Clermont City Council Workshop Transcript 9/15/26
0:01 Lord, thank you again for all your blessings. I pray everybody involved with this have the wisdom of God. You give us eyes to see and ears to hear.
0:10 You'd bless all our community, our citizens, our businesses, every aspect of this community. Thank you for all
0:18 those who serve here. And we just pray your blessings on them. Lord, bless our presenters today. Father, we just ask
0:25 for your continued blessing on our community today in Jesus name. Amen. Amen. Amen. Yes, sir.
0:34 I'm gonna turn it over to Nathan. The team's worked very hard with DPZ here today and we're very excited to have their involvement. So,
0:43 I'm going to turn it over to Mr. Norris to begin today. Uh thank you, Rick. I appreciate that.
0:48 And uh I'm just going to give a a brief overview of uh where we are and uh what to expect. As a reminder, uh we started
0:55 this comprehensive uh planning process uh last uh at the toward the end of last year. Um we're now to the point where
1:03 we're ready to uh have our consultant team share with you um uh exactly what
1:10 they're recommending. Um today, uh we just over the past three uh or the past week, we've had three different updates
1:18 to the comprehensive plan. So it's we're still in that process in this meeting of gaining valuable feedback. So this is
1:25 not a presentation that Marina Corey is going to give you that says this is what the comp plan is. This is a presentation
1:32 that she's going to uh give that's essentially going to be a discussion. So if there's if if you have any questions,
1:39 don't don't sit on them. We don't need to wait till the end of a presentation because it's really not a present. It's a discussion. Marina is pretty hard
1:47 charging. she can speak quickly and so hopefully we're going to get her to slow down just a little so we can take everything in. But I just want to make
1:55 sure that everybody understands that this is not the time to be super uh uh uh pensive or or hold back. This is a
2:03 time for us to provide uh input uh and and feedback to what uh she's heard as well as what she and her team are
2:11 recommending. Um the comp plan as a as a whole is not a radical departure from
2:18 our previous comp plan indust full rewrite. And so uh um uh this this
2:28 is not radical in any way, but it's important that we get it right because the comp plan has uh true legal authority in the state of Florida with
2:36 how we implement things. So it is important that we get things into it that we really think need to be into it.
2:43 And if you have questions or don't understand, it's an opportunity to uh address it. I'll uh fully h I'll just prepare you fully half of this
2:51 presentation is going to be dealing with some things that a lot of people find boring, okay? Which are things like FLU
2:58 future land use and how we calculate densities and what densities mean and things like that. So once again, if you
3:06 if you don't feel comfortable and and and what she's saying, please raise your hand and we'll try to uh stop her and have that discussion so she gets
3:14 feedback. recognize finally that she's uh eight hours ahead of us uh timewise.
3:20 So it's it's very late. Um but let let's just try try to be as uh uh concise as we can. That's all I have.
3:28 Thank you.
3:29 So u uh Ben Northrup is also with us here from uh the DPZ team. Um and he's
3:36 going to be manning the computer slides while Marina starts talking to us. Marina, are you with us?
3:43 I am. Can you hear me? Yes.
3:46 So, great. Um, Ben, are you ready? Thank you. To start. Oh, Ben needs just a moment.
3:54 Uh, Mr. North. Yes.
3:56 Um, all this he's going to be going over.
3:59 We're going to get a written copy of all this eventually. I mean, you're f to do a presentation and asking us to listen to without anything in front of us to
4:09 refer to. So that can be a little difficult, especially if you're telling me she going to be speaking kind of fast. [laughter] Well, no, I'm trying to slow her down.
4:17 But um uh that is why I mentioned I'm going to be explaining.
4:23 Okay. Well, let me let me go ahead. Um Marina, that's why I mentioned the fact that we had three different versions just in the last week. So they I I
4:31 should have mentioned it. The expectation is that by the end of this week, they're going to have another update that is the full one that gets distributed to everybody because they
4:39 want to incorporate what you have to say today into the next iteration. Since this is a very long document, right?
4:46 You don't want to send somebody 300 pages. Oh, by the way, that was the old version. Here's another one for you to go through. So, that's that's how they were approaching it.
4:53 Well, I'm quite sure the whole comprehensive plan, every every portion of it is being changed, but my own desk.
5:00 I was concerned with the changes that you all proposed and everything. Okay.
5:06 All right. So, Ben, you want to take it over?
5:08 Sure. Well, um, the comprehensive plan is coming first. So, Marina, who's with us on teams presented and everyone
5:17 should make sure you have a good view of the screen. Can you see the screen? I can. I can.
5:25 I can. Thank you. in the room already. Okay, that's good.
5:30 Yes. And I will say I will say um I'm having a problem listening to him.
5:35 You're next time. Thank you.
5:41 I'll begin by saying I'm very sorry I cannot be there. I I had I would have loved to and I will be there for the next meeting, but I'm happy to present
5:50 the the the gist of what this comprehensive plan is about to you all.
5:54 We have had um conversations and review sessions with your staff who have been um who have gone through our recommendations and we've of course
6:02 taken theirs too and made some adjustments. So as N said, this is intended to be a discussion. Feel free
6:10 to stop me at any time. I I asked Ben to actually lead uh the slides. I'm just going to say next so that I can see see
6:17 you all and um and if you have if you have questions, I'll be able to um to to answer them. So next,
6:29 so this is just a for members of the public, this is just a an explanation of sort of where we are in the process. We
6:36 initiated the the project um about nine months ago. We took a lot of time to gather the information with our team to go through a lot of the base information
6:45 that was provided to us including all the different elements. We had some public outreach. We held a sharet of course or a workshop and um and then we
6:54 began to draft the uh the comp plan elements based on what we had heard at the sharet what we began to draw at the
7:01 sharet and um we are now at the point where we want to hand in a draft copy of the comprehensive plan. Um next
7:14 so first you know what is a comprehensive plan for you sitting all of you sitting around the table you know what it is of course it's your long
7:21 range roadmap to guide growth and change and it's intended to turn community values into policy directions because
7:29 essentially it lists goals objectives and policies for different elements.
7:34 It's intended to show or to talk about where growth should go and what intensities of growth are permitted.
7:40 It's intended to to help guide how people will move, what types of housing are needed, and how parks, infrastructure, and uh services can keep
7:49 up with that demand, as well as how natural resources can be protected. It's required by law, of course, as Mason mentioned. So, cities do not have a
7:58 choice. They have to do it. But what's important about this comprehensive plan, I'll say, is that we don't only want to accommodate growth. We're really hoping
8:06 to shape it well. That's part of the reason why this is only one of many efforts. Ben will be presenting after me, the downtown action plan, but uh
8:15 we're also working on a form-based code for the uh for the northwest quadrant.
8:19 And the comp plan is your chance to really try to connect the vision with the implementation. Too often we see comprehensive plans that actually don't have a physical vision attached to it.
8:30 We have a physical vision and where it's your vision that we we've we've in handed and we've tried to interpret it as many of you saw while we were there
8:38 during the sharet. Uh next now we're presenting this but it has
8:48 been a very collaborative effort amongst all our different consultants. And then just as a reminder, we had grits who helped us with zoning analysis and
8:55 visualization. They put your entire code into a a tool and they they they put it online and it's helped us enormously to
9:04 not only understand your zoning but begin to understand the relationship between your zoning and your future land use and able to also map out some of the
9:14 um you know we could tell maps from gridics. for example, show us where villas are or show us where the the plots are not built to their total
9:21 capacity or show us where commercial development is possible or not or not possible. So, it's easy to see these 3D
9:29 to get these 3D views. We had ETM on transportation capital improvements and utilities, urban 3 for fiscal analysis,
9:36 and I'm going to be touching a little bit on what they what they've done.
9:39 Whitesman and Associates for uh the marketability study of course you know what can Clermont expect in terms of growth over the next couple of decades.
9:47 Vicks height for landscaping you know their local modica also for conservation CGI for civil engineering and storm
9:54 water in particular and global five um for communication. Now your comprehensive element your comprehensive plan is organized in essentially two
10:03 sections. The first part is the introduction to the vision which first introduces the context then sort of where we are today uh because that
10:12 informs sort of where you're going and then the vision and the framework which is what I spoke about what that physical vision should be and then the state
10:20 mandates that you have specific comp plan elements and they are listed here there are 11 of them and uh the future land use the transportation I won't read
10:28 them you can read them yourselves you probably know many of them of course um And I I'll tell you, as Nathan
10:35 mentioned, a lot of the change is in um is is technical. It may feel tedious when you review it. It was really we
10:42 went through each and every objective and policy with your with staff. And we really push them to say if this is a
10:49 policy you're you are you are um observing, you are um recording, you are following, then we're going to keep it
10:58 or you're tracking. If this is a policy that is either expired or no longer necessary, then let's have the the the the due diligence and and the and the
11:05 rigor to remove it. And now let's see what's missing. So you'll see some new policies and you will see adjustments to existing policies as well. Um okay, next.
11:16 Then next, I won't spend too much time on this slide because you already know it. But
11:24 before we started the shared, we interviewed um each of you in particular each member of um of the commission sorry of the council as well as the uh
11:32 CRA and we just made a list of where there was strong or partial disagreement or where there were multiple opinions on
11:40 certain topics or how Clermont should evolve. It helped us frame conversations during the sharet and and narrow our focus to those issues. Uh and
11:48 [clears throat] the sharet of course was is in February. We found it to be engaging. We always do. There was a constant stream of people coming in, residents, business owners pouring over
11:57 our shoulders and looking at what we were doing and also property owners coming with their own projects and showing them to us and saying how can we
12:04 either make this better or how can we ensure that that what we're proposing meets the intent of the comprehensive plan next.
12:15 So you know what did we hear in terms of resident concerns? This won't come as a surprise to you. traffic, traffic, traffic was the very first thing we
12:23 heard. And of course, citizens are rightfully concerned to be uh to be concerned about growth and what that's going to mean to the traffic because too
12:31 often growth is correlated with more traffic, the loss of nature and the erosion of your small town feeling. And
12:39 often conflicts arise when those amenities are serving the region rather than locals. We heard that too in terms of your your beaches as well as um some
12:48 of the festivals that that are uh that that people partaken that are apparently incredibly successful. We heard about
12:54 limited options for housing, which is important to grow simply because we um you you want to have a greater variety
13:03 of housing types, not only to allow older folks to age in place gracefully.
13:08 Uh but also to to have housing for the younger generation uh that can not only housing but quality jobs as well for the younger generation. Um, next.
13:22 So, we asked Clement residents, of course, how they saw themselves, and this is what we heard. Lakes, hills, and trees. Find ways to preserve those,
13:31 provide what's the sort of the best of town and nature, um, with where we're going to be accommodating accommodating growth. And you know, one idea we heard
13:39 which we thought was really good was we really want a town center or a neighborhood center in each of the quadrants so that we can capture people where they live and enable them to walk
13:48 or bike or cart to those town centers wherever possible so that it's not people do not have to travel a very long distance uh to get to their daily needs.
13:59 Of course, preserving the lakes, hills, and trees are are are key. Small is beautiful. We also heard that loud and clear. do not um do not increase uh
14:08 heights in any in any uh tremendous manner and uh retain what's beautiful and unique about Clermont. Staying
14:16 prosper of course has to do with how do we keep uh young folks we know the education system is good but how do we keep how do we bring jobs new jobs open
14:25 the job market to entrepreneurs that are that are in um that that are already in Clermont and wanting to stay there.
14:32 We've met with some great um entrepreneurs uh in in your community.
14:37 You know them well. We visited a lot of the shops that were you know that had you know amazing not only amazing things to sell but created these incredible
14:44 environments and uh Clermont Main Street is very active and has um some wonderful initiatives that is that is really putting bringing Clermont up to
14:52 the forefront and um highlighting the assets of your downtown. Healthy living and wellness of course is a key component of that. um you know it you're
15:02 a town that's rather athletic that is that is um that is promoting a lot of athletic activities uh for a town of
15:09 your for a city of your size I should say um it's quite remarkable as well um and that want we want to be able to um to enhance that in every possible way
15:18 and of course the independent and diversified local economy so enable the greatest range of people to participate
15:25 in the growth of your not only of your downtown but the city in general And then I I will say manage annexation
15:32 to control growth because it's been a little bit out of your hands in the sense that you've had to annex certain
15:39 uh certain parts of the um the county because you've had to provide services for them. So it makes sense to collect the impact fees. The problem has been
15:47 that um very often you're annexing land that has been that does not meet your code that meets Lake County code and um
15:55 it there is an erosion of nature and it is it predominantly of one type of housing only. So it it does that's the kind of growth that does aggravate um
16:02 aggravate the u the the the bad sentiment that some people feel when it comes to new growth. Next.
16:13 So the comprehensive plan is essentially um uh framed under four guiding principles. The first one is to create mixuse centers. Where where should those town and village centers be located?
16:24 We're going to show you where those locations are. You'll tell us if you think we got it right. To build a connected greenway network. That's a
16:31 really um big great idea for Clermont which is really not only to have this uh the the
16:39 chain of lakes which Ben will show you specifically starting in the downtown and connecting those for carding and for biking uh but also really connecting to
16:47 the greater regional network and there's a real possibility to do that promoting of course complete and enduring places.
16:53 So, where can the where how can we increase the housing options in ways that don't alter the character of neighborhoods uh but do offer those
17:01 additional housing choices and of course advanced healthy living through the through easier access to parks and trails and recreation.
17:10 Next, this is great the way I'm seeing it on your screen. I don't know how they're doing it, but it's fantastic. Um, so
17:17 Strong Towns participated in the Sharette. You're probably familiar with them. uh they were very we were very happy to have them with us for a few days during the shared and they really
17:25 advocated for incremental development to allow for Clermont to grow and adapt through small manageable investment
17:34 rather than the large high-risisk projects that many cities um are keen to take on the approach that that approach not only builds local wealth but it can
17:42 respond to the changing needs of your community and gradually strengthen the your downtown and your and your neighborhoods over time. Um, as I
17:51 mentioned before, it's also about allowing the larger pool of residents and entrepreneurs to to invest locally and get involved in development, too.
17:59 Um, and of course, expand housing opportunities in a way that are that is completely contextual and that does not
18:06 disrupt what you currently have. Next, now we also had urban 3 with us who gave
18:15 uh Joe Manuzzi was with us and he gave what many told us was a very compelling presentation on how cities can use land more productively and they showed many
18:24 many different examples of different uses and then the actual revenue. This this is revenue tied directly to your property taxes that the city collects
18:32 from uh approving different building types in Clermont. And you can see the spikes. Those are the areas that are the
18:39 most productive in Clermont. And what this does is really help highlight issues and helps people understand the financial implications of different
18:47 development choices. And it's helped it helps focus us on where does it make sense to um encourage the many different building types that are needed in
18:55 Clermont. Where does it make sense to keep places the way they are? And where does it make sense to intensify growth
19:01 in certain town centers? Next and lastly we heard from uh Peter
19:10 Bazelli of Whitesman and Associates who conducted a market research for your housing needs and they identified for us not only what types of housing were needed but which in which types of
19:18 environments in particular. So maintaining zoning flexibility is one example is about uh you you will see that when when when Ben and Lewis
19:26 present the form based code uh how you can do that with a transect based code which is much more permissive in terms of uses and building types in so far as
19:34 it fits the general parameters and dimensional controls that each zone allows. um they made a strong case for
19:41 the town houses and multif family and what we tend to call the missing middle which are uh housing that's embedded in
19:49 walkable people centered places. So you have a you have a huge um amount of single family in all sorts of uh shape
19:57 and then you have the very large multif family buildings and you and you have some garden style apartments but there's a greater range of possibilities that
20:04 happens to be um to track very well with the demographic changes that are happening. You know we're we now are
20:11 smaller household size. Uh young people are getting married later, having kids later, people are living longer. all
20:18 this trends to h having um smaller smaller units in in certain places. Next.
20:29 So, what became clear to us was in terms of your community vision was that there really was a we call a shared commitment
20:36 to uh not only grow with with with care but protect what makes Clermont unique, find ways to connect people to their
20:44 daily lives and create rooms and places for for the next generation. Um this rendering happens to be of the artwork.
20:51 You know, there's Mr. strong fellow who has um you know this wonderful initiative and desire to to to to not
20:59 only keep well he started a great artwork with some of his neighbors but they want to see this artwork cont all
21:06 the way down to your waterfront and so you will see in the plans that Ben presents uh today different ways in which we've explored how that artwork
21:14 can continue in a way that's incredibly engaging and welcoming uh to residents.
21:19 So we we've narrowed down the community vision into these seven principles which are maintaining your historical identity of course the preserving your natural
21:27 assets. Where should those walkable centers be what do we mean when we talk about attainable housing as Nathan alluded to I will be showing you I'll be
21:37 talking to you a lot about housing types and the densities that they produce so that we can all have a clear understanding of what we mean when we
21:44 talk about certain types and what the implication on the land may be.
21:48 Obviously connecting neighborhoods where we can and that that has to do with the greenway network a lot which can really do that in a way that is um that is very
21:56 deliberate and intentional. Uh how and how to forge additional in institutional partnerships and encourage local um enterprise and entrepreneurs next.
22:09 So when we begin with comprehensive plans we always we always begin with well what shouldn't change and most things are not changing in Clermont. So
22:17 that's that's the first thing we want to convey which is um we call these the frozen assets Nathan's term actually I like it because these are areas that are
22:26 established they're stable they have HOAs and so they're not going to change they're not going to radically change in any manner so where so that that's what
22:34 you see that is red on your screen the yellow which is where new growth can be managed is principally your downtown as
22:41 well as along SR50 and US27 that's where change is going to occur.
22:47 It's not going to occur in many of the neighborhoods. Uh but what we do see happening are the possibilities of neighborhood centers where there is a
22:54 lot of residential and not enough sort of desk neighborhood uh focused retail in those locations.
23:02 But we do want to assure you that when you see this, you should rest assured that you're not going to change in in very dramatic ways. Uh next,
23:12 another thing of course that's not going to change is the idea that uh what makes you special, your lakes, your small town charm, the hills, we want to enhance
23:20 those assets. We don't want to we don't want to change them. So we safeguard them. You'll see that there are you already had a very strong conservation
23:27 element. Um it's been made. It's you had some very good policies. We've tweaked a little bit of the language, but you know
23:34 how to how to preserve this well. Um and it it it it came through very clearly in the comprehensive plan and the small
23:41 town character. I think you will see that also very clearly how that's preserved when the form based code gets uh introduced to you uh when they talk about the northwest quadrant in
23:50 particular which is how how we can um ensure that building types that come that go next to each other are compatible and meet the street in a way
23:59 that is that is how you used to when you see photos of what um Montro for example used to be. um you it's about hiding
24:06 parking, it's about buildings that meet the street, it's about engaging pedestrian uh frontages. All of that
24:13 that is what makes you unique and special and those are the attributes we want to enhance and that you I think you'll see that the code of that. Next,
24:24 another of those big ideas was of course the uh the more robust mobility network.
24:30 Now this is a um this is this is a a a complicated greenway network. We spent time refining it with presidents um
24:37 little by little as Bernet and even as as late as last week when we had a conversation with one of you who was who
24:45 had taken some of his routes and she made recommendations. Uh I heard me she was she was telling us I went here and I
24:53 think should be on the lake here not on the street here and I think we're missing connection here and I think this connection is not possible. These are the kinds of details that have really
25:03 gone on into because we want to give you a mobility a greenway plan that is that is absolutely implementable. Um so here
25:11 it is. We're going to add street names to it. You'll get a big copy of it. I think Ben says he has a copy of it. Um but but you will see it and we invite you to mark these mark these up so that
25:19 we can keep making sure we get this correct. Next,
25:25 [snorts]
25:27 I alluded to limiting, you know, the suburban spraw. We know the reasons why.
25:31 You know, the suburban development often doesn't retain nature. So, people get angry when they see it. We know that some growth is going to continue. We know that some annexation will continue.
25:41 That's just the reality. But what we've put into our comprehensive plans are ways in which once you begin to acquire
25:48 land that is of a of more than a certain acreage, it should be in a form that can encourage more complete communities. Um
25:58 you can see here you're sort of expanding at the same rate as your population which is somewhere between your population grew five times in about 25 years and you've expanded by that
26:06 much. Uh you don't want to expand much more. Um, we understand that often the the the growth that you've had to
26:13 accommodate has come in the form of it's come by it has complied with Lake County zoning, but it doesn't necessarily comply with yours. So, we've also made
26:22 recommendations that any new development that you annex from this point forward should really be in compliance with your code because you're going through a big
26:29 effort to do that. And so, it's important that that be uh that that that be one of the policies that that gets um hopefully adopted.
26:37 Next, I have a question on that. Marina, there's a question.
26:44 How can we adopt and enforce that if the county is also involved? Great question.
26:50 Yeah. Well, you, by the way, you already have in your documents something that says that when you annex when you annex, this is a perfect
26:58 example of a of a policy you have in your comprehensive plan that for whatever reason isn't being uh enforced.
27:04 It already says, and maybe Kurt or John could correct me if I if I misstate this, but it already said that says that
27:11 you should that the new development that gets annexed should comply with your your your code.
27:19 Not quite sure why it doesn't. Um, one of the reasons Liz and and um has advocated for that that you can encourage that too is to make your
27:27 zoning more attractive than Lake counties so that developers instead of choosing to go into the county will choose to come into Clermont and then
27:36 you have a better chance of controlling how they develop.
27:39 Marina, we have some comments. We have some comments.
27:42 Marina, I I really I want to wake you up on this. Okay. It's very simple, Valerie. That was a great question. I
27:50 was going to ask that question. It's a great question. We do not have any control of what the county does. If we
27:58 don't annex it, they're putting it in either way. So, I want to bring that to your attention. Am I right, Valerie? Is
28:06 that pretty much spot on what we're trying to say? Yeah. There's no enforcement.
28:10 My question is, how can we enforce that with the county? Right. We can't.
