, they will have their protective equipment.
5:32:27 They'll have their air packs. They'll have a set of forceable entry tools.
5:32:31 They'll probably have like what we call wet water extinguishers just a can with a couple gallons in there. So there there is some level of effectiveness
5:32:40 with that. And we've seen it. You know, good example is Orlando. That's the model they use over there. and the some of the folks that ride on those
5:32:48 ambulances are some of the highest decorated employees because of the number of records that they've been able to make.
5:32:53 Just getting to the scene quick and just going in and doing a quick snatching wrap and getting somebody out of the house. Those those kind of things can happen.
5:33:01 I think it's great.
5:33:04 Yes. Mine too. And thank you all for what you do for us. Thank you. Appreciate you.
5:33:12 All right.
5:33:17 Who do we have next? Most I gave you a package just now on the
5:33:26 back of the package. I gave you some photos. I think Huh.
5:33:31 No, I think I take you photo.
5:33:36 Well, we all after lunch. Let me get a picture.
5:34:47 Heat. Heat.
5:35:14 Hey. Hey. Hey.
5:35:34 Hey, hey, hey.
5:36:02 Heat. Heat.
5:36:36 Heat. Heat.
5:37:19 Heat. Hey, Heat.
5:39:28 Hey. Hey. Hey.
5:39:57 Heat. Heat.
5:41:07 Heat. Heat.
5:41:33 Hey. Hey. Hey.
5:42:32 I guess the microphone I guess it is. That's got
5:42:56 both the wireless link. I think you're right.
5:43:07 Yeah, they'll just put it up tomorrow.
5:43:23 That one picks up.
5:43:37 We're ready whenever you want.
5:43:52 Whatever gets people's attention. Boy, thanks so much.
5:43:59 Get their attention. Yes, sir. We're ready for you. All right.
5:44:05 Well, we have had numerous requests to keep this as short as possible. So, we do exactly what we can. Thank you.
5:44:13 We can be done if there's no questions. Yes. Yes.
5:44:18 All right. Our current year review. We finished construction of the wastewater treatment plant expansion. Uh we have purchased property off of Old 50 for
5:44:28 alternate water storage. Uh that came through funding through grants from the state legislative appropriations. We
5:44:37 continued a pretty aggressive program on road improvements. Uh we are we have replaced two and are replacing two more
5:44:46 peers to give us threat over four from the hurricane dam.
5:44:51 Uh we have a very unique grant from the state to replace sanitation vehicles in which they actually are going to pay
5:44:59 100% for clean vehicles which is unheard of in my universe. It has something to do with a lawsuit from Volkswagen.
5:45:12 So the age of the vehicle is the most important thing. We are replacing the very variable vehicles and department
5:45:19 with three more clam trucks which will
5:45:31 bring our bring our hurricane cleanup capabilities to 10 vehicles which will really help us quite a bit. Um we also
5:45:39 implemented impact sheets for which is produced. That's going to give us the opportunity into the future to
5:45:47 pay for things off impact fees and then
5:45:52 we've got $15 million with impact from the state on those. We reached out to the consulting firm.
5:46:05 So far what they're hearing from other people but some of their other clients we still have data still not received all of their paperwork back from the state yet. So we are still in a holding pattern. It does show us pending.
5:46:18 What is the state funds that was the when we came we did that pres.
5:46:29 So we're waiting on 15 million that we've requested or 15 million available at the state level that
5:46:36 we have 15 about 15 million carpet projects that are eligible for that funding. We're still waiting on
5:46:42 the state to get back to us with that what they actually
5:46:50 this would be a $15 million technically a loan from the state with 15% grant forgiveness.
5:46:58 I remember it. Sorry.
5:47:00 We the council approved the application of that back in March or so. We thought we were told originally that by May we
5:47:08 would have a response from the state and Mr. Griffin just said we're still in a holding pattern.
5:47:13 State hadn't even approved it, but they did. Did they not?
5:47:18 They just finally approved it. Wasn't me. It wasn't. It's a while.
5:47:28 All right. Our department is split into two distinctive halves. Utilities on one side, general operations on the other.
5:47:38 This is general operations. Utilities. Okay.
5:47:46 General operations. Keep going.
5:47:55 All right, highlights for this upcoming year. Uh, with the expansion over the years of all the different vehicles from
5:48:02 all the different departments, we are requesting the hiring of a specific
5:48:08 fleet services manager. Currently, the fleet service operation is managed by
5:48:17 the same individual that manages our facility. So, people's double duty can While our fleet was much smaller, that
5:48:24 was an efficient and effective way to go. All the expansions that we've had and those in the future, it's time to
5:48:33 get somebody that's very specific and very technical about how to manage the fleet to maintain efficiencies.
5:48:41 We're looking for an additional mechanic to help repair everything that we've
5:48:48 got. key piece for those two positions of the fleet maintenance is in the
5:48:54 general fund. The actual uh salaries and benefits would be split between all of
5:49:01 the enterprise fund. So only 20% of both of those fleet m the fleet manager and mechanics positions would come out of.
5:49:13 We're looking for an additional three sanitation employees that would cover our expansion to the south as well this
5:49:22 way area. Additionally to cover some of the new annexations that was already handled an additional five utility workers
5:49:32 and proposed land acquisition for transfer station to give us some independence deal with our future base.
5:49:41 Okay.
5:49:42 the three sanitation you gonna be able to that's all you need with all wellness way and all these along bridge and all that.
5:49:51 Over the past couple of years we have been expanding. So this we anticipate this should be the last three employees
5:50:00 we need in sanitation until we build a transfer station that becomes a different facility. But for collection
5:50:09 on the street, three more people should cover us with our current annexations.
5:50:15 That being Wellness Ridge and Parks Trails and anything else. Now, that
5:50:22 could change if we pick up additional annexations or anything else. So, we're
5:50:29 just looking at it right now as what we currently Wow.
5:50:39 There you go.
5:50:42 Capital proposal uh road program requesting funding at uh 2.9 million.
5:50:50 Sidewalks, trails. We already talked about that this morning a little bit. 575,000.
5:50:57 We've got vehicle replacements for 244 that would be in the water division. New
5:51:04 sanitation vehicles to go along with three employees for 470,000. How many vehicles is that?
5:51:12 That's three vehicles. Three.
5:51:14 That's two smaller rear loading garbage trucks and one uh small flatbed that we
5:51:22 use for white goods and other miscellaneous pickup items. If you put your refrigerator out the street, we'll come pick it up.
5:51:32 We didn't need another truck. side loader and the clam trucks with the addition of
5:51:39 the three new ones that the state's paying for on grant that a total of 10. Okay.
5:51:45 Those are the same vehicles again we use for hurricane cleaning.
5:51:50 So it it's you know we're one of the communities that gets cleaned up the fastest.
5:51:57 So this is really how much of this is in the general fund versus the Well, road program is infrastructure.
5:52:07 Sidewalks are infrastructure. Vehicle replacements are an enterprise fund.
5:52:12 Water sanitation's enterprise fund. Property acquisition for transfer station
5:52:19 enterprise fund. The buildings for 60,000. It's a roof
5:52:25 replacement. That may be the only person
5:52:32 and the enterprise correctly talking about Scott. They're fairly well regulated by law, right? How much
5:52:41 discretion do we have? Creativity.
5:52:49 Creativity. I like that.
5:52:56 This is a I can't tell you how often we have this very same conversation within the finance department. Sometimes to the detriment of what the departments are
5:53:03 trying to acquire. But as long as we can reasonably attach a service or an action
5:53:10 to the utilities, we can at least um allocate a portion of that cost to those enterprise funds.
5:53:19 Are any of these capital or or debt service related or is this all cash?
5:53:24 These are all cash based. We didn't include anything with the SRF because we're still in that golden pattern
5:53:31 thing. Um this is all cash. And on page 75 of the budget book,
5:53:39 you can see exactly the response to your question about how much of that is general fund.
5:53:46 That is this table here on page 75 is a summary of all the general fund public works divisions and as you can see at
5:53:54 the top $60,000 of all of this is capital within the general fund which is
5:54:03 why why are you I mean not complaining but why are we spending less in 27 on
5:54:12 infrastructure? Well, as a general rule of thumb, when we determine the funding source for capital purchases, we begin with the least restrictive s or excuse me, the most restrictive source.
5:54:22 Okay?
5:54:23 So, we'll look at the impact fees first or the infrastructure fund first and so on and so forth. And then with the state fun that we're talking about $15
5:54:31 million, if we don't get it and we approve these items, are we designing the citizens something that they need in
5:54:40 exchange for our wants or should we be earmarking that products that are listed currently?
5:54:51 So for instance, some one of the ones that would be eligible for that statement fund would be storage tank in
5:54:59 greater hills. That's a requirement that we have that in there because we're already hearing peak demand seeing that start dropping lower.
5:55:06 So it's always been in our budget in our capital plan to replace that with a larger tite. The benefit is now it's
5:55:14 eligible for rolling funds. So all sets that where is the wellness
5:55:23 that you mentioned earlier the you said there's a wellness way well that was expansion that's that's
5:55:31 for sanitation trucks those are the trucks that's the three new sanitation vehicles for for
5:55:40 a storage unit or a water treatment facility a water treatment facility down that starts taking out. We start with some
5:55:47 design costs in this upcoming 27 budget, but actual when we start getting into construction costs, we're pushing out in
5:55:54 the 2829. But should we be saving for that now? Absolutely.
5:56:03 So, as part of the rate study that is we're getting close to concluding, we do provide the consultant a five-year
5:56:11 capital plan. Um so as long as we have a solid plan in place that is um included in their analysis
5:56:18 and that project is included in the fiveear plan they have also
5:56:28 of course what are we looking to put down there treatment plant
5:56:36 and how big how big and big of a plant it's going to be probably somewhere close to being I would say in the four to five million gallon of storage.
5:56:48 We just we just cost us what? 48 million. The increase that was waste water. Waste water. Yeah.
5:56:53 We're talking just saying with that what we increase what three and a half million. That one
5:57:00 didn't increase on the wast.
5:57:05 So to do that one now we we probably looking somewhere around 20 30 million.
5:57:10 We're probably close to the high end of the 30s, possibly in the 40s depending on how increases go.
5:57:18 Well, I'm just, you know, running knowing what we just wanted and everything. Okay.
5:57:24 So, as I'm looking at the fund, thank you, Mr. B, for bringing this to my attention earlier. So, it looks like and walk me through this because
5:57:33 I'll be honest, your department's the one I have the least handle on, but we've got the water fund at the end of 27 with the projects you've proposed,
5:57:41 we'd be left with 8.5 million. The sewer fund 12.3 million, water impact would be 5.1 million. Sewer impact would be 2.3
5:57:49 million, storm water 1.7, and then 1.9 and sanitation. Do we have the funds
5:57:55 anticipated at the end of fiscal year 27 to support the needs of the water treatment facilities and wellness way based on those numbers?
5:58:06 No, it would have to be a additional grant funding.
5:58:14 Which fund from which fund would that normally be paid?
5:58:31 with water about three and a half million. I think you said you're looking I think million for that.
5:58:36 We'll be close to the $40 million. We're anticipating neither. We're hoping it's going to be less, but we're anticipating.
5:58:43 So the water fund, we're starting at 20 million. We're anticipating 17 million revenues and we're asked being asked 28
5:58:51 million in expenditures. So our net change is 11 million this year,
5:58:57 but we know we have 38 million coming down the pipe. So is
5:59:06 it prudent for us to spend 28 million when our revenues are only 17 million?
5:59:12 Are we anticipating we're going to have grants to make up that difference and therefore we're not going to have a net change of 11 million? like talk them through it so that I
5:59:20 as we go through the process, we're going to continue to reach out for grant funding. We do not know what that total number will be yet,
5:59:27 but we will we are anticipating that we will have to take out some kind of bond to help pay for that one.
5:59:36 So more debt services. Yes, sir.
5:59:38 Well, and our debt in fairness, our debt services are coming close to an end, right, Scott?
5:59:47 30 33 there was a picture there was a chart of that here somewhere page 16 you'll see in the debt service
5:59:56 schedules uh the two final columns on the on the right hand side show you those that are
6:00:04 related to the enterprise activities. So we do have the one that is concluded in 2031.
6:00:12 Then the second one we just got started on with the voice in 3031. That's been reported.
6:00:20 I don't know what the original project was, sir. It was refinanced in 2017. So I think that goes back to late 90s.
6:00:29 I thought I thought Victory Point. Yeah, I think Victory Point is 2033. I think we're on the same page.
6:00:36 Oh, that was part of the master plan though. Thank you. Yeah, but we're seeing two of the beds are falling off from 29
6:00:46 and then two more fall off in 31, right?
6:00:50 When is there a time frame that we you would say we need to have a water treatment facility up and running along this way? Yesterday or 2031?
6:00:58 We are currently working on a proposal with Sunshine for Internet to help out with the loss issues in that area.
6:01:08 We need to have our master plan identified as being online within the next five years, which why we're talking the planning now moving into a couple years construction.
6:01:18 So, is it normal that we would spend more from our funds than we have in anticipated revenues for a large capital project like that?
6:01:27 It has typically been from some other kind of funding source such as pay for those
6:01:38 We would typically do something with you would typically do something like an
6:01:47 NST or a special fee.
6:01:54 Here's my question and maybe this is for Scott. Did the people in the wellness way pay enough in impact fees to Did
6:02:03 they pay $38 million and would it be water impact fees? Water.
6:02:08 Do we know how to figure out what was paid by the res?
6:02:15 I would have to defer to the building services department. Um I don't know if we could identify the location of the payment history.
6:02:33 Time out. What?
6:02:35 Well, you got to remember Memphis is still count.
6:02:37 Memphis is city, but there's quite a bit of county. Yeah. County, but this is the county.
6:02:43 Hold on. Let me say what I heard you say.
6:02:45 Make sure I'm hearing you right. So, we have to build a water treatment facility because the county approved homes and
6:02:53 collected the impact. This will this additional water treatment plant will service the entire southern area. So
6:03:01 it's anticipated to help with another water source for the water system as a whole.
6:03:06 They it just happens to be that that's at the end of the service line.
6:03:10 So it makes sense to put it down there for reliability reasons and the additional growth in that area. No, I totally agree.
6:03:18 But are we servicing county residents who paid impact fees to the county? We always have.
6:03:27 I'm getting nos and yes.
6:03:28 I think only if if they if we is I don't think down there we providing any services for
6:03:37 county. I think sunshine sunshine does
6:03:47 we're handling some of the subdivisions that are in there right now, it's split service.
6:03:53 So, we do some of the service area. So, right about where on the map, right about where Trout Lake is on there, that's the divider between the service lines.
6:04:02 So, south of that area, Sunshine, north of that area, and the neighborhoods we have so far, we
6:04:09 have water and sewer there. There are some neighborhoods down there like some of the apartment complexes that are down there and some of the new residential that's gettinged down on the 27 side.
6:04:19 Some of that falls in Sunshine. They provide the water and it's confusing.
6:04:26 I know. I need a colored space.
6:04:29 The actual service line cuts uh you're familiar with the Ridge View neighborhood. So, it actually cuts north
6:04:39 of that. A small portion of Olympus is ina Sunshine service area. So, the Integra
6:04:47 that were built originally. That's all handled by Sunshine and Sunshine handles both water and sewer. The new David
6:04:54 Weekly uh single family home that's being constructed right now, it was a portion to the north that was going to be in our
6:05:03 service area that Mark was talking about, but that didn't make any logical sense. So, we have an agreement with Sunshine that they'll take care of that.
6:05:12 But then all of the Olympus proper is handled by our util All of Wellness Ridge is handled by our utilities. All
6:05:20 of Parkside Trails is handled by our utilities. So that's the extent of it.
6:05:27 And anything new that would be built within the city's utility service area will be handed by us.
6:05:35 Well, Parkside Trails is pretty far from every that's a lot of line that we're talking about and that's the reason why we're anxious.
6:05:45 done.
6:05:47 Okay. So, this plant would service the folks in Wellness Way,
6:05:54 Parkside Trails and David Olympus.
6:06:03 Yes.
6:06:04 Provide water to Harvard that the other plan went down. We have system
6:06:14 we just the $48 million water treatment facility is for that. So I'm wasting
6:06:25 time trying to figure out money when I say that.
6:06:27 No, it's good. I'm not going to be as confident with this conversation about money. So I guess what I'm just trying
6:06:34 to understand is and I want to be sure that before first of all I feel like there's an elephant in the room which is
6:06:40 the waste water treatment the new water treatment like that is looming on the horizon. I
6:06:47 don't want to ignore it or be accused of kicking the can.
6:06:53 Um, so I'm trying what I'm trying to understand is I guess what I really want
6:07:00 to understand is why don't we have the money and impact fees to build facilities that and I'm not pointing
6:07:07 fingers I'm actually like asking you know why why wouldn't when development this is new construction new facilities for new construction I
6:07:15 can understand to an extent old facilities that need renovation so because it doesn't make sense to me
6:07:22 asking these questions. It's not I don't know. I'm not accusing anybody.
6:07:29 Well, if I'm sorry, sorry, Jack. I thought you were done.
6:07:34 If I could help possibly alleviate some of your concerns, um I can't speak off the on the fly here about the spending
6:07:42 history of the water treatment or excuse me of the water impact fee fund.
6:07:46 However, my point is the rate study is the first step in determining what the
6:07:53 funding plan for this project which is scheduled to begin two years out um will
6:08:00 be there. The the consultant is aware of this project in their analysis. Uh we believe in the next 60 days we'll be bringing this to city council. Yes.
6:08:10 To study. Um, and then from there we can start closely looking at the rest of the funding plan on that project.
6:08:18 Well, I you know what I'm not saying you've commented on this in the past is there's a
6:08:26 desire by the people that we save them money on their utility expenses. And so what I'm anticipating is that we're
6:08:35 planning on fee increases because we don't have the facil today. But maybe
6:08:42 that's not right. Maybe we don't need to raise their fees. Like maybe we can lower their fees and still have to. I don't know. But I think that's where I'm
6:08:51 coming from is this overlying concern with utility fees. And I can't I'm not seeing anything that doesn't make me
6:08:58 think I'm committing to utility fees even though we're not voting on it because I know that there's this new plan that needs to go in $3,800.
6:09:07 Well, that's where the study going to come in. study going to tell us whether we pretty much tell us whether we need to raise fees and everything to try to keep up the cost. So,
6:09:16 uh people's complaint because we raised them and we have a a plan in place now where we have them in the way mid year but that come from the study before
6:09:24 where we wasn't raising to keep up with the cost of everything. That's one of the reason I feel like we fell behind.
6:09:30 So, when we got the study two, three years ago, a few years ago, we went and started raising these things to try to catch up
6:09:37 and keep the Well, we wouldn't own the city. I mean, all the cities throughout Central Florida area got hit with the same thing. So,
6:09:46 I'm hoping that the new study say we we okay position, but and keep in mind, and I'm sorry if this
6:09:54 is an obvious statement, but um the impact fees can be used towards repayment of debt service. So in other
6:10:01 words, once that project is completed and you presumably paid cash out of impact fees towards it over the next 20
6:10:09 30 years, you can continue use impact fees towards that debt service. It's not so divided upon the the monthly rates of the consumers. Okay.
6:10:17 Yeah. You go back pay for the total project.
6:10:25 Well, at some point it's unwise might say irresponsible and I have to really get my judgment right,
6:10:33 but the idea that you have to grow in order to survive is not something I philosophically believe to be true. So I'm going to be cautious about saying
6:10:42 impact fees will on the other hand they're planning for the future. So on one hand that's good but but it could
6:10:48 also cut the other way. So um I am very interested in how the proposals could
6:10:55 impact the utility fees, utility rates and I know I'd like chance to run by the
6:11:01 impact of this on utility rates by the people and to learn more about these myself and then I'll stop talking.
6:11:10 Well, what' you say? Two months, 60 days. 60 days.
6:11:14 We'll know what what the study says and this is a study that's required. I've been every three four years.
6:11:22 It's recommended that we go through it and stay in line with what's going on updated every couple.
6:11:27 It it should be And of course that's what they complained about now because of course the increase from the last study we just did
6:11:34 that is well and previous to the last study we did we haven't done one for quite some time we had we had one that's what the
6:11:43 problem we had did one in years when we did the last one and that's why it was quite significant you know and we wasn't like
6:11:52 I said we was the only cities in the area that did it everybody else I went apart with the
6:11:59 worst and everything. So we all we all got hit about the same time. I think it was main because state almost recommended
6:12:08 that we do studies everybody hopefully this time our study since
6:12:17 we've been doing the recommended increases as they recommended this time the studies will be okay.
6:12:24 Well that's what consultants tell us.
6:12:27 You know, there's a big difference between not doing it for say 8 to 10 years and suddenly needing to do it. Of course, your increases are going to
6:12:36 chop, right?
6:12:37 But, you know, it's just a marginal increase to keep up with the cost of inflation and everything else like that.
6:12:44 So, and here's our fiscal summary for the year coming up.
6:12:56 Overall, we were looking at a decrease generally to the postponement of a lot of the capital projects that push those back year.
6:13:09 The enterprise funds, we do have personnel increases, operating costs going up.
6:13:20 Requesting some capital overall increases of 20% across all range.
6:13:35 More questions. Uh yeah, I want I meant to ask you about transfer station. You said that you had up there
6:13:42 for the transfer station. Yes.
6:13:46 We're not still looking at trying to put that uh if we do a transfer station down on 12 street as well.
6:13:52 Well, that was our original You know, our access would have been off of the extension of Montro
6:14:02 next to the Catholic Church on the south side of field. We would have come in from that area. Um
6:14:09 that's still a possibility. The advantage to that location is the only we and we would build something reasonably
6:14:18 modest. A transfer station doesn't have to be elaborate.
6:14:23 everything else. It's basically the spot for a truck to unload to debode into a larger truck to the dump. Now,
6:14:32 we'll during the course of designing and discussing with the experts, there'll be questions regarding do we want a compactor?
6:14:42 There's efficiencies. If we compact our garbage into the truck to take it to the
6:14:50 landfill, just us fewer trips and everything else, but that becomes a higher construction
6:14:56 cost, higher operating cost. These are some things we'll have to explore and go through.
6:15:05 We're looking for property to see if we can find something in case the 12th Street site doesn't work out.
6:15:15 So, have we have we went back to really look and see if that's what we really want to do? Look at how much sailing there to be because I know right now we take it all the road.
6:15:27 Yes. Uhhuh.
6:15:29 Is there like a sound that I keep hearing? Okay. Thank you.
6:15:38 So, so about doing our own transfer station, how much what kind of savings would that be?
6:15:45 Worth.
6:15:47 Well, we think it's worth it so that we can control our destiny and our savings. One
6:15:55 key point in the whole discussion and reason the transfer station came up is that they they have fire at the existing
6:16:03 transfer station which shut down for month and a half.
6:16:10 At that point in time, we're stuck. We have no place to go looking to take our garbage trucks to the dump. Our garbage
6:16:19 trucks are not really built to do that.
6:16:23 That is an hour two hours. Hour there, hour back, two hour round trip to dump a
6:16:30 garbage truck. We dump the trucks when they're up collecting two to three times a day. Right? So now suddenly my 10-hour
6:16:39 day picking up your garbage on your collection day may not happen because I'm spending too much truck driving back and forth. This was several years ago.
6:16:50 At that point we became operationally became very concerned, right? What if they choose not to rebuild this transport station? We don't have any
6:16:59 other local options. Our entire operational model for sanitation is built off the convenience of driving.
6:17:09 So we started going down the path of what if we operated our own transfer station? What would that look like? I said it doesn't have to be elaborate
6:17:18 construction but and there's other opportunities to expand into more
6:17:24 revenue gener. We can all of course if we had our own station we can also be utilized by other other services which we can collect as well.
6:17:35 Absolutely perfect opportunity.
6:17:37 Well, but that's where 12th Street site may not be to that advantage because that might end up being too small
6:17:45 because it's more shared with police and fire. So yeah, you're saying you have to come off a mantra which by the church. I was thinking when we talked about it before
6:17:54 I going come off of 50 and there's there's a possibility for that too. So we, you know, without engineering it, I can't completely tell
6:18:03 you what the circulation route would be, but there is access off.
6:18:07 I I don't know what would go into creating that. There's an awful lot of swampy land out there.
6:18:16 This This is true.
6:18:18 Okay. Well, I I know I just sort of think of it transfer station and a lane opposition. So, we look more different.
6:18:26 We're just trying to keep our options open right now and keep our eyes open.
6:18:30 Uh, you know, we were successful in finding spot for alternative water off 50. That prompted the thought, hey, maybe there's something else close by.
6:18:40 You know, operationally makes good sense for our operations to keep the costs as controlled as we can.
6:18:47 So, we're exploring. we can find a piece of land that's more to the east east side and more centralized and everything extra cost.
6:18:57 Go ahead. That's fine with me. Thank you.
6:19:00 Well, no, I mean I would like I actually I think I would like to see the transfer state get transfer station think to save
6:19:08 us in the long run to control our future costs. Right. If
6:19:15 we're if we're disposing, our our costs to tip at the landfill are fairly inexpensive. I mean, right now, our cost
6:19:23 to tip a truckload or a ton of garbage at the transfer station is $57 a ton solid waste, $125 a ton.
6:19:35 If if we take that and bring it to landfill, that cost us $18.24.
6:19:44 So there's and we haven't done a lot of the math yet because we're still in our infancy, but right there it shows you that there's some pretty good cost.
6:19:56 Yeah. Yeah. And you you mentioned the recycle, which is one of the things I think I've mentioned before. I really like for us to think about getting
6:20:03 better recycle because basically nothing being recycled and this cost of money recycle. I found everything being dumped together.
6:20:11 Well, we no longer the The recycling no longer goes to Miami. It does go to Orlando to a municipal waste sorting facility.
6:20:22 Miami ran out of space down something. Can I ask a followup question on that?
6:20:27 Because I I hear that frequently in the community when we're talking about this now that I hear we don't actually
6:20:36 recycle. But that's not what I'm hearing you say.
6:20:39 We do, right? We collect single stream receptive product that gets taken to the same transfer station
6:20:49 loaded on a separate truck taken to Orlando offloaded and sorted. At that point,
6:20:57 what happens to all the various products? I I can't vouch for right. But we take it to a facility with the intent that it goes to a facility to
6:21:05 be recycled. That's that is the service that we provide in that way. Yes. And that we're paying for And that we're paying for it to do.
6:21:12 We're paying for someone to recycle the goods that we get them. Yes. Okay.
6:21:18 Is there a way for us to they own the goods once we drop the material at? Yeah.
6:21:25 We no longer have ownership, right?
6:21:28 We're aware that we can trace the path to this municipal sorting facility where other people bring their materials, too.
6:21:38 And then plastics go to plastics, glass, metals goes where it goes. But then what happens to those products after the fact
6:21:47 is there's probably no way, right? But to make the blanket statement that we don't recycle, we don't
6:21:55 we recycle. Well, let me say this. I understand we we doing the recycle but it's all not my understanding it what
6:22:02 what once we put out a recycle we do the recycling but we take it in and it wasn't being sorted at one point it was just all being
6:22:10 there and there's various times where probably that didn't happen out there out there every single
6:22:19 day watching the trucks fall what I can tell you for sure is we pay a significant premium or under $25
6:22:28 So that's what I was looking for is where where can I see the number sanitation
6:22:42 three times recycling regular trash at one point was doing that recycling
6:22:50 but it wasn't actually I'm not sure what the term is here.
6:23:06 543.
6:23:10 All right. Our recycling fee is $700,000 this year. Yes. Our solid waste disposal is 1.5 million.
6:23:19 700,000 for roughly 3,000 tons of recycling versus the versus 22,000 tons of solid.
6:23:29 I'm sorry, that's way too many zeros. Can you tell me?
6:23:35 So we we're budgeting 1.5 million to dump 22,000
6:23:44 tons of solid waste at 5929 a ton.
6:23:52 And we're budgeting 700,000 for 4,000 tons
6:24:00 at a cost of 13474 per ton.
6:24:05 Is there any way for us to know that the serer is actually recycling? Is there a way for us to verify it?
6:24:12 We I mean we spot check from time to time and every time we have the service appears to be functioning as it is, but
6:24:21 again we're we're not there all the time. And I I guess like I said once once it goes to Orlando and gets sorted,
6:24:29 we have no idea where our problems. Let me ask this question then. Okay, we paying so much for them to collect our recyclables and everything.
6:24:39 How much are they making off the recycle?
6:24:44 We paying this high fee for them to collect for us to collect recyclable and they making all this extra money off of it.
6:24:51 One of the reasons we're paying such a high fee is that there really is no value to
6:24:59 recycle at one point. time roughly seven, eight years ago, we used to get paid,
6:25:09 right, for materials we bought and tipped at the old transfer station, right? They paid us because there was value in that
6:25:19 material. So our our we only started paying $134 a ton.
6:25:26 Actually started at$125 just a few years ago. Prior to that, the cost to us by our contractor was zero.
6:25:33 Zero, right?
6:25:34 There was no cost. And so that was a very big sticker shock to our sanitation budget when it all changed and we now had paid for.
6:25:46 Okay, let me put this out. I don't know if I like this idea, but I'm I'm whiteboarding at this point.
6:25:52 If we did not recycle, could we use that 700,000 a year? which
6:25:59 would end up being what, $640,000 a year to pay down our debt on the wastewater
6:26:08 treatment plant and therefore reduce our utility fees to our customers.
6:26:13 This is this is sanitation enterprise fund. We can't pay for what happens.
6:26:19 Keep keep in mind though we would still have to probably use some of that 700,000 to pay for
6:26:26 sanitation anyway because then money volume is so whether we're picking it up as
6:26:34 recycling or picking it up as waste the only difference is the cost would diminish diminish yeah it would be so there would be a proportion of
6:26:41 savings but not the full 700 600,000 whatever I'm just trying to Scott correct me if I'm I can't I mean
6:26:50 I mean I'm curious what the people would think about a solution like that if they Well, I like recycling and granted
6:26:58 recycling has always been and I'm one of the ones that pushed the city to do recycling years ago because there was good money into it because I know when I was in the military we started recycling.
6:27:07 Yes.
6:27:08 In one year we we made so much money on the one base just off of paper products that we open up a whole recycle. I mean we made millions of dollars. We end up
6:27:17 buying trucks. One of the one of the downfalls of recycling nationwide is the single stream that was done as an effort
6:27:26 to encourage people to make it convenient to recycle. But the contamination probably became just pandemic
6:27:36 and now it's to the point where our recyclable materials in the United States really just
6:27:44 because we used to have we used to make money from other countries. they used to from using our recycle that's where it came from and then like you said it was
6:27:51 contaminated and so now we don't make the money I remember seeing the report on that wow really that's why I understand that's reason
6:27:59 why the way we collect recycle just throw everything in one container pretty much considered contaminated so they not
6:28:07 every some of the feedback I've gotten from citizens academy and we walk them
6:28:16 through what they're like about sanitation and recycling is that they're very thrilled we're recycling and lots of people are very pleased with that.
6:28:25 So, no I I still recycle at home but even though I like I I do separate mine
6:28:32 and keep it keep it uh trash and here recycle here. I'm very big on it. So, I was trained that way years ago.
6:28:43 So, if we want to If we want to reduce the utilities, we should be looking at the sewer
6:28:53 that the water treatments water
6:29:03 not storm water just 533 impact.
6:29:10 That's I guess it doesn't matter if it's the water coming.
6:29:16 Is there anything in there that's like recycling that I wouldn't necessarily think? Not that I'm aware of.
6:29:24 Well, meter replacements are% is there something there we could if we went with me replacements what
6:29:33 we're requesting in the upcoming budget is to increase that there still the old 450 meters that are in the system
6:29:41 in order to get those switched out and approximately three year time frame to get everything off of the old system. So
6:29:48 just to touch base on what that is for the old water meters, the old systems going obsolete and parts are getting
6:29:56 harder and harder to get a hold of. So in this budget we proposed a threeyear replacement program to get those out of
6:30:03 our system which resulted in that increase that you're seeing. Okay.
6:30:08 So we're having to reach out to other places that had the old R450 system to get part of that.
6:30:14 Well, and then we also have the meter replacements and meters for new customers.
6:30:25 Now, you you're saying we still got some old meters out there. That's not what they soal smart meters that we use.
6:30:33 They're smart meters, but they're on the old radio frequency.
6:30:37 The manufacturer no longer supports the old radio. Everything's moving towards the cellular side of things. So all of our new meters are cellular things.
6:30:47 Those old radio power because they're so old now, they don't support them anymore. So we have to reach out to other places that have that system. See
6:30:54 if we can purchase repair part for getting harder and harder to source those.
6:30:58 How many of them do we still have out there?
6:31:03 It's right around I believe somewhere still around,000 maybe slightly.
6:31:16 Okay. Are people outside,000 are people outside of the city paying their fair share of these actual
6:31:26 costs? And is there a way that we can
6:31:32 remedy that and and I'm not going to suffer everybody through what I'm doing here
6:31:40 today, but I do Jim and and Mark, what I'm looking at are all the items in the water fund that hundreds of thousands,
6:31:49 millions, over 50% increase. Is there anywhere in here that we can find? I haven't answered today, but I'm thinking
6:31:57 if we can come through with the utility rate reduction. So, if we can allocate this towards that plan, there's anything
6:32:06 that's been overbudgeted. You know, things that we're, you know, we can shave off, you know, 10% on $2 million
6:32:14 is a lot of money that we could put towards our debt service that we could then pass along to the citizens. You're going to know this way, way better than
6:32:21 I'm going to know this. Let's take a look. We've got again softwares and subscriptions in here almost 700,000. So
6:32:31 there might be something there just in the efficiency that you're working on that we could just if we could get an efficiency that lasts like that then
6:32:40 maybe we could pass that along to the customers.
6:32:46 I mean figure it out. Oh yes they are. Thank you.
6:32:53 Well, and I think philosophically it goes to the the approach of a council in the budgeting process
6:33:01 is the phil is the the philosophical approach of the council to say um this line this line this line this line
6:33:10 x dollars x dollars x dollars x dollars equals this is what we want cut. Or is the philosophical approach of the
6:33:18 council to say we want to see a savings of X amount? Yep.
6:33:24 Professional staff, city manager, work with your staff to save these accounts and report back to us how you plan to do that.
6:33:33 For me, it's the latter. And you know, because the the the kind of fault we might run into of of
6:33:41 looking at each of these lines is we don't know all of the details that go into those accounts.
6:33:47 Y and some of the ones that may look like a 50% increase really are, you know, based off a statutory I'm just, you
6:33:56 know, making up a thing here, but it's it could be a statutoal thing where we have to pay that. no choice to something that is only 20% but actually is an item
6:34:05 that we could adjust if we needed to adjust that.
6:34:10 You know, we have to maybe do 320s to get to that point.
6:34:13 Yeah. So I would rather see if we're if if we are entertaining an idea of we want to see a reduction of X amount that
6:34:22 we direct the city manager to work with staff to come up with that figure and then report back how they come up with
6:34:29 that figure rather than let's do 10 here, 12 here, five here. I agree.
6:34:36 Yeah. So for me the the two points that I would like to see and I'm curious how the rest of you feel is I would like to see a meaningful reduction in the utility costs.
6:34:46 I think we've heard citizens just say it was too much and I think it means a lot to the citizens but we can achieve that.
6:34:54 And then also anticipating this new plant down at Wellness Way. I don't mind
6:35:01 if it's paid for by debt service. That's not going to bother me. But if that debt service this then drives up the utility costs, then what is the point in us
6:35:09 reducing the utility cost? So, a meaningful plan for how we're going to pay for that that we can say to the public, hey, one,
6:35:17 we've saved you money on utilities and two, we're planning for even while saving money on
6:35:24 That's where that's what I'm coming from on this. And you're 100% right. I don't want to line item it. I don't care to line item it.
6:35:32 I don't want to learn what you don't know. No. No.
6:35:36 So I just want to say clean water and toilet also communicate the council's interest to our weight study consultant
6:35:45 as well because it's important for him to understand where it targets.
6:35:50 This is what our desire is. So we don't just run a program based on what you
6:35:56 typically do. This is what like to have results.
6:36:00 And the third element I would say for me is that I'm more concerned about Clermont residents than I am non Clermont when it comes to saving money
6:36:08 to the extent there's a legal issue there. That that's where I'm that's how I feel about it.
6:36:13 Well, I understand that too, but you got to be careful. I don't know where Mr. War in here.
6:36:20 Keep in mind state legislator is looking at some bills up there that's going to limit us how much we can charge
6:36:27 in extra territory, you know, so we may not be able to collect. Matter of fact, last I heard we
6:36:34 may they may be getting more as cheap as the residents if they're all going through what they talking about up in town right now.
6:36:42 We can't charge right now. We can charge non-residents that we service a little bit more money than what we charge res.
6:36:49 But with the bill they talk about passing that may not be true, which becomes a JPA issue. the countyy's colle,
6:37:02 right?
6:37:02 You know, well, but but I'll say it for for us on the council, I don't want to get too far
6:37:10 away from the budget process conversation, but we don't provide a utility unless this council approves a
6:37:18 utility agreement or annexes a property into the city. the JPA if if they're within the JPA.
6:37:26 No, we have the option. If it's outside, if it's outside the city, we have to do a utility. We have to pass
6:37:33 a utility agreement. This council has future councils, past councils have done it too. They have to pass a utility
6:37:40 agreement to provide a utility to a non city of Clermont property.
6:37:49 But our current JPA Yeah, I have an emergency and all I've got to go. I just want you out of that. Good luck.
6:37:57 So, but if we have capacity, JPA says we can't provide. Well, that's why I say it's a GPA.
6:38:05 Is that true? No, no, no. I've been through this.
6:38:12 We do not have to provide service and we challenged that a couple years ago. We came in, we started looking at that.
6:38:17 saying we would have to but we went back and reach out. It doesn't say we have to provide that service. If county approve
6:38:25 a service they come and ask for for service we can say no. Okay. And all that mean is they have to pro do it theirel. They can do it their own individual plan.
6:38:34 They can do their can't force us to provide service even if we have the capacity.
6:38:38 I thought we issued the letter and we had service. No.
6:38:42 If we issued a letter and we've committed. Yeah.
6:38:46 Yes. But that's not the staff. That's not a council issue.
6:38:50 That's that's an analysis. That's it comes to council. It come these projects have come to council several times since I've been here. And uh and
6:38:58 well, two, three years ago, uh we kind of looked at it and we started saying, "Hey, well, we we well, we don't like the project, so we're not going to
6:39:07 refuse the project. We going to refuse to give service." Right? And we refused to provide the service. Okay.
6:39:14 Uh perfect example was doesn't technically commit to providing them. The question asked is
6:39:22 do you have capacity to provide and and we will verify to their engineering groups we have the capacity to provide
6:39:32 but the decision to provide is made by the city council not by staff and maybe that's just a clarification we
6:39:39 can get from the city attorney on what the staff level yes we actually have capacity which is basically what
6:39:46 you're saying in that capacity letter I don't know if that's what it's called but for sake of this conversation. Um
6:39:53 and then the actual utility agreement is approved by the city council and that's when the city actually says yes we are
6:40:02 going to provide X to this to Y basically. Okay.
6:40:06 Well like I say I know we we denied a few projects we had the capacity and we said no. Of course, one of the perfect
6:40:14 ones is the one out there all H red the rental property out there when they first came to us. Uh we said no you
6:40:22 didn't want to provide by our ordinance and our rules. We won't provide you the service. They went back to county did everything but somehow we still provided
6:40:32 once they went through county we end up providing uh some kind of way they came back for but the bridge we we refused
6:40:39 apartment complex out there behind CarMax, AutoMax, whatever it is out there, uh, behind Publix and everything.
6:40:47 We use them the first time around. Okay.
6:40:51 We had the capacity, but we said no until unless they would beat some of our guidelines. And once they did that, we came back and did service.
6:41:01 We we were kind of like losing that at one point for leverage. Yeah, we definitely need clarification.
6:41:07 That was not my understanding. My understanding was if it's in the JPA area and we have capacity that we have
6:41:14 to provide it or all we're doing is open ourselves up to a lawsuit we're going to lose. I don't mind a lawsuit but I don't
6:41:22 I'm not into just causing lawsuits for the sake of but that is not my understanding.
6:41:29 You also have when it comes to the agreements utility providers the first right of
6:41:35 so if we refuse to serve that or ultimately giving up over and allowing another utility
6:41:43 sunshine service that they can be build their own plant. They can go do it themselves. Yeah.
6:41:50 Just so is that where Sunshine came in? They just it's a separate entity, right?
6:41:56 And it's like a private entity. So they just decided to open up their own water treatment.
6:42:00 There were service boundaries established back in the day.
6:42:03 So now they're servicing Clermont uninccorporated residences. Is that correct? They are.
6:42:09 Is there like a boundary line where there is there's a map that identifies a service area?
6:42:13 So they can't they can't come in. So not unless we refuse to service the pro the project or there's some agreement
6:42:20 between the two basically but we tried to buy them all this way. We don't have to build
6:42:29 they must have their own water and what is their capacity? You know I don't know. They can just build a new one.
6:42:37 They originated out of the four corners area. I think they got two or three trending plants in the four corners area. Our boundary line stop right there.
6:42:46 And there's two separate utilities.
6:42:48 There's sunshine and then there's very small limited one that basically serves Kagan's crossing.
6:42:56 Cross has cag built it own.
6:42:59 Yes. They were the original back at 927 back in the day. Do you know how our rates compare to those two?
6:43:08 We are cheap cheaper. I live in the sunshine for a fact. They raise my rates every single year.
6:43:17 They've been they do it years ago. Uh I know we're not the post office anyway. Sunshine was cheaper than
6:43:25 us, but they've been raising our we kept our rates steady. They kept rising.
6:43:28 Their rates are not any more expensive than we are. All right. Well, that was fun.
6:43:34 Yeah. And I believe there are city residents who have sunshine water. Yes.
6:43:41 Legends I believe is one community where have they have sunshine water and city of Clermont sewer. Yes.
6:43:49 Oh yes. Yes. Oh yes. Yes. So it's not just uninorporated.
6:43:53 So that's what I mean. You can you can refuse this and once we refuse it like when legend came in I understand of course I was around but I understand
6:44:01 when they came in we kind of like refused cuz we really didn't have service all the way down there was right next door they just came in to pick it up.
6:44:09 Well it's my understanding Christian is watching so that I can catch him up real quick. I thought Christian that if a
6:44:17 property was in the JPA that we had to approve it if we had capacity for utilities and there's a question on
6:44:25 whether we have to obviously we could say no I'm not trying to initiate an unnecessary lawsuit the question is does
6:44:32 our JPA say if a property is in the JPA and we have capacity does the JBA require us to provide the utility so we
6:44:40 would like an answer to that question I'm speaking to the ether because I don't know which might be on there. Yes, Christian.
6:44:51 So, he's watching. So, that's what the discussion he's watching. He's watching.
6:44:56 So, so now he knows what the discussion was.
6:45:00 But yes, I would love to get an answer on that and then it'll help us. But I still we have heard this loud and clear I
6:45:07 think from the people that if we if we can lower it that's what it was like but I don't want to do that if I know I'm staring down the barrel of debt service
6:45:15 that's going to just raise it right back up in two years. That that seems um I'd rather just do it all at once to keep
6:45:22 continuity than have the customers go up and down.
6:45:27 This is one of the things I would love to see a reduction in utility because as you me I've been fussing for a while now
6:45:34 about my irrigation where I'm paying for irrigation that I don't even use every month. I use zero gallon of irrigation,
6:45:41 but I still got to pay 9 $10 a month for zero. I'm like, why is that administration?
6:45:49 But then I sit down and I think about the other even when I use irrigation, I'm paying more for irrigation irrigation uh water
6:45:58 to irrigate with than I am for regular water. Where did you get the Christmas card from this area?
6:46:05 Well, when I th000 gallons of regular potable water going through my house is only five something a gallon, but they
6:46:13 end up paying nine or so a thousand gallons on on irrigation.
6:46:18 Well, and I'm okay with that to be honest. the higher for irrigation. I mean just philosophically my concern so
6:46:25 I'm clarifying is for the water that people are drinking cooking the you know what's in their home potable water I am
6:46:33 more concerned about what's used inside the home than I necessarily am outside the home uh I think there are a lot of
6:46:40 things people can do with their yards to make them more drought resistant Florida friendly and so there's some of that in
6:46:47 our control as property owners whereas what comes out of my tap is that's dirty I'm sick. There's not I mean there are
6:46:54 things we can do but they're not practicing 2020.
6:46:57 Well, I I I I did some of them things. I took my skinny grass and put it back.
6:47:04 That's why I don't ever much. But yet still I'm still paying all this money, you know. So I'm saying, okay, who else
6:47:11 is doing this kind of thing? I had a couple people come to me then say they got rid of it. They finally got rid of it. But St. Augustine put that up. Okay,
6:47:19 let's see what kind of s you get. Yeah, this will be my shameless plug for perennial peanut and sunshine mimosa and I'll leave it there.
6:47:27 I I I hear the people complain. I see it. I even felt it myself when I look at my irri my my utility bill in the last
6:47:35 year. So, it's almost done everything where $60 a month $100 a month.
6:47:44 Like I said, bless.
6:47:48 So, I I can hear the people Can we talk about roads briefly? Yes.
6:47:56 I noticed in roads significant reduction in expenditures. I think it was that one.
6:48:03 I saw the piece that you were looking at.
6:48:10 I just want to make sure that I know you all have a plan and we can talk about east.
6:48:25 Are we talking about in the capital plan? It's infrastructure fund. Okay.
6:48:31 Okay. So, page 77 which is behind my services tab streets
6:48:39 about 541 we went from 3 million to 2.1 million and again I'm okay saving money I just
6:48:48 want to make sure that our streets are on a plan that you feel comfortable no my um my overall request in the
6:48:56 infrastructure fund um everything that we've got for roads sidewalks trails
6:49:03 everything amounts to 3.5 million is what's requested. That's what's reflected on page 138 if you go to the
6:49:12 infrastructure fund summary. So my numbers match. So I'm seeing um and
6:49:21 maybe Scott this could be like you described the parks and w if you look at page 77 77 you said yes
6:49:29 and then page 79 we can see on 77 the top graph capital
6:49:36 outlay this year 26 is 3.05 million and then f27 2.125 if you go to page 79
6:49:44 middle of the page um 66304 We're going from 2.386 to 1.2.
6:49:53 This could be just the funds.
6:49:59 Oh, okay. There you go. There you go. Okay. So, thank you, K. Appreciate that.
6:50:07 There. Here's your answer. What you see in streets is only streets. I've got
6:50:14 $1.4 million in a street. SL drainage project that's coming out of infrastructure that matches the $3.5
6:50:23 million request that's in a separate area in drainage.
6:50:27 So we see the 2.125 is under this is general fund and then there's
6:50:34 additional 1.2 under the infrastructure fund.
6:50:37 Yeah, it's actually 1.4. So if you run the two together, you come up with
6:50:45 structure compared to apples. Last year it was 6 million and this year
6:50:52 last year it was all budgeted under street. This year we moved out. Okay.
6:51:01 Split things.
6:51:02 Okay. Got it. I just want to make sure you have what you and what are the next streets now that we've done east Houston Lakeshore how do we stay at that level you want to stay
6:51:11 part of the infrastructure fund first thing we're going to do October 2nd is bring our consultant in to re-evaluate
6:51:20 all the streets we have because we are now at year six we should have done it year five we're at year six so I'm
6:51:27 anxious to get the new evaluation that can be generally 60 days from that I'll build our new
6:51:36 program. I've got an idea of where I'm going, but that might change based on evaluation. There's some roads that I
6:51:44 believe I've seen rattling and need to resurface block right by Pit Street is one of them. Pit Street itself is
6:51:51 another one that's starting to show some signs need some repair. And then of
6:51:58 course our program is is a lot of pavement ation which uses recommite
6:52:04 which I applied to all roads that we just recently resurfaced to continue process preserving them. So once every
6:52:13 five years for pennies on the dollar treat and that keeps the asphalt in it
6:52:21 pristine condition if you would how much is that study cost that evaluation uh that's going to be about $80,000 I I
6:52:30 earmarked 100,000 So we do that once every five to six years. So I want to say it back to you here.
6:52:36 Hearing you say the last study you did said that east and lakes shore were the last two in order for us to be consistent. We have now done those
6:52:44 and we now need direction on the next fiveyear plan and to be accurate. Yes.
6:52:50 And it would take 60 days to get that direction. And if it's not already in our budget, is there a reason why we wouldn't go ahead and do that now so
6:52:59 that before we get to our fiscal year 27 budget, we know what the five-year plan should be in case we're off on our plan.
6:53:12 Extra fund from speech system. I know that's how it's a possibility to be
6:53:19 the last time I evaluated infrastructure about a month ago was still to the good about $200,000.
6:53:27 So I've got I've got change order coming up for the plane that I want to make sure I understand what that cost is going to be.
6:53:36 And paving is now just finishing up. I think they finished up a patch at the bark that we want done. off road paving
6:53:43 work, microsurfacing money, all of that is now finished. So, we probably have money left to be able to do this.
6:53:53 Yeah. With the money level right now.
6:53:56 And once we get the black on East Avenue, right? If we got 80,000, why don't we I mean, if it's
6:54:05 That's a good question, Scott. If we can do it now, it lets us not get the answer in December because we're working on what the priorities are.
6:54:15 I I rather he say you only got 200,000.
6:54:18 Let's see how much the back's going to cost us first.
6:54:21 Yeah. I want to make sure that I've got my current expenses covered, but anticipating I'm going to have a little
6:54:28 I think the back on each got everything. So,
6:54:37 I think of what you you saying new part but that's going to cost yeah I mean it's it it wasn't part of
6:54:44 the original contract replacing the existing pavement markings was so actually meeting with contractor
6:54:51 Thursday morning to hand walk them through even though we provided the diagram there's still still tensivity and confusion about the
6:55:00 dimensioning because it's going to be tight but it can work if we if we get lucky We have extra money left over there.
6:55:08 What you say? 80,000 for the study. 80,000. We can get the bike right there for 120.
6:55:15 Uh even if it's a little bit more I mean we got a little extra money.
6:55:21 I think having the information before we make a decision. Agreed.
6:55:27 Yeah. because then I can, you know, once once that plan is put together, I can bring it back to council and kind of give me a five, six year program instead of where we're going.
6:55:39 Is he going to need a budget amendment to do this because it's over 50,000?
6:55:56 come back transfer to professional services because
6:56:08 they still have to bring it back to council because it's over 50,000 Gee, you're making easy.
6:56:19 Who doesn't? How many layers of that?
6:56:24 You printed the drainage that Yes, sir. Yes, sir. Yes. There's a right
6:56:31 at Penzansen Fifth. We have had historically a bit of a drainage problem.
6:56:38 still draining into the lake and everything uh draining into the neighbor's home
6:56:45 over the top of the curb under torrential rainfall efforts, but still um it's easy enough to go ahead and just
6:56:53 extend the line up and bring in another catch basin that has the capability capture the volume that necessitates
6:57:01 increasing the size of the line all the way down. We also have problem two problems right at the intersection of
6:57:07 fence ants and lake shore where the charging water is blowing the sewer caps
6:57:15 off it becomes so intense. So we eliminate that problem by increasing the size of the store line and then we'll
6:57:23 drop in a bath box water quality at which point we'll probably
6:57:31 while I'm thinking about it. Can you have some if you don't mind looking at Drew Avenue? True.
6:57:37 No way. We got the drain over there. I passed that uh yesterday day before yesterday it was the drain was covered with leaves.
6:57:46 Yes. So, you know, we have to keep an eye on over there. They tend to wash down all the time over there on plug people out sometime.
6:57:54 I'll make sure they get out and do that. That's what a storm waters after.
6:57:58 I'm sorry. I passed there Sunday and that's what I meant to tell Mr.
6:58:12 What else? Mr.
6:58:26 He said the answer to Alison's comment was no. JPA does not require it. Right.
6:58:35 A few times already.
6:58:38 So I mean we sat down two three years ago and went through it and the first time the lawyers and
6:58:47 Mr. B came to me. I said sure I went and tried and it worked.
6:58:55 We refueling the service, but that led them to have to go out and buy their own bill and everything, but I
6:59:04 mean spend the money for that to the table.
6:59:10 All right. Anything else? Almost 4:00.
6:59:16 Um, so again in the morning at Mr. B, you say 8:30, Mr. Uh, Congressman
6:59:23 at 8:30 and then we'll start with economic development at 9:00.
6:59:29 I cannot commit to being here at 8:30, but I will shoot for it. I'll be here by I think he's he's coming to present us a check as well.
6:59:37 I mean, that's nice. For what? M. What is it?
6:59:47 750 750. It's a greatbody.
7:00:00 We don't It's earmarked as a storm.
7:00:07 But I have no recollection bridges across 25.
7:00:12 I think it's the parameters or something. Storm water.
7:00:18 I mean, I think there's a real storm water issue crossing 27 Saturday.
7:00:24 It's bad. It's water's running and everything.
7:00:29 Nothing else. I see everybody if you can at 8:30 in the morning. I don't know.
7:01:50 Heat. Heat.
7:02:13 Heat. Heat.
0:12 Hey.
0:29 Heat. Heat.
1:12 Heat. Hey. Hey. Hey.
1:47 Heat. Heat.
2:21 Oh yeah.
3:16 Hey, hey, hey.
5:27 Hey, hey.
5:40 Heat. Heat.
6:57 Heat.
7:16 Heat.
7:33 Heat. Heat. Heat. Heat. N.
8:18 be Come
8:44 on.
9:41 feel. Hey
10:30 Heat. Heat.
11:28 Heat. Heat.
12:35 Heat. Heat.
13:55 break.
13:57 A Heat
14:20 up
15:56 In that case, we'll go ahead. Wayne, you're ready? Yes, sir.
16:04 All right, we go ahead call the workshop to order. And if we don't mind, Mr. Wagner, will you offer us a prayer this morning, please, sir?
16:14 Sure.
16:17 Father, thank you for another day. Thank you for all our blessings. I pray your blessing on our meeting today. I pray
16:24 you give us wisdom. You lead us and guide us. Uh give our council and our staff wisdom today in every decision and
16:31 all of our communication. And I ask for your continued blessing on our city.
16:35 Thank you for all you've done and all the things you'll continue to do. We pray in Jesus name. Amen.
16:41 Thank you. And as usual, workshops are for information and gathering and discussion purpose only. We excuse me, we will not be voting on anything today.
16:51 Okay. Uh that being said, I don't know who all we have left here, but hopefully I think we scheduled to be out of here
16:58 what 5:00 today about 5. Well, we'll see how it goes. Okay. That being said, I turn over you.
17:06 All right. Well, thank you. We we got through our big departments yesterday and with the larger budget. So today
17:13 we'll continue to talk and hopefully finish with the rest of the departments today. And I'd like to start with Nathan
17:20 Norris, our economic development director.
17:23 And recently, just so you all know, Nathan Kurt and I spoke and we felt like Nathan
17:31 would be a good candidate to be our CRA director. So Nathan graciously accepted that role. So uh he's speaking in that
17:40 role now, too. and Kurt and I are very happy to have him coming along and being a support and lead leading that. So, uh,
17:48 with that, I'll let Nathan go ahead and direct us in this conversation for his department.
17:54 Great. So, going from the biggest to the smallest.
17:57 I didn't say that, but can we go to the next slide?
18:05 Um so just looking at this past year uh the broad focus has been on the big investments the council's made in the
18:12 future of the community through the um comprehensive plan to form based code.
18:18 Um we've done uh we've worked with numerous folks on on development issues and we focus a lot of our time on what
18:27 we're calling just internally Clermont business plan. That's essentially what are we going to do coming out of this comp plan effort. Um you know we're sort
18:37 of at a historic moment um for Clermont where we've grown from growing citrus to growing subdivisions and we've got to
18:45 sort of look what is the next frontier for the community and we've heard lots of uh things from the community. So most of the the time has actually been spent
18:54 listening to different leaders and citizens in the community and listening to the council as well. Uh you know sort
19:03 of seeing uh where are the the key issues that we need to address. Those issues as you know are the ones that you get complaints about on a regular basis.
19:13 You know we've got traffic issues. Um we've got uh and how we can get around.
19:20 We've got um development controversies that arise on a regular basis and then we have the issues of okay well what is
19:28 going to be the the platform for creating prosperity uh going forward. So uh the specific initiatives have been
19:36 listening to people setting up interviews doing the pre-shre as well as now post shared outreach with comp plan
19:44 forbased code. Um and there's other things on here like Clermont creates such a a role where I'm merely
19:51 facilitating uh private actors improving our community in that case engaging the artist community to participate in our
20:00 efforts. Um and and you can go on and on about that. Next slide please.
20:06 So this is the uh personnel chart for the department. Uh we had originally had
20:13 an urban designer. Um and what we determined through what we did this year was that we could more uh we could be
20:22 more economically um fiscally responsible by essentially outsourcing keyh
20:45 on the focus to focus on things we focused this past year plus on the formally the development and design
20:52 center the downtown master plan. So really the big thing you know we know what the downtown master plan is. I wanted to be able to show what the
20:59 development center is about as it regards the specific initiatives one of the most important ones that uh has already been started by a private group
21:08 in town is the greenways network. Um as we try to deal with traffic uh we focused on well how can we keep people
21:16 from having to become traffic and then how can we uh keep people from experiencing traffic and one of the ways is just make it
21:24 easier to get around uh without getting on 50 or 27. So that's what really the greenways network is and we really appreciate Jim Mayw's contributions to that.
21:36 He's been hosting uh the committee and we're making progress there. Um but the other elements are things that are really associated with comp plan whether
21:45 it's how to leverage the educational ecosystem that we have today. you know, we no longer in a world where it's just
21:52 a public school uh uh model for how we grow entrepreneurs and workers for the future workforce here. So getting
22:00 involved with that is important. Um and but uh really I think that the thing I do want to talk about not everybody has
22:08 seen is the development of science. Can you go to the next slide? The basic idea development design center serves as a
22:15 concierge essentially for good development. You know, one of the the principal goals coming out of the the all the planning that's been done this
22:23 year is let's make it easier for developers to do what we really want to see or do good develop but what we believe is good. And one of the ways to
22:31 get good development is to preempt bad development. So the idea is to go and work with different land owners and
22:39 developers um with them as they they come up with their concepts. And so this is what the majority of our uh Our
22:48 budget for outsourced services on design is all
22:55 about is providing these these design steps. Now the this is coming up with concepts for how they can develop their site coming up with a schematic site
23:04 plans how the buildings might lay out working on floor plans doing elevations and then creating the eye candy. The eye
23:11 candy is something that uh you will be able to see so we can better understand it. It's photorealistic visualizations that are the eye candy that can matter.
23:20 That's that's in other words, it's not just artistry that gets people to believe the project's going to be better than it really is. It's actually coming
23:27 up with a specific visualization that's realistic. Next slide. So, we did one just for the buildings that are directly
23:34 across from city hall across the street here. We said, okay, well, let's do an aerial here so we can show existing conditions. The next slide
23:43 just shows what if we were able to build additional buildings on those sites and so in order to help create a sense of
23:52 enclosure on our main street of Montre which is our most important street. Next slide please. And so this was where we
23:59 took a photo of what it looks like and we said well what if we can show people what it could be and then that could encourage uh the development to happen.
24:08 So go to the next slide please. Right.
24:10 So that's just what happens when you put the buildings all of a sudden you can start to feel it feels more like a downtown as opposed to suburban place
24:17 where just you could add buildings here again. Um and then you go to the next
24:24 stage you start talking. Next slide please. Um you can start to see how you can provide shade. Next slide please. Uh
24:32 then you can make it fancier if you want. Keep going. Just giving people options. These were called the Montro
24:39 twins uh uh by someone we know and so we thought what if they're just fraternal twins and so we went next slide please
24:48 and you know we can imagine different things and then that becomes Claire and Monty the two
24:55 twins but the idea is to give people ideas on how they can develop the property in a way that serves as an amenity or brings positive value to our
25:05 existing residents which I I think that's a really important way to judge development we bring into the community is is it um you know are we going to
25:13 make it easier to develop places that bring value to existing residents and that's an example where um if we looked at a long-term evolution of the downtown
25:22 right now that this block that we're on sort of is where people stop walking as part of the downtown and the reason is
25:30 there's there's not a sense of enclosure we put this all of a sudden we might get something a better redevelopment next point where you're at Lake and Montro
25:39 and and and that you know that could really be something. Uh we're also working with uh uh like I said owners right now through the comp plan and the
25:48 downtown master plan on specific site plans but next year we'll also have issues that pop up because you know we have a lot of issues pop up regularly
25:57 and people are saying what do we do about this and uh that's essentially where my budget's focused is where we can work through the continuing services
26:04 agreement um on uh with the designers to to come up with this information that makes it easier for our staff to deal
26:12 with the development community as well as the planning and zoning commission and ultimately the council to make informed decisions about what's poss
26:20 So next slide this just you know show you know we can do the floor plan so it
26:27 becomes even more next slide and that's a just a different story. Go to the next slide and so that's that
26:36 there are no capital propos the things that we need to get accomplished will be done through other
26:43 departments and this is just a summary of it. Now, this is a little skewed uh in the fact that we didn't have an
26:50 economic development department essentially um previously that was uh staffed. Um and so we had to borrow from
27:00 different department to get through this year. But ultimately what we're proposing for this year is that $545,000
27:10 which reflects personnel cost plus the operating 339
27:17 160,000 of that is directly for the design assistance that comes through the development design center. The rest of
27:26 it is miscellaneous consulting fees for things that we're already paying. For example, we pay wellness way consulting
27:33 fees every year. We pay for lobbying fees in Tallahassee. That's going through the economic health department.
27:39 So that's why there's a difference between technically it's $285,000.
27:45 consulting fees that are in the department. 160 is for the design stuff.
27:49 The other is 47 questions.
27:57 I got one question on personnel cost there. Is that for one or two people? That is for what?
28:06 6,000.
28:12 So last year this position or these positions were funded from the city manager department.
28:20 Can we first I think it would be helpful if the
28:28 fiscal year 26 budget showed what actually was either spent so we had an actual report
28:36 so that we can see apples to apples what was in you know what was dedicated to this last year.
28:44 I think we have I think our staffing personnel has actually gone down. Yes, we had two now we have one.
28:52 Right. Uh and then I don't hear a lot of exciting things
28:59 from the people that live in Wellness Way about the service that they're getting from their consultant that they have who's been our economic development
29:08 person in Wellness Way. So I'm questioning if the times start cutting.
29:14 I think that what you showed us as an example is going to be more helpful.
29:20 Like if we think about that 7-Eleven application that came to us done in wellness way, I think the residents would have benefited and I think the property owner
29:29 would have benefited from us being able to say, "Hey, here's what could go on this corner." And to engage with the
29:36 public to figure out the type of building they're looking for.
29:40 Because I think the real issue there wasn't I don't interpret the real issue being we're using cars. We're filling up a gas
29:48 station. I think the real issue was I don't want my kids to be driving by a gas station. I don't want cars to be coming into my neighborhood. And so I
29:57 think this is again we've asked for innovative solutions and this is one.
30:01 Um, but I question if the money that we're currently spending on the wellness way consultant, which I
30:09 believe is that 117 to 148 to 154, is actually helping the community. Whereas
30:17 if the same 100, if 160 is what we need for the development design center, could that help with wellness, for example?
30:26 Oh, absolutely. So, I'm sure there's other issues involving the county, but since we had this position, we've added
30:33 Mr. Van Wagner and Mr. Matis, and I think they're both very competent and capable. Um, so
30:41 I'd like to be comparing apples to apples on what we did last year. Um, and then I also remember us being in these
30:50 meetings and having a conversation about the economic development director being a an arm of this council, which is why
30:59 we put it in the city manager's department. So, I'm questioning why we're creating another layer and separating this position from the city manager's direct report.
31:10 Yeah, we and we can we can run you the numbers of what was spent last year. I think the position came on it was remember it was the beginning of the
31:18 fiscal year sometime into it. So when council authorized it, they didn't really give us a budget. They just said bring bring on an economic development.
31:26 They didn't give us like the day operating budget. So we were absorbing those in city manager's office, but we can get what was actually spent on this position last year.
31:37 Yeah, I'd have to go back and look because I thought we put in the budget, Scott, wasn't there a position for economic development director budget last year? There was but I'm saying that
31:46 you gave us the position that you authorized the position but it wasn't like support. It's just so we didn't fund it.
31:53 We did fund we did fund the position. Yes.
31:56 So we gave a position and funded it under the city manager's office. Correct. Correct.
32:00 Right. So I'm questioning why we're creating a new department.
32:03 Uh the department was potential growth at one point we because we had two people in the department. We had an
32:09 urban designer as well. Um, and so we thought that it would be a department of its own to create ultimate growth over
32:17 time, but at this point we're not adding we're not only we're not adding an additional one that was requested, but we're
32:26 urban designer is no longer with us and we're using that right now to help fund the consultants to help out with the
32:35 design studio which I think is great. I'm fine with consultants, but I don't know if I'm not I don't think I'm asking the question right.
32:41 The organizational chart originally had the economic development director reporting to the city manager in the city manager's office.
32:49 Now, it's a department, which changes the hierarchy, and and I'm I'm probably going to have the same question about the
32:57 communications department that I'm seeing in the budget. Okay, we originally said communications is our voice,
33:05 not staff's voice, the voice of this council to communicate to the public, which is why we wanted it directly under
33:13 the city manager last year. We might have changed our minds say I don't think I I don't know that I was ever a part of that conversation.
33:18 No, you weren't. This was during last year, the budget workshops.
33:22 So, the idea then when we approved this original position and the communications was that those would be under the city manager because We direct the city manager.
33:33 Well, we just created the communications position just this year.
33:36 Yeah. Well, that was not a last year.
33:38 The pio was Well, the but the PIO was always there.
33:41 That was not a position that was created last year, but it was under the city manager under the city broken out to the department.
33:47 Well, we don't have a PIO anymore. We're not proposing as a PIO. I I guess I I hear what you're asking, but I take a different viewpoint in the sense that
33:56 all directors report directly to the city manager. So whether that director is in the office or in their own office
34:04 in the org chart, they still directly report to the city manager. It doesn't change how we interact because our
34:14 interactions go directly through the city manager to the staff then the the city manager to the staff. So whether that's in the third floor office suite
34:22 or somewhere else in the building, I guess I don't see. So help me understand. if there's a concern why it
34:31 needs to be within the city manager office versus its own office, why that
34:38 piece of it is a concern if the reporting doesn't change either way.
34:44 Well, well, I don't think she's saying it has to be in the city manager's office. I think I was agree with agree with they can still be under the city
34:52 manager, but we create new departments. See, rather than keeping the position unirectly, we
34:59 don't need a department, another department head is what she's saying.
35:04 Okay. You know, you eliminated you eliminated the PIO department, but now you're committing a whole communication department department. Right. we used to have.
35:12 So the concern isn't that it's that it's it's not about where the reporting line is because the reporting line isn't changing.
35:20 It's a philosophical issue of creating a department even though the position still directly
35:30 reports to the city manager. Is that concern? Okay.
35:33 Well, and then related to that, and correct me if I'm wrong, but I think the org chart has some department heads reporting to the deputy city manager.
35:40 They're all reporting to the city manager direct reports to you.
35:43 Okay. So that takes care of that concern. But that become the wider we get spread with department different departments and department budgets. It's
35:51 kind of like the same issue that I brought up yesterday about the arts and recreation.
35:55 You know we've got some pieces of this function are in public works some pieces are in arts and recreation. Some are of the historic village and we don't know
36:02 who's reporting to that. And it's like I am concerned about the structure.
36:08 So that's why So there's kind of two questions I've had related to the department. One is the the effectiveness of if we're saying
36:17 Scott, can you tell me what the budget was last year that we spent on those two positions for economic development? It had to have been what $300,000.
36:27 So Alison, you feel like it's too many moving pieces.
36:30 Well, I feel like it's a lot of moving pieces, but and so yes. So there's the structural and then on the budget side, if we were around 300,000 last year for plus the operating that's 454.
36:43 So we're talking about 90,000 more. And I'm questioning if the existing consultant for wellness way is
36:51 appropriately being paid 154 or if we look back at the last several years, could we keep the amount we've been spending the same by reducing the amount
37:00 of time that that the wellness way consultant is working and leveraging the advantages of this development design center? Well, we just this council just
37:08 approved the the contract with the wellness way consultant.
37:12 Yeah, but I I don't think it say that we just we just approved it like within the last three months or so.
37:20 Was it 154,000?
37:21 No, no, I don't think it was that because we we're not directly responsible for the consultant. We actually pay
37:28 we pay the county we pay the county we get the county part of the money and I think was only like 30 or $40,000
37:36 that part is split. So what's the 154 form way? Oh is that also it's not just way
37:43 yeah and don't hold me to but I I think and I would just say I think the bonus way amount was 75,000
37:51 and there's 35,000 if not mistaken for the the 45 45 45
37:59 So where's the rest of So Gray Robinson is included with that for 50.
38:06 We have an interlocal agreement for 70. Okay.
38:09 That 35 of that is reimbursed back from the county. From the county. Yeah.
38:14 Yeah. That's that's the one we just approved to get the county and it's 35 and then way Robinson 50. But it's not all dedicated to just Wellness Way,
38:23 right? It's for the city. And the other thing we were just talking about, there's always been an economic development department.
38:31 They've had that for years, but we just put it in my budget previously, but they've had that separate. They were
38:38 just telling me. So that that's where so it's not all like brand new. So I for I didn't know
38:47 we had economic development. I always say we didn't have one though. Well, Jim used to be it years ago, too. Yeah.
38:55 What is that?
38:56 Um, but then still on your personnel, you you so you eliminate the urban design because you still your personnel uh sheet here still saying it's two people.
39:06 Do you have an agreement with the continued services when there's a project for design? That's my understanding how we're doing that.
39:14 No, the mayor's looking I believe at the documents.
39:16 I'm not looking. That's why I asked how much uh was it okay and personnel cost the 206 for one or two people because I
39:25 heard him say it's just him and no longer urban designer but his sheet showing he still got an urban designer there two people are you bring updated that
39:34 that's a mistake oh okay yeah I was going to say I think that page 95 should be the urban designer FT
39:42 should be eliminated and um it basically is a reduction of one FTE for the for the city.
39:50 Well, and we didn't have one in 2025, right?
39:54 So, uh, council member Strange, you just asked me what I was looking at here.
39:57 This is a I had made a request um I think end of like I think everybody got this.
40:05 It was a um list of everybody in every department and their where they're at salary wise and when they were hired.
40:14 Um, and the economic development director and the urban designer were both hired back in October of 2025
40:22 and the the we had $250,000 in the salaries for that. But that does not include benefits.
40:29 Okay. So now it's 156 and now it's 156. So it it is a reduction from where
40:36 this document from HR and finance reduction in salary and reduction.
40:41 Yeah, it's a reduction. Yeah, it's a reduction. We just We just for it sounds like the FTE elimination was fairly
40:48 recent maybe post or kind of during printing, right?
40:52 So really page 95 we just need to reduce the FTE from 2 to one.
40:58 Okay. So last year for economic development then to compare apples to apples we spent 479
41:09 and the request is to go to 545. That's the Am I now preparing those stats?
41:16 I think so. Without looking at all that data, I think I think it's roughly within kind of in line kind of in line with the other increases we're seeing.
41:24 Yeah. For the most part in other departments. Okay.
41:30 Okay. I think my questions are answered.
41:36 I can say one more thing. There have been various expenses expenses that been covered by other departments this year
41:44 simply because there was no budget for a pencil or anything else up. So I mean
41:51 we're still in general ballpark but I see. Okay.
41:57 I think there may Yeah. And I think there has to be some difference or should be some difference on us as the council whether it's a new
42:07 person within city manager's office or a new department that that first year or two we're going to have some of that
42:14 maybe uh fuzziness that we may not have as an established department like the police or fire that have been in
42:21 existence for quite some time. Um no I agree. I just felt like it didn't have a No, I agree. We don't the the comparison
42:28 really isn't there because it wasn't technically funded last fiscal year. It was funded not as a as an individual department, but it was funded elsewhere.
42:38 We just didn't see that here.
42:40 Um I I have a question with regard to um kind of the design center and economic
42:47 development it as a whole. Um and I know Mr. Mr. Norris, you you have some really unique background given your experience
42:55 in working with governments, but also through education and through uh the uh
43:01 military service. Um with there's conversation out there where communities
43:08 have economic development directors and departments, they have community development directors and departments.
43:18 And then there are some that that join them and say that this is our our office of economic and community development or
43:25 this is our director of of community and economic development.
43:29 Philosophically, do you have a a thought on that and what is there a difference between those two verbiages community development, economic development?
43:40 There can be. It depends upon what you view is the the purpose of economic development. It's generally fairly
43:47 fuzzy, but in the economic development world, you know, most of the the focus is on big game hunting of how can we
43:55 bring in out of town corporation to our comp to our town. There's also workforce development efforts that fall under um
44:04 economic development. And that's where, you know, and then they'll say we want to uh you know, we want to go ahead and retain our our best and our brightest.
44:13 And so those are and essentially lead does that uh locally and trying to look in those three different directions. Um
44:21 for how I've sort of set out the economic development department here is to be very very focused on how we can as
44:30 you've heard me talk about achieve our goal and our goal that we've heard people support is this idea of creating
44:37 a place where our children and our grandchildren can stay and prosper.
44:42 Okay, most economic developers don't even they don't even think of a goal.
44:46 They just get rewarded by how much capital investment is made, how many jobs are done, and it's just a numbers game. Okay? But a more thoughtful
44:54 approach from my perspective is no, let's look at the long-term scenario.
44:57 And in our case, just going through this comprehensive plan this year, we we've uh seen something that's pretty important, which is, you know, we we called it the frozen asset map. Okay?
45:08 And essentially, it was saying, look, after we we stopped the citrus industry mostly, we switch to real estate development and we're running out of land.
45:17 Okay. And the land that we've developed fully now we're at 80 over 80% of the land in Clermont is not easily redevelopment going into the future.
45:27 Whereas it was only 12% when we started back in the mid 90s. And so that means that from an economic development standpoint, if we want to prosper, we've
45:34 got to be thinking about what is our next thing. Okay? Our next thing as we've talked about is our opportunity to create a both a diversified and
45:42 independent economy. Okay, independent in that right now we know Lake County, what 70% of 70% of people who live in
45:50 Lake County actually don't even work in Lake County, right?
45:52 Okay, that's that's shock that's not super promising for for our future if we're always going to say, "Yeah, we'll
46:00 just be a bedroom community." Not that there's anything wrong with it. It just can't be sustained for us. So the question is, what do we switch to? We've
46:07 had those conversations about well actually we should shift uh to one that we have more control where we have more
46:14 people working locally um and that actually would also potentially decrease traffic which is complaint but then
46:22 we've got to figure out what our focus is and as as you all have heard you know uh a lot of people have embraced this you know wellness concept that we've
46:30 been calling healthy living is a focus for an economy um whichally we can compete very well on that on that um you
46:40 know on that platform. So the idea is how do we grow those entrepreneurs and right now we have a huge advantage compared to the rest of the United States in how we educate our children.
46:50 We have more freedom in Florida than we do uh than they they do in most states.
46:54 It's at the forefront. I I was at a conference just a couple of weeks ago where they were simply amazed at the amount of things that can be done
47:02 educationally here. Um that becomes part of the discussion. So that that would normally be a community
47:09 development concept as well as how we grow. But actually at our core when we look at if if our goals to create the
47:17 place where kids and grandkids can stay and prosper. Our two main things are how we grow maintain our quality of life
47:25 which is right now we're in a very desirable place. Everybody wants to right. Um but the second thing is um how do we grow that local economy that's
47:34 diversified and more independent than what we've been in the past? And I I I I think that um
47:42 that's the most important thing that can be done is facilitate all the things that fall into supporting her. That to me is the economic development that
47:50 Clermont needs moving forward to be effective. Not whether or not we get the latest company that comes here. Uh that
47:58 not that's not important, but that's being handled by other entities or the idea that we need assistance for people who are starting businesses. We already
48:07 have resources in this region that are tackling that. Thank you for that. Um, I have one more question for you and then maybe one for the city manager.
48:17 And I I don't mean this to be a I guess a direct question, but I don't know how to ask this question without being
48:24 direct. I guess when when we at the end of Octo or in October 25
48:33 we the this the city decided to hire a director and an urban designer. At some point in the last
48:40 15 16 months we've now said okay we don't need that urban designer. We're doing a consultant. Is that as a is that
48:50 a is that a decision that was made based off of an assessment of the last 18
48:56 months, 16 months, or is that simply a staffing change and this is the
49:04 path of least resistance at the moment that we go? Because I don't want to do something that's shortsighted.
49:11 And that's the premise of why I'm asking that question because I I I I understand the need to outsource when it's
49:20 appropriate, but I also understand the need to be able to have the staff to be able to um you know really kind of manage and guide that performance.
49:32 And so I I want to make sure we're we're doing the right thing. And I I guess I need a little bit more to understand the
49:40 decision of the change of course, especially since it's relatively recent that we just were going the other route,
49:47 right? Um the uh the route we're going now is from my perspective and first of all, it's just been what eight months,
49:55 not 18. I just want to be clear for Oh, yeah, that's right. Yeah, I'm I I jumped a year. Sorry, you're right. Eight.
50:02 Because time's flown by. I was a criminal justice major, not a math major.
50:08 Okay, that's fine. And no disrespect to uh chief deputy chief.
50:14 And uh no, it was largely a personnel issue. As you may remember, Rob Fox was uh the other person that was in the
50:22 urban design department. And his focus was to get things up and running. Okay.
50:27 And he's he was great at all that. It was a huge disappointment for me that he had to move on.
50:33 personal issues that arose and I felt once he left that um there were existing
50:40 staff members in the city government that could take on some of the things that he was doing but the more critical
50:47 role was actually creating the specific eye candy that I talked about showed before which was being done essentially
50:54 um uh things you know similar to what DPZ was doing and so the idea behind outsourcing that
51:02 was that actually um that the key person uh would be the most cost effective and the best at doing it uh would not be in
51:10 a position to move to Clermont. he can stay where he is doing what he's doing on an essentially on a computer and he
51:17 can visit here regularly but to be here 247 wasn't a possibility and if we went with a different direction um uh we
51:25 wouldn't be able to get um those people doing the work for us as cheaply.
51:32 So it could change you know thing if that resource became unavailable in the future it could be where it could be helpful to have somebody full-time
51:40 physically here but right now we can't another way to get delivered as much work as we can get through just outsourcing.
51:49 Thank you. And my final question I I think maybe direct to the city manager and you tell me if someone else should answer. Um what is our relationship and
51:58 role as as we whether it's a separate department as being proposed or it's housed within city manager's office and
52:06 not its own department. Um, what is our relationship with lead and lake 100?
52:21 A and what are we expending financially with those organizations
52:27 that either complements andor might be done might be able to be done differently
52:36 within Great question.
52:40 There there's a lot of discussion around these things right now, not just with our city, but collectively.
52:48 Sure.
52:49 So, I would say when it comes to lead, they're working on a lot of things. I have a lot of conversations with
52:58 Rene and we're waiting for them to get some traction. And I would say the county would probably say something similar that they have made a large investment.
53:10 Right. Right.
53:10 And we're kind of more on the coattails with our investment is very minimal. So we haven't seen
53:19 anything that I'm aware of right now that's a direct result of yet.
53:25 Not as a direct result. We've had them come with people to us to look at different sites, but for whatever reason they didn't work out.
53:32 Sure. But we haven't seen a direct impact yet.
53:36 I'll add to this because I can't do it private, so I've had to do it in public.
53:42 Um, I had meetings with lead representatives when I first got elected and specifically said, "What do we as a
53:49 city need to pay to you in order to have you send us?" And I don't remember the number, but it was like
53:57 10 small businesses with four or more employees making 100,000 or more each month,
54:05 right? Like I'm like, let's put numbers that are measurable, but I'm looking for small businesses that raise our average
54:12 household income to over 100,000 because that was our conversation last year. So, it must been after the budget. Yeah.
54:18 Uh because I knew we were talking about that last year and I'll tell you, they just looked at me like I was speaking Greek.
54:27 I don't know how else to say it. It was, well, we're raising up the ones we have, which is good, but otherwise, well, what big ones do
54:34 you want? I said, I don't want any big ones. I just want little ones. I mean, if you count a big one as 20 employees, 50 employees, fine, but I don't want a Kroger.
54:44 I don't want an Amazon. I want personally I'm looking, if you want my support, I'm looking for small businesses. And it was I said, "Who's in
54:52 your rolodex? What do you have?" And I said, "And how?" And they said, "We're paying 5,000 a year. very he's looking up to it's
55:00 very very and I said look for that much money I get it like you can't have someone dedicated to I'm asking for 5,000 a year
55:07 but what number would you need so I can bring this to council because we were talking about economic development right and and we were just not even in the
55:15 same book of attracting small businesses retaining yes attracting no
55:21 and so that's so 2500 oh that's Yeah.
55:28 But then I question what's the point even doing that? I mean it's still 2500.
55:32 So I mean and they'll watch this and they'll say what they say and that's fine. But I think that there's been a and I've been publicly critical about
55:41 it. So I'll just do it here is the county originally was supposed to be
55:48 outsourcing its economic development department and the model they were using was the Ocala model. I don't remember what it was called. You might remember,
55:56 but it was the Ocala model. And so the idea was we were taking county money that we were spending on economic
56:03 development, taking that money and creating a consultant relationship like we're talking about doing for the development design center. But then the
56:12 county reformed its economic development department, which I think has about a million dollar budget now. So instead of us spending
56:21 half million as a county, we're spending 5. So I think that when we start talking about the structure and we're you know
56:29 I'm questioning the structure and concerned about the structure I I feel like there is just kind of a relationship a structure there not the relation the
56:38 people are great but the structure does not support what we're talking about here and having small businesses.