28:14 Here's what we we started doing in the past to try to force them to give us some sight. And when it goes to the
28:21 county, if you come to us and you ask us, we say, "Hey, you have to use our codes and our ordinance." A lot of the developers don't want that
28:29 because we have less density than than the county. So, they would take it to the county. Of course, the county will come back and say, "Okay, would you
28:37 provide service?" we would still say no, we won't provide the service to them unless they to our and that's where what Marina is saying
28:44 about making sure ours is more attractive. Okay, I got it.
28:47 Right. So, so in order to do that, we have to for them to want to really deal with us, we have to uh do something with our codes, which our
28:56 density and we've always tried to keep our density because our density is a lot lot less than the county. Okay,
29:06 that's right. What the what what the mayor has said is exactly right. And um you know, it's been a while that I read I read your your your joint agreement
29:14 with the county, but I'm pretty sure it did say that it really should comply with your zoning. Now, yes, sometimes developers come in, you're forced to
29:23 provide services, and um and it's it's part of the Lake County, but hopefully now with a new comprehensive plan, you can be a little more deliberate about it.
29:32 Just want to throw another let's correct it. One of the thing we found out we're not they can't force us to provide services anymore. We used to think that
29:41 but then we went back and found out they can't force us to provide services. But what happened if we don't provide service they can still go to the county and then they can provide their own do
29:49 their own thing. Okay. And get get what they want. So we we kind of like in a catch 22 sometime. There's a question from the audience.
29:56 Yes sir. Can you come up?
30:02 I'm Scott and I've been a res here 30 years and getting more involved because uh place has changed. I I support
30:10 everything I've been seeing. Um and I just want to piggyback on that last question.
30:17 For 30 years, all everything that we all cherish, the hills, the lakes, the small town charm,
30:25 um the place has just been overrun and controlled by development and but I appreciated your your feedback there Tim
30:34 you know there's ways that we can uh uh tweak our codes through the new you know comp plan for based code etc if we have
30:42 more favorable density perhaps we can do through you know incentivizing developers but I've been an independent
30:49 real estate broker for 20 years it's mostly special you know commercial and penetized real estate worldide a
30:56 journalist for 30 years specializing in this lifestyle. Um, so I understand what what uh the the tale that went to the
31:04 dog. My question as I I'm wondering
31:10 how much of this be this this paradise we have. I live off of uh you know I
31:18 live at Margaret Gardens uh Lake Mha. you know, Lakeshore Drive is still a little oasis, but my question
31:26 is, how much of the land that I see on these maps, you know, today we're 11,500 acres urbanized,
31:35 approximately 26 compared to 2600. We've got a population of 54. I support growth. I'm pro business. I'm just
31:43 curious, how much land does the city today generally speak control? So, I can
31:52 So we don't have to worry about I've been following I mean I've known most of county commissioners the city
32:00 folks so I I know what's happened here for 30 years and I'm getting more involved
32:07 because I'm at a point I really am excited to to uh once I've learned what
32:14 the city has done invested with this worldass firm DPC code design to we have an opportunity to create something
32:23 before we lose this place that 50,000 I don't know about all 50,000 but the majority of us came here versus any
32:31 other place in greater Orlando for the qualities we all agree so I'm curious of the land that's left so we can create I
32:40 support these greenway more connected neighbors I love the idea of traditional town I'm just wondering besides the
32:47 northwest quadrant here in downtown generallying Can somebody give me an idea how much land
32:55 do my entrusted city officials all the way down to the PNZ folks to the city council
33:04 do we control right now that without having to worry about maybe annexing and maybe hope somebody has you know so forth and so on. Can somebody give me that idea?
33:14 Well, they kind of answer that question, sir. Well, really the city basically doesn't have very much land to control
33:23 of the most of the land yet to be developed in the city is basically being mostly in the county. We do have some
33:31 land somewhere in the city that need to be developed that can be developed what I call infield pretty much. Okay. But do
33:39 the city control it? No. Well, we have say over the development because the developers have to come when I say city
33:46 control uh we don't own it so so we can't control okay but we can have input on how it's develop uh through our polls
33:54 and through our ordinances and everything and like I say even even as in the past we were forced by the county
34:03 to provide service because as she was saying earlier we must provide services until we realized we didn't have to provide service so we use that as
34:11 leverage to try to have some sense of it. U now uh what I'm hearing you say somewhat it's like you like to increase density
34:20 and more people is what I'm hearing where we always took the uh point that we want to control the density because
34:29 the transportation problem traffic problem we we keep we keep adding all these people and everything but we don't really add too many new streets to help
34:38 couples with our transportation that has sorry let me clarify no by no means Do I support
34:46 more population growth from 9,000 I moved here in 1995 from Washington DC the beltway some of
34:55 the worst traffic in America next to LA I support growth I said quality growth
35:03 I am huge with sustainable development I know and I really admire the kind of places that so many people that we have
35:11 in the city have been a part rights maybe etc. But but my question is
35:21 you know 30 years from now I'm hoping I don't see a 100,000 and and
35:28 you know 50,000 urbanized acres because yeah for the most part I don't have to work down I don't have to work
35:38 and my wife but but our lifestyle yeah the traffic is number one I support everything that that the city and DPC
35:46 learned in their discovery. I am on board 100% with the vision, all of the guiding principles.
35:54 I'm just being pessimistic, I guess. So, which is why I asked the question, how much can do we control? Because I I
36:03 understand that the tra you know the trading the horse trading with the services, but if I'm a developer, that's a big infrastructure cost.
36:12 They've been going to the county, my good friends up there. So, yeah, let me let me see if I can reframe this question.
36:19 Marina, in the final proposal or Nathan of the comprehensive plan, will there be suggestions for what we as council and
36:28 as city officials can do in order to achieve the seven elements that have been identified? Will there be suggestions by the professionals?
36:38 Yes. Yes.
36:39 I think that Oh, yeah. And can I can I add to your point, Allison, can you just I would like to answer this man's question.
36:47 If you go back to the previous slide, if you go back to the previous slide, what you see in yellow is what the city of Clermont controls. Now, thank you.
36:56 That is that that's that's your city limit. Now I I also want to say I don't know I'm sure you all have read the same articles I've read but in the past two
37:04 weeks Liz has forwarded two articles about how um there's a there's a there's a a lot of people moving from coastal
37:13 cities into central Florida right and Clermont was amongst those cities so people are coming
37:21 this I'm not saying this to scare you but I'm just saying there is a there is a certain amount of growth you you're going to have to accommodate There is
37:29 also the fact that there are and this is why so can we go to the next slide?
37:34 Well, before you go, Marina, can you Yeah.
37:37 That kind of pocket in the middle of all the yellow is going to be served by all of our public
37:44 safety and probably I'm guessing our utilities. What would be your recommendation for kind of that pocket
37:51 and the piece that extends out to the east? Is that is there any benefit to us in attempting to annex that land so that
37:59 we have clear boundaries so that people know that they're in the city or no?
38:04 Just let it be because it's it's inconsistent with our vision for the future.
38:10 You know, my first gut is to say it would make sense in some level, but we we don't know what the zoning is on those parcels. We we don't know much
38:18 about it because it's not in the city, but we're happy to take a look at it. Okay. Which area you referred to?
38:26 We kind of have a yellow donut and then in the middle there's a hole with a little piece coming out.
38:32 Yeah. And we also have to kind of figure about the future. I mean, do we stop annexing and kind of say, okay, this is our limit. And then let everybody else
38:41 kind of go like you always bring up Wellness Way. It could be their own city. So where do we stop annexing?
38:49 Well, and at what point do we look the other way when people I mean, just the extreme example is when people are dying. I mean, when when the
38:57 county approves Panther Run, I'm just going to call it what it is. When the county approves Panther Run and is going
39:04 to provide county services to a place that has a resort with a with a 15minute response time to [clears throat] a heart attack. I mean,
39:12 that's just not going to fly. So, at what point, and and this is probably rhetorical, but at what point are we looking the other way? And at what point
39:19 are we saying you chose developer to build in the county, and that was your choice, and we're not it's not our problem.
39:27 That's a philosophical question, but it's one that I I think is very serious that we're confronted with.
39:32 We we have already previous council already looked at things like that.
39:38 That's why I say we we had an agreement with the county when they come to the county send it back to us before they make any decision on whether they're
39:45 going to approve it and let us give input that was working that was working good up until a year or two ago now we we
39:53 don't a lot of times like for example that's all being done we gave no input to us really and everything even though
40:00 it's in the county and of course I think it's going to be hard for us to even try to annex it in because where it's
40:07 located. So, uh I think this is going to fall off on the county in the future.
40:12 Okay. Unless we make some drastic changes here to be able to annex, but I don't I don't see that happening. But,
40:20 um you can say the county was working real good with us in the past where they would send projects to us, let us get in
40:27 and they didn't want it, they of course the county still turn around and exp. We don't have to provide them service. That's the one key thing we have to say.
40:35 But where do you stop? So we we we Where do you stop? I mean you're going to keep going down to Davenport. I mean to the what is it? Kane crossings.
40:43 They're all known as Clermont. Are you going to stop there?
40:47 Here's the philosophy we we were choosing that we stop when we not providing the services.
40:53 Well, this way we understand one really thing we really want to do. But once we provide the service, yeah, we going to take it in. We not don't want to
41:02 continue to provide services to these subdivisions in these areas and not collect revenue for them. Okay. Uh so
41:09 that's why we we going back and one of the things we've been doing is annexing all these things that we providing service. But if I stop providing service
41:17 for I see no commitment to annexing me that's me I feel about I don't want to annex any not
41:26 you want respect. You have to hear the laws right. Okay. And you know the inside school behind doors. Okay.
41:37 And being sitting there. All right. I've seen everything coming from the county
41:44 growing. I'm not talking about 2,000 homes. I'm talking about growing.
41:51 Started with Groves on Marsh at the end and then now we got Panthers run. That is my biggest fear living in clamor.
42:01 When like m commission m when does it stop? [snorts] And that's my question to you. Am I
42:08 right or wrong? The beginning I agree with you. When I first came to Claymont, the county listened to us. Yes. It seems
42:17 like, and I'm not trying to start a war between city of Claymont and the county. I got my own problems, right?
42:25 But I'm going to be honest. It seems like they're just they don't care what we think.
42:30 All right. Started with Wellness SW how mostly against it. They want to build a 10story building right next to our own.
42:39 I mean, my question is, am I right or wrong? So, she could understand when the county comes in, they're not coming in
42:48 with make regular projects. They're coming in with huge projects. Like Councilman Stranger said, Panthers run is my opinion is going to be a disaster.
42:58 I mean, that's I mean, it's nice for what they're doing, but hard to clam on, it's going to us.
43:05 You're right. And Panther Run is that's why I went to the presentation and I think, wow, this could be humongous. You
43:12 know, my concern when I looked at it was the fact, are you gonna want to stand X?
43:17 I don't want X. be honest with you, I'm not sitting in group. But then when I look at the rules and everything into this location, I don't see how we can
43:25 add it spin well beyond our service line.
43:30 So like I say, if I'm not providing service, I'm not ready to pay next. Okay. Correct.
43:37 But I want her to understand that. Yes. Right.
43:41 The growth of the county is getting larger and larger. I'm watching it. I from Groves to Panther Run. What's next?
43:50 That's my question.
43:51 So Marina, in your experience, what what do cities do when I'm assuming this has happened before.
43:59 I Has it not happened before? Are we are we the unicorn or is this something that's totally normal and there's an obvious way to handle it?
44:07 No, there's no obvious way to handle it.
44:09 There's and it's in Florida, it's particularly complicated by the fact that you have a you've adopted, you know, a very you're a very strong
44:16 property right state, which means that even within your city limits now, only speak about that first. Um there's
44:23 there's a lot of development potential and development capacity and that's probably one of the best one of the best things
44:31 you have is to encourage developers to be building there. Now what have other cities done to so the annexation I think
44:38 it's very it's very important to um to to do a couple of things. One is to ensure that you can at least if they
44:46 choose to annex in that it's coming in the form of communities that can be much more self-sufficient and complete than they have been in the past so that it's
44:54 not straining your your your infrastructure. We've seen cities impose moratoriums and use the quote unquote excuse that the services aren't there
45:02 but that's only temporary and typically what happens is that that growth catches up um once that moratorum is lifted. um
45:11 it's it's a vulnerable place to be. So, it's really going to be about controlling where the growth occurs and
45:18 then really trying to find a way to to to uh to strengthen your agreements with the county to ensure that it's it's it's
45:26 when you do get growth, it's in a way that that is that is uh supportive of your um of your comprehensive plan goals. And the the the gentleman who got
45:35 up from the planning board, I forget his name, who kept telling us, "Don't New York my Clermont." Um, let's get that straight.
45:45 Forget about it. I'm sorry. Remind me your name. Vincent. That's Vincent.
45:50 Vincent. Okay. Vincent. Sorry. He's right. He's right. You have to find a way to get the county to uh to to to
45:59 play ball with you, for lack of a better word. You know, it's it's very unfortunate. Yeah.
46:05 So, there's no magic bullet. But but the the the thing is that there's there is a lot of potential within your existing city limits now. So developers were to
46:13 see that and if they were to see that they no longer can come in with sort of these sprawling plans that there's a way
46:21 to actually stop them which your joint agreement does speak to then maybe that will help. If you make the development,
46:29 as Liz and the mayor just said, if you make the density, and I I have a whole presentation on density for you all, uh more attractive within the city limits.
46:37 Now, everything goes back to my very What is the controllable amount of
46:45 Sorry. Port of order. Port of order. Is this I of order. I got it. Go ahead, sir.
46:53 No. Point of order. Port of order. Is this a council workshop or are we giving public cart blanch to speak as long as they want
47:01 about whatever they want? Because typically at our workshops they come up and speak for three minutes. I think he's making valid points but we're never even going to get through this presentation.
47:09 Exactly.
47:10 And we still have the downtown action plan and I also heard form based code. I don't know if that's being talked about today. Okay. So we still have no today. So I'm just concerned about
47:19 structure and so I'm just concerned. Thank you.
47:25 Well, if we concerned about structure, we would go through the presentation without any interruptions. Uh I think in
47:34 the beginning he uh Mr. North said, "Hey, we can stop and interrupt and ask question at any point during the presentation." I think that's what I heard.
47:42 No, but I do respect.
47:44 Thank you. But and that's one of the reason I've always said I like to go through things without interrupting because then you get into
47:51 these type of discussions. Okay. So if that's the case we just go through presentation and you all jot down your question ask them at the end.
47:58 Well I think that they want to hear us.
48:00 It's just that a question's been asked and answered at this point.
48:08 All right. Thank you. Can we go to the next slide? So where should that growth occurred? During the during the sharet that we h that we held, we were able to
48:17 zero in on 10 sites, opportunity sites as we call them that um where people expressed an interest, property owners,
48:25 residents express an interest in seeing these places evolve as neighborhood or town centers. So you you will see in the comprehensive plan when you get a copy
48:33 of it examples of how those places can grow in a way that connects people to the the the the
48:42 all the goals that are in the comp plan that is you know it's it's within a walkable community. It's a mix of building types. It provides for retail
48:49 uses at grade. It makes sense. Give them a context. Um these are often sites where the property owners have plans.
48:57 They came in with their plans. We think we improve them. um they seem to like them. So we hope that this may be the start of of collaborating with them in a
49:06 way that uh that can be that can bring so that when they finally come forward with projects, if you feel that they're compliant with the comprehensive plan,
49:13 they you can support them and um and and and and see them as as as a as as a good example of how development could occur.
49:22 Yes. Allison, are these in an order or is this just numerical? No, sorry. They're not in an order at all. It's not to say that the
49:30 downtown connecting Mondro to the waterfront is is is number one. We just happen to list them in this order for, you know, we could list them from left
49:39 to right, from up to down. There's no particular order at all. Thank you.
49:45 And um and this is not exhaustive either. There may be others that you all help us identify. Uh next,
49:54 and here's an example of one. Right. So we knew what this is the Waterbrook site. Yes, this is the Waterbrook site.
50:00 It's at the corner of 50 and Hanok. It's one of the three town center locations we've identified in your comprehensive plan in your comprehensive plan. And you
50:08 can see there's a range of possible residential and commercial options.
50:12 There was a there was recreational um facilities proposed. There's, you know, trails. There's a boutique hotel.
50:20 And the different colors represent different different land uses. We made sure that it complied with the zoning
50:26 and the and the and the the flu. So that's one thing that uh that that was important and we wanted to use the land
50:34 wisely and to plan it in a way that is uh that is efficient and not wasteful of the land that you have next. So here's
50:42 one rendering of it. You can see this happen. This this is the the continuous trail around the lake with you know an
50:49 ample prominade for all your lakes are huge and they're beautiful and they are and they can accommodate this this type
50:57 of uh growth and this kind of development uh with those with those amenities that are very much woven into
51:03 the fabric of the neighborhood. Uh next, and this is an example of an aerial uh
51:10 that we believe does development and conservation well. It may scare folks, but we think it's a better uh proposal
51:18 than these pad sites that come surrounded with parking. Uh they be you can see the buildings are shaping streets. You can see the build and this
51:26 is how Clermont developed initially and you can see that mix of building types that exists here as well. Uh, next.
51:35 So now to get to the comprehensive plan, when you get a copy of it, you're going to get um this is the way we began to track changes. When we first began to
51:42 review every single element, we looked at the at the at each goal, objective, and policy in each one of them, read them, and suggested either that they
51:51 should stay the way they are, that they could accommodate a little bit of change, that they should be deleted entirely, or that they or we would impose we would propose new policies.
52:00 So, we have it tracked this way, but we've also given it to the county in a in a word document that just literally strikes out what we're proposing be
52:08 deleted and adds in what we proposing to be added. So, you'll see that it's a very easy document to read. We gave it to them with track changes. They've given us comments back. We're making
52:16 those changes and you'll get a clean copy as well as one that act where you can see those changes so that you can be very aware of every little change that
52:23 was made. Next, now I'm going to, as I mentioned before, I'm going to end my presentation on
52:32 talking about density because that is the most um what what's likely to be initially the most controversial topic
52:39 because we're proposing that you calculate density in a in a very different way and and I'm going to explain the reasons why. And this is where I would encourage you to stop me
52:47 and ask questions as you see the slides because um it's important. It's it's an important concept and it is the most the
52:54 most radical calculation we've done in your flu. As I mentioned before, a lot of the rest of the changes in your in your different
53:02 elements have to do with tweaks, have to do with removing regulations that are in your comprehensive plan that don't belong in the comprehensive plan, but
53:10 actually belong in zoning. Very often cities put regulations into their comp plan because in their mind it's harder for developers to ask for variances but it makes for a messy comprehensive plan.
53:20 So you you'll see that when things are stricken out we say place and zoning place and zoning. Uh but when we began
53:27 to look and understand at what your density was we realized that this is not uncommon that there's a there's a
53:34 discrepancy between the density assigned and the unit the building types that you permit. So, what we've done, and you
53:42 you'll get this in a large chart. You you don't have to read this now because it's not as if you're voting on any of this, but we took your flu categories.
53:49 We listed what the heights were. We listed what the densities were. We listed all the zoning categories that appear in each of the flu. When you see
53:56 a flu grayed out, it means when you see a zoning category grayed out, it just means there are few examples of where those um zoning categories are included
54:05 in that flu. The ones that are black are the more typical ones. And then we proposed uh renaming them. We're
54:13 proposing new densities and I'm going to go through that and proposing different heights. And you'll see that there are places where the heights are actually lowered but you're going to see that the
54:22 density is higher. And I'm going to explain why next.
54:26 So the the very first question I'm going to pose is is is is asking people if we were to ask people in the room to define
54:34 what is density, we would get very different answers, including how community members understand it because
54:41 too often people tend to associate low density with good, high density with bad. But you can do low density very well or very poorly and you can do high
54:49 density very well or very poorly. So we try to get cities to not think about and residents in particular not to think about density because it's a hard
54:57 concept to grasp and to actually start to think about building types. But there's also many different ways cities interpret density. Is it units per acre?
55:06 Is it gross or net? How does it tie to the F? Very The F is the floor area ratio which tells you the development capacity on your parcel. Very often
55:15 they're not correlated. Is it measured by population density? I'm here right now. Don't do it right now.
55:23 Sorry. Sorry.
55:26 [laughter]
55:32 Many stories, Ben. [laughter] I I'm in a I'm in a city right now where they measure population where they're doing a comp plan and they're measuring
55:40 that the the density by people per square kilometer. Now, that's even in my mind worse because that's impossible to understand. is does it does it relate to
55:48 commercial intensity or not? In addition to that, there's lots of other metrics that factor into density. What lot
55:55 coverages and setbacks provide sometimes will preclude a developer or property owner from reaching the density that's
56:03 listed. Sometimes height limits will preclude it. Sometimes minimum maximum law sizes will preclude it. And very often parking ratios and parking
56:11 standards is what further limits density. So it's a complex topic. That's the first point I'd like to make. Next,
56:20 now the other thing I want to say is that it is density is simply a poor predictor of form. When we talk to
56:27 community members, we always ask them don't think about a number because it tells you nothing about what the form is going to be. Think about what are the
56:35 building types you would like to see here, what are the building types you wouldn't like to see here. And so here's an example of a halfacre site. All four
56:43 examples yield eight units an acre, but as you can see, they're very different.
56:48 One is four big houses on the lot that occupies more of the lot. One is a quadruplex that occupies less of the
56:55 lot, but includes more units and smaller units within the site. And then the two on the top right and the bottom are sort of the middle ground. One is two
57:04 duplexes and another one is four cottages. And they're all yielding the same density. Next,
57:12 now here's another example where it's reversed. This time the density changes,
57:19 but the log stays the same. So, you have two single family dwellings at 2,000 ft each. They're yielding four dwelling
57:26 units an acre. If you were to do two triplexes, you'd get 12 units an acre, and the units would be smaller. If you were to do duplexes, it would be half
57:34 the size of a single family home, but you would get two. And if you do a quadruplex, 500 square feet each and you get 16 dwelling units an acre. So often
57:43 density um density flies in the face of providing more affordable housing because there isn't an incentive for a developer to do
57:52 smaller units if they can somehow reach the maximum density with larger units.