56:46 Yeah. And I and I I get there may be a piece of this that because of the size of Clermont and the needs of Clermont
56:55 that that lead is not going to pun intended I guess lead in that effort
57:03 for us specifically. But there is value in being a part of it. And if that's a a nominal I'm not
57:11 minimizing $2,500 because I think all of us if we have $2,500 in our hand we'd say that's a lot of money, right? Um but in the bigger picture of
57:19 what we're doing to still be a part of it to support it and if we do get some opportunity through there whether it's conversation experience etc.
57:29 Yeah. Do we have a are we involved with Lake 100 in that same way as well?
57:35 I I would say that that's more I mean Dan just went through Lake 100 and leadership like he went through leadership which is different.
57:46 You would think I would know the answer to the question I'm about to ask and I do not. I just want you to know that.
57:51 Is there are cities involved in like 100,000? I don't know. That's what I'm asking.
57:54 I don't know that we're in that should be.
57:58 Well, but yeah, I think it's a leadership. I thought you referring to leadership.
58:02 No, I'm sorry. Yeah, I was just making sure. No.
58:04 And then with regard to the lead, where does that does that come from economic development? That 2500. Yes. Okay.
58:11 Yeah. Good questions.
58:14 And the 2500 Uh when the lead first came on, we we looked at all that prior administration. We looked at it and at
58:21 the time kind of like what MR was saying, what's the benefit for us? And we
58:28 couldn't see much benefit, but out of the goodness and to say, hey, we we going to support someone. That's
58:36 where the 2500 we gave them a bare minimum. Uh because the cost was asking us for at the time to be a real part of
58:43 kind of extra And we do not we decided not to go in the lake 100 as well. Okay.
58:50 Yeah.
58:52 I hear hear you Mr. Nor talking about economic development and trying to bring um employment here but under the same
59:00 time I'm hearing you saying we out of land which I've been saying for a long time. We out of land. So you know we trying to talk about bringing employment
59:09 here. Where where we going to bring the employment? we have other than small businesses and everything which I hear
59:16 you say trying to get a small business in here that's paying $100,000. Wow. I would like to see that too. That's going to be kind of tough. And I'm always
59:24 saying one of the biggest things for employment go you got two real sources of employment that I think people can
59:31 actually make a living here in that's your hospital and your post office.
59:36 Okay. Other than that most of it is small business. Um that's one of the reason I was disappointed with what what happened in welders way area because I
59:45 always looked at that as being a great opportunity for industrial to bring in jobs and everything but they decided to
59:52 put houses back in there. So now with all the land g where can we bring in uh
59:59 employment uh businesses that's going to play anything that we can keep people here like I would love to see a lot a lot
1:00:08 more jobs here know one of my goals when I came back is trying to figure out a place we we keep people here uh my kids
1:00:15 go off and get degrees and come back and stay up stay at home or whatever
1:00:21 with the situation we in employment they they got to work outside the city.
1:00:28 You saying 80% I'm saying we we over 90% developed is no I mean I can't go north I can't go east west the only place we
1:00:36 go south and we right up against the line at the south end so where where is the opportunity to bring bring businesses in that's going to pay any
1:00:44 kind of money and and when I was mentioning the 80% those those are the lands that can't be
1:00:51 redeveloped let's say along orders in fact we had the conversation this past week at 50 and 12th. So, you know, we've got
1:01:00 a corner that's almost six acres, right?
1:01:03 And we're meeting with those folks about what can be done there. But that would be an opportunity where that's not frozen in Amber. That is actually
1:01:10 something that can be redeveloped and provide uh something that we have under supply for. I was talking to David Colby at the chamber the other day. He says,
1:01:18 you know, we have small businesses that want to be in the, you know, in Clermont and they just don't have many good options.
1:01:25 That's what I'd love to be able to see on that corner is let's get some space for for the small businesses that can be here. Well, even then that of course it
1:01:34 was that piece of property it was reszone at one point and then actually when we tried to resone it back to industrial we caught a lot of trouble on
1:01:42 that and it always uh industrial because it used to be a steel mill steel factory
1:01:49 con steel used to sit on there and it was one of the better paying jobs in doing back in my youth day you know I
1:01:56 knew a lot of people work there and it supported a lot of families in here but even that I would that's one of the reason I had no problem comparing back
1:02:04 to industrial and hopefully we can get there but some of the people down there not going to be happy with that business and everything sitting there running at home of course back in the days when uh
1:02:13 steel was there you didn't have all the homes around there so so now you have that challenge as well and there is a strong need as as someone
1:02:21 who works in real estate professionally I will tell you I don't do the commercial side but I hear a lot about it and there is a strong strong need for
1:02:31 small business commercial opportunity, even incubator type of opportunities for people to get up and running. And I think that's, you know, as we were
1:02:39 sitting here talking about our future, uh, I don't I I I I almost hesitate to say this out loud because I'm afraid
1:02:46 someone's going to go trademark it. So, uh, Christian, if you're listening, um, go trademark this for us. Um, the small
1:02:54 business capital of the world, small business capital of the country. CL, you know, and And and but but that tells
1:03:02 everybody what are what are what are there's no
1:03:09 question what that means, right?
1:03:13 It's it's specific enough, but it's it's creative enough to provide an opportunity for people to explore and to and to um innovate.
1:03:25 Um and I think we have to we we have to be willing to admit that we don't have all the answers
1:03:32 or know everything. And because this is changing so rapidly that if we've learned anything from the
1:03:40 recessions of our past is that to try to do the exact same thing that we did that Einstein quote.
1:03:50 Yeah.
1:03:51 Definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over expecting a different result.
1:03:56 We're going to see that. And so how can we do things differently? How can we, you know, uh,
1:04:03 be kind of maybe pie in the sky and unrealistic with a with a, I don't know, a culinary arts incubator program that
1:04:12 ties in with Rollins that has a program that ties in with Disney that ties in with Universal. It's Wellness Way. It's it's close to that area, 192 and 27. You
1:04:22 know, I don't know what that means, but goodness gracious, I know there's people out there that can run with that and work with that. Maybe, and I don't want
1:04:29 to tie too much about budget because I think it doesn't necessarily affect the budget for fiscal year 27, but it's more of a philosophical and maybe this is a
1:04:37 great conversation for us to have as a council as we set goals for the city manager in the evaluation process. Maybe the goal, one of the goals for next year is to come up with this economic
1:04:45 development plan roundt. Maybe we take a more active role in the next 18 months to be engaged in conversation and make this a priority.
1:04:56 I like that idea. You know what you said and I'm excited about you got my blood just rushing and I didn't have any coffee this morning so it's probably good is
1:05:04 Groveland had something that they called the strategic planning committee I think I think that's what it was called I think it's yeah
1:05:12 and it was a group of leaders in business so they were all small business owners who worked with the council as Groin was
1:05:20 doing its strategic plans this was five six years ago I think it was it was impressive And so when you're talking
1:05:28 about Lake 100, you've got me thinking between what we saw with Groveland, what we saw with Lake 100, you know, or what
1:05:36 we see with Lake 100 where we when we're getting these business owners because what I hear people say is, "Well, I don't want to run for council. I can't put in that much time." And I'm going,
1:05:44 "Okay, but we still need your brain." Like, as a community, we need the brains and the creative thinking of what do we
1:05:51 have in Clermont? You can't move into Clermont for less than $300,000.
1:05:57 If you want an estate home, you're talking5, $600,000. This is not an average salary. These are people who are
1:06:04 seuite executives. These are people who know how to make money. There are people who know how to manage money. And what are we doing? We're shipping them out every day to go work somewhere else.
1:06:14 Think about that. We already have them here. What if we open up the door for them to communicate with us?
1:06:22 Hey, I have an idea.
1:06:25 Hey, what if we did this? Because I think right now there's this general sense of the public of well, I've hired
1:06:32 my electeds. They're in charge. Well, okay, there's only five of us. And so, when we have 22,000 units now in our we
1:06:41 were 16,000 when I ran two years ago. We had 16,000 homes. Now, we have 22,000. I mean, that's crazy. there are people in
1:06:50 there that can make this city better. So if there's I love the direction that you're talking about small business
1:06:58 capital of the world. Um I think that when you talk about evaluation and direction of the city manager who's running out the back door ironically
1:07:06 right now I know um but I think if we could come up with a measure where we're saying what has been the community
1:07:14 interaction what are we hearing from the community? What kind of one of the things that came up in the consultant
1:07:20 for the communications, she showed me a survey that they can do. Yeah.
1:07:25 Where you kind of get keywords or something. Yes.
1:07:28 Something where you're getting that feedback and then it makes our job so much easier because we just know what what direction do the people want us to go.
1:07:37 So yes, you got me excited. I love it.
1:07:39 Well, yeah. And I don't want to again I don't want to detract too much from the budget hearing where we are supposed to be here today,
1:07:47 but I think I think that there's a lot that we should be focusing on in this area. And um I know uh Mr. Doris, you
1:07:57 you know, you didn't mean anything by where the small, you know, we went through the biggest, now we're starting with the smallest. But I I think that
1:08:05 the the dollar amount spent here means nothing in relation to the level of importance and significance in the
1:08:13 direction of our community. Um and I mean that sincerely. Uh and I think that
1:08:20 there there's, you know, I'm willing to to kind of move forward with uh the budget and and have some conversations
1:08:28 at the council level of whether we want to, you know, obviously fund everything, but I've heard your priorities. I heard why you're proposing what you're proposing.
1:08:36 Um, but I think that this is a conversation that has to be uh a regular a regular thing if we're going to be serious about it.
1:08:45 I I agree with your assessment about Rob Fox not being here. Just I don't think you're crazy. I think he's just trying to save us money.
1:08:54 Yeah. Yeah. No, that's fine.
1:08:55 So, I but I think your observation is well taken. So, we may be back here And I I think it's a good thing if we're
1:09:04 back here saying he's got so much going on, he needs some more administrative support.
1:09:10 If we're going to say we want to attract small business owners who live in risk and chaos, I think we should expect a
1:09:17 little bit of risk and chaos in that area. Mhm. Yeah.
1:09:21 Although I don't necessarily like it in the other areas, I think that there's if that's who we're going to deal with, it's like I said when we adopted the choice of champions brand, I stood right
1:09:29 there at that dis said if you're going to do this, you better be serious about it because the people you're attracting are not people who are going to tolerate
1:09:37 mediocrity, right?
1:09:38 If you're going to say we're the choice of champions and you're saying champions are welcome here, you're going to get champions. So, if we're saying small business owners are going to be welcome here, we need to be ready for people
1:09:47 with great ideas to inundate us and expect us to take action on those ideas and I'm willing to do that. I'm willing to put the structures in place that we need to to do that.
1:09:57 So, public comment, as Mr. Norris was saying, this this design studio is kind of the first step of that. We have a lot of underutilized
1:10:05 land that we can redevelop and make it something that it does attract the small businesses, but it does attract all that. So, his design center is actually working towards that goal to get theirs.
1:10:18 Claire and Monty being a perfect example.
1:10:21 Can we um Yes, ma'am.
1:10:26 Come on. You got Yeah. Well, people on YouTube want to hear you.
1:10:35 Thank you.
1:10:37 I mean, this gets me excited as a small business owner trying to do something unique here. Just Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.
1:10:45 Yes. To all the things. And then also as an advocate for downtown like the development and design center, I think people they just get stuck. They don't know a
1:10:54 lot of times what good development looks like. So, they default to what is the easiest or the cheapest or whatever. And we miss opportunities. So, I'm really
1:11:02 excited about that. And then also just want to address I think it's a misconception that small business means low income. Sometimes it does and for
1:11:11 sure in the beginning it does but that's not equivalent. Um just putting that out there too.
1:11:26 Thank you. Who's next? That's Kirk. All right.
1:11:34 Can I uh Mr. C manager uh the CRA now that that Mr. Norris is the CRA director,
1:11:42 do we have to approve a CRA budget here and when will we get that and how's that process? I think I know, but I'm also
1:11:50 asking for the public. Typically, it's been approved in September, but my desire is to bring something in front of
1:11:56 you in August and talk through it during our time together, which we haven't done. Normally, we just give you a
1:12:04 budget, but I'd like to workshop us a little bit with you guys in So, that that's forthcoming. That's what I would like. Okay. Yeah.
1:12:10 So, we adopt at the same time as the general fund.
1:12:15 Well, typically it's in September. adopt it, but I want to give you a workshop to talk through it and then adopt it the next month.
1:12:23 Okay? If that's how you do it.
1:12:28 Good morning, mayor and council members for the planning and development services department. Um,
1:12:36 you want No, I'm sorry. I don't have there. All right, he's up.
1:12:46 For some highlights of the year, u we have been busy annexing over 561 acres property and we have some
1:12:54 more set this year to go yet. You'll see some projects coming forward. Uh active projects currently in the process. As you know, uh we're working on the
1:13:03 forbased code, the comprehensive plan, and the downtown master plan.
1:13:09 Uh we also cover code enforcement as well which they have received over $73,000 in fines and leans over the past
1:13:16 year. Keep in mind the goal is not a monetary goal there. Our goal is to get compliance by verbal communication with the other side if you will.
1:13:28 Next or chart we have nine fulltime employees.
1:13:33 Um we can have part of them are planning side part of code enforcement side as well.
1:13:41 And looks like I'm sorry I don't do we have this presentation.
1:13:49 I don't I don't see it anywhere in here. I just Oh, you don't.
1:13:57 Okay. Oh, okay. If we can if we can just get a copy. I'll get you a copy. Sure.
1:14:05 the city engineer.
1:14:08 Oh, the I'm sorry. The off to your right, city engineer is going to be a new position, not a new position where reclassification position we'll have.
1:14:18 This will help us immensely when we're working on projects.
1:14:24 Efficiency part will greatly help if the projects through quicker as well.
1:14:29 But we we don't are the economic development people now. the economic development positions.
1:14:37 Those were an old term that we they were our they were what we had for economic development and honestly they were doing
1:14:44 a lot more planning than economic development just because the workload.
1:14:49 Um so the title could possibly change on them planning.
1:15:02 Yeah. So we have five planners.
1:15:11 Are any of them planners? Four of them including myself. Four. Okay.
1:15:18 So what what are they planning? They're all the development comes in.
1:15:23 They work with the code implement the code to their plan proposing to come in and obviously you see us twice a month here.
1:15:32 So like application site well that that term planning kind of throw you off because they not
1:15:40 right okay makes your mind go to a different thing and the economic planning and economic development course we just talked about
1:15:48 Mr. Mill being the economic development but right all the time they always ran out of their office because we didn't per say have that position
1:15:56 that's right separate so you can't like combine all those things I think u I don't know when did Mr. Hicks leave here.
1:16:04 Who? Jim Hick. Oh, goodness.
1:16:07 Yeah, cuz I think his job.
1:16:09 Yeah, he was that was that was I think that was his primary job was correct.
1:16:14 It was okay. But he been gone so many years. So they kind of combined everything into this office. So
1:16:22 people do that know what to do and the public. It makes sense.
1:16:30 Yeah. I always look at if I walk in here and don't know where to go.
1:16:36 It doesn't exist. Yes, it's an old carryover. It is um
1:16:44 uh we proposing no capital projects this year.
1:16:49 The department and then obviously the fiscal summary is before you. Um there's still a bit left over to pay for the uh
1:16:58 comprehensive plan part. That's why you see that 700,000 there. Um it's really a carryover.
1:17:06 So six will actual the actual six will be lower when we look at the actuals and then the car. Correct.
1:17:17 And what happened in 25 that went down in staffing?
1:17:26 Yeah, we did. Yes, we did have a vacancy for a while.
1:17:30 All right, that's it, babe.
1:17:40 I like that. Thank you.
1:17:43 Short and sweet. Yes, kiss. Keep it short and sweet. Yes.
1:17:50 So we we uh the city engineer we we actually going to fill that position now because I thought I saw something in procurement going back and
1:17:59 asking for we're trying. Yes, we're working on that now.
1:18:03 So So the procurement actions that we took to have uh engineers on on hand
1:18:10 when we fill a position if we still need all that through procurement. Correct.
1:18:14 Correct. So we we have the city engineer that was a pro that was a position that was in public services that was doing the plan review stuff. Okay.
1:18:22 We moved it over under under planning because we want public services to really focus on projects and
1:18:29 infrastructure and stuff like that in the development review site in the planning. So we we reclassified one of their vacant positions to the city
1:18:37 engineer. We have had it advertised for about two months a month or two now at least. uh we haven't had a whole lot of luck with candidates yet, but that's why
1:18:45 we still have the continuing services because even if we bring a city engineer on board, there's so many specialties in engineering that you're still going to
1:18:53 need someone that might be a storm water expert or a So I just I know we we did the procurement action and asking have what
1:19:01 four or five in furniture and we need them now until we get our own for now. Yeah. That's why I'm asking, do that go away? But
1:19:09 it it will minimize it. It won't necessarily go away because we're looking for a civil engineer, but if there may be a really specific storm
1:19:16 water review that we need assistance on, we'll have them on standby, but it will be minimized quite a bit once we get one on board.
1:19:23 All right, Kurt. Yes.
1:19:27 Up here it says that the operating goes from 2.29 million to 77. Why? Why?
1:19:34 That's the comp that's the bulk of the comp plan. Yeah. Okay. Yeah, we still have a little bit left.
1:19:40 Okay. That's why it's 700. After that, it'll go down to closer to 25. Okay. The fiscal year 25 numbers.
1:19:48 I had him go next because Mr. Norris and him were working back and forth on different
1:19:56 Nathan's the one overseeing everything with DP. Okay. For the code and the comp plan.
1:20:02 Yes. And that was what I asked the 7 over. So the actuals in 26 will be 700 less.
1:20:10 Okay. Not not quite 700. 77.
1:20:16 I think we got 717, but I think you still have some operating. Oh yeah. Yeah. Right.
1:20:22 I think it be somewhere between two and three. Correct. That's right. Okay. It's actually operating realistically.
1:20:29 Yes.
1:20:33 May I ask just one question? It's not specific budget, but we're talking about it. Can you give us
1:20:40 some definitive as much as possible when we will see in front of P&Z and
1:20:47 council form-based code um and and comp plan um dates? Is that what you're asking for?
1:20:58 We have a uh probably a three-hour meeting tomorrow with them to I'll narrow that down.
1:21:03 Get that update for you. Um sounds like within say two months away, but I Okay,
1:21:11 let me get that number for you. Does that sound right?
1:21:14 We've been seeing preliminary drafts of different sections of it. So, we've been reviewing them and sending them back comments and three hour.
1:21:21 Yeah. Hopefully, and it's still just the northwest quadrant right now for the fire. Correct. Okay. And then comp plan.
1:21:31 Comp plan. We've we've had one review with them on on one of the drafts. So I think they're going to go about the same time at least the initial hearing fall for both.
1:21:40 Yeah. Yeah. We're probably thinking somewhere September, October. Okay. Do you want to add anything to that?
1:21:47 I just want to make sure for timing purposes.
1:21:49 Yes, for Yeah. For timing purposes. Uh just so you know the contracts said that you know it's actually second week of November when everything's due. We're
1:21:57 trying to speed things up on forbase code for the northwest quadrant. Um the thing that we're trying to do right now
1:22:04 is get the the forbase code in a position where it can be over full replacement overlay as a starter code.
1:22:14 The reason is because we want to pursue userfriendly graphics and user friendly graphics take a long time to prod. as
1:22:21 far as coming up with the rules doesn't take forever. So the expectation is that we would come forward in August with
1:22:29 that uh the rules that would be subject to an overlay so that we can have our development committee choose to use that code instead of the existing code.
1:22:38 Gotcha.
1:22:38 And then later once we get the user friendliness map down then we can add to it
1:22:44 comp plan is as far as a draft that will be shared with people or
1:22:51 My expectations were more in the beginning of September. Okay. Okay.
1:22:58 And I I think this is probably more for the city manager and and the deputy city manager. um is that with regard to the
1:23:08 formbbased code and and comprehensive plan measures because of the depth of them and the breadth of them I I would
1:23:16 like to request that we not get them the wind well that we not get the draft on the Wednesday before the meeting. Um I
1:23:25 mean I I say that kind of tongue and cheek a little bit because even some bigger projects we do end up getting the document right
1:23:32 and they could be 50 pages and it's the way you know the yellow pages as uh council member Peterson was saying earlier we were joking um and you know
1:23:40 we get the yellow pages the Wednesday before the meeting and and there's an expectation to vote and so I I think given the seriousness of that um I
1:23:49 really am I'm going to put a plea out there to make sure we get this with a couple of weeks of digestible time before we vote on it.
1:23:58 Right. And and if we can get a workshop in in between, that would be okay with that, too. Yes. That would be great informed on what you're voting. I I'd
1:24:06 recommend you consider sitting with Nathan, too. Yeah.
1:24:10 Personally, and make yourself available to anybody who wants to We don't want to come up with a draft you haven't seen.
1:24:17 Yeah. Right.
1:24:18 Yeah. I I echo that in in that I don't want all of you to work you know, three weeks worth of time and then we just say it like we don't like it.
1:24:28 Yeah, exactly. See if we can give you feedback at the midway point.
1:24:32 Yes, 100%. Thank you for that, Bryan.
1:24:35 Yeah, thank you. Thank you. This is great conversation. Yeah, it is. Okay.
1:24:41 I made an assumption. I'm sorry, but brought Sean McNelte up our building official. I wasn't sure if we were speak to building or not. Sorry.
1:24:49 Well, you're you oversee it.
1:24:52 So yeah, we do I do not have a um I don't think we have any slides any slides, but overall there is a reduction in the
1:24:59 the department of what the yeah for for building services which is
1:25:07 kind of like the everything from Nate to to Kurt to myself. We're doing doing all the
1:25:14 vertical construction and the permitting. Make sure it all meets codes and everything. But please forgive me. Where do I have a tab for this?
1:25:23 I don't think we have.
1:25:25 No, I don't think there was. No, there wasn't in there.
1:25:28 There's slides, but those slides show, but I think this is page 45.
1:25:34 That's planning. That's planning development.
1:25:37 SLE talking services.
1:25:44 It's under a special revenue fund because it's all funed by the building fund. Okay. It's 121.
1:25:50 29. There we go.
1:25:58 You should definitely have I've seen the tab before.
1:26:03 129 129. Okay. Thank you.
1:26:11 The revenues are on this one. Even better. So, we can see the revenues, too. I love it.
1:26:15 Yes. Our revenues are strong. Um this We're uh
1:26:23 pretty confidently going to see a a good reduction in um some of our operating expenses being through some efficiencies. We're going to use less contracted services.
1:26:34 So that that's where you that bulk of that reduction is what you're seeing.
1:26:40 I am admittedly ignorant to much of your department. So please understand I'm coming this way. Can you
1:26:48 tell me and the public what your department does for this. Can you describe your function?
1:26:54 The the building services primarily is the vertical construction a after all the planning and the zoning and and the site review has been uh all hashed out.
1:27:07 Then then now all the buildings come out of the ground that vertical construction where Florida building code kicks in um
1:27:14 through permit application plan review inspections and then the final processing end up
1:27:22 issuing a CO or some sort of completion or keeping people safe.
1:27:28 Yeah. as as your building comes out of the ground. Some has inspectors that go out throughout that building process to make sure that it's being built
1:27:36 correctly, right? That's important part.
1:27:39 That's an important part of on on the commercial side, we work closely with the fire department. They also have
1:27:47 and inspectors themselves work together inspections at different phases throughout the correct. Typically, how long would it
1:27:56 take for a building, just a generic building, let's say, through your whole process? No hiccups, just say just generally.
1:28:02 Our our process Yeah. Um I I I put my goal, okay, or our goals, the department's goals is
1:28:11 we try and get a a residential building permit out in less than seven days. Oh, wow.
1:28:16 Which is is exceeds statutory requirements. Okay. Okay.
1:28:20 And then on on the commercial side, right now we're shooting for 20 days, but looking on to reducing that as well. Wow.
1:28:27 Trying to work on some efficiencies. Thank you.
1:28:31 You talk about building, but also if I'm also responsible for inspection and permitting for renovations that you do
1:28:38 other people, correct? Any alterations, additions? Yes.
1:28:43 All of that falls under the correct. They're one we're actually one of the fastest permitting in all of Central Florida. We we get things out very quickly here extremely efficient.
1:28:54 Thank you for that.
1:28:55 And we got to the point where businesses and big like the Philars and all these big
1:29:03 builders were all going private provider. Now they're asking to come back to us which is a big revenue generator for us because
1:29:11 if they go private provider we have to reduce the permit fees by half. Oh.
1:29:15 Or depending on which part of the pro provider. So this is actually not only because we've gotten it a lot more
1:29:22 efficient and userfriendly that we are getting the developers coming back to us saying now we want to go through you because you're easier to go through than our own private providers.
1:29:32 You would believe some of the stories we get from other jurisdictions how long it takes the review process. It's really we we
1:29:41 we're the city of champions. You're we we got out standing permitting department. And I get compliments on all
1:29:48 the time, different uh contractors and developers and everything saying how simple it means it was go through.
1:29:54 It wasn't always that year that way years ago as you can recall Mr. Bwag years ago. It used to be one of the worst come a long way.
1:30:05 to be here.
1:30:06 Sean Sean has been very intentional so you all know to talk about how we can make things go faster. So we're more
1:30:14 customer service oriented on the commercial and the residential side and continues to look at that. So I give a
1:30:21 lot of props to him and his team just I don't we don't talk about it but I want you to know they're very intentional about it and that's to work with all
1:30:30 departments public services fire all the different groups we're trying to figure out how do we get more efficient right and continue to move forward and I'm
1:30:39 very pleased with where we're at where we're going with that well thank you for all you're doing because thank you so this might relate Mr.
1:30:47 I know you're working so I'm giving you a heads up. I might ask a question that you might need to answer but this also might be for Scott. So two questions.
1:30:55 One relates to if our goal as a council through this comprehensive planning
1:31:02 process is to identify places that are available for redevelopment or new development that are intentionally
1:31:09 planned out and that they're people friendly.
1:31:14 We've got economic development a new development design center concept. We've got planning and zoning and we've got building services.
1:31:23 Where are the pressure points in the process that cause what I call the donuts, which is a concrete building
1:31:32 surrounded by asphalt that is not walker friendly, human friendly. How do where do we where do we get the good design?
1:31:43 Every developer I've talked to says, "Well, I want to a great project, but your code makes me do a bad project. But
1:31:50 then I see PUDS, which means no, you can do whatever you want in a PUB. So I don't understand how do we leverage what
1:31:57 the three of you are working on to effectuate a quick result of good development that is people friendly?
1:32:06 What system and process needs to be in place to achieve that result? And then my second question, Scott, might be for you, is I'm looking for a little bit of
1:32:15 education on this enterprise fund balance. This year, we're starting at 3.9 million. We're basically spending what we're bringing in. So, I commend
1:32:23 you on that. That's good. But philosophically, should we be carrying $4 million in a fund balance, an
1:32:31 enterprise fund, or might there be a better use of those funds? whether it relates to achieving the goal number one
1:32:38 or perhaps lowering our fees to achieve goal number one or some other method to achieve goal. So my my goal the goal is
1:32:46 what it's stated and so I'm trying to understand how this all works together.
1:32:49 So I can I can answer both of those questions. The second one is that this enterprise fund the the state says that all money received by this has to be
1:32:57 spent enforcing the building code. So you can't just move it around to different departments or move it around in different uh ways that aren't enforcing the building code.
1:33:06 Okay.
1:33:06 So they're very very particular about that.
1:33:09 With the first one, the first question go back to that. So are we carrying too much of a fund, right?
1:33:15 You're allowed to carry a certain percentage over, but if you do it continually, kind of like a personal thing, you'll get audited ultimately.
1:33:24 Yeah. And then they'll say you've got a couple options. you either lower your rates or you give the money back to the developers that you've overcharged.
1:33:31 So, we're very careful about making sure that we're not taking in too much or or or we're spending it appropriately.
1:33:38 Should we be lowering the rates? I I've only see 27, so I don't know how far back this fund history goes. I think that's something we can look at.
1:33:46 Is it a long history of hanging out at 4 million? Has it recently spiked? Is it down? Do you know? I have to look. I don't recall the top.
1:33:55 I'm just wondering if there's maybe something here to explore. Carrying four million might be the right number, but it might be high. It might be low. I don't know.
1:34:03 We're looking at different ways to to just to add to that, part of the reason we're trying to go for an engineer. We we need to use these monies to help
1:34:12 expedite the process in the building department. So, that's why we're bringing in some of these key staff. So, we're actually using these resources to
1:34:21 benefit the community. And That's why we're expanding resources. So that's question number two. Got it.
1:34:28 So question number one, you actually answered it yourself by saying it's the code. The code is the problem.
1:34:33 And we we have a code that makes it it's a it's a very generic code that's
1:34:40 been Frankensteined over the years by different amendments. Yes. And so what we're trying to do with this new form based code is we're trying to put it to
1:34:49 where it does encourage the good development uh telling us where we want or telling the developers where we want the parking
1:34:56 in a perfect code. In my opinion, we make puds the absolute exception to the rule. Make the rules how we want
1:35:05 them. Tell them if you follow the rules, you're going to get by very quickly. You may not even have to go to council PNZ if you follow the rules. Okay?
1:35:12 If you don't want to follow rules, then you go through and council and all that stuff and that's through the PD but PD should be the last resort, not the easy way out to do whatever you want.
1:35:23 So we're and with the overlay with the overlay we said we're going to see that before the fall, right? And then the fall will be the pretty pictures.
1:35:32 Yeah, the overlay is going to get going to set it up so we can start doing it and start getting people the technical people ready for what we're doing.
1:35:40 I might not be one of them. But one of the things I liked I want to say this to to the rest of the council in a conversation I had with Mr. Norris about
1:35:47 development design center. It speaks to what you just said which is why I thought of it is if someone comes to us and they've gone to the development
1:35:55 design center and they say well I want to do this thing. We now have staff able to say, "Well, here's what we suggested
1:36:03 they do that would be consistent with the code and we have eye candy to look at as well of what could be done so that
1:36:10 we can compare it to what the developer is bringing us and say, well, we'd like to stick to our code or we'd like to give you the variance or the change."
1:36:18 And so I think that will be very helpful to us making decisions as well having that.
1:36:24 If I could piggy back, it's so important that the five of you and the staff is in sync because if we're making suggestions
1:36:32 to the design center, right, we have to know what you want because it will be so demoralizing for
1:36:40 the developers if we're bringing through a process and staff. Yeah.
1:36:44 So, we just got to make sure we really work closely together, but it could it could make life so much easier for people to build and do things if we're together in what we're doing.
1:36:55 And I've had some planning and zoning people um say and I use the word as well and then I heard you use it. So I want to set a better example of
1:37:03 when we talk about good development I think we might want to say desired development because good for us might not be good.
1:37:12 So that which we desire might be there might be other words that are better but I like
1:37:24 that was all I had. Thank you for answering.
1:37:27 Um I'm sorry. Go ahead.
1:37:29 Okay. I sorry I pulled this out because I saved these two articles. I wanted to ask about um HB House Bill 8003
1:37:39 and House Bill 1389 talking about uh permit processes and timelines and so
1:37:46 forth. Do we do we anticipate needing to make any changes in this next fiscal year to accommodate and and is that
1:37:55 built in since these just went into effect? the the all the turnaround times and all the requirements we already
1:38:02 exceeded. Okay. What what those new requirements are and we have a couple vacant positions
1:38:09 in inspections and plan review those are kind of like on the horizon like what Dan is saying. Yeah. If we get additional uh additional workload coming
1:38:18 from the pies and larars of the world I feel we have sufficient vacancies to cover
1:38:26 that work and and maintain those statuto love to hear that love to hear that.
1:38:32 Thank you. Like I say, we've come a long way in that that's those bills speak to the fact that what other cities and
1:38:38 municipalities are going how long is we we've been doing pretty good.
1:38:42 And I I just want to make sure it's important to ask now because we're in the budget process and we have to make I know they just went into effect in July.
1:38:49 So I I if we got all of the the work that Dan was just explaining, yeah, next year I might be asking.
1:38:56 Oh, sure. And that's fair. That's that's a that's a fair statement. So you probably have the permits to pay for it.
1:39:02 Exactly. Mr. Bwag, before Kurt go, if it's okay, and I'm I'm sorry I'm throwing this out. Can you do me a favor? I need I need some uh I think
1:39:12 it's 741 Pit Street uh along the retention pond there. I
1:39:19 know. Uh back behind that house, uh they came in, somebody came in talking about developing back there before and I thought we disapproved all that and I
1:39:27 see them clearing out. Can you I did notice here. Is this the one without it doesn't have direct access to the road? Is that what you're referring to?
1:39:35 But I see they they cut down a lot of trees and I see them looked like they couldn't put in a foundation back there that I don't remember coming back to the Can you check on that please? Sure.
1:39:47 I'm just curious how how they got through all that when they came to council before and it got this approved.
1:39:52 Now that's unless their whole issue is they needed access. Unless someone gave them some access.
1:39:59 Well, I know the owners of the house there next to them that were fighting against it, they telling me they did it. Okay.
1:40:08 They they trying to figure out what's going on as well.
1:40:12 Please, sir. Thank you. Anybody
1:40:27 need Do we need five minutes?
1:40:36 Any longer? Sorry. You you you started it for us.
1:40:44 Let's make it 7 10:35. But that's all right. That sounds good. Yeah.
1:41:24 Heat. Heat. Heat. Heat.
1:41:54 Heat. Heat.
1:42:14 Heat. Heat.
1:43:09 That's cool.
1:44:10 Heat. Hey. Hey. Hey.
1:44:20 Heat. Heat.
1:45:38 Hey, hey, hey.
1:46:06 Heat. Heat.
1:46:44 Heat. Heat.
1:47:40 We have who do we have? Procurement. Procurement. Oh, okay. Procurement.
1:47:50 You ready? Ready.
1:48:00 We can go back. Come on back. We can go ahead and get started. And we have procurement.
1:48:08 Hey, how are you? Oh my gosh. You just now got out. Yeah. Oh my goodness.
1:48:27 the one.
1:48:29 Oh, that's I'm so proud of it. Yeah, it's lame.
1:48:36 So, how we how you know calories don't burn.
1:48:39 Oh, you ate it. You got to add one piece. They must have I don't know.
1:48:47 This is so today is all the numbers.
1:48:58 Yeah. Well, because I like that.
1:49:01 I have I have to put a house back there because it's here and there's another house and haven't had one in months and months because that's that's my building.
1:49:14 Isn't good for you're eating it? No, I remember someone. I used to do only black coffee.
1:49:21 I was practicing cuz I would have access
1:49:41 delicious. He's looking at some goodies over there.
1:49:48 Well, uh, hopefully we can get through. We going to be breaking for lunch about I think it's Debbie Tobin with lunch be served
1:49:57 about 12 o'clock. So, got about an hour and 20 minutes. All right. Yes, ma'am.
1:50:03 Hi. Yes. Ramsey Gimenez, um, procurement manager. I'll make this short and sweet.
1:50:08 Um, so for our current year review, um, we've earned our achievement of excellence. Um, in 2025, we've applied
1:50:15 for the 26. Just haven't gotten those results. Um, in 26, we also revised our procurement procedures and our PECARD procedures.
1:50:25 Um, as part of our PECARD program, we earned a rebate of $30,436.
1:50:33 Um, through our fuel card program, we got a rebate. We saved um $14,685
1:50:41 and as of June 17th we have issued 108 solicitations and we um manage 350 contracts.
1:50:54 So this is our current um organizational chart keeping the same no new positions laid out.
1:51:05 We also have no capital proposals. Nothing new. Everything pretty similar.
1:51:12 Same with operating costs. Everything's pretty much the same.
1:51:19 Did we add a person last year?
1:51:21 Oh, we had a vacancy for a short period of time and then we towards the end of the school.
1:51:28 And you still got the two uh position that you're not filling, correct?
1:51:33 specialist and the four that we have we're keeping. No new positions. No new positions.
1:51:40 Say it's been before FTE since at least from here 2023.
1:51:45 Are you working with Mr. Matthis on software solutions?
1:51:52 Yeah, it's it's part of so the the audit committee is is primarily headed by Zay and Wayne, but all the departments are being brought in it.
1:52:01 And do we Do do you see from your position in procurement anything or can you keep in mind I guess my friend wants to chime in
1:52:11 on it. Um how the software can better inform and engage especially local
1:52:18 businesses on opportunities to keep those dollars that we're spending here in our community. Do you see anything I
1:52:25 know we've talked about it in public meetings but we've never talked about it. So is there any insight you could give us?
1:52:31 Yeah. Currently we use um open gov as our solicitation platform and they have a lot of resources um to connect with
1:52:38 vendors. They have AI sources. They have local they kind of go through Google. So we make sure that we're using all of those sources that they have embedded in
1:52:46 the software. Um sometimes we work with the chamber as well to get information, send out emails. We also post some of
1:52:53 our solicitations um specifically on Facebook or any other social media and also on the as well.
1:53:02 Has the website been updated since lately? The last two or three months?
1:53:10 So, our website is live. So, as we're posting things on the open solicitations, it's processing those live. So, if you went right now, you
1:53:17 could see what's live. Things that open would be processed out of there. Same with contracts as well.
1:53:23 I did a post to encourage people to and I thought it was really easy because I went to the website. That's why I asked it was new because I don't remember seeing that before. So I thought that
1:53:30 was good. If I missed it before, I missed it. But now when we talked about the software audit, we talked about the the 311 center and everything that we wanted two main
1:53:39 softwares and open Gov was one of them because they procurement uses them, budget uses them. There's several departments that use well there's a few
1:53:46 departments that use it, but they have a bigger capacity to do more stuff. So we're we're glad that they're on opened
1:53:53 up already because that's a system that's actually very easy to use.
1:53:58 I we've been on We we just went to open good about two years, two, three years ago.
1:54:03 Yep. As procurement, we've been on it since 2022.
1:54:06 Um I know the budget was a little bit newer, but we've been on it for a few years.
1:54:09 Yeah. Well, I know we did G and then we come back and try to get where budget finally got there. It's and I like it a lot better since since we went to open it seem to give us more.
1:54:21 It's user friendly and it's free for all vendors. They do not have to pay additional that we're looking at
1:54:29 permitting modules and things like that that they can open gov their model is that 40% of their profits go back into R&D and developing new
1:54:38 modules and new government solutions. So good company.
1:54:42 We talk about software. You open up software. Now we're going to wait till it come in here because I know all of the departments has all these softwares
1:54:49 and everything. And my curiosity are you individually going through doing your own software? Are we all Why don't we
1:54:57 all consolidate on it and maybe get a better rate on all this stuff?
1:55:02 100% exactly what we're doing. The more modules you buy, the cheaper it gets. Okay. Yep.
1:55:07 With it. where it is the license has the license for all the other departments and everything.
1:55:15 Uh yeah, I believe so in just about everything. Yes. Wayne shaking his head. So yes. Okay.
1:55:22 Yours is so easy we didn't even want to talk about it.
1:55:27 You're going to make everyone think you want to stay there or come down here. Okay.
1:55:37 Yes, you get to stretch your legs and procurement has we talked to them about getting more active with letting
1:55:45 the community know what we're doing for bidding. So, they've been very active trying to make more people aware.
1:55:55 There's an effort. That's great. Thank you.
1:56:11 Good morning. Good morning.
1:56:15 Hi, Tracy How, city clerk, and I've asked Caitlyn Wilson, our records administrator, to join us this morning to answer any questions you may have specific about public records.
1:56:28 Our current year review, the clerk's office
1:56:38 has disposed of 1,7 cubic feet of records that have met retention in 2025.
1:56:43 That brings us to a total of 14,725 cubic feet of paper records since 2008
1:56:50 that has met retention. We've also continued to expand our digital records management with 464,000 records scanned
1:56:58 into just I'm sorry into laserfish our records repository bringing a total of
1:57:05 three and a half million total images stored in laser fish. Again that's our records repository for long-term and
1:57:11 permanent records. We also significantly managed the growth in our service demands. We've seen a 25% increase in
1:57:20 lean requests, a 40% increase in cemetery sales and a 102% increase in public records requests since October 1 of 2025.
1:57:32 Operational improvements include integrating laser fish with just Voya.
1:57:36 Just as our public records software to streamline records requests, implementing AI powered redaction of
1:57:43 protected driver's license numbers, transitioning candidate canbook candidate campaign filings to the
1:57:51 web-based easy vote application, as well as updated our records request portal to include frequently requested public records requests to the search area.
1:58:07 The clerk's office has six employees. No additional employees are requested.
1:58:20 Proposed highlights for the upcoming fiscal year include replacement of laptops for the department upgrade to
1:58:27 laserfish cloud. This secures long-term pricing before the deadline of December 31, 2026
1:58:36 and proactively transitioning from an on-site system that will be obsolete by year 2029. The cloud platform provides
1:58:43 enhanced security, automatic up upgrades, AI powered indexing, and improved disaster recovery. We're also
1:58:51 enhancing our Just Foya by implementing a pay first functionality for lean requests to automate billing and
1:58:58 expedite processing. Tier 2 support for dedicated assistance with AI redaction workflows and form enhancements. Improve
1:59:06 public records request forms with dynamic fields to capture complete information upfront and reduce processing delays as well as an
1:59:14 automated workflow that routes the police department requests directly to the PD with department specific tracking
1:59:21 numbers. This improving this will improve efficiency as they are the highest volume of requests that we receive in the city is for the police department.
1:59:36 And this is the fiscal summary. Any questions?
1:59:46 Yeah, as we talked about software and challenges with public records, I know you heard it all. Can you comment to
1:59:54 help us have direction on creative solutions, things we might be thinking about, things we might be mentally preparing for? You know, where
2:00:02 do you see kind of public records management requests going in the future and how do we mitigate that cost for the consumers?
2:00:10 I know that Caitlyn has done some research. Would you like to speak to that?
2:00:13 Um, as she mentioned on the propos on the proposal for adding updates to just
2:00:20 Hoya, we are separating out the PD requests because of it being the highest volume that we receive and those will
2:00:28 then be routed directly to the police department automatically. Um something else that we are planning to incorporate
2:00:36 is the dynamic fields on the actual request form and some of those go to our website and it will have drop down
2:00:43 options of things that if they're asking for meeting minutes those are available publicly already and it will redirect
2:00:51 them to our website. So, it will eliminate hopefully eliminate some of the requests that can be answered
2:00:58 already. It's already publicly available. And it another thing that they're going to do is a lot of times we get requests for
2:01:07 the fire department and we they're asking for incident reports that contain medical information. So,
2:01:16 right now we have to reach back out to the requester, pause the request, get clarification from them like information, some sort of signed release
2:01:24 and that on the front end will go ahead and ask them for that and have them provide that fill that out. So hopefully
2:01:32 it doesn't hold up public record requests in the future. Um we I did some training with just Voya and some some
2:01:40 independent research and I was able to figure out how to get the driver's licenses automatically redacted. Um some
2:01:48 of them are still missed so it does require us to review it. But uh there's other elements like social security
2:01:56 numbers and things like that that can also be automatically redacted. But that would be part of what our updates would
2:02:03 include because they have a like a specialist support team that will be included with our upgrade that would
2:02:10 help us incorporate more AI into our reductions to help us speed the process up a little bit.
2:02:16 Do you feel confident in this technology and the AI that it's gonna be accurate or do you have concerns
2:02:24 about it will be as accurate as it can be? Um, one example that I've given is the last
2:02:32 form of a driver's license or the last form of a social or a last form of a phone number. That's something that we would have to find and redact ourselves
2:02:40 because that's not something that AI would pick up. And if it did pick it up, it could try and redact it as a social even though it's a phone number. So that
2:02:49 would be something that we would have to look for ourselves. But outside of that, I'm confident. I'm excited about it. And
2:02:57 I love to I like the emotion. It lets me know you did a very good job of being stonefaced
2:03:05 and most excitement, right?
2:03:09 Yeah, excitement is helpful to know that more or less, what do we think would be the cost of the FOYA upgrades? And what
2:03:16 I really want to know is is it less than or equal to a salary and how might it save us?
2:03:22 It's less than a salary. Um it is
2:03:31 17 I believe it's approximately 6,000 which is minor.
2:03:36 Do you think that these can save a salary position by doing these upgrades?
2:03:40 Is it that much work that it time that it can save or not really over time like over a year
2:03:47 possibly? I don't because we still have to go in and review. It's not automatically redacted.
2:03:55 It still requires human still have to put eyes on it to make sure it does what it's supposed to do.
2:04:03 Right. Because it what it what it does now with the the driver's licenses is it will kind of put a gray box on it so that way you can
2:04:11 see what it's detecting, but I have to go in and finalize it like to authorize that. Yes, that's correct. So then I
2:04:17 finalize it and move it through the process.
2:04:21 Just make it easier and quicker for you to be able to highlight and get right. I can go right to that page where that box is at and and see if that's
2:04:28 what is supposed to be redacted or not versus before it would be line by line by line.
2:04:33 So it's kind of like docuign where it says come here next, right? Take action. Come here nextction.
2:04:40 That's a good time save a lot of time. Great. I'm glad you're excited. I am too.
2:04:46 I'm excited. Is that Are those updates in here? They are included in the budget. Okay.
2:04:51 Laser fish and just Okay. Um just a couple of questions of me. It's more or less cemetery. You say
2:04:58 40% increase in in the sales of cemetery.
2:05:02 Even when we put a we changed the rule that you have to be a semi-resident now
2:05:08 in order to buy a cemetery plot. No. Um and we still up 40%. Is that because
2:05:15 people buying and trying to preserve now because they think we're running out of land. Of course, the other part of that I know we purchased the lots and we
2:05:23 converted the two lots that we homes that we purchased tore down and added more territory over there. So how much how much How many years we looking at?
2:05:32 So, currently we have approximately 375 ground spaces left. That does not include the fourth edition. Okay.
2:05:40 The fourth edition is the the two properties that was purchased about two years ago. Two years ago on East Avenue.
2:05:47 With those two properties, that would bring in approximately 700 more inground spaces. So, we're looking at probably
2:05:56 selling out in the next, I would say, eight years. Seven to eight years.
2:06:01 That's should we consider buying land maybe? Yes. My next question. There has been discussion about that.
2:06:09 And then we had a previous count we had a I don't know if it was one to two years ago the council did not want to move forward with purchasing additional
2:06:18 land. Um, but it's it's on our radar because we will be selling out in the next.
2:06:24 Well, we not like we need to we bought we bought the two as it say we bought the two lots there on East Avenue next to Bishop Field. Um, and we
2:06:33 converted we total homes down and we made most. There's two more homes sitting there that we kind of like went to the owners of those also and said um
2:06:42 if you decided to sell them, give us first choice because we're looking at that as well. And I know it's another piece of property that we've been trying
2:06:50 to acre land that's behind the homes on the other side of the cemetery over there behind the church and the homes
2:06:58 there off of uh what's that Anderson thing we trying what's that my understanding is that those owners do not want to stop.
2:07:06 Yeah well we we we've been asking them about it for a while and all but I I happened to see the owner a couple months ago she was here for for a
2:07:15 funeral and I encounter spoke with her and she said maybe um give it a talk. I know before we negotiate with the mother and the mother didn't really want to
2:07:24 talk with us but I as the owner was here a couple months ago so we may maybe get
2:07:32 do the fees that we pay for lots lots do they pay for the cost of the purchase
2:07:42 and maintenance of the land I don't believe that it covers the the cost um we are currently ly evaluating
2:07:50 what other cities charge and we are looking at possibly bringing back a resolution for the increase. We're doing
2:07:58 our research now and I don't know how cemeteries function. I've never done that.
2:08:05 Um but I'd be interested in knowing it seems like from a policy perspective if the people I think it's good for a city
2:08:12 to have a place for its residents to be buried. Yes. So start with that.
2:08:16 Um but and you're dedicating land to an individual at some point. And so, how
2:08:24 does that how does that pay for itself if not everybody can be there? You know, because then other people are paying for
2:08:31 someone else's plot. So, philosophically, I'm questioning things like that.
2:08:36 And then I also question, is it better to have a cemetery be bigger or is it better to have because we're
2:08:44 spread out so much? Might we look at land in this way? Might we look the east side of town so people can be very close to their home closer to where their actual home was.
2:08:55 Is that something? And then how I mean I see cemeteries as like parks. You have
2:09:02 to be quiet in them, but I think they tend to be peaceful and quiet.
2:09:07 Usually they have trees and they're nice to walk in and so I I see them that way.
2:09:13 So I don't know if they should be close to what commerce. Should they be close to open space? I don't know enough about
2:09:21 cemeteries. I do know, and I'm saying I'm interested in learning more if there's a conversation about it. And those are some of the questions that I
2:09:29 would have. I yeah I I would love to in the next year calendar year in preparation for
2:09:37 fiscal year 28 have a workshop about because a lot of communities have decided that they they just can't be in the cemetery business as a city as a
2:09:46 municipality because it isn't the highest and best use of the land or um you know in declining resources. It's just not
2:09:55 something that they can they can help sustain. And so either it has to be fully sustainable, right?
2:10:02 Meaning those the fees have to the revenues have to match the expenditures so that it's paid for itself. Um and and
2:10:11 like you said, at some point you do run out of the space and so then it becomes a do you add new ones? Do you build do
2:10:19 you build you know mausoleums up so that you have more space? you know, it becomes a it's a obviously a sensitive
2:10:26 subject, but it's also a realistic subject because it it is a cost and it is an expenditure. And um I think as far
2:10:35 as I remember we really the previous council's outside of kind of the budget cycle and the occasional re resolution
2:10:42 to adjust fees really hasn't had a philosophical conversation about should the city of Clermont be in the
2:10:51 cemetery business or is that something that's better served through the you know churches and and and private sector.
2:10:59 Um and so Yeah, I would support a workshop, you know, at some point next end of this calendar year, next beginning of next calendar year to in preparation for the next.
2:11:09 We your previous council did have had that conversation, Bryan. Uh like say we considered getting out of the business
2:11:18 after we purchased the land the last the yeah the last landing we said okay we filled up there we can't find land and we get out of the business
2:11:26 of cemetery business and everything and eventually we we're not going to it's not going to ever pay for itself I don't
2:11:34 think a cemetery will never pay for itself uh because to try to maintain it and keep it off we only paying a small
2:11:40 amount for example Um, back in 2006, I bought 12 plots at $300 a plot. Okay,
2:11:47 $3,600. Now, have that been used up because they still being maintained out there? I know we raised the price because we had more people coming in.
2:11:55 That's another reason we changed the policy. Uh, we have more people coming in from outside city, Orlando, Winter Garden, buying
2:12:05 buying plots here because it was so much cheaper. You go to Woodland over there, it's about $8,000 or so for a plot.
2:12:12 And I think we only charge what about 15 still?
2:12:14 1,400 for residents. And we do not sell in ground to non-resident, right? See, and everything. So we still
2:12:21 pretty low. And so uh people some people that's not that's living uninccorporated come out, they get a little upset when they can't buy a plot. Okay. because
2:12:30 they're not actually resc one other reason I asked that question
2:12:42 about cemetery and I heard you say you talk about being in the resolution that we maybe need to look at raising our prices to help maintain
2:12:50 well and I think too I mean it's just I I think our city clerk I went to a conference recently And when
2:12:59 I when they said I was from Clermont, the person stopped me at the break.
2:13:03 Sorry to embarrass you, but they said, "Your city clerk is the best is the best." I can tell that
2:13:11 like the state of Florida, everybody knows your city clerk. Yes.
2:13:18 And so what I'm about I say that because you're due that credit. You are, but I
2:13:26 also You're not a cemetery expert and we work closely with the public services department.
2:13:33 Well, but even then like there are people who go to school to to run funeral homes and work in this business.
2:13:41 And so how do we know that what we're doing is is in that industry standard even right
2:13:48 now. And I think that's where that workshop might be able to to to partner with some experts in the industry that you should do it at Halloween.
2:13:56 Oh, no. Well, I I mean we could do that.
2:14:01 We could like decorate chasers and everything.
2:14:04 I'll say this, Bryan. You didn't answer me that question because do I get a lot of compliments everywhere I go crazy,
2:14:12 but I also get a lot of compliments on how great our cemetery is.
2:14:16 And I've heard that too. And that's I was shocked when I moved here that Clermont still had one and and was operating like it wasn't just one that
2:14:24 we maintained. we were actively operating and and when the council approved the two extra lots and I'm like wow this is something that really is a
2:14:32 an investment that this community has decided to make for its residents and I think that that speaks that says something and if it really is
2:14:39 something that is the residents are speaking saying we want to continue this we we don't want it to end then I think we have to start thinking
2:14:48 about what do we do for the future moving forward you're right with finding uh finding space I mean heck Arlington Cemetery is running out of space.
2:14:58 You know what I'm saying?
2:15:01 I think what we should really do is get a consultant like you said we're trying to we're trying to invent something we don't really have knowledge of but there's probably people that this is
2:15:10 what they do for a living and there probably think I don't know you know maybe it is maybe you go on top how do you you know I don't know it's it's kind
2:15:17 of like it's kind of uncomfortable talking about it but I mean I imagine you know a hundred years is there you
2:15:25 know there's probably rules and regulations when you could you know top you have, you know, multiple monuments closer together, etc., etc. But like you
2:15:33 said, maybe do a workshop, hire a consultant to come in. Yes.
2:15:37 And give us some direction and then we can go. Yeah. Well, only two things are guaranteed. A death and taxes. Well, and you don't have to pay taxes.
2:15:46 You go to jail.
2:15:48 You don't have to pay tax anymore, right?
2:15:52 Um, that's funny because it goes to a conversation that the chief and I were just having back there about I was once told I should be a lawyer instead.
2:15:59 But no, I just wanted I just wanted some clarity how much how many years we're looking at and should we like say have this conversation again?
2:16:08 We should do we want to stay in this business or I know I think last year year before last bro was looking at
2:16:15 trying to turn their their cemeteries over to one of the churches over and everything. So it get to be expense after a while.
2:16:23 Do we know if they Well, I would I'm sorry. Do we know if Groveland had any consultants come in and talk to them?
2:16:28 Maybe watch a video of something they've already done. But but yes, I support.
2:16:34 If you don't want to do it at Halloween, fine.
2:16:36 No, we don't want to do another time of year. I do November. I do have two non- cemeteries afterward.
2:16:45 Okay. Um, one is, uh, I I I continually get asked about, um, the the software
2:16:52 that we use to publish our agendas. I I I know that there is a notification system that's built in there somehow,
2:17:01 but I don't know what it would take for us to implement and if that would have any budget budgetary. And where I'm
2:17:08 asking is for the rest of the council, you know, when when the clerk's office posts an agenda, a person can like when
2:17:16 I first moved here, I signed up to get these notifications, but they're not turned on, I don't think, or they're not
2:17:23 active. And so, occasionally, and I did that for Minnola as well, and occasionally I'll get like the random email from the city of Minnola saying
2:17:30 this agenda's been posted, and it's not consistent. So, I don't know what they do, but I I don't think we have ever done that as a community, as a city.
2:17:38 I believe we need to work with our IT department on that together.
2:17:43 Okay. And I just didn't know if there would be budget implications with that.
2:17:47 If we have to if that's a, you know, like a purchase we have to to get from that software.
2:17:53 That's something I will look further into it. Okay. and then and we can I can get back to you because I do think it would be helpful for our community for folks who want to
2:18:02 sign up for PNC agendas or city council agendas that they get that email saying it's live it's here um or you know uh I
2:18:11 don't know what kind of software is options are in there but I ask because I'm more concerned about right now do are there budget implications of that
2:18:20 on that note this there's this software conversation kind of not So, I like that. And to go
2:18:28 further, if we could have an app for our citizens for the city of Clermont, it could be that the app might sync with,
2:18:36 hey, or maybe our social media platform that the consultant was saying, you know, I forget it's called social or
2:18:44 something, whatever that, you know, is there a way that our current system speaks to my Clermont?
2:18:51 Yeah, my might speak to the app.
2:18:54 I mean, it would be amazing if I had map. It's like, oh, new minutes were dropped if I wanted the notification.
2:19:01 Well, I thought there was because I get some I have some residents telling me sometime they they get notification that the uh agenda been post.
2:19:09 Really? Yeah. I know. I I know you all send it to us. I get it from the code all the time.
2:19:15 Well, yeah, that's the council notification. Yeah.
2:19:19 It's not an automatic thing. Yeah. where if you know and I and I don't want to add work that's not what I'm asking to do but but if there's soft if we have to
2:19:26 buy the add-on yeah I'd be interested to know what that cost would be if it's there that that then a citizen could go in put their name and email and they just get added to the
2:19:35 database and every time that category that they've signed up for gets updated boom they get the email the other item
2:19:42 and I know we've talked about this before but it's budget and I I want to talk about it from the numbers perspective too is how we do our public notices
2:19:50 Um and um you know I've had some numbers run based off of 2025 and if we right now we do all of our
2:19:59 public notifications in the daily commercial um and our surrounding communities um Groveland Minnola Mont uh
2:20:09 the other South Lake communities do everything through the the Clermont Sun. Um, now I know the Clermont Sun is weekly versus daily commercials daily.
2:20:20 Uh, but they have figured out ways to make this work and and I I had some numbers run based off of just May 2025
2:20:28 invoice, which was one of our higher invoices for 2025. And we spent almost $7,000 on the daily commercial for our public notices in May of 25.
2:20:38 If we'd have done those same notifications in the Clermont Sun, we would have spent 5,000. That's a that's
2:20:44 a 30% savings. Um so if each month we could save on average 30% based off 2025
2:20:52 numbers that's actually about $13,000 that we could save by going through the Clermont Sun which we
2:21:00 could which now I the so there's a numbers issue there's also a a
2:21:08 distribution issue. Daily Commercial is a subscription-based Leburg newspaper that does really very little Clermont
2:21:17 reporting, South Lake reporting.
2:21:20 Um the the the Sun does more South Lake reporting exclusive for South
2:21:28 and there's their distribution is about 20ome,000 people that get the Clermont Sun either electronically or in print
2:21:37 versus a few thousand in the daily commercial.
2:21:42 Um, so from a transparency standpoint too, I think we we have some opportunities to save some money. We
2:21:51 have some opportunities to do better distribution. That money actually stays local, right?
2:21:56 So, Guanette owns the daily commercial that goes back to Guanette. Uh, the Clermont Sun is is Florida Florida
2:22:03 owned. It stays in Central Florida. Um, and we've already seen some benefits with our Clermont page that we have.
2:22:10 Um, and then obviously we would join our other South Lake communities like Groveland, Minnola, Montbird. Um, and we would still have the opportunity. I
2:22:18 would never want to hamstring our our our clerk's office that if something came up where we couldn't meet the the
2:22:27 the I know it's a little bit more of extended deadline for Clermont Sun, then put it in the commercial. put it in
2:22:34 the Orlando Sentinel. That's what that's what Mola Mont and Groin does now. Oh.
2:22:40 With theirs, if they have something that they can't they call up the Clermont Sun and they can't meet it, they can't meet that deadline, they just put it in, okay,
2:22:48 the Clermont Sun or and that's our ordinance. We we say where it goes. So, we can control that. We can have a oneoff.
2:22:54 Um, but I know in the past we've had some concerns about the timing. And I've
2:23:00 been looking lately at our agendas and when when the clerk's office because in
2:23:08 the back, I don't know if you noticed, but like the last page of of a packet of an agenda item that gets noticed, it says when it was actually like put out
2:23:17 there and I've been looking out and like we can meet those guidelines pretty pretty regularly if we allow the clerk
2:23:26 and primarily planning department or the two big departments. Um I know there's others, but if we give them enough heads
2:23:35 up notice that we want to implement this that they just have to rework some procedures and processes. And so I I
2:23:42 brought it up because I I think if we're looking for ways to improve other areas, but also not just add money to the
2:23:50 budget, but also be more transparent and be more informative, this might be an opportunity for us to really look at and
2:23:57 So, I bring it up. I welcome feedback. I know it will be a change, but yeah. So, we did look into this look into it.
2:24:04 We've looked at it twice over the last few years. Yeah. Okay.
2:24:07 The city requires 14 days notice prior to a public hearing. Yep.
2:24:12 Which is more than what the state requires. The state requires 10. The city requires 14.
2:24:18 Is that an ordinance or That's our Yes. because of the 14 days and our council meets on Tuesdays, we
2:24:25 have to advertise on a Monday or a Tuesday. And my understanding with the sun is their weekly is on a Wednesday.
2:24:32 So we have to do the Wednesday before which would which would mean basically three weeks prior to and a lot of times we do not get the ads
2:24:40 from departments until that last minute especially when we are pushing forward ordinances that are being written just
2:24:49 before a meeting. Let's say it's the week before.
2:24:53 It would be difficult for us to meet that deadline, but that's on volume of ordinances.
2:24:59 But is that b b b b b b b b b b b b b b b b b b b b b b b b b b b b b b b b b b b b b b b based off of when you're getting the information from the departments. It varies.
2:25:05 Well, but she's still saying they publish on Wednesday. But they publish on Wednesday.
2:25:11 So in order to publishing then 20 days prior to public hearing, we don't always have that information
2:25:18 if if we So it will potentially slow us down especially initially until we would
2:25:26 adapt to a new process of okay we need to be ready three weeks in advance versus two or we say we have to have the
2:25:34 philosophical conversation of is the 10day the state requirement does that meet our needs versus the 14 days that
2:25:41 we currently have in our ordinance because that's something we control.
2:25:45 We've we previous council has said 14 versus 10.
2:25:50 So how how many days uh what is Groman and Mola going?
2:25:54 Well, and that's the other thing. I mean probably I don't know if they're 10 or 14, but and they meet on Mondays,
2:26:02 Tuesdays as well. I mean, they're making it work. It's just we have to figure out the system that makes it work for us.
2:26:08 And I don't I don't want to do this today. I I I think that would be unfair for uh the city clerk's office and our
2:26:15 departments that have these public notices to say we need to do this today, right?
2:26:20 And that's why I bring it up in the budget process because budget takes effect in October if we had time to put in place if we need to make changes in
2:26:28 our ordinances to make this happen. This gives everybody that leeway some time and we still have the one-off option. I
2:26:36 would never want to change the, you know, tie the hands that a oneoff couldn't be done in the daily commercial or couldn't be done in the If you start doing that, then you got to bring the cost equal.
2:26:46 Well, but it needs to be a true one-off, right?
2:26:49 I think it needs to be that true one-off, not. We just didn't plan ahead.
2:26:52 I I don't know if the cost savings is worth it. I mean, it's not that huge amount of savings here. And I mean, like Tracy had said, you know, we we've had
2:27:01 the discussion multiple times before and for some reasons it it doesn't work out for us, right? And we also sent them a number of
2:27:08 ads to do a comparison and we did not see a significant savings and on several we it was maybe a5 to$10 savings. Not
2:27:17 this is a d this is a sidebyside I'm happy to share um uh with the council um
2:27:24 and and with with you Tracy as well. Um well even if it's not even if it doesn't save any money I think you make valid
2:27:32 points that are consistent with what we've been talking about. if we want to support small business, if we want to support local business.
2:27:38 I do think and you're speaking to me on that level and I think the other issues that relate here are
2:27:46 to your point at some point a decision was made that two weeks notice is the appropriate amount of notice. If we go
2:27:54 to the statuto notice, there could be a perception that we're trying to disengage the public because we're going
2:28:01 to 10 days instead of 14 days. from a practical perspective, are we really talking about a Wednesday instead of a Tuesday publication? So even though
2:28:09 we're compliant with the 10 days, is it really 13 instead of 14? And so again, it might be it might be an
2:28:16 inconsequential issue there. And then there's also I've heard Christian tell us at least 10 times we can talk about
2:28:23 whatever business we want at these meetings. And so as long as we notice a meeting, I don't think the agenda has to be perfect.
2:28:31 Well, these are the actual statutory public notifications like for an ordinance that you have to do. That's what these Yeah. I'm not talking about like a public notice for the actual
2:28:40 meeting. I'm talking Yeah. So, we would have to do these whether the sun or or uh commercial or sentinel or wherever.
2:28:49 What's interesting to me is that in 2026 we're spending $7,000 a week on publication. That exists. No, that was a month. What? That's a month. That was a month.
2:28:58 Isn't a month? But that's state law requires.
2:29:00 State law requires state law requires a a paper to be paper.
2:29:04 You know, I'm going to digress. I started practicing law in 2005 and we still had to use fax machine.
2:29:10 Like I actually know how to use fax machine. Most people my age don't even know what I'm talking about. I think we should do a workshop on this.
2:29:17 You know, well, I don't I think the question becomes, do we want to direct the city manager? Because to an extent um you did
2:29:25 this to me yesterday, so so I'll turn you your medicine, right? So to an extent we're telling the city manager what to do. However, I think that if we
2:29:34 were to say we have a desire to work with local business. Now we have a legal issue potentially that's been brought up that you know but if we're directing the
2:29:43 city manager that we want to work with local business whenever we can. We want to reach the people whenever we can. You
2:29:50 make a valid point. I think even if it costs the same or a little more I think the point is valid. And then there's the techn the technical like can we and then
2:29:59 if it comes back on us are we willing to change our ordinance our policy whatever it is to say we want to be compliant with Florida law or we want to be
2:30:07 compliant. I think if we go to three weeks that would not be good because we just applauded our building services department for being quick on doing permits and we would be slowing down.
2:30:18 We'd be extending a week for every development which sometimes happens monthly because of the way that our meetings run. So, I think that that would not I would not choose to go
2:30:27 longer. I don't think that would be wise. I could get to the 10day statutory if we needed to. I'm not dying on any of these hills. I think that
2:30:36 but but I think sending the message to the to the city manager, we want to work with local business and we want to reach the people and engage the people and if that happens to be Clermont Sun and you
2:30:44 can figure out a way to make it work, I think that's fantastic.
2:30:47 Yeah, I I there it is. There's a financial, but for me, even if given the choice of getting it to 22,000 people
2:30:57 versus a couple thousand people and it costs the same, I'm and it's local, I'm going the 22,000 all day, every day.
2:31:05 Um, and so I I and it's a budget item because it does affect our budget. So that's why I I ask about it here.
2:31:12 Well, I heard Mr. Peterson say it's not much of a cost saving. To me it is big saving because as you say we only reaching a thousand people or so with
2:31:20 the commercial way reaching 22,000 see costwise and everything. So how many people read the newspaper?
2:31:30 Well, and I'm surprised you own this 22,000.
2:31:35 You send us 22,000 when the son when I when it was the news leader and I used to have to process them papers. I were
2:31:43 doing almost 60,000 papers a week for the son years ago. So uh and when I retired I think I was doing about 33,000 paper.
2:31:52 My understanding it's like 20ome now. 22 I think.
2:31:56 because I think uh they used to also have a paper for
2:32:02 what was it? Uh very uh Mount Dor used to go to Mount Dor and all and do growth
2:32:10 and everything but I uh I stopped processing the Mount Dor brought it down to about 33,000 conversations.
2:32:16 Well, it might be interesting to have conversations with the local newspaper if you got to $4,000 on the line. They might say we'll change our distribution.
2:32:25 You never know. Small business. That's the benefit of the small business.
2:32:27 I don't think I don't think they're gonna change.
2:32:33 But what the challenge is and staff's happy to look at the options and if I and I'm going to put you on the
2:32:40 spot, Tracy. I apologize. But I believe a couple years ago there was a statute passed that said we can now advertise them on the website as long as we post
2:32:48 them in a published newspaper once a year. It has to be on a county website. Oh, it's a county website.
2:32:54 It has to be on the county website, not the city.
2:32:56 Okay. On our legislature and there would still be an additional cost. There would still be a cost to publish it on our website.
2:33:07 It amongst the city. It doesn't make sense, but city polic
2:33:14 run the conversation of part of the reason uh the potential referendums out there is to consolidate power and make
2:33:23 make county governments more powerful than municipal local when you come from that angle. Yeah.
2:33:30 And that same that same law is what opened up for the son to be able to advertise man because when they passed all that the local newspapers start want
2:33:38 to come in and that's when you start having all these conversations that yeah I I I apologize I thought it was cities also that that's kind of odd that I wouldn't as a city member think of
2:33:47 looking at a county website this is good because this is this is stimulating the conversation about
2:33:54 process and reaching the people and if there's something that we can go to the legislature and say hey it's 2026 we
2:34:03 want to be able to publish it on our website can social media work can email newsletter work. Like, are there ways that we could because now you're talking
2:34:11 how much do we spend on publications a year? Are we pushing six figures? Oh, yes. Yeah.
2:34:16 That right there is, hey, if the legislature is going to say you need to cut your budget and we want you to cut your budget, well, we need to be able to
2:34:23 comply with the way people live today in 202.
2:34:28 You can still read the newspaper, but the 21st century digital, the digital age, you're saying that we're what's the word you use? as we mature.
2:34:36 as we mature. As we mature.
2:34:38 Are you you just threw that back at me again.
2:34:42 So if we can maybe that's something that we put on our legislative initiatives next year because that's a six figure impact and that
2:34:49 seriously seriously an easy one for that change.
2:34:52 They could change that very easily and cities. In the meantime, Mr.
2:34:59 If we changed it to 10 days, that would help us to be able to work better with the sun because we've sincerely looked at this and found it difficult over and
2:35:08 over because we would rather work local if possible.
2:35:11 Well, the 10 the 14 and 10 day well 10 days we have to because state, but the 14 is our resolution uh ordinance. So,
2:35:18 we can change that. So, that's what if we made it 13.
2:35:23 I'm looking. I I mean, why don't we go to 10, which is a state requirement.
2:35:28 I'm got I'm on a roll today. I don't know what's going on.
2:35:33 Halloween 13. She just wants to get in the cemetery. That's all. All right.
2:35:39 No, I had that conversation. I No, I mean why why her for anything else?
2:35:47 No, you would though. Sorry. I can't. Thank you, Miss Tracy. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
2:35:55 All right.
2:35:58 Yes, that's a lucky number. 13. Okay.
2:36:06 Well, maybe we do one more before. Yes. Who we HR? HR. HR. Yay.
2:36:14 Let me get out my book. Sorry.
2:36:33 Yes, ma'am. Hello.
2:36:47 All right. So, human resources were a staff of seven and we uh supported
2:36:54 528 positions and 471 active employees in the last uh fiscal year. We assisted
2:37:02 in recruiting and onboarding 92 hires uh just since 10125 which is a 25% increase during that period. We've assisted
2:37:11 multiple departments with reorganizations and we successfully implemented a new medical and dental administrator as well as a pharmacy benefit manager.
2:37:21 And you just filled the important position as I understand. Yes. How long was that vacant? Um since March of 2025.
2:37:31 Wow.
2:37:32 And that was like a director position or assistant director. What position was it? HR and benefits manager.
2:37:40 I'm happy to hear that you have that filled. Me, too. Fantastic. You say benefits manager.
2:37:48 Mhm.
2:37:49 Of course. I thought looking this, I thought that was already filled. I see we changed the uh coordinator,
2:37:56 added a coordinator this year, but we eliminated the uh benefits coordinator, but the benefits and risk coordinator eliminated eliminated.
2:38:05 No, we have the same number of FTE.
2:38:08 Yeah, I've uh changed the job title of the benefits coordinator to benefits and risk coordinator. Changing the job duties a little bit.
2:38:17 Yep.
2:38:17 And the wellness and safety coordinator has always been part of the HR team.
2:38:23 So the benefit coordinator no longer exists.
2:38:26 It is now a benefits and risk coordinator.
2:38:28 Okay. Well, I see both of them here. But I guess that's all because both of them are listed here.
2:38:35 You know I saying you change one and the other but we can eliminate benefits coordinator. Okay.
2:38:40 And what's the difference? What's the additional responsibility? What does risk mean?
2:38:45 Risk management is um it's a a grand title that involves all of the city's claims, the property and liability
2:38:54 claims, auto claims, uh workers comp, um that sort of thing. So this particular position will be assisting um coordinating the risk claims.
2:39:04 Thank you.
2:39:08 So part of city uh part of the city's HR function involves of course the traditional HR things recruitment comp
2:39:16 and class um compensation and classification employee and labor relations but it also includes risk management benefits management and wellness programs.
2:39:27 Excellent.
2:39:30 So, the city's um HR's budget uh overall budget is showing a 9.8% increase um which is approximately $78,000.
2:39:41 The majority of that about 87% of that increase is in personnel costs.
2:39:56 You all have any questions for me?
2:40:01 My understanding is you're still working on some benefit related and insurance related quotes for us to finalize the budget. Is that accurate?
2:40:09 Yes. So, uh the city's health plan is on a calendar year basis. It runs 111 through 1231. So, um right now we've got
2:40:18 five months worth of claims data. If you recall, we unbundled everything and so we have a separate pharmacy benefit
2:40:25 manager, separate TPA and so we've got five months of data right now and um the stop we are shopping the stop loss and
2:40:34 um they prefer to have more claims data in order to give a firm quote. So we expect to see that in August and we
2:40:42 typically will come back to council in September um for more solid numbers. So that will be the plan to come back to you that.
2:40:51 Okay. What was the insurance last year?
2:41:02 What did the actual figure come about?
2:41:03 The insurance increase last year? I can't remember.
2:41:09 As far as insurance, as far as claims or total expenditures, which one?
2:41:16 Insurance cost increase. insurance, general liability, disability. Which one? All of them.
2:41:21 All for calendar year 2025, we had a 9% increase in total expenditures
2:41:29 for insurance, but we are we built this budget on a 7%. We built this budget on a 7%. Yes.
2:41:37 So, we anticipating insurance costs to go down and not up.
2:41:43 uh we are anticipating a 7% increase will be sufficient for for this budget year.
2:41:50 So when we get firm numbers from stop loss in um in August we'll have a more firm idea of what we can anticipate. So
2:42:00 um as far as claims are concerned that we're anticipating a 7%. I'm just I'm just saying we built this budget on a 7
2:42:07 with an anticipated 7 in 7% increase in cost with last year. We end up with a 9%
2:42:14 increase. So why didn't we build it 9% because cost of insurance right now I don't
2:42:21 think it's going to be going down too much. So I think we've been more realistic on a 9% even maybe a 10%
2:42:30 because I remember one year we built it looked at about Uh we talking about a 10% increase and it came in 1516. So it
2:42:38 kind of goes for a haywire. So it's a good point. Yeah.
2:42:42 Um we're estimating a 7% right now. It is purely an estimate. Right.
2:42:49 I looked at it myself and our plan is performing well.
2:42:54 um it's been performing better than expected and while our plan is small and the numbers do fluctuate every year um I
2:43:03 anticipate that if if it does come in higher our reserves are good enough that we can support anything higher
2:43:13 and if if our projections come in much higher than 7% come August September when we present to council I imagine
2:43:21 that in the finance department we can make a slight adjustment to the budget if needed.
2:43:26 Slight adjustment and I guess that's what but me when I I I look for budget I like doing things when it comes to this.
2:43:32 I I rather estimate high rather than not enough and everything. So I rather be able to uh overestimate rather than
2:43:40 underestimate when it comes to insurance and things like that because we have to make adjustment at the end if we if we underestimate these things. So
2:43:47 well let me give you some numbers before you get too committed to that. Um Scott, last year we talked about the total cost
2:43:54 of health insurance and it's some of it split between the enterprise funds as I recall and the general fund. Correct.
2:44:02 Yeah. And my recollection was last year we budgeted about 8.5 million in insurance. Does that sound right?
2:44:10 It does.
2:44:12 And ultimately I'll be asking you what we're budgeting this year. Um, is would there be a reason why at the
2:44:19 50% point of the year our insurance would be is there a potential that the insurance actual numbers for 2026 for
2:44:29 the last half of the year would be different or inconsistent with the insurance numbers for the first half of the year?
2:44:37 There certainly could be for a couple reasons. uh one is claims history which is very difficult to predict obviously
2:44:44 uh but secondly would be dependent upon the level of uh vacancies that exist and when we talk about conserving conservative budgeting practices.
2:44:56 Health insurance is probably the area that that is most prevalent in because we are so conservative with our
2:45:04 budgeting approach on in terms of how we apply increase anticipated increases and premiums towards proposed new positions
2:45:14 and vacancies. Um which is a long- winded way of saying um
2:45:21 we may be overly conservative with those projections. Well, and the reason why I asked is because when I look at the first half of the year, almost every
2:45:30 department's line item for group insurance, life insurance, disability were and workers comp, well, at least
2:45:38 the first three were under 40% at the midway point through the year. So, if we are operating conservatively and we're
2:45:47 at 20%, if we're operating at 80% of what we budgeted on a almost $10 million budget, that's several million dollars. We're not talking about hundred thousand.
2:45:57 We're talking about millions. And when 1.1 mil is $700,000, if we're off on our estimates by 10%,
2:46:07 that's.1 mil. So, I'm interested in UAL numbers. I'm hearing you say more time.
2:46:14 I have prepared something. Okay. I can share if you guys are interested.
2:46:19 So I think this is the single most important item.
2:46:23 Dan, could you Okay. Um, one note I was going to make as part of that conversation
2:46:31 was that we anticipate adding on 11. If you recall, we hired 15 firefighters and
2:46:39 so we anticipate adding on 11 new firefighters come August 1st onto the insurance plan. So while right now
2:46:47 through May, as we projected, we're looking good. Our plan is performing well. It's such a
2:46:55 wild card come August, you know, that is part of what we have to anticipate is adding a lot more lives to the plan.
2:47:04 Um so if I can walk you through this for a moment. Um these these numbers come from a report that we have to file um
2:47:13 with the state every single year. This Florida statutes require us to hire an actuary to file this report. So these
2:47:21 numbers come straight from there. And um just briefly I can tell you so you know our plan is self-funded meaning the city
2:47:30 um the city pays directly for the claims. We hire a separate TPA that adjudicates claims and pays that for us.
2:47:38 And then we also hire a stop-loss company so that we're only assuming the risk up to 200,000 per member. So, um,
2:47:48 the benefit of that, and this is part of why I wanted to show this to you, the benefit of that is in any given year, if our claims perform better than what was
2:47:57 projected, we we keep the extra. We keep, you know, we don't have another company that's holding on to that
2:48:05 profit. So, as you can see here, um with every year at the top, I'm showing
2:48:12 you revenues. Um then I'll show you claims at the next line. And you can see the claims um are up and down. For 21,
2:48:22 the claims went up 8%. For 22, the claims went down 5%, then back up 10%,
2:48:28 down 2% with last year being at 6%. So, they are up and down and part of that reason is because we're a smaller plan.
2:48:37 The 5-year average, as I mentioned last time we met, was only a 3.5% change in claims, which is better than national numbers.
2:48:48 And then as far as total expenditures, the 5-year average was a 4% change. So, when we look at the ending
2:48:57 cash, I've got it highlighted there for you in green. And just below it, target ending cash of 33%. So whenever the
2:49:05 Florida uh the state of Florida is looking at our plan to ensure that we'll be able to continue being self self-funded, um they're looking at
2:49:14 making sure that our reserves are at 33% of claims.
2:49:18 And so that's the target number that we want to be at. So if you look at the next green line that's labeled ending
2:49:25 cash percent of claims, that tells you where we're at. So if we start with calendar year 2020, we were below that target.
2:49:34 Uh we were even more below that target in 21. But then um in calendar year 22, we did receive some fun additional
2:49:41 funding from council. We had to go back to council to um receive money. A lot of that was ARPA funding.
2:49:49 So then in calendar year 23 you see that um we're now at 62% and our plan has continued to perform better than we have
2:49:58 projected. And so when we um when we set those contribution levels we set them based upon what that claims projection
2:50:07 is which is coming from the stop loss insurance underwriters. And um we're performing better than that thanks to
2:50:14 employees who are doing well and healthy um managing the
2:50:20 claims with us. So you can see by calendar year 2025 and that's based on actuals our reserves are
2:50:29 at 116%. So we're doing well with our plant and the reserves. So, what I I had
2:50:37 um recommended to Rick and um Scott is to consider um giving a one month
2:50:46 premium holiday, which means we will not charge deductions for one month. That's two pay periods, which equates to about $475,000.
2:50:55 And by doing so, um we can reduce the reserve a little bit. Let me follow up and and tie that to council member
2:51:04 Strange's comment about the relationship to millillage. All of this data that Naen just walked you through relates to
2:51:10 the self- insurance fund itself. And one of the primary funding sources to this is the employer contributions which come
2:51:19 from the general fund. So while we may while mayor we are projecting our um insurance increase to be 7%.
2:51:29 Um what we've done as Naen just explained is that interfund transfer that covers the employers portion from the general fund we budgeted at 6.2%.
2:51:40 In an effort to reduce this fund balance and reduce cost within the general fund. Is that in the budget right now?
2:51:48 That is in the budget. Yes.
2:51:55 Now, we didn't want to get more aggressive than a 0.8 lower than the claim his anticipate costs in in
2:52:04 insurance just out of concern and conservatism for what claim history might do. But it is a due diligence
2:52:11 effort to reduce the impact on the general fund and uh try to start utilizing this fund balance in the health insurance fund.
2:52:21 So how much does uh for a family how much are employees paying each month for their family policy?
2:52:31 Did I print it?
2:52:33 Um I don't have it memorized. We have two different plans. One plan may be
2:52:40 $300, the next plan may be $200. That is such a rounded number. And that is not per month. I apologize.
2:52:48 That is per year. Oh, so $600. 600.
2:52:54 And how much does the city pay per paycheck?
2:52:57 Per employee or what do we pay per however is the easiest way for you to answer it? I What's the question?