57:57 So that's another reason why you're going to see we're recommending changes next. And then we show examples to community members.
58:08 So here's an example. One has a 12-story building on one site. It occupy they both occupy 4.4 acres. One has 100 units. The other one has 100 units. It's
58:16 exactly the same. One has 8% lot coverage because of the parking that's required. And one has 80% lot coverage.
58:23 If I were to ask you to guess which one has the highest density, I would guess maybe 50% would say the building on the left and 50% maybe would say that the
58:31 the buildings on the right. Next, they're exactly the same density. And I
58:39 like to show this slide to have people understand that density in and of itself is not a remote
58:47 predictor of fall. Uh, next, here's another one.
58:53 You can take a look at these four pictures. It's going to be very obvious which one has the lowest density and which which is the one on the right on
59:01 the bottom right and which one has the highest density. It's the one on the left. But if you were to try to guess which one has 74 dwelling in it, which
59:08 one is 44, which one is 25, which one is 14, maybe people would think it's the one on the top that has the highest density, but that's not the case. Next,
59:18 it's the one on the bottom right bottom left, sorry. Uh because it's a more efficient use of land and there are multiple units in there that are
59:25 smaller. happens to be not too far from where I live in Virginia. So when we talk about trying to introduce
59:33 gentle density into here and in a way that makes sense. So when residents say to us, we want to see more duplexes here, we would like to see more town houses here, we're happy with smaller
59:41 multif family, we're not happy with larger multif family, each of those has a different implication when it comes to density. Uh next,
59:50 now you measure density and in your flu you measure density by gross density and it
59:58 is some people think it's the most logical or the easiest. It's actually the most unstable because it doesn't tell you about the capacity of the site
1:00:07 for obvious reason. So when you use co when you calculate gross density you're essentially saying what are the number of units allowed on this entire site. It
1:00:15 may include many, you know, a lot of wetlands. It may include very few wetlands. It may include a lot of recreational space. It may not include a
1:00:22 lot of recreational sp space. It may include a lot of streets or less streets every time. It it includes all of that.
1:00:29 So it it's not a each site even if it has the same density assigned to it could yield very very different results.
1:00:38 The next level is gross net density which is and many cities do that too.
1:00:42 They say okay let's exclude wetlands from it because um it's too unpredictable. But now we include the
1:00:50 open space, the blocks, the streets and the amenities.
1:00:54 It gives you a density that's typically one after two times what the gross density is, but it's still not as accurate as it could be. The most
1:01:02 accurate to calculate dens. The most accurate way to calculate density is net density, which is simply saying take the
1:01:09 private lots, you take out the streets you're providing, you take out the uh the open space, and you just look at lot
1:01:17 size and you ask yourself what are the kinds of building types that we want to see here? And so what we've done to your comprehensive plan is say we want to say
1:01:26 we want to we know through the form based code that there are certain lot sizes that are being proposed for single family for town houses for cottages for
1:01:35 small multif family for large multif family. And so what I'm going to show you now are examples of that. And I'm going to show you what each one of the
1:01:43 meals in terms of density because then you're going to see how we correlated those to your flu. Initially, you're
1:01:50 going to have a shock because you're going to see a much higher number, but the net density is a much much greater
1:01:57 predictor of the ultimate building form than what gross is. And I want to assure you that we haven't increase your
1:02:06 density in any way. We haven't said we haven't said you should be in terms of the building types that are currently permitted. So, we looked at the building
1:02:13 types that are permitted in your zoning and we've looked at what those densities are, which right now they're utterly unaligned
1:02:22 and we've we've we've tried to adjust it accordingly. So, let's go to the next one because now I'm going to run you through a series of slides. So, here's a
1:02:30 small single family house on a 35x 60 foot lot or on a 35x 100 foot lot. Both of those are decent sizes. We do a lot
1:02:38 of places. We we have a lot of projects in which we have 35 foot wide lots and actually 25 foot five foot sat back on either side. That's not appropriate
1:02:47 everywhere, but certainly it's appropriate in some locations. Next, so that will yield uh so we have the
1:02:56 metrics for each one of them. You don't have to read them, but I'm going to tell you it yields about 18 units an acre. And you can see what they look like.
1:03:03 They can be really charming little homes. Next.
1:03:08 Now, there's a standard single family home. Your zoning code says 50 by 100, you know, for for what what what's the
1:03:15 T3 lot, right? So, that's pretty standard. You have you happen to have a lot of lots in, for example, in some of your downtown neighborhoods that are wide and shallow. That's perfectly fine.
1:03:26 They they may be uh easily retrofitable for duplexes, as we're seeing some people do, but you also have narrow lots
1:03:32 as well. Next. So when you look at examples of what that yields, that's yielding about 8 to 12 units an acre
1:03:40 just by looking at the the size of the lot. Next. Now cottage courts.
1:03:47 We've heard cottage courts are something that people really want to see. And in fact, we saw a few in in Clermont themsel in Clermont. And they're
1:03:55 actually older, but they're really charming charming places. They're great for young professionals, for singles or elderly people. where I live, we have
1:04:03 many of them. And um you know, parents can let their kids go out and play on the green without worrying about kids being uh run over because they don't
1:04:10 have to cross the street. And they're also perfect for senior housing because there's a place that people can gather with their neighbors. Um it's it's just
1:04:17 always a central space that is um it's for people who don't want a yard to take care of, but they may want a single family home. They may want a detached
1:04:25 home. They don't want to be attached to somebody. But that central space is key because it provides them with the open space that they would otherwise have in
1:04:32 their backyard. Next, it holds 30 units an acre. And you can see these are all from our different
1:04:41 communities and they're really convivial places. And when we when we hear that, you know, I could go give a half hour talk on what social isolation does to
1:04:49 people and particularly elderly people, but it's really really a critical component of finding ways in which to have housing units that that can engage residents in a greater common space.
1:05:00 Next, then we move to the next lot up, which is a duplex. Now, a duplex can yield a very different density because
1:05:08 you can do a duplex that's vertical and sometimes they call that a twin. And sometimes you can do a duplex that's side by side, which is the the ones you
1:05:16 have. Next, those will yield typically twice the density of a single family home. Of course, if they're side by side, but if they're vertical, they can go even more.
1:05:25 So, we we've got range of about 12 to 18 dwelling units an acre.
1:05:29 Marina Marina, just to clarify, that the densities you're showing are net.
1:05:37 They're based on the lot size. Exactly.
1:05:39 They're based on the exact lot size of the of the parcel. So, here's a townhouse. Town houses vary in lot sizes. Of course, you know, again, where
1:05:47 I live, we have 14 foot wide town houses, but and they're they're great, but we also have 22 foot wide townous for two parking cars. Uh, so town houses
1:05:55 are wonderful, especially if they're served by alleys because they're not the front yard is not consumed by parking.
1:06:01 Next, that's easily going to get you 18 to 22 units an acre. You have town houses that are allowed, of course, in your in your
1:06:09 in your flu and in your zoning, but the gross density doesn't match it.
1:06:15 So, okay. Next, then you have the small multif family and there's, you know, we do we have what we call uh four packs, six packs, eight packs.
1:06:27 Well, let's go to the next one, please, Ben.
1:06:33 And in particular, the the small multif family are very compatible with larger single family homes because there's one entrance off the side, as you can see in the drawing there. And then you have one
1:06:41 unit on the left, one unit on the right, there's windows on all three sides, so you can get cross ventilation. They're very they can be very generous units. We
1:06:49 know that on a 60 by 100 foot lot if for example you only require one parking space per unit you can you can fit you can get you can hit a density of about
1:06:57 24 units an acre. If you require more parking like one and a half spaces or two then that density will come down. So when I mentioned that parking has an
1:07:05 implication um on on on the on the uh on the ultimate density that's also true.
1:07:12 Next.
1:07:14 And we we tend to embed these in our in our single family neighborhoods often because they can resemble single family.
1:07:21 Now, here you're seeing some three-story ones. The threetory ones are six-packs.
1:07:25 Two units to the floor of the three stories are six and those will 36 units an acre. Next,
1:07:34 just got a couple more. Uh this then this still under small multif family the eight packs. That's uh that that's four
1:07:41 units to a floor and it can go up two stories, eight or or three stories, 12 can be very compact.
1:07:49 Next, they get light on two sides now, not necessarily three, but those will yield up to 44 units an acre if you take that
1:07:57 parcel size, which is about 70 by 100. Um, next,
1:08:05 and then you have the multif family. And the multif family of course varies tremendously. if it's going to have structured parking, if it's going to have under the building parking, if it's
1:08:13 going to have surface parking. But if you take a typical three-story building or fourstory building next,
1:08:21 you're going to get somewhere between 65 to 100 units an acre. So, and that's at an average square footage, it's written
1:08:28 in there, of 600 to,200 square feet on average. So, you could say 900 square feet as an average for the for the units for the unit size.
1:08:38 Next.
1:08:40 So we took those unit types, we looked at the the the size of those lots and we
1:08:47 color correlated the density to it. So can you go to the next slide because this is where it resides. So here you're
1:08:54 going to see the new flu map that's suggested on the right. you're going to see the majority of it's not changing,
1:09:02 but what we have town centers, that's the brown color that you see here, or neighborhood centers. That's the um that's the uh orange color you see. But
1:09:11 here you're seeing the density that this will yield. So, if you want the low density neighborhood as you allow them
1:09:18 right now can easily yield 8 to 8 to 18 dwelling units an acre. If it's single family, it's it's eight or nine. If it's
1:09:25 duplexes, it's 18. your medium density 36 to 65 if it's if it's been now the
1:09:32 the few has a range because if it's medium density that allows T4 those zoning categories it's 36 units an acre
1:09:39 why 36 because that's the six-pack which is three stories not anymore 65 units to the acre is the T5 is the
1:09:48 taller zones that can go four stories or five stories that gets you a higher density and then finally along your corridors what are what you currently
1:09:57 have zone commercial which we're recommending be called mixeduse corridor because you have a zoning a flu called
1:10:04 commercial commercial but it allows residential. It allows all sorts of uses. So we're just calling it what it already is which is a mixeduse corridor.
1:10:12 It shouldn't matter whether people are putting commercial or residential there.
1:10:16 And so that can yield anywhere from 65 to 100 dwelling units an acre depending on how they manage their parking. The height is restricted. We're recommending
1:10:24 that the town center be the only places where you may want to allow taller buildings. You'll have to debate the pros and cons of that. We're suggesting
1:10:31 maybe up to seven stories, but everywhere else and you could add benefits to that. So, you know what? If we're going to upzone you, which many
1:10:38 cities do, that's going to come with a public benefit that you now have to provide us with because we've just now increased your property value. And then
1:10:45 the commercial corridors, which are uh the the mixeduse corridors, could be principally five stories.
1:10:52 Uh, next. Can you go back?
1:10:56 So, just one. Yes. I've got a question about that.
1:11:00 Thank you for doing such a thorough job, Marina. But as I sit here, I think about our city attorney, Christian Wah, who's
1:11:07 here, and I think about the the mayor who's always reminding us about uh live local and how it can upend our our our,
1:11:15 you know, how things are done. It's my understanding that the Florida's live local law is tied to density. and how
1:11:23 what it allows and so I didn't know Christian if uh if we know if we if we
1:11:30 start showing densities like this how does that get interpreted visa v live local so wait I'm going ask you to hold that
1:11:38 question and answer that and then let's go ahead and get through this presentation please okay okay okay I think I have one more slide but that's a very good question Nathan well the one
1:11:47 more slide is just a reminder of what um of what the guiding principles And I I wanted to put this slide at the
1:11:55 very end to say keep these ideas in mind when when Ben begins to present the downtown action plan and you're going to begin to see the vision that's tied to
1:12:04 the uh to to how you can interpret these through a physical vision that's tied to to your downtown. And when they come and present their phone based code, you will
1:12:13 also see that it is a way to preserve your your your historical character, your local businesses, and the familyfriendly atmosphere that everyone is is is promoting.
1:12:23 One more slide.
1:12:27 You know, we've seen this quote. you you Liz I think started or finished her presentation last time on on on this
1:12:33 wonderful quote by your town founder but I hope that once you see the the the the comprehensive plan you'll see we're not trying to impose a new vision at all we
1:12:42 are really returning not only to your roots but to what your original what your original vision was yes in a in a
1:12:50 in a more with it more people there but in a way that can be perfectly charming and perfectly adaptable able to uh to
1:12:59 the context in which you live. Thank you.
1:13:03 Now I'm happy to answer questions you have.
1:13:06 Mr. Nor, back to your question, I guess, Mr.
1:13:10 Well, if I if I understand your question correctly, I mean, live local static, right? I mean, so yeah, what it
1:13:17 basically says is that um the if you have a qualifying residential or
1:13:24 affordable housing development, it's entitled to the highest residential density that you allow in your jurisdiction. Um so, you know, I don't
1:13:34 know what off the top of my head what the implications are based on what's been proposed. Um, like I haven't looked at your the mixeduse corridor details
1:13:44 yet, but I'm intrigued. And I think that it would be entitled to the highest residential density, you know, depending on the project.
1:13:51 But would it be restricted to the areas that are designated for those corridors or can they put it anywhere?
1:13:56 Anywhere there's residential they get the highest residential density.
1:14:00 Well, no. Lift local only applies to commercial.
1:14:04 No, that's use commercial industrial use, right? But you were saying residential cannot go to residential only.
1:14:12 No, what I said was they're entitled to the highest residential density in those areas.
1:14:19 And remember, they went back and amended for uh live local a couple years ago and now those three commercial misuse. No,
1:14:27 it's basically any any property basically you own them. It's not it's not limited those anymore. Okay. And
1:14:34 here's the thing, and it was all my understanding at the time, it applies to the highest density code you had in the city, regardless of commercial,
1:14:42 residential. Matter of fact, we we went back to try to combat it. We went back and I changed we changed our which is the downtown was at 25 per acre.
1:14:53 We went back and changed ours to 15 per acre to try to combat the local. Okay.
1:14:59 And and it didn't work for us really.
1:15:03 Okay. So, so because we changed it after the live local came in, well, I guess it didn't work for that one project because
1:15:10 we changed it and they had already started paperwork on one project. So, they end up being able to do it for 25.
1:15:16 Uh, that's the one piece that Mr. North is always [clears throat] referring to 10 acres that's out in the uh Lincoln Park area that the developer want to
1:15:25 develop that under under the that 10 acres. What is it, Mr. North? out here in that's under develop and he was able to get his 25 acres per per year. Okay.
1:15:35 Could we control that through doing a form based code for the whole city? Would that add controls
1:15:44 onto anything like local try to override? I want to follow up on that. Yes.
1:15:48 Because the farm based code is to be an overlay. Could we say you can have this density if you build consistent with the
1:15:56 formbbased code and might that address live local?
1:16:00 So that's an interesting question because it my understanding I I I'm just spitballing lip local is a huge thing
1:16:08 but my understanding is that it doesn't entitle you to the density that is achievable through
1:16:16 bonuses. So like you can create I think that's kind of what you're talking about different kinds of incentives and bonuses that you get entitled to.
1:16:26 You don't necessarily get those automatically with a development. It's just you're entitled to the raw highest residential density in the code.
1:16:35 So, for example, if [laughter] there's some system through the code that says if you do XYZ, you're entitled to this
1:16:44 higher density bonus, that doesn't necessarily carry over to the live local project, if that makes sense.
1:16:51 Sorry if it doesn't. Um, can I can I add one thing to that?
1:16:58 Um, sorry, I don't I don't mean to interrupt. I just sometimes I don't see you guys. And just two things. One is remember that with the live local, you
1:17:07 also you go to the highest height, but you're not you're not going to have anything taller than five stories, right? So they can't go taller than five
1:17:15 as the your your attorney said the if you were to bonus up for the extra two, that doesn't that's not an entitlement.
1:17:22 So you are so the height is is is part of that. My question is, and that's the question for the attorney, is if we're calculating density in a new way, which
1:17:29 is moving from gross to net, presumably whatever gets done in the city would follow the same calculation of density.
1:17:37 Yeah. Yeah. I mean, I is that a question or a statement?
1:17:41 Sounds No, I I I I a presumption, but it would be nice if you could confirm it.
1:17:46 I think that's accurate. [laughter] No, I mean I I I look honestly this is the first time I've ever heard of the term net density.
1:17:55 Um so this is new for me in in hearing about it.
1:17:59 But I think you know that if we use net density and calculate it that way and define it accordingly then yeah it's it's all going to be based on that.
1:18:11 Makes sense.
1:18:13 I have another question. Um, when we look at the map that shows potential town centers and neighborhood centers,
1:18:23 my question is if I'm thinking about I want to know if I'm thinking about Clermont's future development correctly and the way I'm starting to think about
1:18:32 it relates to a term I recently learned, which is a
1:18:40 polyentric city that London is a polyentric city, I think. Am I using it right?
1:18:48 Yeah. Yes. Different centers.
1:18:51 In other words, as I think of Clermont on a map and I look at the map from 1884, I often on those giant maps put my
1:18:59 hand up and my hand only covers old Clermont, but then there's all this other Clermont and you know, so I think how
1:19:08 many hands could I put on the map? And that's probably not a great way to do it, but it visually works for me. And so
1:19:14 am I thinking of it correctly that the goal is that everywhere you know one kind of a handsize
1:19:22 walkable city and that's where these neighborhood and town centers are coming from. Is that what we're doing theoretically?
1:19:28 Yes. I think that's a very it's a very it's a very nice way of looking at it.
1:19:31 you you would be a mini mini many mini mini polyentric city because you know it's it's essentially polyentric cities establish centers in different places
1:19:40 where the jobs and the housing can be centered around those areas. Uh and then everything else in between is less important. Uh so it's it is exactly that
1:19:49 idea that you have neighborhood centers and and or a town center in each of your quarters.
1:19:53 Well and how do we feel about that? I think that's important for us to deliver to DPZ. Well, doesn't that look kind of like the villages like Brownwood,
1:20:02 Spanish, Lake Sumpter Landing? They have those squares.
1:20:09 Are they as big though? I think towns whereas they might have villages, which is probably why they're called villages,
1:20:17 but but I don't think we have as many. I mean, I haven't looked at the villages on a map compared to Clermont. They have some very nice centers, but
1:20:25 relative to the overall population development, they're pretty sparse. Can you hear? Not very well.
1:20:32 Yeah, they they they have a handful of very nice centers, but there aren't many relative to the overall expansive
1:20:40 development. There aren't enough centers.
1:20:44 But can I say something? Okay. So, that's one of the core ideas behind the comp plan and everything else was dealing with traffic. the way to deal
1:20:52 with the traffic is with the town centers. If you put the town centers uh all in the different uh quadrants, then
1:20:59 that's keeping people off 27 and 50. So that's important. Theoretically, if we were starting from scratch and you had
1:21:06 these centers, it would also give people closer access to nature if you concentrate the development. But if you allow development everywhere, it's not
1:21:15 as strong. But we can essentially benefit from the traffic uh benefit just on the fact that I don't have to go AC,
1:21:23 you know, on 27 or each one of the areas would harness the traffic and everyone being on a stream, right? So the development serves as an
1:21:31 amenity for what's around it. Okay? And that's that's what we haven't been doing as a city is that most new development
1:21:39 doesn't serve as an amenity for the neighbors that are there. And if we reconceive of the quality of what we're doing, that's the advantage.
1:21:46 And see the key the key word you use in there starting from scratch.
1:21:51 Y that would be great if we were starting from scratch. I I understand the concept and I totally agree with that. But
1:22:00 problem we have here in Climouth because all this development had gone on, we didn't develop on that on that philosophy. So, how do you go back and
1:22:08 where do you go back and say you're gonna put a town set here that this this quadrant and everybody here be able to walk to or benefit from? Right.
1:22:16 You just change the rights.
1:22:17 See, you give an incentive for them to redevelop along the corridors.
1:22:24 We have a few places. Yeah. Where you can go from scratch. Yeah. Right. But but but you're you're right.
1:22:31 It's not Nobody's saying it's simple. I think that's there's there's it's not an exhaustive place, you know, but where we did designate your town centers is where you
1:22:39 already have a commercial zoning. So, we haven't quote unquote upzoned areas. We haven't suggested upzoning anything. Um
1:22:47 just just to be clear, but where we are suggesting neighborhood centers is where it makes perfectly perfect sense to um to do that.
1:22:56 No, you passed it actually, Ben. But you know, I could email you the map and you could pull it up if you want. No, you have.
1:23:04 Yeah. Yeah, you you were on the right. Right. There it is.
1:23:06 You were on the right one. All the numbers.
1:23:09 So, the three town centers are is the Waterbrook site, the uh the Citrus Tower site, and the school the university
1:23:17 site, the L LSSC site for now. And then you have many more neighborhood centers.
1:23:22 I thought, oh, can you tell me the difference then between a town center?
1:23:26 Okay, so you said town center and then there's neighborhood centers. I remember saying Wellness Way and the Ark and then something near Hartwood Mars.
1:23:35 Yeah, wellness waves is its own um is its own system. Okay. Yeah, there it is. There's the drawing.
1:23:43 Well, so you have your downtown of course, right?
1:23:48 You can see the three neighborhood the street hometown centers are the elective ones and then the smaller neighborhood centers are places where we know that there's a lot of residential housing. So
1:23:56 for example the arc your recreational center that is um that's across from Kings Ridge. There's a lot of available
1:24:04 land there where you already have your your community center where you have your pickle ball courts and you have your the the residential the the senior housing and down at the base you have a
1:24:13 lot of a lot of commercial uses. That's a place that could naturally identify as well as one of your neighborhood centers. It's just of a at a smaller scale.
1:24:22 Yeah, I think it's worth pointing out on the frozen assets map that like in this version the red are these uh our cold stock subdivisions. Those are unlikely
1:24:31 to change very much, but there's a lot of commercial land along the 50 and 27 and then throughout the downtown area
1:24:38 that is eligible for redevelopment and those could become various sizes of centers where there's a large town center, small neighborhood center. This could serve a lot of those areas.
1:24:48 I think about like the Citrus Tower Plaza for example that is going to be ready for redevelopment soon. It's been
1:24:56 developed but things are and along 50 I think of like the Wind Dixie plaza for example things like that where that's right
1:25:03 there's so much parking that's not being used and if we're changing our code so all that's not require it's going to become very appealing and then if we're getting ahead of it with the development
1:25:12 and design center with good design concepts and things like that supporting developers at the the start it creates opportunity it's not not all within our
1:25:21 perfect control but I think But the opportunity is there and I love the idea of the town neighborhood village centers.
1:25:29 I think people want people want that and we can work towards that. It's not going to look exactly how we maybe have it
1:25:36 lined out here, but what can we do to
1:25:39 [clears throat]
1:25:40 Valerie? I understand exactly what you mean, but the reason why that's a bad intersection, too. And if you start
1:25:49 developing on that parking lot that you say is huge.
1:25:55 It's help me out. That's your part of that thoughts. Yeah.
1:25:59 The reason why it's flowing and barely flowing is because of the excess parking lot. You start and look, you got you come up with great ideas.
1:26:08 The traffic's flowing because there's extra parking. Is that Yeah. You put more buildings there, there's going to be more traffic. That's that's what I'm saying.
1:26:15 Traffic isn't flowing as as smooth as you think out there.
1:26:18 That that's that's exactly what I'm saying. It's not flowing as smooth as you think.
1:26:22 You go to some especially around the Wind Dixie plaza.
1:26:25 You got a we got a real serious problem along Wind Dixie or what's that? Blossom Aroulevard.
1:26:33 There's a serious problem out there drop over on the other side of That's the reason why we're creating
1:26:41 these town centers in every single part that the traffic that you add more you add more traffic.
1:26:48 Well, hold on. Let me see if I can help.
1:26:50 Marina, do we have in our studies and research anyway?
1:26:55 I'm going to ask a question. I'm going to preface it with the average cost of a home in Clermont is upwards of four to $500,000 now today.
1:27:05 And we've four to six four to six. Okay, that only proves my point further. We've grown more in the
1:27:12 last 10 years than we did in the 10 years prior, which means Clermont is filled with people who have the
1:27:21 intelligence, resources or jobs that can afford them those houses and these people are leaving Clermont.
1:27:30 So that's causing traffic. So my question is, do we have a way in your research
1:27:38 of knowing what are those jobs that 26,000 residents are leaving the city to
1:27:45 go to and can we attract those jobs to the city so that people don't have to get on 15 and 27 to go to those jobs? Do we
1:27:55 know what those are the hospitality
1:28:04 and I'm hearing lots. I hear what you're saying, Mr.
1:28:06 But can we verify that with the research? Oh, that's that's my question. Yeah, that that's good question.
1:28:13 And that's that's very your qu I hear what you're saying. My question to that is the fact that uh go back to how much
1:28:20 land do we control? How much property do we control in this city? Where do you have the land to be able to put
1:28:27 industrial and and commercial that would attract that kind of question is, is that accurate? Have we been able to
1:28:34 verify why, what jobs it is people are leaving Clermont to go to? Have we done a study? Have we done a survey? Is there any way of knowing what these jobs are that have people leaving Clermont?
1:28:44 Does anybody know? The easy answer. Yes.
1:28:51 is the number one visited location in North America and argillion.
1:29:13 It's the space coast. It's all the other wonderful things about 70 million plus. We surpassed city years ago.
1:29:21 I always joke in the great financial crisis in 2008, you know how many people from around the world came on vacation
1:29:28 was over 40 million. So the answer where they're going serviceoriented jobs,
1:29:36 they're the hotels, they're the convention centers, it's it's all the entertainment, the Disney World, the the Universal Studios.
1:29:44 And then the second largest employer was my wife's employer, Advent Those two have employed over a 100,000
1:29:54 now. Thankfully we've supported I've sat last time I came in the city of homeless when I supported the emergency hospital to come on to 50 much to the chagrina
1:30:02 Clermont didn't want to have another hospital here but lo and behold we needed that one. So now there's a lot of
1:30:10 great jobs here I'm healthy living is minimize the traffic as Nate said I
1:30:17 don't know we can create as much But we're starting with healthare. We're starting with some other ideas.
1:30:23 I'm all about this healthy living that involves the neighborhood centers because besides going back and forth to work, we're now
1:30:32 spending so much time just going to go and use
1:30:40 my little zone 3 mile radius as much as possible. So I'm selfishly looking forward to the south if we can control the annexation.
1:30:52 We can control this town.
1:30:54 Yeah, thank you. Uh but that's part of the answer there. The other thing is a lot of the jobs with
1:31:01 people I talk to going out is more in industry and other type of industry. So do we have the capability to provide
1:31:08 that that kind of uh job opportunities here? I mean that that's where the conversation comes in too though.
1:31:15 It's not about big industry. Yeah.
1:31:18 It's about the small business entrepreneurial development. This is where all these things come together.
1:31:22 Like the comp plan is a long game holistic approach to how our city grows.
1:31:28 So none of it is going to be easy. No, some of it may not be intuitive. Some of it may go the slow way so we can get further eventually. And that's what I
1:31:36 think of with some of the stuff like whether it's town centers or the the kind of business plan which the entrepreneurial aspect is not
1:31:43 represented in the four big principles of the comp plan I noticed but um in my mind that's where it all it all fits together like this is we need to work
1:31:51 towards something we have to accommodate growth somehow and we can't keep doing it how we've always been doing it and these town centers are real opportunities but it's along it has to
1:32:00 be alongside of it wouldn't happen overnight you start with the comp plan then you have the code and then everything on top of it that's true
1:32:08 and it's big picture and it's a lot of different inputs is all working towards that. So and I think one of the big concern of
1:32:15 course one of the concerns that I always had is what can we do a job opportunity to bring the people back bring our people back here and to keep the people
1:32:24 off the road work right here in the area to live the work and play area. So that's that's to me is the biggest biggest thing we need to be looking at
1:32:32 and trying to figure out that piece of I think that's been a part of some of the conversation but it could be better represented maybe through the comp plan.
1:32:38 I don't know if that's the appropriate vehicle for it, but I think that's huge. The the town center concept.
1:32:45 I don't know if I should say polyentric city. I want to be coached on it. So, I'm saying the right thing, but
1:32:52 if that's I mean, we're the ones who need to weigh in on this, everybody in this room. And I think that we owe it to
1:33:01 each other and we owe it to the design team. If we have questions, concerns or comments about that theory, to me,
1:33:09 that's I heard two things that were significant. One is your current code doesn't match your your comp plan. We knew that. Okay, so we're fixing it. But the other is this polyentric city to
1:33:17 help address traffic. That requires density.
1:33:21 That's going to be something we all need to be on the same page about because we're the ones talking to the public and
1:33:27 communicating this. So, I mean, I think I feel like I'm at a wedding. Speak now and forever hold your peace. It's kind of where I'm at on it because I think
1:33:35 that this is a big deal and I don't want to get a month from now when we're coming to the final and I say, "Well, we didn't think about it or we changed our
1:33:42 minds or we can change our minds, but if there's something we know today, I think it's we we owe it to each other to talk about it today." Could I point out the
1:33:49 obvious if I may speak real quick? Okay, the mayor hit on something which I believe I'm in agreements with
1:33:58 and think about it. You're talking about Disney. You're talking about the attraction parks. Okay. What are they really paying, right?
1:34:06 Okay. They're not paying that much. So, exactly on his page, bring that pay scale to Clermont.
1:34:16 Okay. Now, do we have the room for it?
1:34:19 That's why we're here. But just to say we got traffic because of Disney, they're going. I I I don't buy that. I'm
1:34:27 sorry. I just don't buy that. I think it's just over. It's too much density. It really is.
1:34:35 Okay. And that's the way I agree because I'm I sat here and I'm listening.
1:34:40 Disney, Disney, Disney. I know this. I know what Disney pays. Trust me, I could get better jobs if I go to Orlando.
1:34:50 That's what it's really about. So, let's bring that market like he wants to do to
1:34:57 Well, well, I just I want to point out the obvious. I'm sorry.
1:35:02 Yeah, you're right. And as I think I said before, you're right about the uh medical industry. That is one of the better playing pay playing paying
1:35:10 industries right now. And so yeah, I got crucified. But when we, as he said, when we brought Advent Health in here, a lot of people didn't like it.
1:35:18 But I saw his job opportunity. That's one of the things I look at all the time. And one of the things I'm really I'm so thrilled about Olympus about all
1:35:27 the commercial down there and the job opportunities that is supposed to be bringing, especially in the medical area. You know, when I heard they like
1:35:34 got 175,000 square feet of medical building that's already been proposed down there, that excites me because that's good pay. When I know Advent
1:35:42 Health on 250 acres down there, that excites me because I'm envisioning them putting another hospital down there very
1:35:49 soon. I know it have to it going to be 2030 before they do it because because there's a what's that? Cell [clears throat] phone tower on the piece
1:35:58 of property and they and the lease don't run out until 2030. But then when I talk to Advent Health, every time I talk to them, that's same thing I have. When you
1:36:07 gonna release the fact that you gonna put a hospital down because I'm trying to encourage that because that's good paying and with our senior population here, medical is very important.
1:36:19 Can I go to the to the town center? I think what the town center supports is an entrepreneurial economy. There's many businesses that want to come downtown
1:36:26 right now. it is the only central place for business and this would allow other centers that people can easily access.
1:36:33 So I think you know we're talking to the future. We're really looking long in the future. I mean I I disagree with with some of the comments. I think you know the the big people right now they it is
1:36:41 it's Disney. It's universal. It's advent it's it's those people now but communities that are trying to have sustainable growth across the country
1:36:49 are trying to have entrepreneurial economies. I just went to Fort Collins Colorado a couple weeks ago and it's an entrepreneurial economy. They support
1:36:57 local. They they don't want to go to chains. They want to go to local places and you need to have pockets for them. So, I think it's it's looking visionary.
1:37:05 It's in the future. We can't recreate. We're not going to have a Disney here.
1:37:09 We're not going to have and they're they're very active in our community.
1:37:11 They do a lot in our community because this is where they're and we're not trying to take away from that. But I think in the long range, if we're building for the future, we need to have
1:37:20 these pockets that we can serve this growing population. And just having one downtown center probably as we continue to grow isn't going to cut it. So, I
1:37:27 think it's it's very important to have these these town centers and have different places that the entrepreneurial economy can exist.
1:37:35 On that note, Marina is uh we talked about small town feel I remember saying, but was small business part of the comp plan?
1:37:44 I don't remember seeing Yeah. I mean, you know, yeah, you know, too often we speak about affordable housing in smaller units, we
1:37:53 tend to forget to speak about smaller workspaces, too. And, you know, your downtown is is has um has a lot of good things going for it. So, for example,
1:38:01 you have very very small plots that can redevelop virtue of the fact that, you know, for example, they don't have to provide their parking on site
1:38:09 um etc. So the small the so enabling small workspaces too is as important as uh affordable housing and and the code
1:38:17 was going to make that much easier to do.
1:38:20 So that's already contemplated at the code. Yeah.
1:38:23 In in the comp plan in the comp in the comp plan one of the seven uh principles they had in the beginning was an independent and diversified local economy.
1:38:33 Okay. So it just wasn't prominently.
1:38:35 I just needed it to be done down. Thank you.
1:38:37 I and I think if we think about downtown it's I absolutely agree with the the different centers. The downtown is also
1:38:45 our tourist area and also our event area. So, it's a uniquely distinct town center where the one public 50 and 27
1:38:54 that Citrus Tower area that's a service center that serves the community. It's it's not walkable. If you're on the east
1:39:02 side of on the west side of 50, you want to use the downtown area, but it's it's about
1:39:10 I'm glad we're not going after a whale because I we don't we don't need a whale. When when when people depend on a
1:39:17 Disney and Disney goes south, everybody's real hungry. And so with this, we can take part a lot better. But
1:39:25 have five different city centers, but our downtown I always think of as our it's it's it's our photograph opportunity. It's our events. It's how
1:39:34 we promote us. You know, it's the gem of the hills. But the one down near fences area go down uh towards
1:39:42 the hand and so on. Those serve the community. I have a shopping center doctors get my nails done, get my hair done, all those things and I don't I can
1:39:51 walk, drive, bicycle and I have and I say I agree with the town centers
1:39:58 and everything and I think she mentioned in her presentation is the fact that Climouth was originally built on that philosophy. Okay. Right out there in the
1:40:07 same area that we talking about when Dixon everything, we had our little town centers and everything when I grew up here. Okay. We changed our codes, our
1:40:15 ordinance and got away from that. We took out our little stores and mom and pop stores and everything in the community. Right. Yes. We used to have mom and pop stores in the community. And that's what I've been saying all along.
1:40:24 That's was built on that phil most cities in the country was built on that philosophy. Period. Strong times philosophy. And somewhere back there, we
1:40:33 changed our concept and our philosophy and start putting homes all out there creating traffic problems and all this here because now they go get a loaf of
1:40:41 bread, you got to drive five mile, right?
1:40:43 Okay. Where it used to be when I grew up, my mom say you need low bread. I ran around to the corner store in two minutes, came back with a loaf of bread. Okay.
1:40:50 So, I agree with the concept, but my my question is we talk about keeping people off the road. How big of a town center
1:40:58 that we going to be able to put out there and get well enough paying jobs that we can support thousands and thousands of people in that in that center? That's why I'm saying not just
1:41:07 the town center. We have to develop some kind industrial somewhere else along the way to help support these people because you're not going to build a town. You
1:41:15 can take downtown as you mentioned as a town center. How many people you got employed in the downtown area?
1:41:21 Well, I think if we're if we're spreading it out like they're proposing, I mean, that's a lot. That's a lot of investment. That's a lot of
1:41:29 business space. It's a lot of commercial space. I mean, I think this is very ambitious. Yes.
1:41:35 Um I'm interested. You said something, Tim, that makes me wonder. Is there because I know we're going to see
1:41:42 pictures of the historic downtown and we saw water and that was very cool. Um is
1:41:49 there anything related to or could we get or do we want something related to each of these neighborhood centers, town
1:41:56 centers, because I hear the words and I see the map, but I I'll tell you when I see the picture of Waterbrook, I think, well, my daughter would like to live
1:42:04 there. She just moved out and she'll be moving there. Sorry, she'll be leaving your neighborhood, but you know, that's where she would choose to live as a
1:42:11 young adult. And and I think it would help people have a better understanding, myself included, if we could see what
1:42:20 each of these spaces potentially could look like. And when we start talking about density, I don't think when we use that word, it is like development. Those
1:42:28 two D words are like cuss words in Clermont. But if we can say, well, I like this map a lot.
1:42:35 And if we could say, here's a a cross-section of what that one might look like and here's a cross-section of what that one might look like.
1:42:41 Another way of asking it might be, what's the closest analog? I mean, are there what's the closest example to what's being proposed here?
1:42:49 the villages. I didn't hear anyone say the village.
1:42:53 I mean, I I don't know. I'm curious like we're talking about creating the squares DPZ things because
1:43:02 on those slides there were a bunch of cities named Excuse me.
1:43:08 Whoa, whoa. I got too many conversations going at once. I can't hear. Okay, go ahead.
1:43:12 Well, no. I'm just curious because I did see on a bunch of the slides there were a lot of different communities that were for the different densities and types of
1:43:20 but I'm curious are there like in in terms of DPZ's vision for what this could look like are what's the closest
1:43:27 analog that it has seen I love that question we can provide imagery that helps to sort of visualize
1:43:36 what these different range possibility it's huge range huge continuum historically the towns grew from you like a small
1:43:44 little hamlet to a village to a town to Manhattan, you know, in some cases. Uh,
1:43:52 and there's sort of everything along the spectrum. But it's not just big town centers. A neighborhood center can just be a corner store if that helps take
1:43:59 care of a few of your daily needs. Not maybe every daily needs, but if you don't have to drive five miles to get a gallon of milk, right? But the mixed use when I when I
1:44:08 was in Colorado, I visited Prospect New Town, which was one of the first ones BPZ worked on. And it's the it's the mixed use. It's not just it's not all retail. There's offices there. There's
1:44:17 everything that supports it. It's kind of what you see downtown. I mean, you have you have the attorney and the architect. You have all these different things and they all they all come together and that's why you need the reset.
1:44:28 Let me try to answer it real quick.
1:44:29 There's different flavors of what a town center or neighborhood center can be.
1:44:34 Okay? And one example would be DBZ did the first what they call suburban retrofit of a just a strip mall that was
1:44:41 built what in the late 50s uh called Mashby Commons okay up in Mashby Massachusetts. Okay so that's an example
1:44:50 where you take an existing shopping center and they were figuring out what should we do different and they said why don't we be more like the charming town
1:44:58 sen village centers that we have in New England and so that's been very popular.
1:45:02 Then you have another case where they had a suburban road going through Huntsville, Alabama, and it was connecting different subdivisions, but there was a little area they could do.
1:45:12 DBZ did that plan where they uh created a village center that then morphed, even though they designed it as a three-story
1:45:21 uh area, now it's up to eight stories, and it's become a real hub in Huntsville, Alabama that's very uh growing very quickly. Um then you have
1:45:29 smaller ones that are more let's say that were also new that they've designed
1:45:35 like in Herssham uh that is an amenity to the surrounding rural area there or
1:45:42 you go to a place like a resort like you've been to you know place like Rosemary Beach and they do a main street it's it's in a new place so there are
1:45:50 all different varieties and sizes but you have to the design uh you know for the context is what's critical in other
1:45:58 words we could have horrible town centers or good ones, but it's going to come down to how you ultimately design.
1:46:06 Yeah. So, for purposes of moving us on, the way that I heard Christian's question and for note takingaking for
1:46:13 the final draft that comes to us, it would be I would very much appreciate if each of these town center neighborhood centers had
1:46:22 one to three examples of what that might look like based on what's already there with the with the inventory that DPZ has
1:46:31 at its disposal of all the things that have been done. As we look at each one of these, some of them are green fields,
1:46:38 some of them are retrofit, suburban sprawl repair, like what would be examples so that we're not having to
1:46:45 wait for drawings, but we have pictures for imag.
1:46:54 Yes. Yes, I'm still here. I I wonder whether it would just be worth you showing some of the we did 10 special area plans.
1:47:02 They kind of take a whole range of different uh possibilities within within Clermont and we show what what you could do, right? Yes. So that when we get the the
1:47:10 draft, I would love for that to be included. Yeah. I think that's very reasonable.
1:47:16 Yeah. I mean, you had a design for three sisters and you had a design for the section there. You had another design for you. You had questions.
1:47:26 Well, I there is data to go back to the data point. The Orlando Business Journal,
1:47:33 every every time that comes out, there's data [clears throat] about industry, employment, where people are going, where it's being built. Lead has data.
1:47:43 Lake County, I've heard them present Lake County Economic Development. when they talk about the what is it 70% leave
1:47:49 the county for uh work there's data as to where they're going um so we have
1:47:56 traffic data um I also think that a lot of this
1:48:02 really comes to a shifting focus Clermont was
1:48:09 I've heard Nathan Mr. Norris uh talk a lot in the in the community meetings about what did Clermont used to grow?
1:48:18 Clermont used to grow tomatoes and then Clermont grew citrus and then we started growing residential homes.
1:48:27 But what is our next chapter? Like for the longest time I think that there was a general maybe begrudgingly
1:48:36 but a general acceptance that we are a residential community that we don't we don't have what it takes or maybe we don't want to be or whatever the reason.
1:48:47 I'm not passing judgment on that. But I think there was just this impression that we weren't the place where people worked. We were the place where people lived. It was safe.
1:48:58 And I think that's not bad, but we have to acknowledge the fact that if we want to
1:49:07 be something different than that, that's a shift in focus.
1:49:12 That that's actually a I've talked a lot about maturity and maturing as a city.
1:49:18 That's a that's a that's a hey, are we really leaving behind that grungy look maybe that we had when we were in the8s?
1:49:27 and 90s and we're moving into a little bit preppier look with our apparel or you know kind of you know when you're
1:49:35 growing up you kind of do that you like what you look what I wore when I was 18 is not what I wear now at 51 and so our our Clermont
1:49:44 30 years ago may not be where we want to be Clermont today or in 30 years but how do we get there what does what does that take to acknowledge
1:49:53 that shifting focus the other piece what do you see the the the um we also have some
1:49:59 opportunities to capitalize on this entrepreneurial uh and small business uh um uh small
1:50:08 small business capital of the world. Um I still haven't trademarked that. Um you know some ways to do that but also to be
1:50:16 complimentary to what's around us. We don't have to have Orlando has all of these coming and budding Michelin star restaurants.
1:50:25 Tampa is getting being a restaurant scene. It's not just Miami anymore. But where are the incubators for those?
1:50:35 I I don't know that there is one.
1:50:37 Could we if that was something we wanted to do? Could we do something that would be complimementaryary to that that would put us on map that complements what else
1:50:46 is going on, doesn't compete, it complements.
1:50:49 Um and we have three of the four Lake County economic development zones with spitting distance of our downtown.
1:50:59 Uh Ford Park in Groveland, Minnola Turnpike and Wellness Way.
1:51:05 No other area in Lake County has that luxury of having that within our arms reach. What could we do to capitalize
1:51:13 and complement and build upon that? I don't think it's necessarily incumbent upon us to do it all. I think it's a way
1:51:20 for us to just frame or think about and then if we are turning a in terms of that next chapter. It was tomatoes, it was citrus, it was houses. What's next?