2:53:02 Between 600 and 700. I'm not sure. I wish I had my last per paycheck.
2:53:12 Per paycheck.
2:53:13 That was per paycheck. I do have the the number um number that we spend per year.
2:53:24 On average, city spends 17.5,000 per year. So we have core tiers uh for
2:53:32 for employee employee spouse employee child and family coverage. All of that is number.
2:53:39 So if we're spending 17,000 per year and then the employees are roughly half that they're also paying roughly half.
2:53:47 I don't have that number.
2:53:49 Well they're roughly 300 per paycheck then they're so they're paying another $7,800 give or take.
2:53:57 Split is generally 8 % city 15% employees on the on the bigger
2:54:05 actually employee employees really pay a little bit more than the city employees don't pay more than
2:54:12 well I'm not I mean 80 is it 8020 or 85 85 city 15 employ
2:54:21 no okay um what I'm looking at here claims 26 six
2:54:30 million. So through June no that is the budgeted number the whole budget.
2:54:37 So through May we're about 3.7 million through end of May.
2:54:42 3.7 million. So we about 50% of budget 50% of budget.
2:54:51 We're not over budget.
2:54:54 We're under budget by almost 20% this year to date. Well, what she just done we about 50% of what she budgeted six and she say
2:55:02 oh year to date yes so we're more than we're in July so we're eight months in that's through the end of May through
2:55:10 the end of May five months the 3 million is five months right you say May that's five months
2:55:18 and you budgeted 6 million 6.5 you had 3.7 you said 3.7 so within five months you Basically, it's little over 50% of budget.
2:55:30 That's not I don't believe that's including stop loss reimbursements.
2:55:37 Uh I heard you say so claim you're doing
2:55:44 real good on plane came because you think people are healthy. Um is it that um because of the change of insurance uh
2:55:53 our insurance a lot of them not going to doctors now because of can't some saying they can't afford for that much money that we should be
2:56:01 going to the doctor every month huh for that much money you can go to the doctor every month no well well also the the the u what you
2:56:09 call it deductibles and everything changed at all we did not change any of our benefits
2:56:16 all that we changed was the actual network. We moved from Sigma to United. We didn't change a single B.
2:56:26 Not this time.
2:56:30 Well, I think there's a lot of work to be done because I'm looking at the six-month point and the only department that's over 50% at the six-month mark
2:56:38 was fleet, at least according to the reports that we received, and everybody else was at 40% or less, give or take, maybe 42.
2:56:46 The way that we the contributions, which I believe is what you're looking at. Um, we set the contributions and those don't
2:56:53 change per pay period. So, that stays flat.
2:56:59 And, um, the report that you're looking at, I don't know when it was printed.
2:57:04 Report generated June 4th, 2026 for the period ending the end of April was the six month mark of the year. So, was that for calendar year?
2:57:14 No, six months. April is October. the end of April seven months.
2:57:19 The data I've given you is calendar year just because it's easier to insurance is calendar year. It's not it's not fiscal year.
2:57:30 If the report you're looking at is reflecting fiscal year.
2:57:33 It's through March 31st, 2026 at the 50% mark of the year according to the report we were given.
2:57:40 And here here's folks, we can look at this however we want.
2:57:44 For $250 a month, One of our employees can go to a local doctor, their whole family, and get all their primary care
2:57:52 appointments taken care of for $250 a month.
2:57:56 They can get all their prescriptions called in. They can get all their orders for perare person. No, per month for the whole family.
2:58:05 She's talking about something different.
2:58:06 I'm talking about so when we look at how much of our resources are going to this plan that requires insurance that requires co-ay which requires a system
2:58:15 that restricts who you can go see yes we need to be concerned about catastrophic situations I get that
2:58:23 but right now if you go to a doctor on our current plan you have to pay a fee on top of the monthly payment that you're paying for your insurance that
2:58:31 presumably is giving you care and it's not So, I mean, for $300 per paycheck,
2:58:39 that could be $300 a month that our employees could pay for their whole family to go get whatever care they want at a local doctor's office.
2:58:48 I don't think so.
2:58:48 And then we get a catastrophic. You can you What doctor are you going to call Blue Wellness right now? You can.
2:58:56 I don't know.
2:58:57 It's a It's a primary purpose. It's a primary doesn't exist, but I know for a fact it exists. I can get you quotes right now.
2:59:04 And that's So this is it's to me it's asking the citizens to pay $10 million for a risk plan instead of paying
2:59:14 I we want to talk about what happens if the constitutional amendment takes place the answer's in this it's in changing
2:59:21 the experience that every employee that we have in this city 471 souls and their families can have a healthy lifestyle
2:59:28 healthy living access to doctors the doctor of their choice when they want and we have seven providers in Clermont right now that provide this service outside of an insurance plan.
2:59:39 But what happens what I was going to say? What happens if I have cancer? What happens if I have a heart attack?
2:59:43 Catastrophic plan. That's what you pay for a catastrophic insurance out of pocket for the employee. I'm talking about this is but but I I I hear
2:59:52 what you're saying that I think in order for me to adequately
3:00:01 be able to assess what you're saying compared to what's here is I need a chart I agree with you completely. I've been asking for it for
3:00:08 of left to right in that way. But I also think that you have to consider something that isn't
3:00:16 that isn't going to be able to be concrete in this and that is this is a a a a benefit
3:00:23 that is provided that makes working here equitable reasonable an equitable reasonable attractive thing.
3:00:32 Sure. And I I I I don't I mean I understand the dollars and cents of it,
3:00:39 but I think we have to be careful about how we talk about the dollars and cents of it given that it's it's I don't I
3:00:46 don't think it's as black as black and white.
3:00:49 And I'm frustrated because we had this conversation last year and I'm sitting here today and saying the same exact thing that I saw last year. So I'm
3:00:57 frustrated. So I'm speaking my frustration that it's been a year.
3:01:01 Yeah. and I provided connections and people so that I'm not doing it because I can't and I shouldn't.
3:01:07 Ju just I'm frustrated just just to be communicate we followed every path that I believe was given to
3:01:16 us. We we have and I I will continue what they do to do that. But it's not a lack of effort or diligence at all. I
3:01:25 promise you that we we have talked to everybody I know to talk to. We'll keep it up. Did we go to the chamber and ask
3:01:32 them to connect us with local medical providers to provided I provided if anybody might be interested in in helping us come up with a solution to this.
3:01:41 You had mentioned you had shared this on Facebook. Yeah.
3:01:44 We got a number of resources that were given to us from that and unfortunately
3:01:50 none of those leads came back in a manner that we felt was a good option.
3:01:58 It wasn't that we we're going to have tax reduction. So, we better figure something areas we can say.
3:02:04 I tell you what, I tell you what. Please give me the lead where I can get $250 a month. I'll send it to you.
3:02:09 My whole family will I will be happy to do that.
3:02:13 She gave me the lead and I've given that to Nine and we will diligently pursue and look into. I promise you this is a
3:02:21 big deal. We're listening. We just haven't found the right combination to make this work yet. But, you know, they
3:02:28 we did save money last year that, you know, it's not we're just trying to give our employees a better quality of life that saves them
3:02:36 money and saves the citizens money. And I know there's solutions out there and if I have to do it, it's not in my scope as a council member to do it. It's not
3:02:45 appropriate for me to do it. This is a staff issue, not for me as counsel.
3:02:50 Well, it sounds like they've been doing it and you just don't like the answer.
3:02:54 The answer is do the same thing we've always done.
3:02:57 This is the same system that we've had in place for for however many years, this self- insurance system. And and when you're talking to people that are
3:03:05 doing insurance, you're going to get an insurance answer. When you go to a surgeon, every you know, when you're a hammer, everything's a nail. You have to look at other options. And right now,
3:03:14 it's just insurance. And insurance is diametrically opposed to giving the patient care. Insurance companies don't make money if they pay for patients to
3:03:23 go to the doctor. They don't make money if they pay for patients to get blood work. They don't make money if they negotiate a lower price. They do it for themselves, but they don't do it for for the for the person receiving the care.
3:03:34 Catastrophic. Totally different conversation. That's the gamble. I get that. I'm talking about regular care.
3:03:41 And when insurance became a way for people to have access to their doctor, it changed the entire system. And that's
3:03:48 why we have people who have long-term issues, health issues that stack up and get worse because they're not going to the doctor at the first sign of something.
3:03:58 It sounds like you're talking about a philosophical viewpoint on when when health insurance when health care system
3:04:05 went for profit, that's when all of this happened. And it's not being changed. It's always No, has not. It was not.
3:04:13 1964 is when they changed it to be not for uh for profit. It was not for profit. That's when Yes.
3:04:20 I have um it's um that's something we cannot change on that on on that level or
3:04:27 whatnot. But what we can do is make sure that our employee that our employees and their families have the best care what
3:04:34 we have to work with. And I think it's kind of unreasonable to expect them to find what you're looking for because it doesn't sound like it's cost effective.
3:04:44 I'll put a package together for you, too. How about that? Sounds good.
3:04:47 Do I have permission to do that or am I going to be over?
3:04:50 Let me ask you this, Mr. I mean, if you're paying 250 for for the family, how much is it going to cost them for the car?
3:04:59 Yes.
3:04:59 That's what we should be that's what we should be looking at. If we were to provide catastrophic policies, which
3:05:06 aren't going to be 25 aren't going to be $17,000 a year. If we provide a catastrophic policy and and create I
3:05:14 mean, we have enough there's so much money in this conversation. You could create an endowment fund that
3:05:21 If people pay more than 5,000 a year, you write the check. I mean, there are so many ways to handle this with the amount of money that we're talking about
3:05:29 that we have at our disposal that yes, it's different than everybody gets insurance. I I get that. But when we're
3:05:37 talking about what what was I corrected at the workshop? Oh, we only went up 4%, but we're talking about 7%. So when you have a cost of living that goes up three
3:05:44 to four percent a year, but this one line item consistently seven to nine%.
3:05:49 This is how we don't have money. So if we're going to add employees at market rate by mind you, I mean, we're paying
3:05:56 our employees a salary that's competitive with the private sector. You said yourself, where are you going to get a small business that's paying $100,000? Like how many of our employees
3:06:04 are making $100,000? And then you add 33% in benefits. That's way more than the
3:06:10 private sector and they still can't choose where they're going. But the when you're dealing with this stuff that you make choices about, that market exists
3:06:19 and it's way different today than it was 10 years ago. You got doctors that are fed up with the insurance system altogether, but they're getting out of it and they're starting small practices,
3:06:28 small town doctor. And when you have something, you want to have a relationship with your doctor and know who you're calling. I mean, it's a it's
3:06:34 a better quality of service and care and it's way more affordable. insurance. And my point is simple. We expect this constitutional amendment will pass.
3:06:43 That's what we're talking about. And all I'm saying is I'm a year into saying this is a primary. This this is the thing that changes our finances our
3:06:51 finances and our budget. This could be$2 to4 million. It's huge. And if if we
3:06:58 don't I'm I said what I said. I'm frustrated because I started this a year ago. And if I have to do it, I'll do it.
3:07:05 Strange. I I hear your frustration. I have heard your frustration. We um we we
3:07:12 the first step that we made was to separate these three, you know, to unbundle. Um at the point um where
3:07:19 you've expressed your frustration that that those were that was already in the works because of the way that this is structured. A lot of times that doesn't
3:07:28 happen as quickly as you're desiring. Um I've already engaged with our consultant. We're exploring different
3:07:35 options. Rick gave me the contact for this one which we'll reach out to and we're also exploring other options.
3:07:42 We've got the hospitals engaged and we're discussing with them. So, um I just want you to know that your request
3:07:50 has not been ignored. We are exploring other options. I mean, it can be it can be ignored.
3:07:54 It's just there's going to be a real issue next year when the budget rolls around.
3:07:58 So, that's all we're not going to ignore this request.
3:08:04 We'll keep we in good faith. We've talked to South Lake. We've talked to Advent. We've talked to uh I get the
3:08:12 other gentleman uh Vince what company he is. We are actively pursuing not just insurance but medical related
3:08:21 people too. Nobody has given us the secret code but that doesn't mean we've stopped or given up. I'm I'm optimistic
3:08:28 and we'll take the lead you provided. I promise you we we're a blood hound.
3:08:32 We're not giving up on this. We we will fight through it. So, I hear your frustration, but I want you to hear I don't know that that's a fair
3:08:40 characterization of the situation because it's not just calling our independent agent and saying, "Hey, you got No, this is we're we're tracking.
3:08:49 We're going into the woods. We're going hunting. We're looking for deer. We're looking for everything. Sincerely, we are doing that." And she's now got help
3:08:57 in her department. She's been doing two jobs for a year and a half. Wow.
3:09:02 And I applaud her for that. And we're going for it. I want you to know we're going for it. Don't give up on us yet.
3:09:08 We will figure something out. With with prayer and diligence, I think anything is possible. So I think what you're trying to talk about
3:09:15 is is an independent system where we would contract with local physicians for a plan. Is that what you're talking about? Like the you call it the
3:09:23 Clermont care plan just like H like just United Healthare.
3:09:28 We're already selfinsured, right? So we would then consist we would say okay we're going to give you x amount of dollars if you take our member and then for that that amount of money
3:09:37 that we give you then you would have a zero cate $10 copay whatever the copay and you go to multiple doctors
3:09:44 that would be a local plan and then you would go catastrophic would be outside of that probably is what I imagine yeah I mean
3:09:53 but that would that would you need to have you know you have to have a like a benefit manager that would have to go
3:10:02 out coordinating. This is something we could do as council. That would have I'm looking for the 250 a month a month
3:10:10 a month for my family because uh it it'll save me thousands of dollars.
3:10:14 I know we don't think you'll be getting some calls, Mr. Mayor.
3:10:19 There are plenty of businesses who would love to support you on that. Well, we keep we check our lunch here.
3:10:28 Yeah. Um, it's been a year.
3:10:30 We have two minutes. Any any other questions for for HR?
3:10:35 No, thank you. All right, we'll go ahead and thank you N
3:10:57 Yeah.
3:11:13 Heat.
3:11:31 Heat. Heat.
3:11:58 Heat. Heat. Heat. Hey, Heat.
3:12:28 Do
3:12:43 you feel
3:13:37 Hey.
3:13:47 Hey. Hey.
3:14:04 Heat. Heat. Heat. Hey, Heat.
3:15:56 living it all.
3:16:13 Heat. Heat. Heat. Heat.
3:16:45 Heat. Heat.
3:18:26 Heat. Heat.
3:19:44 Heat. Heat.
3:20:26 Hey. Hey. Hey. Hey, hey, hey.
3:21:01 Heat. Heat.
3:22:17 Heat. Heat.
3:23:40 Oh yeah.
3:24:29 Heat. Heat.
3:25:18 Heat. Heat.
3:26:05 Heat. Heat. N.
3:26:27 Heat. Heat.
3:27:35 Heat. Heat.
3:28:39 Yeah. Heat. Heat.
3:31:01 Heat. Heat. Heat. Heat.
3:31:49 Heat. Heat.
3:32:09 Oh yeah.
3:33:09 break. Hey
3:35:15 Hey. Hey. Hey. Hey. Hey. Hey.
3:35:45 Heat. Heat.
3:37:25 Heat. Hey. Hey. Hey.
3:37:54 Heat. Heat.
3:38:32 Look at that.
3:39:29 Hey. Hey. Hey.
3:43:32 Heat. Heat.
3:43:53 Heat. Heat.
3:44:45 Hey, hey, hey.
3:45:40 Heat. Heat.
3:46:02 Heat.
3:46:19 Heat.
3:47:21 Heat.
3:47:41 Hey. Hey.
3:47:58 Heat. Heat.
3:48:07 Heat. Heat.
3:49:25 Heat. Heat.
3:50:08 Heat. Hey. Hey. Hey. Heat. Hey, Heat.
3:50:37 Heat. Heat.
3:52:12 feel a Heat. Heat.
3:53:41 Heat. Heat.
3:54:27 Hey, hey, hey.
3:55:10 Heat. Heat.
3:56:28 Heat. Hey. Hey. Hey.
3:56:57 Heat. Heat.
3:58:37 Heat. Hey. Hey. Hey.
3:59:06 Heat. Heat.
4:00:26 Hey. Hey. Hey.
4:02:36 Heat. Heat.
4:03:17 Heat. Hey, Heat.
4:04:55 Heat. Heat.
4:06:27 Heat. Hey, Heat.
4:07:04 Heat. Heat.
4:07:31 Heat. Heat.
4:09:11 Heat. Heat.
4:09:36 Hey, hey, hey.
4:11:07 All
4:11:34 right.
4:11:36 Yes, everybody. We we'll go ahead and resume who we have communications.
4:11:43 Communications. We don't have that presentation.
4:11:54 We have
4:12:12 Okay.
4:12:15 All right. Well, welcome back. Hopefully everybody enjoyed their food.
4:12:22 they are on. Okay. So, this so this is the new department that you guys graciously
4:12:30 helped us with. So, new department that was authorized by council back just a couple weeks ago in June 23rd. And two
4:12:37 of the four positions, as you'll see in the or chart, two of the four positions are reclassifications, okay, from existing positions in there.
4:12:46 So, we go to the next one.
4:12:49 So this is the uh proposed communications department. We got the communication engagement director which is a which will be monies utilized by
4:12:57 the by the uh PIO department. The existing PIO is going away. So that money is going to take care of the communication.
4:13:06 The digital content and multimedia manager is also a reclassification of another position. And a community
4:13:15 engagement coordinator would be new. Or I'm sorry, not the the content manager.
4:13:19 The 311 center supervisor is is a reclassification from a vacant position that we no longer
4:13:26 need. So two of the four positions are reclasses. The other two are the new ones. So four total. removing the 311
4:13:35 center under the communications department because that makes sense that it's part of the overall message of the city.
4:13:43 Next slide. Uh no capital proposals in this department and
4:13:50 this is kind of the the financial slide on it. It's pretty much all personnel.
4:13:55 operating cost is uh a lot of that is we've got well I'll just leave it for questions before
4:14:04 I explain it all in detail if there's any question is there like a software package we were talking about earlier you know for
4:14:11 sending emails out and gleaning information on the responses correct get good data yeah and that that was as you recall
4:14:20 when you had the presentation from true north they recommended search software that will make these positions successful. The one you're talking about
4:14:27 is called flashb. That's the one where you send out the in.
4:14:31 So that one's in here. The other softwares that they recommended are all part of this operating budget. So that's what makes up
4:14:38 the majority operating budget other than some of these things like having their computers and assisted.
4:14:46 So I am uh just want to make sure that we're being complete again.
4:14:52 I had seen advertisement go out for the media person, but the listed budget was 84 to 104,000,
4:15:02 which looked to me like that would be the director position and then I'm seeing 203,000 for four people. And so I'm just confused how
4:15:12 we're getting to 203,000 and if we made a mistake and if we made a mistake that's fine, but did we properly advertise and are we getting people and are we getting qualified
4:15:20 people? We So we we advertised the director position and in four days we had 52 applicants.
4:15:28 The the one that you saw has been advertised for just under a week and we've got 55 applicants so far. So we
4:15:35 are getting a lot of a lot of interest in it.
4:15:39 I I am screening him. Zay is screening him. Lori the consultant from True North was in the interviews. So she's helping us pick out the people.
4:15:48 But if we have a this position digital content and multimedia manager.
4:15:56 It was a manager, but it was listed at 84 to 104,000. Correct.
4:16:00 So, how are we going to be at 203,000 if that person's not even the number one person?
4:16:06 The So, the the number one when if you recall in the one-on- ones with Lori, she recommended that the director be
4:16:13 somewhere around 120,000, this manager be around 85 to 90,000, and the last one, I It was like 65,000 somewhere like
4:16:22 that. The last the third position, but that's 265, right? The third position we can wait on. We're not in a hurry to hire that one right now.
4:16:32 I think No, not the digital contact. The uh community coordinator, I think it's what it's called. Something about Yeah, I got the exact title. Yeah, that one. I
4:16:39 think we can probably wait midyear to see if we even need it. So, but what about the 311 center
4:16:47 supervisor? The 311 centers a reclassification. So that one's already paid for from an existing position.
4:16:54 But shouldn't all those positions be in the budget? So they're funded.
4:16:58 That one should it's already it's already funded by another position. I mean it's already funded by a position that's been vacant.
4:17:04 So So where is that?
4:17:06 That one that one was the development liaison, the second development leazison. We had two of them. And so that position is now going to become the
4:17:14 311 center supervisor, which is fine. I don't know if I mind that because we took that out of the city manager's budget, right?
4:17:23 Correct.
4:17:23 We went from two to one, but then we don't we still need the money to be in here.
4:17:28 Well, the money is going to come from We can move it over there. Yes, if we Yeah, we can move it over there. We just Is the money for that position in the
4:17:36 fiscal year 27 city manager budget of 675 for salaries? I believe we took that out.
4:17:57 But but e thank you. You might be the person. But shouldn't we still show it in?
4:18:09 So it's not the four position that's listed here. You're saying two, right? That's that's where I just want to show what you want, right?
4:18:19 We're confusing positions with FTE, though. FTE is what's allocated.
4:18:24 Positions are what's being Well, well, he's saying the old field goal in the FTE.
4:18:29 No, just because there's a number next to it means that that's an actual FT.
4:18:33 That's a spot that a person can go into, but they're not actually putting a person into it. They're just saying that
4:18:39 spot is there. At some point, we might put a person in there.
4:18:44 Well, that's what I'm that's what I view FTE versus position.
4:18:48 Well, I view FT is what's what's there what they're asking for. But when you put a number by position, that's telling me you're filling the position is what
4:18:55 I've already FT is just it's just the FTE count, right? Yeah. You got to educate me on this.
4:19:04 Yeah. Well, well, I understand what he's saying. FP account is the total number of position is the total number of position normally in every one of them
4:19:11 before if they wasn't filling the position it was a zero there okay to show you how many people they were actually hiring you going to have in the
4:19:18 position through the year if they wasn't going to hire me should be a zero there if they don't going to fill that position no because a zero would be that we get
4:19:26 rid of the FTE and and we're not getting rid of the FTE we're just not filling the position I mean it's it's a splitting hair but it's but it does
4:19:33 matter Because when we're setting priorities, we're saying to a department, you can you do you you can
4:19:41 have four positions. You're just not filling all the positions. We we still want to say there are four positions or FTE in that department. We're just
4:19:51 filling three or two.
4:19:55 Um, but you still account for the FTE because for for accounting purposes, you want to know that that's a that's a line in there that hasn't been taken away.
4:20:05 It's just not being filled.
4:20:06 Well, we need to go back and be consistent with with the way we're reporting things because if I go back to other FTEEs, they showing seven. And when you go down through here, for
4:20:15 example, we go right back to H. I guess it's HR, right? Insurance and everything. uh they're showing seven F
4:20:22 uh FTEES, but then when you go down and look at them, the position that they didn't fill was is showing zeros. Okay. That's right. You see?
4:20:30 Yeah. But they that that FTE is no longer there. They move that FTE into that other line is my understanding there. Okay.
4:20:38 But it it's it's a matter of context.
4:20:40 you know your operational context where the person physically is versus the accounting context of where we are
4:20:48 accounting for the related expenditure and this is something that we've seen across the entire budget not just here
4:20:56 um for instance and I'm there already no
4:21:03 everything I was going to speak to a budgeting philosophy again um historically ly
4:21:11 to a large extent the city has indirectly allocated cost to enterprise funds meaning the entire cost of it
4:21:19 would be included in the general fund and then through a calculation of administrative expenses we would have a transfer of dollars from the enterprise
4:21:28 funds into the general fund. We've been making a concerted effort at the management level to flip that and we're
4:21:35 early in that process. In other words, we are directly allocating more often than not with new positions as we go
4:21:42 forward. And this is a good example of that. Um, so the in other words, the related expenditures to these positions,
4:21:50 as Mr. Pride said, is going directly to the enterprise funds. You don't have anywhere in your budget that shows a
4:21:58 detailed allocation of uh personnel expenses for each individual position.
4:22:04 we can develop that and provide that. Um but it's it's something that this this
4:22:12 issue of context is prevalent throughout the budget.
4:22:15 So to go back to as Miss Strange was saying here we under under this um you got salary of 203,000 because the FTE
4:22:23 say four. So that's not four people you're paying. It's there are four people operationally within the department, but only $23,000
4:22:32 worth of their expenses are accounted for here. Okay.
4:22:35 Okay. And I guess now what I want to know which which positions are being accounted for because right here when I look at this, if you got a one listed at
4:22:44 you, you fill in all four position. If not, I need to know which one. So, so like the 311 center operator a lot of or
4:22:53 supervisor they're going to be supervising staff that deal with water, sewer, uh utility billing and permitting and
4:23:01 things like that. So, we can reallocate those the funding source for that into the different departments and they help they help pay for that in their their
4:23:09 enterprise funds. So this is the customer service rep position that shows on the new position request for fiscal year 2027.5
4:23:18 from the water fund. It doesn't say 4500 doesn't give me a number for FTE from the sewer fund and then 2200 from the
4:23:27 storm water fund and 2200 from the sanitation fund.
4:23:31 So that's this person that yeah that one table for new positions is a good Yes, you read that correctly.
4:23:38 Okay. So that person's being funded from the water fund, the sewer fund, the storm water, and the sanitation fund because they're providing customer service to utility customers. So part of it's coming from these funds.
4:23:49 Correct. An interesting thing. Thank you. I didn't know the difference.
4:23:53 And we don't have a schedule within your budget that shows that for all positions. We've just done that for the newly proposed positions.
4:23:59 Okay. So maybe what we could do for the public and people like me is maybe
4:24:07 put a star or something that says funded from enterprise funds something that shows us it lets you know where it's from where it's from. And then I think a a
4:24:16 question that's more management related than accounting. So I appreciate the explanation is as a citizen when I look at what the government is doing and I
4:24:24 say okay we have this call center how much am I same question about the performing arts center you know I'm going well how much are we paying for
4:24:32 that so that we can make informed decisions.
4:24:36 I think We could find a way to say okay this new department which is communications realistically across all bud all funds.
4:24:48 Oh there's another department where we have the general fund and then we did the other funds underneath
4:24:55 that show the personel. What might that have been that had the different funds on it?
4:25:04 I I think the question is saying is the 203 is that for two people? That's for four people.
4:25:10 That's for four people, right? That's the general fun. That was the question. So it's the 203 is for all four people.
4:25:19 That's all four people. But then but we're only going to be utilizing two, right?
4:25:23 Yeah. But but we have as as you see fit. But then when he talk
4:25:31 how many how many the the fund allocated to each position I think I think the strange kept up over the figure wasn't
4:25:38 it 265 or somewhere so the numbers still not adding up.
4:25:43 So I think what would help for this department is if we look at the public services you can see how it shows the entire
4:25:50 budget for the department and what funds it's coming from. So if you look at public services, you see general fund, then you see tree fund, infrastructure,
4:25:58 it's just an example of how the different whether it's personnel, capital or operating is coming from the different funds and would allow us to
4:26:07 see the entire department budget and then what funds it's coming from. This one just has I think it's just that simple.
4:26:14 Yeah, we'll show how breakdown is.
4:26:17 So let me let me which two position you going to be filling now? The right now we have the director position that's that's being advertised and the
4:26:25 communication or the champ sorry communication engagement director and the community sorry digital content
4:26:32 multimedia manager those those two are being advertised right now the 311 center supervisor we haven't
4:26:41 advertised that yet and the community engagement coordinator we're kind of holding off on that until we see how much we need them
4:26:48 and and what what's the salary on the U communication an engagement director.
4:26:55 We we are in interviews now. What what's the uh the salaries was about 120
4:27:03 what they recommended recommended and the other one was what I want to say that was 90 somewhere
4:27:09 around 90 95 for the second position say there again you you're saying 120 and 90 that's 210 then that it shoots
4:27:18 the 203 again just with the two position and that would all be sorted out in the budget process so right
4:27:25 I'll for purposes of discussion. I'll talk about the same thing I did with the economic development department, which is when this was under the city
4:27:34 manager's office, the salaries were something like 90,000 for the director and then or the PIO and then the coordinator was something like 60,000.
4:27:46 So now we're I just want to be mindful as as we create departments, what we're doing is we're creating positions that
4:27:54 add, you know, another positions worth of salaries and hopefully the people can do double the work. But I just don't
4:28:02 want that to be missing in the conversation.
4:28:05 And and that's why we're not in a hurry to fill that third position because we want to see if we can do it without it.
4:28:10 We want to save money where we can but Bill just for clarity and I think I I want to say it back to you so that
4:28:17 we're all on the same page. We have four positions FTE. One is going to be funded from enterprise funds and so we can see what that amount is. with the enterprise
4:28:26 funds and that in the future we would have shown on page 107 that that how that's being funded and that's the 311
4:28:34 champion resource center and then the communications and engagement director and the digital content multimedia manager those two positions are in this
4:28:42 203579 regular salaries which comes to 289,000 when you add in all of the benefits.
4:28:50 Um, and then the community engagement coordinator potentially can be done inhouse or by the two individuals that
4:28:58 we're hiring. So even though we're putting that position in, we're not funding that position right now outside of what we're already funding in other departments.
4:29:07 Correct.
4:29:08 So if that was to even though the position exists, if that was to be a higher, it would either have to be funded from other funds come back or come back.
4:29:25 And what is the 311 center supposed to be? Because this is a new thing.
4:29:29 The 311 center is the basically it is a one-stop customer service for everything. Whether you want
4:29:37 to you you can walk it's I hate calling it a call center because it's really not a call center but it's you're going to
4:29:45 have the expertise that'll be cross trainined from different departments that are going to help answer any questions. There is AI assistance that's
4:29:52 in that that helps them get all the information. If you look at it like a 911 center, when you call 911, you have a list of of staff and personnel that
4:30:00 are that have the exact answers because it's it's repeated questions. It's scripted. They know what to say. They know how to answer the questions. It's
4:30:09 consistent messaging and you avoid that where people call individual people and try to shop for the answer they want.
4:30:17 So, it allows that. It will allow for if you want to pay your utility bill and rent space of the ark and buy the city
4:30:25 has you can do it all at once. So, we're going to centralize all all of our online money taking whether you're paying a permit or or renting a space in
4:30:33 the dark. So, it'll have that component to it also not at the very beginning.
4:30:37 That's going to be probably a year or two down the road till we get all this stuff. Similar to the AI software, that one's not going to be implemented at the beginning. At the beginning, we're just
4:30:45 going to soft launch it and get the cross training together. We're starting out with two with uh staff from UB staff
4:30:52 from public services and that for permanent because those are the three biggest call volumes that we get.
4:30:58 So that's part of the whole software looking at the software to try to minimize the amount of software packages we have and and make it all easy and
4:31:07 consistent. So they're they're really good resources that'll free up time from other staff that's constantly answering phone calls.
4:31:14 So anybody would call the 311 center.
4:31:17 They could email or go directly to 311 center. If it's walkin they can they can go to them and they'll pull down the
4:31:24 right people. So, it's it's a very a lot of the bigger cities have not I shouldn't say a lot of them. They're not
4:31:31 a whole lot of them in the country, but they're very successful where they're at. So, is is it operational now?
4:31:39 No.
4:31:40 So, we have the software for it to be operational.
4:31:43 We we we have the existing software we have now. We're trying to minimize the amount of softwares we have and
4:31:50 consolidate them. So that's why we're kind of soft launching it over time. We want to get everybody cross trainined first before we announce it and before
4:31:57 we start promoting it with AI now. So AI directs AI will be a part of it. We don't have the AI software there now. We we've
4:32:05 looked at several different companies that offer it. It will be, but we're not expecting
4:32:12 that this but things like OpenGV and Tyler are two big ones. They both have an AI software component module that we can add to it.
4:32:22 So, we're looking at both of those.
4:32:25 Do do we foresee this being the the main number that people would call when they call city hall?
4:32:30 Yes, that's that's the hope is that everything goes through that whether it's in the email routes it through there or the phone, they can even text through there.
4:32:38 Yeah. when we get an app, we can and the the 311 center is a is something
4:32:45 I worked a lot with in higher education and it it was always it was the way it was described to me was, you know, a a
4:32:54 student may not know which office to go to to ask this specific question. I need to drop a class. Where do I go for that?
4:33:02 Right? And as opposed to going to the wrong office and that that office saying actually you got to go over here but they didn't really tell them the right
4:33:09 office and now they got it they there's a one-stop shop where I where they could that person can say
4:33:16 I know where you can find that information and I have that information for you. So, it's a one-stop. I don't know what department this is, but it
4:33:25 doesn't really matter that I don't know what department this is because I can just call this one number and they'll either give it to me or they'll get it
4:33:32 for me and I know it's one call versus call, transfer, transfer, disconnect,
4:33:40 call again is how it's how we implemented it through the colleges and universities.
4:33:46 And it sounds like that's kind of what we're trying to do.
4:33:49 It is. It is. We implemented one when I worked in North Carolina and it was extremely efficient. Yeah.
4:33:55 For for the customers to love it because like you said, they don't care who's providing, right?
4:33:59 As long as I get the information, right? Yeah.
4:34:04 And save you time because that's frustrating when you get transferred four or five times and by the time you get to the right person, you have a Well, and sometimes the person calling
4:34:13 doesn't even know they don't even know what question to ask. like they don't know what language to use and then you train your staff and it sounds like we're going to use some hopefully at
4:34:20 some point some AI in here to to in intuitively parse out what actually is being asked
4:34:28 so that we can get them the right information even if they're not asking quote unquote the right question. Right. Right. Right.
4:34:36 So, how is this I'm questioning the completion of the thought and the plan is where I'm coming from.
4:34:45 Okay.
4:34:46 Um, if I've done my math right, the total numbers, and again, I don't have the benefit of it on one sheet, so please forgive me, but I'm coming to
4:34:54 22766 for payroll for this one person. Does that sound like the right number?
4:35:01 $22,000 for the 311 supervisor for the salaries and everything.
4:35:10 I mean, I'm just looking at the new positions requested and the numbers, the wage and benefits. I mean, that's total.
4:35:16 So, it's like $15,000 and that's just what's on the form because I don't I don't I don't have it.
4:35:22 So, I'm sorry. I don't know what this person's being paid. And I guess my thought is even
4:35:30 Okay. So, I can manage about 250 relationships. That's that's my capacity. Most good sales people are supposed to be at 125. These are just universal numbers.
4:35:40 So, I just question the ability of and I use technology to do it. But, but I have a limit. And so, I question
4:35:49 how can one person do all the things we just described.
4:35:54 There's not one person. It's going to be a team meeting.
4:35:56 It's a team. So the team are coming from existing staff and current. So UB is going to donate a person to do it. All the services is going to donate a person
4:36:04 or two to do it. Uh permitting is going to donate a person. So they're all going to be in there cross trainining each other.
4:36:10 I got it. So am I seeing salary increases? These aren't actually new positions where there's a supervisor or none of none of them is a new position.
4:36:20 All of a supervisor position.
4:36:23 That's actually a reclass from an old position.
4:36:27 It's just a rename. Just change the name, right? Okay.
4:36:33 But is it really like four people that are being reallocated? I'm trying to imagine. I see a call I hear call center and I literally visualize World War II,
4:36:41 the ladies with the, you know, we don't have the switchboards.
4:36:45 That's right. So, I guess I can't visualize what it is.
4:36:49 So, so when when it starts off, it's going to be in a conference room in the hold the development services front conference room. We're going to
4:36:57 separate that out, make cubicles out of that. Okay.
4:37:00 And we're going to put the supervisor up front. There's going to be a window cut out in the front so people can walk up and talk to a human if they if they're here talking to a human.
4:37:08 Rose and Rose and Ray and Janet will all have that little bumpout area. So, they'll be there. We're going to move
4:37:17 them over there. so they can handle the walking customers. But then you'll have the four people back there plus the supervisor that are going to be
4:37:24 answering the phones, getting all the information, everybody hunting down the information, getting it getting it back.
4:37:32 And with with the 311 center, with the software, you can actually track how long does it take to respond to people?
4:37:38 How long are we taking to get back an answer? Kind of like a you know the Chick-fil-A metrics. library, right?
4:37:45 So, we'll be able to record that and realize and we can test how satisfied people are with their answers. Are they
4:37:53 getting what they want? Is it more efficient? Are they happy with it? So, it's it's going to make government and I know everybody hears this more efficient.
4:38:03 Well, I like that. I guess I'm curious why what is the function by which this is even before us and and I want to frame
4:38:11 it is if if we're reallocating people that we already have is is even a budget question or is this a structure question that we're
4:38:19 well it will be in the future because if it grows it'll grow into a bigger spot whether it's out in the ark or somewhere
4:38:26 else but but there will be a little bit of technology involved there'll be uh some computers
4:38:34 the cubicles. So, those are little tiny expenses, but there's nothing big prepared there. Nothing big planned for this next year.
4:38:42 But what does it look like in the end? I mean, is this a million? It it depends on how successful. Yeah, it's a pilot.
4:38:49 Right now, it's a pilot. And if it's successful, then it might grow a few more staff, whether they're internal staff or we have to hire another staff.
4:38:57 But that's not proposed at this point.
4:39:00 We're going to try to do it with existing staff as much as possible because in the end it's going to make those departments more efficient anyway taking the calls and the emails and
4:39:07 everything away from them. So having the staff cross trainin will will help anyone. If the UB person can answer a
4:39:14 public services question and vice versa then ultimately we can pair down.
4:39:21 I think this was the problem when we started with utility department we need additional space. I think this is going to solve that problem that we remember
4:39:30 we were talking about we needed a whole uh answering service just utility remember yes that was what last year or so we talking
4:39:38 about that so this is going to really this is going to be a single source 311 for everything I like that I think that's innovative
4:39:45 and it makes it easier for the citizens so you don't have to get transferred all around be frustrated that you still don't get your answer
4:39:52 but is this going to require then not one person If you're going to have all the costs of the city, this is going to you'll need a a phone bank.
4:40:03 You're gonna you're going to have the four switch switch operators. Yeah. Who's who's handling the calls now?
4:40:11 Every different department right now. Okay. But we also going back to Mr.
4:40:15 Peterson, we having problem with utilities, right? And who we having utilities going on phones right now?
4:40:21 How many how many utility people answer your phone?
4:40:24 Two or three. We got two or three just in utility and they can't they can't they can't keep up, right?
4:40:29 So my question is how you going to keep up for everybody with two.
4:40:33 Okay, that's I think we going we going if we going to do this, we going to have to uh need
4:40:41 more people. I don't see two people being able to do it with one of the biggest complaints I get right now is our utility department don't answer.
4:40:49 It's taking them four days to get back to calls. Okay. After they leave the message and we got two people just in utilities trying to do it.
4:40:56 But you have two people in utilities that are not only answering phones but they're also have walking hus doing a bunch of other stuff. This will relieve
4:41:03 the other people in UV to answer to taking the walk to do like that. They're taking all the daily phone calls off.
4:41:10 They're able to do their other stuff.
4:41:12 And if you have it, it's going to start off with four people plus the supervisor. So it's not just two people
4:41:18 in there. But the permitting person can answer a UB call because they've listened enough. They cross trainin each
4:41:25 other. They're gonna they're going to be able to help each other out. They're we're going to as the calls come in, we're going to be recording, not recording calls, but we're going to be
4:41:35 scripting what the answers are going to be. So based on the the calls, UV person can say, "Well, here's how we answer this always." And then that gets trained to the other. It's just like a 911
4:41:43 center. So if someone calls, the expert has already typed in here's the response for that answer. So someone someone else
4:41:50 calls, whoever answers that call has that up on their screen where they can say, "Here's the answer that I'm supposed to give." So, it will ultimately
4:41:59 dilute the calls to where it's not one or two people having to answer all the calls at once. It be four people plus a
4:42:06 supervisor get getting all the calls. And and it's it's a pilot right now. It's gonna, you
4:42:14 know, it's we're gonna soft it softwatch it for probably a good year before we really own field two of the position.
4:42:24 I'm just there'll be four. It'll be four communications department.
4:42:33 Okay. And Mr. Mayor, we there's something called overflow routing. So if those four people plus the supervisor,
4:42:41 five are on the phone, it can it can go to utility. So those people who were already answering the phone. So we're
4:42:47 actually going to have two people from utilities plus the four. So we can have an overflow routing of the phones so
4:42:56 they're able to pick up the phone. So we'll have a small army more people than we did previously because what we're doing now isn't enough, right?
4:43:05 No. what we doing now definitely isn't enough because like I say that's one of the biggest complaint we get you know I got people calling me telling me they
4:43:12 they call and they get put sent to an answer machine they don't get a call back in four days you know and all
4:43:20 that's that's unheard of you know of course we talked about this before uh doing the community center and of course another thing I
4:43:29 talked to you the both of you about is the fact that uh we own we own um Many people don't know this, but we own
4:43:37 uh a sharing lake a pocket gas and they looking to try to maybe us provide them space and what I talked to you all about
4:43:45 it maybe we get together and see if can't we um have them provide us a personnel in the office they pay for it out of their place to help us in this
4:43:53 call center as well and they be as trained as well and all the different things but uh because they ready to move out of the office across the street
4:44:00 because they being pretty much gouged um being asked to pay $3,000 a month right now for if a building across the street
4:44:08 they rent jump from 2,000 to 3,000 air condition went out and they trying to make them pay 10,000 replace the air condition.