1:51:32 How do we engage the public and share that and sell that so that we all get energized by and want to help
1:51:40 collectively turn that page to that extent? I don't have an answer with that, but that's just what I'm hearing and and and thinking about as we as we work this.
1:51:51 Okay.
1:51:52 Well, um Well, there was one one concern I had in our presentation. I think if correct me
1:52:01 if I'm wrong, but I think I heard you say parking to one uh change it to one per unit.
1:52:08 No, no, I didn't say that. I said it the density will the density parking is just a um a determinant of density. So, uh
1:52:17 Ben can speak to what the parking requirements are in the code, but we're not suggesting that you that it gets changed. I'm just saying that the it's a it's a metric that impacts entity.
1:52:28 That's all.
1:52:29 No, I was just I thought I heard you say uh in course some of the units of diagram you show you show one unit I showed examples.
1:52:38 Yeah, I showed examples but but I was Yeah.
1:52:42 Yeah. That just concerned me when you start talking about one because nine times out of 10 these days, you know, uh most homes going to have five and six
1:52:50 cars. So where the rest stop parking on the streets and and clogging up our streets and everything. See which is which is one of the other thing
1:52:57 I I say to people all the time back in my day I I mean I'm from a family of 12 mother and father 14 of us in the hospital we only had one car to get around. Okay.
1:53:07 Now today in my house today I got four or five and we got five cars. So, so parking is one of the things I really
1:53:16 want to uh I hope we really address in this thing because I want to be able to like well when I go in some of these
1:53:24 subdivisions now and I see people park their SUV or whatever right up to the garage door and they still overhanging the uh sidewalk. That is a concern to me
1:53:33 because then you got narrow streets and they can't park on the street. So the parking issue is one of the things I think we really need to look at in in
1:53:40 our in our comprehensive plan. So okay, the the parking is looked at in your zoning code, not in your comprehensive plan, just to be clear.
1:53:50 Yeah. But other than that, anybody else have anything else before we we move on?
1:53:55 Uh yes, because we do have the uh the downtown
1:54:03 activation, ma'am. But I know you you What is it? It's about 2:00 in the morning or so over there where you are.
1:54:09 Oh my goodness. [laughter] Not quite. Not quite. Not quite. I was happy to to present. Okay. Thank you, Marina.
1:54:17 I'm I'm going to try to stay up and listen to Ben's presentation, but thank you for your time. Well, thank thank you, ma'am.
1:54:24 Thank you.
1:54:30 [laughter]
1:54:40 That's something that's okay. Uh the downtown activity plan.
1:54:49 Who's handling this one? Mr. Oh, you're handling that, too. Okay.
1:54:54 This is the last thing on the agenda, though. Yes, sir.
1:55:01 [clears throat]
1:55:08 the microphone.
1:55:12 All right, I'll try to speak loudly if any not just let me know. He has one.
1:55:19 All right. So, um I'm Ben Northrup and I'll be I'm with DPZ project manager for the formbbased code and for the downtown
1:55:28 action plan and I'll be presenting our work on the Clermont downtown Clermont action plan. So, it'd be handy for
1:55:35 everyone to make sure you have a view of the screen.
1:55:40 Is this like the comprehensive plan where we're going to get it later?
1:55:44 Yeah, I mean I I'm going to present feel free to interrupt and have questions, but I think it probably would be good to get through, you know, maybe we'll keep the questions short.
1:55:52 So, u and keep it moving.
1:55:54 Before you start, let me just throw this at Mr. Mr. Wayne, we got to do something about putting the screen up here so we don't have to be turning around.
1:56:02 Thank you on that, sir.
1:56:05 No, I'm talking about you sit up here. I know uh they had the TV taken out because it was always inconvenient to me.
1:56:15 You're right. So right.
1:56:19 All right. So uh DPZ has been engaged to, as you know, to come up with a a new downtown action plan. This is in connection with the uh CRA.
1:56:32 Um so the the the presentation will consist of two parts. An introduction where we just kind of give the context.
1:56:38 you're familiar with it, but we we just want to reassure you that we've looked broadly at the at the city and engaged quite a bit. And if there are holes,
1:56:47 there things were missing, by all means, let us know. And the the main the real meat of it is part two is the vision.
1:56:53 And then we'll we'll talk about the sort of five big [clears throat] goals. We'll share our master plan, which is the kind of drawn document of the whole thing.
1:57:02 and then we'll describe a bunch of broad initiatives that kind of cover the whole CRA and then a bunch of specific area plans and then just a brief word on sort of implementations.
1:57:13 So part one introduction uh context um the area that we're talking about is
1:57:20 this right here. So it's it's not the entire northwest quadrant. It's the boundaries of the CRA which I assume you're fairly familiar with.
1:57:31 And there you have it. That's the boundaries of the CA CR. And the thing that's to sort of note about it is that it clearly involves all of what you
1:57:39 could what you consider downtown. It also involves most of the waterfront.
1:57:45 And the plan in 2015 was called the downtown and waterfront master plan. And if you look historically, the boundaries were expanded at some point to include
1:57:53 both sides of 50. So it's really from 50 to the lake.
1:57:58 And we certainly brought up should should our study be a different different boundary and there's no real compelling reasons to change the
1:58:06 boundary. So we're sticking with the current CRA boundary. But that is ultimately enough question for you to decide.
1:58:14 Um, now you you you already know more than anybody else about the CRA, so I don't have to go into sort of detail, but the
1:58:22 CRA obviously has a mandate to uh to to redevelop and reinvigorate downtown and has a number of funding mechanisms to do
1:58:31 so. And it it sounds like it's obligated every so often to come up with a new plan. And uh that's why we're here. you
1:58:38 had a very good plan in 2015 and we'll talk about that in a few minutes and how much was achieved and why it's time for a new plan.
1:58:47 Uh and the CRA is very active with storefront renovations.
1:58:51 Um and and then there's Clermont Main Street is a very active partner in this representing a lot of businesses and
1:58:58 other stakeholders downtown um and hosting all kinds of regular events that we're aware of. the farmers market, the
1:59:05 wine stroll, the uh the food trucks, a lot of great activity.
1:59:11 Um, and then the stakeholder engagement that's been part of our process. We're, as you're well aware, we're sort of building on the work that we've been
1:59:18 doing and continue to do with the comp plan and the form based code. So, lots of visits to Clermont. I'm I'm quite a regular on the bright line now. Uh,
1:59:27 which I enjoy. I actually have to say I really enjoy it.
1:59:29 And, um, and we had a sharet which I think you all participated in and were were aware of. Uh that was specifically
1:59:37 focused on the form-based code and the comp plan, but it's all so interrelated and so much of the focus is on downtown anyway that we learned a lot has really
1:59:44 informed our work on the downtown action plan.
1:59:50 Okay, so existing conditions um our first thing to do was to come up with our base map. This is not the ma the master plan. The master plan is based on
1:59:57 this. This is this this is the state of Clermont in the CRA as it stands today. And this required a fair amount of work.
2:00:05 Uh you know you nowadays with GIS you can get building footprints but different databases have very different information. So sort of synthesizing
2:00:13 that trying to fill in the gaps and then uh figuring out what the uh existing conditions are in the actual streetscapes within the rights of ways
2:00:22 is a helpful document to actually make concrete proposals.
2:00:27 Uh there's the core downtown you centered on mantros and the surrounding blocks where it's really kind of kind of main street. There are residential
2:00:36 neighborhoods on on all sides and parks and the lakes. Um there there's neighborhoods to the east and
2:00:44 neighborhoods to the west. Um I don't have to describe all this to you. You're very familiar with it. Um
2:00:52 and a really important aspect of course is the lakes, the large lakes, minhaha, but also all the small lakes which
2:00:59 really give such a distinctive character in conjunction with the hilly topography and you have a lot of nice parks.
2:01:07 uh the historic village records you know kind of historic building types that existed in the area and uh one one of
2:01:14 the projects that was um came out of the the 2015 plan was to celebrate entry off of SR50
2:01:23 um all right so our then our analysis of the existing conditions one of the first things we always do is pedestrian sheds you know classically it's a five minute
2:01:32 walking radius which you can see in the upper right corner that's about as far as most people will just sort of kind of intuitively just sort of walk to meet
2:01:40 the daily need without getting in their car. If it's beyond five minutes, you tend to hop in your car.
2:01:46 So, uh so the the downtown area is equivalent of like two or three pedestrian shifts.
2:01:54 So, it's eight blocks. What's that? Three blocks basically.
2:01:57 Well, it's a five minute walk, which is a quarter mile. Like like if you look from here Oops.
2:02:06 Like like take this for example like from that center to there is a quarter mile which is a five minute walk because
2:02:14 like people walk about three miles per hour 20 20 minutes per mile five minutes is a quarter mile give or take and and you see it's six walks wide at the heart of the downtown.
2:02:24 Yeah.
2:02:25 Well and also from the waterfront park to downtown which has always been our issue.
2:02:29 So 10 minutes it's 10 minutes now. Okay.
2:02:34 Five minutes is really sort of a kind of a metric for sort of meeting daily needs. People will walk much further if it's great walk. If you're like on a a
2:02:43 great street and you just don't who's been to New York City and you walk like 20,000 steps and you don't realize until the end of the day if you create a
2:02:52 walkable environment where people will walk.
2:02:58 Um so on the left here is uh what we call probably a frontage quality analysis.
2:03:05 Just basically assessing um what is the quality of the front of the building spacing the public realm because that
2:03:12 really determines a lot uh how walkable an area is. And it's very strong here along Montro that that one block of
2:03:20 Montros is very strong. Elsewhere, there are a lot of sort of missing teeth, parking lots, demolished buildings,
2:03:28 empty lots, and you know, they've done studies, but but but you can observe this yourself that like
2:03:36 people just stop walking as soon as they get to an empty lot. Like like people will walk basically from there to there.
2:03:43 Unfortunately, well, fortunately, your lakefront is only two blocks away, but there are a lot of holes along the way, a lot of
2:03:50 parking lots and um you can see the water, which is a big attraction, but just but it's hard to get people to go there unless the frontage quality is
2:03:58 good. So part of uh all the efforts like especially in the formbbased code is to require buildings to make good frontages
2:04:06 with visible front doors and adequate glass and I mean basic things that everyone got right 100 years ago without any rules and not being told what to do
2:04:14 but now we live in a very different world and we have to sort of code for it if you want to. Uh on the right is a
2:04:22 property aggregation analysis. It's just sort of a study of like the ownership of property and looking into sort of
2:04:29 aggregation of a larger lots. Um and and actually uh downtown Clermont still has quite a
2:04:37 kind of diversified um ownership which is you know great for entrepreneurial efforts
2:04:44 but but but large aggregations also afford opportunities as long as the form of the building is done well and that's where the form based coach can really kind of guide and protect.
2:04:55 All right. So, now I'll just talk briefly about opportunities and challenges. I won't go into uh detail on these because a lot of them are pretty
2:05:03 obvious, but one of your greatest uh opportunities is the extensive lakefront along Lake Bonola and it's close proximity to downtown. I mean that I
2:05:11 mean there there are a lot of great downtowns in Lake County, but Clermont is unique in having that proximity to the water and yet the connections need
2:05:19 to be strengthened. And so a lot of what we're talking about is how to connect mantros down to the water. Um, another opportunity is just the picturesque
2:05:27 hills and lakes. Uh, Reena spoke a lot about that and u what morning to be said it's beautiful.
2:05:35 Um, another great opportunity is that you now have a reinvigorated core downtown which as I understand it has really happened in the last 10 years or so. So you've made huge progress.
2:05:46 There's still a lot of potential and a lot more to do but you have a but that's a real good basis to start with. And
2:05:53 then recreation and athletics. I mean the the the choice of champions and all the athletic pursuits of all varieties is a real opportunity for for Clermont.
2:06:05 Um the coast to coast trail I mean goes right through town and there's a lot of talk about how it's the middle of that town. It's called the South Lake Trail
2:06:13 where it passes through. Uh, one thing that you might not focus so much on is the walkable grid that you have a street
2:06:20 network and for and for what you want to do that is a huge blessing. Um,
2:06:28 the advantages are, you know, are countless. One of them just at at a merely aesthetic level is just that the straight streets of the grid really show
2:06:37 off the topography really well. Um you you you really feel the beautiful hills with the straight roads that go sort of
2:06:44 up and down. But just it provides alternative routes, uh alternative interesting routes. Um you know, if there's a little flood around uh Center
2:06:53 Lake, no problem. There are probably a million other ways to get around.
2:07:00 Okay. Challenges. One of the biggest is management. uh the the ground is is this
2:07:07 cared geology and it's extremely porous and the water goes straight down. It's so interesting to see all these little lakes without creeks running in and out.
2:07:16 Uh the water for the most part water just sort of seeps straight down into the aquifer and so as a result your your storm water treatment requirements are
2:07:25 very strong and you have to set aside a lot of land for for treating it and that's understandable why that is the case. But it it definitely that that
2:07:33 that's sort of an invisible barrier to development. We have some thoughts about that. Another one is lack of shade and shelter. You know, if we're encouraging
2:07:42 walkability, it it's got to be safe, comfortable, and interesting. And a big a big part of that is shade and shelter.
2:07:50 Um actually, when we were here last time, it broke out in the rain. And walking along the south side of the block of Montro, you can actually make it most of that one block under the
2:07:59 cover. That's the only block, but you can sort of avoid the rain. Um, underperforming furniture, we already talked about, you know, the the blank
2:08:08 walls, uh, lack of windows and doors, you know, there places that could be, uh, improved.
2:08:16 Um, challenges, uh, we we'll talk a little bit about the parking studies that were done. Um, parking, uh, poses a
2:08:24 challenge, although maybe not in the way that people exactly. Uh, maintaining a family a family uh atmosphere is seems
2:08:34 to be sort of really probably more of a goal than a challenge.
2:08:38 All right. Uh the 2015 before we go into the new proposals, let's just reflect a little bit on the master plan for 2015
2:08:46 and completed projects. Here's the plan done by um GIA and um
2:08:55 there we go. And a lot of the we one of the first things we did is we did this um assessment of the projects and how
2:09:02 many have been sort of completed and not and not and it's remarkable how many things have been completed and it made a really positive impact on the city. uh
2:09:12 and the city has uh on its own website um a good sort of record of some of the major projects that have been completed.
2:09:20 And to highlight a few, one of the most significant is Victory Point, the transformation of Westlake into a storm water facility treatment that
2:09:27 facilitates uh development into downtown on a kind of a first come first- serve basis, which is really uh fantastic project and I think a model for how
2:09:36 Clermont could move forward. Um the the boat ramps uh relocating those and getting motorized vessels over on the east side I think was a really great
2:09:45 move has been very successful and uh the artwalk has been tremendous success um right at right at Montro a delightful connection heading towards the water.
2:09:58 All right and there and we're not the only ones studying Clermont and proposing things. There's a lot of there have been a lot of studies ongoing and there a number of other ongoing plans.
2:10:06 So just If there are any I've missed, please let me know. There quite a few. But, uh, FDOT has had numerous proposals along
2:10:13 SR50 uh, for improvement back, you know, about five or six years ago and for more ambitious proposals um, with a center
2:10:22 median. Now, they have a proposal uh, for for resurfacing. And we've kind of piggybacked on that and made some recommendations which we'll get into
2:10:29 later. There's the proposals for East Avenue, the complete street study, um, which is a a great proposal. how to make
2:10:37 that sort of overly wide street, you know, more usable by by by different modes of transportation and provide more shade.
2:10:46 Um, a lot on parking. So, there's already been KDson has done quite a bit.
2:10:52 There's this study of six existing parking studies and one of the first things we did is we looked again at those six sites and and made proposals
2:11:00 which which will share those. Not that anyone's saying you need a parking garage on all six sites, but what the parking structure look like on those
2:11:08 those sites helps you sort of evaluate whether which of those might be better or worse. Uh and and we're aware that at
2:11:16 this point it's in the hands of the uh the pigstack committee.
2:11:22 [laughter]
2:11:22 I'm not sure what that means, but parking garage technical special advisor.
2:11:33 [laughter]
2:11:34 Okay.
2:11:35 All right, we have another committee that pigstack.
2:11:43 It's the citizens committee.
2:11:46 There have been u controversial proposals like this one to put diagonal parking on Minnola which local residents strong came out against very strongly.
2:11:56 Uh in 2021 there was uh kind of growing consensus around building a parking garage uh south of the the the city
2:12:04 hall. And this uh larger parking study the conclusions are interesting and the um the fact of the matter is is that on
2:12:12 a dayto-day basis there is not currently a parking problem. There's parking there parking challenges during major events and then there's the long-term prospect
2:12:20 of as land that's currently leased for parking gets sold and redeveloped you lose supply and increased demand and so that's why there's thought about building sort of structured park.
2:12:35 Uh there's the meet in the middle park, a prop an ambitious proposal for a block between seventh and eighth on the waterfront with uh just about everything
2:12:43 you could think of, amphitheater, bathrooms, uh marina uh and veterans memorial.
2:12:51 And there and then there's the uh VAP study, the vision activation parks, recreation by uh Shane Fernandez
2:12:59 uh completed recently which was an assessment of um the parks facilities, access schools and made a lot of recommendations citywide but a fair
2:13:08 number
2:13:10 [music]
2:13:12 uh which we sort of pick up on uh and one of the most noticeable notable and I think the origin was his work that's
2:13:19 focusing on the uh chain of pearls which we'll talk more about. Uh Dix
2:13:27 Height is is working on proposals for link dot enhancements and uh I think the downtown uh Main Street Clermont has
2:13:35 been behind landscape plans for Montrose Avenue and a botanical garden around Center Lake. So there's a really a lot
2:13:42 of a lot of good efforts going on and then DPZ of course we don't need to say anything more about the comp plan. We just got a very thorough update on that
2:13:51 and uh Elizabeth Peter Ziver and I have been working in parallel on the formbbased code for the Northwest Quadrant
2:13:59 and you'll be hearing more about that I'm sure in the near future. All right, on to the vision.
2:14:06 All right, so downtown goals. Uh we sort of enumerated five and and and we want
2:14:13 your feedback and comments on on all of this. Um, goal number one is increase the vibrancy of downtown. And and
2:14:21 Nathan, if I miss anything, you're very good at articulating these. Um, uh, but that one I think is fairly
2:14:29 obvious. It's already a vibrant place, but there's potential for that to expand and grow into more. Uh, we we've also
2:14:36 heard a lot of interest in keeping it familyfriendly and not having being sort of overwhelmed with sort of large noisy bars.
2:14:47 and breweries and breweries and marijuana shops.
2:14:54 Uh goal number two and a lot of these are very interconnected. I mean they they really reinforce each other providing shade from the sun and shelter
2:15:02 from the rain. How how are we going to expect anyone to walk if you don't provide those things? Um, goal number
2:15:10 three, connecting the string of pearls, which is really about the greenways network and creating greenways uh to connect this wonderful string of small
2:15:19 lakes that you have, but really it's more it's part of a larger greenways network. And I'll show you that. Uh, goal number four, adding storm water
2:15:27 capacity. And we'll talk more about that. Victory Park is a great facility, but a lot of people are under the impression it serves all downtown. It
2:15:34 does not, and it's only a first come, first- serve basis. So if you want to grow in the kind of the healthy ways that you're talking about, that is kind
2:15:42 of an invisible impediment that needs to be addressed. We have a proposal for that. And uh goal number five,
2:15:49 coordinate the waterfront experience. Um I mean coordinating what actually happens on the lake is beyond the scope of this study, but that directly impacts
2:15:57 the waterfront and downtown. So it's worth thinking about those things in conjunction. And we have a few thoughts that I know many of you are working on ambitiously.
2:16:07 Um, all right. So, these graphics I'm not going to dwell on because the these are being edited and sort of fleshed out,
2:16:15 but those are just the five goals uh articulated more fully. Okay. So, the master plan um okay, first we start with
2:16:24 the existing conditions which we've already shown you and then this is what we're calling the proposed downtown master plan. So you can sort of flip
2:16:31 back and forth between those and see uh the the the brown are proposed
2:16:37 structures. Um and red is civic and the lighter color are sort of existed. So for the most part we're talk we're these
2:16:46 are and then we'll get into specific area plans where we sort of show what what what what these proposals are in
2:16:52 detail. Uh and um for the most part we're talking about sort of uh underdeveloped or or sort of empty land
2:17:01 or or or land that we aware of like somebody wants to develop or redevelop.
2:17:09 And there's kind of a zoom in so you can see it a little bit more clearly. And I I'll I'll describe what all these are.
2:17:16 Um, and there's uh the master plan just kind of simply showing uses for your reference. Red being commercial, yellow
2:17:25 and orange being different grades of residential and purple being civic.
2:17:30 So the red wouldn't have like residential on top.
2:17:33 No, it would these these are just ground floor uses. So almost everything we propose is mixed use.
2:17:39 So it gets it gets tricky to that's a good question because it gets tricky to identify what is that building really just commercial? So it's usually ground floor commercial.
2:17:48 Well, the ones that are red, but but but not all are commercial. All right. So in terms of the vision, uh some of the initiatives are broad initiatives that
2:17:57 apply to the whole CRA and some of them are specific area plans. First we'll talk about the broad initiatives.
2:18:03 Um okay, so the goal of connecting the string of pearls is really about a greenways network. And I'm sorry I
2:18:11 didn't get the image that had the the uh the if you can see there's a there green waves. Whoops.
2:18:21 Um, if you read the key, it's probably easier to see up close, which you'll get
2:18:28 to see when you get a copy. Um, but but there are greenways like this that create a network. And the
2:18:36 and the idea is to sort of create uh literally a network of of of ways that people can get comfortably either
2:18:44 walking, biking, golf carts, alternative means of trans transportation where shade and shelter are emphasized and and
2:18:52 the purpose of this is to help people meet their daily needs without getting in a car. Now, you're not going to meet your daily needs for every you by
2:19:00 walking for every need. But what what what if you can meet 50% of your needs by by by walking? Well, part of that is having good access. Now, one of the
2:19:09 great strengths of your downtown is this grid and and we selected streets that made sense. So, like you if you look at
2:19:16 the original plat um West Avenue, Lake Avenue, and Minnola were all 100 foot rightways. So those are just great opportunities for additional bike paths.