4:44:15 So uh and if we part owners of it of that so
4:44:22 why can't we maybe combine them and bring a person in there that help us in there let them pay the cost of that personel and we we receive some benefits
4:44:31 out of it as well. So, and I know I've been asking you all about getting that uh we sitting down and having that meeting with with the lawyers and
4:44:39 everybody to see if we can do that. So, that can help us out because I I know they don't get that many calls
4:44:47 over there. I think they may they may have four people a day in the office to pay a bill over there across the street some.
4:44:54 And I know right now I know we we receiving quite a little bit of money from public in the last couple years.
4:45:03 We as I said on the board of directors we changed the policy I think I asked the other day if we think we should have
4:45:10 received about 225,000 from in the last month sometime I don't know if you all receive it I don't know
4:45:22 I would like to see a completed picture of what we're being asked to do if it's as simple as the city manager asking to
4:45:33 handle customer service with the existing budget. I don't think that there's anything for us to do. So, I don't I guess I'm I'm kind of saying if it's in the budget there, I don't see what we need to do with it.
4:45:43 But, if it's something that is likely to be a$1 or2 million thing in 2028 and we have constitutional amendment that says
4:45:50 we need to find $4 million. I'm not sure that that's a wise thing. So, I guess I'm not clear on it's the cost for this year is going to
4:45:59 be absolutely next year. because the staffing is already taken care of. It's no staffing. It's just fixing up the
4:46:06 room and getting it ready for phones, technology, computers. So, that's that's the only
4:46:13 real expense this year. And I think we can cover a lot of it.
4:46:20 Scott, Dan, if I could uh help paint this picture from a from a budgeting perspective, if I can turn your attention to page 35.
4:46:29 Um, and this might be a good segue into the city manager's budget review. You'll notice on there that the personnel expenses for the year is a decrease of $174,000.
4:46:40 A lot of that is the reallocation of the positions that were discussed towards the communications department, but PIL.
4:46:47 Oh, there there's others as well, but yes, some of that is for the communications department.
4:46:54 Well, that's fine. And I don't get me wrong, I I think call center is a great thing, but I just want to make sure we we we
4:47:03 have enough people there and other problem I'm I'm having problem visualizing doing it in that little comfortable mode. Right.
4:47:11 Okay. Especially especially when you said two I but four people to try to fit in in cubicles
4:47:18 and trying to talk on phones and everything that's so uh and of course my thing and then you talk about maybe have to grow. So where you going to expand?
4:47:28 How are we going to waste money doing it if we going to do this? I mean, I've said this to you before. We got the building across the street sitting there vacant. So, why don't you set it up and
4:47:37 you have the room to grow as well and give them spread out that building to use for us because we need to do something. Okay.
4:47:45 Right.
4:47:47 And I can tell you we we've been working on this for almost a year now. I think Wayne Wayane can attest.
4:47:55 He he visited one of the call centers up in sorry the 311 centers I had call center centers okay up in North Carolina and came back with
4:48:04 oh this this can be amazing and and we've worked on it for almost a year now about how we can do it as absolutely low
4:48:11 cost as possible to make it to where there's there's very little very little money needed to we're starting it out
4:48:18 small that's why we're starting with a trip we could do that for virtually free now very And if it does grow, if it does become
4:48:26 that big successful, if our city gets bigger and we have to expand it, then we'll look at places like the Ark or even expand where the the um the
4:48:36 conference room is now. But we just we wanted to keep the cost as low as possible. And that's why we're starting small. We're starting slow. We're we're
4:48:44 limping into it because we we don't want to advertise to the public till we have it ready to launch.
4:48:54 I can understand maybe one to four, but I I think there's a need for it. So, uh I'm still the type of person, hey, I'm
4:49:01 going to go out and do what I need to do and and have the room to grow. Um you do this, you do the comp, of course, if it grows, then you're talking about
4:49:09 relocating again, which is going to cost you no money. So, why don't we just do it up front and get it out of the way?
4:49:14 because I'm I'm going tell you it's going to be I'm quite sure it's going to be a success because we um it's the need for it right now. We know that.
4:49:22 Okay.
4:49:24 And it could be that we can expand where where it's at now if we need to. But I I was trying to be very very cautious of
4:49:33 the budget and very cautious about spending taxpayer money. So I'm trying to keep it especially the first year or two of
4:49:40 startup is just keep it as lowkey as possible.
4:49:44 And I and I agree that and and I'm always close to the budget too, but I'm also when I'm looking at my money, I don't want to put money here when I know
4:49:51 tomorrow I'm have to eliminate this here to go. Okay? I rather put it all here now and get it out of the way rather
4:49:59 than waste money here today when I know tomorrow I got to change it. Okay. If if I could add something to, Mr.
4:50:06 Mayor, you made reference to the building across the street. The last directive from you guys was to sell the
4:50:14 property across the street. So if you change that, we can change the directive, but I I have to go forward
4:50:22 with whatever you tell me to do as a group. And so that's what we've done is tried to create a plan based on what you
4:50:29 told us to do. So I don't recall us saying sell it. I think we I think there the motion and everything to surplus it, but I don't I don't recall ever saying sell it.
4:50:39 Well, surplus in my mind is sell, right? That we're supposed to put it up if we ever put it up, but we don't we can
4:50:48 go back and change that. I mean, well, that's up to you.
4:50:50 Again, that's why I was against surplusing as well. Here we are. We're growing city. Yeah.
4:50:56 And and yet still we have property. We talking about selling off property and everything that we need to expand it.
4:51:04 Why? You know, it's not that don't make sense to me. As a growing city, we should be holding on to our property so we can have places. This is a perfect example.
4:51:13 But I thought the reason that we didn't have the move over there because the cost of the fiber optics is going to be too expensive and we didn't have enough
4:51:21 people to vote to pay the cost for that and that's why it got on the surplus. Correct.
4:51:29 was over there. I think they say five going to be about 150,000. I think that's the figure I was given again.
4:51:37 Yeah. But we voted on it and it was only two of us were in support of it and the other three come out. So
4:51:47 I'm not trying to take us. I'm just we're just following the directive you gave us. Hasn't been listed.
4:51:55 What's the status on that?
4:51:57 I I have to check with. It either just got listed or it's just getting ready to get listed. I don't remember. It's been listed.
4:52:10 We can we we can always pull that listing. Okay. I mean, we need we need the building for for expansion.
4:52:17 We don't need the building for expansion. We don't need to take CRA property, which is our highest generating tax revenue in the city to
4:52:25 use for a government building. We we we we just don't we we use fire money to do that. It came out of the general fund
4:52:32 reserves. We could use it to expand the fire station or the police station down at Wellness Way. We could buy cheaper land somewhere else and build something
4:52:40 that's actually for this purpose. It it's just if it was your money, you would not spend it on you would not
4:52:48 spend it on that. That property will generate more in tax revenue than any utility 311 call center will generate.
4:52:56 I'm going to Mr. Vaner, this is the second time that this has come back up since we've said we want to surplus that property. It's July of 2026. The
4:53:04 direction was to surplus it and it hasn't been surplused yet. And I I don't know why this council is directing staff
4:53:12 to do something and then it doesn't get done and then it comes up later and it I don't like the feeling of it.
4:53:20 So, I mean, if someone on this council wants to put on the agenda to talk about not surplusing that, you know, then we should do that. But
4:53:27 this feels I don't understand what we're doing here.
4:53:33 Starting a new communications department that's going to need four to 10 people in a in a government space. This wasn't something that was discussed with me and
4:53:41 it feels like we're growing government when the whole conversation has been about trying to stay low on the millage, low on the taxes. And if all you want to
4:53:49 do is better customer service, then then have better customer service. You don't need us to approve a budget for that.
4:53:54 This feels like a bait to me. It feels like we're being baited to approve a 311 center that cost us nothing this year, but then next year it's a million or two
4:54:03 million that we have to do because we've committed to it. Now we've got employees, but we're not being presented with you're going to need to spend$1 half million dollars on a piece of real
4:54:10 estate and you're going to have to spend a million dollars on employees next year. And I think that we should have a complete picture. This doesn't feel right to me.
4:54:19 I'm not sure what to say to that because I don't I'm not aware of the bait where the switch that's so honestly that's the property across the street coming up. You brought it up.
4:54:29 Okay. Okay. I'm going to be so blunt it's going to hurt.
4:54:32 You guys need to get on the same page and you're giving somebody told you that we can finish my thought if you wouldn't mind.
4:54:38 Have you been told by someone on this council that we need to take that out of surplus or is this staff undermining the direction of this council?
4:54:44 It's not the staff. I'm not I'm not comfortable. I'm just telling you I I feel like I have I'm being pulled in
4:54:53 different directions from the council and I'm just I'm trying to be sweet. I'm trying to be respectful and I respect
4:55:01 all of your positions, but I'm being pulled in different directions and then one is frustrated at me for not going in the direction and then another one's
4:55:09 frustrated at me. And I would say respectfully, when you guys make a call, it's got to be over or you have to
4:55:17 revoke because you're putting us, myself included, in a very awkward position where we're trying to honor what you
4:55:24 asked. But it's not the staff not wanting to do anything. And there's no bait and switch.
4:55:30 Well, then who did why wasn't it listed six months ago?
4:55:32 There's there's five of you here and you can have the discussion. I'm not comfortable. I'm not I'm not outing
4:55:39 anybody. in this council, but I am receiving pressure to not do it and to do it. So, I'm just telling you that's
4:55:47 what's going on. You're you're forcing me to say it. I have said it, but I'm not going to get any.
4:55:52 But, I mean, was it it was voted on and and it was surplus. And the reason it's taken a little bit is because we had DPZ and the architect look at it and
4:56:01 see what we could possibly do with that property before we put it out to list because that helped us determine what the the going rate would be for it and
4:56:09 what it could ultimately be developed in the direction that we're trying to go with the forbased code. So when that when it goes out for listing as it's
4:56:16 gone out for listing it's going to say here's kind of the concept that will be comparable to new code. So, if you're
4:56:23 interested in purchasing this and redeveloping it, this is kind of what we're going to be looking for. And that's what this the delay was. It wasn't that we were not wanting to do it
4:56:32 or or anything like that. We were trying to get it set up to where we get the best value for the property that we could.
4:56:42 So, it is surplus. It is surplus. It hasn't been taken off. Has not been taken off surplus.
4:56:48 No, but the delay was that we're waiting DPZ DPZ was involved in it. The design
4:56:55 center was involved in it and we have been trying to internally wrestle through this as well. Like I said,
4:57:04 that was the Clare and the mount that you saw the picture of whatever we call it. That was that.
4:57:09 I would just ask respectfully if a directive's given, please don't put pressure on us to change the directive.
4:57:16 That's what I would respectfully ask.
4:57:18 I'm asking why it wasn't surplus. That's all. And you're saying council member has given you a different direction. You're pulled a different direction.
4:57:25 I'm not I I don't think I I'm not hearing it's not surplus. I think this is a matter of trying to figure out what
4:57:32 the definitions mean or the words mean to me. I I sat in the audience when that decision was made and it was a 3-2 vote to surplus the building.
4:57:44 To me, surplusing the building is the first step that the city can do to do anything other than use it themselves.
4:57:54 And from there, I thought as a citizen up until November and now as a council
4:58:01 member since November, that there was discussion with DPZ about what could that space
4:58:11 look like in our downtown, CRA, CBD areas so that we are in the best position
4:58:20 possible when we list it to be able to say this aligns with what is going to create
4:58:28 the best possible scenario for this community, for this CRA and for this CBD and for the downtown and for the city.
4:58:38 Yes, we're willing to entertain this offer. No, we're not willing to entertain this offer. That's that's due diligence and that and that does I I
4:58:46 think take some time. Can be frustrating, but it does take some time.
4:58:51 It sounds like we have that vision or idea and now we're following the state
4:58:58 pro or the process by which we advertise it. We have that period of time and then
4:59:04 we can start entertaining and actually have staff bring something back to council for an approval of an actual
4:59:11 sale. That's what I'm hearing as somebody who was not involved in the in that decision- making process. as someone who sat out there, that's what I
4:59:21 either recall andor have heard pre- November and post November. You're right.
4:59:28 And I think that there is a frustrating piece and I I've said this before up there about fire station 2 for the
4:59:36 example. You know, initially I I wasn't in favor of just remodeling Fire Station 2, but the reality is that was the
4:59:45 direction the city went based off of a council vote, and it was beyond the point where we needed to relitigate that.
4:59:54 It was plans were in process. You know, we bought temporary facilities. We were relocating. The horse has done left the stable.
5:00:03 Yeah. Um, and so we got we got to move on on that.
5:00:07 I think if there to your point, council member Strange, if a council member wants a different direction on that
5:00:14 building, there is still the ability because we have not sold it for a council member to put this on the agenda
5:00:22 to say, I want to vote again on this item. Whether that's frustrating or not to us, that is well within our right as
5:00:30 a council member to do because it's still owned by the city. And you may disagree with that. I may disagree with
5:00:38 that. Council member Peterson may agree with it. So forth, so on. I don't know.
5:00:43 But it's within our purview. I think the frustrating piece what I'm hearing the city manager say is that there's
5:00:52 yes direction was given but it it's taken time to get to that point and I don't I I didn't view as somebody who
5:01:00 was watching and now a part of it. I didn't view it as staff not doing what that vote was made to do. I viewed it as
5:01:08 staff was actually doing it. Otherwise, I think that there was a pretty strong argument, and I'll just say it out loud.
5:01:14 I think I'm not wrong to say that. I think it was council member Myers and the mayor who who voted to to use that building. They made some strong arguments to say that they wanted to use
5:01:23 that building for that for city purposes.
5:01:26 Um I I'm not hearing staff, you know, working behind the scenes to try to do
5:01:32 that. Um but I'm I'm hearing that there's but I'm hearing that there's there is still some pressure
5:01:40 from within the community to not get rid of that property. And they have to
5:01:47 listen to that. They have to understand that. They have to work through that. But the process still is moving forward.
5:01:52 I I haven't heard anything that leads me to believe that the surplus leading to a let's set a vision for that space
5:02:00 leading to let's list it isn't taking place. As frustrating or as time consuming as that may be,
5:02:08 that's not my issue. My issue is in private meetings, I have been approached by staff about this issue.
5:02:15 So, that's what I'm bringing to the table. That's what I'm talking about.
5:02:19 And I haven't been approached by staff with here's another solution. Here's a less expensive solution.
5:02:25 Every time I hear about a call center, the very next line is, "Well, we have that building across the street and
5:02:33 we've already been down that road and I've already expressed that it's a very expensive building that's going to produce taxable revenue." So, my
5:02:39 frustration is that I feel like this in a way whether however faded.
5:02:47 And so, that's my frustration. I have expressed it.
5:02:50 It may not be true. It may not be factual. It might be coincidental. It might just be what it is, but that is how it feels. So, if staff would like us
5:02:58 to purchase a building for a call center, I think that should be clearly communicated and not something that's snuck into a budget
5:03:07 as if it costs us nothing. I think it should be something that we're going to need a building, we're going to need 20 people, and this is the estimated cost,
5:03:15 and that we can make an informed decision because whatever happens with this 311 center will come back to us approving the start of this center,
5:03:24 which is why I've said, what am I being asked to approve? I don't have to approve you providing good customer service. I don't have to approve you spending money that's already in the
5:03:32 budget in another department. But if you're asking me to approve a call center that's going to become a $2.5 million conversation next year, that is foreseeable. I want to understand that.
5:03:42 That's where I'm feeling baited.
5:03:45 Yeah. I I can't speak to that because I don't want to I don't want to say how you feel or why you should feel a certain way out there.
5:03:52 No, but but it's true. I I I don't think it's my right to say that or or to to try to interpret that. I I'll just say I'm not hearing that and I'm I don't
5:04:01 feel that same way or hear that same thing. Um, what I'm hearing is that they
5:04:08 they're asking for a re essentially to reclass the development liaison position to the champion resource center
5:04:15 supervisor to use those funds for this position and it happened to they're they're placing it in this communications budget.
5:04:25 It's not happening though. What you just said isn't happening. That that's a $100,000 position and that's not reflected in this budget. Well, it is
5:04:33 happening. I I don't think it's I don't I will agree with you that I don't see the funding in here. That's what I'm saying.
5:04:39 But it but as per the finance director, the city manager and deputy city manager. If you look at the FTE for that development second development leazison position, it has gone from two to one.
5:04:51 The funding line on the city manager's budget has gone down.
5:04:55 Y we just didn't see the increase coming here. it just is it went down and it's kind of just I think it's out there and
5:05:02 it wasn't put into a line. So, I do agree with you in that way. It's not visually in a line somewhere, but I I don't think it's an added FTE or
5:05:11 an added new expense. It's a reallocation of the funds for an FTE
5:05:19 for an FTE, not the funds for the budget. And one of the things that I have expressed to staff and and I'll say it to all of you so you know where I
5:05:27 stand on it is I feel very strongly that when we approve a budget that is our communication to the public that this is the plan for next year and there are
5:05:36 certainly things that could come up mid year. We we know there are mid-year hires and I mean we know that what I
5:05:44 prefer what I think is good practice is that we say when we go through the budget these are things we anticipate
5:05:51 adding midyear and that we put them in the budget for midy year because when we put an FTE in here what happens is at
5:06:00 some random date in the future if we're not diligent about it there's a budget amendment that says oh we already had this position it was approved in the
5:06:09 budget process. We're just reallocating some funds towards it. And and that's fine if that was communicated up front.
5:06:18 And and this this whole situation has me off center because I'm not getting a clear picture of their direction. And I
5:06:26 mean, the fact that I mean, look, I'm sorry. I'm sorry if this feels harsh, but this is an incomplete budget
5:06:33 compared to other departments. There there's no picture of what this call center is. There's positions between the supervisor and the other people that
5:06:42 aren't being displayed here, but we're being asked to approve it. And if it's not a budget issue, we shouldn't be approving it, which means it's a policy issue or it's going to come back later.
5:06:50 I would like to see a complete picture before I approve anything related to the 301 life center, and I'm not going to harp on it anymore.
5:06:59 For me, as a member of the public, this is a red flag.
5:07:04 So, but I think what you're asking is can you amend this communication package to put in the 31 using the existing salaries and
5:07:13 reallocating them to a different function and I want to see what the projected 2829 is. You're talking about a new department and we're asking police and
5:07:22 fire and everyone else to give us a five-year plan. I want to see what the plan is for this because I want to be very clear when this becomes a $2
5:07:29 million issue that I approved or didn't approve it.
5:07:35 You're aware of things I'm not. I want to publicly go on the record and everybody here I have no idea what
5:07:42 you're talking about with a bait. I need to say it. Yeah.
5:07:45 So there's not a bait and switch. I don't know of millions of dollars upcoming. So personally I have no idea what you're referring to. I want to make sure that's crystal clear on the record.
5:07:56 We're talking about next year this department is going to be successful. It's going to happen. I'm not consciously aware of that today.
5:08:01 We're going to need a building. We're going to need a space. Why can't we use the arm?
5:08:05 We can't again show a plan. The only thing I keep hearing related to this issue, and I said it's the third time I've heard it since we cast the vote, is
5:08:13 well, we've got that building across the street.
5:08:15 I we we gave you a solution to use our existing building, right?
5:08:22 I don't I don't know how to say this to you.
5:08:24 We can talk about it offline or we can talk about it here.
5:08:26 We we have a solution that is not across the states.
5:08:30 Then then show me that that is not it's right here. No, it's not.
5:08:34 The four people would go sit right here in that office for this year. But then next year, we expect it to grow. We're going to expect more people.
5:08:42 We don't know that yet. And and that's the thing. You don't know.
5:08:46 Well, I Zane has actually been heading the the 311 center since he's well the past few months. He can speak to it more
5:08:54 because he's been working with the other departments on the long term, but we we're not anticipating a multi-million
5:09:01 dollar thing at all. This is the city's not that big to do anything like that.
5:09:06 The goal would be eventually that wall, we could knock that down and expand the space if anything. The goal is not to relocate. The goal is to expand the
5:09:14 area. There's some space that we're able to reutilize. So, it's not for the intention of finding more space offsite.
5:09:23 It would be on site and that's kind of the intention as it grows. Uh it didn't make sense to send them over to the ark
5:09:31 right away because then we wouldn't know what's going on with them. So, that was the main intention behind it.
5:09:38 We were going to present whatever offers are given to us for the building across the street since that was the directive
5:09:45 and then give you all your their last opportunity to say sell this, don't sell this, do whatever you want. And then,
5:09:52 you know, I'm following the directive Miss Meyers asked me, "Please get these phones answered, you know, and you you
5:10:00 were very you you said, "Please." And so, we've been working for a solution.
5:10:06 And I think it's pretty stinking creative that we're in the building using existing employees to do this. And
5:10:14 it would be silly for me to start whipping out tools and start creating sawdust and not even tell you all or have the respect to show you. So that's
5:10:22 all this is. But I don't know of any million dollar things to add to this. I mean, we're not going to have that auction next year.
5:10:30 Across the street is a million dollars. But I'm not proposing that. No.
5:10:34 No. The intention is forever to be in that space and there should be minimalist software updates or anything
5:10:41 along those lines. We can use our existing software. Uh it's mostly headsets, computers, which we already have. Uh it's really on a shoestring
5:10:50 budget by design. Um but no, there's no intention of a bait and switch or any uh anything other than what's being presented.
5:11:00 Thank you. I appreciate a longterm vision.
5:11:15 Mr. Matthysse, when do you anticipate the two positions that are being the two new positions for communications,
5:11:23 the two that are the two FTE that are in this budget line, the director and the manager?
5:11:29 Uh when do you anticipate those to be onboarded? Uh probably in the next 30 to 60 days.
5:11:35 We're doing interviews. We did one interview last week. We're doing three more interviews this week. Uh if we find a good candidate, then we're going to move forward. If not, we're going to keep interviewing.
5:11:44 Okay.
5:11:45 The second position is um we're going to pre-screen ones and when we get to the top three or four, then we're going to
5:11:53 let the new director help pick who that person's going to be. Make sense? Yeah. Thank you.
5:12:06 Okay. Uh, you going to do the city manager as well?
5:12:24 This go through the city manager.
5:12:25 Okay. We don't have any slides from the city manager department because it's it's pretty basic.
5:12:31 But we're uh Wait, I'm sorry. I'm hearing two things from other council members here. Uh is there someone who's here to speak on the communications?
5:12:42 Okay. So Oh, I'm sorry. I was I was going I I want to get through the city manager get it all. So if they want to see any of it
5:12:49 because I think some of the city manager stuff basically some of the position we talking about came from the city manager's office. So let's get through this whole whole thing and then I have thought to come back.
5:12:58 I just want to make sure we didn't I'm not going I no Okay. So the city manager's office it it's there's no new no new positions.
5:13:09 It's actually a decrease in positions and um I mean it's pretty basic. I'm happy to answer any questions. There's not a whole lot to it.
5:13:18 You decreased the position which basically from the city management office some going into communications and everything basically and that's why because they kind of tie together.
5:13:26 That's why I wanted to try to get through right both get through all that. All right. And that's all you have.
5:13:31 That's I mean there's really nothing short and sweet.
5:13:34 Just like the uh the council the council members budget. There's very little to that. Okay.
5:13:41 Well, all right. We Mr. Bryan D Thank you, Mayor M.
5:13:52 Yes, sir.
5:13:53 Council staff, thank you guys for letting me speak. I know you guys don't normally take public comment during workshops, so I appreciate you giving me some time. Um, and I'll be very brief
5:14:01 because it sounds like the train has kind of left the station on some of these existing or these future positions for communications. I was going to
5:14:08 advocate for the private sector to maybe get a shot at proposing uh an option for some of the content creation positions
5:14:18 and things of that nature. Try to save you guys some money. I do think that what you've allocated for your budget is a little high um compared to what you
5:14:25 could get if you contracted it out and especially after hearing I got here really early and heard the insurance discussion too. Potentially some cost savings there, but it sounds like you
5:14:34 guys are pretty much at the process where you're already looking to hire somebody. So, I just wanted to advocate again for the private sector to
5:14:42 try to get a shot at being able to work with the city to create some of the things that you guys need based on a goal based year-to-year kind of uh
5:14:51 expectation. And that's really all I want to do is try to help you guys save some money and uh work with some local businesses to achieve the goal.
5:15:00 I'm sorry, but uh Bryan, if I'm not mistaken, this all this go this this way out through procurement a few months back, right? We did. Yeah. And that's
5:15:07 when True North was hired for our communications consultant. So, they're still on board helping us consult as needed.
5:15:14 When it came out procurement a few months ago asking for outside and did you not see that?
5:15:19 No, sir. I I was and I'm speaking um based on what I saw for the budget for next year. This was a brand new department. So, I thought this was all brand new stuff.
5:15:29 No, based on what I had seen being advertised for the workshop. So, this seems to be done a long time ago.
5:15:36 further from the station than I thought.
5:15:37 So well what I think is important to distinguish here is when we did the public the procurement
5:15:45 that was really for like a communications consultant like it was a overarching strategy
5:15:54 right so um what I'm hearing you say Mr.
5:16:01 is because one of the positions is media and graphics.
5:16:07 You're saying that one seems like it would be good.
5:16:10 There was one proposed for 27 for a content creation that yeah, that would was I thought based on what I was seeing it was
5:16:18 something that's proposed for next year as part of a new department within the budget. So I was going to say, hey, before you guys jump to do that next year, maybe look outside. This looks
5:16:27 like it's something that stemmed from a 26 conversation that is filtered down and it's not really actually just brand new for 27. This is something that's kind of ongoing.
5:16:35 It actually from when we went out I'm making sure I understand when we went out through procurement asked for
5:16:42 overall commun uh communication communications and everything and came back and I guess we stemmed down three companies. Of course, we couldn't make a decision. That's when we had True North.
5:16:52 True North came in and did the study and these are the positions they recommended to us basically what it was up to.
5:17:00 I I just communications isn't all one thing. So that's the I think that's what makes it different. Whenever it's a more
5:17:08 specific thing or a different scope, you do have to put it back out to procurement again. And I think that's more so what you put out to procurement from a communications function
5:17:16 perspective and what communications professional would understand was a much broader brand strategy. It wasn't just a call to anybody that does anything in marketing. There's a lot going on there.
5:17:25 There's content creation. There's people that specialize in digital ad stuff.
5:17:29 There's people that specialize copy. I mean, there's just a million roles it could be. But what you put out was a more generalist kind of strategic
5:17:37 oversight. So there's not been a specific uh just to clear up that I wouldn't say that there would a communications professional wouldn't
5:17:44 have seen that as a specific call for content creation.
5:17:48 Well, it was when it went out and I agree when it went out for through procurement it went out for basically marketing firm and and that was the right call. I think
5:17:56 that was the right call. It just doesn't mean you're not going to have to do more procurement again for communications related things. And of course, True North was one of them and we went and
5:18:04 hired True North to come out and evaluate and of course True North themselves is say these are the positions that we need experts in these
5:18:12 different different Yes. Yeah. And it but how you fill to his point actually I thought it earlier but I didn't say it but I'm like
5:18:20 the position could still be fulfilled either by a contractor or an employee. Right.
5:18:25 And I actually do see when it just when it comes to content creation specifically and I would float this by Lori. I don't know if she'd be super
5:18:32 against it or True North. I bet this is what True North does for their own content creators uh is subcontracting or contracting that out because then you
5:18:40 have more access to a range of skill sets. Again, we tend to reduce down communication. There's so many different skill sets in media. Um, and that's why
5:18:49 a lot of times in the places that I work and consult with, we do see the content creation part is often outsourced
5:18:56 because you then you're not having to pay, you know, you don't have to pay benefits on these employees and all this kind of stuff. You get a lot more flexibility and then you often have
5:19:03 access to a wider skill range. So for there are certain things you want in house like your director and you know some of these proposed. So
5:19:11 um I I get what he's saying and I agree actually. I agree that that could be a good option. I don't think that's the way you have to go, but you will be limited. There's no one person you could
5:19:19 hire that can do all the content creation.
5:19:22 Yeah, you will be limited if that's what the role is. So, Mr. Mr.
5:19:27 Mats, Sure.
5:19:29 Uh, you say the positions is open are still being advertised right now, right?
5:19:34 For this second position, yes, still being advertised.
5:19:38 So, and I'm I'm not opposed if council wants to do another RFP for very specific content. creator or or any
5:19:46 specific rule that you we feel that I would keep it broad. I would put it out broad as cont
5:19:54 as needed. What wouldn't it make sense to consider a route that hires the director,
5:20:02 the communications and engagement director and actually then having that conversation with that that person about
5:20:09 what route should we go forward with digital content and and multimedia?
5:20:16 Do do we have a manager position and do it all inhouse?
5:20:20 Do we have somebody who maybe at a at a little bit different pay scale, coordinate that and we then contract out
5:20:29 and that person coordinates and works directly with some contract services to to to to broaden the skill set that we
5:20:36 get for that. Um because I think we're maybe making the assumption that
5:20:43 this is one of those situations where an in-house staff member position at that level at I don't want to say this level at that
5:20:52 content for lack of a better word I know it's content in the title but the con this may be one where it is something that because of the diversity within
5:21:01 what we're looking for we might be asking for that unicorn in one one person, but if we had a couple of
5:21:10 different entities to pull from for this content that and then have somebody inhouse to coordinate that, that might
5:21:18 be the better route. And our our new director might help be able to set that vision better for us with True North Consulting with collaboration with the
5:21:27 city manager staff to because that's, you know, ultimately where it where it rests at the end of the day. Um, and
5:21:34 then we decide what we want to do and you can report that back to council before we make that next step.
5:21:39 Yeah, I'm not that and do the same as we've been doing the other professionals. That way worst case worst case they've got it at their
5:21:47 disposal. We've got a group of professionals and you could then you have a group can get quotes from different projects or a retainer type content creation get a better deal.
5:21:55 Mr. Crane, you bring up something and this relates to what happened in Mr.
5:21:58 Norris's presentation, but it's a policy question.
5:22:02 Do we council because I think this is up to us. I don't think there's a I don't think there's a policy on this. Someone correct me if I'm wrong. Um when we
5:22:11 approve the budget, are we we're talking about hiring employee versus contracting?
5:22:22 Are we concerned with the money so that the city manager could hire a consultant or hire an employee or do we actually
5:22:31 want to be in the depth of this is how many employees, this is how many, you know, we want you to use a consultant or
5:22:37 do we just want to say this is within the department budget whether you hire a consultant or you
5:22:45 hire an employee as long as you're under budget?
5:22:48 I think it might depend on the department. I mean I you know I because it gets to the philosophical of what you do in terms of you know I think if you
5:22:56 ask people who have uh who live in unincorporated Clermont and get their waste management from a
5:23:03 contracted service that oftent times that contracted service doesn't come and there's nobody at the county
5:23:10 building that can do anything about it um because it's not their employees that's a whole another you know ball
5:23:17 game in this situation I hadn't thought of that until Jay Bryan came up here and and Valerie talked about that the
5:23:24 diversity of the content and and why this might be one where it might make
5:23:30 more sense to have that be a contracted opportunity because of of
5:23:37 the diversity and you might be able to get two or three individuals or companies to provide
5:23:46 X and Y A and B and Q and are this one's good at infographics. That one's good.
5:23:51 And have somebody in house who coordinates that with them and says this is the this is the brand. This is the vision for the city of Clermont, but
5:23:59 your expertise is this. Your expertise is I don't know that in this area and I think that's might be where the once we hire the director, this should be in
5:24:07 their per their purview, their wheelhouse. This should be something that they should be able to provide us that direction on.
5:24:13 That's smart. And this is one of those scenarios where you're going to get that probably going to get the highest quality work if you open up this particular work to contractors.
5:24:22 They're contractors for a reason. They are, you know, I mean, there's a ton of contractors out there, but the good ones that hopefully will make it through a
5:24:29 good a good procurement process will they're they don't want to come be a city employee. They can make more and
5:24:37 work at a higher quality level working with multiple people. It doesn't mean they have to charge you more to make that more, but the spread is wider.
5:24:44 And if anything, they'll probably charge you much less than what you're allocating for a salary position.
5:24:49 Yeah, that depends on how much content you want to create. But yes, well, again, that that is that is my other thing was I was going to ask how you got to the amount of the salary because based on goals and how often
5:24:57 this person be producing stuff like where does that where does that set because that could also help determine your cost per project for contractors to come in and do that for you.
5:25:08 really overloading an employee who may not be able to do all that employee will be overload actually that's very typical in an organization
5:25:16 just just a suggestion um when I was looking at what you guys were looking to create and then again just wanting to advocate thank you um for the uh private
5:25:25 sector to help you guys I have a question for you we're talking about the digital content multimedia
5:25:32 manager u as professionals in this industry knowing what you know about the city being committed the way you are.
5:25:39 What are your thoughts on having the communications and engagement director and the community engagement coordinator in house?
5:25:49 Does that make sense? That makes sense to me.
5:25:52 So, the one that jumps out is the digital content.
5:25:55 Yeah. Yeah. Your community coordinator should be very deeply connected with what's happening with the city, city, DNA, vision. Obviously, the director
5:26:04 needs to carry that. So, those make sense to be in house. There are ways that it can be done all you could outsource the whole creative paint and it can be done effective like including
5:26:12 comm strategy but I don't I don't know I wouldn't recommend that I do I I I will acknowledge that there
5:26:19 is a great need for someone to be a director within the city that is a staff member that is involved in the absolute day-to-day operations everything below
5:26:28 that person though is completely up for discussion in my opinion just based on value price even your coordinators perspective.
5:26:38 Mr. Matis, are we having the director applicants and the coordinator applicants meet with people in the city that are involved in media so we can see how those relationships?
5:26:47 We haven't yet, but we can.
5:26:50 I mean, it seems like they probably should have a good rapport with our local media outlets and our chamber and our main street.
5:26:59 Are you talking about the applicants or the actual person they hire as part of the job interview? Okay.
5:27:07 I initially I don't know how I feel about that long term, but my initial reaction on that is concerning in the sense that
5:27:14 I feel like that that's met that's getting a little too in the weeds of of making the decision of hiring a staff member.
5:27:22 Not sure I'm directing. I'm just No, no, no. I'm not saying you're directing, but I'm just wondering even philosophical if that's because I I I
5:27:29 don't you know I I think I want to I I feel the initial piece of me says let the city manager interview and hire and fire the staff.
5:27:42 But I think I think was there you could utilize experts to help the city manager make the best decision.
5:27:49 We could think of it that way. Yeah, if if the city manager is okay with that, but I certainly I'm not sure I want to direct that.
5:27:58 I thought I thought originally the biggest thing here when I talked with True North, the biggest key here was hiring the director.
5:28:07 Yeah.
5:28:08 And then let the director do all the rest of the hiring. Yes.
5:28:12 Okay. And that that was the way to go is hire the director first, which I think we that isn't what we were doing. Okay.
5:28:19 hire the director and then let the director because they know what key part as it was explained to me through true love when I sat down with them this uh
5:28:29 skill set and this skill set this skill set and your director should know what skill sets they want and that I mean that's the plan Lori has been in is has
5:28:38 been in the interviews already and she's going to be in all the interviews for the director once we get a director on board the first thing I'm going to have them do is sit down with Lori and go over the the
5:28:46 full because they're not to what you guys information have we have. So I want them to sit down and get the full report
5:28:53 of what what the findings were and then they can start looking at number two position. Again, the number three we're
5:29:02 we haven't we weren't going to fill that immediately, but it sounds like Well, I think in doing this presentation, they recommended at least
5:29:10 three people right away. Correct. you know and everything which something I've always agreed with when we had our original committee my original
5:29:18 conversation with these three people and I well at the time of PIO office
5:29:25 but you asked for four years I still see three people at least
5:29:32 on the issue of a communications team versus the 311 center I think that the sounds like there's a possibility that
5:29:39 using relationships in the city, we could reduce the cost of that digital content and multimedia position which
5:29:48 might allow us to move forward with the hiring of the third person.
5:29:51 So, so we we don't have too much more time because time is running out and I think we have Thank you guys.
5:29:58 Okay, Bryan. Uh I think we need uh Mr. B Wagner, Mr. U
5:30:05 Matthysse maybe go back and look at making sure we get the uh director on board and
5:30:13 and go from there maybe agreement. Um and we can put once they come on board
5:30:21 if that's what we want to do is go out and advertise yourself whether you want a contract or however you want to do them. But I I do agree. I think the
5:30:29 director should be on part of staff because as I even talked to north, one of the things I expressing
5:30:37 one day, they they related to me as well that we have to have somebody on staff to handle them emergency calls. Okay. Uh
5:30:44 when the water main break at 3:00 in the morning, we need that that person on staff. So I think the director should be
5:30:51 that person of course contract If that's the way she decided they want to go and you all decide.
5:31:03 Is that okay? Is that all right? All right. Okay. Who else we have left?
5:31:12 Yeah. Is there was there any questions on the city council's budget? Okay.
5:31:21 Oh, yeah. I I did have one question.
5:31:24 Miss Miss Miss uh Mars had asked for a pay increase. Did y'all put in there?
5:31:29 We did not because the direction that when she brought it up, there would seem there didn't seem to be any uh any direction for us to do that.
5:31:36 Okay. Well, I Well, I told I couldn't support her $2,000 a month, but is that what she wanted?
5:31:43 Well, in in fairness, I guess we could ask when she comes back, too, just to make sure.
5:31:47 I just we don't we didn't feel like we had Oh, I don't know that there was, but I think just since we're talking about budget Yeah. I think it'd be fair to ask. Okay.
5:31:55 Yeah. I didn't I didn't know whether she she was curious with I know we have a reduction in salary, but I didn't know whether you you you
5:32:02 put any increase in in well the council's a little increase, but I haven't figured that with the training and all these travel training a little
5:32:11 bit. Uh, Miss Myers, one of the questions I just asked about the fact that you had a question about a pay increase for council and I was asking
5:32:19 them if they put it in the in the budget.
5:32:22 I guess say no you want how you want to handle that.
5:32:34 I just want and you're on.
5:32:38 I just I didn't want to move on until I asked that question since you weren't here. But I don't know how you feel about it. But uh like I told you during the workshop, I I don't think I can
5:32:46 support a thousand $2,000 a month, but I can. You can support 1,200.
5:32:51 Uh well, uh,000 and well or whatever it is, I think, however y'all want to break it up anyways, but 2,000. I can't support that. That's too much.
5:33:02 Um I don't know whether you want to comment on that or whatever but so we can move on now.
5:33:08 Um and we have to have the consensus. I didn't we had a consensus to bring it to 12 countries.
5:33:15 It was an agenda item. You can't Well, we have to Well, we can't take a vote just like at the last work. We can't take a vote now, but I didn't
5:33:23 try to put it in the budget. You can try if you want to try to put it in the budget as can be, but it have to be something that approved at at a council meeting.
5:33:31 Yeah. Go on the ballot.
5:33:36 No, no, no.
5:33:40 It no.
5:33:42 But I just if you want to do that, go ahead and try to get it in the budget and everything. If you want them to go back and include it in the budget,
5:33:49 whatever. Okay. Is our is our is the council pay an item that has to be a separate resolution or is that just a budget item?
5:33:59 Because I don't a resolution tells me that it would be like somewhere else in writing that the num that the figure is somewhere it would have to be an ordinance.
5:34:06 It would have to be an So do we have an ordinance on the book of what our pay is now? Correct. It's an ordinance. It is an ordinance. Okay.
5:34:12 It is an ordinance. It have to go We thank you.
5:34:15 As I explained at the time in the workshop, we cannot quote ourselves to pay rates. Correct.
5:34:20 Okay. It have to go it have to go and on the ballot or whatever and then once I think Mr. W said it didn't have to go
5:34:28 on the ballot. It just have to we have to vote on it and then it have to cycle through two uh election cycles. I think
5:34:36 it was and everything give the even off year would have to go through go through and then it would take effect. Okay.
5:34:44 Is what what did I Can I bring up one other quick? Yes sir.
5:34:48 When it comes to council members going on trips. I think there's value in
5:34:55 perhaps you guys doing things beyond conferences because I know some of you want to go to Tallahassee to advocate
5:35:04 for Clermont. So if we have XYZ number for our budget, I personally don't have
5:35:11 any problem letting council member X use an allocation of that, but I feel very
5:35:18 strained right now what I can use because precedent has been just using conferences.
5:35:25 So, but I know some of you have relationships and you could advocate just as effectively perhaps not going on a
5:35:33 conference. So, I'm just bringing that up front and saying that out loud. I think that should be a consideration
5:35:40 that's made as long as there's a budget item with explanation. I I I personally have no problem with that, but just want
5:35:47 to bring a policy on what our travel and predam can be used for might help because I don't think we have a policy
5:35:54 on that. I think this I think I don't want to speak for you, but I think this comes from I tried to go to I went to Tallahassee the week after everybody
5:36:03 else went to meet with our legislators and um I was not able to get reimbursed without putting on the agenda to get
5:36:10 council approval and so I think that might be where he's coming from which is fine.
5:36:17 Uh I don't think I should have to do that. I've been on one trip in the year and a half that I've been here but Yeah,
5:36:25 but I you know I think if he knows what the parameters are that you can approve.
5:36:30 I mean yeah we we don't talk about that and that's another one of the line items across the board travel and PDM and
5:36:37 training and education that midway through the year we were anywhere from 2% to 38% across eight different
5:36:44 departments and 7% to 31% for travel and training. It's not a huge line item.
5:36:51 Training is $131,000.
5:36:53 We're spending less than half of that as a a city, you know. So maybe having some sort of policy on what like do we want staff to go get training?
5:37:05 I do. Yes.
5:37:06 I mean, yes.
5:37:07 Maybe they need to spend it. Um because that could be one of the things is, you know, and then what kind of your skills,
5:37:15 what kind of criteria, you know, I I did a records request to or I asked to see the records. say on, you know, all the
5:37:23 expenses and it looks and I'm fine with the city manager approving it all, but I think that if we're going to have questions about what people are doing or
5:37:31 or what they can't do or what requires council approval, what doesn't require council approval, I think that should be in a policy rather than putting Mr. Van Wagner in the position of guessing.
5:37:42 Yeah, if we haven't ever discussed that, do we I guess we don't have anything in writing of what we can use our training Mr. Where's Mr.
5:37:50 Like it was only could be used for the conferences. Okay. Well, let's let's have get with Mr. W.
5:37:56 Let him let him look at the legal ramifications of all the different things. I know Mr. W and I talked about it before, but uh I don't
5:38:05 think it went any further than the conversation I had with him a couple months ago.
5:38:08 I think it's I think it's warranted. I also think it's warranted to to just throw out to to say to consider, you know, rather than have it be one pot,
5:38:17 have it be per council member. Uh, you know, I've worked in institutions before, especially in public institutions in higher ed where, you
5:38:25 know, you're there was 15 I think it's 15,000 for training and education. Well, it wasn't 15,000 until and then whoever
5:38:33 used it got to use it. It was you got three, you got three, you got three, you got three, you got three. Uh, and if you
5:38:41 used it, great. If not, there might be some leftover. We could fund some other things. But again, that could be a part of a policy conversation. I don't want to peacemail it. So maybe we add all
5:38:49 that to together to talk about that and see how that works. Well, yeah. And and let me say this, Mr.
5:38:55 Strange. I would never look to cutting cut training. That's one of the things I've always been against is training the cutting training. Uh, always seen when
5:39:05 establishment start running low on money. First thing they want to cut is personnel and training. And now you got all these lack of people, lack of training, and people can't do the job.
5:39:14 And it makes sense.
5:39:15 I'm in agreement with you actually is really important. It's something I always spend money on.
5:39:20 I bring what the spend has been midway through the year to raise awareness that we may end up with a surplus because we're not getting the training.
5:39:29 I'd rather get the training surplus. And uh then I I admit one of the things uh lately uh I think
5:39:39 this council and previous council well since I've been on council anyway we probably do most traveling to uh training and all the different things in
5:39:48 in the previous council was and conferences and everything because uh and participate in a lot of different other things. Of course, a lot of times
5:39:57 I go on on conferences and trips and stuff and I don't even charge it back. A lot of times I just take it out of my pocket.
5:40:06 So um other other than the hotel usually if I'm staying overnight I charge that but the travel and everything I usually just a lot of it I take it out.
5:40:18 But I think these things I don't want to discourage anybody from going because I think the training from the going to the
5:40:26 conference and everything has a lot of value.
5:40:29 They very helpful. For example, when we were down FB Leo in April and everything, it was a lot of good information we was able to gather there
5:40:36 and everything in and that's why I see a lot of value. As a matter of fact, I'm leaving the night to go on one tomorrow with Florida legal mayors, board of
5:40:44 directors tomorrow and Thursday. be tied with them. Uh, but I'm expecting to be able to communicate with a lot of
5:40:52 other elected officials and mayors and everything from all over the state.
5:40:59 Their budget budget.
5:41:02 I think we all in the budget process right now. So, that's going to be interesting to see what everybody else is doing. But, uh, is that it, Mr. Bay?
5:41:10 Thank you.
5:41:11 Who we have next? It Oh, it you're up.
5:41:16 knowing knowing just how much that all of you like to sit down and talk with the lead IT geek for hours on end. I I'm
5:41:24 going to try to keep this short. Um couple of comments in the beginning.
5:41:28 There's very few advantages of being the IT director, but being able to take over the electronics in the room at any time is one of those. If you look at that
5:41:36 screen there, I've got I went off script. Um I've got copies of this right here.
5:41:43 One of the things as I was sitting over there. I'll go ahead and put this back over to to the normal screen. I've got copies of that screen you just saw. What
5:41:51 that represents is the software products that we have here at the city of Clermont. Uh this one's a little dated.
5:41:58 It's uh about five months old, but what we saw with the support of the city
5:42:05 manager's office and uh and Zane the leaison uh we've managed to start talking about
5:42:12 this subject. something that's that I've brought up a few times and we and city manager's office said we'll we'll run with that. So we're we're looking at
5:42:20 across the city software products that are not only deemed as aging and possibly unnecessary but also looking at
5:42:28 where is the same product being duplicated elsewhere in the city. So um so I just want to let you know uh as as
5:42:35 my other 12 department directors were up here and sometimes struggling with the topic of the technology and and software
5:42:43 products. Um it's kind of I wanted to jump up and kind of aid them at sometime because it's it is a struggle. It is it
5:42:51 is tough to know what's going on in different legs. I touch all places in the city. So um the the the IT
5:43:00 department um since we are in all places at all points in the city, we see the hardware, we see the software, we see the way that
5:43:09 they communicate. We never try to dictate process because we can't we're not experts in those other areas, but we can give a good insight to to what is
5:43:17 duplicating and what we can do to optimize.
5:43:21 So looking at the uh current year in review, it was a big year for for big things that on paper uh these are
5:43:29 projects that really were multiple years in in the making. They just kind of came to an end. Um the um uh in the area of
5:43:37 uh migrating email services that that came in not only email but in the area of uh our products that we use for our
5:43:46 primary office suite throughout the city. So that is the Microsoft Office product that most cities use. We made
5:43:54 that change to 365 which is a a model that is cloud-based. It makes us more efficient. Uh that was part of an
5:44:02 initiative that we were able to shrink the footprint of the local hardware that we run in our data centers locally by
5:44:08 60% over the last four years. Um the uh that's less that's less power, that's less replacement hardware, that's less
5:44:17 storage, that's that all those things are add up to a cons a significant savings here at the city. Um the phone
5:44:26 system, that was another thing. We had a an aging phone system that was very shy on on functionality. Um now with the new
5:44:34 phone system, we've gone to a a modern phone system where I in my office, just to make a point, I disconnected the brick that's on my desk and put it up on
5:44:43 the counter next to my desk. Um I I receive calls on this laptop right now.
5:44:48 somebody were to call me, I can receive calls on my phone, uh, and I can receive calls on the kiosk if I wanted to. So,
5:44:56 it it just it really does make life easier for everybody. And we're we're going to be doing a lot of education
5:45:03 with our staff to show them how they can benefit from that. And not only voice calls, but Teams meetings, video calls, uh, texting, all that stuff.
5:45:14 Absolutely. Does each person have to have a phone with a phone number that syncs to your system?
5:45:22 Yeah, every person that is there this employee that is on the system has a phone number associated with their with their name.
5:45:29 But is it a phone or is it like a digital phone number or is it an actual physical phone with an account?
5:45:34 Is it a digital phone number? They have the choice of having a physical phone on their desk which which most people do. I
5:45:42 don't. I disconnected it to make the point. I I disconnected it, set it up on the desk next to me to be repurposed for
5:45:49 someone else just to show the functionality difference. If I've got my cell phone on me and I'm 10 feet from my desk, why walk over there and answer the
5:45:57 phone when I can pick up my cell phone and just answer the call. Um, if I'm on my laptop and I'm just I was just on vacation. I was in the mountains of
5:46:06 Tennessee. If a phone call came in and I just happened to be doing something on my on my laptop, I just push answer phone and and I can use the speakers in.
5:46:16 Can you text? I can text from it as well.
5:46:19 Yeah. So there's there's really no reason to myself. You can't text it from a desk.
5:46:23 I can from my Well, from my Well, not from not from the desk phone, not the brick, but from my computer. I can use that to do texting as though I was on the phone, just like a MacBook.
5:46:34 You can do it on iPad. Yes, ma'am. I'll bring it in.
5:46:37 You got it. You got it. It does. It does offer. It opens up a world of stuff. And this isn't this isn't, you know, rocket
5:46:45 science. This isn't this isn't stuff that's this that's brand new. It just took us a while to get to that point.
5:46:51 We're government and we we move a little slower sometimes. That's But I I'm trying to make that change happen. Um the um the other piece is of
5:47:01 the puzzle that we uh that we really did that was uh big this year was it came to a head as well. Um I've been in the
5:47:08 position now a few years and one of the things that we that we did in the past is we we had um we really didn't have
5:47:15 outside audits of our processes procedures, our security, our firewalling, our our switch
5:47:23 configurations, all of those items. Uh we have not only annual audits of the
5:47:29 work that I do uh third party um we also have uh audits of our existing
5:47:36 configurations. They go into our firewalls and they look at the way that we've got those configured. They give me suggestions on what they think I do. No
5:47:44 matter how good I think I am, uh it it does it you you look at something long enough, you don't see the numbers
5:47:52 anymore. You just see blah blah blah blah. It it just it just happens that way. So we uh we have an annual audit and we have quarterly audits. Uh so they
5:48:01 they come in and do a quarterly audit which is a reduced uh footprint but it does uh they do hit all of the the the
5:48:08 major attack vectors and review the logs that I review daily.
5:48:14 Um the other thing that we did that was notable is in the same vein of security.
5:48:20 When we talk security in the IT department, we we're also talking about the security meaning access control
5:48:27 and uh security cameras throughout the city. This the IT department also uh manages and installs and and works with
5:48:36 consultants to install in a lot of those cases and uh and manages the the security of the of the access control,
5:48:44 the doors, what have you, and the cameras. Um we have now migrated all but one of our
5:48:52 major facilities and one minor piece of one of our facilities to a common system for all of our access control that
5:49:00 allows all of our administrative people in all of the departments to be able to the ones that do access control in the
5:49:07 buildings. It allows them to go into a a common interface and be able to isolate a person, a badge, access to a door, and
5:49:16 be able to to more effectively do that work rather than having four different access control systems and uh and and making a thousand keys a year, right?
5:49:28 Um other than that um that's that's kind of
5:49:36 the general overlook of what we've done this year. Um major major things the IT department we
5:49:45 we um uh in the position section that you see there
5:49:51 we have a very flat or chart. Uh when I first got here, I looked at where we have where we have manager positions and
5:49:58 I looked at where we have uh uh administrators and I said, you know, it's it's crazy. Our our chart looked a
5:50:06 lot different when I first took the job and and it was broken out into submanagers.
5:50:12 I manage effectively there's more people on that list than than this, but I manage effectively daily six people.
5:50:19 Those are the six people that touch people's desks every day. Uh there's no reason to have sub managers in that environment. They they can report all to
5:50:27 one person and that's me. Um we do have uh two positions on that list that are paid by other departments and I excluded those from that statement on purpose.
5:50:38 Water and sewer department. Uh they pay for the GIS position that's up there and the SCA network position. Both of those
5:50:45 positions are are vacant and I'll give you some context to that in a second.
5:50:50 But uh they they asked me uh and my predecessor this came before me but they asked if we could manage that because
5:50:56 it's a technology sort of position. Uh they want somebody that's a technology person to manage those those roles. So
5:51:04 so uh my predecessor agreed to do that and I agreed to take it on as when I came to to the position. Um currently
5:51:14 both of those positions are unfilled because we've tried to fill those positions with warm bodies in the past.
5:51:18 That doesn't work. not not just filling them with warm bodies. You need people that are really good at what they do and have a very specific skill set to
5:51:26 government. Um so right now I'm very effectively working with a couple of uh a couple of consultants that are doing
5:51:34 the work that is by the city working with the fire, public works and police departments to get the GIS mapping that they need and also working with
5:51:43 consultants to get the SCADA uh meaning the controls that we use in in water and sewer. uh working to make those updates
5:51:51 happen, the software updates, making sure that we do the server work internally anyway, but working with those consultants to get them what they
5:51:59 need and and to provide the server resources they need to do the job. We're finding that that's very effective and
5:52:06 in at least one of those positions I may come to council later on and say we're really going to work with consultants
5:52:13 more efficiently than we can with staff on this this position and we may be able to free that up in the future for some other use. But as it stands right now
5:52:22 I'm fielding it out right now saving money. We're uh the city manager, I believe, uh has officially allowed me to
5:52:29 uh to utilize funding that we would normally use in the uh in the area of uh of employment uh for salaries to fund
5:52:38 some of those uh those contractual dollars. Is is that right, Scott?
5:52:42 Yeah. So, I can't officially do that, although I haven't had to tap into it yet. We still have a budget. But anyway, that's that's that part. Trying not to
5:52:49 bore you to death and I can see from the faces I might be failing. Um we we have uh wait we're we're approaching 500
5:52:58 employees here at the city. Uh this the IT department has grown one person in eight years. Um we uh we recently added
5:53:07 116 uh people on at the city uh citywide.
5:53:13 Um those people were either new FTEEs or refilling of vacant positions. Every
5:53:20 person every computer computer, laptop, phone, uh although the procurement department shares some of that load with
5:53:28 us. Um printers, um and all the connectivity in between all the wires and wireless that they use to connect to
5:53:36 that. The IT department manages that. Um so when we see these FTAs coming on board, we see those new hires coming on
5:53:43 board, we have to create an account for that person. We have to to manage their resources. We have to make sure they've got the tools they need to do the job
5:53:51 and make sure they always work. Um, make sure that the sound system in this room works. Another thing sometimes I fail at.
5:53:59 Um, what else? What else? What else? Uh, the one position that you see that's a requested. I saw that screen just pop
5:54:07 up. That uh that FTE that I am requesting is to bring a a combination person. I don't believe that we can keep
5:54:14 a a uh an AV person uh for what we do here in the chambers and what we do with our other engagements, the teams
5:54:22 meetings, the the u the uh official uh meetings here in the chambers where we bring the public in and we bring uh
5:54:31 members that might be out of town in. I don't believe we can keep a person busy full-time yet at the size of our city currently. So that's a combo position
5:54:39 that's going to that person will also be utilized to handle desktop support handle and a lot of that might be, you know, related to what their primary uh
5:54:48 education is in in in the AV world, but also be able to handle those those rudimentary desktop support issues. So, that's what that one position is that
5:54:56 I'm requesting. It'll backfill some uh some areas where we're stressed a little bit when we have a vacation person or not.
5:55:09 construction projects. Just about all of our construction projects, whether it be streets or buildings, uh we have IT
5:55:16 resources that need to go into those. Uh Montro Street, we have uh fiber that goes down the streets for connectivity,
5:55:23 both in existing, both enhancing and and getting us out to areas that we don't have uh currently. Uh we've got uh some
5:55:33 stuff coming up where we would like to uh to back fill some places that need a little bit more. Uh Keeler building is
5:55:40 one of those uh when when that building was originally put in play. Uh we didn't realize all the things that we were going to do with Keeler building. Since
5:55:48 then the directors found many uses for that. So we we could uh you know we we might once the opportunity comes up we
5:55:55 might put fiber into that building so that our phones and our computer resources and that sort of stuff the Wi-Fi everything else is working real
5:56:02 well to there. Um uh down at fire station 4. We still don't have fiber down to that building.
5:56:10 Uh and one of the items you'll see on my budget is is for fiber. That that budget doesn't always get used but what we try
5:56:18 to do is earmark that fiber. What happens is we we say that we want to connect fire station 4. That depends on
5:56:24 DOT. It depends on the county. We got to have easements to run that stuff to dig that trench and to put that conduit in the ground. Going down to Wellness Way
5:56:33 with our new combo police and fire stations. Um we had to work with the contractors to make sure we we were
5:56:41 allocated this the easements and also they they helped fund getting that conduit in the ground. Um so that's what that budget is for. kind of these
5:56:50 capital projects. Um, any questions on that?
5:56:57 Okay. And when I say fiber, I do mean private fiber. We own all of our fiber.
5:57:01 The city has in whether it be 24 strands, meaning 40 24 channels of of
5:57:08 data or whether it be 96 of our main connections around the city that connect us from different places. So if we get a
5:57:16 backhoe that goes crazy over on one side of town, we don't lose connectivity in the whole city. That will backfill another way. Uh we own all that fiber.
5:57:26 We don't pay a monthly fee. Once it's in the ground, it's in the ground.
5:57:32 Um personnel, uh you will see and also I'll
5:57:40 just make one more comment on the general budget. you will see some some negatives here and there. Uh that
5:57:48 efficiency is what counts for that. Um with the the help of the city manager's office and the help of staff, we've
5:57:55 managed to to do some things that have made us operate much more efficiently over the last eight years and certainly over the last three, four years. Um
5:58:04 those items that you see that are reduced in budget, that doesn't mean I'm not offering those services. It just means I'm able to offer more efficient
5:58:11 uh that foot shrinking the footprint of the server rooms means that we're not buying as many replacement servers every year. We're not buying as many um power
5:58:20 outlets and UPS's and all those things that we have to do to support that.
5:58:27 If you look at the the budget as well and this screen makes it pretty apparent when you're talking about operating capital going up 74%.
5:58:37 Um, some of that is contractual dollars.
5:58:41 So, where we're able to um um utilize those those phones, the phones for
5:58:48 instance, that's a good number to throw up in there. Is that when we went to the a new phone system?
5:58:55 Well, we we increased that budget by I think it it's uh $70,000 a year
5:59:02 in the software side of things. the hardware side, meaning the connections that the Telos provided us and the
5:59:11 resources required for that were $85,000.
5:59:15 Those those those phone lines, those trunks that we used are now gone.
5:59:21 Uh so that's a net positive. So we were able to to then, you know, save money in that area. um computers.
5:59:31 Some of the computers that we buy have literally gone up 100%. They've doubled in cost. Uh and it's all about AI data
5:59:40 centers, uh uh video chips, all of that stuff that you hear on the news all the time, that affects the cost of goods,
5:59:48 and we can't control that. So, the cost of your average desktop computer, it may be faster than the one we had last year,
5:59:56 but that's that that that that ohms law that law that says that things get faster and cheaper well that just got
6:00:03 destroyed. Uh this we feel like this is a temporary thing that once the data centers and everything else that the
6:00:10 initiatives with AI go up uh uh that will normalize again. So I think this is going to be the wor in my opinion this will be the worst year that we get.
6:00:21 So that's where you see our our increases. That's pretty much the only increases you'll see in our budget for this year. other than the one FT.
6:00:33 Any questions on those budgets?
6:00:38 Um, I do see on page 53 of the budget for capital for the council chamber ad
6:00:45 system, we have nothing for this fiscal year, but money for in fiscal year 28.
6:00:51 Right. And I' I'd like to ask my fellow council members to to move that into
6:00:57 this fiscal year. Um, I think we all hear uh you beat me to it a lot from our from our residents, from people who
6:01:06 participate that the sound system in here. And I think even uh our IT director would agree that there, you know, we've we've
6:01:14 had conversations where we could do different mics from the ceilings and so forth to pick up different sound and it doesn't have to be a physical mic that
6:01:21 you hold, but we just don't have the capabilities currently. And I think that um with the age of technology and more
6:01:30 people participating online and us trying to promote that transparency and getting things out there also too I
6:01:38 think just sometimes it's hard to hear even when you're here in the in this room talking like I can hear maybe the
6:01:45 mayor more clearly because he's right here but you know Mr. bore down there if I don't necessarily hear him out of the
6:01:52 speaker. So, I have to really try to like listen to him because it's not being amplified as well. And if we had a different system in here. So, long story
6:02:01 short, I really would like to see us move that funding from fiscal year 28 into fiscal year 27 and get that going
6:02:09 so that we can improve the sound system in here.
6:02:11 You beat me to it and I agree with you wholeheartedly.
6:02:14 But that was a big topic for us. We really the city manager's office and and and myself we we because as as the as
6:02:21 the IT director we look at the you know making things new and shiny. That's a good thing for an IT guy. Uh but the but
6:02:27 we did we we struggled with that uh looking at budgets and where budgets are and trying to trying to decrease
6:02:35 expenditures worried about shrinking budgets on the legislative side. Uh, so we did talk about that quite a bit and
6:02:42 and and that was our decision at that point was to pull that out. But the city manager and you guys worked through that and if you want me to bring
6:02:50 that back in, I am certainly willing to I mean I've had a lot of people complain to me over in Kings Ridge that I see they said
6:02:58 a lot of times they don't hear what's going on. Yeah, there's little gaps in it. So I don't know. I guess this might have been an improvement the new little speakers
6:03:07 unless there's something better that everybody can have one of those lapels microphones where let's say yeah is it it encompasses the whole
6:03:14 broad yeah that that term one other quick thing is there's a product called OraCast I don't know if
6:03:23 you're familiar with that is that something that we can use at the PHC or is it it's a it's a Bluetooth type
6:03:31 device but it's not It's a different type people that wear hearing aids.
6:03:35 Yeah. Was this way it goes right into the hearing aids?
6:03:37 Yeah. There there's there's half a dozen of those products that are out there.
6:03:42 Uh we actually have one in the back for for that that's similar in design for uh for um uh handicap use, right?
6:03:52 And uh but yes, the answer is yes. And is already there now to be forecast? Not forecast itself.
6:03:59 It's like a bandaid, right? Band-Aid meaning the the term band-aid, right? Okay.
6:04:04 Uh but yeah, there are many of those devices out there, but yes.
6:04:10 Are you working with Mr. Matthysse on the software audit? Yes.
6:04:14 And are any of the anticipated savings in that reflected in this budget?
6:04:20 It's hard to it it I I would say no, but but let me qualify that answer. Um the uh we're early in this thing. So it's
6:04:28 been a matter of weeks that we've been working on this. Um we have not only are we doing the audit of the software, but
6:04:35 we're also uh trying to form a a committee um organizations much larger than the organization I'm in today.
6:04:44 We've done that in the past and had great successes in that, including the department heads and and key people in in the organization with making these
6:04:52 decisions on these software products, not just going out and buying the vendor recommended solution of the day.
6:04:59 I I completely understand that. And my question based on the fact that you believe that you've done this before, um is how long do you think it will take
6:05:07 for this city to get to a final recommendation of software and implementation of software? Well, I think number one, that's g it's it's
6:05:16 always going to be a bit of a floating target, but as far as the overview, um I really uh and talked with the city
6:05:24 manager and uh with with Oh, Zayn's not here. I was going to give give Zayn a little bit of credit here,
6:05:31 but the uh but uh working with Zayn, I think that the audit itself is something that's very short term. I think that
6:05:38 within within the next couple of months that the city manager will have the information uh necessary to be able to
6:05:45 give you a summary of where we think we're at. Um so 60 days probably we can we can have a summary of where we think we're at.
6:05:54 Can we get an update at the beginning of September so we kind of know? Yes.
6:05:59 That way as we go into budget I'm lucky I don't want I don't want to commit you to anything, sir. Um uh yes
6:06:08 you can. Uh and and I think that this is an easy lift. Uh we we go through this, we take a look. The hard part is making
6:06:17 sure that the production side of things is not affected by the technology decisions. And I think that over the
6:06:24 next 30 to 60 days, we'll have a real clear. We already we're already getting That's great. Thank you.
6:06:33 Just so our city manager is clear, I don't know if we got the consensus on moving. I think we do. Okay.
6:06:40 Okay. I just want to make sure I don't want to leave it out there. You're like, I want that taken care.
6:06:45 I do, but I but I I fully respect if we don't.
6:06:48 My my only question on that, Wayne, is do you anticipate any potential conflict with with that project as you're going
6:06:56 through the audit? Would we be spending money on something that we don't need six months later or is it something that would feed into the system as we move forward?
6:07:04 I I don't see any conflicts there at all. Uh most of what we see in the in the budget that we're talking about doing for the we are talking about the
6:07:11 the chambers and and the the updates here. Most of these are uh are hardware enhancements. This is this is a design
6:07:19 that what you're seeing here. We've we've made the other things work within a design that was done in the late8s and a out that was done in the 90s and the
6:07:28 early 2000s. Uh, this room was never intended to do what it does. The acoustics are totally wrong. The the
6:07:36 electronics are antiquated for what we do with it. And we've spent roughly that many dollars doing what you see today as
6:07:43 far as the teams and the other things that we brought in. You know, we we we you know, as much as we love the octopus, it would be able to go away and
6:07:51 this sort of stuff would not be as visible as it is today. Um, No, there would be no conflicts and it wouldn't be anything short term. This would be we'd
6:08:00 be building something that we could look at for the next 10 or 15 years with most modern hardware and software
6:08:09 too. You're you're looking at stuff that's designed to be updated.
6:08:17 Anything else?
6:08:22 Uh did you uh we don't need to hit legal? Well, I know he's not here.
6:08:32 I don't think there is nothing to it though.
6:08:34 There was no well miss finances last
6:08:41 and then if if you'd like the police have an update from yesterday's conversation.
6:08:48 Well, we finance now. Let's listen to the police real quick so they can get out of here and we'll finish. We start with finance.
6:08:58 We're going to get and then you just got to give me a suggested military.
6:09:06 Okay. Chief. Chief. Did you do you need a break?
6:09:16 I guess let's stay. 10 minutes.
6:12:42 Heat. Heat.
6:13:08 Heat. Heat. Heat.
6:13:31 Heat.
6:14:51 Hey. Hey. Hey.
6:15:23 Heat. Heat.
6:16:57 Heat. Heat.
6:17:23 Heat. Heat.
6:17:46 Heat. Heat.
6:18:05 Hey.
6:18:45 Heat. Hey. Hey. Hey.
6:19:45 Tracy, Missie,
6:19:56 the chief is here to answer some of the questions that were brought up yesterday uh by Miss Paige. So, Okay.
6:20:05 Yes, sir.
6:20:06 All right. I will uh I will try to be as brief as possible and we'll go down the down the order. I'll start with the replacement vehicles as that's that's one of the line items at $1.4 million.
6:20:18 So, the the 18 vehicles that we're looking to replace. They are all spares.
6:20:22 Only three of those vehicles are unmarked. 15 are marked. All of them have significant issues such as no printer or internet connection. Lights
6:20:31 don't fully work. Decals or wrap peeling or fading. The Dodge Chargers all have suspension or radiator issues. Many of the Fords have mechanical issues.
6:20:41 All are well over the mileage and or age in the mileage listed here on the sheet that I have doesn't include the idle
6:20:48 hours. The idle hours, if I remember correctly, it's I believe it's one hour of idling is
6:20:55 equivalent to 30 miles. 30 miles of driving. Those are the cars. I have the list of vehicles prepared. If the
6:21:03 council wants to see the list of vehicles, we can turn that list of vehicles over to you guys. We're not hiding anything. That's just where we're at with the ATV.
6:21:11 What is is there a standard every eight years for departments across the country or is that just us or is other
6:21:18 departments take you know I would imagine an argument would be well why don't you just replace the engine? Why don't you just replace the tires, the transmission, the radios, the software?
6:21:30 Is that is that a viable option with other departments?
6:21:33 Correct. In instances where the replace the repair is more than the vehicle is worth, it doesn't make sense. But let's
6:21:40 say we just got a car and it's a year old, have 15,000 miles on it. Yeah, we would replace the transmission or we would replace the the engine. We would replace what fix
6:21:49 whatever mechanical issue exists to extend the life of the car. These cars Make sure I read the right age and mile is basically what's going
6:21:57 on now. Mr. Peterson, what would you ask?
6:21:59 So, is it eight years to Well, I think originally we we 100,000 miles when we first started doing this plan, I think we set it up for seven year every
6:22:07 seven years where you replace them. But we didn't we didn't think about the mileage. Okay. And now the problem he having here is the the high mileage on
6:22:16 them. So, but I I'll give you an here's here's the list here. It's a a 2009 Chevy Malibu.
6:22:23 That's administrative car, 2014 Ford Fusion, 2014 Ford Explorer, three 2015 Ford Interceptors,
6:22:32 seven 2016 Ford Interceptors, two 2017 Ford Interceptors, four Dodge Chargers, 2018 Dodge
6:22:40 Chargers, and two 19 2019 Dodge Chargers.
6:22:43 The oldest one is probably the one that wasn't used on patrol most likely. the the Chevy Malibu, the Ford Fusion.
6:22:51 I'd have to look at the 2014 Ford Explorer.
6:22:54 Maybe it could have been repurposed, but those the top three look like they were all un for a fact the Malibu in the future were never patrolled vehicle
6:23:08 as my car.
6:23:09 115,000 miles, but but I'm saying the mileage on them is probably a little bit Well, they older, so the mileage may be up there because they're older, but it's not
6:23:18 going to be like the ones that's on patrol that's a little bit younger.
6:23:21 Great. And you have I mean but that is that is protocol for seven years.
6:23:26 That like we're not just we have 100 officers. We're going to be replacing 15 to 20 vehicles every year, right? And that's just what it's going to be.
6:23:34 You just have to policy is our policy. We're inventing something different.
6:23:42 Basically, we got them set up. Mr.
6:23:44 Peterson got us set on a rotation where every year we're going to be replacing them. Try to keep them keep them under this and everything. So, and like I had mentioned yesterday, we
6:23:51 work with with public works, we work with the mechanics. They help us identify the vehicles that are in the worst condition. Those are the vehicles that we surplus and then you'll see the year probably
6:24:00 next year's vehicles that'll be getting surplus are the ones that we go into spares right now. And that's kind of how it works is the new cars come in, they get assigned to new cars, then those cars go into spares.
6:24:09 Bill and Bryan, in case you're asked, one thing that we used to do is we used to pay for the police vehicles at the
6:24:16 infrastructure fund, which is where our get paid from. Oh yeah. And that was 800 to a million a year.
6:24:23 And now we're doing it from the police fund. So when we see the police numbers go up last year, it's actually because the money used to come from a fund
6:24:32 that was our streets and now it's appropriately coming from the police fund and so they're adjusting to that.
6:24:38 I didn't think anything was unusual with that.
6:24:42 That one's Did you have information on the on the tank?
6:24:45 I do. I have an update on the tank. The rescue vehicle, the Emraat, it goes by 50 different names throughout the community. It's always the right one to use.
6:24:53 We call it the the rescue vehicle is what we call rescue or the armored vehicle. That's what we call high water vehicle.
6:25:00 But I'm I'm glad you I'm glad, Mr.
6:25:02 Peterson, you kind of went into that because that vehicle is an all-purpose vehicle.
6:25:06 We can go and do high water rescues as we did um when the hurricanes came through at Emerald Lakes on that little portion uh that's surrounded by water. That's
6:25:13 one of the few vehicles that can maneuver through the water in deep water. Um, we created some flexibility within our fleet by getting some F-150s
6:25:22 and F250s to where we can assist in those types of missions uh with smaller vehicles. The the rescue vehicle is a
6:25:30 very heavy vehicle so it cannot get everywhere if that makes sense. There are weight restrictions on certain roadways. So, you have to create some flexibility within your fleet.
6:25:39 Uh, some quick stats. I I don't want to keep us here much longer than we have to be. Um since and we went back to 2023.
6:25:48 Since 2023, we have had to ask the Mount Door Police Department for assistance utilizing their pack Bearcat 15 times.
6:25:56 We have used they're a Bearcat is a similar uh it's a smaller armored vehicle uh same uh protection rating
6:26:06 that is what they use to for their uh high-risisk incidents to get SWAT operators to on the scenes do things like that.
6:26:14 So apples to apples on this one. We have used the rescue vehicle four times on missions and four times for rescue
6:26:21 operations since 2023. So if you add in the 15 and the eight, that's 23 times in the last three years. This is not a high
6:26:29 use vehicle. This is a low frequency, high-risisk vehicle. We roll this vehicle out when we need to go do something that is dangerous and we need
6:26:37 to deploy our personnel in a safe manner. It was used effectively during the Cottonwood um incident that we had
6:26:45 there where we were able to deploy gas to the apartment from a from an armored place. when we uh went and
6:26:54 excuse me uh picked up the homicide suspect, we used Maldor's Bearcat for that operation. The MR was or the rescue
6:27:01 vehicle was down. They function in in many of the same ways and that's what we're looking to do. We keep our eyes
6:27:09 out on the military surplus program. We haven't seen what the military calls this vehicle is an MRAP or a mine resistant armored personnel vehicle. We
6:27:18 haven't seen one of those come available and I had mentioned this yesterday. We're looking for grant opportunities.
6:27:24 We're looking at the UASI grant. We haven't had a lot of success with that and I understand that but we keep putting it in. Um we also have other
6:27:32 other federal monies that are coming in in the future to where we may be able to purchase that with those with those funds. But I have to put it in the
6:27:39 budget in case those funds don't come through. It wouldn't be fair for me to come in and ask for a $500,000 budget amendment to the council and then catch
6:27:47 all of you by surprise. That that doesn't make sense. That's not how we're going to do business as the police department.
6:27:52 So, that's the that is the really condensed version of the armored vehicle. Any questions?
6:28:00 Were any lives saved in those 23 incidents?
6:28:03 We did. The uh Chief Azelle had mentioned the one where we deployed I think it was Hurricane Milton and uh maybe you'll recall this. It was it made
6:28:11 the a tree had come down uh through a residence and someone was pinned to the bed. Oh dear.
6:28:18 That's how we were able to deploy. We we trained the person to operate the vehicle. The paramedics jumped in. We
6:28:25 deploy to the residence in the middle of the storm. We're able the fire department's able to get the person in.
6:28:31 We're actually able to get the person to the hospital at some point. I don't remember how we got the doctor to the hospital, but the doctor ends up at the hospital as well. That ve when I say
6:28:40 that vehicle was all purpose vehicle. It is meant to do everything we need it to do. Um if we didn't have one of those,
6:28:47 we'd be diminishing our capabilities and the assets we're able to provide to Clermont. But in states of emergency,
6:28:55 we're really a South Lake regional asset. So when you think about it in terms of that, it's much more than just
6:29:02 a an armored vehicle or as some people may say a toy or something like it is.
6:29:07 There is functionality for it. There is use for it. Is it worth anything?
6:29:14 The one we have now, we have to give back to the That's right.
6:29:17 But what did we pay for that? We didn't pay much, right?
6:29:20 We I think all in with the lights, the delivery, and all that. We're somewhere around the $20,000.
6:29:24 Yeah. I didn't think it was It was a pretty good I would say it was probably a once in a-lifetime opportunity for us. We took advantage of the opportunity.
6:29:33 So, what's wrong with it? We have to give it back. Is that what you're saying?
6:29:36 We don't have to give it back. It's 20 years old. The maintenance costs are rising. the air conditioning is uh is not as reliable. I mean, is it repairable?
6:29:46 Yes. Right now it's it's down more than it's up, but we uh we can I think you're Are these like CJs where
6:29:54 they last forever or are they like our new modern cars? I think everything has a lifespan on it.
6:30:00 You said usually 13 times in three years. 23 times.
6:30:04 23 times because Well, you got to remember it was old when we got It went brand new, huh?
6:30:13 No, it wasn't brand new when we got it.
6:30:15 And the way I look at it was it was a really smart way to test how this type of vehicle might be used in our community.
6:30:23 Correct.
6:30:24 Without having to spend half a million dollars.
6:30:26 We got it from the army, right? And we have to return it to them when we get rid of. We just can't get rid of that's why it has to go back to the It's kind of on loan from the military.
6:30:36 They don't want the wrong hand.
6:30:38 Well, you don't want it in the wrong hand. That's true. Okay. Well, thank you for listening.
6:30:43 I'm quite sure the army had used quite a bit before we got beyond you can be
6:30:51 that question. Oh, I thought it was going on.
6:30:56 I'm I will throw this out there to cut some of the some of the decision making.
6:31:03 I understand. I'm asking for $55,000 for a remodel of the police department. If that's not in this year's budget, I understand. At some point, I'm going to
6:31:12 have to do something to the building to create space at HQ. Um, just internally,
6:31:19 I don't think sharing offices at the captain's level is appropriate when we have to have difficult conversations with personnel. If they're dealing with
6:31:26 internal affairs, they're dealing with different things like that. I think that one-on-one meeting is way more impactful with the employee, whether you're you're giving them praise or whether
6:31:34 you're disappointing them for for poor performance. Um, but if I as me sitting in front of y'all, if you end up cutting
6:31:41 the 155,000, I understand that and I am not married uh to that project. I would just say in the future we would have to come back
6:31:49 and do some kind of renovation to the police department. I think my focus right now should be on station five and ensuring that we have the appropriate
6:31:56 funds to build a southern substation that will meet the needs of wellness way today and at least for the foreseeable future.
6:32:09 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you guys question.
6:32:29 Yes, sir. Finance. Yes, sir. Yes, sir. Come on down. Right.
6:32:33 You You started this and you going in this. Well, hopefully. Sounds ominous.
6:32:40 Hopefully we end it on a positive note. I'm hoping so.
6:32:53 All right. So, much like the other departments, we'll start with uh talking about our current year and review. When I presented our proposed budget for this
6:33:01 current year, uh this time last year, I talked about this year being a year where we uh review and update policies.
6:33:09 We've uh brought two of those before you already and thank you for your support on those. Uh currently we are working
6:33:16 the next policy we'll bring before you is one related to utility billing and collection policies and um I'm trying to
6:33:23 tying the presentation of that with uh the presentation of the rate study. Um so I do anticipate that coming for you
6:33:31 before the end of the fiscal year. Uh as you know we uh reestablish ourselves as a distinguished audit award winner with
6:33:38 GFOA for 2024. Um we do so the goal and expectation obviously is to retain that every year going forward. We do have our
6:33:47 25 application in and it is in a review status as we speak. Uh one of the things I'm most proud about this last year is
6:33:55 the creation of that popular annual financial report when we did present that audit for 25. Um so my intention is
6:34:05 to create a similar document for this budget cycle as well. Uh so once we get through the the workshops on this will create what's called a budgeting brief.
6:34:16 Um similarly condensed version of of the budget once we get to that point in this current cycle.
6:34:23 Another accomplishment during the year is we updated the utility billing format in the spring. And um you know, as a side note, we're always
6:34:32 open and receptive to uh adjustments and tweaks to that billing format. So I'd encourage both council and the public to let us know if they have recommendations
6:34:40 on that. We control that was oftentimes the nominal cost on that, but always open to feedback on adjusting the
6:34:47 billing format. And then, as you know, back in the uh winter, February, March, we launched resident access with autopay
6:34:55 and uh phased out the former direct debit program. Uh we had a huge increase in call volume and customer servicing
6:35:03 during that point in time, but we worked through it with patience and diligence and uh we're four months into it now and we're seeing the efficiencies we
6:35:10 anticipated with that. So, I'm happy with where we're at with that. Last two notes are more internal but um
6:35:18 informational, but we did complete our banking transition uh around the uh start of the calendar year. We're very
6:35:26 happy with our banking relationships at this point in time. And uh lastly, last year I I asked for council to consider
6:35:33 establishing a a tiered job classification model for our non-exempt team members. We did launch that um a month or so ago. uh it was well received
6:35:42 by the employees and and I'm confident that that's going to uh help with retention going forward which was certainly a goal of that initiative. Um
6:35:51 so once again thanks to council for supporting that.
6:35:56 All right, next slide shows you our current organization um chart for the department as a whole. Currently 19.5
6:36:03 FTEES and we're requesting 1.5 additions for a total of 21 into the new fiscal year. And I'll talk more specifically
6:36:12 about those requests in a moment. Um, but while we're on the orchar, I want to much like what we talked about with other departments, you know, we do have
6:36:20 funding that's allocated to multiple areas. Uh, generally speaking, the utility billing and collections team is
6:36:27 all to the four enterprise funds. So there's no general fund impact by those individuals. Um and then on the finance
6:36:34 division um majority of that is general fund impacted but we do have some allocations in in some cases to uh the enterprise funds.
6:36:45 Next slide we put together uh just some uh quick department matrix to give you an idea of the volume that we're working with and this feeds into the discussion
6:36:54 and on the u the communications department and the proposed 311 center.
6:36:59 Um, as you can see up top, accounts payable, we're issuing over 16,000 per year. That equates to over 300 per week.
6:37:07 Uh, utility billing call volume over 42,000 we believe we're going to be at the end of this year. That's over 800 calls per week with our utility billing
6:37:15 and collections team. I think that number in 23 for them is a typo, but and I will verify that, but I know those
6:37:22 last three numbers are accurate. Then those last two rows um in terms of shows you that steady progression and as you
6:37:30 would expect to see with a number of utility uh water and sewer customers that we have we're over 31,000 for water
6:37:37 at this point and close to 21,000 on the sewer side. So that growth that annexation that extensions of the
6:37:45 service areas this this reflective of that.