2:19:29 Um and then uh the greenways are all sort of a green dashed line and and the
2:19:36 chain of pearls has a kind of these little circles and and this is sort of proposal around Center Lake up and over
2:19:44 by Crystal Lake and actually continuing on and there's a team of people sort of investigating what what that might be and where it goes. Um, one thing I sort
2:19:53 of want to emphasize is that like you already have the South Lake Trail and other county trails which are a fantastic system of what I would call
2:20:01 kind of like recreational bike trails good for long distance exercise and some people certainly use them for commuting
2:20:09 and and sort of other uses. The greenways network is a complement to that and it's more smaller scale and more fine grain and it's not
2:20:18 the chain of pearls bike trail can be a destination for families but it's also part of a network that connects schools
2:20:26 to homes to business centers to all those places.
2:20:30 So that's an important sort of broad initiative is the greenways network that supports this connecting the string of pearls. Um oh and and this is I think
2:20:39 you've already seen Marina showed this to you and this is the greenways network at the scale of the city. So we we we
2:20:46 were looking Oops. We were looking specifically at this little area in the northwest in the downtown area, but
2:20:53 we're we're proposing uh a network throughout the entire city. It it it's easier to propose downtown because you
2:21:00 have this wonderful grid. Uh there's a lot of discontinuity and lack of connections to the rest of the city.
2:21:06 It's harder to pick those out and over time you might have strategic conversations with places like Kings Rich. Are you willing to have not a
2:21:14 place for cars to zoom through, but are you willing to let maybe some bicyclists and some pedestrians pass through to sort of increase the uh the greenways network?
2:21:26 [laughter]
2:21:31 We'll have to ask the president.
2:21:35 All right. And then uh another goal was adding storm water capacity.
2:21:43 So this diagram really shows you the existing uh it's kind of kind of catchment sheds. So you'll recognize um
2:21:53 this is Victory Point and it was taking advantage of the natural topography that drained into West Lake and and it had it
2:22:03 has an a connection out to Lake Mola which is a Florida protected water Florida outstanding water. very high
2:22:09 levels of uh of cleanliness are required and so they really did an amazing job transforming West Lake into Victory
2:22:18 Point and it provides uh storm water capacity. I think I'm holding these buttons. Okay. Um
2:22:27 for that area, but if you look at that boundary a little closer, that goes right down the middle of Mount Montro.
2:22:32 The whole south side of Montro is not in the Victory Point catchment basin. Nor is the Deoyos property.
2:22:39 So, uh the but but you can see that there are other existing other just natural
2:22:46 catchment castling basins. the these have not none of these others have been sort of studied and engineered in the way the victory point was, but they
2:22:54 could be they they they could be and as you want to grow, you may need to to consider that. So this this this next
2:23:01 diagram is a proposal specifically for Center Lake. So here you see Victory Point. And what does Victory Point
2:23:09 consist of? Well, you got the pond where where larger things settle out. You got the inundation marsh and what they call a filter marsh. And then this is the
2:23:17 outlet to Lake Minnola. So you're obligated to do all that and rightly so to to to clean the water. What about the
2:23:25 idea of reconfiguring center lake, keeping a big open body of water here for the same stages like an open pond
2:23:33 and then having your inundation mar your filter marsh and you already have a six inch pipe that lead that heads out west somewhere and you have to bring in a
2:23:41 pipe a truck to pump it. Why not put in a permanent larger pipe and a permanent station. The truth is is that you don't need it that often. Uh speaking to Jim
2:23:50 Mayworth in public services, uh water is only flowing out here very rarely.
2:23:56 Um and uh so I think you have something like 100 pumps already for sanitary.
2:24:04 Why not one for to enable this to have sort of be sort of a catchment basin?
2:24:08 And then you could treat Center Lake a lot a lot of the way that you do Victory Point. It has this sort of um bank of
2:24:16 that you could disperse on whatever basis you want, first come, first serve or other, you know, you ask for community benefits, uh, to to enable the kind of development that you want to
2:24:24 see. Otherwise, it's going to be quite hard um because the the the standard rule is that you handle storm water on
2:24:31 site and with the kind of rules you have around here, which are understandable, it's it's a bit hard to do. It might also be really good for Center Lake
2:24:39 because as lovely as Center Lake is, the water quality is not so great and it has some challenges. it could use some work
2:24:46 and um maybe it gets a little bit more of a natural treatment. It's such an important entry feature that I think it's important that it remain more than
2:24:55 it'll be a stormwater facility but it can be a beautiful one that's an entry to the city. So you've seen it's going to be kind of sketched in sort of more
2:25:03 naturalistic form rather you know like uh uh victory point is very jagged with these highly visible concrete walls.
2:25:11 Mayor you you want to say something?
2:25:13 Well, one I don't know if you looking maybe maybe it be I'm just throw this out at you look at center lake a little bit more because one of the problem we
2:25:21 used to have with center lake was flooding all the time. Yes. Okay.
2:25:25 Uh and that's why we somewhat did what we did not do catch basin. Yes. The water is very quality down there is
2:25:31 terrible very you know in terms of the flooding.
2:25:36 People told us about the flood and we walked around with people from the church and they showed us how far it came up to the center of the center line of of uh 8th street and we had several
2:25:45 thoughts about that. Well, one is I think in response to that the city had already installed that 6inch pipe and that could become a larger pipe and
2:25:52 pump. So, so, so flooding events might be less um frequent in the future. Um,
2:26:00 but one solution is is you can see these red hatched areas Those are elevation
2:26:07 98. If you just took those two that stretch of uh 8th Street and that stretch of West Avenue and raised it two
2:26:14 feet, uh you probably overcome most of your sort of flooding issues in terms of circulation on public streets.
2:26:20 The third thing I'd say is that you have a street grid which is highly resilient.
2:26:25 So unlike modern culde-sac subdivisions, you can actually drive around it. So if for uh a week or two the the these these
2:26:32 streets are flooded, it's not really the end of the world, especially given the local topography. Floods are really damaging when structures like interior
2:26:40 space are damaged. I mean, ripping out drywall and things like that is a nightmare. The buildings are all out of the flood range. So you're really just talking about the inconvenience of a
2:26:48 street that's blocked. But maybe a part of this whole sort of uh kind of re-engineering and beautifification of center lake is to address address the
2:26:57 flooding whether it's through pumping raising the street elevations but I think a big lesson to take away from u victory point is the pedestrian access
2:27:05 and having the nice paths that go around all the sides. I mean this should be really thought about not just as a stormwater facility. It is that
2:27:13 but as a park and an important part. Um, and just emphasize one thing. I don't think you said it, correct me if I'm wrong, but
2:27:21 St. John's, you know, who controls all this, right? They will tell you Center Lake is at capacity right now, right? So, you can't add to it.
2:27:29 So, adding the the the two feet to the street sounds like a lot, but when you start thinking about what the cost of Victory Point was, the cost of adding two feet is negligible.
2:27:39 Yeah. So, that's that's And Ben came up.
2:27:42 Yeah. Yeah. you could you could increase the capacity of it in a number of ways.
2:27:46 The interesting thing that I you know uh in Clermont is that the issue with storm water is not so much um
2:27:55 storing excess capacity as it is filtration and cleaning cleaning right you know um but you know if you look at
2:28:04 the 100redyear flood maps in Clermont it's pretty negligible although it's striking that clear that center lake is it seems to be the one place downtown that has that I'm aware of there may be
2:28:13 others but um some some flooding issues, but but they're relatively minor in the scheme of things. I mean, that's spoken from someone who does work down in
2:28:21 Miami. So,
2:28:24 [clears throat]
2:28:24 well, when they used to flood on a regular basis during the rainy season before we did all this work. Okay. So, it used to be much more regular.
2:28:32 Oh, yeah. It used to flood a lot before we did all the put in all the drainage and everything about it.
2:28:37 Well, were there any other lakes where No, the only other area we worried about I worried about flooding. I've seen a lot of flooding is Emerald I mean
2:28:46 Emerald Lake over here right outside come up went outside in dro mobile home park over there now that
2:28:54 still have a lot of flooding problems other than that those the two main are one thing I' I've heard from residents
2:29:02 who've been in Clermont a long time is that center lake used to be a bit more feel like the kind of the center of the community there used to be sort of events on the shoreline and um some of
2:29:10 those were sort of um diminished after I think all the swailes were installed. So I think it'd be good to really sort of I
2:29:18 mean the engineers need to do their thing and do a really good job but it needs to be under the direction of u someone looking after the design of it as a public space and as a public park.
2:29:29 So all the engineering needs to be done in the service of those goals.
2:29:37 Um this diagram on the left um is is is really about you know connecting I spoke
2:29:44 a little bit earlier about connecting the challenges of connecting Montros down to the lakefront. So Montro has these great frontages and a thought is
2:29:53 is really you know your lakefront should have great frontages. I mean, especially those two blocks there are such great opportunities for uh restaurants and
2:30:02 other places that really take advantage of amazing views looking out there. Um, but how do you connect down? And we have
2:30:11 a number of strategies to to do that, but one of them is making the end of each street an attractive destination that sort of draws you there. One thing
2:30:19 you have built in is just the views. So, we're all for planting trees, but maintain a view corridor at the end of
2:30:26 each street. So, the streets should be lined with trees, but make sure that you don't have trees blocking the view of the water. Um, and then the each street could have a sort of distinct character.
2:30:37 Like, for example, we have a proposal for like a waterfront plaza over here in West Avenue. You know, this is really more of a catalog
2:30:46 of techniques. So, so there's idea of a plaza, there's idea of a pier, possibly a building. Historically, there used to be some buildings. There could be a chapel or a meeting hall or something.
2:30:58 Long time ago used to have buildings like I think one one old police station used to actually sit out over the wall.
2:31:05 I've seen amazing photos. They're they're incredible. So, I mean that I mean why why not revive one of those?
2:31:12 Uh and then you the cardio challenge is a great way to uh terminate West Avenue.
2:31:17 So, so each street has kind of an identity as it approaches the water. Um, and then this diagram over on the right
2:31:25 is really about uh planning uh what happens on the lake, which as I said earlier is beyond the scope of this study, but we provide this just to sort
2:31:34 of simulate convers. It's based on conversations I've had with with residents. And one of the conversations was the possibility of relocating the
2:31:42 rowing course, which we're given to understand is somewhere over here. It used to end right the end of the 8 Street Pier. So, you could stand at the A Street Pier and watch the end of the races, which I thought was pretty cool.
2:31:51 I I rode a bit myself and I thought that was a pretty cool sort of public uh celebration of that moment. But, uh we
2:31:59 understand that the waters are a bit choppy and windy over here and maybe a rolling course would be better somewhere over on the on the west side. Maybe
2:32:07 maybe in fact, maybe a little bit better over here. And um and the idea of a boat house potentially even in Lake Hayawa.
2:32:17 Uh, and the existing boat house sounds like it have plenty of use with other sort of water sports. Uh, you've already taken the great move of moving motorized
2:32:26 boats over to the east side. So whether sailing boats or kayaks or other things could, you know, use the existing
2:32:33 structure and then uh the the a new rowing club potentially up here would have great views of uh the raceourse.
2:32:41 But it's it's a complicated thing. I think it needs to be sort of coordinated with all kinds of other users that we just don't know about. We've heard about wakeboarders and jet skiers and uh and
2:32:50 and and and and others. So, um but it does have a direct impact on how your shoreline gets used. So, it's worth thinking through.
2:33:00 Let me add just a little to it because you talked about it more at length. I think it's really cool. He was talking about if I want to go fish, where would
2:33:06 I want to go fish? That's a user. If I want to go take a a a picture uh of a sunset, like that's what you'll see a
2:33:15 lot of times right now just on the trail is people coming out, they drive down, they park, and then they get out and take pictures. They want to see a natural sunset behind them, you know,
2:33:24 and where do you do that? And so just coordinating between all those different users of the lake as opposed to always just looking at as a single thing is
2:33:32 what you said before. I think that's a great idea.
2:33:34 Yeah. I mean, you have such an amazing expansive lakefront and it just it deserves comprehensive planning and coordination and not everything has to be in sort of one location.
2:33:45 Um this is probably in the vulnerable places but we we we in this context we mentioned the the cardio challenge
2:33:54 uh at the end of uh I don't know if everyone's aware of that but it's it's a great proposal at the end of West Avenue. the rightway gets very steep
2:34:03 and it go it goes down to the lakefront and um this is sort of an artist's interpretation of what it would be. So
2:34:09 there's kind of like a um you know a stairway up and a stairway down and you you kind of challenge yourself or you know there's an app and you compare your
2:34:18 results to others but it could be a sort of great public space perhaps with some sort of public outlook overlook at the top.
2:34:25 Okay.
2:34:27 All right. So now we we we've looked at broad area initiatives. Now we're going to focus on some specific area plans
2:34:36 and this is uh this sort of calls out what these are. I know it's hard to read from where you are but um these are the six parking garage study sites.
2:34:47 Uh these are I think potential development sites. I can't even read it from here.
2:34:52 Uh these are like parks and public spaces and um proposals by others. So
2:35:01 we'll just walk through some of them. Um the first one we'll look at is what we're calling the West Avenue waterfront plaza. Just to back up, um right at the
2:35:11 end of West Avenue [laughter] and this prime waterfront location, you have a brand new surface parking lot. And we've heard a lot of people say that maybe
2:35:18 there's a better use for that spot. So this is a proposal. This is a this is an idea. And by the way, um these are all
2:35:26 very specific. It's up to you what you do. Uh we're trying to sort of paint a vision and give you an idea of of what
2:35:35 sort of Clermont could be, but we where well that each and every project needs to be sort of negotiated and figured out financial design at all different
2:35:43 levels. But we're trying to paint a picture. So maybe Waterfront Plaza is kind of where the city meets the lake
2:35:50 and uh there's like a a shared use plaza here with maybe a hotel and shops and restaurants here and it really opens up
2:35:59 a great view to the water. And maybe this there's there's been talk about how nice would be to have be able to bring a
2:36:06 a boat or pontoon boat or other downtown and have a meal. Maybe this is a great location to have sort of a marina. And you'll notice that we've kind of split
2:36:14 it so we keep a view open to the water and create like a little mini boat basin. This is not like a overnight marina. There's no uh gas station or
2:36:23 repairs. This is just for people for like kind of day trips temporary boat parking basically. And it's completely optional to the scheme. If people don't
2:36:30 like that idea, you could completely cut that out. And basically you've got the plaza and what we're calling like a prominade. And I I'm sorry that the
2:36:39 image is so slow, so so so small, but you you can study when you get the copies, but the uh the bike trail sort
2:36:47 of winds its way through here and um parking is is proposed on this sort of empty lot here. And we realize that this
2:36:55 is private land and uh this is certainly no kind of requirement, but it's a suggestion for a parking structure that's lined and and we think almost any
2:37:03 parking structure that's constructed should be lined with habitable use so you don't have parking which is such a killer to frontages and it could be accessed in the middle of the block
2:37:12 directly out over to the hotel. So actually you just go right out this way and connect through. And the other proposal, which may be hard to see in
2:37:19 this proposal, is that we're actually proposing to continue um what is this little street?
2:37:25 Well, no, but you start with Ocola wherever.
2:37:29 Yeah. So, so Oyola continues and C and connects here to this dead end street
2:37:36 because I my experience is always when I come to that corner of sort of Oyola west, there's like this turn and you feel like, well, that's kind of the end
2:37:44 of everything. I don't I don't know what's beyond there. um uh a street if handled properly. We're not talking about like a high speed, high volume
2:37:52 street, but a very pedestrian friendly street to connect this dead end over sort of OciOla. I think would really activate that corner and make it sort of
2:38:00 more accessible. And then you'll notice here behind this mixeduse building, this is maybe a three or four story mixeduse
2:38:08 building. There's service off the road and then these little structures could be popup retail. Like a good example is like at Carlton Landing, little small
2:38:16 individual structures that could be for kayak rentals or um or anything. Uh
2:38:23 kind of over on the edge of Victory Point Park. This is that structure that's like a stage and a storage
2:38:31 building there. Um what else can I point out? This this is all about sort of like West Avenue and it termination. This
2:38:39 you'll recognize is the go ahead is the is the current location of the post office. And what we're proposing is
2:38:46 maybe keep the post office there but redevelop it with parking but lined parking. So you have a parking structure
2:38:53 that's sort of hidden from the street and out on the corner could be a nice civic building that that's your new post office. So the post office just
2:39:01 literally moves to the corner and has a more civic presence. Right now the post office really doesn't do anything as a civic building. just kind of disappears.
2:39:09 But like it could be you could really sculpt the corner of that building and make it really a nice post office. Uh or
2:39:16 or not. It could just be retail or commercial or restaurants, what have you. And then you'll notice uh well, I'll talk about more when we get to 8th Street.
2:39:25 Um can you just clarify go back once just clarify quickly where the cars can go and can't go?
2:39:32 Well, the cars can go through this plaza, but What what what it is is it's called um it's like a shared use space.
2:39:42 It's it's a oneear and um what did you say?
2:39:46 It's called a werf. Werf. It's a Dutch term. Um w o n e r
2:39:54 werf and woo nerf.
2:39:56 Werf. I like that, you know. So like when you separate out with like painted lines, which of course is the typical condition, places for
2:40:05 cars, cars go as fast as they can and and pedestrians stay on the sidewalk and that's the way it is in most places and that's fine, but you can create these zones, these special zones. You don't
2:40:13 want to do it everywhere, but where it's a shared use space and if you pave it, um it's amazing how cars slow down and
2:40:22 accommodate pedestrians and becomes like a shared use space. So that's what we're proposing here in this West Avenue. So, so the hotel drop offs um and local
2:40:31 traffic would circulate that. That's clearly not like I mean you wouldn't want to do a winter on Route 50 or 27 or something like that, but this is out at
2:40:38 a corner where where there's there's uh it's close to the waterfront and this seems like a prime location for that.
2:40:45 And the trees are planted along the sides to preserve the open views of the water.
2:40:51 I regret not having a larger image of this.
2:40:55 Um all right. Let me just It's helpful, I realize, to kind of show this for context. So, what we're looking at was
2:41:03 this on West Avenue. Next, we're going to look at proposals for the art walk.
2:41:06 There's currently an existing artwalk, as you know, between Montros and Minnola, but there's talk about expanding it and connecting all the way
2:41:14 down to the water, which is a great idea.
2:41:17 Um, hey, good to see you. What's new?
2:41:22 [laughter]
2:41:25 You only knew. Hey, I have so friends.
2:41:30 Uh so here the art walk, this is an existing art walk and it continues straight down to we're
2:41:37 proposing a little court uh a little pedestrian plaza. There's talk about this in the shred. How nice it would be to have a place just in close proximity
2:41:44 to Montro where kids could play. And then it continues across the street with a building that receives you into sort of a a four court, a three-sided court.
2:41:54 And then it becomes sort of a pedestrian passage that winds its way down. Um, and I need to include President. I don't
2:42:01 know if anyone's been to um there's a great building President in Winter Park called Grenada Court. I don't know if people are familiar with that. It's
2:42:09 amazing. It's it blows my mind. It's so simple. I'm amazed that it just isn't done everywhere. You just take a standard 50-foot commercial lot on the
2:42:17 main street and put a little 12-oot passage down the middle with 19 foot buildings on each side. It's the most intimate, charming place and lots of
2:42:26 retail frontage and then you little sort of courtyards along the way. So that's the kind of the the scale of what we're talking about here. So you you wind your
2:42:35 way down and and we and we did not keep it straight on the philosophy that uh Clermont has this amazing grid with all
2:42:43 these straight streets that terminate the view. Like you have no shortage of straight streets with views to the water. Why not have a place that winds
2:42:49 around a little bit? and we've carefully worked around this sort of hold out property. Um,
2:42:58 and then along seventh, we've actually we we're actually proposing town houses, which seems like a perfect transition building type because it could kind of
2:43:06 sustain the urban edge of downtown, but to provide a residential front to this neighborhood, which actually has a lot of nice old craftsman bungalows. It has
2:43:14 the Todd House. They're they're very protective of that little neighborhood.
2:43:18 and why not sort of do them a favor and and present something plus a building plus as a building type a townhouse steps down that steep topography
2:43:26 perfectly. You know, like I think how well San Francisco is handled with town houses because they're narrow. Uh so there's an alley back through here. Um
2:43:35 and then and then completing the art walk with the east walk passage that goes that cuts horizontally there. And actually you'll see in other drawings we
2:43:42 we we've heard about proposals to continue the art walk into this block. So, we please we've drawn that in.
2:43:48 Um, I hope we're not freaking anyone out with this.
2:43:53 Only in the audience. [laughter] All right. Here's another option for for for the for the for the Wait, what
2:44:00 happened? Oh. Oh, you know, I was talking through a diagram. This is the proposal for the artwalk here. It's the same project there. And then here's
2:44:09 option two. So instead of the art wall kind of going to the left of the hold out property, it cuts a diagonal kind of like Rosemary Beach over to the uh east
2:44:18 side towards the northeast side towards a little plaza facing the water here.
2:44:23 And in some of the scenarios, we even have that sort of building out terminating the end of Seventh Street.
2:44:28 And so you get great views out in that direction.
2:44:32 Um okay. And there's a an artist interpretation of what view might be
2:44:40 look like from the artwalk in this little plaza looking down there and seeing this. Where am I standing?
2:44:47 You are standing right um at the top of the court.
2:44:52 Well, imagine you're standing in this courtyard.
2:44:55 It's kind of it's kind of a compiled view, but you're looking down this you're looking standing right here and you're looking down this diagonal out to the water.
2:45:07 So that that more or less where it's more like like like it's like you're standing in the square in option
2:45:15 one you said talk about the plaza for the kids yeah yeah the plaza for the kids but but you're looking down the diagonal
2:45:23 of option two so they combine yeah kind of combined they call that artistic license
2:45:29 artistic license okay and then and then this uh
2:45:36 let's see so then Uh, okay. Eight street infill. So, we talked a lot about connecting mantros to
2:45:44 the water. And here's the existing conditions where you see you have empty parking lots, sides of buildings. Um, pe
2:45:52 people some people do walk down there, but not as many as you'd like. And so, this is is a proposal just to sort of how can you sort of infill it along the
2:46:00 way? And they're number like here's Patrick Biankey's scheme, which is excellent for infilling that parking lot. that will do a huge amount of work right there. And there's also talk about
2:46:09 putting a hotel above the existing storefronts at that northwest corner of eight de Montros. Um
2:46:17 we're we're we're not in love with the trail head there. It seems like the the little pocket park over here might be a better park and maybe that gets
2:46:25 redeveloped and actually I think it'll do more benefit in terms of drawing pedestrians along ETH Street than than
2:46:32 kind of a a wall. Um And then uh here here's a proposal uh for this property
2:46:40 down here at ethan oyola how you can sort of you know uh keep that building but line it with sort of commercial mixed use and then if you look more it's
2:46:49 hard to see from where you are but like there are lots of opportunities throughout downtown of an old strategy of like say you have a house in an area
2:46:57 that became more urban. You can just build a little storefront out along the the front. I'm sure you've seen this everywhere. just a little one-story commercial thing that brings it out to
2:47:04 the street, provides a nice frontage, provides added value, and and sort of helps draw people along the street, but
2:47:11 but you need a destination. So down here, um uh is maybe the the Veterans Memorial
2:47:19 and sort of a plaza and maybe this uh this fishing pier here and maybe Salt Sack uh lines. It's sort of outdoor
2:47:27 eating area with more of a kind of a pergola and uh it sort of framed that sort of space there. So just ways to sort of kind of bring people along the
2:47:36 path and then create a destination that people that draws people into to the waterfront.
2:47:44 And then uh here's that proposal at the corner of uh Minnola and Nate.
2:47:53 Uh the city hall parking garage uh which this this decision is ultimately up to you guys whether you want to build a
2:48:01 garage at all or which of the two sites that are currently being considered 7th in Minnola or city hall. Uh we admit to having to to favoring the city hall site
2:48:10 and we can tell you why. Um but there are a lot of considerations for that.
2:48:14 But here is the uh city hall parking garage. And as with all of our parking garage studies, we lined it so that what you see from the street is habitable
2:48:22 space. And we like this site for many reasons. One of which is that it's large enough to build liners easily and they don't have to be sort of integrated into
2:48:30 the structure, which is very doable, but it's just kind of simpler to have fe simple units lining the parking garage.
2:48:36 We also liked it because it didn't use highly valuable developable land at the core of downtown and it sort of intercepts Parker people coming off of
2:48:45 50 before they cross Montro because Montro gets blocked off for you know uh food trucks and farmers markets. So why
2:48:52 not get out of your car before you drive through farmers market? You said these simple liners.
2:48:58 Well, they could be or they could be rental apartments or anything.
2:49:01 But in other words, like this liner could can sit on its own land. as opposed to underneath the parking garage. If you build it up here at 700,
2:49:10 the liners are on the lowest level and require speed ramps.
2:49:17 It could be rental. It could be anything. But it also affords an opportunity to really define that. You have a nice little park here, but it
2:49:25 feels too amorphous. It needs more definition. And if you have a liner here facing it, it creates it actually transforms that little green into a really nice space.
2:49:36 And then one opportunity I think you know and again we're I know we're I'm sure we'll be controversial setting people but that alley needs to continue
2:49:43 through. Uh I I I see trucks all the time parked on mantros and on eight because they can't turn around and it's
2:49:51 a very short distance. If you just poke that alley through then trucks could pull through and then you wouldn't have deliveries on trails.
2:49:58 It's already a street is what's that?
2:50:00 It's already a street or there's a building. It goes all the way to the end and then it's just a piece of grass.
2:50:07 That's not a street. That used to be actually a building used to sit in there. Yeah.
2:50:12 Then you of course you had the other one is alleyway for Yeah.
2:50:16 Well, alleys function best when you could pull all the way [laughter] make a street all the way through to the alley. Put that in the report.
2:50:28 Yeah. Okay.
2:50:30 All right. So then um what what what we've kind of dubbed the Keeler Park neighborhood. This neighborhood along Minnola with these nice historic homes.
2:50:38 Uh a couple of moves to help sort of strengthen its sort of uh integrity of its kind of urban fabric. One we already mentioned was the the the town houses
2:50:47 along seven, but then also lining the um the uh the city center parking. Right now
2:50:54 there's an ugly surface parking that comes right out into the rightway, but you could use square style liner
2:51:01 building and uh mask the parking and improve the street fun because it's a lovely street.
2:51:10 And and then here is the um the uh cardio challenge.
2:51:16 And then we we we did calculations for each of these about uh number of residential units uh square footage of commercial and amount of parking.
2:51:26 Now, this is really a sort of a look at the waterfront here. And we've already discussed some of these like the possibility of a waterfront plaza, end of West Avenue, uh the 8th Street Pier.
2:51:38 Um possibly this is the moment where you celebrate the middle of the uh Florida Coast to Coast bike way. Here's the
2:51:46 cardio challenge. And then in the bath, there's an interesting suggestion about a some sort of way of honoring
2:51:53 celebrating the kind of the triathlon over here on the edge of the triathlon area and then fifth street already has its own sort of pier down here smaller
2:52:02 pier that doesn't get beyond the grass the nice thing about the street pier they got you are so far and then another thing is thinking about
2:52:10 sort of pedestrians along the waterfront you have this great prominade already in the existing park here between seventh
2:52:17 and 8th uh we're proposing kind of a prominade over here uh at the west avenue plaza And if Salt Shack is
2:52:25 willing to entertain the possibility of like a little boardwalk connection, if they're building uh you know
2:52:33 like a dining chairs out there, there are lots of good examples of this, but that would be sort of they certainly increase their visibility, increase walkability.
2:52:41 Yes.
2:52:42 And the B there would suggestion that we repurpose the storm water in between lake and that seven.
2:52:50 Yeah. Okay. What's your thoughts on that?
2:52:52 Well, we're all in favor of having more sort of retail and restaurants facing the waterfront. It seems like the natural obvious place to start is
2:52:59 downtown like these blocks between seventh and west. You know, why give up parkland when you have private land and frontage that needs to be developed and
2:53:08 it's closer to Montros? That seemed like the place to start. But there is also the opportunity long term to activate the these frontages and maybe instead of
2:53:17 giving away the public park plan, just put not a full street but like a basically pedestrian access. not a
2:53:24 narrow sidewalk, but a prominade that that creates a frontage along these lots. So that over time, these lots facing the park could redevelop into
2:53:32 restaurants or commercial or great uh places to live and and they would have sort of a front because right now they're all turning their backs on it.
2:53:43 But but but the potential there is huge.
2:53:46 So like like after this area is filled in then maybe it continues out along there along sort of pedestrian access
2:53:53 from a the other thing that that does is it helps se separate pedestrian traffic from bicycle traffic which we're not
2:54:00 super strict about that but I noticed that there are a lot of people walking along I mean I had a bicyclist uh yell at me because I was taking photos along
2:54:07 the uh the the the South Lake Trail but in this stretch especially like here's the bike trail come through coming
2:54:14 through if you had sort of a prominade really from from here along here for pedestrians. They cross here. You have a
2:54:22 crossing and they continue through the park over the boardwalk and over to the I and you'd have just a spectacular pedestrian realm throughout your sort of
2:54:30 downtown area. You really would because with water from I mean just people I I travel every single and the full people
2:54:39 especially any events man there just so much opportunity there.
2:54:48 Uh all right I guess you want to talk about the church sites.
2:54:54 No, you I mean it just the only reason I say no is you haven't even given a presentation to the church about what you've done and I don't know.
2:55:04 Yeah, I don't think it'd be appropriate public.
2:55:08 Well, I think the church has its own ideas over there as well. No.
2:55:13 Okay. There there's some exciting opportunities there too.
2:55:17 And then um Okay. And and this was a property. We don't have to do a lot on this, but this is what we're calling the gateway property. It's at 12 and 50 as
2:55:25 you kind of enter from the west, a large parcel. And trying to think of something that'll kind of support your vision more than a convenience store or a car wash
2:55:35 or something like that. You still might incorporate those uses, but maybe in a more walkable format. So maybe it's a little bit more commercial um out
2:55:44 towards 50 and more residential facing the existing residential neighborhoods towards the back and and a good transition type is townhouse uh or you
2:55:53 know small apartment buildings. Um, we we have a bunch of options.
2:56:06 Which one?
2:56:09 Oh, yeah. So, like the town homes are turned sideways and and they face a little uh pedestrian court here that comes off of uh what is it?
2:56:19 Oyola. Dodto. Dodto. Uh are served by alleys in back.
2:56:29 Um here in this scheme, the alley runs sort of east west which has the benefit of not not presenting fronts to 11th
2:56:38 street which is a which is really feels more like an alley. It's it's only a 40 foot rideaway and it doesn't has a parking lot in the back. Um and then the uh what is this street here?
2:56:49 Juniata. you know, Juniata continues through and there's a little plaza in the middle and then you come out on this
2:56:56 side. Um, [snorts] in this scheme, maybe this is a small grocery store like Trader Joe's, something like that,
2:57:04 you know, kind of facing drop it in there. Better than a fire.
2:57:11 Better fire. And here's a little attached closet. Trader Joe's.
2:57:20 And this might be a nice way to handle 11 Street since 11th Street is really there's nothing to it.
2:57:26 Just just handle it almost like a like an alley and make the fronts here face the cable pedestrian way here, apartment buildings there. Um, all of these have
2:57:35 uh setbacks because there's currently a required 56 50 foot setback along Route 50 anyway. And as part of the formbbased
2:57:44 code, we're proposing that that be sort of handled as what's called a contradirectional parking lane. Uh, which is a way of handling parking in a more elegant way in front of the buildings and making use of that space.
2:57:56 All right. So, the lumber yard has already half of it's been constructed, all this stuff down here, these four buildings, but but what's called a
2:58:03 commercial pot parcel. The owner is thinking of selling it off and um these uh um here here here here you can
2:58:13 see what's already proposed. So uh it's already proposing some kind of a uh retail entertainment use creating nice
2:58:21 front edge actually along the um the Florida coast to coast bike trail. And um this is just sort of rearranging kind
2:58:30 of the the kit of parts a little bit so you have more sort of walkability, more green spaces and providing more better frontages towards the lake and towards
2:58:38 streets rather than putting a big parking facing the lake
2:58:46 and that's sort of variation on that alternative.
2:58:50 Um all right so and then another area of proposals was along Route 50. So, as we
2:58:58 mentioned, FDOT has a bunch of proposals over the years, and as long as they're doing the resurfacing, there's an opportunity for for Clermont to make
2:59:06 requests, see if money might may or may not eventually be available from the NO or whether CL Clermont feels like some of these are worth it to invest in
2:59:14 themselves. But what we did is we looked at it. You'll see that we we've layered in the greenways network. And a big
2:59:21 challenge is crossing 50. So, wherever you have a green like along West Avenue, we're proposing a new pedestrian crossing for that will help assist with
2:59:30 pedestrians, bicyclists, even golf carts. Um, where you have a traffic circle. What we've proposed is sorry,
2:59:38 where you currently have a traffic light. We're proposing traffic circles which have a which are very efficient at um handling uh you know, traffic um and
2:59:48 certain times of the day more efficient and and our our traffic This would be appropriate location.
2:59:55 You're saying traffic circle like a roundabout? Yeah, like a roundabout.
3:00:01 That's what everybody said except at Okay. So, um you know what is right?
3:00:09 Yeah, I've seen them in cities and it works.
3:00:13 Yeah, in some of the cities. Yeah. Major traffic cities. Well, that's the city.
3:00:19 Was that the Not good for
3:00:30 don't don't get hung on up there. There are a lot of other proposals.
3:00:33 One of the most important is is a median in the middle of Route 50. Way to stop. That's fine.
3:00:44 An important opportunity is is is the is transform the the turning lane in the
3:00:50 middle of Route 50 uh into a median which will actually uh which you can do with a roundabout, right?
3:00:59 Yeah. Which is totally congruent with with a roundabout. Plant trees, improve sidewalks. These are all improvement. In fact, FDOT provided a great they
3:01:07 actually suggested this in 2020. So they're it's it's definitely they're definitely open to it. So even if you don't get a roundabout like this, we
3:01:15 we've actually had proposals for how can you just improve the intersections and one of them is to uh make the crosswalks more perpendicular to the direction of
3:01:24 travel to so that the directions are are uh so that pedestrian crossings are shorter and provide pedestrian refues in
3:01:31 the middle on these medians. Um strategies like that. Here where 8th Street meets 50, you could use um brick
3:01:39 paving. It's actually stamped asphalt to sort of make a contrasting color which improves safety and improves the visibility.
3:01:48 Um and then finally, I'm going to share with you the the parking studies that the these were the six sites that were considered at one time. I I I know that the PAT committee is really only
3:01:56 considering two, but we just want you to see this as a way of thinking about how to handle parking if you feel the need to build parking.
3:02:05 And um so for example, the city hall site, which I already showed you, sort of lined with residential on these streets and maybe a mixeduse commercial
3:02:13 building facing the park here at the church. Uh a parking deck with with with lined units around.
3:02:23 And and here's the uh liner units at the city center and the post office.
3:02:31 And uh this is this is one of the sites the pigsack is considering. If you want to put a parking deck at 7th Miniola, we
3:02:38 would recommend that you have a speed ramp up to the first level so that you can have tall retail lining the streets at the ground level and then a narrow
3:02:46 band of residential liners and upper stories and we were told at that time to extend it over the artwalk. We definitely don't recommend that and I think that's out of consideration now.
3:02:55 So we think that was a good move. Um, and then we've already shown you uh schemes for the Toyos property.
3:03:04 Uh, cramming a lot of parking into Toyos would be a shame.
3:03:12 So, 150 pages. Good job. That was a quick 150 pages. Wow. Good job.
3:03:20 Thank you. What a visionary.
3:03:31 You got to start somewhere.
3:03:35 What would you say is you you talked about the need to address a comprehensive use on the lake. Yeah.
3:03:42 And we had ABA and RPA in here.
3:03:48 In your experience, what would you say is a next step for us to address uses on the lake so that we can really nail down
3:03:56 a plan for the water, you know. Um, yeah, it just seems like like like like like someone's got to take the bull by
3:04:05 the horns and sort of, you know, kind of reconcile all these different sort of uses. Maybe, you know, uh have your own
3:04:13 uh sort of Lake Manola sharet and bring bring all the people around a table, you know, and and sort of try to understand
3:04:21 all the different competing uses and proposals, but but but make sure you have someone who draws there. Don't let it just be a talking session. The magic
3:04:29 of a sharet is drawing. Until a pencil hits paper, you can just talk endlessly.
3:04:35 But but ideas quickly sort of sort themselves out when they when they start to get drawn. So, so what if we put the rowing course here? Oh, well that doesn't work because you need to go
3:04:42 through this bridge or um what what what if we have like uh diners visit downtown here at this location. Oh, that's too
3:04:50 close to kayaks and stuff like that or you know uh what's the best part of the lake for this? I mean, uh,
3:04:59 requires a comprehensive planning effort and but but where where the rubber hurts the road here specifically is, you know,
3:05:08 okay, where if you're going to have people visiting uh for to dine in downtown, where do you want to handle
3:05:15 that sort of boat parking? Where where do you want um the rowing course to be? Where do you want the sailors to be?
3:05:23 Where do you want kayak rentals to be?
3:05:26 Um, those are all important questions. And you you've got so much waterfront, it really deserves planning. And the thing
3:05:34 is is you've got at least a mile there, if not more.
3:05:39 And uh you don't have to put everything all in one location. You know, there might be better locations for this, that, and the other.
3:05:50 Are you aware of any other city that has two miles of Chicago is amazing. It's just one mile, right?
3:05:57 I don't know. A lot of lakefront. Miracle Mile, right?
3:06:06 But the Miracle Miles Lakefront is very expansive.
3:06:12 Okay. Minneapolis, multiple
3:06:20 like connected
3:06:30 Milwaukee has more than the point is you're saying it's unique. It's unique.
3:06:38 It's a reality. No, it is. Well, it is integrated. Yeah. There's nothing.
3:06:47 See like you know like say along here along this zone right there.
3:06:52 all that like prime land. I mean, it may be underdeveloped now, but it's valuable land. It will get redeveloped eventually. You as a city have the
3:07:01 opportunity because you have control of the over the public land to actually create uh a nice frontage and maybe and turn it into something more. Otherwise,
3:07:09 it's just going to be developed like I mean so often waterfront gets developed in very sort of unfriendly ways. Really?
3:07:17 Oh, yeah. I mean I mean that's the defaults kind of World War II development is that you know a lot of times well
3:07:26 it's privatized or or people turn back or put in appropriate uses. Um so I mean the city has an opportunity to sort of
3:07:34 guide it. I mean you can't control ultimately what people exactly do on their private land but I think you can provide a vision and then people get excited about it and jump on the ballot.
3:07:46 I mean he's from Miami. Miami we have a lot of tourism. This is not Miami.
3:07:52 No, I'm we're we're talking about It's not about Miami. We're talking about uniqueness and there's really nothing. You were asking what city?
3:08:01 Not even big cities have what we could have. I got a question.
3:08:08 It's not New York either.
3:08:13 I'd love to see a greenway.
3:08:25 This pearl is unbelievable.
3:08:27 Why do you think this unbelievable
3:08:36 develop from your perspective?
3:08:49 Good question.
3:08:50 Some of this everybody said this is one of the most beautiful hilly lakes.
3:08:56 I have some kids. I'm just curious when you look at this pallet.
3:09:02 Is it because we was just a matter of time? This isn't
3:09:10 the most part you know other parts of
3:09:16 West Orange there's just you know we got to be honest here's
3:09:25 a lot there's a growing amount but I what are your thoughts you see this
3:09:32 well I I I mean I think there are a lot of reasons and I I I don't really know the history deeply but just one of the reactions is that I some of it is supply
3:09:40 and demand. There's so much waterfront and so so efforts get so sort of dispersed and um now and I think it's
3:09:48 you know as the population increases I mean there's only a fixed amount of waterfront so the value is going up over time and so I think it'll be more and
3:09:56 more valued um uh but yeah
3:10:04 well sort of misguided development impost following World War II. I mean I mean Clermont is wonderful
3:10:12 because it was lucky enough to get laid out in the 1880s. It has a great an amazing topography and really established nice basis up through World
3:10:22 War II. And then after World War II people weren't interested in straight streets and um walkability they want to close out.
3:10:32 Let me add the the other big thing that happened was when it developed around the lakes. Remember this was a very
3:10:39 relatively rural place. People weren't coming here to build a town in 197.
3:10:46 Okay? And so you had everybody grabbing their food of nature but on the lakes.
3:10:52 So as soon as he said that he used the word privatized and what he meant was they they sold the land all the way and many times into the water.
3:11:02 Okay, which cut off use from it. And if you So once they did all the property lines and sold all the individual lots, you couldn't build a town,
3:11:11 you couldn't build a walkway, you couldn't build anything around there.
3:11:15 and and and so that was just a function of when it developed those people weren't thinking oh why don't we build
3:11:22 this great city that everybody will love to come to that's what has it's a timing thing so that's why Mola doesn't have a water
3:11:30 on Lake Mola and Nathan Nathan you're exactly right on on that because what people don't realize and what one of the biggest
3:11:37 driving factor was that that lake uh East Avenue where it turns off and the boat ramp is at actually we used to be able continue
3:11:45 right around. It used to be a lake road that ran all along the lakefront.
3:11:51 It ran all along the lakefront. Years ago when growing up here when you're coming out of Min instead of going up East a you could go up East Avenue but
3:11:58 the road continued all the way around lakefront and it dumped out it ended over here on 8th Street but you had access to Fifth, 7th, all the other streets had connection.
3:12:08 The old train route right and the train track ran through there as well. Okay.
3:12:12 You see the old Yeah. all that ran through there. But so when going back to what Nathan was saying, when they sold off off that and closed
3:12:21 off that road and started selling it like trying to sell off their property for redevelopment, basically that that destroyed a lot of Well, yeah,
3:12:28 that's what killed the downtown because nobody knew it existed anymore because you never had any traffic. You come around East Avenue, you come back to Highway 50, you knew that downtown South didn't even know it existed anymore.
3:12:39 Okay, so that's why it was a ghost town back here in the early in two 2010 2012 it was like a ghost town and that's why we made so much effort to try to bring
3:12:47 it back. Uh but along with that when they started dividing the land people grabbed hold of everything and they didn't want to develop it you know they
3:12:55 want to hold on to their own little piece of the pot. Okay. So so it all go back there and I always vision the fact that if they had kept that road there
3:13:03 all that probably been developed along there now. Okay you know but it didn't happen.
3:13:12 I have three points and one question.
3:13:14 Um, one is I concerned about the amount of use of
3:13:23 activation and not the words preservation or restoration.
3:13:30 I I don't think I heard the word preservation or restoration used at all in that presentation. And when we're talking about our historic downtown,
3:13:37 that concerns me that that those words aren't being used at all.
3:13:42 Um, I think if I own some of these properties, I would have some
3:13:50 I would I think I would have some concerns about seeing my my space being planned by a city
3:14:01 for something other than what I may have want for my property.
3:14:09 So I guess my question is this is this a plan or is this a series of proposals and I think just proposals
3:14:17 that may be rhetorical but I it's being proposed as a plan and I think a plan has a connotation that this is what we
3:14:24 want to do and a series of proposals are these are things that could be done.
3:14:33 Um and I I I feel differently about in the comp plan in some respect. And I didn't feel that way until this presentation.