6:37:49 Did those numbers take into consideration the fact that the spring transition was an outlier.
6:37:57 Spring transition was an outlier.
6:37:59 The spring transition of the auto that would not have impacted those numbers. My understanding is those
6:38:06 numbers is the actual number of bills that we process. Sorry, utility bills.
6:38:13 Yeah, it's already Oh, sorry. Utility the second row. Um, yes, that's included in that data.
6:38:20 And do we know what happened between 23 and 24 that I think that 23 number is a typo.
6:38:28 That's the one. Yeah, that's what I was referring to.
6:38:30 I wasn't tracking which one you thought might.
6:38:32 Yeah, I will get an update on that, but I believe that's a typo. And what is what is an accounts payable?
6:38:39 What is that? Why is it down?
6:38:43 That is the number of uh checks that are or payments that are processed by our accounts payable team to all of our
6:38:49 vendors. It does not include payroll. Um there's a few reasons why that number could be decreased. It could just simply
6:38:58 be fewer payments made. It could be uh consolidation of bills with vendors. Um it it's hard to explain.
6:39:07 Why would we have 16,000 vendors? Oh no, we don't have 16,000 vendors.
6:39:12 Those are the number of payments that we process.
6:39:17 So some vendors we pay regularly on a monthly basis. Um other vendors will pay sporadically. Um, but you take all that
6:39:25 activity together for the full uh fiscal year, we're processing over 16,000 accounts payable checks in the year.
6:39:33 That's personally basically everything pretty much everything we buy.
6:39:38 Most of what everything we buy pretty much.
6:39:41 Yeah, we have we have reoccurring payments to uh Yes.
6:39:48 Yeah. All of our accounting functions are centralized. Maybe I should have started with that.
6:39:53 Yeah. So, we're processing the payables for every department in the city. I'm thinking we're talking utilities. You're thinking we don't pay 16,000.
6:40:01 That's the whole city.
6:40:04 So, our our AP team deals with tremendous amount of volume even though it's going down. And I'm getting a little ahead of myself and Kyle, why
6:40:11 don't we go ahead and go to the next slide? It's a good transition to um some of the proposals that are in the fiscal
6:40:18 year 26.7 budget. So, I'll start in the middle for that purpose. Um, one of the there's two big things that
6:40:26 are are driving a 28% increase in operational costs in the proposed budget for the finance department. Uh, one is related to software additional software
6:40:35 modules. Uh, the one I'm most excited about is that first one, vendor access with AP automation. This is another
6:40:42 Tyler module. So, it's with our current vendor, but it's a new module. And what this would allow is for our vendors
6:40:50 through a secured portal to submit their invoices to us electronically. And there's an AI component to that that
6:40:57 would then take those invoices, create that payable within our system and help us turn around those payments at a much
6:41:04 faster time. So it'll eliminate the paper pushing between departments before it gets to finance. it would still retain the workflow approvals of all of
6:41:12 our supervisors and managers and then eliminates that data entry that our AP team has to do. So it make it
6:41:19 significantly more efficient. The the problematic part with that may be getting vendors to sign up. So if we
6:41:26 move forward with this, we'll have be asking our uh our team to help us push out information to the vendors and and help with signups on that. Uh the other
6:41:35 thing that that module will bring is the ability to electronically pay our vendors. That is not something that we are currently offering. Um but now we're
6:41:44 in a point uh in terms of department stability as well as with this module uh where I'm I'm ready for us to to go that
6:41:53 route. And we hear from vendors quite often. How come you can't turn around payments faster? Well, part of it is because we're on a primarily paper and
6:42:01 manual process. And secondly, we pay by check through the mail. And so this investment would help in both of those endeavors.
6:42:11 And the second bullet point there is resident AI assistant. Uh this is the finance department being the the hub, if
6:42:18 you will, of of the ERP system. Um and our assistant director, Jenny Cassidy, is is the point person for all of our
6:42:27 software audit and and decision making that's going on right now. Um, so th this is something that would be part of
6:42:35 the communications and 311 center effort. Uh, but we're showing it as currently in the finance department
6:42:43 budget. Uh, this is, as it says, an AI assistant. That phone call comes in, they can help direct to how to apply for
6:42:52 a building permit or how to uh submit payment for invoicing. Um, any number of things across the entire city. But that
6:43:00 software investment is included in our budget.
6:43:04 The second thing that is uh driving that 28% increase in operational cost in our department is we're working on
6:43:12 consolidating our citywide expenditures into the finance department. So there's two line items within our department uh
6:43:19 to where the year-to-year comparison is up around 170 180% increase. Um that is
6:43:27 because we are currently we are allocating uh payments for things such as our banking contracts and our
6:43:35 investment um uh consultant contracts throughout the city. This is an effort to bring all that into the finance
6:43:42 department and make that process more efficient. Um so you'll see you would see a corresponding decrease in the
6:43:50 other departments for those 170 180% increase that you see on those two line items. So it's budget neutral but it is moved into the finance department.
6:44:00 Then going back to the top is uh the bullet point on the requested 1.5 FTE uh
6:44:07 positions that we're asking for. uh the utility billing customer service rep uh is the part five.5 the part-time request
6:44:17 as Mr. Matthysse was describing earlier in talking about the champion center. Um multiple departments will be contributing staff to that effort. Uh we
6:44:26 foresee two individuals rotating in and out of that champion center from the utility billing team. Um so a lot of
6:44:34 work that those two are currently doing will migrate with them into the champion center. However, I'm confident in saying that there's going to be at least some
6:44:42 residual leftover within that team. So, I don't want to leave them completely without um adjusting for that. U
6:44:52 initially the request was for a full-time position. I said, I'll be glad to go to council and ask for a part- timerr for this next year. Let's
6:45:00 accumulate a year's worth of data and see how this pilot program goes and then we can reassess and and um next year's
6:45:08 budget, whether it's eliminate the part-time position altogether or to upgrade it to a full-time. But I would like a year's worth of data under this
6:45:15 pilot program before we decide on the long-term um status of that role. And
6:45:23 then the top one is for the uh finance division and uh it this will be a newly created position. Uh Mr. Bane earlier
6:45:32 referred to a position as a unicorn position and I chuckled because many times I've referred to this proposed position as a unicorn one. Um it is a
6:45:42 newly created one. It's I'm envisioning it as a hybrid position. Uh one that is
6:45:48 rooted with a strong accounting base um that will provide uh backup and a primary and backup roles to the current
6:45:57 existing accountants on their compliant reporting to the state. Uh this is our land lease uh report to the state. This is our local highway report to the
6:46:06 state. Fuel tax reports. There's eight to 10 different compliance reports that we do on a regular basis. Uh this person
6:46:13 would take on some of those directly and serve in a backup capacity and others and frankly uh backup training and
6:46:21 backup roles within our department is an area that we are lacking. So this position could help with that. But um on
6:46:28 the more forward- facing side of it and on the analyst side, what I'm seeing is envisioning is is I'd like to take us now that our department is stabilized, I'd like to take us to the next level.
6:46:38 Um and that is with forward- facing uh improved reporting whether it is within our budget book or uh developing a
6:46:46 performance ma uh management programs citywide that would be part of the quarterly budget reports and frankly
6:46:53 when it comes to budgeting decisions. I smiled yesterday when we were talking about the uh water department uh
6:47:00 facility and and what is our cost of operations in the department. This is a type of role in a performance management program that could have those metrics
6:47:09 routinely uh calculated reported on um and then as I said become part of our decision- making and budgeting in the
6:47:17 future. Um, so again, in summary, this is a position I see and envision as serving in both an internal and a
6:47:25 forward- facing public capacity. And uh um we're ready to to make that next step.
6:47:34 Tell us about the triple crown. Excuse me. Tell us about the triple crown.
6:47:41 Kyle, can we go back to um the first slide that talks about the act for award three slides?
6:47:57 So, in case you didn't hear, council member Strange said, "Tell us about the Triple Crown." Um, Triple Crown is not an official program.
6:48:07 It is a term that finance director use directors commonly use um it's a self-appointed term uh for those as it
6:48:17 relates to the GFOA award programs that they offer. They offer three different types of uh program awards. One is the
6:48:25 distinguished audit award which we've reacquired. The second one is related to the popular annual financial report
6:48:33 which we just established and we have submitted um and is in a similar review status for the the 25 report. Then the
6:48:42 third component of the triple crown is the um GFO's distinguished budget presentation award and that of the three
6:48:50 is certainly the most difficult of the three to acquire. Um we did submit for it based off our new platform last year.
6:48:57 I knew we wouldn't get it and we did not, but we got invaluable feedback. So, the intent is to get us to the point
6:49:05 with our four our public reporting on all three of these to become a to earn those three designations and thus
6:49:12 becoming a self-appointed Triple Crown award winner.
6:49:16 So, there is a tie into this position that I'm requesting um selfishly or on the city's behalf for that triple crown designation.
6:49:25 It would it would mean that we are a model city when it comes to transparency and fiscal reporting.
6:49:34 I love it.
6:49:35 I want a picture of you with a triple crown. There you go.
6:49:42 You know, you can do that on the balcony on third floor looking out here on There you go. That's a banner that There you go. with the purple banner.
6:49:52 There are others that are much more photogenic than I am. That's a good one.
6:49:58 So, so what how can we help you achieve distinguished budget presentation award?
6:50:04 What do you need from us as far as direction so you can frame it and apply your work? Part of it is certainly the the resources um partly with this
6:50:12 position and um possibly probably an additional software module. Um but more
6:50:20 practically at the council level is a um is a strategic plan. Yeah. um an adopted
6:50:29 strategic plan that we can tie to the budget, which by extension ties our our daily,
6:50:36 monthly, and annual um budget goals to that strategic plan. And that's what GFO
6:50:44 is looking for, not only to serve as a reporting and transparency communications tool, but also something that says, "These are our priorities.
6:50:53 Here's how we plan to meet those through the budget process." and then document that within the budget award. We get to
6:51:00 that point, we'll earn that award. We don't have that strategic plan currently. We do at a department level in a couple cases, but we don't have one citywide.
6:51:10 That that would I'm not saying we can't get there without it, but it would certainly help us tremendously.
6:51:16 Uh you said last year you applied for it and you got some valuable didn't win it, but you got valuable input. So did you
6:51:24 have we one of the things I used to do when I gave these things is I I take that list of where we were shortfall where you
6:51:31 came in shortfall and make sure I checked off my squares this year and that's what you're saying that you're treating your plan as one of those
6:51:38 things that we cost us last year when you submitted it.
6:51:41 Correct. That was one of the primary uh reasons why we uh did not get it awarded.
6:51:48 What might you need from us? What what are we missing? And you're going to say strategic plan. I'm going to call that circular definition. So you've heard all this. What are we missing?
6:52:00 What do we need?
6:52:01 Some stated goals and purposes of the city. How many? So for instance, uh you know, it varies.
6:52:09 I can draw upon my my own experience. We had a very robust performance management program at a prior municipality. We had
6:52:16 five what we called key performance indicators. KPIs. One was to establish the city as a as a uh safe and secure
6:52:26 community. A second one was to be a fiscally healthy and responsible community. So on and so forth. These are
6:52:33 five these were five overarching broad citywide goals. And then the performance
6:52:41 management program would develop a metrics um a series of metrics in support of each of those and we would
6:52:50 regularly report to the city council what the status of all of those metrics and rolling up in support of that goal. And that's the software you might need.
6:52:59 Yeah. Yeah.
6:53:00 So what do we need to do to get there at this point? Uh I use the software.
6:53:08 I have not included any software a module for that program on this proposed budget because I didn't want to put the cart before the horse. I need a
6:53:17 strategic plan on a city-wide basis before I suggest we um invest in that.
6:53:23 Would you like me to work with him to present something? Yeah. Well, like I say, well, he said he got this valuable
6:53:30 input from the from from not making it last year. Of course, that's one of the things, like I said, I used to do when I was in the military. I I submitted for
6:53:38 award that I didn't get it. They send me feedback and show me what squares I didn't fill. So, I go along and make sure I in the next year to fill all the squares. You said the strategic plan.
6:53:47 What's the other one? Oh, yeah.
6:53:48 That other ones that you didn't you didn't meet that maybe we can help you with what you're asking.
6:53:54 Yeah. the strategic plan. Our our budget does not have a documented strategic plan.
6:54:00 So, it is the major variable that we were deficient in in their review.
6:54:06 I said a few moments ago, I'll say it again. I think we could still get to that award designation without it.
6:54:13 But it would certainly strengthen us not only from an award context, but just from basic governance.
6:54:20 Governance. Thank you. That's a perfect word. your first two groups, right? Well, let's see what what we need, Mr. Van Wagner, what we need to do
6:54:29 to get to get the treat strategic plan accomplished. And then I guess after you get that done, we go to the next step.
6:54:37 Well, we've talked about attracting small businesses, right? Safe and secure came out, fiscally responsible came up. Well, I don't know.
6:54:45 Family oriented. I'll be glad to share my previous managers.
6:54:50 And is there a certain certain requirements in your strategic plan that they're looking for that they give that you
6:54:58 they don't necessarily have they don't want to dictate what our strategic plan is. They want to see the presence of one and have it incorporated into your budget document.
6:55:07 Okay. Okay.
6:55:08 So there's no there's no real requirements or what uh no certain Right. Our goals are our goals. We
6:55:16 established them and then this position in cooperation with the other departments would develop
6:55:23 a metrics program i.e. a performance management program in support of measuring our um our efforts towards meeting those goals.
6:55:40 Public official anymore.
6:55:44 Can I suggest that your strategic plan probably comes and it's informed a lot by your comprehensive plan and your city
6:55:52 business plan like that isn't that but I would imagine you would want it to be consistent with that and there's a lot of material and recommendations coming out of that even the small
6:56:01 business stuff is is a lot of that's coming from those things that's kind of why I'm sitting here going if it helps you I don't see that
6:56:08 we're that far away from being able to say these are our top five targeted goals as the city for the next what do you say
6:56:16 10 years what what's the term of the plan 5 10 20 ideally these are overarching goals that
6:56:24 always exist I mean we always want to be a safe and secure community that's true we always want to be a fiscally responsible we've been here since
6:56:33 I'll get his vibe with him but we'll sit down and chat individually in a workshop sounds That's cool.
6:56:42 Great. All right. Okay. Back to presentation here. Uh capital.
6:56:48 We don't have any capital. We don't have our own vehicles or anything like that.
6:56:51 Um and then here's that fiscal summary uh within the general fund. So this is just the finance division within the general fund. I mentioned the 28% uh
6:57:00 increase in operating. It's tied to um as I said on the previous slide uh the new the the two software module
6:57:09 additions as well as consolidating some operating costs into the finance department division with the corresponding decreases in other
6:57:17 departments and then of course 10.4% increase in personnel is directly tied to the proposed position.
6:57:27 That is it. Thank you. Thank you.
6:57:38 I mean, I think the state of the city is is really good. I think we're in a great position.
6:57:44 I think maybe we got to tweak the budget a little bit, but I mean, I think we owe the taxpayers
6:57:52 to be uh fiscally responsible, but you can always drop it down later.
6:57:57 But they did the budget at 31 at 4.36 I think or what right this year you got to have four
6:58:05 people to change it above that mill rate is my understanding anything you can always go up above the
6:58:12 millage rate uh whatever you set it set it at right now uh say five or whatever but you can never
6:58:20 go above that but you can always come back what is it now4 4 4.5 million.
6:58:29 I would propose that we set a rate of 4.29 as the maximum. The maximum.
6:58:37 Yeah, I support that. What are you willing to cut? Well, maybe we can cut that tank.
6:58:45 Cut more than the tank. What What is half a million tank?
6:58:50 4.29 29 is is 700 less how much from 4.3601
6:58:56 and then 700,000 per.1 mil 1.29 you looking at another mill so 1.2 too.
6:59:06 It's about 500 550,000.
6:59:12 It's over half million,000 we have to cut.
6:59:15 So that's well Well, keep in mind keep in mind uh I think we we just asked them to put some other things back into the budget
6:59:23 as well. Okay. Uh and I think when we when you prepared this at the 4.3601
6:59:31 or whatever, uh we was already 1.2 two million short or whatever we we took out of reserve to balance
6:59:40 our structural defaken that's what I read our structural deficit is around 1.5 million 1.5
6:59:47 1.5 million okay at at 3 at 436
6:59:53 we're advancing forward several projects that comprise that 1.5 I mean some of
7:00:01 this is money that we've had allocated this that's going to end up being a surplus that's coming into next year.
7:00:08 So, we're not really at a deficit. We're just carrying forward certain projects, which was one of the things I asked to see before we
7:00:16 come back and so that we could see it more clearly.
7:00:20 I'd like clarification on that because I I thought if you read if you read just the numbers that are in our book, it looks like it's
7:00:27 6.5 million, but with the definitions we approved, it's 1.5.
7:00:35 But is that 1.5?
7:00:41 Is that 1.5 just because of carryover or is it actually 1.5
7:00:49 in our current fiscal year expenses over revenues or is it both?
7:00:55 Yeah, I'd like breaking it out so that we can see that information.
7:01:00 But there's definitely carryover because the comp plan alone that's why I'm asking the question if that 1.5 what is that 1.5 new 1.5 I
7:01:09 guess maybe is a way to ask the question right I'd like to go through the exercise instead of giving a number off top my
7:01:17 head and we we can't vote I think it's a combination of both sir well we have but we have to we have to give guidance on the maximum millage rate today.
7:01:26 Yes the maximum in the But we have to get but we have to tell them what to put on the res.
7:01:32 We put the maximally rate today. Let them go back through and work the exercise. You can always go down but you can't go up.
7:01:39 Okay. U I would like at 4.361
7:01:47 whatever you prepared it at as I went through I was okay with it. Of course you can always come back down. And we
7:01:54 just had, like I say, I think we just asked for a few things to be put back into the budget. So, I don't know where we are.
7:02:04 Mr. Bane, um, in my opening presentation, I had a slide that summarized the proposed additions for personnel, right?
7:02:12 The general fund portion of that, if I recall, was $680,000. So, that's obviously new money. That's new money. That's new money.
7:02:20 New structural deficit, if you will. Correct.
7:02:22 Okay. So that is certainly a a portion of that 1.5. Okay.
7:02:28 So I'd like everybody to have this information. It's historical information on Clermont's Village. From 1992 to 1998 the millillage was 2.979.
7:02:38 1999 it was 3.479. From 2000 to 2006 it was 3.729.
7:02:45 So they got scared. Uh but then 27 to 2012 it came back down to 3.142.
7:02:52 from 2013 and 14 it bumped back up to 3.729 and then 2015 through 2021 it was 4.2.
7:03:00 Wow.
7:03:01 So we are the highest mill right now that Clermont has ever been. And let's keep in mind millage is a percentage.
7:03:09 It's not a rate, it's a percentage. So as we've grown and I continue to come back to
7:03:16 growth should result in efficiency and we're not seeing efficiency.
7:03:22 So you know and the homestead exemption went up in 2008 from 25,000 to 50,000.
7:03:31 So in 2008 our council maintained a 3.142 millillage for four more years
7:03:38 before there was any increase. What year was that again?
7:03:41 So that was 2008 when we went from 25,000 to 50,000. Okay. So it was 25,000 from 1980 until 2008 and then it went up
7:03:50 to 50,000 in 2008. So just kind of historical context as we're talking about, you know, what we can and can't
7:03:57 do. And I just look at this myself and say for, you know, 30 years councils operated at 4.2 or below. For the most
7:04:06 part, they were under 4.0. And so I will vote with the lowest two votes on
7:04:15 July 28th, whatever they are. And I think our staff is competent and capable of backing into it. I like that.
7:04:23 I think 4.29. I think staff could work it out to get that done for us. If you can see the number be okay.
7:04:29 I'm not willing to, you know, we want to go to to have that as the max. I'm at a minimum. I'm willing to to do the 4.3601 which was the budget presented.
7:04:40 um that because I I I I would want to know then
7:04:47 specifically when we enact because there's two different votes. We enact the millage rate and we approve the budget, right?
7:04:53 I would want to know before we so saying that the max is going to be the roll back
7:05:00 if we then decrease that from there. I would want to know what that means for than our budget before we approve that budget.
7:05:09 We would have that, right?
7:05:10 That's why I'm not willing to say the max is 4.2 right now because like I'm not
7:05:18 I as it's presented, I'm already concerned philosophically with this with the standpoint of a second year of a
7:05:26 structural deficit being proposed in the budget. Um, and so that has me concerned
7:05:32 already, but I I I I think that at a minimum, the the maximum should be what
7:05:41 was presented at the 4.3601.
7:05:46 Um and if we want between setting that and
7:05:53 approving through the hearings and the workshops to make adjustments, we could come down, but we can't go above that. Can't go above.
7:06:01 Um and so we we say as presented, this is would be the maximum.
7:06:07 Um but we might still have opportunities to find ways to to make that less. I I I just am I I haven't heard anything other
7:06:16 than a a desire a personal desire to be less um
7:06:24 strategically or operationally to support that. Anything lower?
7:06:30 Police alone have 655,000 that they said they could Well, okay, but we're also rolling over
7:06:38 $6 million for EMS that we don't have yet. So we could say that we could we could put that back. We don't we don't actually but we don't have an EMS program.
7:06:49 So I I I get that. I'm just say that's what I'm saying that's included in here right now too. I'm willing to say that's
7:06:56 the max and then we we as a council have to figure out is that what we actually implement or do we go less?
7:07:06 Uh, I'm not willing to set that max at a lesser rate today.
7:07:13 And I I mean, I just said if we did 4.29, could you make that work?
7:07:20 I'll do whatever you tell me I need to do. That's But do you think can you make
7:07:27 I mean, she's just named off 600 somehat thousand dollars. I I just have to look look at it. Right.
7:07:34 I'll I'll do whatever you tell me to do, I'll figure it out. Okay.
7:07:37 So, whatever the majority of you tell me to do, I will do.
7:07:41 I've given you a budget, right?
7:07:43 And now you just have to tell me what you want me to do. Well, you can we can go ahead and do it.
7:07:48 And I stand with you, Mr. Bane. Uh if what I take uh I commend you all for taking the initiative to go ahead and do
7:07:56 the roll back rate and prepare it. Now, if we want if any Mr. Peterson, if you want to look at going lower than that,
7:08:03 Uh right now I I my suggestion is you go through the budget and you say hey we start going through what you going to
7:08:09 cut if you go lower. Uh Mr. Mr. uh Scott you can tell them basically if we go uh
7:08:16 the 4.29 what we will get and how much more we have what we need how much we need to cut from the budget to get there get where you need to be. Uh but right
7:08:25 now what I'm seeing is you presented us with a product at 4.3601
7:08:33 which is less than what we were sitting at. So we got a reduction there and I think we also had going if I'm not mistaken what I read we had to go in and
7:08:41 use some uh fund balance to get it balanced. Okay. Um I've heard but talking about add some more things in
7:08:49 there. So that mean we gonna have to use more fund balance just now just to keep it at full point of what you prepared
7:08:57 which is if we go back I don't know I can't remember how much money we was throwing back in there but uh we just told people to throw back into the into
7:09:04 the budget we had uh one I think the only thing we we said was the it we asked
7:09:14 it to roll in I don't know did we ask any other department to add anything back in I don't know if We found that building services had a surplus. We found that
7:09:22 our health insurance has a surplus. I mean, we we've got we're sitting on millions of dollars of the taxpayers money. Million tens of millions of
7:09:31 dollars of the taxpayers money. And I that's look, you could go 3.0 and I'd say yes. I'm that serious about it. I
7:09:39 mean, we have that much money that we're sitting on that the people have paid and I think we owe it to the taxpayers.
7:09:45 I mean, just because everybody's, you know, valuations go up, you know, is it we're getting all this additional money.
7:09:53 Should we penalize the tax? We have the money. I think I think 4.29 is a good number to deal with.
7:09:59 You're sitting on the tax you're sitting You're right. You're sitting on the taxpayer money. You got all these projects that hey, some of it can be used for some of the projects we got out
7:10:07 there like the fire station and maybe we won't have to go in so much debt services and everything doing these things. Uh I think being here when we raised it, right?
7:10:17 That was the whole idea when we when we uh raised the taxes before because we anticipated having to build new fire stations and all these things. So to
7:10:26 keep us from having to go in so much debt service, yeah, we raise the rates and everything to try to generate a little bit more.
7:10:32 It's not true. A little bit more revenue.
7:10:33 It's not true because only 21% of that budget went to police and fire. 44% went to parks and recreation. The public was
7:10:41 told we needed it for public public safety and that is not what it was used for. And we also took out took out a $15
7:10:49 million bond for the fire station. So I'm just it's factually inaccurate what you just said. The public was tricked
7:10:57 into into I mean we were forced to pay. The public objected. I was at every single one of
7:11:04 those meetings when we went from 4.2 to 5.06. The public only spoke against it.
7:11:09 The only people who spoke for it were staff who came to the dis and the podium and said please do this so I can get a pay raise. Please do this so I don't
7:11:17 lose my job. Which was not accurate when you looked at the actual budget. In fact going from the 5.06 budget to the 5.02
7:11:25 which it was a whole issue with the budget police and fire fire actually fire inspection took a cut of $40,000. I
7:11:33 mean it was just so inaccurate and misleading to the public. So yes, do I have a sense of justice that needs to be
7:11:40 served? I do. When I look at the history of how this city has operated and I see that we were under four for the better part of 20 years. Is it a matter of
7:11:49 principle? Perhaps. Do I believe in small government? I do. Do I think that we have millions of dollars to make it right? Yes, I do. Am I worried about
7:11:56 2028? A little bit. But I think we can figure it out.
7:12:00 It's only a little bit actually. It's I I'm certain we can figure it out. And what I'm hoping we can all agree is that
7:12:08 we're willing to give council direction, staff direction to figure it out, right?
7:12:12 Because if we don't give them direction to figure it out and then we're just fighting and then the public is fighting, then nothing gets done. But if
7:12:21 we say, you know what, we hey, let's let's have a wild hair in this. What what if we did 3.9? Show me a budget at 3.9. What's that look like?
7:12:32 You know, I stood at that podium and said, "Can you just show me a roll back budget?" And I was told by the city manager, I I serve at the pleasure of the council.
7:12:42 No, public, I'm not going to show you a roll back budget. I refuse to do it.
7:12:48 That was wrong. So maybe we say, "Hey, we'd like to see a 3.9. Show me one.
7:12:54 Show me a 4.2." And then we've got a 4.36. And we can look at all of them and Instead of this
7:13:01 game that was played of, well, we're going to have to cut services. Well, show me.
7:13:07 We have so much money that that's not even true. We don't have to cut services.
7:13:10 Then in that scenario, we should advertise the maximum millage rate at 4.3601 because we can't go above it, but we can certainly go below.
7:13:19 I won't vote for it.
7:13:21 Okay. Well, I guess we need to provide consensus. So, 4.29. I'm okay with 4.29.
7:13:29 I got you.
7:13:48 Miss Strange, let me say this. I don't know where you got $15 million $15 million for uh bond service. I don't
7:13:55 recall any any debt services going out for $15 million for fire station. you know, and one of the things that I'm I'm starting to get very aggravated about,
7:14:04 you keep throwing out $100,000 because I know the budget I went through every line.
7:14:08 We haven't even did a debt services, but need $100,000 in the budget in 2025 to go towards debt services fire station 2.
7:14:17 There was, but it was not equity, right? We didn't we stopped it, but we had applied for the for the loan and we had planned on it. That's why there was $900,000 in the budget in 2025.
7:14:28 900 keep hearing these these I read these numbers and everything and it's far above what what was uh what was presented.
7:14:36 I I agree with you. It wasn't what was presented to the public and that's why I ran.
7:14:43 Uh and another thing yes uh I think through our budget process back in them days we we presented different budgets at all
7:14:52 different rates uh about five or six different rates.
7:14:55 Yes. all above the the nothing was balanced at the current rate, let alone the roll back. Everything showed a deficiency and it was all above 5.0.
7:15:04 I agree with you. You're right. And it was wrong for the C it was wrong for council not right now what we what we to do right
7:15:12 now is going to show a deficiency. So my thing is what are we going to cut without a deficiency? What are we going to cut? Yep.
7:15:20 Okay.
7:15:21 Without a deficiency. I'm fine with that.
7:15:24 Now, we've got capital projects. We've got to spend down. We either have to spend down or give back to the public the $20 million in unrestricted funds.
7:15:33 So, we we need to have a plan for that. That needs to be clearly communicated.
7:15:38 And frankly, I'd like to see the roll back or or there's projects that we had several councils or staff members say, I'm applying for a grant. I'm applying
7:15:46 for a grant. Well, it'd be kind of nice if we said when we approved the budget, here are items that you can bring us an amendment for if you get these grants
7:15:55 and we might be able to say okay when that item comes to us as a budget amendment it was included in the budget process that we anticipated it and we're going to apply for a grant for it
7:16:03 Mr. Van Wagner uh Mr. Scott uh what was it 4.29 prepare the budget or let us know what
7:16:12 it need to be what I guess what you need to do is go back and prepare our budget at 4.29 29 and give us recommended cuts.
7:16:19 Okay. Uh to get it get it get a balanced budget, please sir. Okay. Um for the
7:16:28 next workshops and I don't know when to schedule next workshop and all you can if you can present us all with that and everything and um we just have to go
7:16:36 through it and still start a cut department's head and get with the department's head and see see what what
7:16:43 cuts they they they don't have any problem with. Sir. Yes, sir. Yes, sir.
7:16:51 Uh, I'd like to clarify your request.
7:16:54 We'd like to clarify your request, Mayor. Um, we haven't talked about this in in this
7:17:00 forum. There is a I mentioned the revised law on the calculation of the maximum millage rate. In addition to
7:17:09 that, there's a new requirement in the budget process to where we have to publicly present a 10% reduction plan for the city budget. That's right.
7:17:18 So my question is given your request you just made. Do you want us to go through that exercise before we do that 10%
7:17:26 exercise or do you want that to leave be part of the 10% exercise?
7:17:31 Part of show it show it. Well, maybe if you if
7:17:38 you what was the red what was it when you when you uh reduced it when you prepared
7:17:45 the budget from uh at uh 3 4 36 our structural deficit was in the neighborhood of $1.5 million.
7:17:55 Yeah. But did it meet the 10%. Is that why you Is that why you went at the roll back rate because of deferred to Mr. Van Wagner?
7:18:05 Why? But as I did say during my presentation, at least partially because of the new maximum village rate calculation, 10% reduction of what?
7:18:15 So the the new requirement, as I understand it, requires us to publish a plan to reduce the budget by 10%.
7:18:26 And as I understand it, that is the citywide budget. So if for instance we have a hund00 million budget, we have to
7:18:33 put present a document that shows what a $100,000 excuse me 10 million $10 million reduction would be and that
7:18:41 could be as something as simple as reducing $10 million worth of capital or it could be much more expensive than item bonds. But we have to produce a plan. We have to reduce it.
7:18:49 We we don't have to adopt it. We just have to show to cut 10% and then have that on our website showing that we
7:18:57 actually sat tried to cut it. I guess the question I I really have on that uh Mr. got is the fact that is it 10% of
7:19:04 what we budget now or last year's budget as I understand it is for the of the proposed budget the proposed would prop be 10% from from last year's
7:19:14 budget no this year so then I think well that's that's a little that's a little crazy I mean if I sit here and prepare a budget right now you know and
7:19:22 everything how am I going to reduce it to 10% what where you where you think they say you don't have to adopt well we don't have to adopt it but I
7:19:30 think if it has to be based off of our proposed it. My understanding of the interpretation was what Mr. Borer is
7:19:37 saying is that essentially your whatever the municipalities or the government because it could be a county as well.
7:19:45 Whatever the the government uh entity is proposing for that next fiscal year
7:19:52 budget that they also have to publish a 10% reduction of that.
7:19:57 So if that's the case there there was just consensus here to to have a max millage rate of 4.29.
7:20:06 So I think then that's the however you have to get the budget to that 4.29 and then
7:20:14 10% at 10% from there because that's that's essentially what was the direction that was given. That makes sense.
7:20:22 Can can we can we get with Mr. Mr. a while and find out the official ruling whether 10% on last year a reduction of 10% last year.
7:20:31 So let let's be clear and we look on page one we have all of our fund balances and if we look at the expenditures they total $168 million.
7:20:45 So based on your interpretation, if we were to approve this current budget that's identified here, we would have to
7:20:52 show what a 16.8 million reduction would be, correct? In a separate document, separate standard.
7:21:00 But here's why I struggle with that a little bit is for example, we're selfinsured, right?
7:21:06 So we have eight and a half million of that is a self insurance policy. That's what they're not talking about the general fund
7:21:14 there. It could be anything as I understand. It could be anything throughout the entire city budget. And we are not beholden to that. We just
7:21:22 have to document that we went through an exercise to identify what a 10% uh reduction would look like.
7:21:30 See, it's a state law if we constantly It's a state law. And I thought I thought the law was they were looking at
7:21:36 reduce last year's this year's budget be 10% less. I wouldn't do that. That doesn't make sure
7:21:44 but it's a new requirement we have to meet.
7:21:47 But see the and then a side note but and then not really related to budget but
7:21:55 beginning in calendar year 2027 we have to um publish a quarterly report showing all the compensation of all employees in the city.
7:22:04 Yeah. Really?
7:22:05 So there's a lot of new requirements that come to us.
7:22:11 And that's why that's one of the reason I'm a little afraid about trying to set our mill so low because people we going
7:22:19 to find you you keep trying to reduce this millage in a year or two you going to find yourself in in a lot of financial trouble. Okay, with the laws and everything else we we got coming.
7:22:28 Even though even though you you're sitting here thinking we reducing the budget and cost of operating is still going up.
7:22:36 And if we hadn't raised the millage from 4.2 to 5.06. I might feel differently about I mean I might agree with you if we
7:22:45 hadn't raised it so much but we raised it and we shouldn't have. So as far as
7:22:52 I'm concerned everything on 4.21 is I'm not it's not a cut. We that's where we should be
7:23:00 if we just kept the mill. I would I would encourage my fellow council members to save their arguments for the
7:23:08 actual meeting and and very honestly well I mean because this is I mean it it does it goes down to a philosophical
7:23:16 conversation of what you want for your budget and what you want for your military and we have given the direction in the spirit of moving forward. We talked about that earlier the consensus
7:23:25 was given it's 4.29 29. We're going to ask for clarification on the 10% reduction, but I I believe Mr. Boore is correct on that. How I've read it.
7:23:34 Uh but we'll I guess we'll ask turn you off for that final clarification on that. I thought it was 10% last year.
7:23:42 Is this a one time 10% or is it a handle moving forward? Every year we have to go through that.
7:23:49 I thought it was 10% of last year's budget and each year from here on out you would be showing it about 10% reduction
7:23:57 is what I thought it was. You get with Mr. W.
7:24:02 According to Chat GBT, attorney GBT says yes, there is a relatively new Florida law that requires municipalities
7:24:09 to perform a 10% budget reduction exercise, but it's important to understand what that requires. The law does not require cities to actually cut
7:24:16 their budgets by 10%. Instead, it requires them to identify and publicly show how they could reduce the tenative budget by 10% while protecting essential public services.
7:24:26 Yep. Okay.
7:24:27 We have to do this at least 14 days before the final adoption of the budget. Yep.
7:24:32 And we show water and sewer and police and fire won't be affected.
7:24:36 So you saying that so at at what we at right now 168 pound 68 million. So that's $16.8 million we have to shortcut.
7:24:45 Yeah.
7:24:46 It can be as simple or as complex as what we want to make it.
7:24:50 We are not beholding to it, but it is a required exercise. Oh, happy day. Okay.
7:25:00 And of course, if you could use that 10% I guess we have to look and see what rate we we would need to be at to balance everything.
7:25:10 I don't that's not I don't think that's part of what he said. No, I think I would have said that.
7:25:16 That's why but that's why I asked the question there mayor in case you're thinking in that context you know I think if I'm if I'm going through this
7:25:25 exercise and they they tell me to go through this exercise to cover a budget by 10% then I'm
7:25:32 say the state law say you mandate we cut 10%. How are we going to finance?
7:25:41 It's an exercise to go through it.
7:25:44 It's an exercise that says we have to show specific things that we're going to cut in the exercise and that we must post it on our website.
7:25:54 Well, I mean, for example, if we spent $200,000, excuse me,
7:26:00 if we spent $655,000 on trees, we would be $655,000 towards that 16. So we might say we're going to spend our treatment.
7:26:12 You one of my complaints is we're taxing people but we're not spending. So part of this would be if you look at our uh I
7:26:20 mean if we look at our wreck impact fee we've got $1 million almost $12 million in our recreation. Let's put a plan in place for how we're going to spend it.
7:26:28 We've collected it. We're not spending it. So I mean that right there we're at 12.5 million dollars without trying close.
7:26:37 I mean, so I don't think it'll be that terribly difficult and that's where this capital piece becomes helpful because we can say here's projects and here's the
7:26:45 fund it's coming from and how are you saying actually I think that process will set a really good opportunity for the next few years as councils go do
7:26:53 this but I don't think it's to show how we spend it.
7:26:59 So you can't say we're going to spend it. Spend it and get down.
7:27:01 It's to say that you have to take that out from your expenditure line.
7:27:05 The expenditure line is not how you going to not how you actually reduce it. It's it's not actually reduced. It's actually cut. Cut. It's cut.
7:27:13 Yeah. Yeah. It's not Yeah, it's cut.
7:27:15 And again, it's as Mr. Bor has said multiple times, it's an exercise. We have to put it on the web to comply with the state law to show.
7:27:22 So we might say just make the knowledge 2.0 and then we can use all the money in our our impact.
7:27:34 All right, Miss Mr. Bo, Mr. You you okay? Okay.
7:27:38 I do want to just ask a question. Do we have what is the plan moving forward with workshops and conversations relative to millage and budget?
7:27:47 So on the 28th, you'll adopt the maximum millage rate.
7:27:52 Um, other after that, there is nothing officially scheduled until the first trim meeting in September, but from there I'll defer to Dan and Rick.
7:28:03 We have the August workshops.
7:28:09 I'm going to recommend we get together again in August. Yeah.
7:28:14 Yeah. We can show you suggestions we have for budget change as well as talk about that 10%.
7:28:23 Yeah, I think we all have the 18th available is because the CRA I don't but I mean that's on the calendar.
7:28:31 Yeah, I know. That's why I'm just saying I have a conference I have to go to for work. But that's I mean that's I was going to call in for the shade meeting at three.
7:28:41 What about what's the next week look like? So cancel that one. We have a council meeting on the 25th.
7:28:48 Could we meet early? I mean, considerably early before a council meeting.
7:28:54 I don't know that we need to spend a great deal of time. You guys are the ones doing the work right now. It depends how many questions you have.
7:29:02 If you want to make different suggestions, which you've been given a direction and you got to go through the 10%.
7:29:09 Well, that that will do. But I'm I'm more thinking you're going to need you're going to weigh in on the reductions because we're going to say this is what we recommend and you're going to say yes or no to those reductions.
7:29:19 Oh well to get it to the mill. Oh those. Yeah.
7:29:24 Yeah. But it's not going to be that much.
7:29:32 Scott, what is the best report for us to look at on that 10% exercise?
7:29:37 Is there an overall budget somewhere? Uh there was anformational bulletin put out uh by I forget whom but I will find it and distribute it.
7:29:46 Does it need to discuss that? The the 10% no the 10% the 10%. Yes. Right.
7:29:54 Yeah. That has to be at a workshop would but maybe not the reductions the specific reductions that we're doing before that exercise. We do that
7:30:03 whenever we we could do that item.
7:30:06 Yeah. So that could be at a council meeting.
7:30:11 So to answer your question, I think just the 10% just reduction in the budget is what we have to show at some point, but
7:30:20 it seems like that's more of a Yeah, I was just more wondering are we having any more budget workshops?
7:30:27 I know we don't we currently don't have any on the calendar and so if not then it'll be handled in council meetings and the trim trim notice meetings.
7:30:38 Is that in a council meeting? Talk about the budget. Yeah, the 10% reduction.
7:30:47 I I don't know for sure. It talked about a workshop and it didn't say you had to do it by workshop. So potentially we can do it by I'll have to look into that.
7:30:56 Can we get back with you on that? Yep.
7:30:59 I don't I've got to just ask Christian to weigh in on. Sounds good. But we need to do something in August. Yep. One way or another.
7:31:18 Do we say again?
7:31:22 If you look on page eight, Am I reading this right?
7:31:31 On page eight, it shows fiscal year 27 proposed CRA fund $1.2 million.
7:31:39 Is that a balance or is that an expensive?
7:31:41 No, that that there that's an expense. Yes.
7:31:49 Do we have anything else? No. We're finished. We're done. No.