3:14:42 Um, and I think if I were the general public, I I might
3:14:49 have some big questions about this given the depth of it, the the gravity of what
3:14:57 some of what's being proposed here or
3:15:00 [snorts]
3:15:00 uh planned here. Um, but I have a I just have a general question for us as a council, for CRA, for PNZ, and and for
3:15:09 the general public because I think we're getting closer to the end points.
3:15:14 And I've never really felt like I had an actual concrete what are our next steps for the
3:15:23 comprehensive plan, the downtown action plan, the formbbased code, and the the
3:15:29 VAP for the parks. in terms of are they formally being presented to a body or multiple bodies and are they going to be
3:15:38 voted on for action to be implemented and put into place? I know we have to do that with comprehensive plan. That's a that's a
3:15:46 state requirement. But if we're not doing it with these other things, I guess why do we why are we here? And
3:15:55 if we are going to do those things, I want to make sure that We give the bodies who are going to
3:16:04 review it ample time to digest it and that there's nothing else on the
3:16:11 agenda that needs to be covered when we're talking about that because this is going to be deep. Not deep because it's
3:16:18 bad, but just this is big time discussion points. Yes.
3:16:24 That ought to be given the amount of time that they deserve.
3:16:30 Um, and so I I I asked that I don't know if it goes to the city manager, but for
3:16:37 comp plan, those four things, and you don't have to necessarily answer it today, but can we get all of us as
3:16:44 members of our different boards and councils, a here's the exact plan for the comp plan, the downtown action plan,
3:16:51 forbased code, and the VP next steps, the boards it goes to, when it's coming, when we're going to get the materials,
3:16:59 going to be given to the community. Um because there's a lot of moving parts here and the last thing I want to have happen and I I said this to Mr. Van
3:17:08 Wagner and Mr. Matis in agenda review is for this to show up in a packet on a Thursday and be expected to vote on Tuesday.
3:17:17 Um I I will tell you right now I will absolutely filibuster the heck out of that if I have to because that is not
3:17:26 the right way to go about doing this. We have to have ample time to digest it, review it, discuss it publicly, and vote on it.
3:17:35 And I'm I'm worried I'm worried that we're just going to get this right before it comes out. Um because we've seen nothing in writing about a concrete
3:17:43 plan moving forward. So I'm putting it out publicly in front of council, in front of PNZ, in front of CRA, in front of staff. I really would like to see a
3:17:52 plan for these four things moving forward.
3:17:56 Look, I'm in agreeance with you 100%. I don't care about anybody else. After that, the documents up there. I couldn't I couldn't even read you off.
3:18:06 All right. So, how am I going to do my research? This is supposed to be a workshop. Honestly, I'm not here to beat anybody up, but I really, really thinko
3:18:16 came up with a great idea, right? Cost money for the documents. You give us a suggestion online. So we have we all
3:18:24 have cell phones so we can look at it. I don't I'm trying to con I'm trying to
3:18:30 understand exactly what show I think your ideas are great. I just I'm in
3:18:37 agreeance with with Councilman B. I mean it's it takes a lot. I mean this is a lot to ask for.
3:18:45 Can we get an answer?
3:18:47 I think I think I asked that someone asked that question at the beginning. I think Mr. Nor that we would be getting something later on down the line because
3:18:55 I think that one I don't know but I I agree with him and that's one of the reason I asked the question will we have something physically in writing to be able to sit
3:19:03 down and look at so we have time to study u that Mr. Bain more specifically and everything here we going to need a
3:19:11 lot more time to digest this and go through all these stuff and that's why I I pretty much when I
3:19:19 came in here sitting here at this We have nothing to look at. Uh nothing we could have went through. Okay. And like you say, trying to look at that
3:19:27 boy, that's that's tough. That's why I asked the question in the beginning. Are we going to get some physical you know that we can hold hold on to and look at back to him? Yes.
3:19:37 So yeah, I can try to address uh you know both of you your uh questions. As it relates to the comp plan, once again,
3:19:44 the idea is at the end of this week, uh we'll go ahead and put out electronically uh the draft that is
3:19:52 going to be uh updated based upon what was heard and discussed today. Okay. Um so that's where the complaint is and that's the that's essentially the most important because we have to do it.
3:20:02 Everything else you don't absolutely positively have to do, but you've got to do that and uh that's also going to help inform everything else. Interrupt me if I don't.
3:20:12 Um the next thing is we can talk about the downtown action plan. Um this is their the first time that he's been able
3:20:20 to get feedback from the community the real community leaders on it. And so
3:20:27 this is a very rough rough draft. So they've got to also produce quickly an update based upon the things
3:20:36 that they've heard. And so if even if you have ideas or or concepts or whatever or that you want to share that
3:20:43 you think of tomorrow, you know, that'd be great if you just email me whatever your comment is. Great. I ship it to Ben
3:20:51 and his team and they try to incorporate it in this next drip. So they're going to have to come back out. We're going to have to put it online, right?
3:20:59 Okay. Give everybody the chance to provide feedback. Then things are going to drop out. Things will be added. One of the good things you just as an
3:21:07 example is if you look at this, you know, he's a V. He can see things in 3D.
3:21:13 He's got his masters in architecture from you. He's got a brain that I don't have. Right.
3:21:18 Right. He he knows what that looks. I don't you know that's different colors.
3:21:22 And so what that tells me is I go back to Ben. I said, "Ben, we've got to get some visualizations, the unprecedented photos perhaps that
3:21:31 are going to help illustrate what you were talking about on this. It's not that we're above anybody citizens, but we have a little more head start. Don't
3:21:40 forget, I mean, this also has to go to the public. Right. That's right. That's right. That's right.
3:21:46 So, so and then we talk, you know, so so the downtown action plan [clears throat] has to get massaged based upon what
3:21:53 we've got. You get that. You'll have the opportunity to have another conversation about it. Um, and and and so and it goes
3:22:02 through the process. whatever happens happens. The next thing you have a form-based code. Okay, that's a essentially updating at least in the
3:22:09 northwest quadrant the idea is updating the zoning code. Well, the zoning code doesn't really work if it's not matching the vision that you adopted for this
3:22:18 area. So, that's why you have to have the comp plan and the downtown action plan because if everybody says, well, we don't want this to happen here or there.
3:22:26 They've got the expertise to go ahead and alter that form a scope before you get a big everybody's calling you say what are you doing with my property. You
3:22:34 know we had the meeting in Lincoln Park and what what do we hear from Lincoln Park? They you know getting back to what uh council member Bain said they want
3:22:42 protection and preservation right they you know I learned real quick redevelopment was the wrong word when I was thinking about redevelopment. It's like oh they're going to upgrade the
3:22:51 Wind Dixie shopping center. He's like, "No, they're coming in to mow down my house and they're going to, you know, all that." And and that's not what it
3:22:58 was. And so that's an example where you go and you listen to the neighbors that live there, the people who live there, you know, then all of a sudden the
3:23:06 consultants get, "Oh, okay. I see. What we really need to do is how well is the current zoning code protecting them
3:23:13 versus what we could come up with in the code." So the bottom line is the code, as much as we'd love to have the code ready to go, we're not ready to go
3:23:21 because we don't have the, you know, you have the vision ready to go right now.
3:23:24 They've they've they've got a draft code, but we got to make sure that gets changed for that. Okay. And then we have what was the fourth thing?
3:23:32 Vap.
3:23:33 The VAP. And I I don't know about the VAP off the top of my head. That's that's the order. Sorry. Go ahead.
3:23:41 Well, so that's the order, but what's the projected timeline?
3:23:45 The projected timeline for the complaint is to come to council in October. So we'll have it hopefully done uh by the end of this week.
3:23:58 Hold up. Let me tell you the date.
3:24:01 The 8:18 is Friday. Okay. That would give everybody two and a half weeks before it goes to planning and zoning on
3:24:09 the 6. And the request was for two weeks from Councilman Bay. That gives us two weeks and three four days. And we were
3:24:19 wanting to do a another workshop for the comp plan only on the six also before the planning and
3:24:27 zoning. So that way the planning and zoning department would get also another opportunity to hear a presentation so
3:24:36 they'll have two weeks and some change another meeting before their meeting so they can engage the planning and zoning meeting. I apologize.
3:24:44 I we got a plan and we just got to talk about and then Another week later, the council would meet on the 13th and we
3:24:53 have cleared off most of the agenda for everything. A couple there's a few intros, but we are pushing back
3:25:01 everything we can off of the 13th. So there it's three weeks and three four days, something like that. So if the
3:25:09 plan works well and we can get it out to you on Friday, it makes sense. But if it doesn't, I totally get it.
3:25:16 We were just planning on moving forward with the comp plan first.
3:25:20 So, and then going from there based on your input though, we needed to get your input today to even see if that made sense.
3:25:27 So, that's why I was told to get my stuff off the 13th.
3:25:30 So, let [laughter] me let me answer. So, on the 13th, what what would you be expecting from the council on the 13th to to hear the comp plan and transmit it
3:25:39 to the state for transmitter? Correct.
3:25:43 Just the comp plan the based code has got a lot more work to do. So that's going to be that's probably going to be later maybe early next year.
3:25:52 So we we you talking about on the 13 well we get it we have two weeks to look over. We talked about going to PNZ, you know, in the week for the six and then
3:26:00 on the 13th we doing transmitt still we transmit before we really have anything back from the public having
3:26:09 public input on the competence in there there's going to be another another workshop and they'll have the
3:26:16 public will also be here on P&Z and council there and and don't forget this thing has been workshopped many many times
3:26:25 there's been more public on this process that I've seen in any complaint I've ever worked on. There's been a lot of public input.
3:26:34 Can I ask a comp plan? Does it reference the downtown action plan or form based code or or parks plan?
3:26:44 No, no, it stands on its own.
3:26:45 That sounds right. I I was concerned that you know referencing things that haven't been brought before us or or
3:26:53 the only thing that it might say and I haven't finished reading all that the future code will implement for this plan
3:27:03 it's not going to have any of the specifics of the code. Okay.
3:27:07 So are we giving you what you need for the master plan right now in terms of feedback?
3:27:13 I I'll pose just for the sake of a happy counterpoint is when I look at the 2015
3:27:21 strategic plan, it's different, but it looks a lot like
3:27:28 I mean the the visual of how it's laid out and yes, some people's individual property. I mean, it looks like this,
3:27:37 but it's a concept plan. And you know, I think There's no other way than to show
3:27:44 what could be. I don't know how to do it, but to show what could be. And I don't think it's inconsistent with the
3:27:52 way that we handle the 2015 presentation. Whether people choose to build or not, that's up to them. But the
3:27:59 fact is the idea would be I mean, what I'm hearing from this is we want to have streetscapes that invite people to walk
3:28:08 through downtown. What I really like about this that's different the 2015 plan is is I like how kind of the density of downtown is actually much
3:28:17 more consolidated than the original 2015 concept. It kind of sprawled a little bit with the downtown
3:28:25 from my observation. Um, you know, in 2015 the idea of victory point was proposed. Now we're saying, hey, Center Lake is an opportunity. Doesn't mean we
3:28:33 have to do anything with it, but it shows us what could be there. And I think that's the value of this of this proposal. um you know the idea of west
3:28:43 there was an idea of a prominade in 2015. So there's some sort of theory that over time and and in a classical
3:28:51 education you worry about the things that survive over time and so it's interesting that there are many things that are similar or the same um updates
3:29:00 obviously additional planning you've done one now here's phase two I like what I heard as far as direction of focus on building the core I'm using the
3:29:09 wrong words, but those those two blocks that are waterfront before you worry about like in the VIP the suggestion was
3:29:17 the downtown the idea of creating a a human path versus a bike path. That was kind of cool. So, these are concepts
3:29:25 that we might choose to implement or not choose to implement, but I don't know how we do this without saying what could be. And I also don't think this is
3:29:33 inconsistent with the CV our old back in 2015 there was a a CBD and I think we don't have that anymore where
3:29:42 well you still have a CBD but but that'll change for right so like the density is not much
3:29:48 different than the density of what was you know but the question is how do we get people and maybe it'll happen in
3:29:57 time how do we encourage people I like to develop because obviously we have we have the CBD all this time certain
3:30:04 parcels we choose to develop I like that there's concepts for where parking could go. I think that's really cool.
3:30:13 You know, I could see I could see development and drawings and you talked about the develop
3:30:21 development design center. You know, the post office becomes an interesting I think it's an interesting concept as a civic space. It's really important. So,
3:30:28 to me, this just gives ideas and I think that's fine.
3:30:35 I would suggest to staff that individual have been addressed that you talked to those people, but it's my understanding
3:30:42 that certain of them have been involved in the process.
3:30:46 So, could could I suggest a couple of Brian's points? Uh um first of all, let me say in terms of preservation, I'm a huge fan of
3:30:54 preservation. It almost goes out without saying that there's a lot of preservation going on here. Clermont Main Street is very active and has
3:31:01 secured lots of grounds for for uh for uh storefront uh renovations and we were
3:31:09 very careful. I mean we were very careful actually to sort of knit these proposals in like if you look carefully at what we things were proposing like
3:31:18 you see like like Montro is untouched right that amazing block of Montro is untouched where where you see dark
3:31:26 colors are like that's a That's the deo's property. That's a parking lot. Uh that's a parking lot.
3:31:34 That's a parking lot. That's the post office, which was put in play by by the city. The city actually said, "What what
3:31:41 what can we do with that parcel?" Uh the police and donor, the police station saw what was going on over here at Peter and said, "Hey,
3:31:50 I'll take some pre-esigned services."
3:31:53 [clears throat]
3:31:53 So, so like you know and uh the the church was like super eager to meet with us. We we I think they're gonna be very excited. I'm very excited
3:32:01 about this scheme which we we really listen to what they want. Now the kids with this proposal they could get two layers of parking taking advantage of
3:32:09 the tobo. the kids could walk out into a play area that's entered from the sidewalk that could be sort of a where where else can you put a parking
3:32:16 structure that actually has a usable um exterior space accessible from the parking from the sidewalk. There's no other site where you could do that.
3:32:25 Well, I think the point is you're talking to the people that are Yeah. So, so we we we've been in communication with a lot of people. Now, it doesn't mean everyone's going to like
3:32:32 it, but um the other thing I would say this is just in terms of approach to to
3:32:37 planning, we're new urbanists and we our approach does tend to be sort of specific and I think to make good places
3:32:46 you need to be specific. So much postwar planning is just kind of bubble diagrams and just getting out a marker and just
3:32:53 huge areas of yellow red. there's no place making and and and so like the the 2015 plan I think has some very good big
3:33:02 concepts but I would say it was very weak in placemaking and that's what you need in our opinion is what you need is placemaking and and
3:33:09 you need to create a vision doesn't have to be done exactly like this I mean I'm sure each one of these projects is a take a lot of effort and they'll find
3:33:16 better ideas than we had but it it helps get people on a certain trajectory
3:33:24 yeah I hear that And I I I I agree with aspirational and and visionary. Um, I
3:33:31 also know just from what I hear from a lot of folks,
3:33:38 I don't want to say everybody, but I hear from a lot of folks that a preservation of historical downtown or a
3:33:45 semblance of what we have here, which that which makes us unique,
3:33:53 in my opinion, better than some of our neighboring Central Florida cities that sometimes get compared to
3:34:01 um I just want to make sure that folks are hearing that that is being incorporated
3:34:09 and and and is important because when when when there's lack of
3:34:16 those words I think mind goes to it's not it's not on the board anymore. It's it's not [clears throat] it's not part of it's not a part of the plan.
3:34:26 I think one of the best examples of that is what we're calling Kiler Park. I don't think the area actually has a name, but there's a part there called Keer Park. So, yeah, we called it Keeler
3:34:34 Park and um instead of like proposing redevelopment, we we we kind of listened to the the residents. They resisted the
3:34:42 parking proposal. They resisted an effort to put in townous. Um and so what we did is we actually proposed things that would kind of strengthen their
3:34:49 neighborhood identity, sort of keep that. It's very tempting just to sort of develop the redevelop the whole thing.
3:34:55 But so I just want to assure you that we we we made a lot of efforts to be very sensitive.
3:34:59 That's a good call out on the messaging though because I think that it is I didn't think about it because I'm like oh it's interwoven in this like you know the things that they're proposing is to
3:35:08 go with and support and make help those things shine. But that has to be explicitly it was preservation. When he said conservation, I was conservation.
3:35:19 Restoration, right? Was it restoration or conservation?
3:35:22 But I think this is another example where having imagery of what the third the 3D could look like is going to help
3:35:29 because when we see the two-dimensional layout of these buildings, it can feel intimidating, but being able to see what
3:35:37 it could look like, [clears throat] one I think helps us, all of us, when a project comes to us that we can go, "Oh, no. I've seen what that could look like
3:35:46 and and I want to see the higher quality. But also, I think it can avoid that. You know, someone's listening to this and they say, "Well, at times you
3:35:54 can go up to seven stories and look at all this all these buildings that we're putting on parking lots." That can feel like we're building a downtown Orlando
3:36:02 and and that would not go over well with anybody in Clermont.
3:36:05 Um, so I think that some additional renderings help us be able to say, "Okay, that's what this could look
3:36:13 like." Just the the part that looks option one matched with option two. Yeah.
3:36:18 Like I mean that took me I could look at that for another 20 minutes and still feel like I didn't see it all. Yeah. Sorry.
3:36:26 Yeah. No. So in regards to preservation or historical did you guys look at the main street historic study that they did. They did that. So that was all part of that.
3:36:35 Oh yeah. I should put that in our president's they did an amazing assessment of all the buildings.
3:36:40 Yeah. I think that was the important that would cover that.
3:36:44 at that study as well because they did [clears throat] a great job with it. It just hasn't been showcased. Sorry, Christian.
3:36:51 It's okay. I had a legal kind of question. I mean, normally when Florida cities, you know, amend their or change
3:36:58 their comp plan, they they change their comp plan and or, you know, change the code, things like that. But you don't always see a downtown activation.
3:37:08 It's not strictly necessary legally. Um but I guess one of the
3:37:15 benefits I mean do you you know you agree it's not legally necessary correct? Yeah. So, but then the second
3:37:22 So, I'm I've been thinking about it like why is this so important and I'm wonder is it because of our design center, you
3:37:29 know, that we've funded because like here here's what I'm I'm wondering because if if it is indeed aspirational for all these properties, you know, that
3:37:38 here's an idea of something that could unlock potential and that fits the council and maybe the public's vision for what happens. Um, is that something
3:37:47 that could feed into why we would use the design center? Like that someone comes and does if it fits the activation
3:37:54 plan, is that a criteria perhaps for how someone gets access to it?
3:38:00 Also, okay, so there's a you asked a question that has a couple different layers to
3:38:07 it. The first layer is that as you know we're crafting the objective criteria where the development design center can help people. Okay.
3:38:17 And I'm wondering if consistency with the activation plan is one of those that would be one of the reason that that was that's very much one way to do
3:38:24 that. So that's a very important purpose for it beyond just helping. Remember a lot of planning is not only about
3:38:32 creating something good but preventing something that you don't want. Okay? And Because ultimately, whether we like it or not, in the United States, we've made
3:38:40 the determination that real estate development is a political act. Every developer will say, hence the term exclusionary zoning.
3:38:48 That's right. But but but so that the the developer is like, okay, the the government, you know, the government is my partner because I can't build unless
3:38:55 they say yes. All right. And so what that means is it's there's always an element of politics to it. Well, it's really unfair to an elected
3:39:04 representative to have to sit on the dis on every development project instead of
3:39:10 opine, okay, well, how should I handle this? As opposed to providing them with some political cover or shield to say,
3:39:17 well, we as a political body adopted a direction we want to go. And so when I'm judging that particular project that
3:39:26 came up before us, we could look at it a little more objectively than say I don't think I like it. Um instead you say it's
3:39:33 not consistent with what the context I wanted to give the council and the planning and zoning commission is you know this might fit some of what
3:39:42 you've already done. And if there were questions, I mean, if you approve, however it's approved, the downtown activation plan, um, one of the ways you
3:39:51 might end up implementing it is through your design center potentially, but there are implications for the property owners as council member Bain said. So, I just wanted to put that in context.
3:40:04 But also, we remember this started because we wanted to update the code, which was never updated with the 2015 plan. And so, when we're updating the
3:40:13 code, we need to know what the vision is in order to make the code match. So that's how all these have been working.
3:40:21 Just so we know context for history.
3:40:23 And the vision thing is a big important thing. If you don't have the vision, guess what? There's other people coming in who want to develop in your community
3:40:31 who have a clear vision of what they want. And so they tend to succeed if there's no competing um vision for what you want. And here
3:40:39 what we see is we've got these more assets than almost any other city, you know, and that's why you you talked about the context in the beginning. We
3:40:48 have all these advantages and if we don't take advantage of them, we end up with siloed mistakes. I would all right.
3:41:00 Any other questions?
3:41:01 Yeah, I just have one comment. I'm glad that the council sitting in these chairs. That's what we have to do all the time when you're back there.
3:41:08 Meetings go six, seven, and I'm not addressing this to you, your honor. I'm just saying dismay. Am I right?
3:41:16 It's a lot different sitting in there. Am I right, Valerie?
3:41:20 Yeah, I was just Can I offer one thing back to an opinion? When it comes to the waterfront and even how we put it in the
3:41:29 downtown action plan, I do think it probably is smart to leave open green space and long stretches along it still.
3:41:35 We're talking a lot about infill in the downtown. Though I would not be inclined in this particular action plan to start
3:41:42 going too far down where ABA was with the swsils and stuff. I think that's just that's asking a lot right now. We may never want we might want to keep
3:41:50 that open. So that's a relevant opinion for right now.
3:42:01 All right.
3:42:03 [laughter]
3:42:06 Any any other No other questions? I can't understand.
3:42:13 Brain overload. Brain overload.
3:42:17 Nothing else needed to close come before the council. Um the board I guess you can say um meeting adjourned.